27 ms·
Corded headphones are making an unexpected return
- RachelF 5y agoPity most phone manufacturers have got rid of the headphone jack in their recent models.
- rhdunn 5y agoThe thing that annoys me about bluetooth headphones is the really loud "Battery Low" notifications, especially on headsets that think that it is a good idea to spam the notification every 5 minutes and mute the audio while giving the notification. Other than that, I like the mobility that you get with bluetooth headsets.
- dehrmann 5y agoRemember the iPod commercials from, well, the only time people bought iPods? I'm far from an Apple fanboy, but they were pretty iconic. The music was spot-on, the actors and choreography amazing, and the white silhouette of the headphones sold it perfectly.
- sdze 5y agoAirpods are throwaway products. After 1 year of active use, my 150€ AirPods offer only a mere 90min listening time. And if it is cold outside, it can go down to about 40mins. I will never buy them again >:-/
- Aerroon 5y agoIf it had been up to me I would've rather removed Bluetooth functionality from phones rather than the headphone jack. Bluetooth never seems to work quite right and it'll probably forever be a security/privacy issue. I would even take the audio jack over the front camera and Bluetooth both.
- jbverschoor 5y agoAirpod battery dies within minutes after 2 years of use. Never again will I buy them. Soundquality no that clear as wires. Glitchy, and even brand new ones dimply don't last long enough. Also, the wires function as a parachute sometimes, saving me screen repairs. The new macbook pro has phantom power, so it can drive my sennheisers.
- no1lives4ever 5y agoYou may want to try out services like this one: https://www.thepodswap.com/products/airpods-battery-replacement-swap https://www.thepodswap.com/products/airpods-battery-replacem...
- bitwize 5y agoThis trendoid is so caught up with fashion movements and countermovements that they can't see the obvious truth: wired earbuds are cheap, deliver good sound without further compression artifacts or just plain cutting out due to body interference, and do not need their own batteries that need to be charged. Their simplicity also makes them relatively durable. An excellent value proposition for music on the go.
- Gravityloss 5y agoI was reading this as "corded telephones". In Helsinki, a few guys turned a brutal concrete block house into a retrofuturistic haven, including corded phones and neon lights.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- brassattax 5y agoApparently I'm fashionable again. Wait long enough..
- makecheck 5y agoI have never really gotten used to wireless buds, and still find myself reaching for wires half the time: - Wireless buds don’t connect 100% reliably; sometimes I get one and not the other, or neither. Sometimes they will randomly disconnect during use. - Sometimes the sound glitches out randomly, which is so irritating that I don’t care how good the sound supposedly is the rest of the time. - Gestures and voice are simply not as convenient as buttons on the wire. If I tap the thing in my ear, it tends to get shoved further into my ear and may still not register. - They fall out of my ears, no matter how “snug” they seem. This makes me only want to use them in places where I won’t lose them, e.g. at home but not out for a walk. Crucially, there isn’t a single problem above that occurs when using wires. The only inconvenience is that the default headphone wires are stupidly short (provided by a company that sells wireless buds, hmmm) but that is fixable.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- herbst 5y agoI have a pair of really good wired Sennheisers. I never owned or used Bluetooth devices for more than giving it a try. I may be audiophile. But when I put a music on I want to get fully absorbed and hear every little detail while I don't worry about battery life. Sounds weird I know
- Vrondi 5y agoWhen you do try bluetooth again, try full cans from a good brand. No earbuds at all. Check which codecs the cans will use. Just cans vs earbuds makes a hug sound and comfort difference. Literally, you get larger drivers and a larger battery, so physics is already on your side vs earbuds.
- herbst 5y agoI think the only wireless 'full cans' I've tried are beats which I don't like the sound profile of anyway. Also larger battery surely will decrease the comfort from its weight? However I keep my ears open :)
- squarefoot 5y agoYes, they aren't a novelty anymore, they don't screen from other people effectively, cheap clones are almost identical, too many people use them and the cool factor dropped, yadda yadda yadda. ...or maybe most users after some years realized the true costs of having non replaceable batteries. Making them replaceable on the AirPods would be very easy; and a nice move that would also bring them some more customers including me, but apparently milking users to the last cent pays more.
- fastball 5y agoHow would it be very easy to make the battery user replaceable? I don't even know where they stuck the battery.
- dghlsakjg 5y agoI’ve resoldered the batteries on my generic wireless earbuds that were very much meant not to be serviceable. It really wouldn’t be hard to make them serviceable, even if they weren’t user replaceable. There’s one in each bud, and another in the case. A battery only needs two electrical contacts on a component that is already self contained. Its a very simple device. The lithium ion ones in this size range are a few bucks each on the wholesale market. There are even standardized button cell sizes. It is very much a design choice. The other side of it is that lithium ion battery tech is at the point where the battery lifespans is starting to exceed the device lifespan. Certainly true for the cheap side of the earbud market
- squarefoot 5y agoThe battery is contained in the stick coming down from the AirPod body. They could make them threaded with concentric tracks at the top making contact with springs, so the user could simply unscrew them and swap with fresh ones, so that the parts cost of replacing the battery would be the battery itself plus a piece of plastic, some wire and a small almost empty pcb, surely not the entire device.
- brewdad 5y ago
- fbelzile 5y ago> For disorganized types, corded headphones are easier to keep track of and needn’t be charged. This is why I've never bought wireless headphones. You don't need to be disorganized to appreciate the convenience of not having to charge yet another device you want to use on the fly. Why would I pay more for something that takes more mental bandwidth to use?
- fastball 5y agoAirPods kinda solved this problem with the wireless charging case. I almost never use them long enough to drain the battery in the headphones before they get put back in the case. At night I put the case on my wireless charging thingy and I don't really ever "think" about charging my AirPods. My wireless headphones I do occasionally have to think about charging, but they are USB-C and mostly I'm using them on my computer, so whenever they need charging I just unplug my USB-C computer, plug in my headphones for an hour, and then we're back. Not really an operation I think about much either. If I really want to I can then plug in the wired cable and still listen to them while they're charging, but usually I don't bother.
- chmod775 5y ago> At night I put the case on my wireless charging thingy and I don't really ever "think" about charging my AirPods. You just did. Us absent-minded people are likely to forget even putting those things back into their case, forget the case at home or some other place (since we don't need it to listen), or forget to charge it. My stuff is likely to be in the last place I stopped using it. In this case that's hopefully my jacket, but it certainly won't be some charging station. My wired earphones I can wear under my shirt with only a small chance of losing them. I still lose those occasionally, but mostly I break them every six months. A new pair is ten bucks, so whatever. I already have trouble keeping my phone charged. I don't need more stuff with batteries. Especially not in something that's never supposed to be more than a few centimeters from the device it's receiving signals from anyways.
- fastball 5y ago
- bluedino 5y agoI wear three pairs of headphones. 1. Sennheiser earbuds that are on a Lightning adapter. I keep them in my desk at work, and use them for phone calls a few times a week. 2. Sony 1000MX or whatever they are called. Bluetooth, noise-cancelling, full size. The battery lasts like 20 hours so they go with me on the airplane and some car rides, but don't use them too much otherwise. They also can be used with a cord which is great when you need that. 3. Aukey Bluetooth earbuds, they are only $18 and "good enough", fit in my laptop sleeve. These get used the most out of any of them.
- xaduha 5y agoPandemic is still not over, wireless earbuds are much more convenient with a mask.
- wintorez 5y agoI try to avoid things with irreplaceable batteries as much as possible.
- derekp7 5y agoI used to feel that way, but then I've got a drawer full of old gear with replaceable batteries that I can't get the batteries for anymore. Would be much more useful if rechargeable lithium batteries were standardized. Also I probably wouldn't really want to use any of these devices even if I could get a battery for them as the technology has moved so much since I originally got them.
- vorpalhex 5y agoA lot of those batteries are probably easy enough to source the cells for. Usually just the adapter is what differs. Larger packs are usually discrete cells at that.
- Gigachad 5y agoMost of them would be those flat lithium batteries. You can find endless replacements on eBay. Only they are all just as dead as the one you have.
- vorpalhex 5y agoYou can buy them directly from any electronics shop. It's not as if your device maker is rolling their own packs. I would avoid buying sketchy batteries.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- adzm 5y agoAlso, latency. I can't get over it.
- Someone1234 5y agoI have Bluetooth headphones (WH-1000XM4) that I use on a PC. They work great for music, but for video content the latency is very perceptual. It is sub-second, but you can tell actor's mouths aren't in sync. Unfortunately there isn't a lot of solutions on PC, since the platform has no control of browser based video playback and even if it did, finding the exact audio offset would be impractical.
- RNCTX 5y ago> finding the exact audio offset would be impractical. And yet you can land an airplane without looking out the windows, by measuring timestamps between source and destination of a signal (GPS). I'd argue not that impractical.
- MaulingMonkey 5y agoVLC and other video players have options to tweak video/audio latency to get them to syncronize by delaying whatever's ahead by a fixed amount to more accurately match the other. There are even chrome extensions proporting to let you tweak such syncronization for youtube, although I haven't tested them. You don't need to find the exact audio offset either - just close enough that you can't tell anymore. But this only helps with less interactive media. Adding even more latency to video games or MIDI keyboard synthesizers is counterproductive: sure, you could delay the rendering of a muzzle flash to match the playing of a gunshot, but that makes things feel even worse when you click! Maybe tolerable in a casual macro-focused RTS, but not so acceptable in a twitch shooter.
- sundvor 5y agoFortunately you can hook them up to a good soundcard quite easily! Something like the Soundblaster ZXR makes for exceptionally good headphone listening on the PC. I have the XM3 and some wired-only Audio Technicas. I only use the XM3s wired on the PC, can't stand the lag however small myself.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- m_ke 5y agoI have two pairs of airpods, one is practically dead and the other keeps falling out of my ear when I tilt my head. The only reason why I still use them is because I'd need to carry around 3 different wired pairs to connect to my MacBook, iPhone and iPad...
- jrm4 5y agoThe 1/8th inch RCA stereo jack is the best interface ever created. The fact that it's essentially unchanged from when this 44 year old used it in middle school is pretty good proof.
- coldtea 5y agoThe US power plug and socket is also unchanged, and yet it's a crap design.
- coin 5y agoWhat's so bad about them?
- lmm 5y agoEasy to mispolarise, not earthed, not safe when partially inserted.
- Eelongate 5y ago> Easy to mispolarise I've never given polarization any thought and never had any problems, so I don't buy this being an actually a problem in practice. > not earthed NEMA-1 aren't earthed, but NEMA-1 sockets have been forbidden since the 60s, so that fails the "unchanged" part of coldtea's assertion. NEMA-1 plugs may still be used on Class II double insulated appliances, which is fine. And NEMA-5 does have a ground. > not safe when partially inserted. I've never worried about it, never been hurt by it, and never heard of anybody being hurt by it. This is a "problem" that I often hear described by Europeans online but it's totally alien to me. Please remember that we only put 120V through these things, which is substantially less nippy than 240V.
- NobodyNada 5y ago> I've never worried about it, never been hurt by it, and never heard of anybody being hurt by it. Just as my anecdotal experience: I've shocked myself at least twice because my finger slipped over the contacts while I was trying to plug/unplug something in the dark. I have of course learned my lesson and am much more careful when plugging stuff in, but it's a relatively easy mistake to make if one is tired or not paying attention. Yes, I got shocked because I was stupid and careless. But a connector that everybody uses every single day should be idiot-proof -- it should not be possible to kill myself because I plugged something in carelessly. The US has the "excuse" of being the first domestic power distribution system -- other countries have better standards because they were able to learn from the design flaws in our plugs. And our split-phase 120V system is (as far as I know) a great idea that's way safer than direct 240V. But there really are a lot of things that the NEMA plugs leave to be desired. I second the recommendation by a sibling commenter to check out Technology Connection's videos on the subject -- I found them to be entertaining, nuanced, and highly informative.
- senectus1 5y agonever liked plugging things in my ears unless to wipe out loud noises. I often plug in earphones when mowing the lawn or vacuuming / woodworking. Otherwise I use "bone conducting" headphones to listen to podcasts and audiobooks. I rarely listen to music this way, I only seem to like music that's played out loud.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ddingus 5y agoBest music is live. Second best and sometimes a tie is music reproduced on a good system, room filling. That said, I do enjoy music playing down with good earbuds. Miss feeling the low end, but it can be nice.
- kevindeasis 5y agoAuthor's opinion is subjective and falls under selection bias. There's a lot of famous people that don't use wired headphones For the wireless argument, here is mine. I use an airpods pro. I also have multiple high end headphones. I only apple os with wireless. If I was using linux, android, windows then I have to use my other headphones, since my bluetooth always have issues with wireless using other os. The airpods pro is probbably my favourite headphones that I have. I use it 95% of the time The only time I use wired headphones is if I need to use my amp when I really need/want to listen to the quality of something or if im using non apple os. Wires are a pain in the a$% for me personally and ironically more fragile than my airpods pro. It's hard to move around with wires and they tangle a lot wether if im wearing them or not. The airpods pro are small and you can have noice cancelling, transparency, and normal mode. The only downside is I have to charge them every 5~ hours. They connect to my phone, and my 3 computers easily without unhooking the wires. The only annoying thing about the airpods pro is that people don't know that i have something in my ear because my hair is long and I am listening to something. When they are trying to start a conversation I usually can't hear them. The only time they fall out of my ears is if im cleaning the house cause im moving my head around too much. They don't even fall when I'm working out or running
- bananamerica 5y agoPlease point me to an opinion that is not subjective.
- ddingus 5y agoLol, I always liked that line. People like what they like. Forcing it just does not go well, unless the reasons are really good. I was, and am seriously put off by the omission of analog audio jacks. Most of the reasons given just do not resonate and sometimes it is stated or strongly implied I am somehow the problem.
- scns 5y agoI'd guess it is tribalism at work. Different opinion -> Not my tribe.
- fuzxi 5y agoFulltext archive: https://archive.md/A9Mm0 https://archive.md/A9Mm0
- secureleaf 5y agoI might be in the minority here, but wired headphones have always been a disaster for me. I only buy wireless ones now, even though they're fraught with their own issues. It seems like there's always a tradeoff to be made, specifically regarding quality. My biggest complaint has been the damage that I've always seem to have done to the headphone jacks of devices that I use. I'm not harsh on my devices, but I do tend to put my phone in my pocket and walk around with headphones on. And if it's not the headphone jack that gets destroyed, it's the cable; I went through ~5 different cables/earbuds when I was using the Shure SE215s. Bluetooth headphones aren't great either. I have not lost a pair of headphones in years, but I've gone no more than 12 months without purchasing a new pair. This gets expensive when I also want my headphones to have active noise cancelling and sound reasonably good (I don't care about audiophile cans, because I wear my headphones primarily when I'm active). And don't even get me started on a pair that has a good (not even great) mic... I'd love to be able to have a phone conversation when walking through midtown Manhattan.
- rootusrootus 5y agoEven if they're not cool anymore, I hope they keep making them. I don't even mind buying a new pair every few years if the batteries get too worn out. I use them when I work out, I use them for zoom meetings, and sometimes even to listen to music :). I charge the case once in a while, probably every couple weeks, aside from that I rarely run the airpods themselves out of battery -- takes a few long zoom calls to do it, and then I just alternate ears if I need to. Corded headphones at my desk use to make me so angry. Always tangling. And with earbuds, cord noise. I don't miss corded headphones.
- Gigachad 5y agoSometimes I wonder what fantasy land HN readers come from. I was standing at a traffic light as I opened this thread and I looked around at the people near me, I saw several AirPods users and no other brands or wired users. The AirPods alone bring in more profit than most major tech companies. Why in earth would they stop making them?
- HKH2 5y agoI have never had earbuds fall out of my ears. I used to worry that it would happen and it never has.
- LAC-Tech 5y agoWired in ear phones are a nightmare. If I use them every day I end up going through about 2 pairs a year. No I am not surgically precise with them, but at the same time I'm not a gorilla - nothing else in my life breaks this much.
- sudosysgen 5y agoBuy some with replaceable cables. I use KZ ZSX and I keep a spare cable, if it ever breaks no biggie thats 4$
- timeon 5y agoIs $ the only issue?
- sudosysgen 5y agoIt's a big one. The cables are cheap enough that you can buy a second one and keep it in your backpack for complete peace of mind. Other IEMs have cables that cost much more and you might not preemptively carry one.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- GekkePrutser 5y agoTrue but they cost almost nothing. 5 bucks for a decent pair of Sonys. Though I have to say the Bluetooth ones are also really cheap now. I got a Xiaomi true wireless pair for 15 bucks and they work amazingly well.
- brewdad 5y agoThis. I used to run daily with a pair of Sony corded earbuds that hooked over my ear. I think they cost me $10 and lasted about a decade before I finally bought a phone without a headphone jack. They now live in my carry-on bag for use with the inflight entertainment systems.
- poink 5y agoI love my AirPods Pro because I can take them on a run with my Apple Watch and be able to listen to music + do guided runs without having to carry anything else. Glad I bought them just for that. They suck otherwise. I have these wired earphones I bought 5 years ago for $99 that I use most of the rest of the time. They sound better, fit better, connect 100% reliably, and I don't have to worry about their batteries dying in the middle of something because they randomly decided not to charge last time I put them in the case. I'd rather have no wires, but AirPods are a significant compromise to get rid of a wire... I find it's rarely worth it. Only the one use case, actually. Same for the watch.
- ddingus 5y agoI like this idea. Tried a few early on when jacks were being omitted from phones. The whole thing put me off big. So I dug in, bought a backup phone with jack and am just camping on good gear to wait a while and see what comes. Maybe I will put a set in my carry bag.
- fartcannon 5y agoI'm an old man now so I can't speak for cool kids, but the sheer amount of old people who love and rock Apple gear would be more than enough to make them seem powerfully uncool to a teenage me. Apples got a bad case of the Facebook mom's group, basically. (No offence to the mom groups, you've given me so much help over the years)
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoI use a little Bluetooth to 3.5mm adapter and clip it on to my wired headphones. This one is the fiio ubtr which is nice and tiny tho a little more battery life would be nice. I designed my headphones to be 3D printed on a resin 3D printer and I wired them with a short cable going to a male 3.5mm jack. I can plug them in to a Bluetooth adapter or just use 3.5mm male to female extension to use them as wired headphones. I love the flexibility. I have photos and source files on GitHub here: https://github.com/tlalexander/reboot-headphones https://github.com/tlalexander/reboot-headphones There is a newer design in the linked OnShape document which is smaller and uses two 3mm titanium rods for a headband. They’re really nice and they’ve been my daily headphones for what feels like a year now. I love knowing that no matter what breaks on them they can be repaired forever.
- ddingus 5y agoCool! Thanks for sharing your project.
- zz865 5y agoCan we get the headphone sockets back please?
- ddingus 5y agoSeconded. I am willing to continue to try on wireless ones, but NEED my wired ones.
- walterbell 5y agoThirded. Will buy a dozen sacrificial dongles if that will please the gods.
- PikachuEXE 5y agoOne of the issues with wireless buds/headphones for me is the DAC (Digital-to-Analog Converter). The DAC is quite critical for final sound quality (responses to different frequencies, amount of noise...). Most wireless use built-in DAC and provide no method for using an external/standalone one. Another obvious issue would be the connection stability which is why I still use 3.5mm on my iPhone 6s (or previously iPhone 8 but requires an adapter).
- Skunkleton 5y agoHow would you envision using an external DAC with Bluetooth headphones?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hammock 5y agoYeah it would have to be connected via wire to the headphones. Lol
- starky 5y ago>The DAC is quite critical for final sound quality (responses to different frequencies, amount of noise...). This incorrect statement is a bit of a pet peeve of mine. A DAC on its own is useless for listening to sound, it always has to be accompanied by an amplifier stage. I honestly don't know why people have become focused on the part of a DAC+Amp circuit that rarely matters. If a DAC makes any difference to the sound quality of the device, then it is a bad DAC. All a DAC should do is output the exact analog signal that was sampled in the digital file (provided it is below the Nyquist-Shannon frequency). Even dirt cheap commodity DAC chips do this well beyond what any human can hear. If there is any fuckery with the sound, it is probably due to the implementation of the pre-amp or amplifier circuits in the device which have far more ability to introduce distortion or noise to the signal, or introduce a sound signature.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoOh hey, I just bought my first pair of corded earphones in basically forever. I don't know everyone else's reasons but here are mine: 1. So-called chi-fi (Chinese Hi Fi) has made huge strides and I was able to get a really great pair of IEMs from a company called TinHiFi for $70. Definitely the best sounding pair of in-ear headphone's I've ever had, and rival some wired regular headphones I've owned in the past as well. 2. Bluetooth is worse than Hitler.
- causi 5y agoI carry a set of wireless earbuds in my pockets 90% of the time. They still haven't replaced wired headphones for me, for two reasons: 1. Lag-free audio. Even if I didn't play videogames and need instant audio response, Windows makes no attempt whatsoever to compensate for audio lag. Android does a decent job when it comes to Youtube, but embedded videos on the web are still wildly out of sync. 2. Comfort. I've spent hundreds of dollars on various TWS earbuds and not a single one of them is comfortable when I'm laying on my side in bed. My wired buds are entirely comfortable that way. Oh and it's also quite annoying that you have to choose between wireless buds with physical buttons that hurt to push or ones with capacitive buttons that are liable to get triggered to start playing again after you take them out and put them in your pocket. The idea a 3.5mm jack takes up a huge amount of space in a phone is so much bullshit.
- bagels 5y agoI'm always amazed that more people aren't bothered by having to constantly charge wireless headphones. Wired ones never run out of battery.
- speedgoose 5y agoThey charge quickly and the battery lasts a while.
- redisman 5y agoApples design genius really shows here. The container that you’d immediately lose the buds without charges them
- monocasa 5y agoI got a free pair of samsung buds woth the same idea. I just forget to charge the case too.
- brewdad 5y agoThis is my biggest pet-peeve. I bought a pair of bluetooth headphones that sound pretty good for their price (Cowin for about $50). They offer a corded option, so I can use them when a plug is needed, like watching a movie on a plane. BUT they will not work at all, even in corded mode, unless they are charged. If I forgot to charge them, I'm stuck with nothing and they are too bulky to deal with that. So now they get used at home and I travel with cheap earbuds.
- Gigachad 5y agoI charge mine about once a week. I have a cable sitting on the desk I work at and I’ll notice when the case is almost flat as I open it which prompts me to plug it in.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoI plug them in before I go to bed. They are fully charged in the morning and last me the whole day. I've never run it down to zero. My phone also charges at night. Same thing. I have a high end over ear pair for when I'm working. It blocks out the noise and the neighbors. It's on my head pretty much all the time when I'm at home. 16 hours is not unusual. Having the freedom of movement is very nice. For outdoors, I have a cheap set of bluetooth earphones (25 euros). Not the greatest quality but plenty OK for listening podcasts. Surprisingly comfortable and they have a soft plastic handle that wraps around my ears to keep them in place. They supposedly last about 6 hours. And the case allows me to charge them 3 or 4 times or so. They only need to be plugged in once every two weeks or so.
- jurassic 5y agoWhat kills me about wireless is when I need to switch sources. E.g. from my work laptop to my phone and vice versa. Or from my work laptop to my personal laptop. Perhaps Airpods do a better job here, but my experience with Bose and Sony wireless headphones has been terrible on switching sources... I have to manually unpair from device A and repair with device B. In the case of Bose this handoff is mediated by an iOS app that seems to crap out 50% of the time. It often takes several minutes to get everything working as it should. This does not feel like a $350 UX. It makes me rage when I think of the ease and speed I had in the past with wired headphones that can be instantly unplugged from A and plugged into B quickly with 100% reliability.
- julianlam 5y agoI don't understand this complaint, are Bose and Sony headphones only pairable with one device? Seems a little short-sighted... My $30 Anker headphones are able to pair to at least two devices...
- redisman 5y agoBose experience is very underwhelming for a $300 pair. Mandatory iOS app to change many settings, it fights me every day about the active noise cancellation (I want it off but it keeps turning on), using the microphone seems to bug out 70% of the time, opening the “Input” tab on MacOS sound settings makes them all crackly until I turn them off.. just an absurd amount of problems. I’m very happy with my corded audio technicas over 10+ years I’ve had them and surprisingly the wireless buds I got off Amazon (Tozo T-6). Even though those still have about 25% of the issues the boses have
- morsch 5y agoMany more recent bt headphones support multipoint, but I'm not sure any support more than two simultaneous connections. This meant I was back to disabling Bluetooth on my tablet when I wanted to use the Jabra 85hs to the TV. And I was naive enough to think that the sound from the two connections would be mixed, so you could, for example listen to music on my phone while hearing audible notifications from the computer (without the music dropping out). As with anything BT, it's a mixed bag. That said, after resisting it for a long time, those Jabras were one of the best things I ever bought. https://www.soundguys.com/bluetooth-multipoint-explained-28601/ https://www.soundguys.com/bluetooth-multipoint-explained-286...
- arpa 5y agoCorded earphones: * never run out of juice * never have internal noise/audible hiss * never have trouble connecting * you can hear your vinyl rip FLAC as it is, not subjected to lossy psychoacoustic compression * you can use a variety of devices spanning decades to listen your music on
- invalidname 5y agoYes! And: * Cheap * Better for the environment by a mile * Much harder to lose The one downside is the damn tangled wire.
- ddingus 5y agoMaterials can help with this to some degree. When good materials are in use, the tangles are fewer and easier to sort out. I like materials that resist bending after a fairly large minimum radius. More could be done IMHO.
- tehjoker 5y agoOnce I learned this trick to folding the wire, I never had that problem ever again: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9D_oV14dGmM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9D_oV14dGmM EDIT: Some people in the comments seem to think this shortens the life of the cable, but I've never had problems with Apple earbuds or Bose headphones (that have a replaceable wire anyway). EDIT2: Another advantage of wired headphones if you want the wire out of the way and to make them less visible: Just thread them through your shirt!
- theshrike79 5y ago* will at one point start mysteriously crackling unless you hold the wire in that one weird angle from that one spot
- atoav 5y agoWho buys headphones without replaceable cable?
- sandworm101 5y agoMilitary perspective. If you are wearing a helmet and running around all day there is aren't any products that will stay in your ears. On long marches it is normal for young soldiers to abandon any concept of headphones in favor of full speakers. They put one, sometimes two, speaker in the top of their pack and simply blast music for everyone around them to hear. The effect is the ultimate retro, harkening back to the days of ghettoblaste/boomboxes.
- Animats 5y agoiDweebs are back!
- armchairhacker 5y agoCorded headphones have much better latency than wireless headphones, which is essential when recording and making music. Wireless earbuds or bone-conduction headphones are essential when working out.
- dorianmariefr 5y agoAlso corded headphones don't require battery
- shmerl 5y ago> Since Apple launched the Bluetooth-enabled headphones in 2016, they’ve become an inescapable feature of daily life Really? I thought bluetooth headphones were a thing way before Apple woke up about it. This "Apple made wireless headphones the feature of daily life" is just bizarre to me. May be for people who are stuck with Apple, anything that happens outside it doesn't exist.
- Gigachad 5y agoIt’s hard to understate how successful apple was with wireless headphones. I opened this thread while standing on the street, and as I look around, _all_ of the headphones I saw were AirPods. The AirPods are by far the most successful headphones ever.
- shmerl 5y agoDepends on where you are. May be in your area Apple usage is disproportionally dominating, so you simply don't see anything else. I don't buy this whole "Apple made it common" thing in general. They just like to present as novelty what existed long before they decided they think their users should start using it. And their users start thinking it's common when Apple decides for them.
- Johnny555 5y agoI've pulled my phone off the desk too many times to go back to wired (the laptop is heavy enough that it yanks the headphones off my head). But I'm still old school enough to use over-the-air headphones (Bose QC 35 II currently). It's nice to be able to walk away from the computer without worrying about the wire. And if I triple-check the mute setting to be sure I'm muted, I can even make it to the bathroom (or to the kitchen for a glass of tea) during a long zoom meeting without losing the call.
- stillblue 5y agoBeing able to move around a lot has been super helpful for me with the QC35 IIs. I've gone everywhere inside the house, the occasional smoke breaks, running downstairs to pick up an order and so on. This pair has a surprisingly good range
- zaptheimpaler 5y agoWireless headphones suck. I have a good pair (WF-1000XM3) because my phone doesn't have an audio jack and they are always a pain. They connect to the wrong device frequently, the battery life is barely a few hours and the sound quality is ok. Always have trouble with voice quality on calls too. Often only one headphone will turn on but not the other. They are supposedly easier to carry because no cords, but they are harder because I need to carry two things (case + headphones) most of the time instead of one. Given how low the battery life is, carrying the case is essential In contrast, my wired headphones are 100x easier - i plug them in and they work. It takes less time than fiddling with bluetooth and they are 100% reliable.
- roopawl 5y agoI had those too. AirPods are incredible and will change your mind about wireless headphones
- _emacsomancer_ 5y ago*As long as you don't need to connect to any non-Apple devices.
- thrashh 5y agoI use my AirPods Pro with my main laptop that uses Windows.
- _emacsomancer_ 5y agoTheir codec availability for non-Apple is not great. They really work best inside the Apple ecosystem.
- californical 5y agoThey definitely can pair with any Bluetooth device
- skinkestek 5y ago
- ddingus 5y agoI just bought a few Samsung OEM Earbuds tuned by AKG. I wanted to stock up because I am not gonna switch for a long while yet, if I ever do. They are flat out amazing! Beware of knockoffs, rejects and counterfeits however. I blew about $50, until I found a seller with the real deal, new old stock. 5 pair cost me about $25 each all in, including tossing the garbage ones. These things were $100 originally. I scored and am super happy about it. I have tried a few bluetooth sets. Some are pretty good. If I had to, I could use them, but would be missing my wired ones constantly. The issues for me and wireless ones are: -Losing one. -Then losing the same one again! That would anger me considerably. A family member did it. I fear doing it myself. -Mic quality might be good, but I have tested the audio others get, and it is kind of lousy, like 5Khz or maybe 8Khz. AM quality. This is all software related, so air understand. Sometimes it is better. Depends on... and frankly I did not bother past that because my wired ones are always awesome, and remain that way even when in a car window down. Others can hardly tell. I get compliments on my call audio quality all the time on the wired pair, and they work great on my laptop and phone. Ok, moving on... -Another charge to manage. Some people have a phone, watch, laptop and or tablet, earbuds... I got fat batteries for my phone and laptop. Can sometimes go a couple days. Can always go a whole, long day on the go. I hate charging management. -Audio quality incoming to my ears ranges from good to crap. Nothing has been exemplary like the Samsung earbuds are. Seriously, they are great. They are better than my ears. Perfect. -Pairing. Mostly works. May require voodoo when it does not work. To be fair, most worked great on my Samsung Note phone. I expected worse. Win 10 laptop seems a bit worse. Audio just is not great. Hard shell design on many models do not acoustically couple to my ears well. Many I have tried do not have the tuning to get rid of resonances, response peaks and the like. -Requires dongle / Adapter to work with all my gear. This is yet another thing to carry around, and need. -Cost. (Though frankly, I will pay for good stuff.) Pros: -No wires! I really like that, and it is compelling. I totally get why people want it. -Ambient sounds get through. I generally use one ear on my earbuds for that use case, but using two with how the ambient sounds can work is nice. Summary: We are closer! But, when one uses the crap out of earbuds professionally as well as personally, there is no contest. Wired sets, good ones to be clear, just work and they rule! More people can make good use out of wireless ones than ever before, and that is good. But, the people who count on performance, need it bulletproof and high quality at all times will struggle.
- voldacar 5y agoI was a little disappointed that by "corded headphones" they meant "corded earbuds"
- betwixthewires 5y agoUnexpected? I've been using them, never stopped, never bought Bluetooth headphones. Passively powered peripherals are always superior to actively powered peripherals.
- code51 5y agoBluetooth headphones are a nightmare when your computer is under heavy load.
- ilvez 5y agoIt does not have to be one or the other. I use wireless outside to listen audio books and podcasts and for this purpose they are ideal. Audio quality not so important. Wouldn't want to go back messing with wire on the street, have been destroying many wires and pairs because I'm clumsy. At home when listening music, have some wired higher end comfortable overears, perfect sound quality and comfort. Working with noise cancelling overears, most important are ANS and when meetings one can move around freely and not be attached to device. So I'm using them in combination, based on what's the situation.
- deanc 5y agoI consider myself somewhat of a sceptic when it comes to a lot of technology. I'm quite surprised at the level of discontent with bluetooth headphones and "buds" in this thread. I own 1000XM4's and Airpods and absolutely love them. I never have bluetooth drop-outs. My only issues are: - Multi-device on the Sony's is still a bit shit. Works pretty well on Airpods. A little too well at times (e.g. time on phone interrupts audio from laptop) - The seal of airpods is not great, but this not unique to the airpods. You can supposedly buy custom memory-foam tips but I've not gone down that path yet.
- Buldak 5y agoI don't mind wireless earbuds for walking around town, but my primary use for earbuds is running and cycling, and I've found wired earbuds more practical here. The wireless earbuds I've tried are heavier, bulkier and more prone to falling out (they're especially bad for running); they don't work with the devices I prefer (like my iPod shuffle); and they don't have enough battery life for longer activities (which can last six hours or more). Meanwhile, a cord is just not much of an inconvenience to me.
- jagger27 5y agoI haven’t found comfortable tips for my AirPods Pro. None of the ones in the box fit properly and the foam ones I bought are pretty painful. Despite constantly pushing them back into my ears, I prefer them to wires getting snagged on door knobs and the awful rubbing sound against my coat. I still grab my AirPods over my great old IEMs which sound way better and were only $80.
- rcarmo 5y agoI have an ancient Sony Ericsson MW600 Bluetooth headphone adapter. It is the size of a pen cap, has a great little display, a a touch-based sliding volume control, can pair to multiple devices (even has an FM radio!) and a headphone jack that works for any headphones I might want to use. Sadly, these just aren’t made anymore, and the current crop of BT headphone adapters is, comparatively, pure crap where it regards usability and quality. The MW600 feels like an artifact from an ancient higher civilization in comparison. Anyone know of a decent replacement?
- benjaminwootton 5y agoBluetooth is rubbish in most contexts, but it seems stable in the Apple ecosystem. I use a few Macbooks, an iPhone and two pairs of Beats headphones, and switching between them all seems totally reliable.
- gkanai 5y agoI hate bluetooth headphones. I want high quality audio both input AND output. I need a good mic on the phone- the only way you can get that is with a wired mic.
- zwaps 5y agoToday I learned that for most people, even on HN, headphones means earbuds. All wireless earbuds I have ever used, including Apple Airpods Pro, sucked. Fit, charging stability, not randomly breaking, sound, you name it. By contrast, I have wireless Sennheiser (over-ear) headphones which sound great (compared to my old wired HD25, say), last for 20 hours or so, and plug into USB, Headphone jack and, well, Bluetooth. Run out of battery? Just plug it in. I really only use earbuds for sport. In my opinion, that's what they are for.
- ImaCake 5y agoI can give pretty much the same anecdotes as you. The bulkier over-ear headphones seem to have no trouble with connectivity, brilliant battery life, and great sound. While every pair of in-ear headphones has had troubles. A lot of people I know have the fancy sony over-ear headphones and the issues they have had are very rare.
- roveo 5y agoYes, in addition to the ridiculously long life (30h seems to be the standard), they also have somewhat-easily replaceable standard cell batteries. (judging by iFixit guides) My friend has an older model that he uses every day for like 4 years, the battery is still reasonably good. And after that, you can still replace the battery and they'll be good as new. So I opted for over-ear Sony and never looked back. The considerable investment (about 130% of top AirPod model in my country) is totally worth it in my opinion. My wife's AirPods became unusable for a single 1-hour call after about a year.
- globular-toast 5y ago> Today I learned that for most people, even on HN, headphones means earbuds. Yeah, I found that odd. I thought "headphones" very specifically referred to the type you wear on your head (hence the name?). I thought this was going to be about audio quality of headphones versus earbuds (wired or wireless). Instead it's just fashion works in cycles, what's old is new again, we're back to 2005 again etc.
- timeon 5y ago
- mclightning 5y agoIt is pretty interesting how depending on the direction of the headline & article, a certain subset of readers become more expressive in comments, giving a false perception of the popular opinion. Take this topic, or Apple Touchbar threads... For/Against groups voice their opinions more openly when article matches their opinion. Where are my contrarions, misfits, non-conformists?
- wruza 5y agoArticles have more (fallacious) authority over noname anonymous on the internet. You’re observing the insecurities that people have about their opinion, nothing new.
- mclightning 5y agoIndeed. I'm not really saying one or the other is wrong. My last line was more to poke fun at the situation. But it is pretty interesting and good to be perceptive of this, when taking in public feedback.
- licyeus 5y agoThis seems pretty clearly not about nostalgia or technology. Nothing signals "don't talk to me" like plainly visible earbuds. I used to wear a pair, with nothing playing, when walking around the city. Worked like a charm + more portable than over-the-ear headphones.
- havkd 5y agoItt: lots of people complain about their non-apple headphones being shitty.
- JetAlone 5y agoI saw an airpad drop out of a woman's ear as she passed me crossing the street today. I never switched to wireless. Always had to deal with wires, which can be a little inconvenient but well worth it.
- omegaBroom 5y agoIt's true what they say, if you do nothing, fashion eventually catches up to you. Apparently I'm way cool
- knaik94 5y agoOne of the biggest problems with Bluetooth for me is the lack of standardization in codecs. Top of the line using codecs that come from very really generation of Bluetooth audio transmission with horrendous latency. There isn't even a cross operating system compatible basic codec that will guarantee audio and video sync within ~50ms round-trip. There's AAC which is Apple preferred but not every android or Windows 10 support. Fallback to SBC. There's Aptx, Aptx hd, aptx ll, Aptx adaptive which has genuinely come far over iterations but no ios support and windows only supports Aptx. 500$ headphones and the best codec is AAC or SBC shouldn't be acceptable to anyone. It's not about being an audiophile. The nicest DAC in the world can't recover data lost from lossy compression. LDAC is Sony's answer but that's a android supported codec and nothing else and the nicest xm4 don't support Aptx. The interesting thing is that Chinese companies and fiio are releasing cables and products to turn wired headphones wireless. Kz Az 09 is with looking into. I just ordered a Bluetooth cable that comes with the qcc5141 chip for 40$ and decent iems around 80$ and it will sound better than the best Apple or Sony offerings. Bluetooth 5.2 and newest Aptx adaptive and tws and voice, aac, and ldac just from a cable and can be adapted to whatever iem I want. Fiio just released the UTWS5 for adapting iems and they have the BTR5 you can plug any headset into and those even support high impedance headphones and can be used as a USB dac. Bluetooth 5.2 also has a new audio codec LC3. [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LC3_(codec) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LC3_(codec)] All that just to be able to do what regular headphone cables do. There's nothing unexpected about people hanging onto cables. They haven't really been gone, it's weird how a headphone jack is considered a budget feature for phones when cables are the best way to transmit lossless anything. Cables never left. But the day multiple people can connect to a single Bluetooth source to watch something at the same time, that's when people will care about bluetooth. In a different world, where hd audio wasn't stuck behind a proprietary codec in the US. There was room fm radio to take the place bluetooth audio has been forced to take. I personally use an an app to make my headphones wifi capable. Soundwire server listens transmits audio to my android phone 40-50ms latency. I keep wired headphones plugged in at all times. I get the range of wifi. Lossless audio transmission bandwidth is so tiny in the world of wifi, it's a rock solid connection 5 to 6 times further than Bluetooth in residential locations. I once tried it at my university and could leave my laptop at one end of the building and heard it playing in the connected building due to how they set up the network. 802.1x authentication. 400ft away minimum. I also use viper4android for on device audio equalization on android. PeaceAPO for windows 10.
- roystonvassey 5y agoNot sure if it's just me but I got my Airpods last March and I've been using it fairly regularly for the work calls. I got an ear infection in August that was pretty severe and after consulting with an ENT specialist, I was told to not wear these for long use or constantly since it prevents the ears from naturally clearing out (which normally happens when one chews and has nothing blocking the ear canal). So now I use them only when I absolutely need to (e.g. in noisy places, taking calls on the move) and avoid them all other times.
- anon2020dot00 5y agoSame, I also got an ear infection not being careful when wearing Apple Earbuds
- jacksonkmarley 5y agoThe only thing more annoying than having a wire between my ears and my device is having a bad connection between my ears and my device.
- Havoc 5y agoStarting to run into another issue lately - the 2.4ghz spectrum is congested/polluted enough to break bluetooth links
- tomduncalf 5y agoNot sure if the article mentions it or not due to paywall, but wireless earphones are still useless for anything which is latency sensitive e.g. music making/playing a virtual instrument, and I would guess some categories of games. The last product I worked on was a piano learning app where the user’s mobile device generated the sound of the piano, and we had to explain to users that unfortunately they couldn’t use their AirPods/other wireless headphones with the app due to this lag. IIRC it was around 200ms for AirPods, and all the way up to 500ms for other brands, though I may be misremembering.
- iamsaitam 5y agoI must be living under a rock, I wasn't aware that they had gone out (of what, I don't know)
- skocznymroczny 5y agoI wish behind head/neck headphones made a return. Seems like they disappeared several years ago, and now only exists as a sports equipment, with neckband connected to earphones, which is not the same. I used to find them much more comfortable than the ones that you put on top of the head.
- kohlerm 5y agoAir pods (started the trend) are IMHO also are mostly a status symbol. Early air pods would arguable sound worse than 30$ Chi-fi IEMs. Yes later sound got better, but even the old ones were selling like hell. It seems also that people don't care that much about sound quality, but prefer convenience. Apple made it less convenient to us corded phones by omitting the head phone jack. I personally think that ATM i do not need a wireless IEM. I use IEMs mostly during sports,and longer travels. There a cheaper IEM is just preferable in my experience,because if it breaks it does not matter and if it gets stolen it also does not matter. Also the cords make it less likely that the IEM fall down and break. I do have a small bluetooth receiver but mostly because it also includes a good microphone.
- herbst 5y agoSo what I've learned from this thread about airpods: - Quality is really subpar - Battery is dying fast, charge often and throwaway product - Comfort is relative - most are already on their second or third pair - Ear infections get more common - BT still isn't perfect especially on busy places - doesn't work too well outside of apples walled garden - yet the majority likes them
- m0zg 5y agoThe thing that baffles me is, with the kind of engineering and manufacturing prowess that Apple has, they could _easily_ make far and away the best earbuds, earphones, and over-ears in the world, bar none. It wouldn't even be difficult - they can just buy Sennheiser with money from between Tim Cook's couch cushions, and then they can redesign their products to both be better and cheaper to manufacture, simultaneously. And yet my 15 year old Sennheisers still _way_ outperform anything wireless at any price. It's not even close. Also, no bluetooth dropouts, no batteries, no compression, no digital correction, no Siri, and no compromises.
- vletal 5y agoI am used to wearing wired Apple earphones all around with me. I often listen while biking or riding an EUC. I simply must hear the surrounding traffic. These earphones let just enough ambient sound to pass trough yet they have a superior sound quality compare to other "OEM" headphones. Moreover, IMO the mic recordings sound just much better as well compare to earphones when used outside while passing around morning traffic. At last, I got an ear infection from wearing plugs in the past. Since then any plugs start irritating my left ear very quickly. I basically can not comfortable wear plugs in my ears for more than a few minutes anyway.
- _kulang 5y agoThe Apple corded EarPod microphone is unfairly good sounding
- jokoon 5y agoAll I want is a high end mic+earplugs, high quality, with a strong cord, even if it's very thick.
- B-Con 5y agoDo people dislike wireless or do they dislike Bluetooth? Because Bluetooth sucks. It's a shame it's the industry standard. Bluetooth support is still spotty on Linux, which to me is continued evidence that the stack is complicated and bug-ridden. Even for my high-end BT devices, there are still lots of problems. In addition to the problems listed elsewhere in this thread, I particularly have problems with: * Easy, reliable switching between connected devices. * Reliably connecting when a device is turned on. * Audio delays on the order of 200ms. I stick with wireless almost exclusively, because I hate the wire, but I switch to wired for gaming because a 200ms audio lag for a real-time game is unplayable. 200ms is obvious even just watching someone speak in a video.
- out_of_protocol 5y ago* BT sucks * BT audio codecs sucks. Why cant everyone agree on e.g .opus, gotta be enough for everyone * BT audio hardware/software implementation sucks * BT audio hardware/software implementation totally inconsistent across vendors * OS support is not really great, system mixer adds some mud to the mix * Headphone's DAC modules sucks, even $400+ ones - tried some Sony's, same headphones via BT and wire, and wired connection felt so much more alive, despite being connected to crappy builtin phone jack. * BT headphones much much more expensive while providing much much lower audio quality.
- cutthegrass2 5y agoCan anyone recommend a corded set of headphones with a decent microphone? I currently have the Bose QC35ii, so something like this, with a cord and no bluetooth. Noise cancelling not required, just need something decent for work.
- beezischillin 5y agoI grew up very poor and I always get this awful feeling when something costly I own breaks - and that's consistently been my experience with Apple and Beats wireless headphones and earbuds. The batteries simply went from good to barely holding a charge or not even charging within a year on four pairs so this a major negative to me. I've had better luck with my Sony 1000XM2, which is still fine, thankfully. The other downside is the volume, I like to be able to crank it up and listen to music louder sometimes. Apart from that it always felt to me like it mostly depended on the situation, at home when I can lay in my bean bag and listen to some vinyl I'll always prefer my wired Sennheiser through my Schiit amp. When I do some yard work I go for the Sony and when I'm on foot taking care of business in the city I'll go for the AirPods because they're good enough and convenient. And a side note: A really cool audio discovery to me was the existence of Chinese hi-fi brands like TIN Audio. Their wired IEMs are pretty nice. I'm looking into getting one of those MMCX bluetooth DAC AMPs to give me the option to use them wirelessly, too, when I want.
- anothernewdude 5y agoThey never went away. Depending on batteries for headphones is stupid.
- yonatron 5y agoThe main problem for me with wireless earbuds is: they fall out of my ears. No matter what brand, no matter what shape. I'd love to wear them, but they pop out quickly even if sitting perfectly still. I've tried over the ear headphones and if you wear glasses, they hurt - they press your earpieces painfully. Guess I'll have to wait for a combination of bluetooth and skull induction built into glasses...
- solarkraft 5y agoAh yes, the WSJ is in touch with cool kids. I wish for more of the practicality of wired headphones (less charging), but I don’t miss the wires at damn all. Don’t know what you guys are doing, but apparently I like to move around in ways that’ll entangle and often break the wires.
- ksec 5y agoI am surprised the vast majority of the 280 comments seems to be about bluetooth connection, fitting, sound quality and not a mention about TCO ( Total Cost of Ownership ). May be I am cheap, but I cant get myself to buy another Wireless Earphone again with non -replaceable battery. They are basically consumables. And Apple expect you to buy a new pair every 1-2 years. And even if you dont use it much the battery will still deteriorate after 2 years. I dont know about current M1 MacBook, EarPod and HomePod, but Apple has a history of speaker being relatively easier blown out. But even then they last 4 - 5 years. Again may be I am cheap. I expect these things to last a decade. I have often dream of a Wireless earphone where the long end part is a screwable battery.
- tinus_hn 5y agoIf you consider AirPods to be environmentally safe to recycle, which is not unreasonable given that Apple will take them back and promises to recycle the parts, the only downside to a disposable device like this is cost. Two years of using AirPods means you pay about $0,25 a day of use. Most users use them every day and are very happy with them. I think it is pretty reasonable to pay that kind of money for being happy.
- soneca 5y agoI never had a wired in-ear earphone that lasted more than 2 years. My guess is 90% didn’t pass the one year mark. I use it while commuting, going to the supermarket, cleaning the house, etc. Any recommendation of a wired in-ear earphone that could last a decade?
- Intermernet 5y agoNot new ones, but I have a pair of original Sony Fontopias that came with a high end walkman around 20 years ago. They're built to last and incredibly comfortable with good audio quality. Unfortunately I dont think they made them that well for long. The equivalent headphones from only 5 years later were terrible in comparison. Edit: I just looked them up. MDR-E484. They seem to be classics that sell for hundreds of dollars used! I never realised they were so sought after!
- 5y ago
- yodsanklai 5y agoI'd be curious about the environmental impact of wireless headphone compared to wired ones. IMHO it's a question that should be asked for any new tech which provides only a slight improvement (if any) to existing solutions.
- normaler 5y agoI use Beyerdynamic 990 at home and Beyerdynamic 770 in the office. Both with an additional ModMic and FiiO DACs. At the office I recently got one of the wireless ModMic things with a dongle. It is nice to safe a cable, but then the battery life time of the mod mic is around 7 hours. So I am glad at home that i simply dont have to think about it.
- dayvid 5y agoI bought three pairs of airpods and the mic stopped working for each after a short amount of time. I decided to get a non-apple earbud and got the Galaxy Buds Live. I quickly realized how much better sound quality is out there and also got some wired headphones when I’m at a stationary location. You can get really nice wired IEMs for a decent price and you can add foam tips for good noise cancellation. You can also get a wired cable with a mic for a dollar more.
- jefftk 5y agoNo mention of latency? I strongly prefer headphones wired for calls because they affect on lag is huge. Wireless headphones typically have more lag than the entire rest of the connection, usually 100 to 300ms.
- _han 5y agoAgreed, this is especially noticeable when making digital music. The latency was too much for me to be able to naturally follow a rhythm. Plugging in a wire improved the situation by a lot.
- noasaservice 5y agoTo be frank, bluetooth is a crap protocol that introduces latency, missed data, skipped data, random disconnects, and overall flakiness. Wired has none of those. And is cheaper to boot.
- moron4hire 5y agoI can't wear earbuds. I've tried a variety and they cause excruciating ear canal and inner ear pain for me within 15 minutes. I have to use around-ear, open-back headphones to not feel like I'm free diving 15ft under water. I particular, Beyer Dynamics DT 990 Pro https://north-america.beyerdynamic.com/dt-990-pro.html https://north-america.beyerdynamic.com/dt-990-pro.html
- aulin 5y agoAmazing how wireless earbuds basically means airpods for almost everyone here, maybe it's a north american thing... I've been using cheap bluetooth earphones (20-30 €) since way before Apple decided to reinvent them, they always sucked, terrible audio, terrible battery, lousy waterproofness... but they get the job done as a sports companion. Having a wire jumping left and right can really get annoying or even dangerous while biking. Cheap chinese ones have a nice rubber thing that sits inside the concha making it way more stable than apple ones that seem so popular these days...
- bool3max 5y agoHmm, $30 Xiaomi wireless Bluetooth earpods have pretty good battery life and very decent audio quality. I don't know about waterproofness, but the low end range of wireless earphones has improved significantly in the last few years.
- aulin 5y agoI meant more battery quality than battery life, they usually include a small supercapacitor that tends to fail abruptly. I've had ones that lasted for years and others failing after a couple of months.
- klelatti 5y agoI loved my AirPods but I’ve gone back to wired headphones. Why? The batteries lasted less than 18 months and the cost to replace them is more than a new pair. Not even considering again until this is fixed.
- newsbinator 5y agoExactly the same here. My AirPods are worse than useless now because they enticingly work for 5 ~ 20 minutes before instantly dying. I now use corded earphones because they're consistent and always ready to work.
- ximeng 5y agoSummary of thread - you can't keep everyone happy, and for some people there's no such thing as non-replaceable battery or broken cables if they have a soldering iron. The variety of things to complain about is greater with wireless. Wires (+) - Connection more reliable - Sound quality consistent and stable (this is non-negotiable for some who won't buy a phone without an analog jack) - Buttons on wire are convenient - No battery worries - Better audio "resolution", can hear more details (but theoretically wireless should be able to match "Harman target"), no compression - Can replace cable, earpads if it fails (modular, good value Sennheiser HD25 has easy to replace parts - cable, earpad - and lasts >10 years; some manufacturers do not add 3.5mm TRRS jack) - Clear which device is connected - Simple and easy to understand - Harder to lose - Can use amp or USB DAC for sound quality - Supported by decades worth of devices - Better for environment as less disposable and repairable - 1/8" RCA stereo jack is "best interface ever" (but ground connects last, plugging in may cause jumbled connections and shorts, and noises - bad with amps and speakers - partial plugging in possible, unbalanced signals; pros prefer XLR or heavy-duty cables such as Speakon, and TS/TRS cables only for patch cables such as guitar to amp; newer equipment uses audio over ethernet / Dante) - Can convert to bluetooth with an adapter (e.g. fiio ubtr, although has less battery life) or 3d print a converter for flexibility - Cheaper Wires (-) - Default headphone wires are short (but fixable) - Headphone wire must be removed before taking off a shoulder-strap bag or shirt (can route under shirt or bag, but takes more time to put on or off and may yank wire if looking at phone so need slack in pocket) - Tethered to source - Taking off a face mask / shoulder-strap bag or passing a doorknob or exercising may tear headphones out of ears and damage them (need to treat wired headphones as consumable) - Might tangle e.g. with keys in pocket, or if walking or running and putting things in and out of pocket (folding wire may help although some people thinks it damages wire; better wire materials may help) - Some wired headphones are earbuds, so might be affected by issues people note for wireless earbuds - Wires and ports may be fragile (may be able to solder to fix) - Wires may crackle if not held in the right angle (although most headphones now come with replaceable cables, 2.5mm jack in headphone end) - Annoying carrying cables - May have cord noise Wireless (+) - Can change shoulder-strap bag or top without taking off headphones - Portability: listen away from source (e.g. bathroom, up to ~40ft at home) - Audio is fine in general (Airpods 2nd gen) - For some (e.g. AirPods 2nd gen) no connection issues and good switching between phone and iPad (but auto-switching is not always wanted such as with an interval timer; sometimes connects to the wrong device) - Bluetooth problems mostly solved in AirPods and Beats lines) - Can help with hearing protection (e.g. reducing wind noise, especially on a motorcycle) - Note that wireless headphones aren't necessarily earbuds (may have wrap-around design, although over-the-ear may hurt for glasses wearers), so some earbud issues are not necessarily linked to wireless; so longer battery life and can plug in if needed (so some people just use earbuds for sport) - AirPods noise cancellation increases apparent loudness (also have transparency, normal mode; this is not necessarily just for wireless though) - Not reliant on an analog jack (more device choice, one less part to fail) - May be "cool" (but too popular so maybe "uncool") - Convenient when moving around e.g. working out Wireless (-) - Don't connect, or only one connects, or randomly disconnect (possibly interference especially in crowded areas but not issue for everyone) - Connection speed can be slow (varied experiences) - Might connect to wrong device - Sounds sometimes glitches out randomly (e.g. by large diesel generator), may have internal noise/audible hiss - Bluetooth protocol - just drops stale packets, and enough dropped packets disconnects - Earbuds fall out of some people's ears, so only use in "safe" places such as at home not outside (some people find OK for 5k run, may need better fit, and not necessarily a wireless only problem; more a problem if moving head a lot) - Gestures and voice inconvenient without buttons as tapping just pushes into ear without registering (but AirPods Pro have buttons on stems and some use Siri/watch/phone instead of gestures; can also use device with wire between earbuds with controls and bluetooth transmitter) - Batteries are inconvenient as need to be charged and get worse over time (can use one and swap to charge while using; maybe could have replaceable batteries - this is a HN obsession, can just resolder as cheap wholesale; wireless charging and case helps, USB-C headphones help too if used with USB-C computer) - Latency (~200ms) means not good for pro audio or games or music or video (although some software may compensate e.g. YouTube) - Bluetooth is not as quick to connect as DECT (e.g. Jabra DECT wireless headset suitable for all-day in call centre) - Bluetooth is a complicated protocol with error correction and lots of failure points (software, hardware, bluetooth controller, protocol, medium, codecs) and not everything support bluetooth - Easy to lose (would be good if had a way to wirelessly locate) - Sometimes computer doesn't connect on bluetooth, especially on Linux and when using with mic or not - Some models don't connect while charging (but wireless headphones can be temporarily wired) - Other people may talk to you without realising you are wearing them if you have long hair, or think you're talking to yourself - Bluetooth has lossy, pyschoacoustic compression (may cut out at low volumes to save battery), codec may be worse when using microphone as well (but not for all models) - Worse for environment as finite lifetime with Li-ion battery - Annoying carrying case (but needed for battery life) - Expensive (but cheap clones may be OK, some say replacing every 3 years is good value for how much they use) - Microphone can be bad - May be security/privacy issue - May be uncomfortable on your side - Possible ear infections (as prevents ears from naturally clearing) - Some complain volume not high enough - May be heavier and bulkier Speaker (+) - If you're in the military and headphones will fall off, so just share music with a boombox Individual models - Sennheiser PX100 for good quality sound outside not driving as doesn't isolate from surroundings - Sennheiser HD220s for radio and TV on tablet or phone late at night - Sennheiser HD485s for music - Bose QuietComforts (case is annoyingly big, but charges quickly) - Bose SoundSports have wire between earbuds which clip to collar so hard to lose; also charge fast - Galaxy Buds+ had bad battery after a year - AirPods 150 Eur with 90min listening time after 1 year of use, 40 minutes in cold - AirPod Pros (need to replace if has "crackling"), falls out for some not others, may be better with Apple devices, AirPods Pro take 5 hours to charge - Nokia BH-503 on-ear bluetooth headphones lasted 10 years (minimal problems except slight pitch changes, OK sound quality but not as good as over-ears, one of first A2DP headsets) - DT770 have bad non-replaceable cables (although can modify with a miniXLR socket), but may not be updated - DT 700 Pro X (Beyerdynamics successor to DT770) has replaceable cords - Shure SE215 in-ear headphones have detachable MMCX cables for 100 Euros - Wireless Sennheiser (over-ear headphones) great audio (vs. old wired HD25), last 20 hours, plug into USB, headphone jack, bluetooth - mitigates battery issues - Sony over-ear headphones have few isues - Sennheiser wireless earbuds don't suck - Sony WF-1000XM4 can pair multiple devices so don't need to disconnct then reconect e.g. phone and laptop - Sony WF-1000XM3 "good" wireless headphones but connect to wrong device, low battery life, OK sound quality, bad voice quality on calls, one will turn on but not the other, buttons too sensitive e.g. if wearing hood or rainy/windy days, poor pairing; some people have good experience with this vs. AirPod Pros, but plug in XM3 for lossless music - Sony WF-1000XM2s similar issues to XM3 but worse - Sony WF-1000XM (first gen) very reliable with android but nothing else, very bad pairing - Sony WH-1000X (headphones, not earbuds) - good audio, battery charge once a week, pairing perfect, comfortable all afternoon, but microphone low quality codec - Bose QC45 has good quality codec even with microphone - Apple Beats Fit Pro similar to AirPods Pro but has wingtip to keep in ear - Bose QC15 had replaceable batteries (2009-2015) - Beyerdynamics studio headphones last 16 years with replaced cords - Apply corded EarPod microhpone sounds very good
- EMM_386 5y agoI'm seriously considering this. Every other day, on Windows, my Bluetooth headphones decide they prefer the left output to be louder than the right outpout. And it will randomly fix itself. Truly randomly. Nothing I try to do, from adjusting auto settings, to disabling the headset mic, to re-installing drivers, to rebooting, to unpairing/repairing, to everything else has any impact on it. Then it will start working normally, only to stop working a day later. And it's not the headphones, it's the Bluetooth stack. All headphones I try are either broken or working, depending on the day and whatever mood my Windows Bluetooth stack is in.
- vdqtp3 5y agoI have a similar issue intermittently with my wired headphones. Try changing your spatial sound settings (I choose Windows Sonic then turn it off again), it fixes it for me (until next time it messes up)
- piokoch 5y agoTo spare people reading article: "In short, AirPods have become too widespread to be cool" This is the same phenomena like the return of vinyl records, there is exactly zero logical reason to use them over CDs or flac compressed files, yet they made a big come back because of being in fashion now.
- dangerface 5y agoUnexpected? This must be an apple ad.
- WhompingWindows 5y ago99% of the time I use corded headphones, it doesn't matter that they're corded. They are simply better in every respect outside of the cord. I've owned at least 5 pairs of mid-range headphones, I loved my Sony studio monitor headphones so much that I bought a second pair. I also bought some DT 770 pro headphones recently and I am enjoying those quite a lot.
- daneel_w 5y agoThey never went away. Not the slightest.
- melgafin 5y agoI never got the appeal of cordless headphones. A 120$ pair of headphones from the 80s will still work perfectly fine today. A pair of bluetooth headphones will probably die in 3-6 years, either from a dead battery or because the protocols become outdated.
- dangerface 5y agoWireless headphones are just as good as wired. I own both I like both. It's annoying that since apple removed the jack a lot of people suddenly became very opinionated that wired headphones are somehow less than. Apple isn't a cult.
- timbit42 5y agoOnly if you don't mind the lag. It's fine for music but for video or two way conversations, it's annoying.
- tomiplaz 5y agoTo each their own, but I've been enjoying my bluetooth ear buds since the day I got them. Not having to deal with wires has been as great as I imagined. Battery life of 4 hours is more than enough for daily usage when walking between places, and having to charge them and the case is a great trade-off, IMO. I've had mine for more than two years now. I sometimes even shower with them, if I come home and want to continue listening. They're still as good as new.
- Poiesis 5y agoUnfortunately I didn't see this on HN until fairly late, but I'd love to hear any recommendations for Lightning connector to audio jack adapters. We've gone through so many here (Apple, Belkin, no-name...) and they just seem to break fairly easily. Wish there were a case solution but those seem to have fizzled out over time (presumably no demand). Anyone know of a good adapter that survives daily use?
- Vingdoloras 5y agoThe reason I don't use wired headphones is that I'd need an adapter for them to work with my iphone. I used to use those adapters (both from Apple and aftermarket ones), but they would last two months at max, sometimes even just around 2-3 weeks. Since I wear headphones at work any time I'm not in a meeting, and my phone is always in my pocket (with half of the adapter hanging out), after around two months, the adapter dies from the strain on the cable. Adapters that lasted less long seemingly didn't die to physical damage, but insteadto static charges, just from me moving (and I work a desk job, so not much extreme movements). Could that be my clothes? Sure, but am I really going to change my wardrobe just so I can use some stupid adapter? Since getting airpod pros, I've fallen in love with their anc, so that's one more reason for me to stay wireless (never heard of any wired anc headphones).
- acd 5y agoI have a set of wired Sennheiser 600. These wired headphones has lasted twenty years. Ie wired headphones last long which are better for the environment than wireless with glued non user replaceable batteries. Since wired headphones do not have electronics they do not get obsolete.
- diebeforei485 5y agoCorded headphones are arguably better if your commute involves a bike ride or crowded subway. They also feel more secure when face masks are involved. Airpods 1 and 2 have long stems, and can fall off when wearing certain accessories like scarves, earmuffs, and face masks (when wearing or removing masks that use ear loops). This is not an issue with Airpods 3 or Airpods Pro which have shorter stems. Tip for people who find the connection unreliable - I have noticed that having Bluetooth 5.0 on both the source device (iPhone X or later) and the earbuds (Airpods 2 or later) resolved most connection issues. It is miles better than Bluetooth 4.2 in my experience. My complaint with wired headphones (not all of them, notably not the Lightning EarPods) is that the wire itself creates sounds while it's moving.
- akvadrako 5y agoCorded headphones are pretty annoying to use with masks; I recently switched to wireless for this reason.
- diebeforei485 5y agoFair enough. My point was if they do fall out, they just dangle from the cord - they don't fall to the floor like AirPods (which is annoying if they fall into subway tracks, or if they fall onto the road while you're on a bicycle).
- akvadrako 5y agoMaybe the difference is I use the ones that wrap around your ear, which are more secure.
- browningstreet 5y agoI have some Plantronic connected wireless bluetooth headphones (with the over ear loop) that I wear every day in the gym. I keep my phone in a bag and walk to and fro... zero issues. I'm on my 3rd pair, in about a decade (eventually the batteries die, from charging so regularly). I also just bought the Nothing Ear, mostly for those occasions where I want to wear wireless with glasses. So far, no issues. All with my old iPhone XR.
- poopooracoocoo 5y ago(accidentally pulled to refresh and there was no confirmation dialog. Yay deleted comment! Excuse the crudeness) My laptop, PC, speakers, TV, console and console controller all have the headphone jack. Everything except my phone has the 3.5mm jack. I'm losing options. I don't like having to keep both. Microsoft, Sony and Nintendo have all said that Bluetooth is not good enough for gaming and have decided to not support Bluetooth audio in their consoles. If you only use Apple devices you're lucky to have a perfect experience with wireless earphones. Particularly due to their cleaner stack and to proprietary stuff. The second top comment mentions longevity, right to repair, battery, etc, but we all know what you get when you buy TWS earphones. It's the general public that does not. Fingers crossed government regulation can fix that one up? The author must have delved into a niche. I consider myself rather culturally relevant and while Tumblr aesthetics do exist of course, this one isn't mainstream. I try not to follow developers on Twitter and Instagram, as a bias check. What would make wireless earphones and headphones more bearable is if Android and iOS allowed you to choose your own input and output devices so you can avoid the low-quality headset mode by using the mobile device's microphone. I believe Windows 11 made some changes with Bluetooth devices to make this no longer possible which is a bummer. Bluetooth on Windows is a nightmare as is. Apple not having removed the 3.5mm headphone jack on their new MBPs is evident of an anti-consumer, pro-profit strategy. Plain and simple. They deemed it a pro feature that they likely use themselves but it's one that isn't for mobile devices.
- JohnFen 5y agoI have some high end wireless earbuds, and they're useful when I'm doing something physically energetic. But I strongly prefer my wired ones for sound quality and reliability and use those the most often.
- simonblack 5y agoWires are dependable. Wired items (earphones, keyboards, mice) are always ready, always available. Several times I've tried bluetooth keyboards and mice, only to throw them away in frustration as the batteries go flat in no time at all. Logitech Keyboard: "Up to 6 months of life" - bullshit. I'm lucky if a set of batteries last 2-3 weeks. My USB keyboard and USB mouse are always available. So I don't need to think about that extra problem at all.
- mikewarot 5y ago$15/year at Target for a new set of Sony headphones is well worth putting up with a 3' cord. I don't want pulsed microwaves doing who knows what to my brain, no matter how low power Bluetooth is, thank you very much.