25 ms·
The strange trend of "authoritarian minimalism" design that seems to be working its way through the majority of newer software is very strange. I wonder who act
by userbinator 5y ago
The strange trend of "authoritarian minimalism" design that seems to be working its way through the majority of newer software is very strange. I wonder who actually wants this stuff, and is not content to merely make it a default, but instead forces it to be the one and only way.
Monitors are bigger than ever with huge resolutions, and yet UIs are being dumbed down to uselessness and alienating an increasing number of users.
A recent related article https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29954266 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29954266 seems to indicate that not even people inside Microsoft --- who are being forced to use Win11, because MS --- have any say in the matter. It's almost like some tiny extremist faction has gained control of Windows and is determined to show everyone else how much power they have by making these changes and gloating sadistically at seeing everyone object, but still end up using Windows.
I wonder how much damage they will inflict before people start turning to WINE and a saner Linux distro, just to run their Windows applications.
- spikej 5y agoGotta make use of those full-time UI people somehow... sigh.
- spaetzleesser 5y ago"authoritarian minimalism" Can we blame this on Apple?
- epistasis 5y agoI think we can blame it on a poor imitation of what Apple does. However even Apple has copied the atrocious flat UI fashion that has destroyed the ability of users to decipher what can be interacted with, and how. If I have to deal with another goddamned toggle that has reinvented the wheel and in so doing destroyed the ability to decipher the current state and what toggling will cause to happen... well I'll be very unhappy and then continue to eat the dog food because I have no other choice.
- BLKNSLVR 5y agoOk, so this light grey text and toggle means it's not selected, I assume? Click. Oh, the text has now changed to the other option and the toggle is green, so that means the text is telling me what option is actually currently selected, whilst the toggle colour indicates which option the system thinks is equivalent to 'on'. Yep, many interfaces I've come across require me to interact with the toggle to work out what the current setting is.
- stonedartist 5y agoMany web interfaces use iOS style toggle and somehow use "double negatives"(?). It's a binary decision but still, they somehow make it seemingly confusing like you mentioned. It's like - is the text label, the result of what happens after you click this, or is it showing the current state?
- ihateolives 5y agoThat's my pet peeve as well. It should read "activate feature x" not just "feature x" and then change to "deactivate feature x".
- daemin 5y agoWorst one is when the button text changes. Does the new text represent the current state of the system, or does it represent the state which the system will be in when I press it?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bmitc 5y agoApple is terrible at this. How do you close all tabs in Safari on iOS? Press and hold the tabs button. God forbid there was a button when viewing tabs.
- esalman 5y agoI want to throw in Tesla too. The minimal, buttonless dash is as dumb as the Windows 11 UI.
- anigbrowl 5y agoYes. Years and years ago there was a funny chain email called 'if you car was an operating system' about how different operating systems would make a simple trip to the store unnecessarily difficult. The Mac entry was 'You get in your car to drive to the store, but it takes you to church instead.' I've had an antipathy to Apple gear over this since the very first tech job where I worked with Mac SEs, because when they'd crash they'd display this amusing bomb graphic and an utterly unhelpful numeric code. There was no way to explain what had gone wrong to the person using the machine (who had just lost a pile of work) and more often than not the more experienced people in the support department would just shrug and reinstall the operating system. This Fisher-Price toy mentality now pervades personal computing and is making problem solving itself obsolete. Many people just don't have the patience or inclination to figure something out when they could just reset it.
- sschueller 5y agoYes, most profitable company in the world. People copy all including the really bad ideas. Just see how car makers have copied stuff out of the Tesla that is really bad like touch screen only controls. Some are thankfully going back to tactile switches as they realized the safety concerns.
- grishka 5y agoI'm not sure. Yes, latest macOS versions do have their share of misguided decisions, but at least most of the time it still feels like it's built by people knowing what they're doing and what their users need. It feels like there's some sort of contention going on between those who want shitloads of whitespace and other attributes of "UI like an art piece", and those who want their users to have great, empowering, and easy to use tools.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Can we blame this on Apple? We can always blame everything on Apple. Quite a lot of the time, we'll even be right.
- queuebert 5y agoOr an eccentric billionaire to fund SerenityOS.
- userbinator 5y agoThere is interest in getting WINE to run on it: https://github.com/SerenityOS/serenity/issues/6410 https://github.com/SerenityOS/serenity/issues/6410 Compatibility is definitely the one big thing SerenityOS is missing. A nontrivial effort for sure, but if it can run Linux and Windows binaries, you are going to see much more adoption.
- simondotau 5y agoBut then you've basically just made ReactOS again?
- norvvryo 5y agoReactOS is a kernel-level implementation of Windows NT. Serenity is a Unix-like.
- simondotau 5y agoFor the kind of people who read Hacker News, this does sound like a significant distinction. For everyone else it's a mere implementation detail.
- quacked 5y agoOld UIs were like woodshops, with brightly-colored tools stored in a series of labelled tool chests. Everything got reorganized once every other year, which was annoying but understandable. New UIs are like shoe stores, with off-white shoes stored in unlabelled off-white shoeboxes. Everything is shuffled around randomly once per quarter, which is exhausting and not understandable. Why did this happen?
- ncann 5y ago> Why did this happen? UI/UX people need to make their mark to justify their salary, that's why.
- fendy3002 5y agoUhh I don't know if UX takes part here. The new design really ignore ux. I guess it must be UI & marketing people.
- numpad0 5y agoMy guess is marketing roles just pays a whole lot better than anything in the society today thanks to extreme focus onto the Web. It is plain stupid to seek career in actual hard engineering when just consuming alcohol and socializing in suits lands you mid six figures. People often criticized that we are spending finest of a generation into extracting clicks just few years ago but it's not even that.
- CRConrad 5y ago"UX" is mostly just the new "sexy" term for UI. Look how many UI designers there used to be; now they're (almost) all "UX designers".
- warning26 5y agoTo be fair, classic Windows had its share of poor UI choices. Remember those days of a system tray with 25 icons in it?
- warning26 5y ago> Monitors are bigger than ever with huge resolutions, and yet UIs are being dumbed down to uselessness and alienating an increasing number of users. > I wonder how much damage they will inflict before people start turning to WINE and a saner Linux distro, just to run their Windows applications. The issue is, operating systems aren't something you have a whole lot of choice in; you use whatever OS goes with the software/hardware that you need to run. (It's like that classic "I need you to understand that friends don't go around recommending operating systems to one another" meme). Sure, you could try setting up Linux+WINE, but that is a lot of effort for a few taskbar improvements. Even most power users wouldn't go that far.
- emkoemko 5y agothat,s what i did about a year ago, got sick of windows forcing updates that take forever, dealing with garbage being installed on my computer, advertising, spying etc. Now Linux UI/UX is way better then Windows depending on the desktop enviroment you choose, but it has other issues that i hope they will solve soon. Installing a printer on Windows... you have to go through so much crap to get it running but on Linux you just connect your printer to WIFI or to your pc and its ready to print. No idea why Windows makes it so hard. I was also surprised when i seen my wacom tablet just works without doing anything and its settings or in the settings panel, but GIMP UI/UX is horrid that's what you get when programmers try to do UX/UI
- Arainach 5y ago> It's almost like some tiny extremist faction has gained control of Windows This has been the case for a while. I worked on the Windows Desktop Experience Team from Win7-Win10. Starting around Win8, the designers had full control, and most crucially essentially none of the designers use Windows. I spent far too many years of my career sitting in conference rooms explaining to the newest designer (because they seem to rotate every 6-18 months) with a shiny Macbook why various ideas had been tried and failed in usability studies because our users want X, Y, and Z. Sometimes, the "well, if you really want this it will take N dev-years" approach got avoided things for a while, but just as often we were explicitly overruled. I fought passionately against things like the all-white title bars that made it impossible to tell active and inactive windows apart (was that Win10 or Win8? Either way user feedback was so strong that that got reverted in the very next update), the Edge title bar having no empty space on top so if your window hung off the right side and you opened too many tabs you could not move it, and so on. Others on my team fought battles against removing the Start button in Win8, trying to get section labels added to the Win8 Start Screen so it was obvious that you could scroll between them, and so on. In the end, the designers get what they want, the engineers who say "yes we can do that" get promoted, and those of us who argued most strongly for the users burnt out, retired, or left the team. I probably still know a number of people on that team, I consider them friends and smart people, but after trying out Win11 in a VM I really have an urge to sit down with some of them and ask what the heck happened. For now, this is the first consumer Windows release since ME that I haven't switched to right at release, and until they give me back my side taskbar I'm not switching.
- GuB-42 5y ago> Starting around Win8, the designers had full control, and most crucially essentially none of the designers use Windows. What happened to the culture of "dogfooding" that supposedly was a big thing at Microsoft, and often pointed as a contributing factor to its success?
- idiocrat 5y agoCan somebody forward this feedback to Mr. Bill Gates? Not sure if he cares that his legacy goes down the corporate drain, becoming a failure.
- throw_m239339 5y agoOr some "UX consultants" need to justify their high salaries and some managers want a promotion by giving the illusion of novelty to their superior. There is absolutely nothing wrong with Win10 taskbar and MSFT didn't learn a damn thing from Windows METRO fiasco. Explorer and file browsers on the other hand are in a dire need for change. For instance, I wish I could easily tag my files, no matter where they are. I shouldn't have to remember where I put this or that file in my hard drive. File search on Windows is still terrible.
- gigel82 5y ago> It's almost like some tiny extremist faction has gained control of Windows Specifically, this faction's name is WebXT. They're the one responsible for adding all the ads, the forced Edge adoption, etc. And they're doing it with no oversight because there no longer is any one person in charge of Windows any more, it's a pissing contest and whoever's running that team wins because they can show short-term profits (no one seems to worry about the long term effects of burning all the good-will away), such short-sightedness...
- Stratoscope 5y agoAnd it's not just Windows proper, but also things like PowerToys. In every version of Windows since at least 2.0, Alt+Space has worked to bring up the system menu for the current window. This is the same menu you get if you click the app icon in the top left corner. Once in a while, this has been a lifesaver for me when a window gets stuck offscreen with my multiple monitor configuration. It is a bit tricky, but even if you can't see the window, you can press Alt+Space to open the system menu, then M to select the Move menu item, then press any arrow key, and finally you can use the mouse to move the window around. Yes, quite kludgy, but this has worked on every version of Windows for decades. The PowerToys team decided to take over Alt+Space for their own Mac-style launcher, without even warning you at install time that they are disabling a fundamental Windows keyboard shortcut. This caused me loss of data when I tried to use that trick for a window that got stuck offscreen. I forgot that I'd installed PowerToys a while back, and Alt+Space didn't work to rescue my window! There have been multiple threads and GitHub issues raised on this, but the PowerToys team has seemed deaf to the problem. They closed one of the issues with a comment like "our metrics show that very few people use Alt+Space for its old purpose, so we felt OK about reassigning it." I was like, "Your m-----f---ing metrics told you that? Your metrics just caused me loss of data! Do I need to go get Raymond Chen to explain to you the value of backward compatibility?" But I didn't post that, as there is no hope of getting through to people who think metrics should tell them what to do. Let's say there are a billion Windows users. And only a tenth of one percent know about Alt+Space to open the system menu. No big deal, that's only a million users you have just inconvenienced or caused to lose data. Please forgive the rant, but I just don't understand that line of thinking.
- CrendKing 5y agoReminds me how Mozilla removes various things from Firefox such as [Compact density](https://www.pcmag.com/news/firefox-redesign-will-see-compact-density-option-disappear https://www.pcmag.com/news/firefox-redesign-will-see-compact...) because their telemetry tells them nobody uses them. And oh boy the backlash from the community...
- tablespoon 5y ago> Reminds me how Mozilla removes various things from Firefox...because their telemetry tells them nobody uses them Got I hate telemetry. I usually (and I imagine many people) turn it off because I don't like my stuff phoning back to the mothership, but then some brainless moron mindlessly uses their "data" for decision-making, and rips out good features. This is especially dumb for Mozilla. Who do they think still uses Firefox? The people who want some dumbed down minimalist lookalike? Their overall browser market-share isn't too much more than Samsung Internet, and probably the only reason anyone still uses it anymore is that it's not as dumbed down as Chrome. Maybe they should just run with being the browser for power users, with all kinds of interesting niche features and customization. Honestly, UX telemetery probably should be banned for everything except error reporting. Nothing good seems to come of it. If you want to know what people do with your stuff, just try to empathize and maybe have some focus groups.
- antris 5y agoSure, for power users and people who have used the same UI for over a decade, the changes do not seem to make any sense. But that's why there's options to re-enable legacy UI, as seen in TFA. I suggest you give a laptop to a normal person who doesn't spend time on the computer and see how they use it. Give them a task that doesn't involve using the browser. I'm pretty sure you'll be surprised how easily they get lost in the UIs. These "minimalist" UIs actually do have a use for people who struggle with basic usage of their OS outside the browser.
- Ysraes 5y agoJust give me the Windows XP UI
- Ostrogodsky 5y agoIt is the Zeitgeist. "We know what it is better for you, peasant, we will create this cozy, little garden and you will never leave it, and if you complain you will be expelled, like Adam and Eve", or like the Xbox guy said recently "If you are banned from one online service you should be automatically banned from all of them"
- Zardoz84 5y agoThe Windows 10/11 debacle... I only use Windows 10 to play Fornite. And only because Epic don't release Fornite & Epic Launcher for Linux. Nearly every game that I play, ran native on Linux or just ran fine over Wine/Proton. If I can, I would NEVER touch the dumpster fire that is Windows 11. A sane GNU/Linux distro with Plasma/KDE, have a user experience that it's far superior to Windows. It's simply works out of the box, don't spam you, and don't spy you. And offer a familiar UI where the user can customize it totally.
- GeekyBear 5y ago> The strange trend of "authoritarian minimalism" design that seems to be working its way through the majority of newer software is very strange. A lesson that Microsoft could stand to relearn was from Windows XP, where the new grating Fischer Price UI was easily turned off to return to the sane defaults of Windows 2000.
- filipsch 5y ago> Monitors are bigger than ever with huge resolutions, and yet UIs are being dumbed down to uselessness and alienating an increasing number of users. Looking at the screen resolution data of visitors to the web apps I’m working on, I’m still surprised by how many people are on 1024x768 screens and even smaller (often more than 50%). Don’t forget there’s a big crowd of people on small and cheap laptops in the developing world. New OSes should also serve this group.
- yiyus 5y agoTrue. But the reason W11 UI is a horrible mess is not precisely to make the experience better for people with low res laptops.
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>I’m still surprised by how many people are on 1024x768 screens and even smaller (often more than 50%) I was also surprised when you said that, but after a few seconds of thought outside of my tech bubble where everyone has 4K/retina screens, I remembered that my parents, and my GF and her parents, all still use their 10+ year old PCs/laptops with low-res screens, so now I am not surprised anymore.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Don’t forget there’s a big crowd of people on small and cheap laptops in the developing world. In the developed world too, I'd think. It's not like Grandma -- or the kids / grandkids buying her a Christmas present -- are going to splurge more than a few hundred bucks on a laptop for her to Facebook with.
- m463 5y agoYour words remind me this is happening everywhere. Relentless focus on minimalism but they don't know where to stop. Apple is doing it. So is Tesla. Their cars have fewer and fewer dedicated controls, removing control stalks and putting critical functions on a touchscreen (for petes sake).
- jasfi 5y agoIt looks like Mac OS's dock, which is IMHO the best way to present a taskbar. Good to see this in Linux distros as well, such as Elementary OS (which looks a bit ugly, but is getting there). Minimalism is about getting out of people's way. Many extras are never used by most people and shouldn't be visible, or they are annoying. If you want those extras there should be options to enable them or make them visible. Maybe even specialized software. But don't force every obscure feature onto my desktop!
- rcarmo 5y agoYes, but on macOS the Dock can still be put to the side of the screen, it supports drag and drop and right-clicking, etc. Windows 11 broke most of that, which is the most common complaints I have (and hear). Windows’ SnapAssist is _amazing_, and I miss it on the Mac, but I am not happy with what was done to the taskbar. (I use both OSes and Linux, so I am OK with change, just not losing flexibility)
- mariusmg 5y ago>Minimalism is about getting out of people's way. Nothing says minimalism as shoving a 80 pixels dock in people's face. :)) Here is current taskbar https://i.imgur.com/GkAfOMx.png https://i.imgur.com/GkAfOMx.png , this is minimalist.
- nikanj 5y agoIt's always every other release. Then the next one is a massive 180, because all the power users (including server admins, software developers, etc people who actually might affect MS market share) absolutely loathed that release. We have seen this happen with Vista and Windows 8, and it will happen again with whatever comes after Windows 11. Microsoft does eventually listen to the users, but unfortunately only after it's too late for release N. I still can't explain how things are able to get that bad, before the correction happens
- jmnicolas 5y agoI have loved Vista. The difference with all the people that hated it is that I waited about 1.5 years after release before installing it. It ran flawlessly on my PC and to this day I have no bad word to say about it. I'm pretty sure Windows 11 will be mostly OK next year. What's the rush? It's not like Windows 10 is broken. If it wasn't for telemetry I'd still be on Windows now.
- PostThisTooFast 5y ago
- coldtea 5y ago>I wonder who actually wants this stuff The same people who want the authoritarian minimalism buildings: their designers, who get to satisfy the design fashion, and show off to each other.
- yread 5y agoIt's the same thing with hardware, just look at laptops. Apple from 2005 would think we have gone too far. No dedicated volume controls, all keys must look exactly the same and keyboards of exactly rectangular shape, no touchpad buttons, no leds to indicate battery status, the fucking power button that looks like a normal key and sits between other keys. At least the webcam shutters are coming back
- PostThisTooFast 5y ago
- bserge 5y ago
- nsonha 5y agoI don't think this is minimalism though, this seems somewhat informed by "a picture is worth a thousand words" (hence an icon suffices). Let's not kid ourselves, designer just need to justify getting paid. A programmer suggesting a "refactoring" of the whole codebase is often frowned upon (yet happens). On the design side it feels like the opposite, if a designer doesn't come up with some sort of overhaul every year, they, or their boss will feel insecure or something.
- bitlevel 5y ago>before people start turning to WINE and a saner Linux distro, just to run their Windows applications I jumped to Linux when Windows 11 was announced. I tried it (W11) in a VM and it convinced me that things are only going to get worse. Must say that I couldn't be happier for the move. I still get to run the vast majority of software via WINE (Affinity products need to up their game though) to boot. Games are much better supported nowadays as well, so it's all good, and no Windows 11.
- seumars 5y agoNot sure I follow. What's the relation between monitor size and UI?
- mrjin 5y agoIf I remember correctly, Chrome started this minimalism sh*t. It was kinda make sense as most people like me only had one single 17" CRT with 1027x768 resolution by that time and thus the screen estate was quite limited. But not things have changed a lot. Most people now have one or more 24" LCD with 1920x1080 resolution at least. For myself, I have two 27" 4K ones. So screen estate is no longer a problem any more but such ridiculous trends are not going away but getting worse and worse. Hamburg menu becomes everywhere and the tabs are most likely with huge icons/ribbons but still no place for menus, even there is more than enough space. So the result is that even though there is sufficient space, uses likely still need to click at least one time more to do what we could easily do in the past. Making it worse, such BS is not only limited to software but also expanded to hardware designs. Bought a TV recently, in general I'm happy with the image quality etc., but the remote drove me nuts: it removed video source button along with whole bunch of other buttons. Now I have to press at least 5 times to get to the video source... and such disaster is called optimization... And you were right, I'm on the verge to ditch Windows but unfortunately, there are something cannot run on Linux yet...
- bigbizisverywyz 5y ago>Monitors are bigger than ever with huge resolutions, and yet UIs are being dumbed down to >uselessness and alienating an increasing number of users. This! so much this! Never have we had so much screen real estate, yet UI designers seem to want to compress the actioanable items into as small a space as possible, with the stated goal of providing as much 'content' space as possible. The result is swathes of pointless unused whitespace, or overly large fonts to fill up the space if anybody uses the app maximized. Currently on Chrome, the tabs occupy what was once the Title bar (why ??!), same on Office apps where the save and search functions take space on the Title bar. Please, I'm an MDI guy, I hardly ever maximize application, and since the monitor(s) is so large, I like to have an easy to click Title bar to select my focus app, or to move the window somewhere. I've been doing this since the GEM days, and that's how I like it!
- daemin 5y agoI would guess that the designers have nice clean desks as well, so all that whitespace is giving the illusion of cleanliness. I also imagine that those designers would maximise a window where there would only be a single page in the middle of the screen and whitespace all around. Looks "nice" from a minimalist standpoint but a complete waste of space otherwise.
- croon 5y agoI actually have an issue with my Windows 11 right now where I have 7 (seven!) keyboard layouts to choose from, but according to windows settings only one language installed, with one keyboard layout. It's gotten so bad that what they're enumerating in these mobile menus aren't the same source the system is using. It's extremely annoying. Edit: If anyone is curious about this specific issue, I solved it by adding the languages and layout Windows thought I had, just so I then could explicitly remove them again, which seems to have solved this issue... for now at least. Edit 2: Don't get me started on the new context menu where you have to click "more" to get the rest of the options that applications can add. Edit 3: Oh, and there's no setting for not grouping taskbar items, or always showing all systray items, in Windows 11.
- blt 5y agoAndroid 12 had the most bizarre UI changes. They made everything so big and spaced-out, it induced scrolling everywhere. Most infuriatingly, the default pull-down menu (with wifi, flashlight, airplane mode, etc.) became tall enough to crowd out the music player controls and induce scrolling. Who wants to scroll on such a constantly accessed part of the UI? And all in service of spacing out the button text by an absurd 10mm. I can't imagine any justification for this other than some blind adherence to a design ideology over user testing.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Most infuriatingly, the default pull-down menu (with wifi, flashlight, airplane mode, etc.) became tall enough to crowd out the music player controls and induce scrolling. On many (most? all?) Android phones, you can move the icons in that menu around. (Press-and-hold, then drag, IIRC.) Takes a while to find out which ones you use and which you don't, but once you do you can then move the former before the latter.
- Shadonototra 5y agoit's not "authoritarian minimalism" it is laziness from microsoft