24 ms·
Bitcoin consumed 134 TWh in total during 2021
- Proven 5y ago
- diego 5y ago
- hddherman 5y agoWouldn't it be better to instead store that surplus energy using methods like this one? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricit... The value of Bitcoin is purely speculative and varies wildly, at least with stored energy you always have a market that's willing to buy it from you.
- diego 5y agoBetter for whom? The upfront investment is much higher. If the market buys energy from you, they give you money. You can turn bitcoin into money instantly without having to store energy. You don't care about the value of bitcoin fluctuating, you care about the instant profitability of mining vs storing the energy.
- notahacker 5y agoSure, we get the arguments why people prefer Bitcoin mining to other possible uses for energy. We just don't see it as remotely plausible that this leads to a net increase in renewable energy available for things which are not Bitcoin mining (especially since Bitcoin demand for energy which costs less than expected block rewards is inexhaustible by design and gravitates towards the cheapest power source). Difficult enough to find real world examples of places whose existing power demand became more economic to convert to renewable sources as a direct result of cryptomining, never mind to assume the scale of these ventures plausibly exceeds the amount of fossil fuels burned to mine Bitcoin or provide power for other activities which needed to find additional power as a result of Bitcoin mining.
- hddherman 5y agoFrom my limited experience as an observer of the cryptocurrency world, my impression is that mining hardware usually has a certain time period after which it starts paying itself off (6-18 months range). You can probably turn it into money relatively quickly assuming that there's enough real money coming into the system, but the cost of the hardware and the fact that all this custom silicon and electrical components present in the ASIC-based mining hardware results in additional cost, especially the environmental kind of cost that has to be taken into account. Those ASIC-s aren't much good for anything else once they've been made obsolete by generational improvements.
- theli0nheart 5y agoNot the OP, but my assumption is that most miners sell the Bitcoin they mine into fiat currency as quickly as they can.
- Scarblac 5y agoAs long as we have by far not enough green energy, any new energy use adds to the amount of fossil fuel burned.
- mutedpossibly 5y agoI'd say it is an extremely factual position to say those things.
- flipbrad 5y agoI can explain my own downvote, if you like: the article is calling for reform of Bitcoing to make it more sustainable. You're pretending it's calling for bitcoin to be abolished - i.e a total strawman. You're also downplaying the enormity of the statement made by the post - including that Bitcoin has singlehandedly negated any climate gains we're making by electrifying cars. That's appalling, given the extremely low social or economic utility of Bitcoin at the moment.
- diego 5y agoI didn't see an article. I saw a tweet with statistics. I had to look for the article, it's further down past a few hidden tweets. I appreciate your written explanation, I'm not a fan of the "downvote as disagreement" mechanism.
- esarbe 5y agoIt's not about the point you are making or that people are disagreeing. It's you misrepresenting the point of the article that's the problem.
- paulgb 5y agoThe cost of mining equipment makes it only economical to mine bitcoin if you can run the hardware 24/7, at least until the difficulty rate levels off. We can talk about hypotheticals or small mining operations, but the reality is that the big miners (Riot Blockchain, Marathon Digital Assets) are using coal and natural gas and are putting out hashrate that blow the “green” miners (dubious anyway) out of the water.
- YZF 5y agoTurns electricity into heat is more like it. Destroy our planet for speculation(tm)
- Havoc 5y agoUsing EV savings as benchmark strikes me as rather hilarious. Like what does the author think those run on?
- dtech 5y agoThe comparison is the CO2 saved from transitioning from fossil fuel vehicles to EVs
- adventured 5y agoThe world's biggest EV market is China. 60% of their grid runs on coal. It would be interesting if there's any climate savings from what they're doing with EV vs ICE given their infrastructure. I'm doubtful it's much if anything.
- Hamuko 5y agoChina's urban population is like 61% at the moment. Considering that EVs are more efficient in urban environments since they don't actually need to spend much energy when idling, I imagine that it's still more efficient to burn fossil fuels centrally for electricity than everyone in their own car.
- sktrdie 5y agoWith a climate crisis the last thing we needed was to make the most effective energy consumption system ever constructed. The whole thing literally works on competing on consuming more energy. No other system works so efficiently towards such goal. What's scary is that the whole thing was designed to be unstoppable. My utopian hope for the future is that we start sending rigs in orbit close to the sun. Since we only need to send a few bytes back to earth this becomes the only competitive way of doing mining. Space travel thus becomes dirt cheap. Humans are finally able to explore the solar system. But that's just a dream. Realistically, we are screwed.
- AlexCoventry 5y ago> start sending rigs in orbit close to the sun The 16-minute round-trip delay would wipe out any energy benefits, for bitcoin. Maybe you could come up with a consensus mechanism which allows people to somehow amortize recent calculations, though.
- ur-whale 5y ago> Maybe you could come up with a consensus mechanism which allows people to somehow amortize recent calculations Isn't that exactly what pooled mining is all about?
- belltaco 5y ago> start sending rigs in orbit close to the sun Does heat dissipate well in vacuum? Won't having it so close to the sun result in more heat? I guess the only way to dissipate so much heat would be via radiation. Outer space seems to be really really cold so that might help.
- aaomidi 5y agoDark body radiation is slow as shit and generally were gonna need a huge surface area to dissipate energy. The mechanics of heat sinking in space is amazing and terrifying.
- metalliqaz 5y ago
- hrhrhrhrhr 5y agoGold mining consumes 240.61 TWh per year, which is comparable to the electrical energy consumed by a country like Australia. Source: https://globalenergyprize.org/en/2021/11/24/the-bitcoin-gold-rush-the-new-threat-to-world-energy/ https://globalenergyprize.org/en/2021/11/24/the-bitcoin-gold...
- grzm 5y agoGold as a material has many uses, not only to back currency. Comparison to bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies is not particularly useful.
- hrhrhrhrhr 5y agoMost of mined Gold is used as an investment vehicle or to make jewelry. Source: https://www.statista.com/statistics/299609/gold-demand-by-industry-sector-share/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/299609/gold-demand-by-in...
- samwillis 5y agoBut that 46% used for “investment” can still be used for something tangible at a later date and so has something other than speculation setting it’s price. Frankly I was pleasantly surprised it was only 46% used for investment.
- vmception 5y agothere are multiple generations of people at this point who don't draw the line of utility at “tangible” now that population has irrevocable possession as well, which still doesnt exist for digital tradable goods outside of this system, and all those people can use their digital property for multiple things too even if it only does any one of those multiple thing moderately well, instead of anything exceedingly well, thats still value. it relies on cognitive negligence to make a separate higher standard for this, that could not apply to any asset under supply and demand pressure.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- moonbug 5y ago
- pcdoodle 5y ago
- mwattsun 5y agoThe counter argument is that Bitcoin is a battery [1] so that if you live in a place like Iceland with plentiful energy, so much that even exporting it as aluminum leaves extra, then you can turn it into Bitcoin and export it that way. But most Bitcoin mining is not that. I feel like Joni Mitchell in the Big Yellow Taxi: "They paved paradise and put up a parking lot" [2] Why are we allowing this to happen? (Well, at least outside China) [1] https://www.nickgrossman.xyz/2021/bitcoin-as-battery/ https://www.nickgrossman.xyz/2021/bitcoin-as-battery/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94bdMSCdw20 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94bdMSCdw20
- jallen_dot_dev 5y agoExcept it’s not really like a battery because you can’t get the energy back out. The energy ultimately turned into resistive heat and was lost. It’s more like something you manufacture using energy, which is most (all?) things.
- RobertoG 5y agoIf you use energy to process aluminium at the end you have aluminium. If you use energy to move bits in a computer at the end you have heat and the result of a calculation. If that calculation was just to proof that you did the calculation, well, that doesn't sound very efficient to me but that's just my opinion. What I'm pretty sure is that it's not a battery.
- landemva 5y agoThere is a physical and energy cost to assay gold. Same for btc.
- teraflop 5y agoThe "Bitcoin as battery" analogy fails for at least two significant reasons, IMO: 1. If you spend energy to produce, say, charged batteries or aluminum or biodiesel, that allows you to do something useful with those resources without needing corresponding energy consumption later. When you spend energy to mine Bitcoin, there's no way to use it to decrease your future energy needs; you can only use it to pay others and induce them to produce something you want, spending even more energy in the process. 2. With most energy production methods, you can get at least a bit of extra efficiency by scaling up. But the Bitcoin economy in aggregate can't produce coins at a higher rate; the best you can do is compete for a larger slice of the fixed pie. So even though each individual miner is incentivized to spend more and more energy, the economies of scale are negative.
- hsavit1 5y agoWe are rapidly depleting our remaining carbon budget. Can a bitcoiner please explain to me why this is a necessary technological development right now?
- HKH2 5y agoBecause banks can get away with shutting down accounts for political reasons.
- johndevor 5y agoIt's not "necessary" - it just is.
- hotpotamus 5y agoWe all know the answer is greed.
- epolanski 5y ago"technological development". Don't we already have plenty of more efficient coins out there?
- thathndude 5y agoI’ve never understood the BTC purists. I’m generally anti-crypto in any variety, but As far as cryptocurrency‘s go, bitcoin is really bad compared to so many alternatives. I’d just as soon see it all go up in smoke. But why does BTC reign?
- bidirectional 5y agoThis is what I find strangest. At least coins like Ethereum and Solana have entire ecosystems of complex projects being built up around them (no matter how skeptical one may be of those projects), Bitcoin seems like an incredibly spartan ecosystem with basically one use, and the sole advantage of being first.
- 5y ago
- robomartin 5y agoI had an interesting conversation with a friend a few days ago. We both installed larger solar systems than we need. We are net exporters of energy. And we are both disgusted by how the energy company takes this energy and, effectively, pays us nothing for it while charging our neighbors who use it full rate. One of the ideas that was floated in the conversation was to setup a Bitcoin (or some other crypto) mining system that would be design to only operate on excess energy. In other words, we become export nothing or very little energy and consume the excess mining crypto. The idea, of course, is to make more money with that energy than what the power company pays us for it. I haven't done the math. I have no clue if this is fantasy or reality. My instincts tell me it would be an exercise in futility, which is why I won't waste any time on it. I could be wrong.
- Nbox9 5y agoIf you’re trying to ‘do the math’ one thing you might consider is that any excess heat from the rig can be recycled in the house.
- lordnacho 5y agoEven if you only use excess energy for your own personal mining, the only way it has any value is if the rest of the network is running and mining. In the end, whether you're disconnected or not, there's one market connecting everything and if incentives decide it, business (in general) and here electricity specifically will flow across whatever boundaries you've set.
- qqqwerty 5y agoIt would take decades just to recoup the equipment costs. It currently takes about 12-18 months to recoup the equipment costs ignoring electricity costs This assumes running the miners 24/7. If you only run your equipment a few hours a day in the summer months when your excess solar power is most abundant, then a decade feels about right.
- wdroz 5y agoThis also assume eth1-like profits after eth2.0 this summer.
- pcdoodle 5y agoNaturally the market will move this heat to where it's needed. The world needs bitcoin.
- moonchrome 5y agoI'm usually a market proponent but bitcoin is a clear example of a market pathology. It also clearly illustrates that government/regulators are incapable of acting quickly and efficiently, especially with interest groups involved, it's been over a year where it's plainly obvious that allowing institutional investments in BTC is a terrible idea.
- it_does_follow 5y agoIn my darker moments I've come to believe that accelerationism is the only viable pathway to save the planet, since nothing short of civilizational collapse seems to be capable of seriously reducing our carbon emissions. From that perspective this is great news!
- cryptica 5y agoI've also been hoping for the same thing. The faster the current system falls apart, the less painful it will be. The years of daily grind combined with a feeling of hopelessness is what hurts people the most and causes lasting resentment.
- esarbe 5y agoThe problem is that with the current system falling apart that will be it for modern human civilization. I wouldn't be surprised if the technological level fell back a few hundred years. Our civilization is too interdependent with no place being able to sustain any level of advanced technology on itself. We traded all the resilience we had for "efficiency". Our current system is very brittle and if it fails, it fails globally. Expect hundreds of millions to die if it does.
- cryptica 5y agoI disagree with this. IMO, it's just propaganda that the elites use to maintain control. Look at all the economic 'miracles' in Germany, Japan, South Korea, ... Pretty much any time a developed, highly educated country had fallen, it managed to return to even more prosperous levels than before.
- hootbootscoot 5y agoI have issue with the massive cost in other peoples lives you seem to be ok throwing away with such pronouncements. We have to FIX our system, not make it worse. The reality of trying to force our entire civilization to commit mass suicide is a slow horrible intensification of all that is wrong with the world. Please do your part to spread the word to your fellow nihilists. (by definition, not my opinion nor an insult)
- saint_angels 5y agowould be cool to see research about total energy cost of traditional financial systems, that bitcoin is trying to replace
- esarbe 5y agoIt will almost certainly be less than bitcoin. What bitcoin is trying to fix is decentralized trust and uses Proof-of-Work for that. So, you're wasting energy to solve some cryptographic puzzle to proof that you did some work. Traditional banking does not need that, it uses social networks to establish trust.
- hootbootscoot 5y agoexcept that bitcoin doesn't replace any traditional financial systems. in the real world, crypto holders also have banks and buy and sell cryptocurrencies with/for fiat. very few retailers of any quality/price/repute sell physical for bitcoin, let alone denominated in fixed prices in bitcoin, even at peak hysterical hype (right now) apples priced in bitcoin would fluctuate wildly and you wouldn't be able to count on being able to eat any given day of the week buying food denominated in bitcoin. the reality is that bitcoin is an unregulated security. It's a volatile investment and it's fluctuations make 'fiat' currencies inflation/deflation pale in comparison.
- Nextgrid 5y agoThe only way to beat Bitcoin or other proof-of-work cryptocurrencies is to remove the need for them. Bitcoin and other cryptos have a use-case; it may not be apparent to someone living in a developed country with access to a good banking system or it may be one you don't like and involves criminal activity, but there absolutely is a use-case. The only way to stop this is if the traditional banking system catches up and covers all these use-cases, including undesirable ones. As the war on drugs proves, prohibition is expensive and doesn't work even for a physical asset, let alone something completely virtual that just needs software and a network connection.
- unicornmama 5y agoCare to share your evidence for the first paragraph?
- slickrick216 5y agoThe best evidence is the price surely.
- tgv 5y agoThe fact that people trade in it isn't enough evidence?
- hocuspocus 5y agoThere's none. It's mind boggling that 12 years later, people like the parent poster are still claiming bullshit like that when there's literally zero evidence, rather the opposite. No country with underdeveloped banking and payment systems is interested in something like Bitcoin. They need something cheap and efficient, federated and... centralized! Many African countries are perfectly fine using M-Pesa.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoThere are a lot of countries where people need anything but centralised money. Because they have every reason not to trust the ones who would run the central authority. It's hard for some first-world country citizens to imagine that.
- gime_tree_fiddy 5y agoA slightly tangential question, in regards to Bitcoin and Blockchain, that I (surprisingly?) haven't seen answered/asked: Blockchain is computationally intensive, but why does it has to be used for Bitcoin. There could be another solution, which achieves all its objectives, but isn't necessarily as convoluted. What am I missing? Why not just use SQL databases?
- NickM 5y agoThere are absolutely other solutions. The problem is they don’t allow existing participants to extract as much money out of newcomers as PoW, so the artificial hype being generated around alternatives is much lower.
- razemio 5y agoTell me one solution that would make blockchain technology obsolete. I would bet there is none even close because other solutions will require trust to some degree or have rather big security concerns but I am always open to learn new things. If we are talking about blockchain tech PoS is a possible (not perfect) solution to replace PoW but this is even more hyped then PoW in my opinion.
- jstx1 5y agoSQL databases work well when all parties already agree with each other. With a distributed public "database" like blockchain you need a mechanism to prevent fraudulent transactions from being written to the database. That's how you end up with solutions like proof of work and proof of stake.
- ur-whale 5y ago> Why not just use SQL databases? How would a centralized SQL database have prevented the USG from cutting funding to Wikileaks?
- anchpop 5y agoThat’s actually a good question and most bitcoin people don’t know the answer. Bitcoin actually does solve a real technical problem but it’s kind of subtle. The problem is that an SQL database isn’t distributed and trustless, but bitcoin wanted to be. But how does bitcoin accomplish this? Bitcoin is backed by a blockchain, which is like a linked list of blocks. (Each block containing a list of transactions.) By looking at the history of the chain, you can learn the current balance of every wallet. Anyone can add a block to the chain, and because bitcoin is distributed it’s possible for two people to add blocks at the same time. When this happens, the chain forks, and there needs to be a way to decide which fork is the “true” one. That’s because the chains associated with each branch of the fork will have different wallet balances, and it’s no good if there’s uncertainty about what your balance is. In practice one of the two branches is picked randomly, but there’s an attack where someone spends bitcoin to buy something irl, then forks the chain at a point before they bought that thing. If the attacker’s fork were picked as the “true” one, the seller would find the bitcoin they received has disappeared. All the computational work of bitcoin to mitigate this problem. Whatever way of deciding which fork is the true one must have one very important property: “the current true chain is always the descendent of a previous true chain”. But anyone can join the bitcoin network at any time, and when they do they need some way of knowing what the previous “true chain” was. You can’t just ask, because the person you ask might lie to you, so you need a way to tell which branch is “true“ just by looking at them. Bitcoin solves this by introducing “proof of work”. To add a block, you need to do some computational work, and the true chain is the one with the most computational work behind it. That means that as long as more than half of the computing power in the bitcoin network is honest (always adding their computational work to the “true” chain), the chain with the most work behind it will be the true one. Bitcoin goes further and rewards people who add blocks. This incentivizes people to add blocks (and therefore, computational work) to the longest chain they can find. The goal of doing that is to increase the chances that more than half the chain is trustworthy.
- svara 5y agoPoW mining (at least), must be made illegal. I have no doubts that it will end by becoming illegal, the question is how and when. It boggles the mind that there is now essentially a worldwide tax on semiconductors, which is used to do... nothing of any value whatsoever. And this thing just keeps growing. The effects will be felt in more and more economic sectors. Something will have to give. So, the only question is: Will we be smart enough to ban it soon and avert the worst consequences, or will this thing blow up in a huge way and we ban it afterwards.
- superkuh 5y agoYes. Nationstates very much want to make the proven distributed mechanisms of consensus that allows people to exchange value without their oversite illegal. No significant cryptocurrency has gone proof of stake, and certainly none just starting out. Etherium will never actually switch. Making proof of work illegal would make effective cryptocurrency illegal. The violent standing armies (and their logistics networks) that protect other international currencies from manipulation and attack use far more energy and do it in very violent, centralized ways.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoWhat else would you make illegal? High fidelity 3d graphics in gaming? It is clearly wasteful and games are hardly any better because of high polygon count, right?
- 5y ago
- exeldapp 5y agoI don't doubt the number, but it does make me genuinely curious. How does this compare to other software? How much energy does running, for example, Facebook require? How much extra energy is required if you use a language like Ruby, PHP, Python, etc. versus a language like C? It will be interesting to see how energy consumption will be a part of software in the future. I wonder if we will see something like "green" programming languages.
- belltaco 5y agoI feel this is the wrong comparison. PoW intentionally raises the difficulty by making computer do more "work" finding useless hashes as the price of crypto goes up. The "work" isn't used for processing transactions, which is why the number of transactions per second is stuck at a pitiful 7 transactions per second for BTC, and 15 for ETH. Programming languages don't have a mechanism where Ruby, PHP or Python have features to intentionally burn more CPU cycles in order to accomplish their objective of making programming easier.
- hetspookjee 5y agoI agree that the raising of difficulty is problematic. But is it not that running arbitrary javascript in advertisements, and the ever growing scale of said javascript chunked in, is also growing ever more? You state indeed that it's a mere 7 transactions per second, yet I'm settling transactions over 2nd layer networks like Lightning and Liquid. Javascript advertisements bring me nothing but distraction and a settled state of mind. I find this a far bigger harm than commodotizing international transactions, how slow they might be.
- hocuspocus 5y agoI'm gonna skip the obvious whataboutism of your argument, but your 2nd layer networks have just re-invented centralization of federated and trusted peers, congrats. International settlements aren't a technological problem. SWIFT has been commoditizing international transactions for many decades. When there's still friction, it exists by design. International transfers are pretty fast and cheap between countries that agree on the same rules and regulations regarding capital flows. Sure you can use Bitcoin to avoid these regulations. But most people and businesses aren't actually interested in illegal ways to move money.
- superkuh 5y agoHow much energy did the standing army for the dollar and it's logistics network consume during 2021? Much, much, much, more. And yet the energy expenditure to defend the Bitcoin network from attacks both succeeded using far less and the energy was used completely non-violently. Bitcoin's efficiency and morality stands head and shoulders above nation state based mechanisms for defending the integrity of their currencies. And no, bitcoin doesn't depend on one single country. If, say, China made it illegal (hmm!) it'd still keep working. So no, a nation state going down does not actually kill bitcoin but it would kill that nation's currency. We'll see how well the Ukrainian hryvnia holds up this spring.
- belltaco 5y ago>How much energy did the standing army for the dollar and it's logistics network consume during 2021? Much, much, much, more. The standing army defends a lot more than the USD. If BTC was adopted as currency, the size and cost of the standing army would barely change.
- bcherny 5y agoNot an expert, but Proof-of-stake (what Etherium 2.0 does) solves this, right? Now Bitcoin needs to find a path to implement it. https://blog.ethereum.org/2021/05/18/country-power-no-more/ https://blog.ethereum.org/2021/05/18/country-power-no-more/
- jallen_dot_dev 5y agoYes for Ethereum but Bitcoin will never adopt it, for ideological reasons. The community is extremely resistant to big changes like this. It took what should have been a small and uncontroversial change (where to store the witness data for transactions in a block) years of vicious debate and led to competing forks.
- walkhour 5y agoPrediction markets estimate at around 15% the chance that Bitcoin will adopt PoS. If you think this will never happen you can make money at https://www.metaculus.com/questions/7109/bitcoin-consensus-mechanism-by-2035/ https://www.metaculus.com/questions/7109/bitcoin-consensus-m....
- jallen_dot_dev 5y agoHmm, how does this work exactly? Is my money locked up for 13 years while we wait for the result? That seems like a poor return on investment. Do I have to trust this website will still be around 13 years from now?
- londons_explore 5y agoIt's worth remembering that these figures are calculated based on the efficiency of known bitcoin miners. However, I believe it is likely that a good chunk of bitcoin mining is done on privately designed, owned, and run machines which are likely to be substantially more efficient. Since the main cost of bitcoin mining is electricity, anyone who can design a more efficient miner has an incentive to keep that design to themselves.
- epolanski 5y agoI actually think the very opposite, that massive amounts are mined with very old and inefficient hardware, while those calculations seem to always over represent more modern and efficient miners.
- spenrose 5y agoThe world used about (12,000 Mtoe = ) 140,000 TWh [1], making this 0.1% of world consumption. OP claims 64 MtCO2e of associated GHG emissions, which is also about 0.1%. I'd call these figures under "troubling but not yet material to the climate." [1] https://www.iea.org/reports/key-world-energy-statistics-2020/final-consumption https://www.iea.org/reports/key-world-energy-statistics-2020...
- tgv 5y agoCO2 concentrations are a bit like traffic jams: a small increase can lead to catastrophic consequences.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 5y ago> making this 0.1% of world consumption I believe that your info makes it sound even worse than the headline if you take into account how few people use cryptocurrencies vs. the amount of people worldwide using electricity directly or indirectly.
- lostmsu 5y agoDo you believe less than 1/1000 of people used cryptocurrency?
- alkonaut 5y agoThat’s an absolutely terrifying amount.
- cryptica 5y agoI like cryptocurrencies but this high electricity usage has kept me away from Bitcoin in the early days. I've since come to forgive Bitcoin for this ridiculous energy usage because of how important a problem Bitcoin is solving (the world desperately needs provably scarce, deflationary hard money). It's just unfortunate that people chose to focus on Bitcoin and not some other PoS crypto which uses less electricity... Unfortunately, now there are all sorts of false narratives around how PoW is more secure than PoS and the Bitcoin tribe will not accept any argument which says otherwise, no matter how logical. I think we are stuck with Bitcoin for now. It's unstoppable. The delusion is too strong. But on the plus side, it will likely solve major economic problems once it reaches mass adoption.
- hihihihi1234 5y agoWhy does the world need deflationary money?
- lfdz 5y ago
- Gwypaas 5y agoTo make the early ones in win.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cryptica 5y agoSo that the richest people don't have unlimited money. Compounding returns yield unlimited money for those at the top. The real economy does not experience compound growth like the economy of numbers does. Those at the top of the pyramid have unlimited money due to compounding returns facilitated by infinite money printing. So long as the real economy treats those unrealistic numbers as if they represent real economic value, everyone else is enslaved to those at the top.
- selfhifive 5y agoBitcoin and Data centers are two major global warming behemoths no one talks about. It's about time it became an issue.
- Hamuko 5y agoAt least data centers aren't designed to burn as much electricity as possible. Amazon is even giving me like a 20% discount to switch my services to run on the more energy-efficient ARM machines.
- tsywke44 5y ago? data centers are a net negative for carbon emissions. 1. no need to drive to a bank/govt office/business when it has been digitized 2. watching a video on youtube, netflix or tiktok is basically carbon emission free compared to other forms of enterntainment that would be consumed if the internet wasn’t available 3. emails instead of paper snail mail, billions of trees saved since the 90s The list goes on and on
- shagie 5y agoPeople are working at making data centers more energy efficient rather than less. https://www.energy.gov/eere/femp/energy-efficiency-data-centers https://www.energy.gov/eere/femp/energy-efficiency-data-cent... https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/opinions/green-data-centers-the-key-to-energy-efficiency-in-a-digital-world/ https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/opinions/green-data-ce... From the later article: > What we do know is this: if the latest efficiency improvements in data center hardware and infrastructure continues apace, it should be possible to accommodate a 60 percent increase in demand for both traditional and hyperscale data center services over the next 12 months, without an accompanying increase in the energy they consume. But in order to achieve this feat, it is imperative that data center operators follow energy-efficient design principles. https://www.comsoc.org/publications/tcn/2019-nov/energy-efficiency-data-centers https://www.comsoc.org/publications/tcn/2019-nov/energy-effi... > The report by the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory has an encouraging conclusion. It states that improved energy is almost canceling out growing capacity. In 2014, data centers in the United States consumed 70 billion kilowatt hours. If energy efficiency levels remained as they were in 2010, the energy consumption by data centers today would be 160 billion kilowatt hours. The surprising reality is that the estimate for 2020 is only 73 billion kilowatt hours. --- Data center power consumption is a big topic, and a lot of people are talking about it and working on improving its energy efficiency.
- whoisninja 5y agonow do cloth dryers
- ur-whale 5y ago> now do cloth dryers Christmas lights FTW
- hetspookjee 5y agoJust copying another comment abotu the energy consumption of online adverising "The online advertising ecosystem resides in the core of the Internet, and it is the sole source of funding for many online services. Therefore, it is an essential factor in the analysis of the Internet's energy footprint. As a result, in 2016, online advertising consumed 20–282 TWh of energy. In the same year, the total infrastructure consumption ranged from 791 to 1334 TWh. With extrapolated 2016 input factor values without uncertainties, online advertising consumed 106 TWh of energy and the infrastructure 1059 TWh. With the emission factor of 0.5656 kg CO2e/kWh, we calculated the carbon emissions of online advertising, and found it produces 60 Mt CO2e (between 12 and 159 Mt of CO2e when considering uncertainty). The share of fraudulent online advertising traffic was 13.87 Mt of CO2e emissions (between 2.65 and 36.78 Mt of CO2e when considering uncertainty)." The paper was: "Environmental impact assessment of online advertising" https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0195925517303505 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S019592551... It was the one of the five papers included in the authors PhD thesis, "Towards Sustainable Data Centers and ICT Services" https://aaltodoc.aalto.fi/bitstream/handle/123456789/38725/isbn9789526086125.pdf https://aaltodoc.aalto.fi/bitstream/handle/123456789/38725/i...
- kibwen 5y agoGiven the context I can only assume that this is intended to be a defence of the energy consumption of mining, but even so it's the most tone-deaf defense I can imagine. Excusez mon français, but gently caress the online advertising industry, and gently caress proof of work cryptocurrencies. Scourges of the modern world, the both of them.
- seibelj 5y agoYes but if we start playing the “which energy use is more valid” game then quickly we realize energy is in the eye of the beholder, and the solution is a pollution tax. Bitcoin shouldn’t be outlawed anymore than video games (a totally useless tech from a society viewpoint) but HNers love their video games and Google paychecks.
- landemva 5y ago
- FabHK 5y agoFor comparison: Worldwide Total final energy consumption is around 82,000 TWh/a, or 10 MWh/a per person (a bit more than 1 kW on average per person). So, Bitcoin consumes more than 13 million people, or 0.16% of world energy consumption (total final energy, not only electricity - it's a higher share of electricity consumption). Edit to add: Put yet another way, one BTC transaction burns as much energy as a person needs per month. Can't wait for the utopia where BTC is universally adopted!
- lfdz 5y ago
- boramalper 5y agoMy personal opinion is that whilst Bitcoin is not the answer, many seem to miss the point of cryptocurrencies, which IMHO is, to enable a permissionless electronic cash system. Being decentralized is an important aspect of it, and TPS and time-to-finality etc are important metrics for any practical use, but the appeal of cryptocurrencies is that you don't need the permission of others to open an account nor have to pay premiums to send or receive money. It is also truly global so there is no difference whatsoever between splitting a bill in a restaurant or sending remittances to your family back home. I guess many people live their lives on the "happy path"[0] thus never really experience how difficult the simplest tasks can get. In the country I have emigrated to, to open a current account you need a proof of (permanent) address, and to be able to rent a flat, you need a bank account to pay the deposit---a Catch 22 that I was able to break only thanks to TransferWise and Revolut. Another example is cash being deprecated for convenience and hygiene reasons, yet banks being just as difficult to give a POS terminal to self-employed and small businesses (hence the emergence of Stripe Terminal and Square) yet alone marginalized groups such as sex workers. Neobanks and fintechs really make life easier for many, but they are still not as free as cryptocurrencies aspire to be, and to be fair, cryptocurrencies are not there yet either... I am looking forward to the day I can spend my stablecoins as easily as using my Visa/MasterCard. Hence, in the end, it may not matter as much whether some chains are more centralized than others or if stable coins are backed by the assets of some central custodians. Bitcoin is far from providing that, I think, but let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_path https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_path
- WheatM 5y ago
- cipheredStones 5y agoGenerally, if your system can handle the vast majority of cases easily and most edge cases with some effort, you don't think about tearing it down to replace it with an entirely new one that's far less efficient and far more difficult for the end user. The appeal of cryptocurrencies for most buyers is that Bitcoin dectupled in a year and people seem to be getting fabulously rich off of them everywhere you look. No more and no less.
- lowkeyokay 5y agoI’ve been told mining for Bitcoin is almost done, and therefore the energy needed for Bitcoin will drop. Is that true?
- hootbootscoot 5y agoenergy usage is RISING with increased difficulty of proof-of-work, as intended.
- tromp 5y agoNo, within a few decades transaction fees will exceed block subsidy and provide an ongoing incentive for mining.
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoIf Bitcoin mining ends, then it's because Bitcoin ended too. The block reward is lessening, yes. But miners also get the fees from the transactions in the block they mined, which incentivizes them to keep mining (mining is also what secures the whole thing). I'd speculate that energy usage will go down somewhat in the future, but not significantly.
- thatwasunusual 5y agoThis exactly the amount of renewable energy produced in Norway each year. Source: https://www.regjeringen.no/en/topics/energy/renewable-energy/renewable-energy-production-in-norway/id2343462/ https://www.regjeringen.no/en/topics/energy/renewable-energy...
- me551ah 5y agoIt’s crazy how all of this energy is used to repeatedly calculate sha256 and 99.9999% of those generated hashes are discarded.
- gimme_treefiddy 5y agoSlightly tangential question: Couldn't Bitcoin be implemented on something other Blockchain, since Blockchain is so computationally intensive. Like why not use a SQL database instead. It's definitely not technically infeasible, and you can reliably achieve all objectives of Bitcoin by doing so. The idea of independent financial system is great, but the inefficiency of it's usage is something I am very doubtful about.
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoWell, if it wasn't a blockchain, it would be a lot easier to rewrite history and give myself millions of bitcoins.
- Cycl0ps 5y agoThe blockchain model is designed to be immutable, a block of transactions are locked in place by the blocks before and after it. A traditional database structure wouldn't have that form of baked-in security, though I'm sure there are other models that could work.
- gimme_treefiddy 5y agoYou, that’s the word I was looking for. There are solutions out there which achieve similar objective. It’s like they the benefits of blockchain are being used for bitcoin, but if you designed one with bitcoin in mind, there is efficient solution there.
- alkonaut 5y agoYou could use a centralized blockchain to ensure immutability but there is then a central trusted party such as a central bank. This seems to me like the “proper” way of managing digital currency, but obviously those that like Bitcoin see the independce and decentralization as a feature.
- imtringued 5y agoA decentralized application requires you to download all of its data so that you can verify it yourself. An SQL database on top of a blockchain doesn't really change anything except make data storage less efficient.
- formvoltron 5y ago
- xqcgrek2 5y agoInvest in utilities. XLU and VPU are two decent ETFs.
- pengwing 5y agoTo put this into a context, we must look at the problems faced throughout human history: Major conflicts for resources, starting with a small tribe vs tribe conflict, going up to a full world war. A globally distributed permission-less system is a great step to decouple force and resource acquisition. The majority of the world energy consumption could be spent on it while still yielding a net positive.
- akagusu 5y agoWe often are told to save on energy consumption because of climate crisis but 134 TWh was used for Bitcoin. What is Bitcoin useful for? I use energy to cook, to get a shower, to work, to watch TV, and a lot of other things. But Bitcoin is used for financial speculation, get rich schemes, and all sort of scams. And I am told to save energy otherwise I am a contributor to climate change, but Bitcoin scumbags can use whatever energy they want to cheat people and take their money. This is what people call civilization. A good f#cking civilization.
- paulus_magnus2 5y ago134TWh would power 36.22 mln EV cars for 20.000km each (at 18.5 kWh/100km).
- bluecalm 5y agoAt 10c/kWh which is cheaper than anywhere in US it's the cost of 13.4B USD. Miners get the electricity cheaper than that but still, that's a crazy amount.
- captainmuon 5y agoI like to think of bitcoin as solving the sybil problem via proof of work. Because if you just gave every "account" coins, then somebody could just make multiple "accounts" and get more than they are entitled to. (I know bitcoin doesn't have "accounts" but bear with me.) By it's very nature it is wasteful. Question: Has anybody tried to replace proof of work with social proof? Let every participant create their own fiat or scrip out of thin air. The different kind of scrips are not fungible with each other. Often scrip would be used like a voucher. You acquire it on the market and then return it to its emitter for goods and services. I can imagine digital companies or successful streamers to have their own scrip, but also local and national governments, or banks. If Joe normal emits their own scrip, well then it is at first worthless. Same as if you make your own shitcoin. BUT the twist here would be that you can endow other scrip with your scrip's value. If you are a celebrity with a lot of value, you can put a little bit of your coins in the coins of, say, an environmentalist project you want to support. Suddenly their printed money can buy things they need. In a way, it is the anti-bitcoin. Bitcoins are hard to generate, and the algorithm is strict with no room for negotiation. If somebody has a lot of coin but the majority doesn't like what they are doing with it, tough luck. Social scrip would be trivial to generate, and it's value is due to the services I provide to others, or the value transferred by others to my scrip, so a part of it is permanently up to negotiation. Probably it is a crazy idea. I'm still thinking about how to make the "imbueing" work exactly while keeping the value stable (the current idea is some kind of page-rank algorithm). I'm also not sure how to incentivize people to keep the ledger running if there is no mining. But maybe somebody is already further along with this idea.
- rojeee 5y agoNot a crazy idea! I think this is the only decentralised system that can work long term. I’ve spent a long time thinking about it. Figuring out how to manage reputation is key, which you allude to with your comment about needing a page rank type algorithm.
- captainmuon 5y agoFor reputation + value, I was hoping to piggyback on external exchanges. Your coin is just worth what people are willing to trade for it. If you mint more coins, you have to sell them for something real, or they are not worth anything. The hard part is the reputation transfer (or voting, or embuing). If you have 30 A coins and B puts 10% "juice" in them, does this mean you can use them like 3 B coins? Or can you convert them somehow? What happens when C puts "juice" in B? Or A puts "juice" in C? The potentially recusive nature reminded me a lot of Pagerank, but basically you will end up with coins that are a mixture of different coins, and you have to find an algorithm that converges. I also think the economics are going to be really funny because suddenly price does not depend just on supply and demand, but your coins are going to be better or worse for certain purposes depending on how the emitters vote. (They are basically giving out vouchers to a bit of their surplus depending on what you buy.)
- RivieraKid 5y agoDon't forget that Bitcoin doesn't only consume electricity, but also hardware. I wonder what's the electricity / hardware cost breakdown.
- anotherevan 5y agoFYI: 134TW / 1.21GW = 110,743 missed time travel opportunities.
- jsiaajdsdaa 5y agoWith a decentralized electricity grid, this problem vanishes, as supply becomes correctly priced.
- natas 5y agoThat's little compared to how much is burnt by the traditional financial system, including corporations, employees, etc.
- ab_testing 5y agoThis sounds like a really huge number and it is. However when you compare it to the total world energy consumption, it is less than 0.1%. Looking at this data set [1], the total energy consumption in the world was around 160,000 Thw. https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption
- nswest23 5y ago> the next time you read that Bitcoin consumes as much electricity as Sweden substitute Bitcoin spends as much on electricity as Americans spend on Halloween costumes. https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/11/bitcoin-and-electricity.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/11/bi...