10 ms·
> We need to erode all that capital concentration, and the only way to do it without hurting the regular guy is through heavy taxation. Bob bought a house this
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> We need to erode all that capital concentration, and the only way to do it without hurting the regular guy is through heavy taxation.
Bob bought a house this year. He paid $500,000 even though it should've been $200,000. He's paid $100,000 and still owes $400,000. If you cause his house to be worth $200,000, as it ought to be, regardless of the method, he's going to default on the loan and you'll have screwed him out of $100,000 and (at scale) bankrupted all the banks.
How is raising somebody else's taxes going to fix that?
> And now the FED can't really reverse it. If you start raising rates, and stopping QE, you're not actually getting the money back from the people you gave it to, you'll just get a lot of businesses to close.
The solution is to move the incentives back the other way.
Raise interest rates on debt. This will cause people to pay back existing debts. At the same time, print money and give it out to everyone. This will give people the money to use to pay back their debts, without screwing over the people who didn't take out debts to begin with, because they still get the money.
Now asset prices come down in real dollars, because people aren't as willing to borrow money to invest when interest rates are high. We need that not to happen in nominal dollars or everybody will be underwater on their mortgage, but that's okay, because we're printing a lot of money and all the people who didn't have debts to pay back are going to spend it. We get inflation, which counteracts the nominal fall in asset prices.
Instead of having asset prices fall to parity with wages and consumer prices and causing everyone to default on their mortgages, we need wages and consumer prices to rise to parity with asset prices.
It's got to be one or the other.
- chaorace 5y agoThat's a bit of a stretch, isn't it? Being underwater on a loan doesn't instantly bankrupt you. As long as Mr. Bob is actually living in his house and not just speculating on the market, he's still quite likely to come out ahead in the long run, despite the unfortunate setback.
- ricardonunez 5y agoYou don’t have to declare bankruptcy to default on a house. Many people did it 2008.
- kazinator 5y agoSure, as long as Mr. Bob doesn't have to move for reasons having nothing to do with speculation.
- 14 5y agoThis is kind of my mentality. I want to buy a house to live and die in it I don’t care if price goes up or down I just want my own place. Can someone explain why a market crash would be bad for someone like me who was poised to buy when the pandemic priced me out of the market? Why do I car if someone has multiple houses loses all their investments? This is a genuine question I would like to understand. Thanks
- jhickok 5y agoIt impacts your evaluation by lenders. If you are underwater on your house, even if you can afford the payments, carrying a net-negative balance on your house (owing 500k on a house valued 350k resulting in net assets of negative 150k), it can make it harder to buy a vehicle or cosign loans for your children etc etc.
- pxeboot 5y agoSource? I have been underwater on a home, and it's current value was never considered for anything not related to that property. It's not like banks send appraisers to your house everytime you apply for a credit card or auto loan.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoGood reasons by another post above: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29337344 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29337344
- CyanLite4 5y agoBecause “life happens”. You may need to move jobs, stay closer to your parents to help them as they get older, downsize after kids go to college, you may have grandkids that you want to be closer to. You may even have to move because your neighborhood demographics change and crime begins to rise. Climate change also will seriously mess things up since it’s not easily predictable at a local level. When that life change happens, if you try to sell your house in a market downturn, it would be at a tremendous loss where you would have to cover that shortfall in one single payment. Ex: you owe $500k mortgage on a house that’s only worth $300k, you would have to find $200k in cash (and no bank will lend this) to be able to sell your property. And if you can’t do that, well…then you can’t move. Alternatively, in a hot market, you could sell your house for 650k, and since you only owe 500k on it, you would get a $150k lump sum (tax free here in the USA). Even if you didn’t want to sell the place, you could still rent it out, and also take out a home equity line of credit, where you still could get nearly 80% of that 150k in a tax-advantaged lump sum and still have the rental cash flow coming in to pay for that loan while you’re living that lavish lifestyle. Since it’s a line of credit, you can extend this lavish lifestyle for quite a while until… you guessed it, the market tanks and you’re back underwater on your mortgage.
- refurb 5y agoIt takes a lot of mental effort to pay off a $400,000 loan on a house worth $200,000, especially knowing you could default and drastically reduce your monthly expenses.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoMore like Bob bought 10 houses at $500k/each, hoping to flip them in a year for $1m/each. If you cause his houses to be worth $200k, as they ought to be, he is really screwed. Raising taxes and/or raising interest rates decreases speculative forces. Property tax is especially effective in combating speculation, since you have to pay it even if you let the house sitting around waiting to appreciate and be sold (and worse, as it appreciates, you might have to pay more of it). Taxation that discourages speculation to the benefit of people actually looking for housing (and not assets that will appreciate) is a good idea. > Instead of having asset prices fall to parity with wages and consumer prices and causing everyone to default on their mortgages, we need wages and consumer prices to rise to parity with asset prices. Either housing prices fall back to earth, or the earth expands so that housing prices don't seem that high anymore :). The latter is obviously just old fashioned universal inflation (wages and consumer prices rise), and really screws someone saving for a housing downpayment (not to mention, loans would be harder to get as inflation picks up).
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> More like Bob bought 10 houses at $500k/each, hoping to flip them in a year for $1m/each. If you cause his houses to be worth $200k, as they ought to be, he is really screwed. That Bob is indeed really screwed, and so is the bank. But if we're printing a bunch of new money and giving it to everyone equally, that Bob doesn't get any more than the original one. > Raising taxes and/or raising interest rates decreases speculative forces. Raising interest rates especially, and that's the one I'm suggesting. The problem with raising property taxes is that it equally impacts people who aren't speculating. You have to pay the same amount even if you only bought a house because you needed somewhere to live; even if you're not borrowing the money. It also doesn't solve the general problem, because then people move money into things that aren't subject to property tax, like stocks. We don't need to deflate the housing bubble by creating a stock bubble the size of the sun. > Either housing prices fall back to earth, or the earth expands so that housing prices don't seem that high anymore :). Right, exactly. And housing prices falling screws people with mortgages and causes defaults, which is so bad that we haven't been able to solve it since 2008. > The latter is obviously just old fashioned universal inflation (wages and consumer prices rise), and really screws someone saving for a housing downpayment Their existing savings will be the same percentage of the house as it was before, because the nominal housing prices are staying the same -- inflation offset by higher interest rates. Then their nominal wages go up, so they can save the rest of it more quickly, which is the entire point. > (not to mention, loans would be harder to get as inflation picks up). Not harder to get, just higher interest rates. Which is, of course, the idea. If you want to make it easier to buy a house, fix zoning so we can build more housing.
- 01100011 5y agoYou have to avoid moral hazard. In a just world, Bob would get screwed because he took a risky bet. If you don't allow Bob to fail, you tell people they need to be more like Bob. Then you have a nation of Bobs and the game can never end. We need to let risk takers fail. They gambled and lost. That should serve as a warning to other risk takers to better calculate their exposure.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoBob didn't pay $500,000 for a house because he was trying to speculate in the housing market. He did it because he needed somewhere to live and that's how much houses cost when interest rates are held at 0% by the government. What is it that we were trying to get all the Bobs to do in the alternative?
- 01100011 5y agoLike it or not, Bob is an investor. He had a choice to rent or stay in his current residence. He is not compelled by any force to participate in an inflated housing market. He should do his due diligence and not assume risky bets that he is unable to handle.
- Spivak 5y agoEhhhh like I get where you’re coming from but it would be fantastically bad policy for a nation to treat housing like this. A person’s primary residence needs to play by different rules if you’re gonna crash the market semi purposely. When the forces that cause the market to crash are the feds monetary policy it’s a tough sell that it’s actually a free market. To first order individuals should be able to purchase shelter assured that it’s fairly priced. The concerns should be like “the foundation is cracked” not “JP Morgan is pumping house prices.”
- 01100011 5y agoIf you cause Bob's house to go back to being $200k then it only screws the Bobs. It doesn't screw the Mary's who bought at or below $200k. Your logic is what gets us into these messes, because it removes moral hazard by telling speculators that housing is special and therefore immune to risk. Of course it's not a free market. Has America ever had a free market? When is the last time that the real estate market hasn't been manipulated in some way?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- engineer_22 5y ago"At the same time, print money and give it out to everyone." Wouldn't this de-risk speculative investment and drive assets higher?
- mixmastamyk 5y agoYes, it’s their idea to mitigate high interest rates.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aceazzameen 5y agoAs someone who doesn't own a home yet because of insane competition, if I were to buy a home tomorrow and afford the mortgage, and suddenly the value dropped by $300k, I wouldn't care. I'm not looking for a home as an investment, which is the problem. I would still have that same home to live in and raise my family in. If anything, I might be able to reduce that fictional mortgage. I'm not in favor of homes dropping in value either, but if the argument is it's going to hurt investors, then let's do it.
- skuhn 5y agoI think you're seriously underestimating the problems a homeowner faces if they purchase a home (with a mortgage) and it later experiences a large reduction in value. This, by the way, is going to happen to a lot of people who have recently bought houses. First of all, buying a house for $1 million that is later worth $700,000 has no bearing on what is owed to the mortgage company. The mortgaged amount has already been paid to the original seller, that money is gone and the buyer has agreed to repay it. Defaulting on the mortgage can be done, but any money already paid will be lost and the borrower won't be able to obtain another mortgage for 7 years. Or the homeowner can continue to live in the home, but there are a few potential problems: 1. They cannot sell the house should their life situation change. Depending on the overall real estate market, they may also not be able to rent the house out for an amount that covers the mortgage payment. 2. Not only did they agree to pay $300,000 too much at purchase time, they also are continuing to pay interest on that amount. $1 million for 30 years at 3.5% is $616,000 in interest; $700,000 is $431,000 in interest. 3. The loan cannot be refinanced, because they don't have at least 20% equity in the house. Say that interest rates drop from 3.5% to 3.0% -- that would save $100,000 in interest over 30 years. But in order to refinance, they would need to pay the mortgage down to the point that they have 20% equity in the house (in this example pay the mortgage down to $440,000). 4. Since they have no equity, they cannot obtain a HELOC to help finance home repairs or life events in an emergency. So yes, investors and speculators will be hurt when their portfolio value drops and those are the risks you take when investing. Homeowners, however, are also hurt by the decline of home values.
- HWR_14 5y ago
- acchow 5y ago> If you cause his house to be worth $200,000, as it ought to be, regardless of the method, he's going to default on the loan You are conflating defaulting with underwater loans.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThat's what people do when they have deeply underwater loans. Who is going to pay a $350,000 loan secured by a $200,000 house when they could just walk away and then go buy a $200,000 house for $200,000?
- joe_the_user 5y agoBob bought a house this year. He paid $500,000 even though it should've been $200,000. He's paid $100,000 and still owes $400,000. If you cause his house to be worth $200,000, as it ought to be, regardless of the method, he's going to default on the loan and you'll have screwed him out of $100,000 and (at scale) bankrupted all the banks. -- The gp actually make this clear and is grasping for alternatives to this scenario rather than advocating. So you reply is either ignorant or disingenuous. Edit: Gp's quote before your quote - "If you start raising rates, and stopping QE, you're not actually getting the money back from the people you gave it to, you'll just get a lot of businesses to close." The same clearly goes for individuals.
- neilwilson 5y agoThat housing is an appreciating asset is the problem. That's a big red flag that something is wrong, and that's because houses wear out. Therefore they should depreciate like a car. The problem is not solved by messing about trying to control "Domestic Credit Expansion". Limiting the supply of money causes the problem by limiting the funding of housing production. The problem is the power of exclusion. Housing should be used for housing services, not hoarding. If the price of it is going up, all that is telling you is that there are insufficient housing services available, and there is some market failure that is stopping it being produced. The solution is anti-trust action and, if necessary, government intervention to limit the power of exclusion and directly produce more housing services until houses start to depreciate. Address the root cause, not the symptoms. The solution to asset prices going up is produce more of the required assets and stop people trying to corner the market in them. Nobody is suggesting that the price of used cars suddenly going up should be solved by reducing the loans available to buy them. It should be solved by sorting out the production issues for cars to put the market back where it normally is. Why not the same for housing services?
- rohitb91 5y agoHouses go down in value, land goes up in value on average, partly due to scarcity. Best example is Manhattan. Additional land is non existent, and any existing land becomes more valuable as more people and businesses move there.
- slt2021 5y agoits not the land that has value, it is the community on that land (police, public services, schools, parks, beautiful nature, access to jobs, etc) that has enormous value. Take Detroit for example, nothing has changed to the land itself, but the community has changed and caused land (and housing) prices to change. the way to solve it, I think is to build better communities, help with more construction of houses, parks, and building better public services (police, fire, public education, parks&recreation, etc). What should be the source of such funding? I dont know, but the American approach seems to be to use local funding from property taxes, but this approach only sustains status-quo, and does not help to improve struggling communities
- omegalulw 5y ago> Raise interest rates on debt. This will cause people to pay back existing debts. At the same time, print money and give it out to everyone. This will give people the money to use to pay back their debts, without screwing over the people who didn't take out debts to begin with, because they still get the money. This absolutely does screw over people who didn't take out debt. Yes you gave them money, but you also devalued the money they already had. And you have just driven up the price of houses and assets even more. > Instead of having asset prices fall to parity with wages and consumer prices and causing everyone to default on their mortgages, we need wages and consumer prices to rise to parity with asset prices. You can't just raise wages and consumer prices without raising asset prices - the people who are getting more wages would either loose that money on higher prices of goods or invest in assets - driving up their prices.
- d--b 5y agoYes, indeed. You can do a little bit of both too. Raising targeted taxes on very wealthy individuals and corporations is assuming that this wealth is going to be redistributed at the bottom somehow, effectively helping Bob not default on his loan. Printing money and giving it to everyone also risks causing more bubbles… Either method requires fine tuning…
- andy_ppp 5y agoHyper inflation on things other than housing will happen if you do this…
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe government inflated the price of speculative assets (housing and stocks) using long-term low interest rates. They're now totally out of whack relative to consumer goods and wages. Deflation causes defaults, the disproportionate wiping out of the wealth of the middle class (because mortgages are leveraged) and a financial crisis. Inflation, if done by printing money and giving it directly to individuals, reduces wealth inequality. To get things back into alignment, your choices are: deflate the price of those assets, or inflate the price of everything else. Which do you choose?
- splitstud 5y agoSo the solution you propose is raising interest rates even though the we couldn't afford the interest in our national debt? Then we ruin the value of household savings with inflation, raise taxes so that our economy falters from both lack of demand and higher costs for producers, thus ensuring neither individuals or companies can meet this higher tax burden?
- tehjoker 5y agoIn my opinion, you move the prices back to $200k and reprice the loans to the $200k price level. The banks take the haircut, Bob gets to continue to live in his house. Of course, this causes the financial system to fail, but fuck em. Let the government take over the financial sector.
- knicknic 5y agoThe banks don’t own the loans, the government does, or peoples retirmenet funds… How is repricing home loans going to affect banks?
- tehjoker 5y agoWell, I'm pretty sure the banks do in fact originate mortgages but if they are ultimately owned by the government, then given we print our own money and collect taxes, such things can be adjusted easily.
- solatic 5y ago> Raise interest rates... At the same time, print money So basically, take everyone sitting on mountains of cash (e.g. Apple) and start to pay enormous returns for keeping that money stationary, instead of investing it in the productive economy? > Now asset prices come down in real dollars, because people aren't as willing to borrow money to invest when interest rates are high The economy isn't composed of only "people". There are businesses too. Rising interest rates means that businesses borrow less money to build new factories, hire new people, and expand. Corporate finance takes available interest rates into consideration; it is literally one of the factors on which CFOs decide whether to start a given project or not. That ultimately translates into whether business start to lay people off or not. Look, I also think that interest rates should be brought up. But I also appreciate that it's not that simple.
- UncleMeat 5y agoApple doesn't have their cash in the bank. They operate a massive hedge fund. They are already receiving returns on that money.
- HWR_14 5y ago> If you cause his house to be worth $200,000, as it ought to be, regardless of the method, he's going to default on the loan Why would that be? If he locked in a low rate, his mortgage payments could still make sense. If it's a variable rate, then yeah.
- petre 5y ago> At the same time, print money and give it out to everyone. This will give people the money to use to pay back their debts Or they'll use it to buy booze, pot and iphones like most oeople did with the $2000 covid cash handouts.
- lumost 5y agoThe problem with raising interest rates is that there are many mechanisms by which exceptionally wealthy cash out borrowed dollars. Owing to how wealth is distributed the majority of QE has gone in this direction. Consider leveraged stock buybacks, leveraged dividends, selling to a greater fool, and simply owning corporations which are too big to ever go chapter 8/11 without taking the economy with them. Increasing rates will simply mean that these individuals can get paid by interest rates ( you have to borrow from someone after all ). The only strategies to break this wealth concentration involve punishing capital accumulation. Meaning inflation or taxation.
- dougabug 5y ago> Bob bought a house this year. He paid $500,000 even though it should've been $200,000. […] If you cause his house to be worth $200,000, as it ought to be […] An honest question: why “should” or “ought” the price have been $200k, instead of the actual selling price (assuming that this was a typical price for a comparable home in the area over the same time period)? Who gets to determine the canonical value of real estate, and how is this somehow more fair than market consensus?
- lumost 5y agoIn an ideal world, housing would be a depreciating asset class - other than scarcity there isn’t any reason for housing not to have a price comparable to its construction cost minus depreciation/renovations. We have many policies that for good and ill restrict housing supply and increase the marginal price for shelter. There isn’t any strong reason to believe that this pattern should or will continue indefinitely.
- dougabug 5y agoSaying that “in an ideal world” housing prices should be cost plus minus depreciation seems begging the question. Why is this ideal? Ideal for whom? Should all goods and services be priced using a cost plus model? What, then, would be the incentive for efficiency? Goods made by inexpensive means would be low priced by fiat, regardless of performance. I’m not saying that nothing should be cost plus, but there needs to be a strong justification for it.
- lumost 5y agoIn a standard market economy with many participants the incentive for efficiency is in productive portions of the economy being able to deliver more for the same cost. In a cost+ model of value the cost is typically assessed in terms of building new today. If the original builder was particularly inefficient then it will lead to a lower valuation for the home as new buyers consider the cost of building new. This process incentivises more efficient means of production, when goods become very cheap relative to performance then consumers of that good can spend money elsewhere. In practice most material goods should be on a cost plus pricing model for this reason. The alternative is scarcity economics which hardly incentivizes efficiency but instead rewards market timing, monopolies, and other activities which don't do a lot to make the world better in the future.
- boublepop 5y ago> How is raising somebody else's taxes going to fix that? Just raise the taxes on peoples 3’rd or 4th home. It will definitely screw over a lot of real estate investors and banks, but that’s sort of the deal with investment risk, and after more than a decade of state guaranteed return on this investments it’s about time for and quite fair with a state guaranteed shakedown. This will cause the market to drop, and the unfortunate ones who overspent on their primary recode are will have a big loss, which you help reduce through tax breaks for people owning no more than one home.
- hapless 5y agoIf interest rates go up, homeowners are instantly underwater on their mortgages. Purchase cost on housing is very, very tightly correlated with the interest rates, because shoppers' budgets are determined by their monthly payments, not by the total cost of the house. When interest rates go up, potential buyers can't afford to borrow as much money, and prices have to fall.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- montblanc 5y agoI like your thought process and it might be a good way to go. > Raise interest rates on debt. This will cause people to pay back existing debts But this is risky for the stock market right? interest rates on debt are connected to the fed's interest rate and to bonds yields. Higher bond yields = stocks are less appealing. That could be fine during normal times but the stock market is very very high so the risk for a huge crash is high. Who knows what the result of a stock market crash might be, the 30s were one huge depression. During the current political climate I can see why the high-ups want to avoid that. But It's something to think about what you're suggesting and it's very possible what you're suggesting will happen in some form or another.