25 ms·
America’s Covid job-saving programme gave most of its cash to the rich
- BiggsHoson 5y agoNo surprise there. Who are the rich? The politicians and bureaucrats who implemented these ideas, along with their buddies who fund their campaigns and junkets, and offer cushy board positions and lobbying gigs if they ever do leave their government posts.
- sbelskie 5y agoWere there countries that did a better job than the US in regards to the economic response the pandemic, particularly with respect to fiscal stimulus? Is any other country as close the the US to prepandemic GDP trendlines? I wouldn’t be surprised if there are but I’m honestly not aware of them.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI'm curious too. But I would suggest that the U.S. has very deep pockets and can throw a lot of money at a problem. That doesn't mean it was a "smart" response by the U.S.
- sbelskie 5y agoI think it’s totally fair to criticize the response and suggest it could have been better, I meant it more in terms of the people complaining never seem to entertain the counterfactual of how bad things could have ended up with no/poor fiscal response.
- mikea1 5y agoWell said! In hindsight, it is easy to forget that there was a lot of FUD at the time. These programs were created quickly - some countries had better infrastructure to handle this than the US - but the alternative could have been an underwhelming response to an even larger problem.
- mikea1 5y agoOn the one hand, the S&P 500 has outperformed the FTSE for just about any period in the last five years. But that’s not necessarily due to the PPP. Stimulus checks and unemployment insurance were the majority of the $2.2 billion effort. European countries were more efficient with their version of PPP (and perhaps general pandemic assistance programs) because they leveraged existing programs that touched payrolls. From the article: > Many countries that kept workers in jobs had programmes in place already: some of the most successful—including France, Japan and Germany—simply increased coverage and benefits at the onset of the pandemic.
- therealdrag0 5y agoThe posts article says, > European countries did better: governments encouraged struggling employers to keep workers on their payrolls with reduced hours, and then made up some or all of the pay gap. Unlike the ppp, such programmes were usually aimed only at struggling firms that needed to cut salaries (though they were not always well targeted: a share of beneficiaries in Britain continued to pay dividends). Yet despite the flaws in America’s programme, the study’s authors argue that Congress was incapable of doing better. Crafting a targeted policy would have been hard, expensive and slow. Many countries that kept workers in jobs had programmes in place already: some of the most successful—including France, Japan and Germany—simply increased coverage and benefits at the onset of the pandemic. If America hopes to waste less money in future crises, it should plan ahead.
- kortilla 5y agoHow is that better though? They punished companies that were doing well going in. The end result could easily be worse for the whole economy.
- lifeplusplus 5y agoa religious school on same block as my house in nyc which refused to close down when there were dead bodies in trucks and also secretly served as wedding hall when wedding hall were shutdown, got 12 million dollars in loans, probably also got loan forgiveness.
- Dowwie 5y agoUnfortunately, the post I made to HN 2 weeks ago didn't propagate. I shared a study about this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29965743 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29965743
- danuker 5y agoUpvoted... for what it's worth. Thanks!
- beaconstudios 5y agoNo surprise there - after all, the state is the strong arm of the wealthy. Pretty much every time there's a big round of handouts or tax cuts, they go to benefit the richest in society.
- Day1 5y agoThis is generally how socialist govt programs work. Give money to the rich and advertise it as helping the poor.
- wdh505 5y ago"trickle down economics" for general economic policy, and straight bribing the rich to act well during social programs. The problem is "a fool and their money are soon parted", and the rich don't stay rich by parting with their money easily. I don't see an easy answer.
- lijogdfljk 5y agoConversely, it also seems to be how capitalist designs work. I ask: What designs actually help the working class?
- voisin 5y agoUniversal Basic Income.
- Cloudef 5y agoUBI has the potential to shift the cost of ubi into everything else, then you are back to the starting point
- asdff 5y agoThis is not very great logic. People try and argue the same about minimum wage and it falls in its face, because economists who practice critical thinking note that when minimum wage has been raised historically, inflation generally did not follow.
- tastyfreeze 5y agoAfter reading about the history and impact of minimum wages it is a policy that I vehemently oppose. Minimum wage started in most places as a way to price a group of workers out of the market so some other group could keep their jobs at the pay they liked. Additionally, minimum wage fails to deliver on its promise of helping low income groups. It makes less jobs available to low skill workers making it more difficult to acquire skills that would increase the pay they could demand. Finally, as with any price fixing scheme a black market arises. This would be cash under the table type jobs. What is wrong with two people agreeing on a price for some work that is below what some far away bean counter thinks is acceptable?
- frakkingcylons 5y agoThe graph showing the PPP loan distribution by income is kind of unsatisfying because there’s a broad range of incomes in the richest 20%. It would be much more convincing if there was more granularity in that graph. The 80th percentile household income is in the low to mid $100k range. If you have children and live in an expensive city, you’re not rich even if there are a lot of people worse off compared to you. This is not to say that I’m disputing the reporting showing that there was abuse of the PPP program.
- warning26 5y agoDon't worry, that money went to job creators and it will definitely trickle down to everyone else!
- marco_yolo 5y agoDon't worry government lockdowns of business were for the greater good there will be no side effects of destroying the economy to save lives!!!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anonporridge 5y agoAnything other than direct cash transfers to individual humans is likely to have this effect. Institutions are simply always going to be able to navigate and take advantage of complex government programs better than real human beings. UBI or stfu. Time to try some trickle up economics. Also, for the love of god, let's stop prioritizing saving "jobs" that may or may not be necessary for civilization and start prioritizing real people's well being.
- ericmcer 5y agoDirect cash still has this effect. $1500 to subsidize rent that is $1500 to property owners.
- asdff 5y agoOnly if you have no rent control and allow property owners to take as much as they are able to off the table short of starving their tenants.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoOr only if you prevent supply from meeting demand.
- nsxwolf 5y agoWhen I was a landlord I found it very difficult to even cover the mortgage, let alone cover association dues and maintenance. I would try to raise the rent a little in between tenants, and it would greatly reduce interest in the listing.
- rvense 5y agoWhy should the rent cover your mortgage?
- germandiago 5y agoBecause people who buy a place would like to reasonably be able to pay something that takes 30 years or similar to pay with the rent itself. That is a reason why you invest in the first place.
- sethammons 5y ago[EDIT] - Ignore. The article summary and the article are unrelated so my comment is unrelated. I can't read beyond the summary, but this is true in my experience: > Its hastly designed scheme sent much of its relief money to people who didn't need it My neighbor's granddaughter (age 18 or so) got relief money to the tune of more than she had ever earned in her life. She got purses. Many of them. My wife's friend got relief money atop unemployment. She was a waitress and stopped working during the time and she was making more than she could if she was working. A buddy's friend's work strategically cut hours so employees could get the relief checks atop their pay for a net pay increase. On the other side, my dad's work dried up and he was able to stretch things due to the checks.
- NationalPark 5y agoThe article is about PPP, which gave out forgivable loans in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to businesses and self-employed individuals. The total cost of this was about the same as the direct payment stimulus checks, but went to about 10m borrowers rather than the ~150m who received the checks. As for your anecdotes, it was sort of the point of giving people money that they would spend it, "stimulating" the economy. It was not intended to become a nest egg or to satisfy some cosmically appropriate amount of money for an 18 year old to have. It's macroeconomic policy, not moral policy. In many cases, the cost of doing means testing so you don't accidentally overpay someone you think is undeserving is more than the amount saved.
- disambiguation 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220201222841/https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2022/01/31/americas-covid-job-saving-programme-gave-most-of-its-cash-to-the-rich https://web.archive.org/web/20220201222841/https://www.econo...
- hibikir 5y agoThe US lacks the state capacity to tell who was going to have trouble with COVID-19 closures, and who wouldn't, so a whole lot of money just had to go to people that had no need for it whatsoever. Regarding PPP, every local tech staff augmentation company got a few months worth of payroll out of it. For those of you not in the know, their model involves hiring developers at $x an hour, and then placing them at large enterprises for $x+y, often for years at a time, as those companies would rather have contractors than employees. So where does the money go? Straight to the owner's pockets, as lockdowns only changed staffing needs in a very small number of companies. So if your sole proprietorship staffing company employs 25 of those developer-contractors for, say, 180k and a couple of HR staff, you could get million dollar "loan", that would be forgiven in a few months, as you didn't fire any of them. Needless to say, the people in charge of that kind of company were very happy about the PPP program.
- ryandrake 5y ago> The US lacks the state capacity to tell who was going to have trouble with COVID-19 closures, and who wouldn't, so a whole lot of money just had to go to people that had no need for it whatsoever. I love how it’s so critical that we means-test individual welfare so that no dollar can possibly go to someone who doesn’t need it, but when it comes to means-testing corporations for handouts, all of a sudden it’s impossible to determine which corporations need the help and which ones don’t. So just dump money on anyone who fills out the paperwork. If welfare and food stamps just went to anyone who applied, politicians would be up in arms.
- pjc50 5y agoThose are the political conditions imposed by the ruling party at the time; the measures did get actual money to the public, but to do so it was necessary to pay off everyone who might have objected.
- ThunderSizzle 5y agoThere wasn't "ruling party". You had Trump as president, you had Democrats in firm control of the house, and Uniparty RINOs in charge of the Senate. All three "worked together" to get their goals done, which for Congress, means ensuring kickbacks get paid.
- wnevets 5y agoAnd no one was worried about "socialism" when the tax payers gave tons of cash to the rich. Certain people only seem to worry about "socialism" when it helps regular people.
- jdminhbg 5y ago> no one This is an article in the Economist decrying it, so I don't think you can claim that no one is worried.
- codeivore 5y agoyeah, an article in a publication where the authors are anonymous because the views published in it are painfully true enough to make you real life enemies
- biorach 5y agoall of the economist articles are anonymous https://www.economist.com/the-economist-explains/2013/09/04/why-are-the-economists-writers-anonymous https://www.economist.com/the-economist-explains/2013/09/04/...
- wnevets 5y ago>so I don't think you can claim that no one is worried. No that isn't what I claimed, I claimed no one was worried. Using an article written almost two years after fact as proof against my claim doesn't make a whole a lot of sense. Now obviously my no one claim is hyperbole but the fact the bill's passing was near-unanimous is my point. Using one of the very few no votes in congress as proof against my claim would make a lot more sense.
- westurner 5y agoWould a [premined, escrowed] stablecoin token make it easier to answer these kinds of Transparency and Accountability questions in regards to government spending and government stimulus funding beyond intra-governmental transfers of real value? Said stablecoin token would be hosted on more or more resilient Distributed Ledger Technologies (DLTs; 'blockchains') with a - indeed more auditable - transaction record specification that supports multiple transaction inputs and outputs and an optional identifier such as an e.g. "coinbase field" to key auxilliary (unfortunately comparably mutable, offsite-backuped by which responsible parties) database records to.
- burkaman 5y agoThe issue here is not transparency, it's who the money was directed to. This is a policy question, and what type of currency you use is totally irrelevant. It's already very easy to see who received money (https://projects.propublica.org/coronavirus/bailouts/ https://projects.propublica.org/coronavirus/bailouts/), what we're discussing is whether it should have been given to different people.
- westurner 5y agoSo, in your opinion, the "And then where did the money go?" question is entirely distinct from the "Did those investments have the desired impact for the desired audience, per the predefined criteria for success?" question? Who were we doing capital investment for, in hopes of them raising additional separately-accounted-for monies? https://westurner.github.io/hnlog/#comment-25893860 https://westurner.github.io/hnlog/#comment-25893860 re: https://www.usaspending.gov/ https://www.usaspending.gov/
- burkaman 5y agoOh, are you talking about tracking the money after it's been loaned out? Like for a given dollar we can see that it was loaned to Company X, then paid to an employee, then spent on rent, then spent at a restaurant, etc. If that's what you mean then I agree it would be useful for studying the impacts of stimulus policies, although I think there are a lot of other privacy impacts we'd need to consider.
- phonon 5y agohttps://archive.is/Kr7d1 https://archive.is/Kr7d1
- rory 5y agoI know a few upper-middle class small business owners (all non-retail sectors) whose businesses weren't substantially affected by the pandemic, but who basically got a free handout as part of the program. Two mentioned how they were initially hesitant to apply for money, but then worried that if they didn't, their business could take a downturn after it was too late. Then as long as they spent the money on payroll (which they had to pay for anyway), they didn't have to pay it back, even if their business didn't show any losses. I shudder to think of how much the bigger players yanked out of it.
- vgeek 5y agoI was doing some work for a $30MM/yr ecommerce retailer whose business was up 30% YoY pre-pandemic and began a trend of doubling in April 2020. They were still hiring and got ~$600k for free. Another $50MM/yr company had flat/slightly up revenue and got $1.2MM. Both companies are notoriously stingy with W2 worker pay and bonuses, and remained so even after getting bailouts.
- MattGaiser 5y agoA friend worked for a company that used the Canadian equivalent during a period of record growth. As they doubled their headcount, they got the gov to pay for it all.
- moneywoes 5y agoWas this around the CERB time?
- brailsafe 5y agoand it still took me 2 years to find a job, not even in Canada! GG
- Fricken 5y agoFriends I know run a small Canadian documentary film production company. They received a hefty chunk of change in the early days of the pandemic that they really didn't need.
- 5y ago
- mchusma 5y agoThe PPP was designed to obviously benefit the businesses that needed it the least: 1) For any business that is fine or growing with COVID. PPP is free money. 2) Your business is in severe trouble with COVID, so you can't even have employees working productively. You can just give them the money, or use the PPP loan as a bridge loan, but you have to pay it back. It's low interest, but relatively short term and you had to start paying it back before COVID is even over. I think in hindsight all of these loans should have clearly been truly loans, probably leveraging the existing SBA disaster loan program. This is a great program, was already working and distributed some money in COVID. 30 year loans at like 3%, with a personal guarantee. Basically for any business owner who just needs money to bridge a disaster (the purported target of the PPP), this is way better. And anyone who doesn't need the money, won't take it (saving the taxpayers billions). It's unclear what the losses on this overall would have been, since its a loan, but I think its reasonably likely to be in the $10B to $100B range (instead of the $953B the PPP turned out to be).
- jlmorton 5y agoIn hindsight, it should have been structured like Germany's Kurzarbeit ("short-time working") program. Impacted businesses simply furlough employees they don't have work for. Employers continue to pay furloughed employees 70% of their salary, and the government reimburses businesses for the cost of the furloughed employees' salaries. There are no loans, no unemployment insurance. There is nothing employees need to apply for, and no Byzantine rules. Employees just get furloughed and continue to get 70% of their paycheck in the exact same way they always have, and businesses get reimbursed. When the crisis is over, businesses bring their employees back to work, and there's no major economic churn. Everyone goes right back to what they were doing before, assuming they still want to.
- wyager 5y agoIn hindsight, the government shouldn't have precipitated the conditions that justified these "loans" in the first place. The whole putative point of this (reducing covid deaths) was obviously ineffective and/or a red herring. Of course, if you think the actual point was liquidation of Kulaks, it was quite effective at that.
- cube00 5y agoSame story all over the world https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/aug/31/harvey-norman-repays-6m-of-the-22m-it-claimed-in-jobkeeper-after-record-profits https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/aug/31/harve...
- tim-- 5y agoTo quote the article though: > Harvey Norman repaid all the wage subsidies for its “controlled entities” The businesses that were claiming the cash were the franchisees of Harvey Norman. Not the publicly listed company (and it's owned subsidiaries). It could well be that those franchisees were indeed justified in claiming the Jobkeeper subsidies. I love picking on Gerry Harvey/Harvey Norman us much as the next guy, but this time it is unwarented. Pick on the plenty of other ASX (publicly) listed companies that used the money, didn't repay, and still dished out dividends to their shareholders. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/dec/07/less-than-6-of-42bn-received-in-jobkeeper-repaid-by-asx-listed-companies-asic-reveals https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/dec/07/less-... For example, Premier Investments (ASX: PMV) received $87m over two years, paid back $15.6m. In that period, they paid out $1.04 per share of dividends! They have as of writing 158.99M shares outstanding, so why did Just Jeans, Smiggle and Jay Jays need Jobkeeper? All that cash went straight to the shareholders pockets.
- hammock 5y agoDevil's advocate: is this altogether a bad thing? Hear me out (thought experiment). COVID relief wasn't supposed to be welfare. Its purpose could be viewed as being not a safety net, but rather compensation for allowing the economy to be shut down. In that sense, it makes sense that much of the recompense goes to the people who were asked to shutter their businesses, put up signage and buy new equipment and reduce capacity, make their employees check vax cards at the door, etc. "Relief" could be a misnomer for a fair payment in return for cooperation with a government lockdown program.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoBy the same logic, when British Empire made slavery illegal, they owed reparations not to people they enslaved, but to business owner's who could no longer keep slaves and lost their 'assets'. Is that the logic we want?
- cryptonector 5y agoWhich is in fact what the British did when they ended slavery.
- space_fountain 5y agoThough to be fair you can make a very compelling argument that that wasn't the most moral choice
- naasking 5y agoAvoiding a civil revolt and the subsequent death count probably undercuts any such claim to morality, if we're using "human suffering" as the metric.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThere may have been a population with more human suffering than former slave owners.
- abeppu 5y agoI think the second graph in this story is perhaps answering the 'wrong' question. Yes the richest 20% received the most from these programs. But the top 20% usually receive the most. The rescue plan was not advertised as the dawn of a new era of redistribution. It was an expensive bandaid to try to stabilize a bad situation. It wasn't _trying_ to give more to the poor. I think the right graph would compare rescue plan funds received by each income quantile against the actual income distribution. The better question it illustrates is roughly, was the inequality in the rescue plan funds distribution greater or less than the general income inequality? In particular, if ordinarily roughly >50% of the income goes to the top 20% (I think that's true), and the graph in the article shows that maybe a bit less than 30% of the rescue plan funds went to the top 20% (>600B / 2.2T), then yes we should regard the rescue plan as benefitting the rich, but to a lesser degree than like, the whole rest of the economy. If you want to complain about ways that we needlessly hand money to the rich, shouldn't we start with the ways which are most unequal? How about the fact that we distinguish capital gains from earned income? How about the mortgage interest deduction? https://www.statista.com/statistics/203247/shares-of-household-income-of-quintiles-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/203247/shares-of-househo... https://www.brookings.edu/?simplechart=top-quintile-receives-most-of-the-benefits-from-the-mortgage-interest-deduction https://www.brookings.edu/?simplechart=top-quintile-receives... See fig 5 https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/substantial-income-of-wealthy-households-escapes-annual-taxation-or-enjoys https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/substantial-income...
- naasking 5y ago> It was an expensive bandaid to try to stabilize a bad situation. It wasn't _trying_ to give more to the poor. I think the poor were the only ones feeling the instability, so I don't see how that logic tracks.
- hogrider 5y agoAnother example of how hyper focusing on jobs is counterproductive. You were afraid these jobs would be lost. It is conceivable that you could let these jobs just die and then give this money to the newly unemployed. But no, you stilll have that puritanical / protestant devotion to work itself.
- fastball 5y agoOr we could've let the people that were going to die anyway die, and avoid the job loss in the first place.
- lquist 5y agoMy business received about 1.25M from PPP. It was essential cash flow for us and helped save the business (from a cashflow pov) but it was also 100% a massive handout. On a systemic level it makes some sense I guess, but at a micro level it seemed like a bailout to the people who needed it the least. There is also basically no reason it had to be a handout vs an actual loan that required repayment.
- kumarvvr 5y agoRich creating programs for the rich, saying it is for the poor, but ultimately benefiting the rich. Where have I heard this before?
- kingcharles 5y agoWhen I was in jail, a MAJORITY of the people in there were scamming the COVID handouts. I remember one cellmate who had obtained $25,000 in COVID funding to buy PPE for his non-existent business (he was in jail for something unrelated). The guys in my block all had girls on the outside who would do all the paperwork for them for about 25% cut of whatever they made. The prisoners would feed them all their personal information and a few weeks later the fixers would put a substantial amount of cash onto their commissary account. It was a total production line affair. The fraud was substantial.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThis needs to be a movie.
- whatshisface 5y agoCan't be made into a movie until it ends.
- raxxorrax 5y agoPerhaps Hollywood should hire some lawyers for fresh new ideas then?
- anm89 5y agoEvery single one of the richest people I know got a 6+ figure handout on PPP. I'm only upper middle class so I only got $15k. I'm guessing most of the people who could have eaten more food if they got a bit more from the program got one less zero than I got. It's as if the program was designed to be as regressive as possible.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThis is inevitable in the winner take all economy. The only solution is to tax the gains and reinvest to improve the baseline quality of life.
- TheSoftwareGuy 5y agoI thought it was obvious at the time that some of the money would end up going to people who didn’t need it. But we were okay with that, to an extent, because enough would get to the people who did need it
- charvard 5y agoI worked on a paper that showed that the "Paycheck Protection Program loans increased employment at small businesses by only 2%, implying a cost of $377,000 per job saved" in April 2020: https://opportunityinsights.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/tracker_paper.pdf https://opportunityinsights.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/t... It still hurts me to read. Over a third of a million, 7 times the average salary, to save a job during the pandemic under this plan
- WalterBright 5y agoIn general, a government spending program to create jobs costs 3x as much as the jobs pay.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoAnd to think that they could have just given the money to people instead.
- pempem 5y agoBut then they would never work again! Look at where rent moratorium and $6,000 got us! /s Sorry, hearing this ^ bs logic every day in outlets from WSJ to NPR is beyond frustrating. We have helped our citizens so little during a pandemic it has shaken my already cynical core.
- sobani 5y ago> increased employment at small businesses by only 2% > implying a cost of $377,000 per job saved The second doesn't follow from the first at all? The fact that employment increased doesn't tell you anything about how many jobs were not lost, right?
- jsmeaton 5y ago> Crafting a targeted policy would have been hard, expensive and slow. How about simply stating that any firm paying dividends to shareholders or bonuses to execs could not have the loan forgiven? It wouldn't be perfect but it'd cut out the most egregious snakes. Hindsight yadda yadda. The same thing happened in Australia. Cash to businesses who could show an impact by Covid, but a lot of that money went towards bonuses and dividends. Crazy.
- sumedh 5y ago> How about simply stating that any firm paying dividends The people who write these laws know they can add such clauses but they wont because who is going to complain about it. Most people dont care.
- marco_yolo 5y agoLol a largely government created problem coupled with government shutdown followed by a poor patchwork government solution and the lefty takeaway at HN is that we need more different government to make more government more better
- ejb999 5y agoI used to listen to a podcast I enjoyed about a small and rapidly growing tech company in Oregon, someone I had personally met a few years back at a conference - which is where I first learned of the company; they work in the e-commerce space and I enjoyed listening to the founder talk about the trials and tribulations of growing his company; when covid hit, the company grew like gangbusters (like just abut every online business), and he would talk about the skyrocketing business growth and all of the money they were making. Then he also went on to talk about how he was lining up at the public trough to get welfare from the government (PPP) to 'help' his business - was so thoroughly disgusted by the lack of ethics and have never listen to the show again, and lost all respect for this founder as well. I will never understand rich people making money hand-over-fist and still willing to take money from taxpayers who make a fraction of what they do so they can have even more (are you listening Elon? this story is not about you, but it could be.)
- AlchemistCamp 5y agoRelated: https://www.startupsfortherestofus.com/episodes/episode-493-startup-roundtable https://www.startupsfortherestofus.com/episodes/episode-493-...
- Frost1x 5y ago>I will never understand rich people making money hand-over-fist and still willing to take money from taxpayers who make a fraction of what they do so they can have even more The two are correlated because our economic system rewards that very cut throat greedy behavior. Those behaviors mixed with some luck and skill are often how those very people became rich in the first place.
- toolz 5y agoSo in your opinion it was the companies fault that they didn't purposely leave a competitive advantage on the table while their competition surely utilized it? It seems that you judge from a place of detached ignorance. We are going through a pandemic and that business owner may very well be worried the bottom will fall out any moment and if that owner has employees it is their responsibility to prepare as much as possible during times of uncertainty. I find it unethical that you would judge the company rather than blame the core root of the problem which is the incompetence of the handouts in identifying rather easily that this company was growing and thus not in need. For all you know the owner would very much prefer he didn't qualify for those loans alongside their competition. Blaming the company solves nothing but does create division. Blaming the program, however, has the potential to solve every problem you have with the situation.
- rob_c 5y ago...but don't worry the rich assure me it'll be alright
- RspecMAuthortah 5y agoCOVID was the largest wealth transfer in our generation, from children as young as kindergarten (who will pay prices with the reduced social and IQ growth due to quarantine and school shut downs), millennials and GenZ to boomers.
- throwaway6734 5y agoThat's social security and healthcare/housing costs
- projektfu 5y agoI still can't understand why they created this bizarre program through bank lenders and the SBA, when they really only needed to send checks directly to people or employers based on the Social Security records. There was, as usual, a sizable handout to banks, in the form of a 1% processing fee.