10 ms·
Apple is working on iPhone features to help detect depression, cognitive decline
- twofornone 5y agoConsidering the unspoken consequences that a depression diagnosis can carry, surely this is rife for abuse. Imagine being involuntary committed after a "wellness check" brought on by your "smart" phone.
- yonaguska 5y agoImagine being red flagged by your phone and having a swat team show up to confiscate your guns. Google and Apple absolutely know if you are a gun owner.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoIf this had been released in, oh, 2019... it would have been very revealing during the worst of the pandemic.
- spansoa 5y agoI think people are aware of when they're Doomscrolling[0]. Do they need their devices to remind them of excessive screentime? That depends on what info they're consuming. I deliberately follow and subscribe to positive and uplifting content, and people. There are plenty of groups on Facebook, and lists on Twitter that have nothing but inspirational messages and content to make you Think Different™ about your life. I have two news apps on my device that I check daily just to keep tabs on current events. I deliberately train my feeds not to have news-type content because once I've read the news, I don't need to see it popup in my feeds again throughout the day. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomscrolling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomscrolling
- raman162 5y ago> I deliberately train my feeds not to have news-type content because once I've read the news, I don't need to see it popup in my feeds again throughout the day. Sad that we have to train the feed on our apps to be more positive. I'm happy that you found a way to beat the system but I believe some people do have a negative relationship that feels "out of their control" with their phones and the internet. I think apple wants people to always have a positive relationship with their devices and promoting healthier habits on their devices is a step to keep iOS users happy.
- gentle 5y agoI've lost all trust in Apple.
- w-j-w 5y agoThis is an even flimsier excuse than CSAM for my phone to spy on me, isn't it.
- h2odragon 5y agoWe''l tell you when you're happy, we'll tell you when you're sick, put your faith in us! We don't miss a trick. We'll tell you when to sleep, where and what to eat, with neural networked data our judgment can't be beat. It only costs a little, all your friends bought in, you don't want to be the odd one, do you? Clubhouse is The Thing! We know your body, we know your mind, we hold your worldview safe. Hew only unto Apple lest the unclean seal your fate.
- selimthegrim 5y agoJust waiting for the Taliban moderated Clubhouse channel to add “Be Good for Goodness’ Sake!”
- polishdude20 5y agoSomething something Adam and Eve ate an apple and were banished from paradise.
- WesolyKubeczek 5y agoTheir hell was a version of paradise where they had to eat apples all day long, for the fear of missing out and for the sake of appearances.
- the-dude 5y agoI can't see how this will be sold. Get the latest iPhone to see if you are depressed! Depressing.
- jkestner 5y agoBackwards. It’ll be an OS update that tells you your happiness score is nil, but you can start tracking it with the new iPhone. Then you’ll get nudges to close that Mood Ring by watching Ted Lasso.
- babarganesh 5y agothe obvious use case is to use facial expression detection to track how much attention people are paying to advertisements
- user-the-name 5y agoCould we not waste time on making inane comments like this, just for today. What you just said has nothing to do with this article, nor does it match anything Apple does, as they don't even serve advertisements in any form, and offer lots of ways for users to cut down on advertising.
- vmachine1001 5y agoIt was terribly dangerous to let your thoughts wander when you were in any public place or within range of a telescreen. The smallest thing could give you away. A nervous tic, an unconscious look of anxiety, a habit of muttering to yourself -- anything that carried with it the suggestion of abnormality, of having something to hide. In any case, to wear an improper expression on your face (to look incredulous when a victory was announced, for example) was itself a punishable offence. -- 1984
- gordon_freeman 5y agoRead 1984 so many times and it still gives me chills whenever I read it again.
- Tade0 5y agoIf you, ahem, liked 1984, you'll want to read: https://elan.school/ https://elan.school/
- oblak 5y agoOK, you lost me 15 minutes, possibly more soon. What is this?
- Tade0 5y agoAn art therapy project done by a man who as a teenager found himself in a "tough love" "school"(heavy quotes in both cases) as an alternative to juvie after he was caught with a month's worth of hashish. Long story short prison would have been more humane. EDIT: Reading this made me physically ill. It's the embodiment of my worst fears.
- andrei_says_ 5y agoThis was terrifying and heartbreaking.
- chestervonwinch 5y ago
- rafaelturk 5y agoHere's an ideia: Why not just remove Facebook, Instagram?
- swarnie 5y agoBecause those are 2 of the 3 most popular apps and my retirement account depends on their continued success.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoOr, severely regulate what they can do with your information, and make them pay their users for any material the user contributes. It could be a few cents for commenting, but anything to stop the growth, and monopolies. The catch is only on companies that are valued over a billion dollars, excluding credit. A company couldn't borrow heavily in order to stay below a threshold. This would Only apply to large monopolies that are valued over 1 billion. The small companies would be free of any regulations. I mean any. Small companies could experment, and maybe have a chance at making it. I could just see Zucky sitting on a high chair in front of Congress crying, "But it's just not faaaair, and my wife doesn't like it either? You are penalizing Machiavellian success governor--oops--I mean Senator? The one Senator that kinda understand tech, "No Marky--we are just stopping cancer, and giving small companies a chance to get out of your shadow.". Mark, "Do you have any tissue besides this government cotten stuff. I'm used to lanolin apricot infused tissues! And where's my professional nose Wiper?"
- asiachick 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- babbledabbler 5y agoThis is creepy.
- devindotcom 5y agoUCLA has been working with them for quite a while on this: https://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/ucla-launches-major-mental-health-study-to-discover-insights-about-depression https://newsroom.ucla.edu/releases/ucla-launches-major-menta... It's creepy in a way, but monitoring activity and expressions could result in some valuable insights about warning signs, habits and such. My guess is Apple is just wondering if it can snip out something clinically viable from the part that relies on its hardware. Doesn't mean it's a great idea, but this is part of a larger science push.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nobody0 5y agoFeeling sad, angry, depressed are essential parts of who we really are. We are not something sits in containers waiting to be amused at every second. Salut, brave new world.
- burnished 5y agoClinical depression is different from feeling sad. Being able to detect cognitive decline would probably be a great boon in elder care.
- maybelsyrup 5y ago> Clinical depression is different from feeling sad. I don't want to come off as a pedant on this, but the prevailing definitions of clinical depression show quite clearly that it's a difference of degree, and not of kind. Clinical depression can indeed be "feeling sad": > Criterion A.1: Depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day, as indicated by either subjective report (e.g., feels sad, empty, hopeless) or observation made by others (e.g., appears tearful). (Note: In children and adolescents, can be irritable mood.) > The essential feature of a major depressive episode is a period of at least 2 weeks during which there is either depressed mood or the loss of interest or pleasure in nearly all activities (Criterion A) > The mood in a major depressive episode is often described by the person as depressed, sad, hopeless, discouraged, or "down in the dumps" (Criterion Al). In some cases, sadness may be denied at first but may subsequently be elicited by interview (e.g., by pointing out that the individual looks as if he or she is about to cry). In some individuals who complain of feeling "blah," having no feelings, or feeling anxious, the presence of a depressed mood can be inferred from the person's facial expression and demeanor. Both of these are straight from the DSM-5 (pp. 160-163) on Major Depressive Disorder: this is what's used to diagnose you, and not any blood test or neurotransmitter assay. "Depressed mood" is not described in any further detail, by the way. (Which, to me anyway, was always surprising in itself. You'd think there'd be more precision.) Again, I hope this illuminating instead of pedantic. The notion that "clinical depression is not 'the blues'" is common enough these days, and it's well-intended, but people can get a somewhat mistaken impression from it. I think maybe it's safer to say that "clinical depression is indeed the blues, but also some other stuff on a list of 8, for an extended period of time".
- Jtsummers 5y agoSince most of the comments here seem to be on the hysterical side: 1. This is not something Apple is rolling out now with their devices and systems. 2. This is research being done by UCLA and BioNTech using Apple's various sensors. 3. There's nothing concerning here (yet). This is a common kind of research using novel sensors (either actually novel sensors or taking advantage of their now-pervasiveness). Webcams were used as part of studies at least 15 years ago (by classmates while I was in grad school). Other sensors have been used for decades to monitor people in research studies to see if they could be used to detect conditions either after they'd developed or earlier while still developing. The only interesting thing about this is that the researchers are using Apple's sensors, and that's not terribly interesting at all. Last year, Garmin and Oura partnered with DOD and others to use their sensors to try and detect COVID infections before people developed the obvious symptoms, was that terrifying to any of you?
- bfga 5y agoThe pattern is always the same. When an invasive technology or a precursor to an invasive technology is announced, someone on HN sagely points out that everyone should be reasonable and drop the conspiracy theories. Five years later the tech is on everyone's phone.
- m463 5y agoalso, even if "privacy" is assured, once the tech is normalized either the private version can be cracked, or a similar but non-private tech is released everywhere else (with hooks for advertising/data-mining/govt access)
- ashtonkem 5y agoWhich is why all the afib data from watchOS got leaked to increase insurance costs, right? Right? Sometimes the sky does not actually fall.
- snypher 5y agoHow would you know if it was? It was more likely sold by whoever collected it. The very existence of this pool of data is a risk, and just because the sky didn't fall today, do you stop wearing a seatbelt?
- sennight 5y agoThe single most valuable datapoint for advertisers is depression - they figured out a long time ago that depressed people are more easily marketed to. You can be sure they've already perfected the state of the art as far as is economically practical. Either Apple knows this already, or... actually, I can't think of any plausible reason that they wouldn't already know this.
- worrycue 5y agoNot sure how true that is. I’m relatively depressed … I don’t spend much money as I can’t be bothered.
- sennight 5y agoYeah I'm just making it up, all those years managing analytics for tens of millions of highly engaged subscribers and dealing with scumbag databrokers pales in comparison to "advertising doesn't work on me".
- illwrks 5y agoJust measure the amount of time spent on various social media apps...
- borski 5y agoAs a counterpoint to everything here, the Apple Watch just saved a friends life by telling them they were in AFib. Yes, it could be bad. Or it could be medically beneficial to people who are anxious and depressed and simply don’t have anyone to help them recognize it because they’re alone. Particularly during the pandemic, that would have been useful.
- worrycue 5y agoFrankly, it would probably be fine if it could be turned off and if turned on, doesn’t report its findings back to Apple (or anyone, but you, for the matter).
- user-the-name 5y agoNo Apple health features report anything back to Apple or anyone else. Why would you expect this to be different?
- multiplegeorges 5y agoOh, I don't know... the behaviour of the entire rest of the tech industry.
- user-the-name 5y agoBut this is not being done by the rest of the tech industry, it is being done by Apple, specifically, who have a record of behaviour with medical data that, as far as I am aware, is spotless.
- hungryforcodes 5y agoEven if that's true -- and you've provided no proof -- the data would most likely get stored on iCloud, and just like iPhotos, Apple will decide one day to just start trolling through it for fun and profit. CSAM is coming back in other ways. Apple will try again.
- knaik94 5y agoIf a human with a medical degree has a hard time diagnosing mental health issues after spending hours with a person, I don't see how this research will provide anything except noisy garbage data.
- okwubodu 5y agoOn the health app there's a new feature to share your biometric data with your doctor, which I can see improving their accuracy and diagnoses. I'm not sure where you got the idea that the data is garbage, but even I (untrained, not a doctor) can pick up patterns and make positive changes from the data collected.
- knaik94 5y agoMy comment is focused on data related to mental health issues. A heart rate is a very specific number that is a directly related to your heart function. Cognitive functions, focus and mental health issues can't directly be tied to things like screen use time, sleep patterns, facial expressions, and the most nebulous metric, a self reported mood score. The point of this research is also to remove the human element from the analysis loop.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoDepressed after spending so much on a iPhone? here's your happy face emoji.
- trhway 5y agoafter a college shooting sometime ago Russia started (and after the recent one in Perm - added even more funds of course) a program to identify and monitor potentially dangerous youth - the first line is automated monitoring of Internet, mostly social media (i don't remember anything specific about mobile device tracking/listening though i bet it is included officially or not), and the signal from the automated system is passed to human analysts, and they may apply actions like trigger police visit "to talk"/etc.
- user-the-name 5y agoThis website is a disaster.
- ArchStanton 5y agoI can imagine the advertising value of watching for depression and cognitive decline. In the latter case, you could probably sell a dozen extended warranties for the same item. EZ prediction of the day. Combine depression, cognitive decline, anger, etc. values against a database of gun owners (picked up through registration, social media posts, ATF background checks, etc.). Send police to house when some crossover point is hit. It's for the children.
- BoorishBears 5y agoOr maybe detect people who might be unstable through paranoid ramblings about how Apple is out to get gun owners before they can "take a stand against the tyranny". Probably less work and marginally more fruitful.
- ArchStanton 5y agoI'll improve that... ...detect people who might be unstable through paranoid ramblings about how Apple is out to _fill_in_the_blank_. The spice must flow to keep those stock options in Cupertino rising.
- BoorishBears 5y agoWhy do I get the impression this is an attempt at being mysterious because "can't openly state something that's wrongthink!" When really no one would consider what you're vaguely implying "wrongthink" or inflammatory at all. They'd probably just consider it "normal wrong" and poorly supported by reality...
- ArchStanton 5y agoNo mystery. You can simply make the claim that Apple would detect anything that's anti-Apple. Why not? It isn't like that the company has anything approaching morality, aside from perhaps the occasional craziness from the worker-drones there.
- cblconfederate 5y agoFrom what i understand, absurd overregulation prevents hundreds of diseases to be diagnosed because ... reasons. They cant add various sensors, but they happily add useless and dangerous stuff like face recognition, even if it 's harder to implemetn. You can't even get a health report based on your genetic profile anymore. Which i understand can be a problematic in the US but it s happening in europe too It is curious that they chose depression and cognitive decline because , even if you diagnose them , depression is iffy to treat and i dont know anything to prescribe for cognitive decline
- iszomer 5y ago> From what i understand, absurd overregulation prevents hundreds of diseases to be diagnosed because ... reasons. They cant add various sensors, but they happily add useless and dangerous stuff like face recognition, even if it 's harder to implemetn. You can't even get a health report based on your genetic profile anymore. Which i understand can be a problematic in the US but it s happening in europe too Opting into [a feature] should be as easy as opting out. I for one don't mind people making their data available for analysis but to include a blanket default opt-in for everything is the very reason why "absurd overregulation" exists now. > It is curious that they chose depression and cognitive decline because , even if you diagnose them , depression is iffy to treat and i dont know anything to prescribe for cognitive decline Especially when depression and cognitive decline can be so subjective. For example, I think CSAM is quite objectively understood as detrimental for everyone but is it really in Apple's interest to specify a systemwide implementation for all of their product lines to combat this behavior?
- ljm 5y agoI suffer from bi-polar disorder and it's been difficult to get a referral to a psychiatrist who can confirm the diagnosis. The depressive phases are easier to spot and I get medication for that when it's too bad. The thing is, there are already countless mechanisms that can track the obvious symptoms of a manic phase, but none of them have an incentive to tell you that you're suddenly spending too much. Frivolous purchases have increased, monthly spend is up, you're staying up late and buying shit on Amazon at 2am, etc. You're at the pub more often, and drinking more. You're working late or staying involved with work, late. The data is all there, why can't it be used to say... maybe you're in a manic phase, you need to know this. But more generically, if Apple invested in this but also kept the data open and portable (i.e. adhering to or contributing to FIHR and similar medical standards), I would switch back. Basically, using the mass of data to understand your mental state and physiology, privately, instead of powering the ad industry.
- fragmede 5y agoWhere hours of sleep/night is a reasonable proxy, providers of sleep tracking aren't incentivized to let you spend as much on Amazon as you can. A warning that says something like "hey, you've been getting ~2 hrs of sleep/night with no naps for the past couple days, you might want to consider doing X" would go a long way to helping me manage my symptoms.
- graeme 5y agoOh, you can actually do that with Shortcuts and Apple Health, today! Mine has a bug for some reason so I can’t make it, but basically: 1. Get details of health sample, should be one for time asleep 2. Get the number, compare it to the total you want a warning at 3. Display a custom notification if below threshold 4. Set this to run as an automation at like 9 am or whenever, daily, without asking My only point of doubt is whether you can get this week’s sleep as a health sample. But you can definitely get last night’s sleep from the health app. I also checked Autosleep. They have a sleep bank function in shortcuts. You can parse the dictionary output, extract sleep debt and hours sleep, compare both to a set level, and alert if either is beyond threshold. Autosleep is a great, inexpensive app. Works best with apple watch but can function without. Shortcuts has gotten extremely powerful in past few years. Anyone on HN with an iphone should check it out. You can automate all kinds of stuff.
- yumraj 5y agoIf and when these become common, while there will be instances where such devices and detection is helpful and life saving, I'm wondering if for the larger population it will only lead to increased hypochondria. Only time will tell I guess..
- CharlesW 5y agoAt least one study has discovered that for some hypochondriacs, seeing previously-hidden health data can increase health anxiety. I personally find it reassuring and helpful in improving behaviors.
- indymike 5y agoThese are features I do not want and will not buy. This is one step too personal.
- fartcannon 5y agoApple is working on iPhone features that, when they leak, will hurt your ability to get a job, and health insurance.
- odyssey7 5y agoThe same could be said about electronic health record software generally. Electronic healthcare data as a phenomenon isn't going anywhere; it will only get bigger, and individuals stand to benefit tremendously from this fact as it will make early diagnoses and getting the right care at the right time more likely. Rather than panic when we find out that another company will be handling healthcare data, we need to set high standards for engineering, security, user consent, and privacy expectations for companies working in this area.
- yyyk 5y agoThe comparison between software that lets doctors file data you give them and software that may do proactive automatic monitoring of users is absurd.
- odyssey7 5y agoThe specific concern raised in the parent comment is about healthcare data leaks. In my view, every company handling healthcare data should be responsible for keeping that data safe and having proper consent, regardless of whether the software is paid for by doctors or by iPhone users. I don't think this viewpoint is absurd.
- yyyk 5y ago>The specific concern raised in the parent comment is about healthcare data leaks. Hacking electronic health record software requires hacking into data centres/cloud providers. Hacking this proposal merely requires hacking an iPhone. Electronic health record software only stores data you wish to allow your health provider to discover. Apple and co. are (according to the article) thinking about automatic collection. This proposal is dramatically more expansive than typical health records.
- bdcravens 5y agoIt's kind of already there. I can look at time spent in certain apps - when I'm in a depressed mood, I find myself trapped in brainless swiping, instead of being motivated to do the things that bring me joy and productivity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- concinds 5y agoA little dismayed that the sci-fi "tech futurism" attitude of previous decades is now a beaten, lifeless corpse. Opt-in health features that give you more control over your health? World-ending! But 20 years ago, we were imagining a little wristband-type machine that would be able to non-invasively and routinely analyse blood samples, detecting cancer a decade early, increasing human lifespans, etc. This pattern is all over the place now. I get there's reasons for it, but let's take into account one thing: throughout history, the luddites/skeptics were rarely right in their apocalyptic predictions. People today may be deciding to drop all smartphones, avoid modern TVs, avoid modern computers and stick to a 2008 barebones ThinkPad, give up music streaming services and run their own email; i.e. refusing any of the time-efficiency gains technology gave us in the last decades and ensuring they'll spend much more time troubleshooting and maintaining tech, taking away from the precious, short time they have on this earth, all to what end? That hypothetical person, who switches away from all corporate technology because of Apple's CSAM news, is now maintaining their own music library, turning music discovery from something that takes seconds, to taking minutes or hours. A pattern that'll repeat itself throughout their life if they're consistent. But will Apple users be living in camps, in 2050, because the frog will finally be boiled by then? Or will none of these fears turn out to be real concerns, and CSAM-detection's (just using it as an example, since that seems like a catalyst for many here) errors will be extremely rare and rapidly corrected? To me, the risk of dystopia is lowered not by those willing to burn it all down and give up modern society, it's lowered by the fact that modern society is too interconnected for these dystopian scenarios to unfold like a novel: laws will be passed, corporations will be pressured by social media campaigns, and the state of the world will remain "mostly acceptable" just like today. Why the endemic pessimism?
- kergonath 5y agoThere's a kind of collective paranoid delusion here (I mean, on the Internet in general). When you start from the idea that they are all about to get you, it's easy to interpret anything as a confirmation of your suspicions. It is not easy to be rational with this sort of siege mentality, which is reinforced by the fact that non-technophiles do not seem to get it or take it seriously. We've gone from a (unwarranted) radical techno-optimism to (just as unwarranted) general hostility. A consequence of that is the pervasiveness of this cynical, nihilistic mood, which quickly corrupts most discussions every time some subjects pop up. To some extent, these companies brought this onto themselves with some objectively despicable behaviours, but we are not doing ourselves any favours.
- bwship 5y agoUsed in conjunction with Apple Maps, they could start pushing people to take long drives off of short piers.
- nbzso 5y agoEveryday passing by I feel better and better that removed myself from Apple ecosystem. As I felt they will be more invasive than Google and Faceebook combined. Google has your search data, Faceebook has what you share, Apple has your entire life in a box. And this is only the start. Minority Report seems like very optimistic rendition of the future. Where are my soma pills, Apple? What you mean that "the bottle is not included" in a purchase? It is subscription service? For my health and well being? OK. And dear friends, if you are blind where all this "advancements" and "progress" are going, nobody can help you. I feel that conspiracy theorists will have hard times ahead. They cannot be creative and competitive as marketing and pr cohorts of richest companies of the world.:)
- black_13 5y agoI am getting a nokia 3310
- twirlock 5y agoHow about Apple work on iPhone features to do what I tell it and not the other way around.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/hRTnw https://archive.is/hRTnw
- asn0 5y agoWill this detect depression caused by too much time on your iPhone? </snark>
- throwawaymanbot 5y agoAn ever deeper Surveillance infrastructure.
- hungryforcodes 5y agoMore spying from the spiPhone people. Nice!
- agumonkey 5y agoso your next iphone will autosuggest to get rid of itself ? one step closer to full sentience.
- black_13 5y agoI just when out and purchased nokia 3310 and will switch to that.