14 ms·
Lorinda Cherry, author of dc, bc, eqn has died
- rizkeyz 5y agoRip, Lorinda. I'm using bc almost daily.
- graderjs 5y agoRIP. I use bc in production for calculations in the shell.
- kasey_junk 5y agoBrian Kernighan is not mentioned in the obituary and nor should he be. Can we please change the HN title?
- ggm 5y agoSure. I changed it. I put it there because I expected some pedant to say "She didn't write eqn, Brian did" There is a very good non-obit by Doug McIlroy, written when Lorinda got an award in 2018. I was going to post it, but it's in a small listserv archive and I think the list members prefer not to be cited into these kinds of thing. I can't find the text elsewhere which is a shame, it has a really good rundown on her time at Bell Labs and the amazing things she did. I guess i could cut-paste it here, but that would exceed a 10% quoting rule I try to stick to. They're Doug's words, not mine.
- kasey_junk 5y agoThank you.
- MonkeyClub 5y agoIt'd definitely be an interesting read, could you pastebin it for us?
- ggm 5y ago4 levels down a comment threat is probably deep enough it doesn't cause problems. The list archive is actually fully publicly visible: https://minnie.tuhs.org/pipermail/tuhs/2022-February/025390.html
- kasey_junk 5y agoThat’s really good. Thanks again.
- gsinclair 5y agoHear hear!
- greenyoda 5y agoThis article is a profile, not an obituary (I'd expect an obituary to state that she died, and give a date). What's the source that reported her death? I searched the web, but couldn't find any. At the moment, her Wikipedia article refers to her in the past tense, but doesn't cite a source for her death either. (In case the title changes, this comment refers to the original HN title: "Lorinda Cherry, author of dc, bc, eqn has died".)
- ggm 5y agoIt was reported on a mailing list of ex-Bell labs staff and other early UNIX users. This write up of her career was the best one I could find, sourced from information there. It's from 2018 when she got an award. If you have a better one I'd welcome it being posted.
- greenyoda 5y agoThanks for the confirmation. I first saw her mentioned when I started using Unix in 1979, and am sorry to hear of her passing.
- tpmx 5y agoHere she is demoing Unix, pipelines, etc. (1982) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XvDZLjaCJuw&t=828s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XvDZLjaCJuw&t=828s
- tonto 5y agosuch a cool video
- gameswithgo 5y agoeven now it is all pretty slick especially for people who have always been in GUI operating systems, at the time it must have seemed like wizardry.
- srcreigh 5y agoI love how she takes a sip of her coffee/tea when she has to wait for the computer
- macdice 5y agoIt's interesting that uniq is spelled unique in that video. I wonder who changed that!
- bspammer 5y agoI was wondering what "mismatch" was too, turns out it's comparing to the system dictionary https://github.com/watson/old-unix-spell-checker/blob/master/mismatch https://github.com/watson/old-unix-spell-checker/blob/master...
- darkwater 5y agoThanks for the video! How come we lost the `lowercase` command? I know you can use `tr` or `sed` among others to accomplish the same but I would still love to have a `lowercase` command :)
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoPossibly the most amazing thing is that speak(1) is actually functioning in 1982 !! And remember, it's not just the software, you need some sort of DAC connected as well. Granted, Max Matthews had done the first digital synthesis of sound nearly 30 years earlier, but there's no sign that Cherry is working in an digital audio lab. She's on a terminal, probably connected to what was then called a "minicomputer" ... with a DAC!
- sulam 5y agobc is still my favorite calculator, 30 years after I first learned *nix (SunOS for me back then).
- jasone 5y agoSimilarly, I have used dc as my desktop calculator of choice since the mid-90s. It has been useful in many one-liner scripts too. A simple, powerful tool.
- tannhaeuser 5y agoOne-liners? dc is using reverse Polish, with newlines to separate tokens, or is there an alternate separator I didn't know all these years?
- somat 5y agotokens are separated on parsed input, where the token needs to be explicit, like two numbers in a row a space can separate them. An example from the manual. the first ten values of n! [la1+dsa*pla10>y]sy0sa1lyx
- MarkusWandel 5y agoIs there a runnable version of her "typo" program anywhere? From the description at least, it sounds like a really cool idea.
- btrettel 5y agoThere are some links to various versions here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22582644 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22582644
- nonrandomstring 5y agoWavey memories of typesetting my graduate thesis with eqn, nroff and dvi to postscript things all in a long Unix pipe chain. Thanks Lorinda.
- atdrummond 5y agoLorinda helped me massively with my attempts to bring back online some hardware that had escaped early 90s Bell Labs so that, as a pre-teenager trapped in rural Illinois, I could run Plan 9 and build some software for it. She did not stop at connecting me to the right people to locate the hardware I needed to restore my computer to the living. She also went above and beyond by introducing me to individuals whom I did not deserve to talk with nor did I appreciate how lucky I was to be sharing e-mails with these people at the age of 12. These unlucky (former) Labs employees included both Rob Pike and Ken Thompson. Lorinda, thank you for taking such extensive efforts to encourage my passion and interest in obscure operating systems. I have not lost my drive to explore this area of computing. My only wish is that I had sent you more than one of the coffee cakes from Morton, IL that you loved and said made us even. Hopefully, wherever you are now, you can have as much coffee cake as possible. Thank you again, truly.
- dylan604 5y agowow, that's kind of crazy cool. 1) the help was offered at all. 2) to put you in touch with others (lots of personal cred at risk there) 3) they helped you out in kind 4) you were only 12. things sure were different in the 90s.
- jthrowsitaway 5y agoIndeed. These days you're lucky if you can get a project maintainer to respond to a PR within a few years.
- gowld 5y agoI don't think a colleague and friend would disrespect someone for making an introduction to a kid, even if the kid turned out less cool than thread OP. Nowadays kids can befriend celebs on Twitter. It's easier, not harder.
- dylan604 5y agoGood grief. There's a huge difference in following someone on Twitter vs a personal email account. You think someone you meet that knows $famousCelebrity is just going to give you their email account? Really?
- kreelman 5y agoMany thanks Lorinda for bc. A super useful tool. Rest in peace.
- ghoward 5y agoAs one of few authors of an implementation of `dc` and `bc`, but one who never actually met Lorinda Cherry, perhaps I have a slightly different perspective of her work. I've read the closest thing we have to the original sources of `dc` and `bc`: the source bundled with Plan 9. It didn't take me long to read the entirety of the source because they were simple and concise. That immensely impressed me. However, I hate to say that my youth (compared to Ms. Cherry, at least) caused me to look at the source with disdain, mostly from a lack of handling errors caused by user mistakes. It took several days for me to think more carefully about the context. She was writing for herself and other programmers, who would probably be able to recognize when they made a mistake and fix it. The code has a simple elegance that mine will never have. Sure, you might call mine "industrial strength," but I think a quote by ** Gabriel sums up the difference between Ms. Cherry's code and mine: "I'm always delighted by the light touch and stillness of early programming languages. Not much text; a lot gets done. Old programs read like quiet conversations between a well-spoken research worker and a well-studied mechanical colleague, not as a debate with a compiler. Who'd have guessed sophistication bought such noise?" [1] And that says nothing of the design of her software. `dc` was, and in many ways still is, the simplest calculator that could ever exist. It was the simplest shell too, with the `!` command. I personally believe that it was for this reason that `dc` was the first program Bell Labs made run on the PDP-11. [2] `bc`, while more complicated, is also a great design (for the time). In short, Ms. Cherry was a master of her trade, and I only recognized that from afar. One of the items I had in my bucket list was to meet Ms. Cherry; because of her work on `dc` and `bc`, I felt a kinship to her having written my own. It is sad to know that item will never happen. Oh, well. [1]: https://people.csail.mit.edu/alinush/6.824-spring-2015/l07-go.html https://people.csail.mit.edu/alinush/6.824-spring-2015/l07-g... [2]: https://youtu.be/EY6q5dv_B-o?t=1767 https://youtu.be/EY6q5dv_B-o?t=1767
- sergiotapia 5y agoAll of our giants are passing away. Makes me a sad. Who is the next generation? I can't think of any names.
- mlac 5y agoI have two thoughts on this: 1) our “giants” will be Zuckerberg, Elon, and Bezos. They have taken all the talent that would have gone to bell labs and used it to generate ad revenue. 2) our “giants” are still making their name and working, and we will recognize their accomplishments in 30-40 years.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anthk 5y ago9front guys with plan9's legacy being modernized. Gemini. NNCP as a disaster-resistant network. Solar powered minicomputers and devices. The future won't be like the 20th century one. It will be less power hungry.
- lanstin 5y agoI got solar a few months ago and I am shipping 7kWh back each day and trying to find useful stuff for the electricity (may even give in the Air Conditioning crowd prior to temps hitting 35 Celsius). I am all for efficiency but cheap solar changes the material conditions significantly.
- beebmam 5y agoMost giants I've met never make a name for themselves and prefer it that way.
- smabie 5y agoHow can you be a giant if you never make a name for yourself?
- every 5y agoI use dc almost every day. I even do my taxes with it. I will forever be in her (and others) debt...
- alisonatwork 5y agoGlad I'm not the only one. I started using dc for shell scripts before I knew that expr existed, and when some UNIX systems I logged on to spat out a bunch of noise on the console whenever bc was invoked. As a result I started thinking in the stack arithmetic way, and just adopted it as my standard way of doing math on UNIX. Eventually I got so used to it that I also preferred using it on Windows (via Cygwin) over calc.exe. It was a sad day when the developer world moved to Git Bash which either never included dc or stopped including it at some point. After a few years of grumbling with calc.exe and ancient versions of GNU dc that didn't work quite right in a Git Bash console, I discovered Gavin Howard's dc, which works well in Git Bash, and now it's once again one of the first things I install on a new computer. Remarkable how this program written ~50 years ago is still useful today, in whatever rebirthed incarnation. I can't think of many others with such staying power.
- gavinhoward 5y agoIt's good to hear of another person using my `dc`! You're actually the second confirmed user; the other is a die-hard original Unix user that now uses NetBSD. That said, I'm glad my `dc` works for you under Git Bash, but it's weird that GNU `dc` wouldn't work.
- alisonatwork 5y agoI can't remember exactly the problem - it was some time ago - but I think it might have been related to console input. Either it was built for Windows console and didn't quite handle mintty LF, EOF and line wrapping, or the other way around. Usually you can wrangle programs into working by using winpty, but it still didn't operate quite as smoothly as dc did under UNIX (or Cygwin). In the end I mostly ended up invoking it in a pipeline instead of interactively. Fortunately your dc worked out of the box with winpty a couple years back, and - to my delight - I just discovered the latest version works both in a modern Windows console and Git Bash mintty as well, without any winpty wrapping. Great work, thank you!
- hackernj 5y agoI remember her from my summer job in 1980 in the Computer Library at Bell Labs in Murray Hill, NJ. She was one of the few women in computer science department. Nice bunch of brilliant people who patiently answered my newbie questions about Unix, Shell, C, etc.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- macintux 5y agoFound a transcript of an interview with her, not sure how old. Talks a great deal about the statistical analysis of text that McIlroy praised her for. https://www.princeton.edu/~hos/mike/transcripts/cherry.htm https://www.princeton.edu/~hos/mike/transcripts/cherry.htm
- svat 5y agoThe tool `eqn`, which she wrote (joined by Brian Kernighan) is an "ancestor" of TeX: The mathematical syntax of TeX (design started 1977) was based on eqn (1975). For example, the eqn paper (https://research.swtch.com/eqn.pdf https://research.swtch.com/eqn.pdf) has the expression sum from i=0 to infinity x sub i = pi over 2 which would have been entered as something pretty close to that in the first draft design of TeX (the second draft introduced the backslashes), and today as: \sum_{i=0}^{\infty} x_i = {\pi \over 2} and you can see the evolution. The Wikipedia page has more examples (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Eqn_(software)&oldid=1061600145#Syntax_examples https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Eqn_(software)&ol... ). Knuth credits Lorinda Cherry explicitly a couple of times in the first draft design (https://www.saildart.org/TEXDR.AFT[1,DEK] https://www.saildart.org/TEXDR.AFT[1,DEK]): > A special syntax is used in formulas, modeled on that of Kernighan and Cherry, Comm. ACM 18 (March 1975), 151-157. For example, ``sup 9'' in line 41 specifies a superscript 9, ``sub {n+1}'' in line 74 specifies a subscript n+1. and in the last page/paragraph: > To conclude this memo, I should explain how TEX is going to work on math formulas. However, I will have to sketch out the code in more detail and it is only fuzzy in my mind at the moment. […] it may be necessary to build the parse tree first as Kernighan and Cherry do. (Yes indeed TeX builds the parse tree first, as we can see from the second draft: https://www.saildart.org/TEX.ONE[1,DEK] https://www.saildart.org/TEX.ONE[1,DEK] ) The eqn system was a pioneering and capable one: although Knuth did not use any of the code of troff/eqn as-is (not sure if it was available to him; in any case he was targeting "book" quality), clearly it influenced the design, and I imagine it inspired him about what was possible in the first place. Even after TeX became widely used, there have been some math books typeset with troff and eqn. Reading about Lorinda Cherry's other accomplishments like `typo` and the Writer's Workbench, it's clear we've lost someone who was a pioneer in multiple respects.
- mukundesh 5y agoCompletely agree, 'eqn' was a pioneering achievement followed by TeX and Mathematica
- e12e 5y agoAfter having a look at: https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/unix-text-processing/9780810462915/Chapter09.html https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/unix-text-processing/97... and a few man pages, I figured I could play with eqn like so: eqn -Tpdf - <<eof | groff -me -T pdf > eqn.pdf .EQ sum from i=0 to infinity x sub i = pi over 2 .EN eof xdg-open eqn.pdf I did not have much success trying to force it throug groff/troff and render pretty in a (wayland) terminal - with neither `--text` (as below) or `--tty`. But perhaps there is no such "magic" renderer? eqn -Troff -Tutf8 - <<eof | groffer --text |less -R kEQ sum from i=0 to infinity x sub i = pi over 2 .EN eof
- rodgerd 5y agoI think the thing in her obit that most delighted me was the note that she developed an analysis of judges' decisions for dog competitions.
- mzs 5y agofor me it was the rally car racing: https://web.archive.org/web/20120624081721/http://www.scca-nnjr.org/NNJR_Mgmt/History.shtml https://web.archive.org/web/20120624081721/http://www.scca-n...
- danielvf 5y agoDoes anyone have a link to her dog show judging bias paper? I'd love to read it. I knew some people on the dog show circuit a long time ago, and each judge having obvious bias for random dog aspects / ages was well known. Since dog breeders and serious dog show people would have many active dogs simultaneously, for each judge at an event, they would enter their closest matching dog to what the judge liked, and skip entirely if that wasn't your dogs. Thus if you had eight dogs you were currently showing, and a two day weekend event with two judges, you would bring two dogs, one picked for the Saturday judge and one picked for the Sunday judge.
- mastazi 5y ago> In these years, Cherry recalls, the potential of the computer had barely been tapped, and if asked what she did for a living, she would say that her job was to “see what kind of neat new things I can make the computer do, and in those days the computer wasn’t doing a lot, but it was super interesting and there was a lot more stuff you could make it do.” It would have been so different. What we have now must feel like an Eternal September to anyone who was around back then.
- jamiek88 5y agoDon’t you just ache to have missed it? Oh to have been forging that frontier!
- mbarbar 5y agoWonder what frontier we'll look back on in the same way in 50 years.
- mastazi 5y agoYeah, I was wondering the same, I know for sure it's not the industry I'm in, which is now "mature" and boring. It's probably something we're not even familiar with because it's so niche. Or maybe it is something that we know, but to our eyes it doesn't seem that powerful. In the same way that people used to think of computers as just tools for doing multiplications and other arithmetic operations and they could have never imagined everything else that computers do.
- gsinclair 5y ago> She worked on several influential mathematical tools, including a desk-calculator language (bc); TeX and eqn, both typesetting systems for publishing mathematical formulae… Saying she worked on TeX seems incorrect. Can anyone confirm either way?
- drfuchs 5y agoI think the lovely comment by svat covers the extent of her contribution to TeX: the eqn language informed the design of TeX's math-mode syntax. But that's all I'm aware of; it seems the much-copied quote you mention is off base. Keep in mind that TeX was initially written in Sail, which had no Unix compiler, and also assumed 36-bit words, which no Unix system had. The later rewrite of TeX that ran on 32-bit machines, and finally became available on Unix, pretty much retained the Sail version's existing math syntax.
- ncmncm 5y agoI use those every week of every year.
- tmn007 5y agoStill use bc
- mukundesh 5y ago"The eqn program was created in 1974 by Brian Kernighan and Lorinda Cherry. It was implemented using yacc compiler-compiler.[1]" eqn Wikipedia. Interesting to know that eqn pre-dates TeX, TeX was released in 1978
- khan-saib 5y ago
- bamboozled 5y agoThanks for everything, I love bc, use it relentlessly. Rest in peace.
- tannhaeuser 5y agoUsing dc on a regular base whenever a small calculation is required - it's just so much more convenient compared to starting up a graphic ^H^H^H GUI calculator when you're in a shell+keyboard flow. And eqn is also much, much easier to use for basic high school math and casual use than all-mighty TeX. Used to document entire app suites using troff/eqn/tbl/pic in the 90s, order receipts and bills even, as well as preparing moderately math-heavy course material. RIP
- mprovost 5y agoI pretty much always have an open terminal window running dc for doing quick calculations throughout the day. And I do my taxes every year in dc!
- throwaway5486nv 5y agoOne of the oldest math precision calculator was written by a women programmer. That cool. What other well know programs were written by the women authors.
- brettermeier 5y agoThere are not few. Margaret Hamilton * was lead Apollo flight software designer at Nasa for example. *: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Hamilton_(software_engineer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Hamilton_(software_en...
- gabrielsroka 5y agoLook up Ada Lovelace and Grace Hopper.
- atmosx 5y agoI love the fact that HN celebrates the largely unknown tech heroes of our times :-) I've used "bc" quit e a few times, thanks & RIP Lorinda.
- zelphirkalt 5y agoI just did `man dc` and then tried it out to run 1 + 2. I tried only entering the numbers, then tried writing "push 1", then guessed, that maybe it is just "p 1" and then guessed, that I also need to "p +" and hit "=" and return. Voila! Figured it out intuitively! Great!
- kristopolous 5y agoIt's still one of the quickest ways to do math on the command line. dc -e '3 k 57 47 / p' Or what have you. It's pretty useful. I recommend spending an hour or two with it. You'll use it. One of the nice things about rpn is if you forget something or want to modify things, you'll quickly find out that it's more convenient. A little syntax weirdness apparently goes a long way in making things ridiculously easier to manipulate. You can write programs with it btw. Hobby away: https://rosettacode.org/wiki/Category:Dc https://rosettacode.org/wiki/Category:Dc Things get delightfully cryptic: https://rosettacode.org/wiki/Generate_lower_case_ASCII_alphabet#dc https://rosettacode.org/wiki/Generate_lower_case_ASCII_alpha... Go through a Forth tutorial to get the hang of RPN style programming if that's truly gibberish to you. It won't make it easy, but it will make it readable
- zelphirkalt 5y agoHaven't used a language with RPN as default, but Forth is somewhere on my endless "to look at at some point" list : )
- e12e 5y agoUnless there's a difference between yours and mine `dc` that's not quite right: 10 # pushes 10 20 # pushes 20 + # pops 20 10 sums, pushes results p # prints top of stack (peek) Equal (`=`) is a conditonal macro invocation `=r`: pops two values off stack, invokes (the contents of register) `r` if they are equal. [p]sa # store peek stack top as macro in a 1337 10 20 + 30 =a # Stack should be 1337, 30 (20+10) and 30, so should output 1337 # pops 30 and 30; 30==30;p -> top is 1337
- nullc 5y agoscale=0
- usrbinbash 5y agoRest in Peace! Her demonstration of the capabilities of the (then novel) pipes and scripts of the Unix Operating System is one of the best parts of this documentary: https://youtu.be/tc4ROCJYbm0?t=935 https://youtu.be/tc4ROCJYbm0?t=935
- Ambroos 5y agoI love what she does here: https://youtu.be/XvDZLjaCJuw?t=949 https://youtu.be/XvDZLjaCJuw?t=949, also demonstrating pipes and scripts. The input she chooses makes the whole segment pretty damn funny.
- TheChaplain 5y agoShe's a hero to me, I use "bc" at least a couple of times per week. Thank you to Lorinda and everyone else working on UNIX operatingsystems and their tools, you make my life better.
- gameswithgo 5y agoAll yall going on about her programming and that’s great but she was a rallycross racer for 21 years!!!
- pietroppeter 5y agoreally a lovely thread, as an aside here is nice Nimplementation of dc called ad: https://github.com/subsetpark/ad https://github.com/subsetpark/ad
- taf2 5y agoI like her quote - “ see what kind of neat new things I can make the computer do, and in those days the computer wasn’t doing a lot, but it was super interesting and there was a lot more stuff you could make it do.” Still true today!
- EdwardCoffin 5y agoHere's a good interview with her [1] which I happened across indirectly via a discussion here about the most surprising Unix programs [2] [1] https://www.princeton.edu/~hos/mike/transcripts/cherry.htm https://www.princeton.edu/~hos/mike/transcripts/cherry.htm [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22574603 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22574603
- easton 5y agoHey! She was having the same problems we're having: > 'Cherry: That's hard to say. If you look at the Berkeley Unix system and some of the commands that are similar, the same in Berkeley as what we have here but you look at the Berkeley manual they've added 85 flags to the Cat command or something. It was a very simple elegant thing that did a very simple job. I guess we've always had the attitude that it has to be really useful to be worthwhile putting in. Maybe just 'cause it was a smaller group than at Berkeley or maybe people in Berkeley, everybody needs to find a niche so they've got to put a flag on something, I don't know what the environment is there. But I think it was here to prevent featurism. I think that's the difference between the two systems. And I think that undoubtedly has to do with the university environment where everybody has to do something as opposed to the environment where in some sense everybody had to justify what it is they were doing to your cause. And there is also some hesitancy 'cause it you touched it you owned it, you thought hard about whether you needed to add that flag or whether there was some other way around it. Whether there was some program. You said "I'll find some other way to do this 'cause I don't want to own this program."'
- hn-new 5y agoLess technical and detailed (but with some distinct stories and quotations): https://ncwit.org/profile/lorinda-cherry/ https://ncwit.org/profile/lorinda-cherry/ Some other material: + An interview between Michael S. Mahoney and Lorinda Cherry: https://gist.github.com/telemachus/c01e3a213574a7bdcf79a480231396a2 https://gist.github.com/telemachus/c01e3a213574a7bdcf79a4802... + Some mentions and quotes in this oral history of Unix: https://www.princeton.edu/~hos/frs122/unixhist/finalhis.htm https://www.princeton.edu/~hos/frs122/unixhist/finalhis.htm I’d be curious to see her appearance on the Today Show that McIlroy mentions. She and [Nina Macdonald](https://www.ninamacdonald.com/pub.htm https://www.ninamacdonald.com/pub.htm) were on in May of 1981 to talk about Writer’s Workbench, but so far I can’t find any video.
- todd8 5y agoI've used all three of these programs and never knew that the same person had written all of them. I still occasionally use bc--I started using it decades ago and prefer it to any calculator for basic use. For more complicated calculations I now tend to use the python RPL at the command line, but I'll always remember bc, dc, and eqn fondly. Thank you Lorinda Cherry. There may be some people out there that don't realize these commands are available on your machines. The macOS operating system on every contemporary Apple computer has a core that is build on Unix. Just open a the terminal app and you now have access to the only user interface that all of us old Unix users used for many years. At the command prompt you can learn how to use bc and dc simply by using the man command (short for manual). Type man bc to get the brief page from the Unix manual describing bc (or any other shell command in the same fashion). One of the next commands you should look up in the manual is the man command itself (type man man). Somewhere, I've got the original thick printed Unix Manual. I used to carry it around just to read before the days when I had a dial-up terminal or personal computer at home.
- rmk 5y agoI use bc all the time to do quick calculations. I never knew who the author was. I wonder how the software world will change as a generation of authors or maintainers of everyday programs dies off. Not all software package maintainers/developers have planned how things will continue after their death. The U.S. Government could fund some work into this, seeing as how a lot of open-source software is essentially a public good.
- jeffsco 5y agoI use bc a hundred times a day, it's invaluable. Thank you; RIP
- jeffrom 5y agoi use bc just about every day, thank you!!!
- CRConrad 5y ago> She then joined the (self-organized) Unix team, collaborating on several applications with Bob Morris. Bob Morris Sr, the grandfather of The Worm, I assume?
- parentheses 5y agobig fan of bc. love that program