10 ms·
Fig (YC S20) – Adds IDE-style autocomplete to your existing terminal
- saagarjha 5y agoPreviously on Hacker News (Fig is YC '20): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27277819 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27277819
- binarynate 5y agoThanks for the context. I was curious about the business model, and they describe their planned business model in this original thread.
- riquito 5y agoMacOS only should be part of the description. Cool work, really, but it takes too long to realize your OS support is a maybe in the far future
- NiekvdMaas 5y agoSounds like they are actively working on adding support for Windows and Linux; https://github.com/withfig/autocomplete#does-fig-work-on-windows-or-linux https://github.com/withfig/autocomplete#does-fig-work-on-win...
- mschrage 5y agoWe are making really good progress on this and will have a cross-platform prototype in the next month or so. See the Github issues for Linux[1] and Windows[2] [1] https://github.com/withfig/fig/issues/34 https://github.com/withfig/fig/issues/34 [2] https://github.com/withfig/fig/issues/35 https://github.com/withfig/fig/issues/35
- colordrops 5y agoIs this built on top of electron? edit: oh, it's a private company and it's mac only. Something about proprietary extensions to my command line is a huge turn off. Functionality itself looks great though.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoIn fairness, "not electron" and "only one OS yet" are probably somewhat connected.
- sofixa 5y agoYeah, and I find it peculiar people rant about both about the same time. Making cross-platform stuff takes time, so it makes sense that Fig ( and many others) focus on a single platform only initially, if they haven't chosen a cross-platform stack. Which sucks as a user, which is why I prefer Electron apps to X-only apps.
- snovv_crash 5y agoQt works great for cross platform and isn't so heavy. It still blows my mind that it's ok for a chat app to take half a gig of ram.
- colordrops 5y agoHow would electron ever be suitable for a command line tool, cross platform or not?
- rubatuga 5y agoWow, using it feels like I'm living in the 21st century. Can't wait for TUI to reach renaissance.
- danfang 5y agoHow does this compare to https://www.warp.dev/ https://www.warp.dev/?
- akmittal 5y agoWarp is full terminal with focus on collaboration features. Fig can be used with your existing terminals like iTerm, terminal or VSCode
- steve_adams_86 5y agoIt seems like it’s intended to be complimentary, and it runs in warp.
- SheinhardtWigCo 5y agoCompetent marketing, if nothing else. Warp's landing page: - Product Hunt #1 Product of the Day - The terminal for the 21st century - Warp is a blazingly fast, rust-based terminal reimagined from the ground up to work like a modern app. - All cloud features are opt-in. Data is encrypted at rest. - Fully native, Rust-based terminal. No Electron or web-tech. Fig's landing page: - Fig adds IDE-style autocomplete to your existing terminal. - Works with your existing terminal & shell - Supports 300+ of your favorite CLI tools - Autocomplete for cd, git, docker, npm, yarn, kubectl, brew, aws and hundreds more!
- progbits 5y agoRegarding Warp's: > All cloud features are opt-in. Data is encrypted at rest. The most generous interpretation is this is misleading (I would consider it outright lie) given they currently also have telemetry which isn't even opt-out, it's always on. See last time this was discussed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30921231#30922189 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30921231#30922189
- sk1pper 5y agoAutocomplete usually drives me crazy in IDEs - often it covers up nearby code that’s relevant to what I’m currently typing, so I end up hitting ESC all the time just to get it to go away. I guess you don’t have that problem here if the popup is always below your cursor, since there’s never really anything below your cursor in a terminal when you’re entering commands. But also autocomplete often suggests the wrong thing but I’m typing too quickly to notice, and then I hit enter and get the wrong thing filled in. What I want is just non-automatic completion - which we already have. Ctrl+R gives me exactly what I need when trying to find some odd command I ran last week. Add in fzf integration and it’s perfect. Tab completion covers everything else. When I don’t want completion, it stays out of the way. In an IDE, you can usually bind completion suggestions to Ctrl+Space or something and then turn off automatic suggestions, or something like that. Maybe you can set up this tool that way too - then it might be nice to try out. But as I mentioned generally I find the terminal to be pretty ergonomic already for completion stuff.
- EugeneOZ 5y agoWhat IDE has such dumb autocomplete?
- c-fe 5y agoVSCode - at least the described issues perfectly describe my experience with VSCode autocomplete.
- aordano 5y agoI had the same issue until i took the time to check out the docs and config it to my taste, it offers a fair amount of customization. Granted, you shouldn't need to fiddle with it to make it usable, but i really didn't mind spending some time to get to know better the tools i'm using every day.
- djaychela 5y agoCan you share what you did? I find the number of options ins vscode bewildering.
- sizediterable 5y agoFrom https://fig.io/privacy https://fig.io/privacy: > Inevitably, there will be users who, for whatever reason, don't want their usage of Fig to be personally tracked. Of course. It's your data and software on your device. You shouldn't even need a reason. We want to cater to these users. And we will. But unfortunately, we are so early on in the process of building Fig that we need to be able to speak to our users. De-anonymising telemetry for the time being while minimisng the events tracked enables us to do this in a non intrusive way. But it is of course not for everyone. Therefore, once we reach a critical mass of usage in the coming months, we will then anonymise all telemetry, making Fig more accessible. It has been several months since this was written. Are they still collecting de-anonymized user data?
- Rygian 5y agoThat statement means that they have chosen, by design, to be unavailable in Europe. In Europe you must be able to prove that your software was designed from the ground up with enough safeguards for user privacy, as opposed to considering privacy requirements as a bolted-on afterthought.
- greggsy 5y agoThey would be able to argue that the data is anonymised.
- erickhill 5y agoI feel like HN should peel a page from Reddit and introduce a bot that auto-informs us of previous posts/discussions about the same URL.
- wodenokoto 5y agoThere’s a link up top called past.
- mrtksn 5y agoWhat's the business model of this and why I'm not allowed to use it without signing up? The same thing with wrap[0], to have autocomplete, somehow giving special permissions in the OS is not enough to function; I also need to give my identity and communication details. It feels wrong to me. [0] https://www.warp.dev/ https://www.warp.dev/
- krono 5y agoEven if those weren't requirements, sensitive data is rather difficult to hide from your shell/terminal. Warp being closed source doesn't help either. Edit: A nice alternative based on ZSH's native featureset: https://github.com/marlonrichert/zsh-autocomplete https://github.com/marlonrichert/zsh-autocomplete
- systemvoltage 5y agoThe answer is usually "They'll upsell me for business/commercial/corporate use". Similar to what happened with Postman (they started nagging you to sign in and sync your accounts). IMO that's totally OK. I'm glad people are building stuff like this and if it requires an account to sign up, I am happy to do that. > why I'm not allowed to use it without signing up? I want to politely raise this question – is it not rude to have expectations for something you didn't build and be entitled that it to be offered to you for free? You're more than welcome to ignore it and find dozens of terminal emulators out there.
- stanpinte 5y ago+1
- mrtksn 5y ago> is it not rude to have expectations for something you didn't build and be entitled that it to be offered to you for free Well, Fig or any other free to use software wasn't commissioned upon my request therefore I don't think that I owe anyone anything. Engagement is worth quite a lot thise days, they earned my engagement by offering me something but did not disclose the requirements to use their product upfront so I ended up not benefiting from the product. Think of this, you are walking down the street and someone really nice offers you a free meal. You accept, sit on the table and the food arrives but to let you eat the food they ask you for your contact details and a copy of you key for your home. You say, no thanks, would rather pay and they say no, it's only free meal in this restaurant. I'm not sure I will accept it and assume that they will upsell me a boiler. Okay, there's probably nothing nefarious but they stole my time and attention without giving me anything back. The restaurant shouldn't have advertised free meals but meals for key and contact details. I would have had gladly skip the offer, so they can concentrate on those who really need the meal and are willing to fulfil the request of the restaurant.
- isoprophlex 5y ago> Needs your email for a download link Thanks but thanks, I have ctrl + R
- dewey 5y agoDid they just copy the https://linear.app/ https://linear.app/ landing page 1:1?
- fwr 5y agoYou mean https://www.raycast.com https://www.raycast.com?
- kall 5y agoThat page is way more beautiful and unique with it's use of vibrant color and gradients in dark mode. Also it doesn't share the most obvious thing between the others (Built for speed... section). I think almost straight copying landing page designs and layouts is basically fine and common practice. Using the same or very similar copy... not quite.
- aidaman 5y agono but congrats you figured out that it is a landing page.
- bajsejohannes 5y agoClearly someone looked at the competitor while building this page: https://imgur.com/a/q6kaD3q https://imgur.com/a/q6kaD3q
- jollybean 5y agoLet's have more of this. Frankly branding and arbitrary layouts are not fun. It'd be great if we had a template web site format so we know where everything is!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gitgud 5y agoThe headings, styles, even features are identical. It's not possible that this is a coincidence.
- jollybean 5y agoLooks cool, installed ok, but it won't start on my mac. Clicking the icon does nothing. Questions about 'sign up' for a cli type app, I mean, I get it, but also slightly uncomfortable with that. Love to try it out, if others have seen this issue and can hint at a resolution I'm all ears.
- mschrage 5y agoYou have to open a terminal, like iTerm, and then autocomplete will appear :)
- golergka 5y agoI've been using it since it first appeared on HN and I absolutely love it. The suggestions are actually smart for majority of commands that I use. When I type 'yarn add we', it fetches the list of packages from npm and suggests webpack. When I type 'git add', it lists the two files I actually modified.
- sombremesa 5y ago> When I type 'git add', it lists the two files I actually modified. Is not typing `-u` really worth installing a whole app that spies on you? Especially since shells like `fish` (FOSS!) will have you just write `-u` + up arrow? This seems objectively worse to me but I guess we'll see whether they find a real market.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoI commented above, but actually fish already detects and lists only changed files by default if you do `git add <TAB>` (with or without -u).
- ComputerGuru 5y agoFYI/FWIW fish does both those out of the box.
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoAll other concerns aside, Fig is still a buggy tool. Been using it since it was launched. It doesn't add a huge amount of value, yet. That said, I feel the need to support anyone trying to improve terminals.
- eligro91 5y agoAgreed. It has been slowing down my overall usage and no much added value. I decided after 1-2 months of usage that it doesn't worth it and uninstalled Fig.
- billconan 5y agoI really want to know how does it intercept terminal inputs and display the pop window at the right location. I dug the code a bit, didn't find it out.
- billconan 5y agook, this answers my questions https://github.com/withfig/fig/issues/35 https://github.com/withfig/fig/issues/35
- tentacleuno 5y agoI really don't like seeing companies use GitHub just as an issue tracker for a proprietary product. Something about that feels... wrong, almost like they're using the platform but giving nothing back.
- UncleEntity 5y agoI’m sure Microsoft is crying all the way to the bank. Though…if they make it simple to get a refund on the ‘Microsoft tax’ you have to pay whenever you buy a new computer but have no interest in running windows past making sure the thing actually works I might have a tiny, tiny bit of sympathy for them.
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoPreviously heavily discussed on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27277819 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27277819
- marshmallow2 5y agoDoes not support linux or windows for that matter and is proprietary
- marshmallow2 5y agodoes not support linux, or windows for that matter, and is proprietary
- sherifnada 5y agoThe terminal has been such a core part of my workflow for so long that I sometimes forget how difficult it can be to use; I've just learned to hack my way around the friction. It's so refreshing to see a product try to reinvent something so core to developers everywhere. Really excited to see where this goes!
- dulvui 5y agoI use hstr to get autocomplete suggestions based on my history. No email or signup needed. Its like ctrl+r but a selection menu is visbile. http://dvorka.github.io/hstr/ http://dvorka.github.io/hstr/
- chickenimprint 5y agoA piece of proprietary software that collects data on basically everything on your machine and is unavailable on Linux? Nice! Surely this has organically risen to the front page, unaffected by it's ycombinator backing!
- ushakov 5y agoyou are not allowed to criticise Fig here when they appeared here last time, i've written a negative comment about them my comment was then pinned to the bottom of the page by super-mods, even-though it had the first spot with 30 upvotes https://imgur.com/a/Z5AZkik https://imgur.com/a/Z5AZkik dang (HN moderator) has actually confirmed that my comment's ranking was manipulated, but declined to answer any further questions https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31117569 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31117569
- VMtest 5y agothis opens my eyes, TIL some people on HN have the ability to downweight a comment (which is not equivalent to downvoting)
- ushakov 5y agoyes, now you know the game is rigged just imagine how much of the HN comment section is manipulated by these elites i guess some YC-investor isn't happy that us regulars are devaluing his investment and downranks negative comments so that people will give Fig a try after reading bunch of good ones
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago> elites I don't think this is the proper use of the word. These are just people with vested interest in making a product more popular - it has nothing to do with any "elite."
- ushakov 5y ago
- shasts 5y agoThe problem I have with tools like this is the latency. Even the git helper info packaged with Oh My ZSH is slow. It is useful. But I really don't like waiting for cursor to appear when I want to type the next command. Haven't found anything better than Ctrl+R.
- jwilber 5y agoGUI autocomplete seems… counter using a terminal in the first place? Maybe that’s too critical, but can’t see myself migrating away from iterm2 for somerhing proprietary.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoApparently you use it with iterm2 or whatever terminal you want...on a mac. And I think it's an interesting idea to move the autocomplete out of band where it doesn't write to the same window where my work is (if I were on a mac), especially if it's still keyboard driven as they say. But I still wouldn't touch this for other reasons. I don't see any justification for this being proprietary. There are already decades old autocoplete in most shells and the enhacement concept that this brings is just not that special that it deserves putting up with having to install proprietary binaries, being limited to their mac-only platform support, tolerating their data collection, and of course whatever their licensing arrangement is or will be. It's not a bad enhancement idea, it just seems like it's barely a little spiff-up over ordinary bash completions. Ordinary completions are already a flexible system that you can customize to do quite fancy things if you wanted. They already execute commands to generate output. It's a trivial addition, conceptually, to feed that output into any of the many xdialog-alikes instead of directly to stderr. This is a little slicker that literally just that, but not by much. And the existing shells are already on all platforms not just mac, and fully open source, and don't have any telemetry or client/server architecture, and so are the xdialog-alikes, and so are the autocomplete definitions.
- pronik 5y agoIn other news, how many things do we want to name Fig? I remember something for docker used to be called fig (compose?) and several others.
- arghwhat 5y agoSo this is just a slower, proprietary version of existing shell autocomplete? (If you don't like bash's simple autocomplete, try other shells like zsh or fish.)
- drdd 5y agoIf Github Autopilot was added on this, would be a terminal on steroids
- throwaway0546 5y agoJust wanted to share my subpar experience as an interviewee at Fig. The initial phone screen consisted of a series of around 7 lightning fast questions on React basics (this was for a typescript role) followed by a basic leetcode question all in 15min. I was then presented with a take home which was to make a minimal clone of https://explainshell.com/ https://explainshell.com/ using the Fig API. Needless to say this task was not only overly time consuming but it was extremely disrespectful to receive a reply over a month (!) after I submitted the task. They cited that my submission was “lost” while moving to a new system. If their management of new hires is this poor I shudder to think of what their internal management is like. Awesome product can’t say the same about the team though.
- laurent123456 5y agoThat's so disrespectful of them (both asking for such a take home, and losing it). Definitely not the kind of company you'd want to work for.
- staindk 5y agoOff topic but thanks for informing me of explainshell.com! I'm sure it'll come in handy next time I need to re-figure out how what curl flags do etc.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oxff 5y agoThis seems almost like a parody of "VC backed SaaS innovation"
- getcrunk 5y agoSeriously. Every once in awhile I see things on the front page and I'm like there's no reason this is supposed to be here
- craftoman 5y agoI installed Fig about a year ago, it was not working on my machine and I remember I was getting spammed for no reason until I hit that unsubscribe button.
- Shadonototra 5y agoWeird that people are promoting such data collecting tool.. ohh it's https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27277819 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27277819 - Launch HN: Fig (YC S20) oh they haven't removed the tracking thing in the url: https://fig.io/?ref=hn https://fig.io/?ref=hn i would love to see what's the algorithm of hackernews, do they give a little boost when it is about their products?
- sourabhv 5y agoOn startup they send request to versions.withfig.com, tel.withfig.com, VS marketplace, Sentry, AWS Cognito and a couple more. My firewall blocked all of these and I couldn't use the app. It needs api.withfig.com, app.withfig.com and AWS Congnito to work. After signup I blocked all these and I saw they ping their servers every few seconds. Removing it permanently.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoDo I understand correctly it all happened after you explicitly opted out of telemetry?
- sharjeel 5y agoOut of curiosity, which firewall do you use?
- brainlessdev 5y agoI had a suspicion that this was Mac-only from the looks of the site and docs, but after some clicks I gave up trying to find out; reading comments on HackerNews was faster.
- xenodium 5y agoIf already running your shell from Emacs, some tinkering can give ya some of these completion goodies https://xenodium.com/eshell-pcomplete-company-completion https://xenodium.com/eshell-pcomplete-company-completion https://xenodium.com/yasnippet-in-emacs-eshell https://xenodium.com/yasnippet-in-emacs-eshell
- Brian_K_White 5y agoWish I could downvote without flagging. I won't flag because I don't think it's wrong (although it approaches qualifying as spam, but, technically not quite, it's topical for this site, and I believe functions as advertised, and I'm sure a few mac users may legitimately find it useful), just bad and of no value and "do not recommend" and I'd merely like to do the opposite of upvoting, which is neither accusing of wrongdoing nor abstaining. Considering it's a YC project and a commercial one, it's at least "spammy" if not quite 100% qualifying as pure spam. It's somehow, in a way I'm struggling to articulate, worse than merely not interesting to me. It's so right on the edge. I sat with this comment open for a few minutes waffling between submit, or cancel and flag. It can be argued convincingly either way.
- artemonster 5y agowhen post downvote feature is unlocked?
- Brian_K_White 5y agoApparently there is no such thing, so never.
- dskloet 5y agoThat's a lot of words without actually saying why you think it's so bad. What's so bad about this post?
- Brian_K_White 5y agoMany things, most of which have already been said here by others, and myself in another comment too. But this comment was about exactly what it says. I'd leave some other comment about Fig itself but it's mostly all been said well enough already and I see no value in being redundant. For the record, a reply where I added a few points https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31223471 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31223471
- 5y ago
- febeling 5y agoI use Z to jump around in the shell. Jump around, btw, is how it's purpose it offically defined. It uses some sort of substring/edit distance matching and LRU heuristics, and it works almost every time. Sometimes it feels like it's reading my mind. https://github.com/rupa/z https://github.com/rupa/z
- mmgutz 5y agoYou should try zoxide, a rust-based cross-platform `z`. I use it in zsh and in powershell. https://github.com/ajeetdsouza/zoxide https://github.com/ajeetdsouza/zoxide
- the_gipsy 5y agoJoin waitlist. For a terminal that wants to send telemetry. I suppose the waitlist is only up for Europe? Does this also require to log in, like the other one, warp (not the HTTP library)?
- kwhitefoot 5y agoThe example on that page just reminds me why Emacs is always open on my machine with a Bash shell in at least one frame.
- sva_ 5y ago> E-Mail to download Don't think I'll do that.
- mmgutz 5y agoHow does fig compare to fzf's fuzzy completion for bash/zsh? Fzf is already used in many TUI apps for search/find/list autocompletions. https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/fzf-a-command-line-fuzzy-finder-missing-demo-a7de312403ff/ https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/fzf-a-command-line-fuzzy-f...
- jpeter 5y agoIntellisense in a terminal is such a good idea i can't believe it has not been done before
- gabereiser 5y agoWhile this looks incredibly useful and productive, it’s also extremely hostile to users and security. I can not recommend. The volume of data collection far exceeds its utility. The argument that it’s needed proves it’s not about auto-complete. It’s about selective exfiltration. Prove me wrong.
- fauria 5y agoThe homepage says: "Fig isn't a standalone terminal. We integrate with the tools that you already use." and then shows 3 icons of terminal applications, including macOS Terminal. How do they open those dialogs for completing commands on them? Those menus don't seem to be text based, but part of the terminal window GUI.
- ushakov 5y agothey draw them on top of the System UI using accessibility API “hacking”
- kall 5y agoI believe they "hack" accessibility hooks in the OS to position the floating window as if it was part of the app. That part is actually quite impressive and works well. I imagine it's quite a bit of engineering effort to make that not janky. I wonder how hard it is to make cross platform. Maybe other OSes have easier hooks? Easier permissions for sure.
- aitoehigie 5y agoI am currently pleased at the current renaissance of CLIs. If you use Python, Rich and Textualize is leading the forth. I am currently using it to build a frontend to a DRF backend and I am really enjoying the experience.
- amelius 5y agoIt would make more sense if terminals had a generic hook that shells like Bash can use to show completion suggestions in a popup menu. But obviously, you can't turn that into a profit machine.
- gtirloni 5y agoI don't understand how this niche tool can be a company, with a jobs page full of positions and everything. I'm really puzzled how this can be.
- agluszak 5y agoVC-funding ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- kall 5y agoIt's basically a small UI change, but I think I would actually benefit from having a real window instead of the in-terminal completions. However, I want ONLY that UI change. If someone could pull the autocomplete list out of fish and style it as a floating window that moves with the courser, that would be wonderful. Sounds more like a tool developed by one person than a venture funded startup though.
- shmde 5y agoI have started with web dev on windows 10, is there an alternate to cmd/powershell like terminal for linux where I can run basic linux like commands but for windows 10.
- hu3 5y agogitbash is installed together with Git and comes with some Linux utilities. Can be downloaded here: https://git-scm.com/downloads https://git-scm.com/downloads There's also WSL2 which gives you a full-blown Ubuntu 20.04 running inside Windows.
- cloudhead 5y agoWhy would anyone use this?
- pastacacioepepe 5y agoI am so tired of these hipster terminal apps for mac only. As soon as I thought "hey a cool-ish terminal app" I was already sure that it would be macOS only. So I searched on the landing page, documentation and FAQ but couldn't find any info about platform support, which gave me some hope. Only once I subscribed to the mailing list and got to the download page, I was told that Linux and Windows users are on a "waiting list". I'm going to refrain from using any app that settles on macOS only as a first target, even if they plan to support other platforms in "the future". Like the ecosystem wasn't already a walled garden without deliberately excluding viable platforms for no reason other than being "cool".
- jesprenj 5y agoI really like those websites that are so greatly integrated with javascript trackers that when I purposely block all of them on all lists I could find, the website appears for a fraction of a second and quickly disappears afterwards. The web is amazing!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- egorfine 5y agoAnother terminal to try - cool! Another terminal that wants me to log in - not cool. I wish I could try both Fig and Warp, but I can't: giving my email to a terminal is insane and I would never do that. I wonder what is it that two similar projects popped up recently for quite non-business lucrative usecase but both require something that the very target audience will mostly never agree to?
- egorfine 5y agoTo give credits where it's due: Fig's data collection policy is explained in a very straight no-bullshit language and is perfectly reasonable. Instructions on how to disable telemetry are written right there. I would be okay with that policy but I will be disabling it anyway without any consideration.
- saltmeister 5y ago
- merricksb 5y agoDiscussion about Fig less than two weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31113396 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31113396 (76 points/9 days ago/63 comments) And their Launch HN less than a year ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27277819 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27277819 (559 points/11 months ago/378 comments)
- user3939382 5y agoRichard Stallman just shuddered without knowing why.
- itronitron 5y agoVery sneaky, whoever marked this as a dupe (but only after the product received many negative comments).
- Canada 5y agoDemanding an email address for "sync" makes me feel really uneasy. That was almost enough to make me back out of completing the installation, but I've given a throwaway email, disabled launch on startup, and disabled auto-launch to try this out. The terminal auto-completion is nice looking. I want to like this, however for me I'm not seeing enough value to justify having a third party potentially snooping my terminal.