17 ms·
You click a link to a news site, to read an article that seems interesting
- muppetman 5y agoIf they can trigger a "video fired" message in the analytics, that's one more "Person viewed our video" they can show to a potential advertiser. That's all it's about, not the end user's experience.
- jtmarmon 5y ago+1 - duh. This is like asking people if they find the experience of stopping at a toll booth to be a pleasant part of the driving experience
- Dylan16807 5y agoExcept it's a toll booth that you don't pay. It's part of some weird scam that depends on annoying you.
- olyjohn 5y agoYou pay with your wasted time and energy, and potential loss of focus as to what you came to the site to actually read.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoOften, they can also show the much more important "well-paid video ad played" event. Video ads pay much better than other ads, and I believe that those videos are often ad-ridden - we just don't notice because your ad blocker takes care of that. (I know I've seen it a couple of times, but I don't know how frequent it is because I rarely make the mistake of visiting a news site on a browser without an ad blocker.)
- donohoe 5y agoYes, but unlikely. Its usually a deal with a 3rd-party that gives the guaranteed revenue based on views per week/month.
- mmis1000 5y agoAnd the one publish ads gets absolutely no attention even though the numbers looks good. Who on the earth will watch a video stick at the corner of a news site page?
- thirdsun 5y agoAnd yet everyone knows that those views are absolutely worthless. Who is paying for that? Who thinks this is a good use of their ad budget?
- resonious 5y agoClassic example of that "if a metric becomes the goal, that metric is no longer useful" quote. At least, I think that's a real quote.
- factotvm 5y agoIn essence, Goodhart's Law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- Mikushi 5y agoHaving worked on video delivery, first play is not paid much attention. In most VPAID supported ads -one of the standards for video ad delivery- you have events fired at set intervals which are what is actually looked at when evaluating a placement value. A placement that has high first play rate but a terrible 5sec event firing will just be worth nothing. In a programmatic world it means you'll get little to no bids for it or a default placement with payment in the fraction of cents per thousands.
- TruthWillHurt 5y agoProblem is - it probably works. It gets a percentage of people to stay longer. You can argue that those full screen "before you leave" popups are annoying, and who in their right mind will abuse users like that? Then they'll show you the results of A/B testing, prooving 15% more users subscribed thanks to that banner. We're screwing ourselves over statistics...
- kristofferR 5y agoFeels almost as bad as opening a HN story and discovering that the only content is a whiny tweet/mastadon about a minor annoyance.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYou're welcome to go through the New submissions list, or my submissions, or any other user's, and upvote the more substantial content. Trust me, I do try to steer discussion in directions I think would prove more valuable for HN and its readers. There's some help in this through the 2nd Chance and invited submissions queues. See: https://news.ycombinator.com/pool https://news.ycombinator.com/pool https://news.ycombinator.com/invited https://news.ycombinator.com/invited That said, the hivemind has certain rather predictably-popular themes. I wish myself it would steer more substantive, but site mechanics make that challenging. That said, the unanimity of the response, given the ubiquity of the practice, shines a light on, oh, say, the "consumer value" arguemnt usually put forth. And that's possibly worth noting.
- ccvannorman 5y agoYou click on the comments without clicking on on the article, to determine that it probably isn't worth your time
- curiousigor 5y agoThis is me, basically every time. Most of the articles don't get opened.
- deergomoo 5y agoAre there people out there that actually engage with the auto-playing videos, or the “articles you should also read” callouts forced between every other paragraph? There must be right? I know no-one likes them, but there must be some increase in engagement somewhere that causes the marketing folks to keep pushing these things. Personally I find it makes the articles very hard to read without reader mode. Sites owned by G/O Media (The Onion, Kotaku) are particularly egregious. On mobile you can typically only get about 20-30 words of the article on screen at any one time (that’s an exaggeration, but not much of one).
- Nextgrid 5y agoWhen it comes to chumboxes aka "articles you should also read" I could definitely see old people less experienced with the internet's scumminess falling for them at least the first few times.
- jjbinx007 5y agoI take a particularly dim view on websites that have these. I don't care if that's how they make their living - they are making money by scamming people.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe sites themselves are aware of this reputational damage risk, and discuss this openly. https://www.niemanlab.org/2019/10/a-merger-of-chumbox-mongers-might-leave-publishers-a-little-bit-poorer-and-their-websites-a-little-less-revolting/ https://www.niemanlab.org/2019/10/a-merger-of-chumbox-monger...
- corobo 5y agoI love that I got a popup modal asking for my email address on that page
- paul7986 5y agoMost of my browsing is done on my TV via my Mac Mini connected to it. The resolution is jack up to the lowest so I can easily see from the couch. This is a fringe case as most people arent enjoying the Internet on their TV via a web browser and wireless mouse. Nevertheless those nuisance videos are the worst in my view on the TV ... take up the screen and there's no X button. Always just have to hit the back button quickly and not bother reading the site.
- keyle 5y agoI'm surprised there isn't an extension for some kind of white-list only video stream content. I too find these sites despicable. But usually, by the time the video play you've already been fighting some popup about joining, dismissed a browser native window saying this site is asking to send you notifications in the future, and GRDP @#$%^$%^& "we care about your privacy so here is a booklet about our privacy policy, in your face" with select all-of-which cookies you'd like to not, maybe (one time) receive in a game of dark patterns. I have an outline.com bookmarklet at that point, which I click as fast as possible to get out of this mess! javascript:window.location='https://outline.com/'%20+%20window.location
- gruez 5y ago> I'm surprised there isn't an extension for some kind of white-list only video stream content. the main problem is that it's impossible to distinguish between "autoplaying video that's annoying" and "animation that's part of the page". If you're willing to block both, firefox allows you to change the autoplay policy from "allow videos by default but block sound" to "block all videos".
- Zak 5y agoFirefox has that built in; Chrome has the option to block audio. Both support a whitelist; Chrome supports a blacklist. There are extensions with more options. A combination of the "I don't care about cookies" extension and an adblocker with a couple tracking blacklists should avoid both the cookie popups and the tracking cookies themselves.
- throwaway81523 5y agoYou know the old joke about the prison where all the prisoners all knew the same jokes, so instead of bothering to tell them at dinnertime, they would just call out a number? Seems like the interweb is like that, except it's XKCD comics instead of joke numbers. There is one for every occasion. With that in mind: 624.
- darkteflon 5y agoNot exactly the same thing but related: shout out to the excellent Vinegar extension for iOS Safari, which disables the abhorrent YouTube “play video on initial touch” behaviour that triggers play on every goddamn embedded YT video as you are simply trying to scroll down a page to read an article. Absolute lifesaver. Metaphorically speaking.
- VWWHFSfQ 5y agoHave you ever driven across a bridge, or along a highway and run over one of those "hit counter" cables that the Department of Transportation lays out to know how many people are driving on that bridge, or that highway? Now imagine that the cable can reach up into your car at the exact moment that you cross over it and pull down your person and your entire life's history.
- ipaddr 5y agoThat's a passport book.
- baud147258 5y agoexcept strangers don't get to see it without having to ask you for it
- adewinter 5y agoA log of where you've traveled (and a partial log at that) hardly constitutes your "entire person".
- hammock 5y agoWhat do you think comes up when Immigration Control reads it into their computer?
- throwawayboise 5y agoThat's E-ZPass, FasTrak, etc. Also those toll bridges where they take a photo of your license plate and send you a bill that includes a $6 "convenience fee"
- hammock 5y agoThey hide ALPR everywhere. All it takes is a camera. I've seen it on the backside of normal green highway signs, where you can't see it and would never suspect it. The idea is to create a dragnet.
- jjbinx007 5y agoIt's not just autoplaying video that's the problem, it's the fact that these videos then go on to autoplay something else completely unconnected to what you were reading without asking you first. You might argue this is to do with advertisers and so on, but this also happens on the BBC News website too. I recently clicked on a video story and after the video was finished I didn't notice there was a 5 second timer and suddenly I got a totally different video play by itself. WHY?!
- gruez 5y ago> It's not just autoplaying video that's the problem, it's the fact that these videos then go on to autoplay something else completely unconnected to what you were reading without asking you first. No, screw that as well. If there's a text article with a video attached, I don't want to be interrupted by the autoplaying video while I'm reading the text.
- chiefalchemist 5y ago> WHY? Because that's how the web team is measured and rewarded. Management wants to see more view views, longer time on site, etc. Leadership doesn't understand nor care about a shite UX (so no one lower in the org is concerned).
- rozab 5y agoBBC management has gone down the horrible path of mimicking social media companies because they think that's the modern thing to do. But these companies have completely different goals than the BBC: they aim to abuse and exploit their users as much as possible.
- zrm 5y agoThis is a common theme with non-profits and open source projects. They see the for-profit incumbents doing something toxic and cargo cult it like not providing a similar experience would betray the users when it's really the opposite.
- northwest65 5y agoHow about an opt in botnet extension for your browser that focuses it's energy on sites with this sort of dark pattern behaviour. i.e. You install the extension, when you come across a site like this you vote it for getting punishment, once the site gets enough vote the botnet occasionally focusses it's energy on the site in question when the participants browser is otherwise sitting idle. The punishment could potentially be anything (follow subscribe links, consuming traffic in the background, a simple DoS), but ideally something that reduces the offending servers ability to do what it's supposed to.
- isamuel 5y agoWhy stop there? Maybe websites you don’t like should have a crowdsourced assassin come to kill the relevant developers.
- northwest65 5y agoThere's an argument to be made that the developers are the new crackers, the new enablers of abusive behaviour. Perhaps they should feel some burn for their actions.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoSo long as all the developers of DoS and assassination extensions "felt the burn" before they could complete their abusive-behavior-enabling technology, I would be fine with that.
- tejtm 5y agoSelective pressure for programmer ethics. May take a more than a few generations to cut through all this cash.
- thomascgalvin 5y agoI've heard rentahitman.com is great. For example: https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/rent-a-hitman-wendy-wein-murder-for-hire-sting-operation-1066756/ https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/rent-a...
- cblconfederate 5y agoIs the point of the video to make users stay longer? How long do they need the user to stay in order to improve their ad profit. Here is an idea, obnoxious webmasters: add an interstitial timer, "your article will be ready in ...". It's less intrusive and i might even tolerate that if it's less than ... 9 seconds. I m sorry that google and FB are sucking up all your revenue, i d like to help
- monkeybutton 5y agoThe only reason users are staying longer is because the embedded video slows down the whole page loading, especially on mobile. News sites that have these are cancer and I actively avoid opening links to them when I'm on my phone. I can see my battery life lose whole percentage points when I open these pages. Can't see the content though; between the cookie consent toast, the video embedded in the lower right corner, the "allow us to send notifications" and "allow this site to see your location" popups.
- cblconfederate 5y agoIt is a tragic situation. These sites obviously provide some value (or else you wouldn't be reading them) yet they cannot get paid for that value because google&FB have coopted the entire ad market for themselves. As technologists this is a problem that we should solve, not simply something to complain about
- bryan_w 5y agoThey could...maybe try rubbing two brain cells together in order to come up with a better, higher performing ad product. Nah, they find sticking to the 90's punch the monkey style ads and blaming FB and Google for "coopting" the market to be a better strategy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- yellowapple 5y agoNot just news sites, either. A lot of fandom wikis run on the same platform, fandom.com. That site is a pain in the absolute fucking ass to use on any mobile device, specifically because of the autoplaying video that takes up half the screen on every page load. Weirdly, desktop is fine; no autoplaying videos or any such nonsense. It's only on mobile that Fandom has seemingly made a deliberate effort to make the user experience as frustrating as possible. And not once has the video had even a tangential relationship to the article being viewed. The worst part is that uBlock Origin's element picker doesn't work on Firefox for Android (or if it does, I haven't figured out how to use it), so on the one platform where it's maximally annoying I can't do anything to block it.
- tpaulin 5y agoA few months back I opened a link to a new article using an in-app browser (no ad-blockers). I kid you not, upon initial load the entireiy of the screen was ads or "annoyances". The one thing missing was the entire reason I clicked on the link.
- rstat1 5y agoI'd say the worst part is that Firefox has a feature for blocking auto playing video. But it never works.
- gruez 5y agoI suspect that's because you can programmatically start video playback from within event handlers. That's necessary because otherwise any site that use custom playback controls will break. However, that also means malicious sites can implement "autoplay" by adding a onmousedown/onscroll/touchstart event handler and starting playback from there. Video playback will start the moment you try to interact with the page in any way.
- boring_twenties 5y ago> any site that use custom playback controls will break Is that actually a bad thing? I have no idea about video playback controls, but in every other instance I've noticed where sites implement their own custom versions of browser controls, it's been absolutely terrible. Custom scrollbars, or lack thereof. Custom drop-down lists, which never support keyboard input properly. And so on. And even if I'm wrong, and custom video playback controls are somehow desirable, why should they be supported for any event except onclick?
- nmstoker 5y agoI feel browsing the web is long overdue having a robot butler to do it for us and come back with the things we wanted, leaving the "People in Norwich are using this genius trick"-style nonsense on the cutting room floor. It ought to be trivially possible, going on from things like grease monkey and ad blocking scripts to add a bit of user intent guessing / content filtering / simplified view logic.
- thomascgalvin 5y agoIf it was trivially possible, Firefox would already be doing it. But there's always an arms race with stuff like this. Our robot butler would be able to figure out how to parse the web today, but the advertisers would completely change the structure of pages tomorrow. Facebook used to have their ads wrapped in `<div class='advertisement'>`. Now, they're buried a thousand divs deeps, and the ads and content both have nonsensical, non-semantic class names.
- discordance 5y agoIt's technologically possible, but not legally possible and not convenient. People in the know have the right extensions to block stuff and get past paywalls using the right snapshot services etc. Firefox can't officially offer this, but they can let people do whatever they want if they run their own extensions. If this was common place or convenient for the masses then it would be actively discouraged or outlawed, similar to what happened with Napster and MP3s.
- thizzbuzz 5y agoIf it was trivially possible, Firefox would already be doing it. I am thoroughly unconvinced of this, as a Firefox user for two decades. There are so many simple power-user features that Firefox has chosen to ignore.
- throwaway81523 5y ago> If it was trivially possible, Firefox would already be doing it. Sorry but Firefox is mostly on the dark side these days. That shouldn't be too surprising since most of its money comes from google. It does have a setting to stop embedded video from playing sound unless you send an event, but it is too easy for obnoxious pages to evade and play sound against your wishes.
- rozab 5y agoThe worst offender for this, in my opinion, is Wikia (sorry, "Fandom™"). There is zero attempt to make the autoplaying content at all relevant to the wiki in question, and it generally isn't even advertising anything, it's just... crap. It seems like they're desperately trying to believe they have a social network on their hands rather than a collection of disparate knowledge bases, and they're trying to sell this non-existent 'fandom' culture to visitors.
- stewx 5y agoIf I remember correctly, if you make an account with them, or sign in with Google or whatever, it lets you turn off the video nonsense.
- fnord77 5y agowhy are news/blogspam-news sites so eager to play videos? (Even if the video is just some intern reading the article with static pictures being shown) Is there extra ad revenue from this somehow? Is it an attempt to keep people on the page longer? don't get it
- arn 5y agoVideo ads pay well.
- cercatrova 5y agoOff topic, but I've never seen mastodon linked like this before on HN. Interesting this this might've normally been a link to a tweet.
- ksherlock 5y agoIt could have been a poll right here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newpoll https://news.ycombinator.com/newpoll
- mattowen_uk 5y agoI can't recall the last time I saw someone use that on HN. I'm pretty sure most people don't know it exists.
- rapnie 5y agoWould be interesting to know how it compares in user base and exposure. The fediverse poll lasted 1 day and gained 268 votes and with only 31 boosts (i.e. "retweets" in fediverse terminology). How many people saw the poll is hard to tell and depends too on the social graph from author and boosters, as well as the network of federated instances involved. When posting a poll on HN, it of course has to reach the minimum number of upvotes to reach front page (which I believe for Polls and Ask HN is a bit higher than regular submissions).
- xupybd 5y agoI've just joined the technology mastodon because of this link.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWorld Domination!!! ;-) Ping me: @dredmorbius@toot.cat
- proactivesvcs 5y agoI'm seeing the Fediverse linked to more and more often, in the wild. Not the first time I've seen it linked here, either. It's heartening to see that there's a little light at the end of the tunnel.
- geuis 5y agoI additionally love whatever is happening on that mastodon site that takes over the browser back button that somehow involves Reddit.com
- swader999 5y agoThis is especially not good when it wakes my wife up by accident.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoSomething about the post itself: while I'm firmly in the "it's annoying" camp, as is the author, the poll is a textbook example of how to make a heavily biased poll. Maybe there is a person or two who actually like it, but the dripping sarcasm of the poll's response is saying "whoever you are, you're cretins", and is not quite inviting for a discussion. I'd love to hear from someone who actually liked this pattern (and many others) as a consumer. It's so alien. Maybe I'd learn something. Then again, I'm probably going to write that crawling bot that would frequent the sites I read, snip the actual content and deliver it to me via email or my Kindle. Call RMS what you will, but that bit of his digital life is quite clever.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe poll is pretty obviously flippant. All the same, for such a widely-used dark pattern, the visceral hostile response is absolutely overwhelming. Think of all the weasly, greasy, contemptuous justifications that have been offerred for this practice. Clearly, someone's lying, and not at all convincingly.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoI've heard plenty from content managers, website owners, management, that is, the side of barricade making this shit. I suspect the overwhelming response from those who sorta tolerate is going to be: well, I want my dose of news, and everyone is doing that anyway, so I suppose that's how things are done today? But maybe there is someone who actually enjoys this. I'd like to hear from them.
- forgotmypw17 5y agoI don't get annoyed, I just close the tab and never return to the site again.
- throwawayboise 5y agoReader mode. Learn it, use it, love it.
- throwawayboise 5y agoI disable media auto-play in firefox, but somehow some sites are able to play these videos anyway. Are they gifs?
- throwaway81523 5y agoThe video can start playing when you "permit" it to by giving it a suitable input event. Apparently a mouse motion is enough. It doesn't have to be a click. There is a bugzilla item about this somewhere, where the FF devs think that is a good interface. Upton Sinclair anyone?
- lmm 5y agoRemind me again why people thought the video tag was a good idea? Flash with click-to-start made for a much better browsing experience.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- coolandsmartrr 5y agoHow about you disable autoplay? Firefox does this.
- victorbstan 5y agoAnyone remember how terrible Macromedia Flash ads were?
- kristopolous 5y ago10 years ago I wrote this: "what will the ad-haters use in this future world of 2022? Some amalgamated FlashBlock equivalent that can easily just turn off all the annoying stuff? This line will be blurred and it won't be possible." I wish I was wrong on these types of things. http://kristopolous.blogspot.com/2011/12/flash-sucks.html http://kristopolous.blogspot.com/2011/12/flash-sucks.html
- anigbrowl 5y agoMarketing is a trash industry episode #451.
- waltbosz 5y agoHow about an extension that disables video elements until you click on them ... Like how Internet Explorer treated Java applets towards the end on their days. You could add a whitelist feature to the extension for YouTube et al. Sure, it would be nice if websites didn't do shitty UX, but as others have said, don't visit those sites. The other extension idea I had was one which would reference a database of sites known to use dark UX, and warn you not to click thru. I myself run a userscript on Google that removes results from websites that I'd prefer to avoid.
- wyager 5y agoI swear Safari used to block autoplay-with-audio, and it recently stopped blocking it. I remember this because I specifically needed to set audio to disabled to get a video clip to autoplay on my blog (basically just a more efficient GIF).
- dragontamer 5y ago> How about an extension that disables video elements until you click on them ... Like how Internet Explorer treated Java applets towards the end on their days. No. Short MP4 files should replace GIFs. MP4 files are more efficient than the terrible compression GIF files have. I've made a few video game pages where auto-playing MP4s were essential at giving the right message... discussion of tactics and "movement" of dynamic video game stuff is pretty common. (Any game requires the player to gain instincts that "predict the future", and short GIFs and/or MP4 files really help show off key moments). Factorio thing I wrote a while back: https://factorioguide.nfshost.com/backpressure.html https://factorioguide.nfshost.com/backpressure.html
- sroussey 5y agoNot sure why you are downvoted. Animated gifs are huge in comparison. One thing to note, however, is that it must be without sound. Auto playing sound of any sort is complete garbage.
- dragontamer 5y ago
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> Inexplicably, it was not blocked by your ad-blocker. This is the real problem. Why wasn't it blocked? We must fix that!
- bambax 5y agoI think because technically, it's not an ad. But you can surely block the zone. Or, more simply, just disable javascript for the whole site. If it breaks the site, you know you don't want to come back.
- matheusmoreira 5y agouBlock Origin has an annoyances filter list, these autoplaying videos fall in that category. I agree with you on Javascript.
- makecheck 5y agoI feel like these are “somebody got a promotion” patterns. Basically, somebody was able to “prove” to Higher-Up Managers that $X number of these videos were “watched” or “engaged with” (or whatever today’s BS lingo is), and therefore the business “benefited” in some way by “reaching” more people. Profit? In reality, at least in my case, what happens is: (1) I say “WTF!?!?”, (2) I make a mental note to never ever visit the site again, and (3) (sadly) I see it again and again at different sites.
- mhb 5y agoSort of related - is geeksforgeeks the new experts-exchange?
- siltpotato 5y agoWhat's the story on experts-exchange?
- ndynan 5y agoThis pattern is purely a representation of how financially hurt news institutions are. They are desperate to make revenue and the end user experience is sacrificed in the name of keeping the ship afloat (and sometimes profit).
- hellbannedguy 5y agoI'm to the point I'd like to see them go 501c3 nonprofit. Admit defeat. Get used to just making a barely livable income, like the rest of us. Stop begging. Stop the obnoxious ads. Stop the shady subscription schemes. Enough with the .99 cent for six week promos. We obviously don't value you enough to give your access to our debit cards. Newspapers you lost the war. The sooner you realize it the better. Follow the PBS model at this point. (And I realize the importance of non-biased news. I wouldn't mind seeing tax money going to certain high quality organizations.)
- chrischen 5y ago
- bogomipz 5y agoI've noticed a variation on this which is a video that is related to the news story however since I am reading the article I press stop on the autoplaying video. However as soon as I scroll down to continue reading the page the video also moves to the lower left corner so that it is still visible even though I have paused this. This seems quite hostile as one has signaled their preference to read the article since they stopped the video. Can anyone say what the thinking is here? Is this just another technique to game some engagement metric?
- authed 5y agoFacebook is pretty bad too... I was just watching a video, lowered the volume and scrolled down... then it popped up an always-on-screen video player... I close it and it reverts back to playing the one that is offscreen, and the volume gets reset to maximum level.
- arnaudsm 5y agoLet's face it : the modern web is a nightmare without an adblocker and annoyance blocklists. And most web creators aren't even aware because they use these tools themselves. No wonder why normal people like walled gardens, the UI is more streamlined and (mostly) more respectful.
- est31 5y ago> No wonder why normal people like walled gardens, the UI is more streamlined and (mostly) more respectful. Oh wow that's actually a good point, never thought about it that way. You are spot on I think, besides some heavy attempts by services to get people to use their apps (especially pronounced on mobile). Note though that the web has always been annoying users, or at least many website have. I remember how in the 2000s, Firefox was advertised as being able to block pop ups, to give an example.
- bobthepanda 5y agoRemember, (one of) the revolutionary things about iPhone was that Apple just straight up refused to allow carriers to preload apps onto the phones. I don't miss the days of Verizon attempting to hawk songs and ringtones on a janky, zero-upside store for $5 a pop.
- gkya 5y ago> No wonder why normal people like walled gardens, the UI is more streamlined and (mostly) more respectful. Have you seen someone use Facebook as of recent? Respectful?
- eyelidlessness 5y agoIt’s not a great experience in a lot of ways, but it’s 10x better than every time I give in to curiosity and follow a Reddit link (all from here, this bastion of good web).
- LordDragonfang 5y ago
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoI blame Javascript. Letting it become normal to implicitly execute code just because it came bundled with a document that you requested was a mistake. We can have a web of apps, we just should've kept it separate from our web of documents so that I could only go there when what I wanted was an app.
- Damogran6 5y agoThere MUST BE some kind of person who's default behavior is "I wonder how hard I can push this and not get in trouble". They do this stuff. I hope I never meet him.
- colanderman 5y agoOn Firefox on macOS, almost always, the close button for these monstrosities is positioned flush right and sized exactly such that it extends merely 1 pixel left of the scroll bar. So, to close them, you must either aim precisely for this 1 pixel sliver, or move slowly enough that the scroll bar does not appear. These days I just click Reader Mode for almost any news site. I wish I could somehow set domains to always open in Reader Mode.
- onion2k 5y agoThese days I just click Reader Mode for almost any news site. That's more effort than I put in; I just don't bother reading the articles when the site makes it too hard.
- sha016 5y agoShameless self plug: I created a website in an attempt to improve the news browsing experience - https://inshapemind.com https://inshapemind.com
- 72deluxe 5y agoWhere are the feed sources? Have you ever used skimfeed.com?
- dbavaria 5y agoSome cooking recipe sites do this but I recently found it's actually helpful. While the video is playing, my phone screen stays on and the OS doesn't lock itself. Since it's always some unrelated video, I just turn the volume off and let it play while I cook, occasionally glancing over at my recipe.
- MaxikCZ 5y agosurely I cant be the only one thinking this: https://xkcd.com/1172/ https://xkcd.com/1172/ - Workflow
- pier25 5y agoThe amount of egress, bandwidth, and energy wasted with this crap must be mind boggling (globally speaking).
- camillomiller 5y agoWhy would anyone expect that a news site would put users first, if we’re all ok with the notion that news organization are regular businesses? For news organizations, the idiosyncrasies of corporate capitalism are more evident, because we keep on accepting the contradictory double bind that journalism has a deeply rooted social role, and that it can be managed as a regular business at the same time. That is, per se, a disqualification of what journalism can be, because business mechanics are directly negating many core tenets of journalism in itself. Without many more meanderings, the idea is this: as long as we accept that journalistic organization can be operated as showbusiness entities, and as long as we accept that journalism can (or should) generate profits, we won’t be able to either fix these annoying elements (the embedded autoplay video, and 1000s of others) nor the generalized and growing lack of trust in journalism itself. It might be useful to point out that I say this as a journalist.
- jmnicolas 5y agoYou can disable video and sound autoplay in Firefox. But anyway I try to avoid those kind of websites.
- ahonhn 5y agoChannel News Asia has developed a habit of putting 2 (two) auto-playing videos on some articles and having them both play simultaneously at full volume.
- johnnywasagood 5y agoWow. They even don't want to pretend that videos are for viewing.
- 72deluxe 5y agoThat's actually made me laugh out loud. It's like you'd be constantly subjected to a cacophony of a senseless din for no reason at all whilst browsing the site. Insanity.
- teekert 5y agoThose 2% (if they are not trolling) may be worth it economically?
- Tepix 5y agoWe need to both shame the websites/companies doing this and tell them that it is unacceptable.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoI will actively block that video player. Spend time to do it, even.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI worry that ad-blockers and similar contribute to this. I, as a nerd, get to bypass all the dark patterns, either by just being informed, using specialized tools or other workarounds that let me use the service (and so increase its reach) but let others take the hit in getting sucked into the adverts or rage-based communities. It feels like there should be a social movement to use tools that don't employ these tactics on anyone. It might mean a short term reduction in quality of life, but it equally could be long term beneficial. How many people struggled with a thousand different sub-par experiences for decades so that today Valve can launch a handheld Linux based gaming PC with Wine based emulation of basically their entire catalog. It's an amazing collective achievement of society, but many people take the short term view because 5 or 10 or 15 years ago it seemed outlandish that X could ever be achieved with open code and shared data. How can we get more people to take the better long term view? "Would you want your kid to use this app?" App idea: take the core code of an open source ad-blocker, make it slightly less harsh, but totally block any site that fails it's tests rather than block only the ads. Provide alternate news stories or whatever from sites that are better. Similar to Google punishing deceptive sites, but decentralised. (I've noticed this recently with Google provided news stories. They let me say "I'm not interested in topic" and "not interested in this specific site" which I use whenever the clickbait annoys me, but there's no generic "no clickbait please" option, nor any way to help protect other users from it who may be unaware of the dangers)
- JulianMorrison 5y agoSecond kind of fuckery of this sort: you watch a video about A, and it auto plays a video about a completely unrelated B. There is no option to switch this off (hello, Independent news online). Just no. Seriously. That gets me to block your entire video player.
- hamasho 5y agoSomehow, I too see a lot of features that exists solely to increase the company's profit and only annoy customers. I always wonder why they think this is a good idea. But then I remember I often implement those features as a developer. And sometimes, when I ask the marketing people or product manager, even they look to think it's a terrible idea. They are also forced to release something BS but can increase some KPI.
- cobbal 5y agoGoodhart's law kills again.
- OJFord 5y ago(Seriously) I wonder to what extent a cause is that the internet is US-dominated - because US (& Canadian) television is just like this too. Opaque and colourful channel logo that spins and barely fades, and advertising that pops up over the programme while it's playing! If that's your norm on TV, sure, why wouldn't a web page work like that? It baffles me just like OP, but no more than it does on television programmes.
- melech_ric 5y agoI'm old enough to remember a time before every TV station had a logo/watermark at the bottom right. In my mind, the logos coincided with the early 80s when VCRs became more commonplace. I suppose stations that licensed shows/movies, didn't enjoy the fact that people could record that content and reuse it. So... logos.
- dredmorbius 5y agoNot that I watch much TV, but persistent logos ... and animated promos for upcoming features during the current programme, which still seems mind-blowingly bad ... were something I didn't notice until the mid-2000s. I may well have missed thier introduction.
- pull_my_finger 5y agoYou know I hate this. The fact that they will autoplay videos with the sound off with the hope I'll turn it on is non-consensual data use. I get 0 benefit from watching some talking head with no sound, so why do you need to start loading and playing the video before I've consented to watch it? I live in an area where data is often slow, metered/throttled/capped. Please stop WASTING users data. It's not a free and never-ending resource.
- comeonseriously 5y agoI'm sure some lawyer someplace would tell you that by visiting the site you are consenting.
- kordlessagain 5y agoTurn javascript off.
- timebeast 5y agoOften times, I click on an article and just get hit with a paywall. At least before I found apps and websites to help me get around them
- jackspratt33 5y agoHere is a partial fix. I have Firefox set to block autoplay vids, and I also created a bookmarklet (look it up) that removes video elements from the web page. If you see a video playing, you can click on the button in your bookmark toolbar to execute javascript to kill the video. It leaves the video player visible, but it is now empty: it does not use bandwidth and it does not distract you. Here is the javascript. To use this, you need to create a button on your bookmarks toolbar, and add this as the URL: javascript:var x = document.querySelectorAll("video");var i;for (i = 0; i < x.length; i++) {x[i].parentNode.removeChild(x[i]);}undefined; One way to use this bookmarklet is to make a new button by dragging (say) this page's URL to your toolbar, then editing it to set the url to above, and renaming it to FixVid.
- derekpankaew 5y agoNews sites don't view people as "users" but as "pageviews". Clickbait and SEO drives pageviews, and you monetize pageviews by getting the highest payment per impression. This obv comes at a long term branding cost - but only large brands like New York Times can really afford to care about the long term. Most news sites are commoditized and barely surviving these days =/ I don't agree with the practice, but I also kind of understand why it's there.