14 ms·
"Following Bernal’s dismissal, Tesla also cut off his access to the FSD Beta system in the vehicle he personally owns, a 2021 Tesla Model 3, despite having no s
by fjklap 5y ago
"Following Bernal’s dismissal, Tesla also cut off his access to the FSD Beta system in the vehicle he personally owns, a 2021 Tesla Model 3, despite having no safety “strikes” in the software."
This shows that you don't own a Tesla, it owns you. What was Musk saying again about the freezing of the bank accounts of the Canadian truckers?
- hackernewds 5y agoIf they _really_ despised him, imagine they could crash his car off a cliff as well? This is our self-driving future.
- mlindner 5y agoTesla has no remote ability to control the vehicle.
- macintux 5y agoI don't know how we'd ever know that's true; at the very least, the capability would seem to be inherent in the system.
- revnode 5y agoThey have remote root access to the vehicle. Even if they didn’t, they can push an update specific to your vehicle that then drives you off a cliff at a designated time.
- mlindner 5y agoUpdates are not automatic. You choose when to install them. People can and regularly do, wait long periods of time before updating.
- catmanjan 5y agoProve it? Link the repo
- tablespoon 5y ago> Updates are not automatic. You choose when to install them. People can and regularly do, wait long periods of time before updating. Says Tesla's software, which can be changed or can be lying. IIRC, one self-described ex-Telsa firmware guy recounted on some story where he or his team scripted running some SSH commands on a bunch of vehicles to fix some bug they pushed that wouldn't have been able to fix otherwise.
- FireBeyond 5y agoDemonstrably false. Prior to the M3 release, someone with an MS discovered its existence in the firmware. Tesla disabled his ethernet port in the vehicle, automatically downgraded the firmware to another version which didn't have references, and then blocked the car from getting future upgrades. -User mode updates- may not be automatic - that does nothing to prove that Tesla cannot update a vehicle without interaction.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mynameisvlad 5y agoUpdates are also not generally delivered via cellular, unless they're classified as critical. Tesla owns the entire stack. They choose when to update, it just happens to be easier and more pleasant to give people the choice. Given that you can trigger the update via the mobile app, there is clearly support for remote updates. And if you as an owner can do it, then Tesla certainly can, even if they choose not to.
- kadoban 5y agoThat's basically guaranteed not to be true. What would prevent them from sending software that does what the current one does except the steering is triggered by different events?
- mlindner 5y agoSoftware updates are not automatic. You choose when they are installed. They can't just remotely force software into your vehicle.
- gjs278 5y ago
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoIs that by policy or by technology? If it's a confirmation button on a screen, I'm betting it's only policy that stops them from updating the software without permission.
- dboreham 5y agoAnyone who develops software is going to say "yes they can". The optional aspect is just its normal behavior, but there will be a forced upgrade mode in there for if they ever need it.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Tesla has no remote ability to control the vehicle. As long as they can remotely update the software, it's always one update away from that.
- mlindner 5y agoAs I've already responded to three people in this comment chain (can no one read?). Tesla cannot remotely update the software. So many people believe so much nonsense propaganda about Tesla. It's unbelievable.
- snypher 5y ago>Tesla cannot remotely update the software. Why would you have any reason to believe this? Honestly speaking, believing they couldn't would be buying into propaganda.
- mynameisvlad 5y agoJust because you responded three times does not make you right. The ability to trigger an update from your phone is possible, Tesla can and does remotely start and stop updates in case of an issue downloading, and either way they own the stack all up and can change any behavior at any time.
- privacyking 5y agoIt must be nice to be ignorant.
- falcolas 5y agoApparently false. A recent article by a repo man reported that Tesla set up FSD to bring the car out to the repo crew. https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/tesla-remote-accessing-car-for-repo.260518/ https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/tesla-remote-accessi...
- mlindner 5y agoPolice have also claimed that they saw Tesla driving with no one in the car and many other things that are demonstrably impossible to do. This is just one more of those things that people claim because they like media attention regarding Tesla.
- falcolas 5y agoThey stated that the remote summon feature was used. Its a well known feature of Teslas FSD system, not some random event. Given the plausibility of the circumstances, we’d need an official statement from Tesla to debunk it. Not confident statements with no backing evidence.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoSmart summon is triggered through an API call over cellular network, true or false? Assuming the request is cryptographically signed or else originates over an encrypted connection, is the certificate in the hands of the car owner, or Tesla? QED, whether or not cops make shit up, Tesla has the capability to remote command teslas. If they are smart, they will prevent you from sending destinations to autopilot navigation over the same API. But anyway if they can push updates OTA w/o user interaction, it's all moot, I, Robot style
- Guvante 5y agoAssuming they have decent source control and an audit trail (most safety critical things do) you would probably have an easier time hiring someone to throw them off the cliff. Assuming you care if people find out you did it of course but if literal murder via software hacking doesn't get you in trouble then you could just hire a hitman for less money.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoSo you are relying on Tesla to monitor Tesla and gather evidence of criminal behaviour by Tesla. Seriously, does noone see a tiny flaw here?
- Guvante 5y agoThis isn't something that is easy to do. You need to interact with probably 12 people any of whom could trivially copy the data off the machine and whistleblow you. Criminal behavior implies something minor. Murdering a dissident isn't minor.
- randcraw 5y agoOf course, those 12 people could also expect to receive the same kind of 'sanction' that they just witnessed. And since their employer has access to all their personal communications while in the car, the company has access to a wealth of the most sensitive personal info that's almost trivial to abuse, if in fact retaliatory murder WAS considered to be overkill. That might be enough to dissuade them from whistleblowing. (That and the fact that whistleblowing is nearly always a great way to commit professional suicide in this country.)
- throwawaylinux 5y agoIf they had good evidence he was a traitorous Russian agent or some other person who was a threat to the government or the corporation they would be be justified in extrajudicial execution. Or so many would seem to believe.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoHe might not have had to purchased it, it could have been given to him as a perk of employment, and when he was let go...it was rescinded until he could purchase it like everyone else?
- mccorrinall 5y agoMy dad has beta 10.11 on his tesla. I don’t know that much about tesla, but apparently the betas are accessible to all FSD customers? I’m unsure if there’s even a “stable” version yet. t. a son who goes by train
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoSo did your dad get the beta for free as a perk? Or did he have to buy FSD to participate in the beta? Without knowing more, pitchforking at this point is probably not called for.
- mccorrinall 5y agoHe bought it.
- filoleg 5y ago> apparently the betas are accessible to all FSD customers? Incorrect. If you are an FSD customer, you are eligible to sign up and put yourself on the waitlist for FSD Beta, and then you get selected at some point in the future if you are lucky. Source: been on that waitlist since it had first opened back in September 2021, still waiting to receive FSD Beta.
- Rebelgecko 5y agoWhat is an FSD customer actually buying if they aren't in the beta? An older alpha version?
- mlindner 5y ago
- savant_penguin 5y agoIt's an absolute shitstorm that electric vehicles are taking the phone route to near no ownership
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gameswithgo 5y agoall vehicles
- MBCook 5y agoHave any other OEMs pulled back paid for features that previously worked on an EV?
- dghlsakjg 5y agoToyota had to rescue themselves when they threatened to retroactively make remote start a subscription service
- bragr 5y agoAnd to be clear it was keyfob based remote start they wanted to charge for, not app/internet based.
- HWR_14 5y agoAre you sure? I heard the opposite - it was only the app/internet version and the keyfob continued to work.
- bragr 5y agohttps://www.thedrive.com/tech/43636/toyota-reviewing-key-fob-remote-start-subscription-plan-after-massive-blowback https://www.thedrive.com/tech/43636/toyota-reviewing-key-fob...
- madrox 5y agoThis shows that you don't own a Tesla, it owns you Come now, kicking someone out of a beta - former employee or not - who is using the access to post reviews is hardly new or unique to this situation. Nor is it unethical.
- oneoff786 5y agoThe FSD Beta is a free service you need to get invited into, no?
- filoleg 5y agoAlmost, but your conclusion is overall correct. You gotta have FSD purchased, but you are correct that FSD Beta itself is free and invite only (you gotta sign up to get put on the waitlist and then get selected).
- mlindner 5y agoYou have to request access and Tesla has to review it and reserves the right to revoke it at any time for any reason. They also turn on extensive additional monitoring of your vehicle while you're in the program.
- mlindner 5y agoPlease don't misconstrue the facts. Access to the FSD Beta is not something that everyone just gets. You have to both request access and Tesla has to review your request to access it and then grant you access individually. It's a privilege, not a right, nor something you paid for.
- Commodore63 5y ago>nor something you paid for It's $12k, isn't it?
- mlindner 5y agoThat $12k only gives you the ability to request access. It doesn't actually get you anything.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThats exactly the problem - the OP is saying you don't own it despite paying money for it The entitled attitude that we as a business will take your money but provide nothing if we don't like your face, started with internet companies and is now spreading into the rest of life like cancer.
- midhhhthrow 5y agoNormally I would agree with this assessment but let’s remember it’s a super beta that may have only been given to him because he’s an employee
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoThere have been calls for Tesla to brick all of their cars in Russia, which apparently is possible for them to do. I'm sure the company wants to pretend they don't hear those calls because if they did it, it'd scare off a lot of future customers but if they don't do it, they're accused of supporting the invasion of Ukraine. Weird times we live in.
- nurettin 5y agoEven github is being accused of facilitating the invasion. While the war is terrible, the accusations are absolutely bonkers. On the other hand, it all depends on the US gov. international trading and tax law regulations. They could pass a law just like they did with Iran and Tesla/Microsoft will have to follow suit.
- rurban 5y agopass a law? the last time they did this with crimea was a presidential executive order, citing a national emergency. passing laws would be used in a democracy. this is not one. https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/presidential-actions/2021/03/03/notice-on-the-continuation-of-the-national-emergency-with-respect-to-ukraine/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/presidential-action...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nunez 5y agoa) that would be an act of war facilitated by a private company, so, yeah, not a great idea, and b) do people really want to set a precedent of having a private company prevent access to the thing you bought because you disagree with a political position?
- unityByFreedom 5y ago(b) is reasonable, (a) is not how I would classify such a move.
- ajross 5y ago> This shows that you don't own a Tesla, it owns you No, it shows that beta software is issued under a license. No one "owns" FSD beta. You apply and get granted access. It's not the car, it's not even the car's native software suite. It's a test version of software Tesla is offering on different terms. (It's also pretty amazing, fwiw.)
- cinntaile 5y ago> It's also pretty amazing, fwiw. Judging from the video's online where FSD beta is massively failing, I fail to see how amazing is not a huge overstatement?
- kmonsen 5y agoIt can be both pretty amazing and massively failing at times? I mean 10 years ago we would not think the FSD beta is possible, even if it is not reliable enough to be used as self driving.
- ajross 5y agoThat's like judging humanity by ZOMG Fail videos you saw on tiktok. Call a friend, get a ride and see for yourself. It's been months now since I've had a safety-related intervention. The biggest problems are things like lane selection and timidity.
- oxplot 5y agoNo one who has access to FSD Beta, is in any shape or form mistaken, to think that Tesla is under any obligation to keep providing the feature whether the driver has a safety score of 100 or not. Tesla clearly states in their terms, before you can turn FSD Beta on, that they reserve the right to take it away at any time for any reason and rightly so. Our great HN community here throws rocks at Tesla and FSD Beta any chance they get. Why in the world would Tesla allow someone whom they employ, to generate bad press while they're still heavily developing a tech. Isn't FSD Beta already not enough negatively covered? As for firing the employee, WTF Tesla?
- esjeon 5y ago> Why in the world would Tesla allow someone whom they employ, to generate bad press while they're still heavily developing a tech. Isn't FSD Beta already not enough negatively covered? Welp, you can’t blame others when you yourself is jumping into the burning pot of politics. Tesla just did that by firing the employee in question, and also blurred the line b/w normal business operation and politics by disabling FSD. Now, nothing can stop all the political notes from everywhere. Rather, if you advocate the freedom of speech, you should encourage this.
- oxplot 5y ago> Tesla just did that by firing the employee in question I think that was a mistake. Taking away the beta privileges would have been sufficient. > blurred the line b/w normal business operation and politics by disabling FSD You're way down playing the impact of the kind of mindset that the average joe has about FSD Beta as portrayed in mainstream media. It's so hostile, emotionally charged and void of any evidence of actual danger, that it pushes the bias needle against Tesla to the breaking point. If your blood sweat and tear is being pummeled around the clock, you get into politics in a blink and double down with whatever you can muster. Those who think Tesla is just in it for the money, well, there is no conversation to be had with them. They'll catch up. But if one actually believes in what Tesla claims to exist for, then it doesn't take a lot of thinking to see they're right in pushing back aggressively as they do.
- itsoktocry 5y ago
- undefinedzero 5y agoThis statement is misleading as is evident by the top replies. He, as many Tesla employees do, got FSD for free from Tesla. He still owns the free FSD after being fired, which as it being an employee perk already seems strange to me. FSD beta is a closed beta only for people in the top ~1% safety scores and can be revoked for any reason (as has been done for reckless drivers). I assume another Tesla tester perk (he was employed as an FSD tester after all) is getting into the beta program regardless of your safety score. Revoking that employee-privilege after firing is not taking something he owns. AFAIK Tesla has never taken unlocked addons such as FSD away from cars that were paid for.
- chucklenorris 5y agoExcept when you buy a used car with already paid fsd by the previous owner.
- millerm 5y agoStop spreading FUD. This isn't happening, there was a case that was overblown and rectified. This just doesn't happen. FSD goes with the car on private sales.
- chucklenorris 5y agoOverblown? If you buy something and the seller sends you the wrong item you have the legal right to keep it. In a normal world if that seller steals back that item, he is guilty of theft. It doesn't matter if he "rectified" the issue.
- stetrain 5y agoOnly when that car was purchased back by Tesla. Private or third party sales transfer the FSD license to the new owner. There was a highly publicized case where they got this wrong. Tesla sold the car at auction to a dealer with FSD still active, then disabled it later after the sale. They reversed this and as far as I know it is not the norm.
- winternett 5y ago
- millerm 5y agoIf I left a company, where I had access to internal betas, yes I would expect the company to revoke access if I were terminated.
- jansen555 5y ago
- winternett 5y agoJust wait until non-employee people begin to get dropped from support for posting complaints to Twitter (While they're doing 80 on the highway in full autonomous mode). That's when I'll just start riding a low-tech bicycle everywhere.