27 ms·
High schoolers are training to drive 18-wheelers amid shortage of truck drivers
- protomyth 5y agoOur little community college has a commercial license program. We, with some outside help, even bought a simulator. The program goes well with the other vocational programs. The students have had no problem finding jobs. The sequence of book, simulator, then roadwork in an actual semi has been quite successful.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lordnacho 5y agoIs this something that you can do part-time? I could imagine making some extra money on the weekends or holidays. You can listen to lectures while driving or sit in the cab and read while resting. Question is whether it's feasible to get jobs that fit that schedule.
- thehappypm 5y agoI would imagine not really. Logistics jobs are all about reliable throughput. There may be spikes that need extra demand, but you're better off with 5 full time employees who will always show up, than having 4 then scaling up to 6 when you need, since that introduces logistical hurdles.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoBasically anything that has you in your own bed at night and not breaking your back is going to be low pay or require a lot of experience. If you have a driver on staff the incentive is to use them for every hour you legally can because your business insurance costs reflect the number of drivers more than the hours your fleet spends on the road.
- djrogers 5y agoIn California, where the largest shortages are, largely not. AB 5 has made it very hard for any driver to operate other than as a full time employee.
- lindwhi 5y agoThere's a lot of minors driving 10 and 18 wheeler trucks. It's quite amazing, but each country has its driving laws.
- inanutshellus 5y agoThis would've been a perfect time to switch over to unmanned vehicles. A large number of senior drivers stay on the job, but we start moving to self-driving tech for the boring all-interstate stuff. But tech (and laws) aren't quite there yet.
- tannhaeuser 5y agoExactly my thoughts as well. We've had test sandboxes for EV trucks with overhead wiring, have been talking about autonomous driving for over ten years now - yet nothing tangible and usable has come out of it except maybe autonomous lot parking and assists.
- bombcar 5y agoOr we can just put one driver in the front of a truck with a bunch of trucks behind it, and put it on a "self driving road" made of iron rails and call the front truck a locomotive ...
- heartbreak 5y agoWe do that too. Have you seen the rail lines in and out of Long Beach or port of LA recently?
- francisofascii 5y agoIn trucking, they call that "platooning"
- whalesalad 5y agoA family friend manages a trucking company here in Michigan. He tells me that it’s not a shortage - but rather an attrition problem. Companies are having a hard time keeping drivers. He doesn’t even have employees. He coaches all of his drivers through the process of setting up their own LLC and becoming independent. They love it.
- LinuxBender 5y agoI am curious if the shortage driven demand is setting these kids of for future career trouble. I would guess there might be short-haul drivers for quite some time, but long-haul and fixed path shipments are maybe not too far off the automation path? Will automation creep in slow enough for attrition to weaken the impact to drivers?
- gerikson 5y agoAutomation is a long way off. It would have to very efficient to compete with a pool of driver-owners who would be motivated/desperate to undercut the automated fleet owners. Those will have to own the vehicles, be responsible for maintenance, and of course, shoulder responsibility for insurance/safety. Besides, what are you going to do when your expensive rig and its cargo drives to the shoulder in the middle of the desert with a software issue? Someone will have to get there and drive it home manually. Edit for a classic look at long-haul transport of hazmats, I can recommend this piece by John McPhee from 2003: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2003/02/17/a-fleet-of-one https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2003/02/17/a-fleet-of-one
- listless 5y agoI would agree with this. Andrew Yang made this a talking point for UBI, but it was always hypothetical. Automating big rig hauling is a long way off just based on where we are with the consumer sector. Even in cars that are currently automated, a driver is onboard at all times.
- kgin 5y agoStarting this year in SF and expanding to 10s of cities over the next few years, this won’t be true.
- yonaguska 5y agoThe way I see truck automation going is that the drivers will still be there, but the skill of the job will be dramatically reduced, at least for long haul loads. I'm thinking it will be a lower paying job for drivers that "babysit" automated driving trucks. I don't believe this is optimal. A distracted driver is more dangerous, regardless whether they have a computer helping them drive. But, the incentives are there. I would much rather it looks like the airline industry, where computers have come a long way in assisting pilots, but the job still has stringent requirements of the pilot.
- jleyank 5y agoIn the states, the lawyers tend to win. So whomever does the design, whomever writes the code and whomever has the deepest pockets better worry when that 18-wheeler barrels over grandma. And this work damn well better be done more to space shuttle standards than those of every web and software package I’ve used… Edit: or just lay roads rather than tracks and call them trains. Keep the humans away like they do now.
- jleyank 5y agoWhy are these sentiments always downvoted? Do people honestly think that this generation of software folks are significantly better than the last 3-4? Given programmers ego, I assume “damn straight”. But then, that’s what the previous bunch said also. Good, safe, stable coding is HARD which it’s not often done cuz hard = expensive. And weregild costs lots and lots of money.
- iso1631 5y ago> Do people honestly think that this generation of software folks are significantly better than the last 3-4? I don't think they're worse, just that the damage they can cause is far wider, both because of the ease of spread and the increase in reliance on technology
- bluGill 5y ago> Do people honestly think that this generation of software folks are significantly better than the last 3-4? Yes, because as Issac Newton said, we are standing on the shoulders of giants. In 1950 the first programmers didn't know a lot of the tricks to write good code that I do. (they also didn't have computers that could handle the multi-million line programs that I work on) Over years a lot of things have had to be discovered, and a lot of seemingly-good bad ideas had to be rejected the hard way. Of course today there are a lot more "programmers" writing simple web apps that depend on complex back ends, but demand even less skill than the programmers of old (who had to worry about where on the drum their next instruction was - concepts that are lost on us today). Still, we have a lot more programmers who are better than the best of the old, than the sum total of all the old programmers. Though I do have to be careful. I'm soon entering the category of a previous generation. I expect anyone still programming today - regardless of age - is of this generation. There is a lot of overlap of people who started out in older generations not knowing as much as todays, but have learned and now are todays generation.
- Symbiote 5y ago> Currently, truckers must be at least 21 to haul goods across state lines. Why is that what determines the age limit? The USA has very consistent signs and roads between states. It's 21 in the EU [1], but it doesn't matter if you're crossing a border or not. [1] https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/vehicles/driving-licence/get-driving-licence/index_en.htm https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/vehicles/driving-licen...
- goodcanadian 5y agoInterstate commerce. Within a state, state laws apply. It probably varies from state to state (I am not an expert). Crossing state borders, federal laws apply.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dvh 5y agoIn EU you can (generally) start driving when you are 18. I assume the intention of the 21 years limit was so that the truck drivers has at least some practice before driving 20t vehicles on public road.
- csunbird 5y agoSome places you can get a learners license as early as in 16, I think
- consp 5y agoLearner licenses (in the EU afaik) will not allow you to cross borders or operate commercially. Crossing borders is like driving without a license. They generally are completely valid as soon as you turn 18 though.
- Spooky23 5y agoCommercial trucking and transportation is really complex, with Federal, State and local authorities for various exerting various and sometimes overlapping jurisdictions. It’s a feature of federalism. The federal government runs a pretty impressive safety program by enforcing rules and targeting enforcement based on statistical analysis and national standards. Shady operators basically cannot operate interstate business for long. At the state or local level, it varies. States usually have more lax standards. There’s a cat and mouse game around the regs which evolve over time - Chinatown busses being the most notorious example recently. The regulations shape business. Usually something like a hotel minibus or senior services bus operates with state or local authority. Large limos often operate in a legal grey zone. As a consumer it sucks, as the less regulated carriers are often a nightmare — that hotel minibus may not have operating brakes or a qualified driver.
- syshum 5y ago>>> work is dangerous, comes with low pay and and that the hours are unbearable. All of which is true for the majority of drivers. If the industry wants to attract people they need to get off the "per mile driven" pay scheme where truckers can spend hours, or even days unpaid waiting at terminals, docks, etc... Trucking today is a terrible job, with low pay if calculated on a per hour worked basis. Combined with most of the regulations being placed on the driver, not the company, with most of liability for violating the regulations born by driver not the company. There is a continual battle between doing what the company says, and doing what the law says. Drivers are stuck in the middle because it is perfectly legal for a company to have a driver break the law or drive an unsafe rig, the only person that has to pay the fine is the driver.
- cat199 5y ago> it is perfectly legal for a company to have a driver break the law IANAL but i can guarantee it's not - whether or not it gets enforced on the other hand...
- syshum 5y agoThe companies are very careful in the language and punishments. If a driver refuses a load because the trucks turn signals are out as an example, well the company will not come right out and say "You must take the load" but that driver will likely find himself sitting for possible days unpaid waiting for the next dispatch as punishment or they will be assigned the less profitable routes, etc I know personally more than a few drivers that would pay out of their own pocket to buy parts to fix trucks themselves so they would not end up in this dispatch punishment.
- datavirtue 5y agoWhy isn't there a national truckers union?
- kingaillas 5y agoMissing a /s tag? Isn't that the (International Brotherhood of) Teamsters?
- gadders 5y agoIt's amusing to see this, as in the UK people think shortage of truck drivers is purely a Brexit phenomenon. That may be a factor, but there are others in place as well such as the tax regime changing for self-employed drivers (IR35) etc.
- Chris2048 5y agoThere is a large cohort of anti-brexit media that spins everything economically bad as a result of Brexit. It's hard to know what to thing when economist are so politically spiked.
- veltas 5y agoMaybe Brexit caused the shortage of truck drivers in the US too!
- jeroenhd 5y agoEven before Brexit, the UK was suffering from a massive shortage of truckers. Covid and the resulting upset of the transport industry definitely had an impact as well. However, many UK truck drivers were foreign nationals that all got sent home or didn't believe in their job security after Brexit. Nothing in economics is ever the result of just one thing, but Brexit has made an existing problem much worse. The difference can be seen all around the UK. Every European country has some kind of shortage in the logistics industry, but only in the UK are the problems bad enough that the army needs to step in.
- makomk 5y agoThe biggest, most publicly-visible problem that caused the army to have to step in - the fuel crisis - wasn't really caused by the trucker shortage itself though. It was a media-created phenomenon; breathless front-page headlines about petrol stations running out of fuel caused everyone to go out panic buying, and the infrastructure just doesn't have the capacity to handle everyone filling their tank at once. The actual underlying problems were so tiny that no-one would've noticed them without the media pushing it - a handful of stations out of fuel in the whole country - and as far as I can tell that's what happened in the USA. According to financial publications like Bloomberg and FT they've been having ongoing problems with petrol stations running out of fuel due to a shortage of tanker drivers too, but the mainstream media hasn't covered it so there's been no panic buying, no crisis, people don't even know it's an issue.
- 0xebc 5y agoWe need more electricians as well. Got a quote to add a car charger last week and it was a hilarious four figure sum, with a month and a half lead time.
- cudgy 5y agoLow 4 figures seems about right for a 6-10 hour job plus transportation costs and a helper.
- mikestew 5y ago6-10 hours?! One is basically adding a 220V outlet, and usually in a place that's very close to the box full of circuit breakers (the garage). In our case, the charger is about three feet from the breaker box. I would have done it myself if it wasn't installed for free (because $REASONS). As it was, took the pro about 30 minutes. Now, that's not to say there aren't more difficult installations. But I imagine in a lot of cases in the U. S., where a lot of breaker boxes live in the garage, it shouldn't be anywhere near a four figure installation sum. My guess is a lot of contractors of any kind can pretty much name their price right now. Or they do I used to do when I didn't want anymore consulting work: jack up the quoted price enough that I would drop other clients to do the job at that rate should the potential client be desperate enough to pay it.
- 0xebc 5y ago>Low 4 figures I did not say low. It was a middling number which is madness. >seems about right for a 6-10 hour job plus transportation costs and a helper. 6-10 hours to install a dryer circuit, with a helper? The job was going to take two hours max, with wire, box, outlet only costing about $75.
- bbradley406 5y agoAre you aware of the requirements needed to be a licensed, bonded electrician? In my state you need at least 4000 hours of training bare minimum, higher tier licenses require more. This usually entails getting average pay for very dull work, for 2-4 years. Then you need tools, insurance, a vehicle (usually a diesel truck with lock boxes on the sides here), and a reliable employer. If you're starting your own small company and training others, that's a bit of a gamble as well. Also, most electricians make more money doing new construction, especially condo or apartment buildings. You're getting charged that much because they could have made the same amount of money (or a bit less) putting those hours towards a bigger, longer term project. As someone who works in a skilled trade, I can guarantee they just didn't think your project was important or worth it (and they're right). They see someone who can afford an electric car, and they know what it's worth to you to charge it. But hey, you could always just google it, do it yourself and hope the inspector doesn't notice. What's the worst that could happen?
- indymike 5y agoI own a recruiting tech company, and we have more than a few trucking companies that use our P2P chat system. In general (yes, there are exceptions): 1. Insurance rates dictate the minimum age... which is often around 26. 2. Average age of a truck driver is 56. So 4 years from retirement. 3. Federal laws are now much stricter on disclosure, so drivers who would have just moved from company to company after an accident... are now not able to get jobs nearly as easily. This is for the best, but the short term effect is there are many drivers who will have to find a new profession. 4. Wages are going up quickly and many drivers are changing jobs once per year (sometimes more)
- syshum 5y ago>>Insurance rates dictate the minimum age... which is often around 26. Many of the larger trucking companies are self insured, so this really does not apply to them >>Average age of a truck driver is 56. So 4 years from retirement. Where do you get that drivers will retire @ 60? For most of them their Social Security will not kick in until 67, and I do not know many drivers that have a fully funded individual retirement account. >>Federal laws are now much stricter on disclosure, so drivers who would have just moved from company to company after an accident.. This is really not due to Federal laws, there is a company the name escapes me right now that is similar to Consumer Credit Agency that tracks all driver activity, companies self report accident, and other adverse load events to this reporting agency Edit: DAX/DAC System I believe, or something like that >>Wages are going up quickly and many drivers are changing jobs once per year (sometimes more) They are still using the flawed Per Mile pay scheme which means drivers will still end up being screwed in the end. Further more companies are adopting the "Owner Operator" model where by the driver is leasing the truck from the company at an obscene rate far more than the truck is actually worth, and the driver then bares all the costs and if they do not get enough work the company takes back the truck, leases to a new sucker, and send the original driver into collections bankrupting him/her
- walleeee 5y ago> there is a company the name escapes me right now that is similar to Consumer Credit Agency that tracks all driver activity, companies self report accident, and other adverse load events to this reporting agency You may be thinking of AAMVA?
- null_object 5y agoFor anyone thinking or saying - "isn't this something someone could do as an extra job at weekends" - from my personal experience driving some medium-size trucks in the UK while I was at university (helping a friend who had a delivery company), driving anything that's larger than a van is a totally different experience than driving any sort of car, and is both much harder work and a magnitude more stressful. Not to mention how f**ing difficult it is to reverse. And I wasn't driving anything near the size of the rigs being talked about here.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoIt's not about driving the truck. It's about camping in the truck for weeks shitting in a ditch and washing yourself with cold water. I know someone who is a truck driver and recently retired. He saw the company he worked for replace the natives with Bulgarians and Romanians.
- Ekaros 5y agoAnd it's not like local gigs are impossible to find. That is doing delivery for local company. Get back to home each day, for not that much worse pay.
- hunterb123 5y agoWell sort of, most routes in America at least do have a TA/Love's with a shower lol.
- paganel 5y agoMy brother is a Romanian truck driver (he’s on his way to France right now, if I’m not mistaken). He got into this career at 32 years of age because he couldn’t make it anymore running a small cow farm, his farm couldn’t compete against the subsidized milk coming from the likes of France or Poland (a temporary, politically-induced ban on selling beef to Russia also didn’t help, his cows’ value was halved over-night). What I’m saying is that every action has a reaction, those Romanians and Bulgarians are not into it to steal someone else’s job, most of them were forced to do it because of economical and political decisions taken over their heads.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoIs there really a shortage of truck drivers? Or are there enough people with the needed licences, but they'd rather work in McDonalds, because they pay more?
- omginternets 5y agoIs this a literary device or does McDonald’s actually pay more than long-haul trucking??
- dagw 5y agoMy understanding is that it really depends on how you calculate pay. Trucking is often paid pr mile driven rather than pr hour 'worked'. So if you divide your total wage by the number of hours you are in or around your truck then hourly wage can come out much lower than McDonald's.
- honkdaddy 5y agoHere in Canada, truckers have an entry wage of about $18/h. Starbucks pays $15-16 and from what I’ve heard anecdotally, has excellent benefits and flexible hours, neither of which are guaranteed as a long-hauler.
- bombcar 5y agoDepending on how you do it, long haul trucking is a worse job than McDonald's, if McDonald's is paying enough. > The average truck driver salary in the USA is $61,843 per year or $31.71 per hour. Entry level positions start at $45,970 per year while most experienced workers make up to $85,000 per year. McDonald's is approaching $20/hr around here, which is getting close to those entry-level positions, no special training needed, and you get to live at home with family instead of being OTR all the time.
- fishtacos 5y agoWould be curious to know what general area you live in to understand how McD's can pay close to $20/h. Presumably a very high COL.
- maltalex 5y agoToday's high schoolers are going to retire in the 2060's. Something tells me that being a truck driver isn't going to be much of a career by then.
- schnevets 5y agoI would argue a competitive salary at 18 can make the world of difference for a graduate who doesn't have the resources to attend college (as long as they were taught financial literacy by a parent or school)
- Jyaif 5y agoTotally. They really should be training older folks that have 10-20 years of work ahead, not young kids.
- runako 5y agoThey've been saying the same about factory and warehouse work for several decades, and yet Amazon (who has spent over a billion $ buying robotics companies) is hiring hundreds of thousands of people in the US at higher than prevailing wages. Further -- we know that employment in a job trails off over decades, it doesn't fall off a cliff suddenly. Truck driving jobs are still increasing. I would wager that the average 18-year-old truck driver today could retire from that job when she's in her 60s.
- bluGill 5y agoI used to work at a factory. In 1950 there were 2000 people on the assembly line. Today there are 200. Today they make just as much as in 1950, perhaps more depending on how you measure. Sure there are still people there, but automation keeps getting better. Not too long ago 80 people lost their job when laser CNC cutters became good enough to do their job. Even where manual work is done, rechargeable tools tighten the bolts faster than a manual wrench. Things have gotten a lot safer too. Many less people have nicknames like "stubby" or "lefty" because the automatic safety stops the machine when (not if - repetitive work leads to forgetting to be safe) body parts are in the way.
- Justsignedup 5y agoIsn't truck driving in the US a horrible job? Pay is shit. Sometimes you work for free. You can't really have a family like you could in other industries, and every year your pay stays stagnant if you're lucky. My friend operates a truck. He owns his own and only with that is he able to earn 80k a year. And even he is looking to get out because 3 months on the road at a time means no family life.
- CountDrewku 5y ago80k is very good money in much of the country.
- bombcar 5y agoYou could sell the truck and buy a backhoe and make as much or more, and stay in the area.
- jessaustin 5y agoThose who don't have the equity to buy excavation equipment can also rent it on a per-job basis. That's not really an option with semi trucks?
- bombcar 5y agoYou can rent 18-wheelers, but the rental price ends up being such that after expenses, you'd be making not much at all (they're aimed at companies).
- ry4nolson 5y agostill need a truck to haul the backhoe around
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThere is no free lunch. Every blue collar business that you can cook up either comes with significant start up costs or a decade of crap jobs working your way up the ladder. The money you make is directly proportional to the amount of stuff you do in house from customer acquisition to maintaining your machines. This comes with employees, paperwork, compliance, etc, etc or it caps your scale.
- Factorium 5y agoThis is good. We should be training more people directly from age 15/16 for direct entry to the workforce. University should be only suggested to the top 20% of each yearly cohort, and senior highschool to the top 50%.
- pavel_lishin 5y agoWhy those numbers?
- varjag 5y agoYeah. Make it 2% instead of 20%, and suddenly 90% of people suggesting it start complaining.
- gruez 5y ago>University should be only suggested to the top 20% of each yearly cohort, and senior highschool to the top 50%. that's going to be politically suicide to implement.
- germinalphrase 5y agoIt would be more palatable to offer free university tuition to the top 20 percent (which has been true many places in the past and is still a thing in some places). my father went to high school in rural Illinois in the late 60’s. He got a full ride “hardship grant” simply because he was a decent (not exceptional) student and came from a poor farming family.
- Chris2048 5y agoTo be fair, the problem isn't the people not going to Uni, it's the chasm that exists in-between. A decent investment in trade-schools/polytechs and it wouldn't matter so much. But then, the UK fcked over a lot of its trades to become a "service economy", so who knows.
- njharman 5y ago"Entry to the workforce" is not a goal. It is a failure of society to force people to labor for ~half their waking hours just to exist.
- self_buddliea 5y ago> "... but I never left trucking," he said. "I would always either drive on the weekends or part-time not because I had to, but because I enjoyed it." The impression I get being in the UK is that driving HGVs is a cruel and soul destroying activity.
- Stevvo 5y agoIn the UK it definitely would be, however in the USA there is an appeal to the 'open roads' that might make up for some of the career's shortcomings.
- tomohawk 5y agoThis is not going to help. You have to be 21. Also, California's AB5 law has outlawed owner operators, which is a very large chunk of how trucking has worked for decades, making trucking a less desirable career. This is also one of the big reasons for the large backlog at the CA ports.
- scohesc 5y agoI find it hard to believe that a single state is able to cause such large supply problems nationally (and internationally) because of a law barring independent trucking companies from doing business in their state. But then again, it _is_ California so I'm not surprised. I just hope that maybe whoever is making the laws comes to their senses, because they're not just hurting California with this legislation.
- tomschlick 5y agoIs there anything that CA hasn't over-regulated to stupid levels yet?
- Invictus0 5y agoI thought the longshoremen were the bottleneck; you're saying they can't get enough trucks to the docks either?
- germinalphrase 5y agoAB5 did not outlaw owner-operators; however, some owner-operator fleets have decided not to operate in California due to possible driver reclassification from contractors to employees due to AB5.
- tomohawk 5y agoSure it did. That's why there's been a big lawsuit by the trucking industry to get it overturned, as it outlaws a longstanding business practice. https://www.caltrux.org/ab-5-faq/ https://www.caltrux.org/ab-5-faq/
- 5y ago
- leros 5y agoOn one hand, I think it's good that high school kids are getting into blue collar work like trucking. We can't complain about lack of people doing these jobs and then also be upset that young people are taking these jobs.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThis is a symptom of the decline of union labor in trucking and deregulation causing a race to the bottom. I'm unsure we should be happy high schoolers are being pulled in, versus making trucking jobs more secure and paying a living wage. There is no lack of workers, only workers willing to tolerate poor working conditions and pay. "This paper examines the forces that have reduced truck drivers' earnings. First, using 1973-91 Current Population Survey data, the authors find that deregulation accounted for one-third of the decline in drivers' wages, with a larger negative effect on non-union workers than on organized workers. Second, using unique survey data gathered in 1997, they explore the effects of three specific factors frequently cited as sources of blue-collar wage decline. This analysis indicates that only one new technology, satellite communication systems, had important effects on drivers' earnings, increasing them through improved efficiency and work intensification; education had no important influence; and union membership increased earnings by between 18% and 21%. They conclude that the two dominant and intertwined sources of wage decline and increased wage inequality among truck drivers have been deregulation and de-unionization. (Author's abstract.)" https://www.researchgate.net/publication/5119434_The_Effects_of_Deregulation_De-Unionization_Technology_and_Human_Capital_on_the_Work_and_Work_Lives_of_Truck_Drivers https://www.researchgate.net/publication/5119434_The_Effects... (can get the paper from SciHub, a family member is a truck driver)
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoUnions are a red herring, they've been mostly confined to specific economic niches (like port work) for decades and in trucking being in a niche pretty much always pays better. This has nothing to do with unions and everything to do with regulation and better administrative technology making the "mega-fleet body shop" business model more viable and owner operators and small fleets less economically viable. Swift has always paid crap and we've regulated everything else out of existence, same story as many other industries.
- flexie 5y agoThe truck driver shortage reminds me on the fossil fuel situation. Generally, we hear that truck drivers won't be needed in the future: Trucks will drive themselves. But now we have less truck drivers than we need, and the future with self driving trucks hasn't quite arrived yet Similarly, we hear that fossil fuels should be out phased. And now we have an energy crisis with not enough oil and gas. The future of renewable energy isn't quite there yet.
- Guest42 5y agoThere’s an endless supply of truck drivers, just a shortage of those willing to be underpaid and abused.
- flexie 5y agoAnd there is a seemingly endless supply of oil and gas. If you pay enough.
- Guest42 5y agoThe price of oil and gas has been far more inflated than the price of truck drivers since 1970.
- flatiron 5y agoI’ve had friends in the truck driving business and the hardest part is finding people who can stay clean with the drug testing. The Venn diagram of people wanting to drive truck and who recreationally use drugs seem to overlap a touch.
- droopyEyelids 5y agoAgain, you're only stating half the description. The hardest thing is finding people who won't take drugs _at that salary, with those working conditions_
- PaywallBuster 5y ago
- exabrial 5y agoThis made me chuckle, as this is pretty common in the midwest. My first job was at 12 years old; I drove a 6 wheeled grain truck for our family's farmer friend in the July heat to help with his wheat harvest. No a/c, windows were stuck down, 3 speed. Bruce, the farmer, rigged up a pedal extension for me on the clutch. Plenty of kids down here can drive a skid steer, tractor, truck, or loader.
- poo-yie 5y agoTwo different things. Driving a farm truck on a rural road in Nebraska is very different from driving a tractor-trailer loaded in heavy traffic on the interstate.
- exabrial 5y agoSouth Kansas actually, thank you very much. And I assume you mean that navigating a farm truck in heavy traffic on a dirt road going into the co-op, sometimes waiting for 2 hours to dump the load, with tight busy traffic passing both ways on a narrow dirt road lined with ditches that could roll the vehicle is different than what you're saying.
- njharman 5y ago> When thinking about the trucking industry, the first thing that comes to mind about its drivers is that they tend to be older No, the first thing that comes to mind is another shit job that has limited future and should be automated so humans don't have to do it.
- nimbius 5y agoOuch. I work on diesel trucks for a living and ive also been a professional driver. I never had a problem driving, but like all jobs, you gotta find something that fits. the highschool things nothing new really, as ive personally seen some young drivers in my time. trucking companies have paid for school for about 2 decades now so thats not really anything new. they pay you while you learn and in return you have offers like buying your own truck, setting your own hours, competitive pay rates and bonuses. you can even ditch your rent payments if you want, its not that hard to just live on the road. you have typically 3 job types. local (the beer truck for example), regional (milk, eggs, poultry), and intermodal/interstate (IPhones and engine blocks.) wanna stay home more? pick local. wanna see literally the entire country? then interstate professional is your calling. Literally everything you own came on a truck, so i dont think "limited future" is a fair assessment. cities like NY would grind to a halt in a few hours if they didnt have trucks and drivers. people have been calling out the death of trucking for 20 years now but its not technology thats killing it, its greedy profiteering logistics companies. the "shortage" has always been caused by this and few other things.
- pbernasconi 5y agoI co-founded https://trucksmarter.com https://trucksmarter.com to enable more drivers and owner-ops to get insurance, find loads and drive on the road
- mrg2k8 5y agoThis reminds me of an impromptu interview I saw with a teenage kid driving trucks in Africa in order to support his family. Found the link: https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1104630323217300&id=100010110281120 https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1104630323217300...
- duxup 5y agoI've got some visibility to the logistics industry. My experience doesn't quite fit some of the posts in here / that story. Drivers have been making LESS over the years for a few decades now. Nobody wants to hire 18 year olds generally, insurance wouldn't allow it any way... Logistics companies who hire drivers have been complaining about driver shortages but not increasing wages for years as well... and they actually seem to meet demand just fine. Issues at choke points like ports don't seem to be a pure driver supply issue from what I've seen. The logistics industry is super price sensitive, people will complain... but they'll also wait to ship a thing to save a couple bucks (I'm not kidding when I say a couple bucks) all while complaining. The drivers you hear who make a good living have specialized skills / work for specialized companies and do not reflect the industry as a whole.
- avgDev 5y agoI used to be friends with a few truck drivers, and all of them were making money because all of them were cheatings the books non-stop. It was basically a job requirement. Drive 48 hours? No problem. This has been made a lot more difficult with the electronic log books. Edit: Just want to add some additional information. Trucking companies at least were my friends worked, were extremely toxic. They made close to $100k. However, their personal life suffered greatly. Dispatchers would call them non-stop, even when they had doctor visits/family gatherings scheduled. The dispatchers would give them loads, that were basically humanely impossible to be delivered on-time by the book. Some of them would be awake all day, and leave in the evening then drive 24 hours+. Dispatchers would often scream at them, when they would call because they were falling asleep and were not going to make the delivery on-time because they needed a nap. Some of them actually crashed, because they saw a "deer" lol.....they fell asleep. These friends were uneducated, and made terrible financial decisions, such a purchasing expensive cars and modifying them. Little to no savings. This put them in an awful position in which they had to keep driving no matter how toxic the environment was. Unfortunately, I don't really know how they are doing today, as we grew apart.
- imtringued 5y ago>These friends were uneducated, and made terrible financial decisions, such a purchasing expensive cars and modifying them. Little to no savings. From a macroeconomic perspective these guys are heroes.
- citizenpaul 5y agoEvery single economic and worker issue can be explained with a single graph. https://files.epi.org/2013/ib388-figurea.jpg https://files.epi.org/2013/ib388-figurea.jpg Or if you really like charts https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/
- lm28469 5y agoWhile valid for a lot of industries, I'm not sure the productivity of driving a truck from A to B doubled since the 70s
- ouid 5y agothe opportunity cost still would.
- kragen 5y agoHi, I took the time to try to answer your question in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28893728 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28893728; would you be willing to clarify?
- joebob42 5y agoProbably at least a little: logistics has improved substantially since then. Also the value of the stuff in the truck is up, I'm not sure how that plays in.
- gruez 5y agoSo according to you, the 2008 recession was caused by... gap between productivity and hourly compensation? also, comparing productivity to hourly compensation is a bad comparison because it entirely omits other forms of compensation (stocks, healthcare). if i try to compare total compensation to productivty using FRED, I get: https://i.imgur.com/ohabUFu.png https://i.imgur.com/ohabUFu.png, which seems to say the opposite? Total compensation seems to have outpaced productivity growth, at least starting from 2000.
- 5y ago
- lm28469 5y agoLooks it's been known to be an issue for a while: https://www.freightwaves.com/news/driver-shortage-ata-estimates https://www.freightwaves.com/news/driver-shortage-ata-estima... https://www.reutersevents.com/supplychain/3pl/12-key-facts-about-driver-shortage-and-future-trucking-industry https://www.reutersevents.com/supplychain/3pl/12-key-facts-a... https://www.fleetowner.com/operations/drivers/article/21691766/economist-on-driver-shortage-higher-pay-alone-not-solving-it https://www.fleetowner.com/operations/drivers/article/216917... Even as early as 2005: http://www.iitr.edu/pdf/ATADriverShortageStudy05.pdf http://www.iitr.edu/pdf/ATADriverShortageStudy05.pdf
- mywittyname 5y agoSomething not mentioned in the article, and I'm sad to see NPR ignore is that the trucking industry turned predatory in the past few years (mainly because I'm sure they reported on it in the past). Certain logistics companies have been pushing drivers into "owner-operator" scenarios, where they are responsible for gas, insurance, maintenance, and lease payments, while not being given the flexibility to drive for other companies. Leaving some drivers with negative paychecks (basically, their pay didn't cover expenses). I'm betting they are going after 18 years olds specifically because they are kind of primed to into debt for a career because the college admissions process kind of primes them to think this is normal.
- fidesomnes 5y agoThis banned in California last year as a boon to unions and it completely decimated the ability to ship products from warehouses in California. They destroyed the economy through legislation.
- klenwell 5y agoMy local NPR station, KCRW, actually did a great series on this years ago covering Long Beach / LA port: https://www.kcrw.com/news/articles/cargoland-a-brief-history-of-the-ports-of-los-angeles-and-long-beach https://www.kcrw.com/news/articles/cargoland-a-brief-history... Here's a site they created dedicated to it: http://cargoland.kcrw.com/the-pirate/ http://cargoland.kcrw.com/the-pirate/ Since listening to that, a lot of the recent news I've been seeing, including this article, haven't been a surprise to me. I remember they talked specifically about how predatory the trucking industry is. They interviewed both the truckers and some of the representative from companies exploiting them. (Business model didn't sound all that different from Uber. Drivers pay for their own trucks, work as independent contractors, while large operating under control of companies.) I can't actually locate it on this site so it may have been reported in some follow-up stories. Or perhaps in details of actual story audio.
- iammisc 5y ago> while not being given the flexibility to drive for other companies. Leaving some drivers with negative paychecks (basically, their pay didn't cover expenses). This seems to me that the drivers should just file a self-written W-2 as a statutory employee and let the IRS figure it out. Not allowing an 'owner-operator' to work for other companies pretty clearly puts the 'owners' into the category of statutory employee.
- btbuildem 5y agoIs it just me or does it seem.. cruel, enlisting youth into what is a hard, and soon to be a dead-end job? They're saying "shortage of truck drivers" but that's just another way of saying "the pay is too low".
- cm2187 5y agoReminds me this headline from Aug: “Jet pilot, 37, who lost his job in lockdown when Flybe collapsed now earns MORE as a lorry driver in Britain's HGV crisis” [1] [1] https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9932619/Jet-pilot-37-lost-job-lockdown-earns-lorry-driver-Britains-HGV-crisis.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9932619/Jet-pilot-3...
- soniman 5y agoThese stories are all planted by the trucking companies. These stories have shown up a million times over the last twenty years, and maybe earlier. The WSJ, NYT, Bloomberg, WaPo and now NPR run this same article about every two weeks. It always amazes me when people tweet this article or it shows up on HN because it is so predictable. Haven't you seen this same article at least a hundred times? Where are all the truckers' yachts?
- bencollier49 5y agoI blame Brexit.
- shrubble 5y agoIt's entirely self-inflicted by the greed and avarice of the trucking companies. Such as paying $3/hour for the first 40k miles driven, which is 4-6 months of employment depending on whether driving in city areas or doing longer haul highway driving. You can read the summmary of the Supreme Court case called New Prime Inc. v. Oliveira to see some of the scummy tactics that large trucking firms pull on people: "In the present case, Dominic Oliveira sought employment with New Prime Inc., an American trucking company. When he was hired, he first had to drive 10,000 miles as an unpaid "trainee", followed by 30,000 miles as an "apprentice" working at US$4 an hour. Oliveira was then brought into the company proper, he was given the option to be hired as an employee, or as an independent contractor, which the company asserted would be more economical for Oliveira. Oliveira opted to be hired as a contractor. However, because he was an independent contractor, this allowed New Prime to charge Oliveira and other drivers through leasing of the New Prime vehicles and to pay for their own fuel and equipment through deductions from their paychecks, items that the company would normally pay for if the person was an employee. Oliveira frequently found these costs exceeded his base rate, effectively paying New Prime for his employment. While the terms of his independent contract allow him to drive for other companies, Oliveira found that his schedule was heavily dictated by New Prime. Oliveira eventually dropped the independent contractor and was rehired as an employee of New Prime, where his work duties and commitment were essentially identical to what he had done as an independent contractor, but taking home much more from his paycheck." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Prime_Inc._v._Oliveira https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Prime_Inc._v._Oliveira
- muzz 5y agoQuite a contrast from the automation-driven jobs loss that was being forecast back in 2016, even by those who should have known better. For example a quote from a piece by Ryan Petersen, the CEO of Flexport: "driverless trucking is right around the corner. The primary remaining barriers are regulatory." https://techcrunch.com/2016/04/25/the-driverless-truck-is-coming-and-its-going-to-automate-millions-of-jobs/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/04/25/the-driverless-truck-is-co...
- TedShiller 5y agoWhat could go wrong
- bluedino 5y agoLife on the road is tough. Lonely, eating truck stop food and sitting for 12 hours a day is terrible, not to mention being trapped in a truck for your whole life. Then there's the drugs and prostitution.
- cmckn 5y agoIt’s really hard on your family too. I had a few friends in high school who’s dads drove trucks, some of them single fathers. Those kids almost certainly did worse in school and got into more shit because their dad was gone all the time. It’s a really tough gig.
- SubiculumCode 5y agoBad career choice. I do believe that within 10 years, trucks will be computer driven.
- somenewaccount1 5y ago*amid logistic companies refusal to pay a living wage with reasonable hours.
- jimt1234 5y agoGrowing up in the 80s, probably around a third of the adults in my neighborhood were truck drivers, and I can confidently say that truck driving is not the same profession as it was back then. The unions were strong back then, and when they threatened to strike, companies had to pay attention.
- carapace 5y ago> Steve Viscelli, a sociologist at the University of Pennsylvania who studies the trucking industry, says adding young drivers won't solve the industry's biggest problem: retention. The article linked at "retention" seems much more interesting to me: "Is There Really A Truck Driver Shortage?" https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2021/05/25/999784202/is-there-really-a-truck-driver-shortage https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2021/05/25/999784202/is-t... > Editor's note: This is an excerpt of Planet Money's newsletter. > In a 2019 study[1] published by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, economists Stephen V. Burks and Kristen Monaco investigated claims by industry leaders that the trucking labor market was somehow "broken" enough to create a decades-long shortage. ... A thorough investigation led them to conclude that the trucking labor market is ... not broken. Yes, they say, the trucking labor market is "tight" — meaning that companies are competing to fill open jobs — but it functions in the same way as any other labor market. > "There is no shortage," says Todd Spencer, the president of the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association. His organization represents more than 150,000 mostly self-employed truck drivers around the United States. > The big trucking companies want to secure a steady supply of cheap labor, and the ATA [lobbying organization for the nation's big trucking employers, the American Trucking Associations] has spent years lobbying the federal government to loosen regulations in the industry. It's now pushing for the DRIVE-Safe Act[2] in Congress, which would allow 18-year-olds to begin driving trucks across state lines. Right now, drivers must be at least 21. > The real problem, Spencer says, is not a shortage but retention. According to the ATA's own statistics, the average annual turnover rate for long-haul truckers at big trucking companies has been greater than 90% for decades. > "We have millions of people who have been trained to be heavy-duty truck drivers who are currently not working as heavy-duty truck drivers because the entry-level jobs are terrible," says Steve Viscelli, a sociologist at the University of Pennsylvania who studies the trucking industry. > Compared with other blue-collar occupations, the median annual income of trucking is actually pretty good: $47,130. But long-haul truckers commonly work extremely long hours, often 60 to 70 hours per week or more. And drivers are typically not paid by the hour. Instead, they are typically paid only for the number of miles they drive. The average truck driver gets paid 52.3 cents per mile, according to the Department of Transportation. Even if weather or traffic slows them down and extends their working day, they get paid the same. Moreover, they're not compensated for the significant time it takes to load or unload their trucks. And they're not compensated for their "off time," even though they're miles and miles away from home. > Being a long-haul trucker also means living out of your truck, because motels are pretty expensive and often don't have parking for big rigs. Meanwhile, finding parking to rest anywhere is a growing problem. Truckers sacrifice their health, sitting on their butt for hours and hours and eating junk food on the road. And the job is dangerous: Truck drivers are 10 times more likely to be killed on the job than the average worker. > But, Viscelli says, through political lobbying, legal activism and harsh business practices, big trucking companies have made a difficult job even harder, especially for entry-level truckers. He says the companies have been "systematically degrading trucker working conditions." Scholars have referred to trucks as "sweatshops on wheels." Viscelli says the industry is rife with minimum wage violations and what he calls "debt peonage." Basically, new drivers become indentured servants, going deep into debt to get training and to lease trucks from their employers > The debate over whether to call this a retention problem or a shortage may seem like mincing words. But it matters for the solution. The ATA and its allies argue that the "shortage" means the government should further relax regulations and make it easier for anyone to become an interstate truck driver. Insurance and rental car companies know that teenagers are much more likely to get into an accident — which is why they charge them more. But the "shortage"! We need teenagers to do the job! > Frame the issue as a retention crisis, however, and the onus falls on the industry to make long-haul trucking more attractive as a profession. After decades of stagnant wages and shriveling opportunities for blue-collar workers, this is the market working on their behalf for a change: forcing employers to pay workers enough to do a really hard but vital job. [1] March 2019 "Is the U.S. labor market for truck drivers broken?" https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2019/article/is-the-us-labor-market-for-truck-drivers-broken.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2019/article/is-the-us-labor-ma... [2] https://www.young.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/senators-reintroduce-bipartisan-drive-safe-act https://www.young.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/senator...
- mensetmanusman 5y agoSomeone needs to invent a standing desk like driving rig (wearing harnesses or what not). It wouldn’t be a bad job if you could stay fit and listen to audio books.
- carabiner 5y agoHow is this possible? 18 year olds can't even rent a car, you usually need to be 25.