20 ms·
20 year study of global wealth demolishes the myth of ‘trickle-down’
- refurb 5y agoPeople realize “trickle down” was just a made up political punching bag, right?
- esarbe 5y agoWhat do you mean? That 'Trickle Down' was a satirical term coined to disparagingly talk about supply-side economics? Sure, I know. That doesn't mean that there aren't more than enough people still clinging to supply-side economic theories as if their undeserved wealth depended on it. Because it does.
- refurb 5y agoSupply side is a valid economic theory. Give people more money and they spend it. You disagree? “Trickle down” was a Democratic ploy to disparage the policy of reducing tax rates. Apparently we are still talking about it despite the economic expansion of the 1980’s in contrast to the “malaise” of the 70’s.
- temp10298385 5y agoGiving people more money (i.e tie wages to increase in productivity) is demand side economics. Supply side economics is increasing the amount of available goods regardless of demand. The lagging wages are mitigated by credit, i.e. debt.
- refurb 5y agoYou’re taking the words to literally. “ Supply-side economics is a macroeconomic theory that postulates economic growth can be most effectively fostered by lowering taxes, decreasing regulation, and allowing free trade”
- esarbe 5y agoNo, you are being fallacious. There are many thousand ways of "giving people money". Supply-side economics prescribes exactly one way of "giving people money", that's by lowering taxes. You cannot claim that because supply-side economics supports one way of "giving" people money that every way of giving people money is supply-side economics. You see that, right?
- esarbe 5y ago> Supply side is a valid economic theory. I presume that actually think that this is the case and that you didn't just forget the /s. Supply-side economics has been thoroughly debunked, again and again[0]. Just look the current state of the US. > Give people more money and they spend it. It depends. It depends how much money they have, how much money they already have and what your definition of 'spending' is. Not every kind of 'spending' is of economic and social value. Give a billionaire a dollar and they'll forget it with the lint in their pocket, will get thrown out with the trousers and incinerated along with the trash. Give a billionaire a million dollars and they'll put it into NFT or crypto or something else of questionable social or economical value. It's only when you give a poor person some money that they will spend it in a 'useful' way that actually increases productivity. But "Give people more money and they spend it" not supply-side economics, actually, is it? In all actual actuality, supply-side economics is about lowering taxes, decreasing regulation, and allowing free trade, with a heavy emphasis on lowering taxes. You could say that it's primarily about lowering taxes, because 'decrease regulation' and 'promote free trade' is not exactly a supply-side original. SSE is about lowering taxes, primarily for the 'job creators'. That's what the Laffer curve is for. And only the beginning of the issues with supply-side economics ... > Apparently we are still talking about it despite the economic expansion of the 1980’s What good is economic expansion if no one but a very small and exclusive group of very exclusive and already very rich people profits said economic expansion? Do larger number make you happy? if so, here's a big number for you: 10↑10. If you are not more happy now, then you are in the same boat as most US workers since 1979. Just because there was economic expansion, it doesn't mean their lives got better. Worse, in fact. Wages stalled, living expenses increased, social support networks were cut and cut and cut again. Why exactly? Yes, exactly. Supply-side economics, or "voodoo economic policy", as George H. W. Bush famously described it. Presumably because it thrives on the corpses of exsanguinated workers. > a Democratic ploy [...] To my knowledge, one of the mayor reasons for the '70ies economic downturn was the "Nixon shock" where prices and wages were frozen and import taxed increased. It's named after Richard Nixon. He was a Republicant President[1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kansas_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kansas_experiment [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1973%E2%80%931975_recession https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1973%E2%80%931975_recession
- 5y ago
- codegrappler 5y agoI guess I’m not surprised that a bunch of folks who have made a career out of advising politicians on income inequality….discovered income inequality in their study. The two questions in my mind are: 1. Should we trust the government to spend the money more wisely than the folks who earned it? Or said another way, how do you combat the almost inevitable corruption you see with large government spending? 2. What will incentivize people to work at insane rates if the vast majority of their income and wealth is taxed? Would I be willing to put in the long hours and sacrifices usually required to work up to a $1m+ salary if it’s taxed at a 90% rate?
- burntbridge 5y agoYou seem incredibly naive. People who earn $1m+ salaries do not work long hours or make sacrifices. You will never be wealthy if this is what you think. Most CEOs that I've known are out the door well before everyone else.
- gadders 5y ago>> Most CEOs that I've known are out the door well before everyone else. But did that hold true for their whole career?
- foverzar 5y ago> People who earn $1m+ salaries do not work long hours or make sacrifices Do you have any evidence to support this claim? Especially the sacrifices part -- this seems like an awfully bold assertion, especially if you consider that most people earning millions have spent their entire careers to get there.
- aNoob7000 5y agoWe need less government and better taxation policy. I believe the inequality comes from the fact that individuals and companies with large sums of money can shape policies in government better than any individual or group of individuals. I agree you shouldn't pay 90% tax rate but you shouldn't be paying zero either.
- 5y ago
- q1w2 5y agoI haven't heard a politician advocate trickle-down since the Reagan era. This seems like one of those strawman political football arguments. Also, the methodology here is a bit flawed. I think that economic data that cherry picks the start of the covid-19 pandemic is deeply flawed. 2020 will always be known as an economic outlier. It's like selecting 2008, or September 2001. These are data points that should be eliminated from your data set - not highlighted in your conclusions. Seems like just another anti-billionaire political hit piece, frankly. No real substance. Also, a nitpick - the STUDY didn't take 20 years. The DATA was from a 20 year period. The title builds the study up to imply far more effort than was actually expended.
- esja 5y agoIt’s not a straw man at all. The Fed explicitly justifies QE and the rest of their monetary insanity on the basis of the “wealth effect”. They believe asset price rises will create a feeling of wealth which will generate additional spending. They know that these asset price prices disproportionately benefit a wealthy minority. This is trickle-down economics.
- Simon321 5y ago>The Fed explicitly justifies QE and the rest of their monetary insanity on the basis of the “wealth effect”. They do?? Do you have a source for this?
- esja 5y agoThey’ve said this publicly many, many times. It’s quite incredible that the Left have not made the connection between the Fed openly aiming to increase wealth inequality (which is what this is) while also keeping a watchful eye out for any wage inflation (which is the only way the common person can keep up). https://digitalcommons.trinity.edu/econ_faculty/31/ https://digitalcommons.trinity.edu/econ_faculty/31/ Search for Bernanke wealth effect or any variation you like. The BIS and other central banks talk about it openly as well. The central banks are the biggest engines of wealth inequality in the world, and it’s all done in the open with barely any pushback.
- romwell 5y agoAhh, the good old trickle-down, aka "piss in my eyes and tell me it's raining" (which is the only way trickle-down actually works). It was pure mythology from the start; there's never been any basis for it to begin with. It's a pity we even have to debunk it like that. Go figure, give a million hungry people $20 each, and see $20M return to the economy the next day as they spend it on food. Give a billionaire $20M, see the money go into the fintech machine and pour out into offshore accounts, as the billionaire holds on to whatever financial product they bought forever as long as it appreciates faster than inflation. Oh, and they'll spend $200 on a fancy dinner. Cue Pikachu face when the economy doesn't improve.
- refurb 5y agoLow quality post unworthy of HN.
- 271828182846 5y agoand your's is better, isn't it
- flooow 5y agoWhen someone makes a bad-faith argument, should one go to great lengths to refute it? Perhaps sometimes. Other times, it is better to dismiss it as nonsense and get on with one's day. "Trickle-down economics" is an extremely bad-faith argument, essentially boiling down to "rich people pay slightly less rich people to tell poor people it's better for The Economy if they stay poor". That it was ever given credence in the first place reflects very badly on the economics profession (or, as I would reframe it, shows that economics as a subject has been wholly captured by elites).
- refurb 5y agoTrickle down economics is a bad faith straw man argument against supply side economics. I see plenty of HN posts argue that “putting more money in the hands of low income individuals is good”, but suddenly that’s wrong because… Reagan?
- 5y ago
- gttalbot 5y agoWell, duh. If you can't even fund enforcement for investigating wealthy tax cheats, not only is there a wealth transfer from everyone else to the wealthy via unbalanced tax burdens, it's also an indication of how deeply captured by wealthy interests out government truly is.
- throw0101a 5y agoTrickle-down economics didn't start with Reagan. One reference to it from 1896: > There are two ideas of government. There are those who believe that if you just legislate to make the well-to-do prosperous, that their prosperity will leak through on those below. The Democratic idea has been that if you legislate to make the masses prosperous their prosperity will find its way up and through every class that rests upon it.[19] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics See also: > Mr. David Stockman has said that supply-side economics was merely a cover for the trickle-down approach to economic policy—what an older and less elegant generation called the horse-and-sparrow theory: 'If you feed the horse enough oats, some will pass through to the road for the sparrows.'[33] * Ibid.
- Digit-Al 5y agoThe article did not claim it started with Reagan. > In America, trickle-down was exemplified by President Ronald Reagan's tax slashes.
- tromp 5y ago> Indeed, the richest 10% of the world's population hold 76%, or two-thirds of all wealth. Math is hard:-(
- vixen99 5y agoBit of a giveaway to write ' demolished the myth of 'trickle-down'. I am not familiar with the authors apart from Thomas Pickety. However would one seriously expect any other conclusion from him? He and the other authors (if they inserted the word 'myth') had an agenda and naturally, produced a report validating it.This is not to say there are no serious issues with the 98% of wealth distribution. I should not use the latter word because it implies a zero sum game for wealth which is not the case. It's otherwise known as the Pie Fallacy of wealth. It's out there and greedy rich people have grabbed the lion's share. Many people still believe this.
- pydry 5y agoThomas Piketty's work is surprisingly banal. If you've ever heard anybody with money talk about "the magic of compounding" they're essentially saying the same thing he demonstrated with a huge pile of data, except on a personal, rather than societal level. It's controversial solely for the same reason global warming is - it threatens wealth.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- temp10298385 5y agoIt is interesting that you think that Piketty, who has studied growth extensively, has not considered the positive sum aspects of the economy. If you read his books you will see him talk about it in excruciating detail.
- yorwba 5y agoThe article makes a weird jump between pointing to global wealth inequality and claiming that this disproves trickle-down effects. But trickle-down doesn't claim that wealth differences between rich and poor should decrease! Rather, it's about absolute gains, where poor people get higher incomes the richer other people are. (I.e. increasing wealth inequality is good if it is the rich getting richer, instead of the poor getting poorer.) A disproof would be something like finding a lot of poor people who got poorer as everyone else around them got richer.
- chii 5y agoan excellent point. I think over all, people are much richer today than 2 decades ago - even those who are poor relative to the rich. Richness doesn't just include cash in hand, but the availability of goods and services. The fact that the internet is available (to be purchased) is a form of wealth, but this is often not counted.
- spencerflem 5y agoBut wages have stayed the same while housing, medicine, college, have gotten massively more expensive and & via inflation everything else is somewhat more expensive. I honestly find it absurd to suggest that we're somehow 'richer' while most young people have no hope of a stable life. Technology has made us much more productive but all that added value has been captured by the ultrarich
- yorwba 5y ago> wages have stayed the same while housing, medicine, college, have gotten massively more expensive and & via inflation everything else is somewhat more expensive Which country is this where inflation affects everything except wages? Are you sure you're not comparing inflation-adjusted wages (where it's not surprising if they stay mostly the same) to nominal prices affected by inflation? > I honestly find it absurd to suggest that we're somehow 'richer' while most young people have no hope of a stable life. If most young people had no hope of a stable life before and then everyone got richer, so that more young people can hope to have a stable life, it can still be the case that most young people have no hope of a stable life. The only way "most young people have no hope of a stable life" could contradict "we're somehow 'richer'" is if there was a time when most young people could hope to have a stable life, and then things got worse. When was that? > Technology has made us much more productive but all that added value has been captured by the ultrarich. When people communicate over long distances today not by sending a letter but by calling each other, they're benefiting from technology without the added value being captured by the ultrarich. (Unless you think their mere existence sucks all joy out of hearing your loved ones' voices.)
- Fricken 5y agoIn a watershed, rain falls and distributes water far and wide. It then trickles downward to where the water is most concentrated. This one is easy. If the monetary system was a watershed, the rich would be at the bottom. You can't dump a billion litres at the mouth of the Amazon and reasonably expect it to make its way to the rest of the rainforest.
- xondono 5y agoThat’s because you are looking at the money, but you can’t eat money, you can’t dress yourself with money, you can use money as shelter. You “pour money” at Amazon and lower prices come out the end. Note that I put “pour money” because no one has never suggested actually giving money, just taking less.
- netcan 5y agoIn college, I studied Ronald Coase's famous 1920s papers. The major application ATT was infrastructure stuff. Coase's argument was that "given 0 transaction costs," it doesn't matter who owns what property or right. The market will achieve efficient solutions as firms sell each other radio spectrum or whatnot. Policy should focus on minimizing transaction costs and let the market organize itself. Circa 2005, I heard a podcast with 90-something Ronald Coase. He has pissed. Everyone had been teaching his theorem backwards for decades, backed with the "chalkboard economics" he despised. What Coase actually meant is that (1) transaction costs tend to be high (2) this explains the clearly observable inefficiencies of such markets. Literally the opposite of what I was taught as "Coase Theorem." He meant that because market are imperfect, it really matters what the starting position is. Trickle down economics is the same kind of error. If we are extremely confident that markets work the way efficiency-assuming models do... Trickle down makes sense. It doesn't really matter where the money starts, the market will deal with allocation efficiently. If not it does matter where the money starts. In any case, the "wealth disparity" discussion is almost always badly anchored. The first thing to understand about wealth disparity is that it maps pretty much to wealth. More wealth, more wealth disparity... almost universally. Many or most people have no wealth, depending on your semantics of "wealth." Therefore, if the value/quantity of wealth rises, wealth disparity rises. The actual equality dichotomy is ROIs vs labour/income.
- user3939382 5y agoI've had The Nature of the Firm sitting on my bookshelf for 3-4 years. Maybe I should get around to reading it...
- netcan 5y agoIt's very readable.
- WastingMyTime89 5y ago> In any case, the "wealth disparity" discussion is almost always badly anchored. The first thing to understand about wealth disparity is that it maps pretty much to wealth. More wealth, more wealth disparity... almost universally. Many or most people have no wealth, depending on your semantics of "wealth." Therefore, if the value/quantity of wealth rises, wealth disparity rises. I agree with you but it remains a problematic point. The issue is the power imbalance it creates and outlines. Because in and of itself, wealth is of little interest. Economy is first and foremost the study of exchanges. If the wealthy stayed amongst themselves with their wealth parked peacefully and little interaction with the rest of the system, you could pretend they didn’t exist and from the point of view of the economy experienced by the majority of the people that would mostly be true. That’s mostly what’s happening actually which is why people don’t riot. It is both a blessing and a curse because as usual throughout history when an aristocracy arise, their main fear is that the general population realise they are not actually providing that much value and could be dispensed with. That’s why they use the power they own - the ability to put the system out of balance - to lobby in their favour, keep control of the political system and information apparatus in order to keep being able to extract value from the system. From my point of view, we are in situation which has a lot to do with the Old Regime. Aristocrats used to explain that they could not be dispensed with because they had superior value and were needed to administer and guide while exploiting the collective labours of the population. Modern large shareholders and executives explain that they can’t be dispensed with due to their superior ability to manage and impart a strategy while exploiting the collective labour of their employees tolling for meager wages.
- anothernewdude 5y agoRobespierre did nothing wrong.
- pepperonipizza 5y agoWhat the hell is this type of comment?! This is the same stupid phrase neo-nazi use to joke about the Holocaust. Thousands have been killed by the terror, even some of his allies turned against him because how bloody it was.
- yorwba 5y ago> Don't feed egregious comments by replying; flag them instead. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- wisty 5y ago"Trickle down" is a snarl word like "Cultural Marxism". Supposed advocates of it never call it that, and anyone talking about it is probably getting most of their information of it from other like-minded critics.
- naruvimama 5y agoSpeaking from a historical perspective. The East India company/ies pretty much won much of the world for Britain & Europe. Europe was neither wealthy nor technologically more advanced than India. But the Church with its christianising mission and doctrine of christian discovery allowed the pooling of resources. Concentration of wealth is important and the wealth did trickle down to other countries of Europe. A modern take within India is of Reliance which has made cheap telecom services accessible for much of the population. Or the TATAs who have created a local automobile ecosystem competitive based on vertical integration. Trickle down does happen in the long run as long as corruption is limited. Concentration or pooling of wealth is important especially for developing countries. Personally I do not care for inequality, and care more for dignity and wellbeing. The metric that matters most especially with developing countries is if their productivity has increased and if they have moved from low skilled to medium to high skilled job.
- tchalla 5y agoYou're basically saying - In a country of 100 people, concentration of wealth is great. Concentration like for every 100$, 5 people taking 95$ and the rest 95 taking the 5$ is fine. Your rationale seems to be the fact that the 95 people have more than 5$/95 than before. Now, you keep accelerating this and you'd notice a 99-to-1 ratio eventually. It's interesting that you call this dignity and well being. You're basically saying that the time spent by the 95 people is orders of magnitude less valuable than the time spent by the 5 people.
- naruvimama 5y agoThe value of time spent by the people is called productivity. We should be more concerned with the productivity. This is especially true with developing countries where people are mostly employed in backbreaking manual labor. Sometimes it is due to lack of skills and many a times due to lack of industry or ecosystem. Inequality is a great talking point for socialist but isn't an important metric. Inequality is inevitable in a highly competitive and fast growing economy. Just productivity improvement is a great measure of how well the economy is doing. For developed countries productivity improvements is difficult because it only comes about from innovation. For developing countries it can be had from just adoption of existing technologies.
- spodek 5y agoThat money will trickle down isn't a myth. It's an outright lie or fraud. It's more clear to see when you take away the imagery and see it says: giving money to rich people is giving money to poor people.
- beardyw 5y agoThere is trickle down, but sadly it is from the rich into political funding. That sets up a loop which favours the rich. It can't be fixed.
- sh4un 5y agoAt the end of the day, any curious, sober, normal human will try to make their lives better. This is why have start ups. But when someone starts company on here we are supportive, soon as they make it big everyone is jealous and that person is evil. You know, if you go on reddit and say you own a home, it's like going to Israeli in a Nazi uniform.
- mrjangles 5y agoGod this article is bad on so many levels I don't know where to start. First, income inequality doesn't measure income mobility. Places like the US that have a huge number of unskilled illegal and legal immigrants constantly entering at the bottom level will always have high income inequality. The question is, what happens to each individual over the course of their lives? 83% of Americans will earn more than their parents. 73% of Americans will spend at least 1 year in the top 20% of income earners in their lifetime. https://fee.org/articles/income-mobility-data-show-america-still-very-much-the-land-of-opportunity/ https://fee.org/articles/income-mobility-data-show-america-s... Also, there is no such thing as "trickle down economics", that is an insult leveled by critics of the idea you should let people spend and invest their own money rather than the government. The results speak for themselves and are astounding. The poorest person alive in a first world country today lives better than the richest 100 years ago. This was all because of investment. Clearly investment, or "trickling down" (as its critics like to call it) isn't just effective, it is the only thing that works to make people's lives better.
- brabel 5y ago> The poorest person alive in a first world country today lives better than the richest 100 years ago. You seem like an intelligent person, but then you go and spit some incredibly stupid sentence like that. Do you think the king of England 100 years ago lived worse than any of the thousands of homeless people camping on the streets of your country? In fact, in relative terms, some of the wealthiest people on the planet lived in the golden age of aristocracy a hundred+ years ago.
- Frost1x 5y ago>The poorest person alive in a first world country today lives better than the richest 100 years ago. What? Not even remotely close. John D Rockefeller was shrouded in wealth about 100 years ago. If you think the poorest, homeless person now stuck on the streets lives better than Rockefeller did, you're confused. Do not conflate general human progress of what's available with more knowledge, science, and basic technology with what a time period normalized standard of living looks like. You can't attribute economics directly with progress (it is a factor but not the only factor), otherwise you could very easily make a valid argument for an authoritarian government and economy like you see in China. China is arguably just as technologically advanced as the US. Now your middle income American might be considered as living better than Rockefeller depending on how you define quality of life. They have all the essentials they need to survive and access to more progress than Rockefeller did during his time period. They also have significantly less free time and less resources to explore the current space of possibilities whereas in the early 1900s, someone like Rockefeller had access to anything they wanted to do during that time period.
- DeathArrow 5y agoWhat's the problem with the income inequality? Isn't it normal that people who do different things and have different skills to win different amounts of money?
- dredmorbius 5y agoIs this improvement in the circumstances of the lower ranks of the people to be regarded as an advantage or as an inconvenience to the society? The answer seems at first sight abundantly plain. Servants, laborers and workmen of different kinds make up the far greater part of every great political society. But what improves the circumstances of the greater part can never be regarded as an inconvenience to the whole. No society can surely be flourishing and happy, of which the far greater part of the members are poor and miserable. It is but equity, besides, that they who feed, clothe and lodge the whole body of the people should have such a share of the produce of their own labor as to be themselves tolerably well fed, clothed and lodged. -- Adam Smith, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, Book I, Chapter 8. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_I/Chapter_8 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_I/...
- DeathArrow 5y agoThat doesn't mean all people should earn the same.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYou asked a question. I answered it. You're ignoring the answer. You're now arguing against a proposition which doesn't exist and wasn't made. Goalposts have been moved. The goal, however, stands. Anyone in the least familiar with Smith's works, would be aware of his discussion on differentiation in wages. It's actually a useful discussion, with solid points though with divergence from empirical evidence, and including only a subset of sources of personal wealth. It would make for a more useful further discussion than ignoring responses and changing the subject.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- shireboy 5y agoI think one point missing in these discussions is access to markets and wealth creation. As a “thousandaire” I’m not too concerned about what percentage of whatever anyone else has, as long as I have the ability to provide for my family and better my situation. My personal experience is that I have had incredible access: came from lower middle class, taught myself to code, make decent income, invest with low fees. I definitely had help and “privileges” along the way. But in general that experience makes me look for solutions to these issues that parallel my experience: education, business incubation, and investment.
- bojangleslover 5y agoHere is an example of the opposite of "trickle down": I am self employed so I get paid everything then have to pay my own tax. Aside from the sticker shock this has some effects. Toward the end of the year when my marginal rate cracks 50% I get a lot more generous. I tend to but more kit, and hire people for gigs. I may even hire an EA next year and pre-pay her at the end of this year. If faced with either saving an extra 20k or hiring an EA and paying her 50k, I am more inclined to the latter.
- JackFr 5y ago“World Inequality Lab” finds inequality. Go figure.
- jpadkins 5y agoOne observation I have on this topic and how the corp. media (vox, et al) handles the topic: The proposed solutions are always along the lines of increased income taxes, which impact people who are getting wealthy (high earning doctors, execs, entrepreneurs, etc). I rarely see discussion from corp. media on wealth taxes, which would impact the already wealthy. It is not widely known that billionaires don't have large "incomes" and therefor don't pay large relative amounts of income tax. The interesting outcome of this policy approach, is it's actually protecting the ultra rich from more competition (more wealthy people competing for influence & assets). Which means billionaires can maintain more socio-political control with their wealth with very high marginal income tax rates. Billionaires (who want to maintain power) do not want a lot more millionaires. The next time a progressive advocates for high marginal income tax rates, ask them why they want to protect the 1% from competition. :-) Edit: My personal preference is a 0.05% tax on any transfer between a LLC and it's owners (dividend, buyback, payroll to stockholders, or equivalent). I would also insist that this new tax be only allowed to flow to a direct citizen payment fund e.g. universal income (as I don't believe the captured bureaucracy will use it effectively or not just end up redirecting it back to billionaires). And for my liberty minded friends, think of it as a payment for limited liability protection for the owners (something that doesn't exist in a true free market. a government intervention that helps crony capitalism in some manner). If owners of a company want to avoid the tax, they can incorporate where their wealth is at risk for the damages their org does.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agowhat you're missing here is that discussions of higher marginal income taxes also often come with discussions about higher capital gains tax and higher estate tax which are the two main ways wealth is hoarded.
- jpadkins 5y agomight be my personal selection bias, but I see it rarely being pushed as the solution. If you think about it, the right order of operations is to consider higher income taxes only a decade after you instituted ultra high wealth taxes and seen the effects on concentrations of wealth. You only need higher marginal income taxes if there is too much 'flow' to the ultra concentrated wealth bucket (and does active harm if you don't have an effective 'drain' to the ultra concentrated wealth bucket)
- nickjj 5y agoI'm not into politics but does anyone else immediately think of the movie "The Platform"[0] (on Netflix) whenever they think about human nature combined with the idea of "trickle-down"? [0]: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt8228288/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt8228288/
- Wolfenstein98k 5y agoWhat an amazing headline. "The rich are taking most of the gains for themselves" No, stock in certain valuable companies rose a lot when their inherent value did (especially in relative terms), and stockholders thus hold a lot more wealth on paper.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoHow much did the wealth of the minimum wage workers increase (on paper or otherwise)?
- Wolfenstein98k 5y agoWhy would you compare the two? Starting a company that skyrockets in value (Musk, Bezos, etc) will never have a wealth trajectory like an unskilled labourer. There is no reason to expect wealth to grow at similar rates between people who do very different things, and have very different amounts of money to invest or skills to leverage for a high wage.
- j_crick 5y agoSo Piketty is now vindicated or what? How peculiar.
- nickpp 5y agoIs trickle-down strictly about money or about value in general? Because during the last 20 years, just (for example) the access to computing power and information did in fact "trickle-down" to almost everybody on earth in the form of smartphones and Internet. This value was worth a king's ransom in the past. But indeed, the number of TSLA stock in one's pocket did not trickle down from Elon Musk to the rest of us. Not sure why that matters though. In fact, looking in the article, they talk define trickle-down as "cutting taxes on the rich [...] eventually benefiting everyone" then complain about "very high level of income inequality and an extreme level of wealth inequality". You can have both true at the same time.
- GDC7 5y agoTrickle down was never about monetary wealth . It’s about quality of life . It does trickle down considering that nurses are taking overseas trips to Europe every 2 months and 800$ purses can be bought for 5$ and the only thing which makes it noticeable is a small hologram which nobody will check . Of course people only look at yachts and mansions because when everything becomes equal the stuff which separates the rich from the rest of us tends to shine brighter and get all the attention. Of course if you want everybody to be a millionaire then trickle down failed , but in the past experiments which tried to make monetary wealth equal for everybody caused a situation where quality of life collapsed for everybody….and being all equally as miserable is not such a great result and the number in the bank account being all equal won’t provide any consolation
- JKCalhoun 5y agoSorry, you're comparing $5 counterfeit purses to $40M yachts? I'm unaware that nurses were popping off to Europe twice a year (unless you meant nurses that already live in Europe). Meanwhile I see more and more homeless living along the freeways.
- GDC7 5y agoNo. I am comparing a 5$ purse to an 800$ purse . Trickle down made it so that the 2 are indistinguishable, except for an hologram nobody would ever check . Of course if you are hating on trickle down because not everybody owns a 40M yacht then you’d always be disappointed in every system . At least with trickle down a regular person can afford to be on a 40M yacht for a week in their whole lifetime if they accept some trade-offs , some sharing of the boat with other guests and maybe some debt . Not to mention luxury buildings costing 5 billions or more . Regular people can go in those hotel buildings at least 4 times per year (think the big Vegas hotels) Also nurses do travel overseas . Don’t know if it’s all paid for or some debt but for sure they are going
- Jensson 5y agoThis is just the effect of extremely low interest rates. When interest rates goes to 0 it means that the cost of any productive asset goes to infinity. That doesn't mean that all that value was actually created the past decade, Tesla for example hasn't created even close to a trillion worth of value, that is just the expected future value produced by Tesla including inflation. Do you think that Tesla will produce a trillion worth of value, not adjusted to inflation, in the next 50 years? Yes, I do, Tesla generated billions of operating profit last year, accumulated that over 50 years and Tesla is already worth more than money. Then Tesla isn't over valued. So the lower the interest rates the more "wealth" actually means future wealth. If interest rates were 5% today as it was steadily 50 years ago then future money gets valued much less and asset valuation would go down. It would cause inflation of course, but I don't think that is a bad thing.
- globular-toast 5y agoI thought trickle-down economics worked because I have seen how much better things have become in my lifetime. The cheapest food available today is so much higher quality than the cheapest available in the 90s. A bog standard car today comes with features that would have been considered luxury in the 90s. But these are all consumables. The difference between income and wealth has only become clear to me recently. I am a top 10% earner in the UK, according to the statistics. But it made no sense to me because I can only barely afford to buy a house (now in my mid-30s) and the amount that others seem to spend on cars etc. is truly baffling to me. So I look up the other statistic. Well it turns out I'm in the bottom 30% when it comes to wealth. Having wealth means someone could afford my lifestyle on a fraction of the income. There are millions of people who are trapped in a cycle of renting and borrowing who aren't building up any wealth at all. Meanwhile, people who started off with wealth in the first place find it easier and easier to keep building. I'm probably not the only person who makes this mistake between income and wealth. Income can give you a nice lifestyle today. But the moment you stop working, you're out on the street. Wealth is what really matters.
- cannabis_sam 5y agoHow the hell was this ever a myth…? It’s trivially shown to be complete and utter garbage.. Anyone pushing this type of pseudo-ideology should be laughed out of any intelligent discussion. (Sadly, in reality, these braindead morons are actually in charge of our economy..)
- Jensson 5y agoTrickle down is true. A McDonalds worker in a rich country earns much more than a McDonalds worker in India. You get paid more the more those around you get paid even if you yourself don't become more productive, that correlation is a fact. Trickle down is the natural state of things, USA just prevented it from doing so. By importing low skill labor/exporting low skill jobs, making unions hostile to workers and not keeping minimum wage up it made less trickle down. Change any of those and trickle down would have worked, if workers had better legal support for effective worker friendly unions like Europe then they could get their rights themselves, if low skill jobs exceeded supply of low skill workers then pay would go up naturally, and if the government mandated a minimum wage so unions don't have to then it would have the same effect as a union. But USA went against all of those and ensured that money wouldn't trickle down.
- nathanaldensr 5y agoIn this thread: everyone argues the false dichotomy of which master is better to serve: government or the rich.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoAs time goes on the distinction becomes less and less clear.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoAny time a headline uses words like 'demolishes' I immediately discredit it because its clearly written to be sensational.
- GuB-42 5y agoI don't know what the original "trickle down" theory is but if it is all about money, then both the theory and its rebuttal are just circular reasoning. The way I understand the "trickle down" idea is that the global economy is not a zero-sum game and when rich people build something, the poor indirectly take advantage of it, even if the wealth repartition curve doesn't change. For example, a rich person may use his wealth to make cheap computers, which sell well, so he becomes even richer, the poor don't become richer, but now they have computers, so in the end, even if wealth inequality didn't change, or maybe even became worse, the poor are better off, thanks to computers being cheaper. If we didn't let the rich entrepreneur get rich, there would be no cheap computers and while the poor may be wealthier on paper, they still won't have computers. But if we only care about money, then yes, of course inequality causes inequality, and if the "trickle down" theory says otherwise, then it is simply illogical, just as its debunking is circular reasoning. The study is not worthless, it is an interesting observational study, but I don't see how it disproves the more interesting non zero-sum version of "trickle down". For that it should also use indicators that are not money, like health, education, etc...
- Frost1x 5y ago>I don't know what the original "trickle down" theory is but if it is all about money, then both the theory and its rebuttal are just circular reasoning. It's more about giving preferential treatment, power, or advantage to the wealthy because they are considered the value creators and by giving them bigger breaks, advantages, or ability to make guidance decisions, they will move things in directions that benefit everyone.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> It's more about giving preferential treatment, power, or advantage to the wealthy "trickle down" is a slur against a set of economically liberal policies. It's not a "theory". It's not an economic model. And it's certainly not well-defined. It would be like arguing against "revolving door" sentencing, which is another slur. Point being, anyone who uses the term "trickle down" is advocating some sort of propaganda, and tuning them out or calling them out for being propagandists is the best course of action. Being on the guard for these markers of propaganda is important in today's media environment, where so often advocacy masquerades as both news and science. That does not mean that underneath all these political slurs there aren't useful debates about, for example, what is the right tax rate on capital income or property taxes. Should we increase or decrease business regulation, etc. Those are all good discussions to have, but unlike the slurs, they are actually nuanced and people who approach them understand there are trade offs not simply reducible to "trickle down" or "revolving door". Therefore the goal of these slurs is to reduce thought. To eliminate nuance and to hide painful trade offs. To make it seem like there is one simple, obvious, correct solution to what is, in fact, a complex issue with no obvious solutions.
- LatteLazy 5y agoThe lie is almost 40 years old. It's done a lot of damage in that time. It's time to stop wasting time pretending the other side are open to discussion, compromise or persuasion. Even pointing out the falsehoods in these lies actually makes people more likely to believe them. You saw this with the "350m pounds a week for the nhs" lie in the Brexit campaign. Even after it was revealed and admitted to be untrue, the more it was mentioned the more people believed it. So stop acting shocked and talk about how we need a trickle up program.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIt's well over a century old. William Jennings Bryan's "Cross of Gold" speech was discrediting the same notion. Will Rogers's original coinage of "trickle down" to ridicule it dates to 1932. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics
- d--b 5y agoThe thing about trickle down is that even the water analogy is backwards! It's combining many small streams that make up the big rivers... as in: give money to the lower classes, they will consume stuff and so the money will end up in the pockets of whoever produced the goods (usually large companies -> the sea?), and there the money will flow back up as income (clouds/rain?) and that will feed the small streams over again. In that analogy, the wealthy act like a dam, not as a source, cause the wealthy can only consume so much...
- flavius29663 5y ago> the wealthy can only consume so much That is exactly the point. The wealthy cannot consume too much, so they will invest the rest. Investment means factories and jobs for the poor. The government could take the money and do the investments themselves, but that never really works well. With so many inefficiencies, the governments would slow down the economic development significantly. Communist countries had 5 year plans setup by the government and they fell further and further behind in the market. All the money was distributed by the government, based on studies and decisions made mostly by engineers and politicians (e.g. if a dam was deemed profitable it was built no matter what. If nuclear is better it was getting built, and get public support afterwards etc.), and still they fell behind.
- d--b 5y agoMy point is that investement isn’t money that flows from the rich to the poor, like the trickle down analogy would suggest. Investment is meant to be recouped. It’s always about creating a bigger pie…
- flavius29663 5y ago> money that flows from the rich to the poor Of course not, which is why whoever proposes these policies doesn't call them "trickle down". But what the poor will get is jobs, better jobs than 20 or 100 years ago, that pay for more goods and services compared to 20 or 100 years ago. Which is true, the working poor today live very well compared to even rich people 20 or 100 years ago.
- benreesman 5y agoAnyone who knows with any sophistication how economics works isn’t telling: they’re pocketing the difference working at RenTec or Jump or whatever. A child knows that privatizing profits and socializing losses is only good for rich people, but a Nobel laureate can’t prove it. So what we get is a bunch of “those who can’t, teach” social science economics. Greenspan in front of Congress talking about “flaws in conceptual frameworks” rather than “me and Summers shouldn’t have squished Brooksley Born like a fucking bug when she tried to institute some sanity in derivatives markets”. California and electricity. Repeal of Glass-Steagall. Top work guys. Sometimes I think that HN will literally be the last place where temporarily embarrassed billionaires are pseudo-intellectualizing about pseudo-science economics when the tent-camp people under the 101 interchange finally head over to South Park and rig up a guillotine on that grassy bit.
- romwell 5y agoHN might be such a place even if most people here agree with you. My snarky comment critical of trickle-down[1] has been flagged and hidden when it reaches a score of 66; and the admins have threatened me with a ban. I don't mind this strict adherence to the "be kind, don't be snarky" rule, but I haven't seen it so vigilantly enforced on fumigation from fiscal conservatives, which I routinely see here. I feel like it reflects a dynamic in which flagging is used to steer a discussion, instead of improving its quality. I would be curious to see the stats on people to flag comments. Do they comment themselves? Do people agree with them? But I digress. I'm surprised your comment is still here, but that's a good sign. [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29483790 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29483790
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- daniel-cussen 5y agoTrickle-down is literal. The wealth trickles down, just like it says. The common conception is the definition of "trickle-down" is "flow down" like the wealth flows in a cycle like the rain into the snow, the snowmelt in the river, and the river into the ocean. That's flow. But we are talking about "trickle", like a faucet trickling, meaning it can be shut off easily, or you need a fixer to fix it, or it merely causes a bit of mold and warps the parquet. Trickle.
- xwdv 5y agoWhat is the point of trying to prove trickle down is a myth? There is nothing to gain, except some cheap political points against dead politicians from decades ago. Are people that pressed? This article is hot garbage anyway. These days people can afford far more things and of better quality that were once considered luxuries decades ago, and people with actual useful skills are earning more than past generations. Maybe trickle down is a myth? I don’t know, but whatever we’re doing now, let’s keep doing it, because it is working.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y agoWell, if you're gonna have rich people that's gonna have to mean that those rich people have much more money than not-rich people. Otherwise, you can't have rich people as a special category- if everybody is rich then nobody is. Then of course the more money you have as a society, the more money the rich people of your society will have. And if you have a large population, the difference between those who are rich and those who are not is gonna have to be very large just because there's so much more money to be divided between the necessarily few rich people (again: if many people have lots of money then you don't have a special class of "rich"). So to summarise, if you're gonna have a rich society, you're gonna have to have rich people who are much more rich than not-rich people. Problem is, that's not about inequality, nor about the richess of socieities, but about amibition. You see, everyone wants to be rich. Translated: everyone wants to have more than almost everyone else. So everyone supports an economic system that supports rich people, and therefore, wealth inequality. Which is funny because the vast majority of people who support that kind of system are necessarily going to have to be not-rich. So in order for most people to be able to dream that, one day, they'll be filthy rich, most people have to spend their entire lives in relative (or absolute) poverty. Funny old world, eh?
- lordlimecat 5y agoThe theory of trickle down does not suggest or imply that inequality will decrease. It suggests that allowing the entrepreneurs (eventual billionaires) to succeed will result in an overall increase in wealth throughout society. Using an inequality report to "debunk" it is to entirely miss the point. You could note that, for instance, despite having a lower-than-average cost of living for the west(^1,2) and lower-than-average taxes for the west (^3,4), the US is top-five for both average wage (^5,6) and PPP-adjusted median income (^7,8). And despite what you may think, even adjusting for government transfers (e.g. healthcare) does not tilt the scale: the US boasts a #1 (or #3, depending on who you ask) PPP-adjusted disposable income (^9). These generally apply to medians too, so one cannot even fall back on skew to explain it away. Meanwhile, when we speak of "inequality" and billionaires, China has above-average taxes (seems to be 25% across the board with no carve-out for capital gains), yet has far worse inequality than the US. As with most things economic, reports like this can be crafted to fit whatever narrative you like. But if you are sitting in the US in 2021-- one of the wealthiest societies in human history-- and complaining about how bad capitalism or low taxes are, you're badly misinformed about the "normal" economic state of a human and where you sit. Here's a hint: it's probably in the 95th percentile across history and the 90th percentile today. Sources: Cost of Living 1. https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/rankings_by_country.jsp https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/rankings_by_country.js... 2. https://www.worlddata.info/cost-of-living.php https://www.worlddata.info/cost-of-living.php Taxes 3. https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/personal-income-tax-rate https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/personal-income-ta... 4. https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=TABLE_I6 https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=TABLE_I6 Average wage 5. https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/median-income-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/median-in... 6. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_income PPP-adjusted Median income 7. https://statisticstimes.com/economy/countries-by-gdp-capita-ppp.php https://statisticstimes.com/economy/countries-by-gdp-capita-... 8. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_average_wage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_average_w... PPP-adjusted Disposable household income 9. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_household_and_per_capita_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_household_and_per_c...
- off_sounder 5y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but shouldn't we be looking at whether the people at the bottom gained more wealth, rather than what percentage of the gains they hold? The wealthy will always have more opportunities bc of the 80/20 rule, and the fact that inequality is inherent in all animals. It is called "trickle down" after all, not "ration down."
- eqth 5y agoIf the US didn't have their weird death laws with inheritance and 0% loans trickle-down would work. It's very simple. A billionaire can do 3 things with their money: 1)spend it reinserting it into the economy- this 'trickles the money down'. 2)invest it- this funds projects and/or decreases yield ratios (thus making capital cheaper) which in the longer-term reinsterts the money into the economy. 3)burn it - this creates disinflation which increases the value of every other dollar thus reinserting money into the economy.
- js290 5y agoFiat Money... https://youtu.be/hx16a72j__8 https://youtu.be/hx16a72j__8 "The [deficit] spending is the [inflation] tax" -Ron Paul
- stevenalowe 5y ago“More wealth, more wealth disparity” Power Law strikes again
- GoodJokes 5y agoOne year studies did too. Yet, here we are.
- RickJWagner 5y ago[flagged]
- tim333 5y ago>Billionaires now hold a 3% share of global wealth, up from 1% in 1995 A lot of that is just a boom in stock and house prices which may reprice lower one day.