28 ms·
An update on the campaign to defend serious math education in California
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lr4444lr 5y agoEfforts like this are well meaning, but only treat symptoms. The major impetus for watered down curricula is the very rational fear that large swaths of the student population will fail if expected to perform at the prior standards of rigor. Schools are not prepared to hold back massive numbers of kids, drop out proclivity for students held back rises, and teachers will be poorly evaluated by virtue of their students' inability above and beyond reasonable expectations of what they can learn in a single year given prior failure to build a proper foundation. How we got to this point is perhaps a lot more complicated and politically fraught, but it has to be dealt with. Administrators and state education leadership are often simply responding to the incentives and avoiding dire outcomes suggested by the data. They have to craft palatable excuses for it, and it's ultimately a waste of time to engage those excuses on face.
- School-Cotton 5y agoThis is a natural consequence of the American myth/narrative that everyone is suited for academic high school and university. Other countries simply sort people into different schools much earlier, and spend the high school years teaching meaningful vocational skills to those not on the academic track, rather than wasting everyone's time.
- sefrost 5y agoWhich countries do that and which countries don't?
- usrn 5y agoGermany famously does. Children are given a test and depending on the score they go to Gymnasium (in perpetration for university) or one of two other options which trains them for either trades or labor.
- brummm 5y agoGermany splits students into different schools starting 5th grade and it's absolutely great.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoDeciding the future of your life in 4th grade (when students are evaluated in Bavaria, at least) is maybe not great. Was living in Munich for five years and I'm glad we left before our son got sorted. There's also a strong racial/class component to who gets into Hauptschule/Realschule/Gymnasium, surprise surprise.
- Lev1a 5y agoHere in M-V I had to go through "Orientierungsstufe"¹ which I partly blame for my learning difficulties and anger issues later in school, since in those two years we later had to find out that we missed 1-1,5 years of material and/or learning methods depending on the subject. I mean... e.g. in Philosophy the teacher was absent for most of those two years resulting in us having to entertain ourselves for those "lessons". When we finally entered Gymnasium at 7th grade we received a culture shock when we had to learn the "Zauberlehrling" by Goethe in 1,5-2 weeks for recital in the first weeks. Realschule felt more like Kindergarten from the treatment by teachers like their attitude while teaching and them not being interested in bullying unless it turned really physical, then protected the bullies when the bullied hit back. What I'm saying is, as the slightly fat kid who also didn't get all the shiny new things from his parents I was bullied by a group of other students surrounding and harassing me almost every single day during breaks those incompetent "teachers" only had the "advice" to basically let the bullies tire themselves out from bullying but heaven forbid once trying to break out of the encirclement i tried to hit one of those bullying lowlives, the teachers descended like vultures isolating me in a room for the rest of the break questioning why I did that instead of "just ignoring the bullies". Those bullies never received any kind of discipline/punishment. Later in Gymnasium, I once had a very heated verbal altercation with a classmate within earshot of a teacher, we were taken aside, our parents called in for an evening sitdown that same week, there we resolved our differences with some guidance from a teacher and remain friends even now. Both schools were only staffed by older teachers with the youngest being late-40s/early-50s and several teachers retiring during my stay at the Gymnasium, so probably little to no influence from education during newer eras of teaching. Honestly I wish I could smack that idiot Brodkorb for all the stupid shit he did as education minister. ¹: no split after 4th grade, instead have everyone go through Realschule for 5th and 6th grade, only starting the split at grade 7.
- morelisp 5y agoIn Germany you can be sorted into a Hauptschule around age 10. At this point you will definitely not get a university education via any usual path. Increasingly even "the trades" are closed off to graduates and people expect a Realschule (HS/GED equivalent) degree for those. I don't think university is appropriate for everyone and I dearly wish skilled trades had a higher position in society, and generally don't believe in the idea of "unskilled labor". But the German system is ultimately as cruel as the American one.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoI don't think either system is great right now. From an American perspective, I really wish that there were still trade-type classes in high school, and those were more accepted as a viable career path at that stage of life for those who want it. One path could be partnerships with local community/technical colleges. My high school participated in a program called "Middle College" where high school students took classes at a local community college (can't remember if it was all or just some) and that seemed to work well.
- pmyteh 5y agoEngland mostly doesn't (though there's some local variation). Most secondary (11-16/18) schools are 'comprehensive', covering the full range of abilities. It is standard to set pupils by ability in most subjects, but uncommon to track/stream pupils by general ability across the whole curriculum. We previously ran a split system, with exams splitting pupils at 11 into academic ('grammar') and non-academic ('secondary modern') schools. Many grammar schools were good; most sec mods were awful. The exams also famously had pretty poor predictive power for underlying academic ability as an adult, so pathways had to be developed to allow bright pupils to go to higher education despite being mis-sorted in the original exam - which somewhat undermines the point of the system. Comprehensivisation has never been nationally mandated, but nearly all areas have now done away with academic selection at 11. The remaining holdouts are mostly suburban Conservative areas where political power is in the hands of the well-heeled upper middle classes who are strongly in favour of grammars (and expect their own children to go there). Interestingly, Margaret Thatcher (as Education Secretary under Heath) was responsible for more grammar school closures than Labour was. Vocational/academic choices are now being made at age 14 and 16 either within the secondary schools or by moving to local further education colleges (similar to US community colleges and trade schools). Vocational classes are low status. Britain no longer has a strong industrial sector to use such skills, and although both parties advocate for better vocational education essentially everyone who matters would be most unhappy if their darling children were diverted from a university track in the direction of trades. That's something they want other (poorer) people's children to do, not their own. We've never developed good vocational training for offices/services jobs, and although such courses do exist they're not taken particularly seriously by employers, despite several rounds of national reforms.
- selimthegrim 5y agoI think Northern Ireland still does the 11+
- School-Cotton 5y agoFrance does.
- OnlyMortal 5y agoThe Netherlands been an example.
- frostburg 5y agoI'm not sure it's merely that. Most vocational track high schools types (except the hotel / restaurant ones that are well designed) here in Italy are honestly bad, not really helping students reach their full potential, but the content of the courses isn't on-its-face farcical like that "data science" course. There are clearly decision makers detached from reality involved here.
- brightball 5y agoThe approach makes sense. How are claims of bias within the process handled? That’s the only thing I can imagine from a similar system here.
- frostburg 5y agoAt least here you can just go to the school that you want. People that don't like math or the idea of studying dead languages do not pick the lyceums. Obviously indirect social stratification is still at work in the process.
- texaslonghorn5 5y agoIt's possible this is a good thing. Though it's also possible sorting too early determines someone's life path before they are mature to understand their talents and abilities. So I don't think early sorting is superior to the American model because at least the American model can uplift late bloomers.
- bigcat123 5y ago
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoA famous example of this that absolutely blew my mind is Uğur Şahin. For those not familiar, he is the founder of BioNTech, the German researchers who developed Pfizer's SARS-COV2 mRNA vaccine. Uğur moved from Turkey to Germany at age 4. At the end of primary school his teacher had assigned him to 'hauptschule'. It was only because of a neighbour's intervention that he was later put through 'Gymnasium' i.e. on track to study 'higher' studies. The rest is history, after med school he did a doctorate in Imunotherapy, he founded a 18billion revenue biotech company and saved countless lives with what we now call the Pfizer mRNA covid vaccine. Had that primary teacher's decision been held it really would have been a 'butterfly effect' of catastrophic proportions for Humanity.
- School-Cotton 5y agoYou don't know the counterfactual, though: how many Americans' talent is wasted because they are forced to sit through watered-down school until age 18 before they can begin serious studies?
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoAbsolutely fair. This one example just stuck with me when I read it because of how serindipitous his mRNA research turned out to be during an all out worldwide pandemic.
- Czarcasm 5y ago
- zozbot234 5y agoUnfortunately, tracking is awful for the low-track students because guess what, no self-respecting teacher wants to be stuck teaching underperformers. So the students are trapped in that situation, being taught by terrible teachers who don't actually care for their educational achievement, and unable to improve. You see those outcomes across the board, including in the celebrated German system of academic vs. vocational school tracks. Yes, there are ways to cross through to the highest tracks, but very few students can avail themselves of those practically.
- alimov 5y ago> “…no self-respecting teacher wants to be stuck teaching underperformers.” If you look at people that are not academically inclined and call them under performers then maybe that’s part of the issue. I think everyone has strengths and weaknesses, and if someone is more inclined to do vocational training rather than the standard track I think their strengths and interests should be developed / encouraged. An educator teaching someone that is actually interested in what they are being taught sounds like a more rewarding experience than lecturing a class where maybe 5 of 40 (not an actual stat) students are actually engaged.
- zozbot234 5y ago> If you look at people that are not academically inclined and call them under performers then maybe that’s part of the issue. It's not me doing that, it's education schools telling prospective teachers that their students will just be "learning their math by themselves", and the teachers can simply be facilitators. It must be a comfy job teaching math class to little Carl Friedrich Gauss and the like, but what about the remaining 99% of students - who will need actual teaching?
- alimov 5y agoSorry, I should have worded that better.
- pessimizer 5y agoIt's not whether people are more suited for vocational or "standard track." It's our aptitude for judging that in children.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoI've talked to some high school students about going to college despite high costs, and there was a general fear (statistically backed) that they would make less over their lifetimes without a degree and that not going to college would put them in a worse position to do basic things like buy a house as costs continue to rise.
- Bostonian 5y agoYes, but if you do sort students by academic achievement, you will send a smaller fraction of blacks and Hispanics to academic high schools than whites, and a smaller fraction of whites than Asians, since there are differences in academic achievement by race. I say so be it, but currently many people assume that disparate outcomes prove racism.
- adamomada 5y agoThe irony of course is that focusing on who they are not what they do has to be more racist by a rational definition
- throwawayboise 5y agoIf it's based on ability, it should not matter what percentage of advanced students are white, black, asian, or other. All that matters is that if you're good enough, you get in.
- tshaddox 5y agoThat doesn't explain what has changed within American public education, if it's true what the parent commenter said: "large swaths of the student population will fail if expected to perform at the prior standards of rigor"
- ghostbrainalpha 5y agoHow do they deal with the late bloomers? I didn't really find my academic ability, and programming until I was in my twenties.
- saint_fiasco 5y agoHow did they deal with you, if I may ask? Is there something you wish they had done differently?
- frostburg 5y agoThey're avoiding dire outcomes for themselves while damaging society, however. A merely performative education is truly something awful.
- wonnage 5y agoI think the cause/effect is reversed. Society is damaged because parents cannot raise kids properly for a variety of reasons. You have kids who don't come to school, entire classrooms where 80% of the time is spent managing behavior, kids who receive zero parental support at home because the single parent is working two jobs, etc. That problem is hard to fix, whereas the curriculum is soft and malleable. You also have an entire industry of education PHDs who have never taught class for any appreciable amount of time who have a neoliberal fetish for minor policy tweaks as the path to heaven. Teachers have the same problems as police, random societal functions have fallen to them by default because there's no alternative. They're surrogate parents, social workers, mental health counselors, etc. and there's barely any time to do any teaching afterwards.
- mrguyorama 5y ago>surrogate parents, social workers, mental health counselors, etc And they're paid dick all on top of it
- adamsmith143 5y agoThis makes no sense even as a well meaning. "Some kids are going to fail so we need to prevent other kids from excelling." Obvious BS from California
- jimbob45 5y agoOkay but what if American children were subjected to the standards of Chinese schools? You'd see 70% failure rates overnight at every school in the nation. Surely, in that case, we'd see policies like these pushed even by white people. Likewise, the minority parents and schools simply see upper-class white schools in this country as we do the Chinese schools. I'm not saying that this is the best solution to the problem but I can at least understand where these parents are coming from.
- throwaway894345 5y agoWe're not talking about abruptly changing standards, we're talking about holding kids to existing standards for which our society is already calibrated. I don't think your analogy applies (also, are Chinese schools really so much more rigorous than American schools, or is this assumed based on performance of Chinese immigrants?).
- apetresc 5y agoYes, they really are. Look up example questions for the Zhongkao (national high school entrance exam) or Gaokao (national university entrance exam) and ask yourself how North American students at those respective stages would fare.
- throwaway894345 5y agoI'm not necessarily surprised, just curious. Thanks for clarifying.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- civilized 5y agoRather than standing tall for universal high standards, education officials pass the buck to look good. The result will be an increasingly unproductive, stratified, and unequal society. You can pass and pass and pass people, but eventually an employer is going to need someone to do the job, and they will make sure they get that someone. So there will be a hard standard sooner or later. The only choice is whether we give all students a chance to meet that standard.
- snowwrestler 5y agoIs the curriculum being watered down? My reading on this the last time it came up on HN is that the sequencing of math topics is being changed, which results in classes not having the familiar names like Algebra 2, Geometry, AB Calculus, etc. That doesn’t mean the concepts will not be covered by the end. I remember the huge blowups over “Common Core” years ago, which included new ways of teaching math concepts. I got to see some of it in action during COVID as I sat in on elementary Zoom school with my kid. I have to say I was impressed; they used techniques I did not recognize, but they seemed to work well.
- wbsss4412 5y agoAs someone with a math background I found the blow ups over common core to be ridiculous. Focusing on parents unfamiliarity in place of any actual discussion of effectiveness. If we are going to get anywhere with math education, it can’t be based on pandering to parent’s expectations.
- dc-programmer 5y agoI think America is going to have to take a hard look at its math education if it’s serious about re-industrializing. Where are all the extra engineers going to come from? I think you are touching on theory I have that Americans are becoming increasingly resentful that technical skills are becoming more necessary for middle class living. This is a huge driver of the pervading sense of precariousness. For some reason there’s a huge math phobia in this country
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> Where are all the extra engineers going to come from? Unfortunately, maybe where they come from now? India, China, and other immigration.
- dc-programmer 5y agoThe unstated irony is that there’s a large overlap in the anti-immigration and re-industrialization crowd. I think an interesting part of 20th century American industrial/scientific history is that many of the prominent figures were European immigrants (many Jewish) or children of immigrants. Maybe there is something exceptional about the environment itself. But the talented and privileged native citizens rarely aspire to be an innovator; they dream of being a leader or strategic thinker or mover of capital. That’s why I think hard math is so marginalized even in elite circles (“I’ve never been good at math”). Technical work is essentially blue collar to the upper middle class. Many of my peers are in this group, and the only time they were ever interested in math or programming, was due to its possibility as a conduit to a more prestigious position. This attitude is directly ingrained in undergrad institutions. They focus on general knowledge to serve as a justification to skip over front line work to become a leader (military officer, factory manager, investment banker). There are excellent American technicians no doubt but most of them don’t fit the typical WASP mold or are predisposed to obsessing over systemic topics (which describes myself, being ADHD, although I can only strive to be excellent). And the upper class? They have never aspired to much of anything really other than hedonism and protecting their position of status. At least in other countries, the upper class ideal is a renaissance man. Edit: some of these assertions are sweeping and maybe a little mean. But I do think the thesis is directionally correct. America will need to change the culture around education to succeed in the 21st century. Immigration has and will continue to be a boon; but we have to accept the possibility that America could become a less desirable immigration target
- acchow 5y ago> the very rational fear that large swaths of the student population will fail if expected to perform at the prior standards of rigor. Why is this a rational fear? It seems shocking to me that students can't perform at the same prior standards given their parents are more educated than the prior generation's parents.
- frostburg 5y agoAre the teachers as good?
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoHard to know. The public perception of public employment as a whole has gone considerably down since about the Reagan era. The pay is mostly not very good, and states and the feds have much more power over things that were traditionally local.
- falcolas 5y agoPotential reason it's rational: The shoulders of those giants are higher than ever before. Climbing to those heights is correspondingly harder to do. Speaking for myself, I had to worry very little about computers until late in high school (Senior year, specifically). There were no spreadsheet or word processing classes, and the typing classes were only for the girls. There was Algebra (up through Calculus as an optional course), but many others that my niece has that I didn't.
- cortesoft 5y agoMaybe I am missing something, but how would allowing some kids to take more advanced math cause other kids to fail? You could allow kids to graduate without taking the advanced math, but still let kids who want to/are ready take the more advanced classes.
- poisonarena 5y agoWhat happened in California over the last 50 years to make math scores plummet ?
- micromacrofoot 5y agoDeclining math scores can be tied almost entirely tied to economic disparity (which unfortunately tracks with race pretty closely). Rich kids are on track, poor kids are far behind. Unfortunately I don't expect these changes to impact that. It will likely take more rich kids out of public schools and further widen the gap.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Rich kids are on track, poor kids are far behind The achievement gap is growing. Part of this is explained by union dynamics [1]. Part by California's elites caring less about addressing the gap than talking about it. [1] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.3102/0013189X211006357 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.3102/0013189X2110063...
- micromacrofoot 5y agoyuup > Altogether, this study provides some evidence that contract changes are associated with the educational opportunities of school districts’ diverse and economically disadvantaged students. Essentially, if you want to prioritize your child's education above all else, get them into the richest school district you can manage.
- logicalmonster 5y ago> How we got to this point is perhaps a lot more complicated and politically fraught, but it has to be dealt with. How many folks are really willing to do that? The problem is that actually discussing the perceived root causes of this issue will get you shunned out of polite society.
- solenoidalslide 5y agoAre you referring to all of the recent laws banning discussion of these topics labeled CRT? Those are the only topics I am seeing being outright banned from being discussed or taught.
- legalcorrection 5y agoWhen the utopian plans to elevate the masses fail, just bring down the elites instead. Equality achieved.
- danans 5y ago> The major impetus for watered down curricula is the very rational fear that large swaths of the student population will fail if expected to perform at the prior standards of rigor. I don't think the previous standards of rigor were ever so high for most students. When I was growing up in the 80s and 90s in the suburban working class Midwest, the vast majority of the students in my high school didn't advance beyond algebra. This was in a well resourced school district. But that was a time when it was felt that most people didn't even need to know anything past basic math to be employable. Times have changed of course, but the vast majority of educational paths, even STEM paths, don't require calculus. However a great many do require basic data analysis abilities, so it's reasonable to emphasize those. This shouldn't be done at the cost of offering calculus as an option for students who are prepared for and motivated to do it, though. Of course in the end this is about cost. Assuming the same resources, to teach a broader set of students data science will require reducing the availability teaching resources for something else. I also recall that in the 1980s in some places there were programs that taught calculus at public community colleges for students who were on an accelerated academic path in high school. That is another option to consider.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- daveslash 5y agoSorry for being out of the loop and asking a (possibly) dumb question: What is the stated reason that the CMF suggested these changes? Is it about budgets? Is it because some people might think these classes "aren't that important?". The open letter seems to suggest that it's about closing gaps between privileged and less privileged - is that it? Honest question - I'm not trying to stir the pot.
- cortesoft 5y agoI believe the gist of the argument is that when you split students into 'normal' and 'advanced' classes at a young age, the students who are not put into the advanced classes will believe they are just naturally not good at math and will give up on trying to get better because they will think they just "don't have a math brain". Here is a short blurb about the idea: > The framework would not forbid districts from accelerating students in middle school. It does, however, recommend that middle-school students all take the same sequence of “integrated” math classes that blend concepts from arithmetic, algebra and other subjects with the goal of cultivating a foundation and comfort level with numbers. > On top of that, the framework recommends that schools postpone offering students Algebra 1 until 9th grade or later, when it says more students are likely to be able to master the material. > “When kids struggle, they immediately say ‘I don’t have a math brain,’” Boaler said. “That changes how the brain operates.” https://calmatters.org/education/k-12-education/2021/11/california-math/ https://calmatters.org/education/k-12-education/2021/11/cali... I am sympathetic to the idea that we don't want to send the message that some kids are just bad at math, but it does seem to be a bit of throwing the baby out with the bathwater by holding back the other kids who are doing well. Even if you keep the advanced kids in the same class, the kids are are struggling are going to be well aware that some of the kids are getting it really quickly.
- nafix 5y agoSounds like more woke nonsense. Sounds nice and easy to a layman from a super high level but not practical or put through any kind of rigorous rational thought.
- deleted 5y ago
- texaslonghorn5 5y agoUltimately the solution is better STEM foundation at the very very early ages. Universal pre school would probably be very useful. Empirically [edit: n = 1 or 2], it seems that drilling basic arithmetic and then multiplication tables early in pre K and earlier elementary will give students a better intuitive math foundation to do algebra very well. That would enable everyone to go into more advanced classes at the same time (earlier) rather than these policies which want everyone to go in at the same time (later).
- FredPret 5y agoI wish we did probability with equal gusto as kids. I very occasionally multiply 7 and 6 in my head, but have to reason with probabilities and statistics all day long.
- texaslonghorn5 5y agoAgree. I think getting really good at addition subtraction and multiplication and then division/fractions is the way to go though. Have really strong math fundamentals and then learn algebra and then everything else is far easier to pick up.
- FredPret 5y agoFair point. My first introduction to stats was at second year in uni though, far too late. By that time I had already done a lot of calculus, which while important, hasn’t exactly been critical in my daily life.
- Jensson 5y agoArithmetics is absolutely the most important topic to learn, since it is the basis for all other quantitative reasoning. For example, it is really important to understand that 1 / 3 chance is the same thing as 3 / 9 chance. It is obvious to you now since you have done so much arithmetic's, but to someone who never properly learned it they wouldn't be able to properly compare those two and could think that one is a very different number than the other. Without basic understanding about quantities all other quantitative skills become worthless.
- voz_ 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- phillipcarter 5y agoThis is a real laptop class kind of statement, to borrow terminology from one of the more prominent anti-"woke" investors. Living in California is expensive as hell, especially for younger folks with no inheritance, and the state operates at varying levels of dysfunction because it's got 40 million people in it.
- voz_ 5y agoI am not sure what you are accusing me of. If there is some class structure panned by an investor, I would advise you be very wary of it. There are only two classes - those who exploit and rent seek, and those who work. I work.
- phillipcarter 5y agoI'm sure you think you do.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- JaimeThompson 5y agoWhat is wokeness in this instance?
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoMath perpetuates an -ism so we must change math.
- kurthr 5y agoFrom the original letter: While well-intentioned, we believe that many of the changes proposed by the CMF are deeply misguided and will disproportionately harm under-resourced students. Adopting them would result in a student population that is less prepared to succeed in STEM and other 4-year quantitative degrees in college. The CMF states that 'many students, parents, and teachers encourage acceleration beginning in grade eight (or sooner) because of mistaken beliefs that Calculus is an important high school goal.' The updated CMF looks better, but I just don't see how an educator who knows math or how to teach math could come to such a conclusion (that Calculus should not be a goal). If it is well-intentioned, what was the intention... to dumb down math in high school? Perhaps we need to educate those who are coming up with the math frameworks in math and science, or to get people who care on the California Department of Education?
- cloutchaser 5y agoMy guess is the intention is to be able to say that the framework benefits disadvantaged people. But like almost any policy like this all it does at best is pull down people at the top, at worst pulls down everyone making the situation worse for everyone. You can have separation of education by ability, and progress, or you can have equality, and everyone being pulled down to the same low level. And suffering for everyone. You can’t have both. Take it from someone who has direct experience with communism, which is the same mentality that drives this.
- pessimizer 5y ago> You can have separation of education by ability, and progress, or you can have equality, and everyone being pulled down to the same low level. This seems a little off. What we're talking about (and what it seems like you're defending) is directing more resources towards the most gifted. It's fine to believe that, but it's an argument to give the most to those who have the most. Nobody is pulling anyone down, and communists are as happy to grant power and resources to those with aptitude and connections as capitalists are. edit: with the constant attacks on teachers, it might be more realistic to stop aiming for calculus in high school. Any kid who manages it within a gutted public system would have gotten there anyway, no matter what situation they found themselves in. They can download calculus books and calculus lectures now; with the internet a feral education is within everyone's reach.
- jl6 5y agoWhich states are doing it right?
- 2sk21 5y agoIn New Jersey and Massachusetts at least, there is absolutely no move to water down the math curriculum in any way. On the contrary, the schools here compete on how many AP courses are offered.
- whymauri 5y agoWhen I moved to MA, it blew my mind when I learned that what Florida considers an 'advanced' or even 'specialized' education is literally the baseline education in Boston and the suburbs. The best schools in Miami Dade County would be median in Middlesex.
- idoh 5y agoHere's a comparison between MA and CA standards: https://twitter.com/BethKellySF/status/1518991575526699008?s=20&t=z_xbNhw6Ea3qB05bOwBhxw https://twitter.com/BethKellySF/status/1518991575526699008?s...
- ecshafer 5y agoNew Jersey also has an excellent practices of magnet schools at the county level. So that even if you are in a poorer school district you can go study and apply for a magnet school at the county that is better and more focused on high academic schools. These schools focus on basically college level education for their area in health care, biochem, technology, arts, etc. with many AP courses. The normal public schools are also good in NJ with a solid baseline, but the magnet schools open up access to what would otherwise be private specialized schools to all income levels.
- texaslonghorn5 5y agoMagnet schools benefit the individual student but they are a bit problematic for many schools because they pick off the highest performers and whoever is willing to do the work to get admitted / physically drive to the magnet. And then the home school quality goes down and that hurts everyone else who isn't among the small group at the magnet.
- ckemere 5y agoText from the CMF: > "Since achieving a solid foundation in mathematics is more important for long-term success than rushing through courses with a superficial understanding, it would be desirable to consider how students who do not accelerate in eighth grade can reach higher level courses, potentially including Calculus, by twelfth grade. One possibility could involve reducing the repetition of content in high school, so that students do not need four courses before Calculus. Algebra 2 repeats a significant amount of the content of Algebra 1 and Pre-calculus repeats content from Algebra 2. While recognizing that some repetition of content has value, further analysis should be conducted to evaluate how high school course pathways may be redesigned to create a more streamlined three-year pathway to pre-calculus / calculus or statistics or data science, allowing students to take three years of middle school foundations and still reach advanced mathematics courses." At face value, that suggests that the root problem is that students reaching middle school Algebra 1 aren't ready and need more remedial math instruction. As an Electrical Engineering professor, I can definitely attest to the fact that students reaching higher level classes with a precarious foundation are rarely as successful as those whose foundation is more solid. I suspect Scott would also agree that barely passing calculus in high school is not an adequate preparation for a career in data science. As a parent of a kindergartner and a second grader, I can also see that there is opportunity to push more math further down, but even at that age there are kids who have a huge variability in how they view their math. With regard to resources, I thought this statement in the CMF was particularly insightful: > “While early tracking of students into low-level courses has been problematic, there is evidence that thoughtful grouping of students to ensure they receive high-quality instruction geared to their needs at a moment in time can be helpful. This includes students who need to fill in gaps in their prior learning and high-achieving students who are ready to be more intensely challenged. It is also true that teaching heterogeneous classes requires greater skill for differentiating supports than teaching in classes where the range of performance may be narrower, and should be accompanied by high-quality professional development to enable success.”
- ckemere 5y agoUpdate - having re-read the first post about this, it seems that the issue of resources is exactly the problem. I think that opponents of the CMF would prefer to see More Resources put into careful, thorough elementary/middle school math so that middle schoolers would thrive in 8th grade Algebra. And in their view, the CMF simply lowers the bar, masking the need for more resources. I agree with that!
- IshKebab 5y ago> as is suggested on lines 1226-1239 of Chapter 5 of the California Math Framework It's a MS Word document. How am I supposed to find lines 1226-1239? They might want to actually quote it.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoHere you go. Multiple methods listed but in short it's under Home / Find / Goto then select the line option. https://www.groovypost.com/howto/quickly-go-to-a-certain-page-line-or-section-in-word/ https://www.groovypost.com/howto/quickly-go-to-a-certain-pag...
- spicymaki 5y agoThe tension here is that educational achievement is a proxy measurement for IQ and in capitalist societies IQ is directly correlated with income. The cultural ideal here in the US is that hard work, effort, and grit is what is necessary for success. It is supposed to be purely egalitarian; you get what you give. However whether you are born with a high IQ is purely random, and even worse IQ is heritable. This is creating a technocracy which is at odds with the egalitarian ideal. This along with the expanding wealth gap is causing the schism you see today.
- n4r9 5y ago> whether you are born with a high IQ is purely random, and even worse IQ is heritable This sounds contradictory to me. Moreover, how does IQ differ in this respect from "capacity and willingness to do hard work"?
- eggsmediumrare 5y agoWho you are born as is random, but who will have children with higher IQ is not. Work ethic is less nature and more nurture than IQ, or at least feels that way intuitively.
- akomtu 5y ago> Who you are born as is random. The essense of materialistic nihilism.
- anthonypasq 5y agoI mean they are completely different measures. They both contribute to success but can be tested independantly. Also assuming that "capacity and willingness to do hard work" is a personality trait, that is also largely random. So no matter which way you slice it, you gotta get lucky on either the intelligence or industriousness axes (or both) to be successful.
- n4r9 5y ago
- klodolph 5y agoI don't live in CA and this isn't my circus, but I have some things to say about math education. From the statement: > We write to emphasize that for students to be prepared for STEM and other quantitative majors in 4-year colleges, [...], learning the Algebra II curriculum [...] in high school is essential. Problems with math are one of the most common reasons why students encounter difficulties in STEM education and careers. The most common problem is difficulty with high-school level algebra. I agree, fundamentally, with the relevant premise of the CA effort here (and agree with Aaronson's criticism of its implementation). That premise is that you shouldn't have to be on an accelerated track in middle school in order to take calculus in high school. And yet... the fact is, we get a lot of adults in college or graduate school pursuing STEM degrees, who have shaky foundations in high-school algebra. Just looking at the "typical" math track in US high schools it does seem a bit arbitrary. Algebra I, Geometry, Algebra II, Pre-Calculus, Calculus--this is the most common math track I see, with accelerated students starting Geometry in 9th grade, Calculus in 12th grade. The thing is... individual performance is highly variable in math classes, and to make sure that everyone gets good foundations in mathematics, we see high-school mathematics curricula that repeat the core algebra concepts in different classes. This repetition and focus on fundamentals is why the division between classes seems so arbitrary--what is presented as a sequence of classes is really more of a unified curriculum spread across multiple years. When you combine these two factors (variable performance, repetition in the curriculum), you end up with a population of high-school students who develop good foundations in algebra early on and are bored by the repetition, and a population of students who really benefit from the time spent mastering algebra, and it's hard to serve both. I think we can figure out a way to let high-school students take AP calculus in 12th grade without expecting them to take Algebra I in 8th grade, and we don't need to push everyone into calculus faster in order to do it. And yet, my experience with high-school education in the US has left me very cynical about it. Letting students progress through the high-school math curriculum at the right rate requires a kind of "personal touch" that seems to only happen to individual students when their parents are involved, but not pushy. It's rare. The school system would rather do the easy thing (everybody moves in lockstep to the next class in the sequence), and parents are largely either uninvolved or overinvolved. (This is more or less what the article says, I'm agreeing with the article.)
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jake891 5y agoCalifornians would do well to compare themselves to Massachusetts https://www.doe.mass.edu/frameworks/math/2017-06.pdf https://www.doe.mass.edu/frameworks/math/2017-06.pdf
- truthwhisperer 5y ago
- idoh 5y agoSF CA resident, parent of two school age children chiming in. The direction with math seems pretty dismal, in that as of right now, everyone is singly tracked together for math through freshman year of high school. This results in children who have higher aptitudes[1] to not be well served by schools. The majority of people I know who have the means opt out of the public school system, which probably makes the problem worse generally but solves a pain point for them. [1] - I take it as a fact that different people have different talent levels for different things, but not everyone agrees with that, and disagreement on this point is a big driver (but not the only driver) in the "everyone gets exactly the same" approach that is trending now.
- 300bps 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron In the year 2081, the 211th, 212th, and 213th amendments to the Constitution dictate that all Americans are fully equal and not allowed to be smarter, better-looking, or more physically able than anyone else
- micromacrofoot 5y agoI'm not sure that would be worse than the current system where the richer American is smarter, better looking, and more physically able
- 300bps 5y agoThere are quite literally billions of people that are richer, smarter, better looking and/or more physically able than I am. I'm glad for it. I would never want to bring anyone else down to meet me at my level on any metric.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoIt doesn’t bother you sometimes that some people starve while others hoard wealth that rivals the gdp of entire countries? I don’t want everyone to be the same, but unbridled disparity seems equally as bad to me… especially considering how arbitrary it can be.
- deanCommie 5y agoIrrespective of specific educational curriculums, I'm curious what does HN think about Calculus? I absolutely loved learning Calculus in high school in Math and 1st and 2nd year of University. I consistently got 97+% on my grades. And I've never had to use it in my Computer Science degree or my 20 year Software Engineer career since. Am in a bubble because I don't spend much time in the Machine Learning domain?
- npunt 5y agoI've never understood the cult of calculus. I think it comes from mistaking the importance of its discovery for the importance of teaching it. It was a huge unlock for science, but is in no way a huge unlock for most people's lives. On the other hand, I feel psychology and stats are the biggest missing pieces in K12 education. We need to build greater awareness of human needs and fallibilities, and awareness of how to make decisions in uncertain environments by understanding probabilities. Both are about developing a nuanced perspective on life and making better, more sober decisions, and they build a great deal of empathy to boot. Finally, psych & stats are inherently relatable - everyone deals with people and has to make decisions. So much of the K12 experience isn't relatable, which is why students often hate school.
- ecshafer 5y agoCalculus is critically essential for learning many later math fields, and many important topics. Mechanical Engineering, Electrical Engineering, Physics, Chemistry, Civil Engineering, Aerospace, etc. There is a lot of very critical fields to modern society that requires knowledge of calculus. You can't build a modern bridge without calculus.
- npunt 5y agoI don’t dismiss its value in the broader education system, nor for certain industries and jobs. But specifically in the context of K12 requirements & expectations in the process of applying for college, it’s hardly foundational knowledge for most of life’s paths. Ergo, it’s best to a) not to have college expectations be built around most/everyone having it before college and punishing those who don’t, b) focus on teaching it where it’s needed (eg when in college for those majors), and of course c) if a kid knows their path involves it earlier, make it available to learn when they want to.
- dboreham 5y agoI think I can translate this: It's saying that it is impossible to get the bulk of students (with the teachers we have) to complete the standard mathematics curriculum by the end of high school. This has always been true, in all countries, hence "streaming". But now they're saying let's do away with the advanced stream, therefore students can't complete the last part of the US mathematics curriculum (which is called "Calculus"). Rather than justify that move in terms of cost or fairness, we're going to say "because Calculus isn't important now". This is obviously completely bogus. If their assertion that Leibnitz-style calculus isn't important now, they could replace it with Linear Algebra, Number Theory, or some other "important now" subject. Add to that, the fact that in the US the names of high school mathematics classes are by convention. "Geometry" isn't all geometry, for example. And "Calculus" isn't all calculus. The classes are really : Math 1, Math 2, Math 3, Math 4, AP Math.
- 0000011111 5y agoWhy can we do both? 1. Make it possible for HS students who are interested in Calculus to take the course under the instruction from a college profess on the high school campus. That way it would be set up for students to get college credit for the class and they would not need to travel to a college campus or deal with the AP exam system. 2. Make it possible for HS students who are not interested (Yet) or at all to graduate with out taking the class. Lots of student are ready for Calculus until college anyway. No need to force them on a single path IMO.
- dymk 5y agoProbably the optics that will ensue - Our public schools seem intent on making sure that to ensure everybody is as achieved as everyone else, but rather than improving education for the bottom percentile, they'll simply remove the advanced stuff for the top percentile.
- 0000011111 5y agoFortuity there are free options for good online instruction available to everyone in the world with youtube access. https://www.khanacademy.org/math/ap-calculus-ab https://www.khanacademy.org/math/ap-calculus-ab When we focus narrowly on what brick and mortar Public HS should and should not be teaching in regards to math curium we sideline all the pathways for learning available outside of this bureaucratic model. Folks in most places in the United States a least can check out a Chromebook from a local library and use their free internet to access this information.
- dymk 5y agoI don't think it's reasonable to expect some kid to sit through their algebra class, and then go home and take a self-directed calculus class at home. Certainly only the kids who are hyper-math-ers are going to do that in the first place, and we miss out on the kids who would have taken calc had it simply been offered. Highschoolers fork over swaths of their day to the public education system already. Let's try to not waste any more of their time.
- bawolff 5y agoEveryone talking about calculus, but they also seem to want to cut logrithms?? That seems super fundamental to me.
- roody15 5y agoI have worked in education for 16 years and just wanted to add my perspective. Here in Illinois over the last few years the state has shifted its goals to "equitable outcomes". This in and of itself is responsible for much of the lowering of academic standards since it is a flawed (but perhaps well intention-ed) goal. In a excellent school district in a suburb of Chicago a district goal was adopted to reach equitable outcomes in higher Math. In a nutshell since black students scored statistically lower on AP Calculus this was seen as a failure in the school district. Despite increasing the number of black students able to pass AP Calculus the school district looked to cancel offering the course since Asian and affluent white students still scored statistically higher. The idea that all races, genders, or whatever categorization you can come up with must have the same equitable outcome is a flawed goal. Education used to be about taking a student where they are and showing improved learning outcomes. Equality used to be about striving for equal opportunity. The shift to conflating equality with equalized outcomes simply doesn't work.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Equality used to be about striving for equal opportunity. The shift to conflating equality with equalized outcomes simply doesn't work. Note that to the extent there was a shift, it took place in the 70s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disparate_impact#The_80%_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disparate_impact#The_80%_rule
- roody15 5y ago"Note that to the extent there was a shift, it took place in the 70s." This really has ramped up in the last 2-3 years.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoI would suggest that in fact it hasn't; it was just as virulent over the past 50 years as it was over the last 3, but you just noticed it more in the last 3 years.
- umvi 5y agoJust my opinion but... is Calculus an important high school goal? I took AP Calc in high school, got a 4 on the exam. I did Electrical Engineering in college and took college level math through differential equations. And yet... a) I've never used calculus once in my STEM career, b) looking back I realize I never really understood calculus back when I was in high school and college. I came to that realization a decade after college when I was digesting 3Blue1Brown's series on Calculus for fun and had it finally click. Before then I was basically a Chinese Room that was able to solve calculus problems via pattern matching (i.e. "oh, this problem fits the shape of these rules, etc.") without really understanding how calculus works.
- colinmhayes 5y ago> without really understanding how calculus works. I think this is the key. No, calculus isn't incredibly applicable in day to day life. But understanding how it works builds critical thinking skills that absolutely are. Math should be about critical thinking, not memorizing. Common core seems to be moving us in the right direction.
- steve76 5y ago
- bigbillheck 5y agoMy high school didn't offer calculus, and now thirty years later I'm posting on the hacker news forums.
- iamleppert 5y agoI'll save you from reading and get to the point: It's a lot easier to just move the goal post than to actually achieve the goal.
- TimPC 5y agoThis curriculum has been brought to you by the campaign to import all technology workers from foreign countries.
- Drblessing 5y agoRecipe for societal collapse
- russellbeattie 5y agoHere's my experience as a parent of a 20yo who went through the MVLA school district in Mountain View. It's a warning to any parents of younger children: Unless something has changed radically in the past 8 years, your child will be put into a math track in 6th grade: Separated into standard, accelerated and advanced classes. Which track you're in is determined by grades, standardized tests and teacher input after 5th grade. This track determines which classes you can take in 7th and 8th. If you were in the advanced class, you will have finished Algebra 1 by the end of 8th grade. This allows the student to begin 9th grade taking Algebra 2, and then extending from there so that by their senior year they can take AP Calculus. If you want little Suzy to be in more advanced classes, you better be prepared to be the most vocal Tiger Mom Karen you can imagine, because you'll have plenty of competition. As a result, almost no child moves between tracks. And in fact, in my opinion, the difference between normal and accelerated is so little, I'm pretty sure it's there just to give those children somewhere to go. In other words, if your child doesn't demonstrate math skills as an 11yo, they will unlikely be able to take AP calculus 7 years later without doing something extra like taking summer classes, redoing an entire school year (an option a fellow parent I know took), or extraordinary effort like that. Even if the MVLA education system isn't exactly the same now, or you live in a district that does something totally different, or even if you're in another state, I suspect this sort of thing is happening everywhere. I personally was happy my son was in accelerated classes, right up until 9th grade when I realized how this circumscribed his future options for classes. In the end he would never have wanted to take AP Calculus, so it was fine. But I personally felt like I had fucked up as a parent because I simply wasn't paying attention. Planning out your kid's future math classes in detail in the 5th grade never crossed my mind, or if it had, I would have dismissed it as ludicrous overparenting! Had I known, I might have sent him to a math camp or something if I had realized how important the difference between a B+ and an A in math was at that moment. And he my have really gotten into mathematics as a subject. I really don't know. So anyways, that's my experience. California is such a massive change from where I grew up in rural NH, I honestly can't imagine where to begin to fix a system with so many millions of children from such a varied socioeconomic and cultural backgrounds. I barely got my one kid through the system unscathed, and I live in one of the wealthiest districts in the country.
- deleted 5y ago
- TimPC 5y agoSomething is rotten in the state of academia when looking at the evidence there are mathematicians, scientists and social scientists standing bravely in favour of a high bar and a quality education program in mathematics. On the other side of the argument you have people from the Department of Education who specialize in Mathematics Education who seem happy to lower the bar as far as possible in the name of equality. When I was in University the Department of Education was the most woke department on campus, except for perhaps the Department of Gender Studies. We are now seeing policies that favour wokeness ahead of the best interests of the students affected by the policies.
- crackercrews 5y ago> On the other side of the argument you have people from the Department of Education who specialize in Mathematics Education who seem happy to lower the bar as far as possible in the name of equality. They should rename the Department of Education the Department of Equity. By pushing frameworks like this, they show that they are less interested in education and more interested in achieving equity. They'll even privilege equity at the expense of actual education.
- Dig1t 5y agoIt's kind of funny how both sides of the political aisle have extremists who find ways to argue that being dummer is better. They mirror each other in so many ways and sometimes the two extremes kind of wrap back around to the other side and have the same goals.
- threatofrain 5y agoNo, the two sides of this debate aren't mirroring their arguments. One side (Equitable Math) is engaged in a discussion of white supremacy in Californian math pedagogy. The other side (Moses Charikar, Scott Aaronson, et al) is arguing against a weakening of math standards.
- caddemon 5y agoI don't think he's talking about this debate, just that the Equitable Math extremists have some common ground with e.g. southern conservatives in how they view educational achievements.
- reducesuffering 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory There were three factions in WW2 and the Cold War. It was about preventing the assault of extremists on both sides.
- Drblessing 5y agoHorseshoe theory supremacy
- slowmovintarget 5y agoThe worst thing about the CMF effort is that it would only deepen the disparities between rich and poor. Public education is often the only shot poor kids have to gain knowledge and skills that might propel them into STEM fields. Do we need to mail copies of Stand and Deliver to the entire California school board? Or am I the only one that recalls that movie... based on something that actually happened... in California. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaime_Escalante https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaime_Escalante
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- john_moscow 5y agoWell, why do you think the elites are unanimously supporting the recent equity initiatives? Because in reality they penalize the potential contenders from the rank-and-file class, while the top ladder plays by their own playback.
- nullc 5y agoI don't think that's the motivation. Elites don't mind if some bright poor kids get a good education-- all the better: more advanced education means that there is a larger hiring pool to fill complex jobs at the elite's companies. When you're highly privileged it's extremely easy to imagine that most things are positive sum and not zero sum competition because when you're wrong and your cooperation was actually a disadvantage it's still no big deal for you. Instead, I think it's just cheap feel good measures, virtue signaling, and not wanting to take the costs/risks of bucking a fad. If you don't know whats good or bad, well cheer for the popular change and pat yourself on the back. If you do know that the initiative is bad, speaking against it may get you called a racist-- better to say nothing and relocate to where your kids will get a good education. Someone sufficiently wealthy never has to worry about a known bad policy resulting in a poor education for their kids-- they can always apply money to the problem, one way or another.
- timcavel 5y ago
- charlescearl 5y agoIn the last couple of months, two readings stay with me on challenging the notion that math/science are things that only “certain kinds of men” do (more a gendered stance in the u.s. than eastern europe / asia). The first is The Dawn of Everything, by David Graeber. I’m left with the notion that what we now call science and mathematics emerged from tinkering, persistent experimentation done mostly by women, and that what we have now disciplined into mathematics emerges from the systematic study and production of pattern (basket making, the organization of communal structures), and Graeber seems to argue against the hierarchical gender divides when viewed across the broad stretch of human history. Rachel Thomas https://www.fast.ai/2022/03/15/math-person/ https://www.fast.ai/2022/03/15/math-person/ also makes a case that math is something that all people do. I think that the larger point both are making is that disciplines don’t have to be the way they are constructed now. My only “political”’statement would be the hope that states (particularly the u.s.) would invest as deeply in mathematics education at the primary and secondary level, for all of its communities, at the level of investment in big science and big military projects.
- hintymad 5y agoI also believe that maths and STEM is something that all people do. Well, maybe not all, but at least not just a few geniuses. For that matter, I believe the progressives prescribed the wrong solution. The ordinary people, those who are are not the top X% in schools, need the push from their teachers, need the challenges in course work to push themselves to truly learn, and need a certain repetitiveness to truly grasp the fundamental concepts and skills. How do I know that? I was one of such students. I made it because my teachers pushed me. They used carefully designed homework to show me that I didn't really have the deep understanding of math as I thought. They used homework to show me that my understanding of Newton physics was inadequate. They used midterms to show me that I didn't really intuitively grasp algorithm analysis (I didn't know how to rigorously and succinctly argue that two pivots and one pivot are really the same in quicksort). I grew to enjoy STEM and CS precisely because I was lucky to have tough yet encouraging schools. Dumbing down courses would have taken away the push I needed, and I would likely have a lot more failures in my life.
- WhyOhWhyQ 5y agoI'd be interested in trying out the following idea: How about we don't mandate mathematics and science courses in high school, and especially in early college? The benefits of this are two-fold. The people who want to pursue other interests are freer to do so. And, more importantly to me as a mathematics graduate student, the people who are interested in math and science can go much much faster, and attain a higher level earlier on. As far as I can tell, most other countries with successful mathematics cultures operate more like this. In my math PhD program, the foreign students almost universally arrived better prepared (more knowledgeable and skilled) than the Americans. I believe the gen-ed requirements and general lack of specialization in American education may have a role in this.
- junar 5y ago> As far as I can tell, most other countries with successful mathematics cultures operate more like this. Which country do you mean? As far as I'm aware, it's the opposite: countries like China and South Korea have math as a required subject on their college entrance exams for all students. The non-STEM students may have fewer requirements, but I'm fairly sure they've still learned more than the average American high school student. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaokao#Reform_of_the_National_College_Entrance_Examination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaokao#Reform_of_the_National_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/College_Scholastic_Ability_Test#Mathematics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/College_Scholastic_Ability_Tes... https://medium.com/@yujia_jo/2016-jiangsu-gaokao-national-higher-education-entrance-exam-mathematics-2beefb93cec7 https://medium.com/@yujia_jo/2016-jiangsu-gaokao-national-hi...
- WhyOhWhyQ 5y agoI was really thinking about the lack of 1-2 years of general education classes before a major can be declared, at university, with that particular remark. I know this to be the case in several European countries, and India; in India you choose a specialization at the "11th-12th" grade level I believe. I did assume that to be the case in China, though it looks like Chinese universities may actually spend a lot of time on gen-ed classes. I'll have to ask my Chinese friends about their experience. I think you declare a major in the first year of university in South Korea, but I could be mistaken. If anybody wants to shed light on this by sharing when the major/specialization is declared in their country, please do. I do know there are countries which allow specialization at the high school level (India, Italy, Romania I believe). I found this interesting list, which is more complete than I can be on this. I don't think it proves that countries with great mathematical cultures always allow specialization in high school, but it does have some examples of this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_secondary_education_systems_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_secondary_education_sy...
- rob_c 5y ago
- poorbutdebtfree 5y agoParents aren't going to stay in school districts that prioritize "equitable outcomes" above all else. This is likely the reason why real estate values for towns with 95% asians/whites are exploding YOY.
- WalterBright 5y agoIs there a summary of the CMF that removes all the bureaucrateese? I didn't get very far through that molasses. I had to scrape it off with my trusty strigil.
- eezing 5y ago“[current curriculum] creates students who see mathematics as an exercise in memorized procedures that match different problem types. Yet, university professors and employers want graduates with critical thinking and reasoning skills.” I agree with this problem statement.
- tonyspy 5y agoStop buying all this fake software, They don't work...Contact a Professional Private Hacker with transparency, sincerity and strategy, Who Specializes in Accessing & Recovery of people’s social media such as Snapchat, Instagram, WhatsApp hack,Viber etc, Skype, Facebook, ICQ with no trace. (spywaresolution4) Gmail watsPP + 1 412 227 3381 Dicord (spywarsolution#3558)
- tonyspy 5y agoDo you have problems with your grades, You don't have to worry any more, Contact Spyware Solution for any website hack and diffusion, We can help you remove any unwanted comments, pictures, videos or article online permanently, Increasing your grades or Back dates of Certification. We do that just like magic (spywaresolution4) Gmail watsPP + 1 412 227 3381 Dicord (spywarsolution#3558)