22 ms·
Google Maps now requires WiFi scanning to use navigation
I've been using Google Maps a long time, and during all of that time I have only used GPS for location tracking on Android.
Depending upon the version of Android, I've had different things disabled. Wifi scanning. Bluetooth. Cell location data. Etc. Always with one single goal -- GPS only for location.
And further, this is always, especially with newer versions of Android, restricted in many ways. For example, only allowing when an app is active, and so on.
Google has always played games with Maps, using dark patterns. For example, with the versions prior to the current version, if I wanted Maps to zoom in on my location, I'd hit the tracking button.
It'd first say something like "To continue, turn on device location". Of course, device location is on, but it's only for GPS, and google so badly wants that (apparently) vital, and sweet wifi + bluetooth + cell tracking data.
Yet you could cancel this before, and it would then zoom in on your present location. Because, of course, GPS works fine for that.
I could also use only GPS, leaving wifi and bluetooth and so on scanning off to use navigation. I've driven all over North America and Europe that way too, and yes with Maps. Tricky dark patterns (ie, lying) about needing wifi scanning to find a route is just insulting, and absurd.
Now, enter a new update. I can no longer navigate with Google Maps, unless full location tracking is on. Comments in Play Store indicate others hit the same wall. Yeah, right Google, driving in the middle of the country, with GPS, is helped by scanning wifi while I pass farmer's fields?!
Google has now drawn a line in the sand. Give us all your local SSIDs, local bluetooth connections, with likely even more detail, or they now refuse to allow you to use Maps to navigate.
I immediately installed Organic Maps, and I'm sure there are loads of others as an option.
Google wants that wifi data so bad, that the only thing I can equate it to, is a used car salesperson. I get the impression that the Maps team is channeling Sméagol, and just shudder.
- mikece 5y agoHow much of your information does Google want? MORE! This is a big reason why I carry a Graphene OS phone... and searched eBay for a Garmin GPS -- that cannot phone home! -- for my car.
- peakaboo 5y agoAll information, and people are giving it to them for free. There is billions in dollar of profit from selling peoples data and the user gets nothing of that.
- acomjean 5y agoTo be fair, the user is getting a pretty amazing map/gps program. It it worth it? Are they completely upfront about the data they’re harvesting? You can opt out. Stand alone gps is still available. Open Street maps is an amazing open source program too. My car has a 2010 gps. It works. It’s not great but it’s gets you close. In some ways I miss my old Tom Tom. It had the mr. T voice yelling at me where to go.
- christkv 5y agoI just bought the Tom Tom app and paid for the maps I need. One of their big deals is privacy protection as no data is collected
- acomjean 5y agoForgot about the stand alone gps apps. And most phones have plenty of storage for those. I would love an app that would feed the data back into open street map.
- culanuchachamim 5y agoJust to remind you, the user get the whole functionality of the app. That's the trade-off.
- fsflover 5y ago> That's the trade-off. Only if the user is aware of that.
- google234123 5y ago
- vgeek 5y agoI actually picked up a mint Garmin from a thrift store for $10 for this reason. I always thought it was just me, I would turn GPS on and open maps on my LG v20, but would still get prompted about location accuracy every time. I upgraded to a Moto One 5g and the verbiage is different enough that I was confused into approving because it seemed to imply maps just wanted to turn GPS on (even though I already turned GPS on), upon later checking, Google Location Accuracy was enabled.
- bkovacev 5y agoWhat are some reliable alternatives for both iOS and Android? I'm unsure how are Apple Maps, but they were hideous a while back for Eastern Europe at least.
- b112 5y agoOrganic maps seems good, and I did take it for a test navigation drive. Not sure how it is long-term though.
- nkrisc 5y agoI've used Apple Maps for a while now and haven't noticed any real difference in from when I used to use Google Maps. So for me: Google Maps and Apple Maps are utterly interchangeable.
- jamiepenney 5y agoSame here - Apple Maps in New Zealand works just fine.
- can16358p 5y agoWhen that's the case Apple Maps would be a better choice as it doesn't try to suck all your privacy into its ad ecosystem.
- asdff 5y agoMy issue is it lacks a lot of local businesses. No point in using it if I have to go to google to find the business address anyhow.
- can16358p 5y agoYup that's also the issue for me. If I know where I'm going (just not how) it's not a problem. If I'm not sure where I'm going (like trying to find a place for the first time) it can be a problem.
- 5y ago
- mcast 5y agoMaybe someone should build a portable (FCC compliant?) device to put in your car that spoofs and rotates a bunch of 2.4/5Ghz SSIDs periodically to "trick" apps that mine wifi data with GPS location. Bonus points for bogus names like "Starbucks Wifi" or "McDonalds Free Wifi" in the middle of the highway. Even easier, just reverse engineer the API and send the SSIDs yourself.
- notacoward 5y ago> Bonus points for bogus names like "Starbucks Wifi" or "McDonalds Free Wifi" in the middle of the highway. I find no joy in saying it, but I bet that would get you some unwelcome attention - trademark infringement, defamation, tortious interference - from one of those companies. :(
- SllX 5y agoOut of curiosity, has anyone ever been sued over their SSID?
- notacoward 5y agoGood question. I'd be surprised if those companies would go after an individual over an "infringing" SSID, but if you sold a product using them that would be a different matter. An open-source project would probably fall somewhere in between.
- dmje 5y agoWe had one on our street called FuckOffAndGetYourOwn which I always liked
- Sohcahtoa82 5y agoI've always been partial to ones named like "NSA Monitor 3AB9D4"
- youngbullind 5y ago
- onion2k 5y agoHanlon's Razor ("Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity.") may well apply here. It could just be a bug.
- alserio 5y agoSure. But the actor gains something valuable from this, so it would be a very convenient bug.
- buran77 5y agoGoogle has been explicitly conditioning access to some features on users agreeing to share data [0]. This is perfectly in line with that strategy. Bugs which happen to work out that way aren't bugs. [0] https://bgr.com/tech/google-maps-forces-you-to-share-location-data-but-its-not-as-bad-as-it-sounds/ https://bgr.com/tech/google-maps-forces-you-to-share-locatio...
- jevoten 5y agoThat article reads like a corporate press release, and is full of misleading statements and outright lies, from the very first sentence: If you use Google Maps to get around, you probably know that Google has to access your location information. That’s the only way that it can offer turn-by-turn navigation and direction features. Plenty of map apps can calculate a route offline and offer navigation, without any data leaving the device. But Google and other companies want to keep people ignorant of how much can be done offline, so they have an excuse to spy on us.
- jevoten 5y agoGoogle has proven so many times they don't deserve the benefit of the doubt, bringing up Hanlon's razor is a bad joke at this point. Unfortunately I can't find the story of that Mozilla developer that recounted how many times Google introduced "bugs" that only harmed Firefox, and how long it took them to realize this was malicious due to applying Hanlon's razor. The fact is, if your opponent is even moderately intelligent, Hanlon's razor guarantees to keep you blind to their intentions.
- 5y ago
- nvr219 5y agoI've been using Waze this whole time
- beermonster 5y agoSo how about OsmAnd[0] ? Supports fully offline mobile navigation. [0] https://osmand.net/ https://osmand.net/
- solox3 5y agoI wish OsmAnd all the best, but ever since the app was created, its map rendering performance has been stuck in the 2010s, no matter how much faster our devices have gotten since then. There is justification for it for sure (see https://github.com/osmandapp/OsmAnd/issues?q=is%3Aissue+slow+map+render https://github.com/osmandapp/OsmAnd/issues?q=is%3Aissue+slow... for a few), and I love OSM out of principle, but as a product, it will remain my last resort until the user experience is tolerable.
- mappu 5y agoIf you have an older device, there is a is night and day difference between OsmAnd~ (the F-Droid rebuild) and Organic Maps (the latest maps.me fork). OsmAnd visibly stutters to load in new tiles whereas Organic Maps is perfectly smooth even when zooming quickly. OsmAnd is still much more feature-rich, though, so it's worth using if you have a more powerful device. Although i do worry about the battery impact.
- mkdirp 5y agoI want to switch to osmand and I've installed it and Google Maps, but I've yet to be able to use osmand full time. mostly because it never seems to find a full and navigate to it properly. The best way I've been able to use it is typing the address's postcode and then finally look for the number or building like a barbarian, but even that doesn't always bring up the result.
- npteljes 5y agoOrganic Maps is also cool. Forked from the then-OSS Maps.Me client, which, to be honest, I liked better than OsmAnd. https://f-droid.org/en/packages/app.organicmaps/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/app.organicmaps/
- LoveGracePeace 5y ago
- marcodiego 5y agoI've been using OsmanAnd from f-droid and have been somewhat satisfied.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jonas21 5y agoAre you sure they're not doing this to get approximate location for use with A-GPS? Sure, GPS will work without it, but your time to first fix is going to be much longer, and your phone will have no idea where you are while you're waiting for that fix. There's a good overview of A-GPS in module 5 here [1]. This is just how people expect GPS to work on modern mobile phones, to the point where they'd probably consider it a bug if they had to wait a while to get a fix. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4CBINyC3NWU&list=PLGvhNIiu1ubyEOJga50LJMzVXtbUq6CPo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4CBINyC3NWU&list=PLGvhNIiu1u...
- M4v3R 5y agoAGPS works with cellular, Wi-Fi is not required. So no, it’s not only for this reason.
- jonas21 5y agoAs I understand it, the OP is trying to keep all non-GPS location sources disabled. > I've had different things disabled. Wifi scanning. Bluetooth. Cell location data. Etc. Always with one single goal -- GPS only for location.
- bryceacc 5y agothat most definitely is the reason to ask for wifi scanning, but the point was reiterated many times in the post. This is about privacy AND the fact that GPS-only navigation works globally just fine. If the user wishes to have that improved cold start approximate location then sure, turn on wifi scanning. If they do not wish to give that up, they should still be able to navigate
- gerash 5y agoSo if an app knows your exact lat long after 30s of spending battery power there's no privacy issue but if it uses wifi SSIDs around you to do the job in 2s with less power it's a breach of privacy?
- 5y ago
- causality0 5y agoI have regarded the entire Google Maps dev team with utter contempt since they first combined maps and navigation into one app, thereby preventing you from using both at the same time. At this point I'd rather use a paper map then let Google wardrive using my phone 24 hours a day.
- Geonode 5y agoMy biggest pet peeve is that when you search for something, your starred places disappear. Hey, I'm actually trying to see if this is close to somewhere I go! What's the closest post office to my daughter's school? Oh, wait, where'd the school go? Insane.
- easrng 5y agoIf you use the Android Go version the maps and navigation are separate.
- gowld 5y agoMaps Go is available for regular Android. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.apps.mapslite&hl=en_US&gl=US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.and...
- easrng 5y agoI'm aware. I didn't want to just say the Go version because that might be confused with the Go programming language. By the way, the app you linked is just a wrapper around https://google.com/maps?force=pwa&source=mlapk https://google.com/maps?force=pwa&source=mlapk and going to that link in android chromium and adding to homescreen gets you an identical result.
- recursive 5y agoI don't understand this at all. If they're both in the same app, then aren't you using them both every time you're using it? What does it mean to navigate without using a map?
- dzhiurgis 5y agoI don't like this being forced on you, but who the hell cares about wifi/bt SSID sniffing? What's so bad about collecting it? You are literally broadcasting it yourself and on most devices you can't even turn broadcasting off anymore.
- osrec 5y agoOn a localised basis, it is perhaps not so bad, however at a higher level, it allows you to piece together a huge amount of info, including grouping members of households etc. Honestly, it's not a great piece of info to be leaking, if you value your privacy.
- luckydata 5y agoThat requires processing the data in ways that would have to be disclosed as per law.
- ithinkso 5y agoThat only requires writing an apology for a bug after processing the data in this ways was found to be undisclosed, and then disclosing it with no opt-out.
- osrec 5y agoOr alternatively, process the data anyway, make tens of billions of dollars from it, and pay a 2 billion dollar fine if the regulators find out. The fine is just another cost of doing business ;)
- dzhiurgis 5y ago> grouping members of households How does GPS location not achieve same..?
- voakbasda 5y agoMy access points are inaccessible to the public. You would have to trespass deep into my property. No one has any business knowing anything about my network or devices here.
- akomtu 5y agoI regret the last time I let it auto-update: that update had brought lots of junk UI and the annoying and equally useless "covid" reminder at the bottom. Since then I've disabled the auto-updates. If one day it refuses to work, I guess I'll just find some OSM-based alternative.
- mschuster91 5y ago> Of course, device location is on, but it's only for GPS, and google so badly wants that (apparently) vital, and sweet wifi + bluetooth + cell tracking data. I'd believe this has been made to reduce the number of "Maps takes soooo long to acquire my position on the map / can't find me when I'm in a building" complaints. A WiFi scan will be very quick (to the tune of 1-5s) to establish rough coordinates, a GPS TTFF can take minutes or be outright impossible.
- nybble41 5y agoOn the other hand, those "rough coordinates" you get from a WiFi scan may be hundreds of miles away from your actual location. WiFi networks move. For example, I have a 4G hotspot with a proper antenna for areas with poor reception. While traveling to a campground the location remains accurate so long as I'm using Maps for navigation (with GPS). Shortly after I arrive and activate my hotspot, however, my phone starts reporting that I'm at the last place I stayed. And it generally keeps doing that for several days (until I'm about ready to leave) before their database finally updates. If I force a GPS fix—which takes longer due to the bad initial guess—it shows the right place for a while and then reverts once GPS is no longer active. What I want is for it to ignore all the mobile hotspots around me[0] and just use GPS and fixed sources such as cell towers. An out-of-date GPS fix would be better than its guess based on WiFi scanning, but Maps no longer supports navigation without what they laughably refer to as "Google Location Accuracy" enabled. There isn't even an option to include the more reliable sources such as cellular service and local sensors (inertial navigation) while excluding WiFi. [0] Yes, I know I could rename the hotspot to use some ugly suffix or other ("_no_map", I think?) to avoid it being recorded in the database. That doesn't help with all the other mobile hotspots I don't control.
- daviddisco 5y agoWhat is the value of sniffing the local ssids? As far as I know it is just to get a better and faster lock on location (sometimes GPS signals are weak) and therefore give better navigation. Does anyone know of some other purpose?
- beeboop 5y agoGPS is only so accurate on phones by itself. I assume harvesting SSIDs helps a lot for knowing specifically which stores you're shopping at in a dense area with weak GPS signal. It's very accurate with it's "How did you like visiting _____?" notifications and if you look at your location history I think it also accurately labels stores well. Obviously knowing every store you visit is very useful advertising data.
- DebtDeflation 5y agoI'm curious as well. Who out there is even using open wifi without at least a captive portal? What benefit to Google is there to just collect SSIDs?
- Croftengea 5y agoTo know where you are even with GPS off.
- charcircuit 5y agoThat still requires an app to have location permissions to do.
- ProAm 5y agoTo serve ads. They can tell a business a consumer was withing X distance if your establishment. We can show them an advertisement in google maps the next time they are near by if you gladly pay us
- legitster 5y agoGPS is pretty battery intensive. Your phone is already gathering a list of every SSID it touches every second. If Google can eliminate the need to use GPS to confirm that you are sitting at your desk, it can eliminate a bunch of needless GPS calculations.
- jdiez17 5y agoWhile I'm not sure if this change to Google Maps has been or will be widely rolled out, you may want to look into what GrapheneOS is working on with their Google Play compatibility layer [1]. It basically lets people use Google's services inside Android's standard app sandbox. That means they don't get access to privileged system APIs and can only access what the user chooses. It can also be used without a Google account. GrapheneOS is working on a way to redirect the Play services location APIs to an open source implementation of those APIs which uses standard Android location APIs [2]. It's expected to be available in an upcoming release [3]. [1] https://grapheneos.org/usage#sandboxed-google-play https://grapheneos.org/usage#sandboxed-google-play [2] https://developer.android.com/reference/android/location/LocationManager https://developer.android.com/reference/android/location/Loc... [3] https://twitter.com/GrapheneOS/status/1486182874567122945 https://twitter.com/GrapheneOS/status/1486182874567122945
- citizenpaul 5y agoI wondered how long before google will have a reason for grapheneOS to suddenly stop being supoorted on the pixel. Now i know it will be soon and i get to tell everyone i told you so
- dragonelite 5y agoThey are creating custom silicon and a new operating system, wouldn't be surprised that will be the cutoff moment.
- tristan957 5y agoGoogle is moving all Android distributors to upstream Linux, so I guess it is us telling you so :).
- ForHackernews 5y ago> to an open source implementation of those APIs Is this MicroG? https://microg.org/ https://microg.org/
- 5y ago
- app4soft 5y ago> I immediately installed Organic Maps, and I'm sure there are loads of others as an option. Here are OSM-based maps applications for Android.[0,1] Not all OSM-based Android apps listed on OpenStreetMap Wiki, so check out also maps apps in various F-Droid repos.[2] Also here are maps apps for Symbian[3,4] and Maemo[5]. For other platforms there are also a lot of other apps.[6] [0] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Android#OpenStreetMap_applications https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Android#OpenStreetMap_ap... [1] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Comparison_of_Android_applications https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Comparison_of_Android_ap... [2] https://apt.izzysoft.de/fdroid/ https://apt.izzysoft.de/fdroid/ [3] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Symbian https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Symbian [4] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/S60Maps https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/S60Maps [5] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Software/Maemo https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Software/Maemo [6] https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Software https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Software
- uneekname 5y agoDoes anyone have a favorite that has worked well for them?
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoOrganic Maps is the best FOSS mobile mapping solution at the moment as far as I can tell https://organicmaps.app/ https://organicmaps.app/
- FourthProtocol 5y agoNot in the list, Here maps (with ancient roots in Nokia Maps) is excellent.
- awiesenhofer 5y agoSeconded, especially the HERE WeGo app just for route navigation is excellent and imho better than gmaps most of the time.
- 5y ago
- dessant 5y agoRefusing service when the user does not consent to non-essential data sharing is illegal in the EU, and it also breaches Google Play's developer agreement. WiFi scanning is not essential to navigate with an app, and the least they could do to follow the law is to gracefully degrade the service if the user does not consent to share data about nearby devices, such as disabling traffic predictions. Of course Google's lawyers will argue that this data is in fact required for navigation, the same way some banks in the EU now claim "legitimate interest" when they send you a message about their credit card promotions with winnable prizes, after you've explicitly opted out from all marketing communications.
- loceng 5y agoIt arguably may allow the navigation to be more accurate, even if a tiny amount, though it obviously isn't strictly required since navigation works without the data.
- moritonal 5y agoCan't believe I'm on this side of the debate, but at what point are we asking too much for free? Google provide Maps for free to an incredible accuracy and value. Unlike Apple, the user is welcome to use any other app, and yet chooses to use Google Maps. You could maybe argue that Google Maps is part of a package you bought the phone for, but realistically I think the solution is Google are just open about the use of data (which they are really) and offers a paid solution that doesn't track you.
- gowld 5y agoSelling organs is illegal. Maybe selling your personal / environmental data is too. Anyone can charge money for access to an app to compensate for value of data. > and offers a paid solution that doesn't track you. of Maps?
- nickpp 5y agoHell let’s make selling anything about me illegal: my voice, my image, my ideas, my bodily fluids, especially my time and effort. Then I can finally live off the allowance our caring government will generously offer.
- dTal 5y agoThey've always been coercive. You've never been able to use GPS passively without Play Services phoning your location home to Google, since the earliest days of Android. They would pop up a confirmation box asking you to agree to data collection, and if you declined, then GPS would remain off. It was a major influence in my decision to never, ever run a Googled Android on my phone. I just can't trust any company with that level of invasive surveillance. It's my line in the sand.
- homero 5y agoWow yeah it exits if I click no thanks. I've always kept scanning off.
- acqbu 5y agoGoogle = Garbage. I don't recommend using any of their services. For a maps replacement, I'd recommend OsmAnd or Magic Earth - both available on f-droid.
- cush 5y agoIf you have an iPhone and haven't been using Apple Maps, it's basically on par now with Google Maps for navigation. I hadn't tried Apple Maps for years because of how bad it used to be, and was pleasantly surprised to find the maps are incredibly accurate and turn by turn navigation is rock solid. I haven't touched Google Maps in months, and this post is reminding me that it's time to just uninstall it
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoIt is amazing how long it takes to recover from a rough product roll-out, isn't it?
- cush 5y agoTruth
- mint2 5y agoApple Maps has better integration with my 2020 Subaru so I switched. It has some features that are more advanced than google, like the voice telling what to do next or advance rather than just immediately before. It’s still rather bad about explorative searching for businesses/restaurants and getting accurate hours, so sometimes I’ll find a place using google maps and then put it into Apple Maps.
- Klonoar 5y ago>It’s still rather bad about explorative searching for businesses/restaurants That it just pipes Yelp results infuriates me every time I deal with it, as I refuse to sign up for Yelp.
- cush 5y agoSo did I! My 2019 Subaru’s OS crashed so many times on Android auto was the reason I switched to iPhone at all.
- rootusrootus 5y agoA little while back my area finally got the Apple Maps 3D visualization update, and I have to say I'm pretty impressed. Took them some time to turn it around, but Apple definitely stepped it up after an awful start.
- sixothree 5y ago> I've been using Google Maps a long time Sunk cost didn't bother me when I uninstalled Google Maps from my phone. Good riddance.
- throwawaymanbot 5y ago
- mdavidn 5y agoRather than assume malice, a more charitable and entirely plausible interpretation is that the Google Maps team simply does not test this configuration. A recent change to Google Maps or Android unknowingly broke it, akin to genetic drift. All phones collect MAC addresses from nearby WiFi devices to speed up the initial GPS satellite fix. Apple does this too.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoI use Magic Earth. It's not as good but it doesn't spy on me.
- ImaCake 5y agoHas anyone else found google maps will turn your position icon into a pop up saying “accuracy: low, tap to improve”? It is the most obnoxious UI “feature” I’ve seen in maps (one of many I suppose). When you click on it, it wants you to take photos of the street around you to improve accuracy! What bullshit. No, google, I am not going to give you free streetview photos because you are lying about location accuracy.
- darkwizard42 5y agoIt isn't about generating "free streetview photos" but actually about matching the imagery around you to the database of Street View photos they already have. If there is no match, it isn't going to take your photos and keep them... it has no accurate idea of where you are. The service is called Live View and is exceptionally useful (and optional) if you are in a foreign country where you are unfamiliar with street signs or in an urban canyon. Location accuracy challenges aren't a conspiracy, it can be very difficult to generate at cold start (see numerous other comments about how GPS can take a while to locate accurately but fused signals from other sources can help turn that into 1-2s)
- ImaCake 5y agoI guess this is good to know. But doesn’t fit well with my experience with it. I am getting the pop-up while living in a first world city. Google maps is allowed to use wifi to help find me. And the dot representing my location is invariably in the correct spot. Yet, the pop-up still shows. Forgive me my suspicion since there is no practical reason why I need to improve my location accuracy when it is already very accurate.
- darkwizard42 5y agoWell, why it pops up I can't really speak to (could easily be a product manager trying to boost engagement), but what it does is more of what I'm familiar with
- TedShiller 5y agoHow about using the mobile website maps.google.com, would that work?
- imglorp 5y agoI'm pretty sure this is to improve the crowd-sourced database of WIFI AP's. Google was involved with Skyhook for a while and there's no reason to think they stopped using similar tech. It's really that simple: war drive to build a map of AP to location, remove any that seem to move around (ie trains), and then you can use the database to map an AP sighting to location in the client. Trilateration on signal strength for extra points. Source: worked with them. Ref: https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/court-of-appeals/volumes/86/86massappct611.html https://law.justia.com/cases/massachusetts/court-of-appeals/...
- throwaway997665 5y agoThis is your monthly reminder that Google absolutely does not care about your or anyone else's privacy. They only care about building a higher resolution view of the little ant farm of humanity that they think they own. > Google has now drawn a line in the sand. Give us all your local SSIDs, local bluetooth connections, with likely even more detail, or they now refuse to allow you to use Maps to navigate. Oh, that's not the half of it. If GLS's data harvesting practices (including its completely inadequate "anonymization" methods) were made public, you'd realize that your phone is uploading literally everything that could possibly be related to location tracking to Google as often as possible, including sensor traces accurate enough to locate you to less than a meter, what floor of a building you are on, etc.
- propogandist 5y ago>If GLS's data harvesting practices were made public are you speculating, or sharing a comment of something you know to be true? \
- nathanaldensr 5y agoI'd like to know more about your last paragraph. Do you have any sources?
- dreamcompiler 5y agoHere we go again. Users desperately need an abstraction layer in Android that can spoof sensor data on a per-application basis. In this case, the spoofing layer could be set up such that whenever Google Maps uses the Android API to ask "Is wifi location sensing turned on" the spoofing layer would say "Yes." When GM asks "What wifi networks are around?" the spoofing layer would say "None." (Even better would be for it to just make up a bunch of random wifi SSIDs to pollute Google's wifi database with noise.) I have several other apps (Twitter for example) who are able to tell that I have notifications for them turned off, and consequently they bug me to turn on notifications. I need a spoofing layer that tells Twitter "notifications are turned on" even when they're off, because if the app can tell some feature is turned off it will bug me or in some cases fail to work at all. So it's also critically important that there be no way for applications to figure out that the spoofing layer is in place.
- em-bee 5y agobig yes to this. whenever an app asks for a permission i want these options: allow deny pretend allow but send empty responses (like no wifi found) pretend allow but send fake responses
- propogandist 5y agothis was supported with Xprivacy many years ago and it was fantastic, but it stopped getting support. The entire pro-privacy android scene seems to have become a very small niche over the years
- em-bee 5y agointeresting. f-droid has an app called xprivacylua which seems to be a successor to xprivacy. last updated less than a year ago. the problem is that it requires rooting the phone which not many people will want to do, and the xposed framework comes with a big warning that it could prevent android from booting. what we need is to have this integrated into the core OS so that it can safely be used by anyone.
- 5y ago
- s1mon 5y agoI don't doubt that Google has changed their policy, but is there any official confirmation of this somewhere? I tried a bunch of searches but couldn't confirm. Also, does anyone know how this might affect the use of an external GPS connected with Bluetooth?
- gerash 5y agoI sense op feels entitled to use free Google services and dictate how their product should work. There are many arguments why using GPS alone is both battery intensive and also more fragile as it won't work near tall buildings, indoors and takes time to localize. But at the end of the day if you don't trust some corporation you can stop using their free services when there are alternatives around. There's Apple maps, Bing maps, Here maps, etc.
- matt_heimer 5y agoWifi? Ha! Google Maps has prompted me to turn on my camera for improved location accuracy a couple of times. And I'm not sure why switching map apps will really help long term. Can't Google just bake in WiFi WAR driving into the location services API?
- darkwizard42 5y agoFYI that uses their Live View to look at building and street view around you to better orient you. Kind of matches what you photo with what they know and orients you. Incredibly useful in places like Japan where you don’t have many readable street signs or dense urban canyons. It has nothing to do with some crazy nefarious google plot.
- matt_heimer 5y agoDo you know for sure that those pictures aren't uploaded to Google? Maybe not nefarious but its crazy that my gps navigation app prompts me to start taking pictures while driving to improve accuracy.
- darkwizard42 5y agoThe feature only works while walking [0]. [0]https://www.pocket-lint.com/apps/news/google/147956-what-is-google-maps-ar-navigation-and-how-do-you-use-it https://www.pocket-lint.com/apps/news/google/147956-what-is-...
- matt_heimer 5y agoMight be related but not the same thing as I've experienced. I'm in maps (not navigating, usually just selecting a location) and driving and I get a promote to improve the accuracy (similar to the one where you'd rotate your phone to calibrate the compass). I am not trying to use AR and the prompt doesn't take me to AR, it just wants to scan the area with the camera and then its done.
- philsnow 5y agoNot related to Google maps, but just today I got tired of the Amazon app sending me "you might like this deal" notifications and dug into whether it's possible to disable them. You can, but if you do, Amazon will no longer send Amazon "Smile" micro-donations to whatever charity you've selected: https://i.imgur.com/wNAkUAT.jpeg https://i.imgur.com/wNAkUAT.jpeg . I can't say that this is underhanded, but it does cast into sharp relief the fact that Amazon is a $1.5 trillion dollar company that generates upwards of $3B in yearly profit, and they're jerking you around, dangling the pennies they would otherwise send to a charity, unless you let them feed you product recommendations in OS notifications. (If you just disallow the entire Amazon app from sending notifications, as far as I can tell they still give the charity whatever 0.5% cut.) So I have to choose between 1) allowing them to send me product recommendations, 2) a poor UX because I don't get any notifications at all, or 3) just not sending the charity any of the scraps of my Amazon transactions. I chose 3 and cut the charity a larger check than usual.
- mhardcastle 5y agoShopping at Amazon has become such a blatantly user-hostile experience. More than any company I've dealt with in recent memory, they seem to tolerate just about any unethical behavior - allowing fake product reviews, facilitating sale of counterfeit merchandise, and evidently withholding charitable donations if you don't allow them to pester you via your own device. It's to the point that shopping at Amazon feels dirty to me. Why support a company that's doing everything it can to transfer your well-being to Jeff Bezos?
- philsnow 5y agoOther online retailers (well, only the huge ones) seem to be stepping up their game and getting closer to Amazon's logistics and shipping ability. It reminds me of how Netflix had more or less a monopoly on big-name video streaming for a ~decade but now every major rights holder seems to have either white-labeled somebody's tech or developed their own and are clawing back their IP to only show on their own platform[0]. Amazon had a long head start in online retail. It's true that they will probably never be surpassed in catalog depth ("the everything store") but I don't delve into the long tail of that depth very much and I'll be happy to move my retail spending elsewhere. ... well, now that I think on it, my only payment method on Amazon is my Amazon Visa, which gives me something like 5% cash back / equates to a 5% discount on everything I buy from Amazon. So any competitor is going to have that headwind to fight against as well. [0] I wonder if this was a Netflix misstep: could they have prevented this by giving a greater share of the subscription revenue to the groups they licensed content from?
- reustle 5y agoI haven't lived in the US in a long while, but recently drove 3,500km here and was surprised to hear Google Maps say things like "Turn left at the McDonalds". We all knew this was coming one day.
- darkwizard42 5y agoIs it surprising? When you give directions to a human you generally use landmarks or businesses to express where you should make a turn, so why wouldn't Google if that helps more than "...in 300m turn left"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- maxclark 5y agoI don’t understand the “want privacy” but “use android” combo.
- Sunspark 5y agoHERE Maps is better than Organic Maps if you need routing.
- sgoyvdg 5y agoThe answer is the same for why google refuses (and silently reverted) patches removing or improving privacy for things like referer(sic) headers in chrome: ad revenue. Learn about "dooh" and POI conversion etc, and you will figure out why google need your phone to be wifi-scanning all the time. It needs to find a store wifi beacon that pays them if they "convert" you, i.e. enter the store after seeing an ad to enter the store. Sansung and apple are into this too. It's all part of "providing services in your best interest that you have signed for" in gdpr and ccpa language.
- egberts1 5y agoGenius Map for iOS iPhone is truly one OFFLINE map. You download the map, turn off WiFi AND cellular, and enjoy your GPS map.
- Seb-C 5y agoI've had some issues lately, but after a reboot it seems to work again. Unless maybe if you need the car navigation, google maps seems to work well as a progressive web app (and since it's sandboxed by the browser, it can only use the actual GPS). On the last days I'm actually more pissed-off with the update of Google translate than Google maps.
- unit_circle 5y agoTry OSMAnd. I started using it because it allows you to download huge areas as vector maps for offline use. But I find myself slowly using it more and more. The only things missing that keep me using gmaps are search, reviews / places, and directions that factor traffic (not a biggie tbh). However, I've been playing with mapbox and, without any prior experience whatsoever got a traffic overlay working within a few hours with a free account. I believe they provide the other parts (search, routing & places) too, I just need to figure out how to plumb them in. I have tried a ton of map apps and IMO OSMAnd has all the pieces to be a serious competitior, at least for technical folks, with just a little bit of commercialization... The gmaps moat is not as deep or as wide as it seems. If you are an OSMAnd dev reading this, I will happily pay a monthly fee for this stuff if provided as a cost plus package... I get a ton of value out of the app already, already pay for it and hate Google maps more with every passing day.
- cimnine 5y agoI love OSMAnd too and used it in places where Google Maps was subpar, e.g. in India or places in the middle east. But also all over Europe when roaming data was still expensive and recently when I crossed Canada east to west by car. The benefit of the map data coming from the open street map community paid off massively where there was little commercial interest for Google to map the area in detail. I also love that you can edit and add POIs to OSM right from within OSMAnd. On a side note: If you like to improve details of OSM, have a look at Street Complete, a gameified app to add details of your area to OSM. One of the tasks is to check/provide opening hours of nearby facilities.
- lmm 5y agoI use it for cycling, but honestly it's pretty frustrating. Searching for Japanese place names is pretty difficult, and since most place names are only listed in the local language but its TTS can only handle one language at a time I have to choose between "turn right onto " and "右に回って、明治通り", whereas Google will give me "turn right onto Meiji-doori". It doesn't help that I'm stuck on an old version for the "turn on screen when approaching a turn" function, which is actually Google's problem but still frustrating.
- Paraesthetic 5y agoI've been using Here maps since it was Nokia Maps, and apart from recommendations on local businesses I haven't missed anything.
- Traubenfuchs 5y agoFor a while now, Google Maps has entered end stage monetization mode. I am now using Apple Maps.
- ajyotirmay 5y agoI occasionally use OsmAnd+ by picking up my destination from GMaps. It works nicely (I like the offline option it provides). The one drawback is perhaps the traffic data, but otherwise it's really good with a good choice of different map types.
- mackrevinack 5y agoosmand also lets you start a navigation from a shortcut as well which is pretty neat. i use tasker (on android) and then add the tasker shortcuts to zone launcher so i just need to swipe from the side of the screen to access them. just set the %lat and %lon variables to whatever and then add this to the send intent in tasker: action: android.intent.action.VIEW data: osmand.api://navigate?dest_lat=%lat&dest_lon=%lon&profile=car&force=1 extra: Package.net.osmand
- botev 5y agoEU user here, deleted the App, lol
- cik 5y agoHonestly Google, what's wrong with you? I'm done. I'm done paying for services only to be the product. The behaviour I've seen this year alone is enough for me to give in and look at every single other choice. Can I run an android without google magic on it - meaning the apps I need? I'm sure going to find out on a rooted phone. I'm shocked, but I'll actually be embracing trying an iphone, a pinephone - hell pretty much everything now. At least Apple is reasonably honest about their evil. I might be able to suck that up.
- hockey 5y agoGoogle Maps is a pretty big application. Have you considered that this might have been a mistake? Refactoring legacy codebases isn't always without regressions. If you file a bug report (especially if there are a bunch of others filing them) then the people in charge of this stuff won't be able to claim they didn't know about it. Open maps > help and feedback > send feedback And remember, Every good bug report needs exactly three things: 1) Steps to reproduce, 2) What you expected to see, and 3) What you saw instead
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"Now, enter a new update, I can no longer navigate with Google Maps, unless full location tracking is on." Sounds like accepting the new update does not always mean there is an improvement for the user, or the negatives may outweigh the positives.
- Giorgi 5y agoUnfortunately openstreetmaps suck comparing to Gmaps, it's same problem all again: Google product sucks but it's the best option on the market.
- amarant 5y agoI don't really get what the objection is here, if you're using maps with GPS, Google has your location, adding precision to that helps you more than it helps them, they don't need sub-metre precision to know what store you were in, but your navigation prompts to switch lanes in a more timely manner becomes possible/more accurate with this, especially in cities where buildings mess with satellite signals. This seems like hating Google because it's Google, not because this particular action merits any hate at all
- thegrasshopper2 5y agoI just tried to disable every "augmented navigation" and use GPS only. Everything works, it's just a bit more annoying because it takes more time to get the location. If I press the "current location" button before that I'm prompted to activate augmented location, if I wait a bit google maps successfully finds my position on the map. Trying to navigate brings the annoying pop-up again (every time I close/open the screen, actually), but clicking OK and then reverting manually keeps the navigation open. I live in Europe, so that might be a reason for the difference, anyway I can suggest OpenStreetMaps as a good alternative (superior to gmaps at times too).
- yamrzou 5y agoThat explains why everytime I turn it off, it later turns on automatically. So shady.
- rishabhd 5y agoFor me, the line was drawn when they forced users to migrate to Google workspace. Looking to de-couple my life with Google.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoIs it the "Precise location" switch? I just checked, every application on my phone that requires location, does not work unless "Precise location" switch is ON.
- nums 5y agoWhat is the best alternative to google maps on my iphone that doesn't sell/store my location data?
- pricci 5y agoCan confirm this behavior. While driving home yesterday the usual "enable Google location services" appeared on Google Maps after starting navigation mode, but if I dismissed it, it exited navigation mode. Funny thing is that if I didn't dismiss it and left the popup there, I could see behind it that the navigation worked as usual.
- beefbudd 5y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/wifi-camera-sees-through-walls-2017-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/wifi-camera-sees-through-wal...
- beefbudd69 5y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/wifi-camera-sees-through-walls-2017-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/wifi-camera-sees-through-wal...