9 ms·
Locked-out New Zealanders outraged as visa scheme for rich foreigners resumes
- throwaway788 5y agoThe last allocation of MIQ slots had 800+ rooms that were not taken. Anyone who urgently needed to return had the ability to secure a room in December. When Omicron appeared and it hadn’t been detected within the community in NZ it was obvious the NZ government would make changes to delay its introduction by moving to tighten MIQ settings and delaying any removal of quarantine restrictions. https://www.miq.govt.nz/about/news/miqs-12th-voucher-release-838-rooms-not-taken-16-dec-2021/ https://www.miq.govt.nz/about/news/miqs-12th-voucher-release...
- vanusa 5y agoAnyone who urgently needed to return had the ability to secure a room in December. I don't see how this is relevant. Moving forward, citizens and migrant workers will still be forced to get in line behind wealthy investors.
- smackeyacky 5y agoAmazing isn't it. We found out who exactly essential workers were (food service, transport, medical, teachers) and also how the rules imposed on all of us were remarkably selective based on wealth. I guess we knew it, but to have it demonstrated in such stark terms has been breathtaking.
- pmontra 5y agoI'm not a NZ citizen, nor resident nor I have interest in getting there except maybe as a tourist someday. Anyway if I would apply for entry to NZ or any other country I'd expect that all citizens jump the line in front of me, then everyone paying millions, then everybody else.
- Taniwha 5y agoAnd that would be true today as NZ is not currently allowing anyone without citizenship or a residency visa in at all (with some minor exemption for touring sports teams and the performing arts)
- throwaway788 5y agoWhen it comes to MIQ allocation they aren’t put ahead of anyone - everyone who has the ability to enter NZ has the same chance and ability to obtain MIQ slots.
- vanusa 5y agoI should have chosen my words better. The point is, given that there is limited capacity for MIQ slots -- some citizens will inevitably be bounced by pay-for-visa holders who are also in line.
- bener 5y agoCitizens are not in line behind wealthy investors, they don't need visas.
- postingawayonhn 5y agoAll of the January and February rooms were taken. There were some rooms left for the remaining two weeks in December (likely too shot notice for many people) and March (the quarantine system was meant to mostly end by then).
- sh4un 5y agoIt's funny because most countries have cautioned people not to leave right now and people just go anyways. No one is shedding tears when you are stuck because you couldn't wait for your budget vacation.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoIt's not always vacation. Many people have close family abroad that they want you see. Sometimes with medical issues so they may not get another chance. I wouldn't travel if vacation was the only reason. Especially if I were living in NZ which is one of the most beautiful places on earth IMO It's also kinda unfair to expect people to have seen Omikron coming :) with the distance to Europe most people from here in NZ only visit family once a year and often go for months. Suddenly returning would have been difficult and costly. I'm surprised the fairly left-wing current NZ government is prioritising investors like this though.
- newnamenewface 5y ago> It's also kinda unfair to expect people to have seen Omikron coming Perhaps, it's unfair that the government is obligating severe COVID restrictions on travel for citizens (and non-citizens, alike) in a country with 80+% vaccination rates for a disease that's essentially endemic at this point. NZ seems to be just pushing the problem down the line at this point. There will never be a time where they can just open without any cases so why are they still so incredibly restrictive? FWIW: I am not a NZer, I don't plan to visit NZ any time soon, and I'll admit I'm relatively unversed on the political situation in NZ.
- pempem 5y agoJust to add to your FWIW: covid is also not endemic. These regulations sound too restrictive but the attitude towards covid also seems kind of advanced of where we actually are, which is a disease that is mutating due to people traveling and artificial vaccine scarcity
- 5y ago
- Macha 5y agoSo what happens if you're a NZer who can not get a MIQ slot (which may have been more plentiful when you left), but your Visa in your current location is expiring?
- aunty_helen 5y agoYou have to plead with the country you're in. Or apply for one of the emergency slots the week you have to leave (pretty difficult at the moment given the flight schedules). Or yano, deportation / imprisonment... There's not many good solutions in this case and it is very difficult to match a reservation spot with an airline ticket out.
- chii 5y ago> deportation isn't this what you'd want? deported back to your country? It's not like you could be denied entry at the airport, and deported back to the foreign country...
- incompatible 5y agoMaybe they'd just leave you in prison until NZ is ready to take you back.
- rafale 5y agoDeportation usually comes with long lasting restrictions on travel to the country you are getting kicked from. Hopefully, USCIS/ICE will use their brains in situations like this.
- throaway46546 5y ago>Hopefully, USCIS/ICE will use their brains in situations like this. lol
- aunty_helen 5y agoWith deportation you're probably going to spend a few days in prision until they can sort you a flight out. Then as other commenters have mentioned, it's going to have some long lasting consequences. It will make a lot of the countries in the world require you to get a visa before entering (or even transiting), as in apply for a visa, spend 3-4 months dealing with embassies and spending a decent amount of money while you explain what happened and potentially be denied anyway.
- nimbius 5y agoI think the cat was out of the bag when kimdotcom was indicted. New Zealand is bought and paid for by the cloistered elite seemingly against any real argument by the locals. You could make an argument the work here/look see initiative that imported skilled labor was somehow a counter indication of a plutocracy but I think its largely just salt in the wound for the average NZ resident as it ran defense for anyone who pointed a finger at silicon valley for buying their island oasis. They could have spent that money on stem education locally but outright chose not to.
- selimthegrim 5y agoWhat’s the point of spending more on STEM education when the absurdly low salaries for tech and IT positions already have them going begging for workers?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gameswithgo 5y agoIncrease the supply
- roca 5y agoCounterpoint: Larry Page entered NZ in early 2021 and was placed in a middling MIQ hotel. His people tried to get him moved to one of the best hotels but were unable to do so. Page is the world's fifth richest person. I think this counts against "New Zealand is bought and paid for by the cloistered elite".
- parkingrift 5y ago>Immigration New Zealand (INZ) recently granted 32 visas to people who pledged to invest at least $10m locally over three years and another 76 visas to individuals pledging to invest at least $3m, according to the news website Stuff. > With their visas in hand, investors may apply to compete for spots in New Zealand’s congested MIQ system. A stay in MIQ is a prerequisite for entry to the country, which has been largely closed to non-quarantined international travel since March 2020 to protect against Covid-19. So… these people have pledged to invest huge sums of money into NZ and the end result is that they have to apply for the same MIQ spots as everyone else? Seems the outrage should be directed at this MIQ system. The visa scheme seems to be an enormous benefit to NZ.
- tuatoru 5y agoIn New Zealand we try to have something called the Rule of Law. The same laws and regulations apply to everyone regardless of wealth or political connection. The rule of law is the key innovation that allowed the industrial revolution to take place bringing the West to its present rich and free lifestyle. Adherence to the rule of law is a major reason why NZ is regularly in the top 5 countries globally for lack of corruption, transparency, and ease of doing business. Abandoning the rule of law leads eventually to autocracy. From this distance the US appears to be well down that road.
- cryptodan 5y agoThe visa programs should be halted until all citizens can equally compete. There is no fair competition here. The quarantined are being pissed on while wealthy players continue to live freely. Do you not understand that? Rules for thee but nit for me applies here.
- gaadd33 5y agoI don't fully know everything about the MIQ program but it seems like citizens can compete for spaces on an equal basis and this adds the visa applicants to the pool. So while it reduces their chances of being picked from 1 out of x to 1 out of (x + y) it seems like it's still fair? If the MIQ program is similar to some citizenship programs where you get points for things and this is giving them as many or more points than just having citizenship does, I would agree it's unfair.
- ilrwbwrkhv 5y agoIn almost all countries you can buy citizenship if you're rich. You don't even need to know the language. Immigration and all these gimmicks are for peasants only.
- vanusa 5y agoIn almost all countries you can buy citizenship if you're rich. This isn't about simply "buying citizenship". It's about literally bouncing people who are already citizens out (for the duration of the pandemic).
- passerby1 5y agoAlthough controversal, there's no clear way to resolve utilitarian way of seeing this: an investment is required, and sometimes the investment can be good for society by improving a country economy. For sure, the condition is paying taxes, and that is usually a partially satisfied only, as there're almost always a way to avoid tax. (Otherwise what's the reason for a rich one to invest into country at all?)
- andrekandre 5y ago> Otherwise what's the reason for a rich one to invest into country at all? what are they all investing in?
- bener 5y agoIt's not. It gives rich people more chance at getting a visa. People who are already citizens don't need a visa.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- roca 5y ago"Bounced out"? No citizens are being forced to leave the country. These new visa holders just make it a little bit harder for citizens and residents to enter the country, that's all. Over 200,000 people have gone through MIQ during the pandemic --- that's a lot for a population of 5M. People who wanted to come back since the start of the pandemic have been able to come back.
- jordansmithnz 5y agoNew Zealander here. My wife and I just made it through the MIQ system in time to see our families for Christmas (and introduce our son to his grandparents for the first time). A few interesting things: - we had to enter the MIQ lottery five times before ‘winning’ a spot. The lottery system is the same used by some shoe drops and ticket reservations, and there is no weighting given to citizens that have enrolled in previous lotteries. - when you make it through the lottery and select a date, it has to match the date you arrive in NZ exactly. If flights only go to NZ on certain dates, and those dates are all taken, then you’re out of luck. Many people make it through the lottery only to find that there are no dates left that work. - you are not told what MIQ hotel room or city you will be in until you arrive in NZ. At that point you may be flown across the country (adding and extra 5+ hours to the end of an international trip), and placed in who-knows-what hotel. You are charged a set fee for the hotel. - at every stage of your stay at MIQ, the people running the show have the ability to prolong your stay if they believe there is any COVID risk. The morning we were packing our bags to leave, the hotel called to say we needed to stay in our room while they waited on an urgent COVID test for a suspected positive case. Had the result actually been positive, most of the hotel (everyone from our flight) would have needed to stay additional days. - ‘famous’ people go through MIQ too. We met someone on the flight that plays the lead role in a popular TV series. Like everyone else, they were flown across the country and placed in a hotel room. - the hotel food is usually not great. We were fortunate enough to be in an Uber Eats delivery area, so we ordered out a few times. In regards to the linked article: the real problem, at least to me, is that New Zealand citizens with an urgent need to come home (visa, sick relative, funeral, etc) are not always able to do so. MIQ is an interesting experience, and at least at the start of COVID it made it possible for NZ preserve a pre-pandemic way of life. Now that we’re years into COVID and vaccines are readily available, it’s extremely frustrating for New Zealanders with family or loved ones overseas. Public opinion is steadily shifting towards ‘open up the country’, and the government has announced some tentative dates for doing this (although they were recently shifted back due to omicron).
- atweiden 5y ago> Now that we’re years into COVID and vaccines are readily available, it’s extremely frustrating for New Zealanders with family or loved ones overseas. Public opinion is steadily shifting towards ‘open up the country’, and the government has announced some tentative dates for doing this (although they were recently shifted back due to omicron). As someone who was in a Covid-free region of Australia all throughout the pandemic, I’ve seen first-hand what happens when borders are reopened. Local businesses are far less harmed from closed borders than they are from people avoiding clustering in indoor areas — either out of an abundance of caution for their health, or to avoid becoming a “close contact” of a Covid-19 case and then being forced into quarantine. Once borders reopen, associated mask mandates give everyone needless anxiety, while the hospital system beginning to buckle becomes a constant source of fear. Closed borders allowed Australia and New Zealand to perform better economically than more permissive countries, and allowed their residents to live life like it was still 2019. Permissive countries like America merely pretended to allow life to go on like it was 2019, while their conservative media exported tone deaf rationalizations for permissiveness to AU & NZ residents who were on average far better off than they were. The American media’s attempts at guilting antipodeans for closing themselves off to the world were laughed off as completely bizarre — most people were all too happy to allow the rest of the world to think they were doing it tough living their happy, blissful, Covid-free lives behind impenetrable borders. AU & NZ would probably have at least another year of normal life left to live if their governments had directed international arrivals to quarantine in dedicated facilities in remote locations rather than in retrofitted hotels smack dab in the center of major urban areas.
- jollybean 5y agoThis is mostly a problem with the bad rules around quarantining, which should not be a problem. It's 2021, are humans able to 'stay away from others' in spaces that are large and vast? Use some common sense and figure it out, there should be no material impedements here.
- bener 5y agoYou think people would voluntarily isolate from each other without any rules in place?
- jollybean 5y agoI don't think everyone would follow the rules, but I don't see that as a limitation to allowing people in. Frankly, being allowed back in your country is probably along the lines of 'human right' and there probably is not any condition in which the government could not allow it. There's plenty of ways to allow for isolation. NZ Climate is actually temperate, they could even have individual military tents with cots and plastic outhouses, while not exactly luxury, it could accommodate almost anyone, and most people esp. those under 35 wouldn't have a problem. They could even do a rapid build of low quality structures i.e. mini-huts, pre-fab style, put them in locations outside the city. Though a bit authoritarian, even ankle bracelets could be used in some case maybe for home quarantine. Commandeering motels and hotels and putting the Health Authorities right on premise. In Taiwan, when you arrive they don't want you on the public transit so they rent you a car. They arrive to your home 10 minutes after you do with masks and explain the deal. They check up on you every day sometimes in person, sometimes by phone. I suggest that most people will 'get the idea' when a government rep. is directly communicating to them, checking up, answering questions, letting them know the 'real boundaries' aka 'you can't go out for coffee', 'you can't have your family over etc.' There shouldn't be much of a wait for that kind of thing.
- dwohnitmok 5y ago> they could even have individual military tents with cots and plastic outhouses, while not exactly luxury, it could accommodate almost anyone, and most people esp. those under 35 wouldn't have a problem. > They could even do a rapid build of low quality structures i.e. mini-huts, pre-fab style, put them in locations outside the city. > Though a bit authoritarian, even ankle bracelets could be used in some case maybe for home quarantine. Though this might be in theory better (after all being allowed in at all is better than be stranded outside), this seems far worse of a PR nightmare. The headlines and accompanying pictures would be atrocious.
- Taniwha 5y agoIMHO this is largely a political storm in a teacup. There has been limited space in quarantine (MIQ) for returning residents over the past year, though this month there is space going free. A vocal group of people stuck overseas by this bottleneck have made a lot of noise about this (and fair enough too). And it's been amplified by the current government's political opposition, as I mentioned above it's not actually a real issue right now (omicron might change this). The small number of people being granted these residency visas won't get priority in MIQ they'll have to queue with everyone else. What we are seeing here is a small resumption of our normal immigration regime, we're also resuming taking in refugees
- silexia 5y agoThe solution is simple... Shut down the unnecessary MIQ system. Everyone has had the opportunity to get vaccinated and risks for those is now back to as low as it was prior to the pandemic.
- pixel_fcker 5y agoWhat about people who can’t take the vaccine for medical reasons, or are too young? Fuck ‘em right?
- CallMeJim 5y agoYes, exactly! The 90% can't live isolated forever because of the 0.2% who can't have vaccines for medical reasons. (The remainder is made up of those who've made anti-vaxx part of their identity). Put that money and resources into protecting the vulnerable, not into isolating New Zealand and severely impacting the economy in a vain attempt to keep a virus, which will be with us together, out. Human lives aren't infinitely valuable. As an example, there were 318 road deaths in New Zealand in 2020, which could all have been avoided by lowering the speed limit to 10kmh. This isn't a solution that would ever be considered seriously, because it's evident that the financial and flow-on social harm caused by such a rule would greatly outweigh the current death toll. It's becoming increasingly evident that 'protecting those who can't be vaccinated by stifling New Zealand in draconian restrictions' is the same.
- pixel_fcker 5y agoLol “draconian measures”. Yep we’re all under house arrest down here it’s awful. Basically the same as Stalin’s Russia.
- grandpoobah 5y agoAs far as I can tell, those who might normally be unable to take vaccines are being encouraged to do so with COVID. The old "we all need to get vaccinated so that those who can't are protected by herd immunity" thing doesn't seem to apply here. Example - https://www.health.govt.nz/news-media/media-releases/third-primary-dose-covid-19-vaccine-available-severely-immunocompromised https://www.health.govt.nz/news-media/media-releases/third-p...
- josephcsible 5y agoInvestor visas are just a distraction. The fundamental problem is that there's any restriction whatsoever on New Zealand's citizens entering their own country. The MIQ system should be abolished, and anyone who helped create it, or who has had enough power in the country to abolish it but chose to let it continue, should be put in prison for human rights violations (specifically, in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 13 says "Everyone has the right to [...] return to his country").
- refurb 5y agoYup. Even authoritarian Singapore didn’t restrict its citizens from returning. It imposed rules on testing and quarantine, but they were free to jump on the next flight home. Incredible seeing democracies like Australia and NZ tell their own citizens “no, you cant come home”.
- Aerroon 5y ago>Incredible seeing democracies like Australia and NZ tell their own citizens “no, you cant come home”. To be fair, it's not their first dance with authoritarian measures. Both countries also employ widespread censorship for movies and video games among other things. Perhaps it shouldn't be that unexpected that they would cross the line on this too.
- m4x 5y agoIf there's widespread censorship then I assume you can give some supporting examples? The only notable "movie" that I'm aware of being censored in NZ was the live stream of the Christchurch mosque shooting that killed 51 people.
- syntheticcorp 5y agoPostal 2 and manhunt are two fairly popular video games that were legally censored. Banned modern movies I am less familiar with, but there were many banned historically where the decision still stands today.
- laingc 5y agoAs a New Zealander, I am super supportive of easier pathways for wealthy people to bring themselves, their expertise, their connections, and their money here. Furthermore, my anecdotal observation is that articles in The Guardian about New Zealand reflect not reality, but rather the talking points of a very small subset of the hard Left of our political class. I know that this is The Guardian’s line in general, but it somehow feels more egregious when applied to a situation I’m more personally familiar with.
- blibble 5y ago> Furthermore, my anecdotal observation is that articles in The Guardian about New Zealand reflect not reality, but rather the talking points of a very small subset of the hard Left of our political class. their UK coverage is similar also they were previously reputable (if slightly biased), but post 2016 reputability seemed to cease to be a priority
- vanusa 5y agoAs a New Zealander, I am super supportive of easier pathways for wealthy people to bring themselves, their expertise, their connections, and their money here. Do you support denying re-entry to people who are already citizens as a means of doing that?
- pixel_fcker 5y agoThis isn’t what’s happening. Everyone trying to enter the country has to go through the MIQ system, regardless of whether they’re a citizen, have one of these visas, or any other type of visa.
- vanusa 5y agoThis isn’t what’s happening. I don't know how you can say that. It's the inevitable result of a system with finite capacity (once capacity is reached).
- 5y ago
- iandanforth 5y agoWouldn't it be simpler if you could just pay for N additional spots to be opened by your financing? If MIQ spots are limited due to finances and you can solve that problem that seems like a win-win. If there's an indirectness where the finances go somewhere else and the MIQ pie gets smaller for citizens at the same time, that's obviously going to cause outrage. This seems like one of those rare situations where more direct graft would be better.
- roca 5y agoIn practice MIQ capacity has been limited by the number of suitable hotels available, and the difficulty of staffing them. These resources are not very elastic.
- yardstick 5y agoTaiwan operates an effective home quarantine system (and 850 deaths for a 23m population). Why couldn’t NZ? There would be a lot more capacity that way.
- roca 5y agoI can't answer that in full because I don't know all the details, but one issues is that Taiwan captures phone location data in a way that has no precedent here.
- yardstick 5y agoI’m fairly sure anyone who wanted to abscond wouldn’t take their cellphone with them if that was the case. And yet the cases and deaths in Taiwan remain very very low for its population.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoIt was about to start next week but was postponed by omicron.
- starklevnertz 5y agoIt’s money that matters. All the poor people who have a problem with this scheme need to be realistic about how the world works and stop complaining. (Snark, to be clear).
- starklevnertz 5y agoWhat proof is required that the money is legally obtained? Or is it simply open money laundering for international criminals?
- vmception 5y agoTypically standard KYC/AML. Standard meaning that if it made it into a licensed institution that also does KYC/AML then its good enough for us! Basically the concept is that its up to the customer to get money magically graced and cleared by their host government, and if there is not currently a problem its not anyone’s problem. Think about it: what is legal? China says that people with their currency cant move more than an equivalent of $50k/year out. If someone only earns Yuan on mainland China but has enough liquid money elsewhere to invest in this program, is it your problem to care about China’s currency controls to suggest this money violated that? Well the same standard applies even if you were imagining terrorist financing and cartels. There is no adequate system to know or care.
- starklevnertz 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoNot necessarily but sure read whatever you want from that, the point of my post was actually that all AML/KYC is a waste of public sector and private sector resources. I’m not a New Zealander and I don't care about the local politics. Its still entertaining to me that any random government could say someone’s money is clean and its magically clean from that point on.
- anothernewdude 5y agoShould be arresting these rich foreigners as criminals and deporting them to Australia
- heax 5y agoThe proles should try eating cake if they are out of bread :)
- jimworm 5y agoEven the most expensive MIQ places are incredibly cheap to the average millionaire, NZ$5520 for 14 days for a single adult, which gets cheaper per person when sharing [1]. There are also huge outstanding bills (over NZ$13M) from people that have been through MIQ and haven't paid [2]. Some of the hotels in the MIQ list could be a lot better than others [3]. The solution is to make these investor visa categories pay a lot more - something like 10x - to fund the others who can't pay, but give them priority to the best rooms. [1] https://www.miq.govt.nz/being-in-managed-isolation/charges-for-managed-isolation/room-configurations-and-charges/charges-by-room-temporary-visa-holders/ https://www.miq.govt.nz/being-in-managed-isolation/charges-f... [2] https://www.miq.govt.nz/about/media-centre/common-topics-for-media-questions/fees-and-waivers/ https://www.miq.govt.nz/about/media-centre/common-topics-for... [3] https://www.miq.govt.nz/being-in-managed-isolation/isolation-facilities/facility-locations/ https://www.miq.govt.nz/being-in-managed-isolation/isolation...
- yardstick 5y agoIsn’t the real solution to disband MIQ? 90% eligible double vaccinated (95% eligible single dose). How long should MIQ exist for? Who should be responsible for paying MIQ dues? I disagree that the traveler should be responsible anymore due to the high vaccination levels. The NZ govt, if it wishes to continue denying kiwis freedom of movement to return home to NZ (or travel to other countries they are citizens of) should shoulder the burden. Or a tax on the eligible-but-unvaccinated… after all, the traveler is having to quarantine to “protect” others, not themselves.
- jimworm 5y agoIf they had put in these proposed charges from the start, it would protect the NZ government from the criticism they're facing. Ending MIQ is inevitable but it's a one-way decision. Once the virus takes hold there's no going back, even if you take quarantine and isolation to China levels. Nobody likes a lockdown. My opinion is that the right time is when the globally dominant variant is a fast-spreading one with a proven hospitalisation rate post-wave that is lower than what NZ could cope with, given the vaccination rate. Omicron could be a candidate but its wave is still spreading, so it's too early to tell. As for MIQ dues, the government and therefore the people bear its cost. NZ$13 million isn't a trivial sum, but it isn't huge either, so while any scheme to reduce the burden would be welcome, a plan with a huge potential cost such as ending MIQ is a bit too much risk, especially with Omicron data coming soon on the horizon.