6 ms·
The cities that do make the transition quicker will have economic advantages, so I'm not so sure that the transition will be slow once a few cities make it. And
by seanmcdirmid 5y ago
The cities that do make the transition quicker will have economic advantages, so I'm not so sure that the transition will be slow once a few cities make it. And we aren't just talking about the USA, we have to contend with large cities in Asia with worse traffic and more incentives to adopt the technology before American ones do.
- dwighttk 5y agoEconomic advantages along with a huge number of jobs destroyed
- jliptzin 5y agoHuge number of *shitty jobs destroyed Isn't that kind of the point of technological progress?
- bufferoverflow 5y agoShitty or not, they are jobs. You failed to address what will happen to these drivers. Average age: 46.
- kadoban 5y agoYes, but since we live in a bootstrappy wonderland, the current holders of those shitty jobs will be ~destroyed as well.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoThe Luddites did ok. Why would it be different this time?
- carlmr 5y agoActually a lot of them didn't, hence the protests. Innovation can take away your job in a span of ten years while not creating new jobs for generations to come.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> Innovation can take away your job in a span of ten years while not creating new jobs for generations to come. That case isn't true. The new generations had jobs well enough (increased productivity grew the economy much faster than before), they weren't committed to weaving clothes by hand. The Luddites themselves didn't fair as well in the short term, but many of them would have aged out of the work force in a few years anyways (manual weaving is pretty unforgiving on the body). Truck drivers are rapidly aging as well, if self driving vehicles move retirement up by 5 or so years, it isn't going that huge of a deal (we can rely even on America's social safety net), and their kids didn't want to be truck drivers anyways.
- carlmr 5y ago>Truck drivers are rapidly aging as well, if self driving vehicles move retirement up by 5 or so years, it isn't going that huge of a deal That's quite optimistic. When did politicians ever talk about moving up the retirement age in the last decades. The internet brought insane growth through productivity gains in all industries. Even more than I'd expect from self-driving cars. And we haven't talked about moving up the retirement age. Also the question is what these people do now? In the next twenty years of unemployment until they reach the current retirement age?
- dfxm12 5y agoYes, but, it unfortunately only leads to social progress if everything else keeps up - you'd be surprised how many social programs currently have work requirements ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. Unemployment benefits, some type of UBI, education/job training affordability, social security, etc. are all things that need to be reevaluated if a whole job category is going to be removed. Job automation is great, but there are externalities that should be accounted for ahead of time. You can ask, "who pays for this?" Well, the obvious answer is the companies that will be enriching themselves due to society's sacrifice. Although, that has happened during the pandemic, so it's clear corporations aren't going to do so out of some sense of civic duty.
- munk-a 5y agoThis argument didn't stop cab driving from transitioning from a serious employment opportunity to employment as a service contractors - so I don't know if that's enough to hold back the tide for the taxi side of things... on the trucking side I think there will probably be a big reckoning at some point though. Teamsters unions mean business.
- jeromegv 5y agoLabor is cheaper in Asia so I'm not sure why the transition would happen faster there. Lots of jobs exists there for the sole purpose that the price of a robot/automation is way higher than paying someone to do it.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoTraffic jams and limited road infrastructure (with no space for more, so use needs to be optimized) are a PITA in Asia. It isn't really the cost of the taxi drivers (who are increasingly becoming scarce as young people choose better careers). Coupled with authoritarian governments that can push changes more readily than western governments, and Beijing, Shanghai, Singapore, Tokyo are easily on their way in this direction.
- tobijkl 5y agoAs long as there are still some vehicles with human drivers on the roadways, congestion will not change.
- seanmcdirmid 5y ago> As long as there are still some vehicles with human drivers on the roadways You understand. If the government can tell you that you can only drive even or odd days, tell you that you can't drive at all (and must use self driving cars inside the 4th or even 5th ring road) is a very distinct possibility.
- pengaru 5y ago> congestion will not change. Congestion arguably will worsen first.
- darepublic 5y agowhy would congestion change if all the drivers were fully autonomous? It's one thing to have a fully autonomous driver, but having them coordinate perfectly to have good throughput even in dense traffic conditions is another altogether. I think this second goal is much farther off and if the articles I've read on autonomous vehicles is any indication I expect they will drive more cautiously and slowly than most human drivers when they finally "go live" in a widespread fashion