15 ms·
Upper limits on partial Dyson spheres in the Milky Way
- nyx 5y agoMost people get baked, wonder if we're alone in the universe, and take a nap. Astrophysicists get baked, wonder if we're alone in the universe, and publish papers like this. Jokes aside, is there really any practical value in this sort of research, or is it the kind of thing that we do because it's interesting and kinda cool? Don't get me wrong, I think it's valuable for that alone, but...
- JuettnerDistrib 5y ago> is there really any practical value in this sort of research In many ways it is too early to do this research, so it is a kind of art (as is a lot of research, imho). As long as only a few people do it, it's cool and useful so we can be aware of our potential future. On the other hand, since we have no credible evidence of extraterrestrials, it would be surprising to find a civilisation so advanced to build a Dyson sphere. If they can build Dyson spheres, wouldn't they already be all over the place? Ok, I suppose I should actually go read the paper now...
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoBeing able to build Dyson spheres does not make them capable of going faster than the speed of light, so any civilization capable of building a Dyson sphere would probably still be clustered around a couple stars and that's it. Would such a civilization spread to more than one star is actually also a question, or would they control their population rationally stay on their Dyson sphere and only start to move when the star had less than 100,000 years left to go. Only some Dyson sphere variants, like Shkadov thrusters, are primarily conceived as ways to move around. Which personally seems to me less likely, is a civilization, as well as the ability to construct these objects, also going to have a species level interest in going exploring?
- perihelions 5y ago> "Being able to build Dyson spheres does not make them capable of going faster than the speed of light, so any civilization capable of building a Dyson sphere would probably still be clustered around a couple stars and that's it." Check your math: this galaxy is ~10^5 light-years in size and ~10^10 years in age.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agowhat does that have to do with anything I said? Yes, I guess they would be everywhere if their civilization was able to make Dyson spheres 1 year after the creation of the galaxy, also if they decided to 1. Not control their population for some reason. 2. Had some sort of interest in exploring. 3. Implicit also in the speed of light thing, would find it really interesting to send a portion of their population to the next available and suitable star which might be enough light years away to make communication impractical. I mean for our civilization there is some level of argument that says it would be a ridiculous idea to move to a new solar system and we have an intellectual exploratory streak in our species. I mean we are currently not at the level of being able to do a Dyson sphere, it took us 4.543 billion years (age of earth) to get to the part that somebody could conceive of it. There is also some discussion as to whether or not our civilization is going to last, so given that and the other things I said it seems unlikely to me that any Dyson sphere civilization would actually build more than one, but maybe some build two because binary stars or some other weird circumstance which makes it worthwhile to do. on edit: if we get to Dyson sphere building capabilities which seems really unlikely, will we build more than one? How many more?
- MattPalmer1086 5y agoThe point is that you don't need to go faster than the speed of light. There's more than enough time to cover the entire galaxy in a relatively short period of time at sublight speeds. A few million years is sufficient.
- bryanrasmussen 5y ago
- dave_sullivan 5y agoNo Dyson spheres, but there are black holes all over the place. Some people think those would make great computing devices, many of their origins are not well explained as super nova remnants, and they efficiently harness energy from companion stars. They have all the properties of Dyson spheres but they actually exist. Maybe with advanced enough physics, intelligent civilizations learn to manufacture and harness black holes, neutron stars, and other dense objects for societal benefit.
- jonathankoren 5y ago> No Dyson spheres, but there are black holes all over the place. Some people think those would make great computing devices They’re crappy computing devices. Even if you figured out how to program one — and that’s an “if” that would make Sagittarius A* look like a neutrino — there’s no way to read the information out except Hawking Radiation, and that would take 10^70 years. https://youtu.be/0GLgZvTCbaA https://youtu.be/0GLgZvTCbaA (8:36)
- alfiedotwtf 5y agoThis is the first time I've heard of this. Wow, yes! A blackhole is far more efficient at consuming energy than a Dyson Sphere... the hard part though is kickstarting the process I guess
- ohyeshedid 5y ago> If they can build Dyson spheres, wouldn't they already be all over the place? I figure they'd have to be. They'd need more than a solar system's worth of raw resources to build the sphere. They may need more than a solar system's worth of resources just to build the tools and craft to be able to build the sphere. They're going to need an insane amount of production facilities for various components, and that's going to take a massive amount of resources. That's going to require exploring quite a bit of a galaxy.
- awb 5y ago> If they can build Dyson spheres, wouldn't they already be all over the place? The number I’ve seen quoted is 50M years to colonize the galaxy: http://www.sentientdevelopments.com/2012/01/new-mathematical-study-reveals-that-our.html http://www.sentientdevelopments.com/2012/01/new-mathematical... > they calculated that any galactic empire would have spread outwards from its home planet at about 0.25% of the speed of light. The result is that after 50m years it would extend over 130,000 light years, with zealous colonisers moving in a relatively uniform cloud and more reticent ones protruding from a central blob. Since the Milky Way is estimated to be 100,000-120,000 light years across, outposts would be sprinkled throughout the galaxy, even if the home planet were, like Earth, located on the periphery. It’s actually so fast that advanced civilizations would have had time to colonize the galaxy and go extinct many times over without us noticing. Or maybe their spheres were built so long ago they’ve already collapsed and been consumed by the stars again. It’s a great mystery and interesting thought experiment though.
- denton-scratch 5y ago> 50M years to colonize the galaxy Our ancestors from 50M years ago are all extinct. So a civilisation spreading through the galaxy would have evolved in all kinds of different ways. It's not obvious to me that these diverse evolutionary strands would all still be interested in Dyson spheres, or space travel, or even astronomy. There's a belief that's hard to shake off, that the properties humans have that we think most important represent some kind of evolutionary pinnacle. Typically, those properties are language, and a large brain for processing language. But if language and a large brain are really such great evolutionary advantages, why are humans the only creatures on Earth that have evolved those properties? Possibly language and a large brain are an evolutionary backwater. At 0.25% of the speed of light, it would take us 1,600 years to reach Proxima Centauri; but it might take a lot longer to reach a star with habitable planets. We'd definitely need generation ships. After (say) a million years, we'd presumably have evolved to adapt to life on generation ships. It's not obvious to me that such adaptations would leave us fit to inhabit a planet. And perhaps adaptation to life on a generation ship means adapting to eating your fellow passengers. Given the history of humanity, I find it hard to believe that the population of a generation ship could survive as long as 100 years without war breaking out on-board. We've had large brains and language for about 50,000 years, as far as I can tell; we've been warring the whole time. Maybe large brains and language pre-dispose us to war? If that's right, then it seems unlikely that intelligent life would ever spread far from it's planet of origin. I'm very sceptical of the idea that any "civilisation" could ever spread far from its home planet. There are two things that we refeer to as a civilisation: a culture, and a species. Culture changes very quickly - over a single lifetime. But on a scale of millions of years, speciation is also pretty quick. So I can't see how any kind of homogenous civilisation or species could spread through a galaxy. They would have diversified before the train even reached its first stop. So I don't have any insurance against being kidnapped by aliens.
- dnsco 5y agoIt depends on how you define practical value. Immediately capitalizable? Probably not outside of Hollywood. Building a theoretical underpinning for the future of our species? I hope so.
- TheDudeMan 5y agoThis probably has implications around the Fermi paradox and the great filter(s). We would like to pass whatever filters are ahead of us.
- wesleywt 5y agoResearch should NEVER be limited by whether it has practical value or not. Because we don't know if future generations will make it practical.
- XorNot 5y agoExactly. Any research which takes something we don't know, and turns it into something we now know, is valuable.
- ncmncm 5y agoResearch is ALWAYS limited to what the person performing it considered practical. Getting a paper published is as practical as most researchers need to get. (Some do more.) If they don't publish, they soon don't get to do research anymore, and have to start doing what somebody else considers practical.
- wesleywt 5y agoYou missed the word I wrote "should". Funding agencies want to fund only "practical" research. But studying the migratory patterns of a single species of butterfly should be funded as much as the latest biotech fad that supposedly is of "practical value".
- tapas73 5y agoAll fundamental research is reaserch for the sake of knowledge, for the sake of satisfying curiosity. Once it is done, possibly much much much later, somebody may stumble upon it and use it in some creative (and unforseen) ways for other research. On the other hand if you give any probability to alien existence, then this is very much practical already in the search for them.
- Apocryphon 5y agoYou could possibly win an Ig Nobel Award out of it.
- captainmuon 5y agoSearching for Dyson spheres is not too different from searching for other hypothetical astronomical objects. Maybe it is a low-stakes analysis you could put some students on, so they learn something. Data collection, statistical methods, paper writing is all identical to "traditional" searches. I come from particle physics, and we did quite a few searches for very weird particles that, I admit, didn't believe in. But it was quick to retool the search for more plausible models. Also I think science works the way that you use your fantasy to come up with outlandish things, and then try to rule them out with logic.
- dillondoyle 5y agoHow do you find one? Is it similar to a black hole where you can detect the gravity, but can't see any of the energy coming from the covered sun?
- terramex 5y agoDyson sphere would emit significant amount of infrared light but no visible light. Original Freeman Dyson's paper from 1960 was titled "Search for Artificial Stellar Sources of Infrared Radiation" https://sci-hub.ee/10.1126/science.131.3414.1667 https://sci-hub.ee/10.1126/science.131.3414.1667
- ncmncm 5y agoWhen somebody got a telescope that could, they found there were way more sources of infrared radiation than visible stars.
- dillondoyle 5y agoCool. maybe James Webb will find one ;)
- kragen 5y agoWas there any practical value in Columbus discovering America? If the Aztecs had instead sailed to Europe or Africa and discovered them, would that have been of any practical value to them? It's difficult to imagine a discovery that would have more practical import than the discovery of an extraterrestrial civilization.
- ncmncm 5y agoHint: Columbus didn't discover America. Millions of people already lived there, and knew all about it. But anyway looking for Dyson spheres will not reveal any extraterrestrial civilizations.
- zzt123 5y agoI believe the person you are replying to is saying “discover” relatively rather than Euro-centrically, as they mention a hypothetical Aztecs “discovering” Europe and Africa.
- vasco 5y agoA discovery doesn't have to imply that no living being knew about said thing/ place. It can imply only that the person or the group of people the person is from learns about this new thing. At some point in time nobody in Europe had definite proof of how to get to America. You can call "europeans learning how to get to America" something else other than "discovered America", but what phrasing should one use instead? To make the point, literally nothing can be classified as "discovered" under your rules because any alien civilization may know about everything we'll ever find or figure out, and if they know about it we can't have discovered it. Columbus was a murderer and people in America before he got there deserved way better but this type of nitpicking correction is just noise if you don't even say what is a more appropriate phrase.
- kragen 5y agoAre you saying that, even if extraterrestrial civilizations existed, looking for Dyson spheres wouldn't reveal them? Or are you saying that they don't exist, so nothing will reveal them? In either case, why?
- tannhauser23 5y agoIt's a low cost, low probability way to look for advanced civilizations. Chances are low that you'll find anything, but hey the data's already here and we have powerful computers so let's run some calculations. And occasionally you find weird and interesting anomalies that push science forward: https://www.space.com/alien-megastructure-mysteriously-dimming-stars.html https://www.space.com/alien-megastructure-mysteriously-dimmi...
- ardit33 5y agoDyson spheres are just inane.... sorry but they don't make sense. Any advanced form of civilization that can build one, probably figured how to do fusion efficiently locally and doesn't have to build these insanely inefficient energy harversters. Keep in mind that the sun is very inefficient at energy release. Dyson sphere prediction is like predictions in the 1800s how we would have coal and steam powered airships to travel around. The reality is that steam via coal fire is too inefficient. Coal is just too heavy. Jet fuel is much more efficient/energy dense and not need to build giant airships. Same with any advanced civilization. Dyson spheres just don't make sense, but they sure make good sci-fi movies/stories for the gullible.
- AprilArcus 5y agoThe ingredients for fusion reactors (deuterium, tritium and helium-3) are rare, not fully reacted intermediate byproducts of the proton-proton cycle that powers the sun. The likeliest case for a Dyson Sphere civilization would be some sort of solar powered Gray Goo von Neumann replicator.
- ardit33 5y agoIn theory you can fuse up to Iron.... the last stage of stars. You are not limited to just Hydrogen.
- tapas73 5y agoI assume that some of fusions done by the star are net energy consumption (i.e. not usable for energy production)
- ncmncm 5y agoYou assume wrong. Anything beyond iron is made in a supernova, i.e. in the last moments before it is not really a star at all, anymore.
- chii 5y agotakes a star's worth of gravitational force to push atoms like those together in the core to produce fusion. To reproduce such heavier elements in fusion reactors on earth would require, likely, a much higher energy than the output.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoI once got the chance to ask freeman dyson what he recommended educationally, for children, to produce more freeman dysons. He didn’t hesitate. He said we need to teach children genetic engineering to children in such a way that they could approach it playfully. Only then would we have a chance of developing warm blooded plants which would be essential for colonizing the asteroid belt. So, if anyone has any ideas for that…!
- tannhauser23 5y agoHis article, "Warm-Blooded Plants and Freeze Dried Fish", is a classic: https://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/issues/97nov/space.htm https://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/issues/97nov/space.htm Highly recommended.
- dnsco 5y agoWas going to ask for someone smarter than me to explain what warm blooded plants would do, but decided to google it and found this speech by dyson: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_yzgPMwshqE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_yzgPMwshqE
- Firmwarrior 5y agoQuick excerpt: "The first species to emerge from a Noah’s Ark egg will be warm-blooded plants designed to collect energy from sunlight and keep themselves warm in a cold environment. “Plants could be engineered to grow greenhouses the way turtles grow shells” The greenhouse would consist of a thick skin providing thermal insulation, with small windows to admit sunlight. Outside the skin would be an array of simple lenses, focusing sunlight through the windows into the interior. Groups of greenhouses could grow together to form extended habitats for other species of plants and animals. In that way, “We will be the machines getting life to grow all over the universe.”
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoPlants like that already exist minus the exothermy. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leaf_window https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leaf_window https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesembryanthemum_crystallinum https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesembryanthemum_crystallinu...
- Jimbonius 5y ago
- tapland 5y agoStart a cult for selective breeding is probably the easiest way.
- teh_infallible 5y agoWe could create a race of strongmen, based on genetic mutation and evolution!
- Iwan-Zotow 5y ago[flagged]
- dang 5y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into flamewar. Not what this site is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Edit: we've already asked you this, and you've unfortunately been doing it repeatedly. Could you please not? If you'd make substantive points thoughtfully, that would be much better.
- twright0 5y agoMy favorite line of reasoning about eugenics[0]: let's just accept that eugenics is a good thing; so good, in fact, we can go back in time and give a past society the ability to decide on the physical and mental attributes of their future, our present. Who would you pick? Would you go back 50, 100, 200, 500 years to gift this power? If you're uncomfortable with people several hundred years ago making decisions about your genetics, why should people several hundred years from now be comfortable with you making decisions about theirs? [0] https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/eugenics-is-a-great-idea https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/eugenics-is-a-great-idea
- jonathankoren 5y agoI’ve been doing a lot of reading on megastructures, giant black hole powered computers, Von Neumann probes, and all the other super advanced technologies, and then thinking about the Fermi paradox, and I can’t shake the feeling these are just gussied up magic by effectively godlike entities. They’re completely impractical and take some pretty big hand waving to make them sound plausible. We’re running out of excuses. We’re either alone, or we’re effectively alone ie everyone else is forever undetectable. Meaning they’re more primitive, or stuck in some subterranean ocean or something. Either way, we’re the Ancients sci-fi stories ale we ya talk about.
- awb 5y ago> We’re either alone, or we’re effectively alone ie everyone else is forever undetectable. Native tribes could be forgiven for assuming they were alone until explorers and conquistadors arrived. It’s possible that a civilization millions (or billions) of years ahead of us in biology, energy, philosophy, etc. is just beyond our comprehension at this moment to even know what to look for, where or how. Plus, we already try to make things hard to find like stealth fighters. Perhaps it’s a good idea for survival in the universe to be difficult to find.
- jonathankoren 5y agoWhere’s their waste heat? A pocket dimension? At some point you’re just arguing for magic.
- xyproto 5y agoOr everybody is hiding. Have you read The Three-Body Problem?
- jonathankoren 5y agoYou mean the books where magical aliens warp the fundamental constants of the universe to eliminate physical dimensions? Even if you skip past that to the underlying dark forest idea, it’s an argument based on pure faith with zero evidence to support it. You need an all power malevolent society that works on a time scale of thousands if not millions of years, and then nit only eliminates another society for “reasons”, but also then also perfectly covers up its own existence, because there may be some other bigger bad out there. It’s about as convincing as the unicorn that’s always right behind you, but everyone ignores because unicorns are super dangerous.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- colordrops 5y agoCould stars blacked out by Dyson spheres or other technology that completely harnesses their energy be an explanation for dark matter? Or would this matter not be so "dark" due to the heat signature?
- awb 5y agoI think most if not every galaxy has dark matter so if it’s Dyson spheres that would mean that nearly every galaxy was colonized with Dyson spheres in the same way (except ours because we don’t have evidence of a galaxy-wide civilization).
- maxander 5y agoIndeed, Dyson spheres would need to release some amount of waste heat, due to the laws of thermodynamics. If there were too many of them that heat would be visible (at least to infrared telescopes,) so we know that’s not the explanation for dark matter. Same with dust and other non-luminescent matter- it’s all way more visible than dark matter has to be, somehow.
- freemint 5y agoWhat prevents that waste head being as warm ad the peak in cosmic background background radiation
- ncmncm 5y agoLiterally every last thing in the whole universe that can radiate heat is at least as warm as the cosmic background radiation. You cannot shed any heat at all unless you are warmer than the background radiation, because you would be absorbing as much heat from it as you radiate. If you were colder, you would necessarily be absorbing more. Thermodynamics does not play around.
- buryat 5y agowhat would prevent an intelligent civilization from covering all other stars in dyson spheres? and the dark matter is everywhere (almost, there're galaxies without it) which would mean that most of the universe has intelligent life but then why there's no other signals? something should've leaked/pointed at it
- bbarn 5y agoMaybe this is a stupid question, but is there actually enough raw material in the solar system to cover the surface of our star and build the necessary machinery to keep it in place, collect its energy, etc.?
- kragen 5y agoYou don't put it on the surface of the star; you orbit at a distance far enough away to maintain a reasonable temperature. Current solar panels are about 300 grams per square meter, but there are much opaquer materials than silicon, so you can probably get down to a hundredth of that. A sphere at the radius of Earth's orbit would be 2.8e23 square meters and thus at 300 grams per square meter 8.4e22 kg. Earth's moon masses 7.3e22 kg, while Jupiter masses 1.90e27 kg. So there's at least five orders of magnitude more raw material than you need. If you happened to live in a planetary system without adequate gas giants, you could probably find some way to scoop mass off the surface of your star or capture it from coronal mass ejections, then use fusion to transmute it into the materials you need. Even Sun is 1.90e30 kg, and it's rather small as stars go.
- Smaug123 5y agoI'm sure you already know this, but GP probably doesn't: I love https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_lifting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_lifting for very many reasons. 1. "Stellar husbandry". That phrase alone is worth the price of admission. 2. The idea of doing mass spectrometry on a jet of matter coming out of a star to separate it out into streams of hydrogen, deuterium, helium, etc. 3. The idea of creating artificial gas giants as a storage mechanism. (The list goes on, but 3 is a magic number.)
- kragen 5y agoI didn't! Thanks!
- dmead 5y agoProbably not. I was under the assumption we could build a Dyson swarm however.
- buryat 5y agoThe only conclusion we should make right now is that the Dyson Sphere doesn't exist and we're the only intelligent life in the Universe, which makes it all more terrifying.
- azernik 5y agoOr that it does, and advanced civilizations just don't need that much energy.
- jl6 5y agoPerhaps civilizations with eternally increasing energy demands inevitably encounter a great filter of their own making, while civilizations that learn to live with more modest energy requirements live on in peace and silence.
- buryat 5y agoevolution seems to be a constant fight for energy, this can be even expanded broadly: the universe is all about gathering energy. So not sure that someone would be fine with a constant limited energy supply. Plus those supplies eventually run out
- azernik 5y agoEvolution is also a constant fight for food calories, and modern societies have escaped that struggle. Judging the dynamics of technological societies by those of evolving organisms is a common and extremely misleading trap.
- gfodor 5y agoThe second doesn’t follow from the first. Dyson Spheres might just not be worth building.
- buryat 5y agoagreed, but where do you get a lot of energy from? stars are the only answer seems like right now, nothing else produces/radiates energy in the universe in quantities needed
- ordu 5y agoIt seems that Dyson sphere may be seen in infrared? So James Webb will find one, if they exist. We need just to wait a few years.
- ncmncm 5y agoWe already have infrared telescopes. There are literally billions of infrared sources already known in the immediate neighborhood. I promise you none of them are Dyson spheres.
- fullstackchris 5y agoAlways have to comment on the meme Dyson spheres posts with the following: has anyone ever thought, for one second, that a civilization capable of building these massive energy systems would actually be capable of generating energy in other different ways that we can't even imagine? This whole "Type I, II, III" civilization crap is stupid because it is based off one paper, of one guy, who had a creative idea. Props to him for the creativity, but millions of scientists every day have possibly creative ideas about space fairing civilizations. Its like sci-fi novels creeped into real science. Literally ape brain to just "wrap a star and capture its energy!" I think most people "like" the idea because it's so tangible. But that doesn't make it any more or less likely that it actually exists or makes sense.
- rini17 5y agoI think it's not only about energy generation but what would massive civilization without dyson spheres imply: 1. sidestepping thermodynamic laws - to allow massive energy use without detectable waste heat and/or 2. sidestepping time lags - so that the system does not need to be bunched as closely together as possible to allow for efficient communication and flows of material
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoDyson Spheres are fundamentally unphysical. The stability constraint on a complete sphere turns out to be less of a problem than it might seem, but there are still huge issues with stresses - Sphere Quakes. And before you can build a full Sphere you have to build a partial Sphere. Which is where stability will really kill you. Dyson Swarms might be more practical, but you still have a computability problem because you have an insanely huge number of objects in orbit and you somehow have to keep them from colliding with each other. Not so much a three body problem as an n body problem. With a built-in light lag delay of (at least) minutes. I'm not sure if anyone has modelled that, but it would be hilarious if the computing and station-keeping power requirements turned out to be a significant proportion of the available energy,
- 5y ago
- denton-scratch 5y agoIf a Dyson sphere captures a large proportion of the radiation from a star, what is the destiny of that energy? It gets converted into other kinds of energy, and eventually becomes waste energy, ending up as low-grade heat. Hence the search for infra-red sources. But the amount of energy that a Dyson sphere absorbs must be equal to the amount of low-grade heat it radiates; so I'd expect a Dyson sphere to be very bright in infra-red - much brighter than brown or red dwarfs. Such an object should be quite easy to spot.
- jcims 5y agoThat’s sounds like something that someone from a Type I civilization would say.
- denton-scratch 5y agoWouldn't know; I've never met anyone from a Type I civilisation.
- mickdarling 5y agoI just did a quick look through the doc but it does not appear that they take into account that Dyson shell elements would try to radiate waste heat directionally to the north and south of their orbits as to avoid too much thrust from radiation that may alter their orbital paths or the paths of other Dyson shell elements. The signal this would create to an outside observer I think would significantly change the heat signature and periodic changes, depending on our observation angle to the star.
- juloo 5y agoSurely a Dyson sphere would not emit what we naively expect. Look at us, we can speculate about these and even try to spot them but are millennia away from building one. What if the external shield of the sphere would be artificially heated to 4000K or higher ? Completely invisible.