18 ms·
Facebook paid billions to spare Zuckerberg in data suit, shareholders allege
- throwoutway 5y agoThat doesn’t really help shareholders does it? Except Zuck has his own shareholder class so it really does! This is another reason against multiple classes of share
- avalys 5y agoFB's valuation is currently around $1T. Shareholders should be pretty happy with what Zuck has done with FB's business and this seems sufficient to justify protecting him from what would have been a major personal distraction. But by all means, have sympathy for all those shareholders who were forced to invest their money in FB stock against their will and without any knowledge of the ownership structure.
- CamelCaseName 5y agoWho exactly was forced to invest money into FB stock? Why should we have any sympathy for them given the stock is up 200% over the past 5 years?
- avalys 5y agoI was being sarcastic.
- CamelCaseName 5y agoMy apologies, that went over my head. Thank you for clarifying.
- edoceo 5y agoMy friends mocked me for buying on IPO day. Sold 1/2 a few months ago. I don't use the network but thanks for the money Zuck!
- skeeter2020 5y agoWeird flex. Do you have a system I can buy that will let me reproduce your results?
- edoceo 5y agoDice. Purchase from your local gaming house.
- neonnoodle 5y agoAnyone with a retirement account in an index fund!
- asteroidbelt 5y agoAnyone with a retirement account can pick a different fund. They can be even buy individual stocks to collect their own portfolio. Or even buy anti-Facebook security. But there's no demand for that as far as I see. So I guess shareholders are actually happy, and unhappy are the people here on HN who are not shareholders.
- JohnFen 5y agoThere is a rather large number of investors that are not happy, and aren't quiet about it. That's why Facebook faces investor lawsuits every so often.
- asteroidbelt 5y agoInvestors sue because they can, not because they are unhappy.
- cool_dude85 5y agoWhere does this logic end? If Zuck shoots a guy in the middle of the street, is it fine for FB to finance his legal defense fund? Hire operators to bust him out of jail if he's convicted? Both of those "protect shareholder value" in the same sense as this.
- vasco 5y agoIt ends in illegal activities. If you disagree with the settlement you should harp on the FTC for having offered it. Zuck is no saint but this "where does it end" is a poor argument.
- cool_dude85 5y agoFTC seemed to think that Zuck was taking part in illegal activities right up until he offered a few extra billion in the deal. So it ends, well, before the article being discussed?
- COGlory 5y agoYou can't prove it's illegal if you stop it from ever going to court.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Where does this logic end? When there is an actual cost to Zuckerberg's behavior. So far, Silicon Valley is fine working for Facebook and Wall Street fine financing it. Users aren't rebelling. Advertisers are docile. Where is a politician aspiring to take Zuckerberg on supposed to find berth? (Genuine question.) The only fecund ground, to my sense, is the far right accusing Facebook of censoring its Nazism and far left upset that Zuckerberg is rich. Neither makes for a sustainably extensible base.
- shmageggy 5y agoWhat about the far middle who have been hearing for years how Facebook is eroding democracy, providing a platform for misinformation, instilling anxiety in teenage girls (the latest headline), and on and on. Zuckerberg continually makes decisions that benefit him and shareholders to the detriment of society and humanity. I think there's a greater appetite for change than it might appear, but I also think for the average person, it's really, really hard to imagine what that might be.
- lordlic 5y agoI'm not sure what you think minority ownership of a public company should entail, but surely you'd agree that it should protect them from the majority shareholder spending unlimited amounts of company cash to save themselves from personal inconvenience/embarrassment?
- asteroidbelt 5y ago"Personal inconvenience/embarrassment" will hurt his ability to operate the company efficiently. Protecting CEO is (usually) in the best interest of minor shareholders. This is why companies pay for personal security of CEOs or for their personal PR (most large companies, not just Facebook). > spending unlimited amounts of company cash This is clearly not the case here.
- lordlic 5y ago$4.9B over what the fine would otherwise have been is pretty hefty. I don't think any human alive is worth $4.9B to their employer.
- asteroidbelt 5y agoPerhaps damage to Z would result in damage to FB for more than 5B (company market cap would definitely fall for more than that, and it could result in large mismanagement in the following years), so he is worth it.
- lordlic 5y agoI meant "really" worth, for some reasonable definition of "really." But I can't argue that market cap is a more pragmatic definition of worth, so your point is fair enough I guess.
- skeeter2020 5y agoSo if I buy a share today at the $1T valuation, I DON'T support Zuck in this case, but if I bought one ten years ago I DO, because he made me rich?
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> So if I buy a share today at the $1T valuation, I DON'T support Zuck in this case, but if I bought one ten years ago I DO, because he made me rich? If you bought a share today, you presumably aren't doing it out of charity.
- howaboutnope 5y agoThis wouldn't be a "distraction", this would be him owning his shit. The distraction from that is what he fills the rest of his life with.
- sfg 5y agoThey bought under the condition of the ownership structure and also the law. If, as alleged, the law was broken, then there is nothing wrong with shareholders seeking redress.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoI would argue against that argument. Arguably, Zuckerberg was instrumental in getting FB to where it is today. It is not inconceivable that protecting him is protecting shareholder value.
- Slartie 5y agoFrom which alternate reality, where you were able to observe how a Facebook "fork" governed in a non-dictatorial fashion has turned out, did you learn this "arguable" information?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoI am genuinely not sure why this is a controversial statement. Allow me to rephrase this in a very quantifiable way. FB IPO opened at $38 ( https://www.fool.com/investing/2019/11/17/if-you-invested-5000-facebook-ipo-how-much-have.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/2019/11/17/if-you-invested-50... ). Today it trades at $346 ( https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/FB?p=FB https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/FB?p=FB ). That is 9 times the initial investment value. Now, we can argue how much of that increase should be given to Zuckerberg in the form of credit for directing the company, but I am relatively certain that the answer is not zero. I stand by my initial post. It is very much arguable. edit: Hatred of Zuckerberg really should not be blind. I mean there is enough there to dislike him for. There is no need to invent stuff.
- croes 5y ago"That was on Thursday. What did he do on Friday?"
- bostonsre 5y ago> It is one thing for the media to say false things about my work, but it's crossing the line to say I'm riding an electric surfboard when that video clearly shows a hydrofoil that I'm pumping with my own legs. Just read that incredibly smug quote from him in response to the many recent articles critiquing Facebook.. It is not blind hatred, I would say it is very well targeted hatred of someone who has an enormous impact on the world while only caring about Facebook. His denial and stubbornness is approaching that of a very recent ex president. https://m.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10113917270654841&set=a.529237706231&type=3 https://m.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10113917270654841&set=...
- dqv 5y agoIf we’re talking about this from strictly the shareholders’ perspective, deposing Zuckerberg would do more than $5 billion in damage to Facebook.
- loeg 5y agoFB investors seem pretty happy with Zuck's leadership of the company, and it's pretty easy to see the argument that the additional cost was well worth it to keep him at the helm.
- notRobot 5y agoSo do we consider this a fine or a bribe? Either way it's someone who did (and continues to do) something terrible getting away with a slap on the wrist.
- vkou 5y agoIf the director of the FTC uses it to buy herself a yacht, it's a bribe. If not, it's 'fine'.
- Ekaros 5y agoYou can't bribe a government, you can bribe an official. Though I suppose executive position after year or two doesn't count...
- alex_young 5y agoI don't follow, why can't one bribe a government? This actually sounds a lot like that.
- Ekaros 5y agoBribe is something that government prosecutes for paying. So agreeing on a fine imposed by them is not a bribe. Even if it can get you out of lot of trouble.
- paxys 5y agoIt is a bribe if it is going into some official's pocket. Making a settlement with a government agency is fully legal.
- throwaway1777 5y agoDistinctions like this are why people feel the government is hopelessly corrupt. It really makes no difference whose pocket it’s going into. It’s paying money to game the system.
- 5y ago
- hellbannedguy 5y ago"Zuckerberg, Sandberg, and other Facebook directors agreed to authorize a multi-billion settlement with the FTC as an express quid pro quo to protect Zuckerberg from being named in the FTC’s complaint, made subject to personal liability, or even required to sit for a deposition,” one of the suits alleged." Don't even think about messing with Mark's personal assets.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- GoodJokes 5y agoWhy do any of you still work there or use this app? Have some respect for yourselves.
- yWrykKFMoW 5y agoI work in one of the FAANG. Every thread on HN about one of these companies has a sub thread that reads something like this. Asking genuinely, where is the line? I now work at FAANG, but even before that I used products/services from FAANG for email/online shopping/grocery shopping/staying in touch with family and friends/electronic devices etc etc. I am not sure if anyone can completely exclude themselves from using all product/services from FAANG. I worked at a small startup before, but as a company we used tech/OSS from FAANG, used their products/services e.g. email/ cloud services etc. Even if I am not a customer, I always held FAANG stock and benefited from them in my retirement account (indirectly via index funds). So honestly, I am curious, where is the line?
- Cipater 5y agoIf you cared, you wouldn't work there. You might as well extend it a step further and stop caring what people on HN think about it.
- pdabbadabba 5y agoThis headline desperately needs to be corrected to reflect the fact that this is an allegation in a lawsuit, not something Politico is reporting as fact.
- drummer 5y agoTwo different classes of criminals made a deal with eachother. News at 11.
- zestyping 5y agoDisgusting.
- gordon_freeman 5y agoI don't understand how this kind of deal is even legally allowed? This is clearly against the Shareholders' interests to overpay the fine in order to protect the personal interests of some top FB executives.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoIt is not, but the FTC is the entity enforcing that. This is corruption, pure and simple.
- rscoots 5y agoAnother thread mentioned that as a figurehead of Facebook, Zucc being named in this could conceivably lead to bad outcomes for shareholders via bad press. My question is, if he was named would that lead to an investigation of his personal actions and dealings becoming public? If visibility into internal workings of the CEO is bad for shareholders then that's the way it ought to be I feel.
- paxys 5y agoI'm curious how the FTC could make Zuckerberg personally liable in any lawsuit.
- OldHand2018 5y agoNot letting you know that was worth $4.9 billion
- paxys 5y ago> The FTC also said in court that Facebook’s fine would have been closer to $106 million, but the company agreed to the $5 billion penalty to avoid having Zuckerberg or Chief Operating Officer Sheryl Sandberg deposed and any liability for the CEO, the suit alleged. This is bizarre. I get throwing in a little extra to shield executives, but $5 billion?
- paulcarroty 5y agoThis is crazy money, yeah, for us.
- ctvo 5y agoIt's not the amount. It's the ratio. They overpaid by over 47 times. A company filled with world class lawyers and business executives, as well as an experienced board does that? Why?
- pjc50 5y agoBecause the boss told them to?
- Reubachi 5y agoyes....that's what's crazy: why? Not sure the why folks are confused about folks being confused about this. There must be some logical reason they would pay out close to 50x the demanded payout, but none of us for the life of us can imagine why beyond shielding personal liability. So, why is that possible?
- Cederfjard 5y agoIt’s not only personal liability - surely Zuckerberg and Sandberg being deposed would be a liability for Facebook as well.
- 5y ago
- klyrs 5y agoImpressive. Does this count as a benefit that Zuck owes taxes on? Or does FB write it off as a loss that reduces their tax burden at no cost to Zuck?
- mrep 5y agoFor the corporation, it depends on the fine. Normally they cannot write off fines but apparently it does happen if it is not considered an official penalty or fine: https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/how-80-billion-in-coporate-fines-can-become-48-billion-in-tax-breaks/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/how-80-billion-in...
- CoastalCoder 5y agoSo it's a "donation" to avoid legal trouble. I'm not a lawyer, but that certainly stinks like bribery (or perhaps extortion) to me.
- autokad 5y agoI don't reckon this is something that is taxed. We don't get taxed if an employer pays for us to go to a conference, offers us legal advice, etc.
- andi999 5y agoActually here if the employer pays too much for going to a conference (for some countries more than 24€ per day for food) then that amount needs to be taxed.
- GrumpyNl 5y agoCrazy and so corrupt.
- xutopia 5y agoSo money fixes everything.
- throwaway3975 5y agoThe full headline is “Facebook paid billions extra to the FTC to spare Zuckerberg in data suit, shareholders allege”. This is just an allegation.
- jaywalk 5y agoYeah, a journalist has to say "alleged" because it's a lawsuit that hasn't been settled in court yet. But it happened, and there's evidence. So it's more than "just an allegation."
- InvaderFizz 5y agoIf that outrages you, how about using threats of fines as an end run around congressional appropriations to fund pet projects? See: https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/will-biden-restore-charitable-shakedowns-11611857183 https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/will-biden-restore-charitab... This has been an ongoing problem since Bush Jr, it was halted under Trump, and it looks like this admin has brought it back. It's a nice bit of work: We'll settle with you, for a reduced amount, but you have to make a tax-deductible donation to these foundations we specify. Don't worry that they are in no way helping the victims of your malfeasance.
- naveen99 5y agoHow much to add a gag order / classify the whole agreement, NSA letter style ? Asking for a friend. At some point these decisions get made by a committee of people who are themselves way below the pay grade for these decisions… I wonder how that works. The math is hard to make consistent.
- warent 5y agoNot to sound snide, genuinely curious how this is different from bribery?
- randmeerkat 5y ago“The most sacred of the duties of a government [is] to do equal and impartial justice to all citizens." -Thomas Jefferson
- shmageggy 5y agoI'm sure the gov't would be happy to take 5B to let you and I off the hook for white-collar crimes as well. See, perfectly equal!
- margalabargala 5y agoThe law, in its beautiful equality, forbids rich and poor alike from sleeping under bridges.
- munk-a 5y agoPlease note - if you own the bridge you may find yourself exempt.
- dfxm12 5y agoThe cynic in me realizes that white collar criminals of Zuckerberg's stature really only likely serve time if it involves a huge amount of tax evasion. This money keeps Zuckerberg's name off of any official filings, but I don't think there was ever any real threat of him going to jail. So the $5b is, in a way, pure profit.
- drunkpotato 5y agoYou think billionaires go to jail for avoiding taxes? Are you sure you have any cynic in you whatsoever?
- skrtskrt 5y agomillionaires go to jail for avoiding taxes, billionaires write the laws so they don’t actually have to pay any taxes
- fallingknife 5y agoThis title is leaving off 2 very important words at the end: Facebook paid billions extra to the FTC to spare Zuckerberg in data suit, SHAREHOLDERS ALLEGE
- dang 5y agoAdded eventually. Thanks!
- comeonseriously 5y ago> The FTC also said in court that Facebook’s fine would have been closer to $106 million... Fines need to keep up. This is ... nothing. $106M is what, 1.5 DAYS of revenue. 1 and 1/2 DAYS. Gah! That's ridiculous!
- tombert 5y agoWait, I'm missing something. Wouldn't overpayments to a government entity have to be reported? Why are we just hearing about this now? This isn't a loaded question, I'm genuinely curious if a lawyer or someone more educated than me could explain this.
- jjulius 5y agoIn this instance, no. The FTC authorized the settlement of $5 billion, and that's what Facebook paid. It's not like the FTC authorized a settlement for $1 billion and Facebook paid $5 billion. The "overpayment" alleged by the lawsuit is that the settlement should've been far, far less than $5 billion, but was increased to that amount in order to prevent Zuckerberg from being individually targeted, thereby "overpaying". Caveat: I'm not a lawyer, and I just have a basic understanding of this entire issue.
- dschuetz 5y agoNews flash: Facebook is a corrupt company, and anyone working there is morally bankrupt. Duh.
- scott00 5y agoOne point I think a lot of people are missing here: it's not likely that Zuckerberg would have paid anything out of his own pocket even if he had been sued individually. Generally most large companies agree to indemnify and defend their executives against any civil liability stemming from their position with the company.
- r00fus 5y agoSo is Zuckerberg saying he values his privacy that much? I mean, what does he have to hide? Meanwhile, FB itself buys info on people to "augment" their understanding of them as users. And for those who don't willingly participate - they create shadow profiles.
- spiderice 5y agoI get you’re attempting to make a point, but liability != privacy. They didn’t pay 5 billion for his privacy. At least that wasn’t the main goal, even if it is a byproduct
- r00fus 5y agoZuckerberg is Facebook - he has controlling interest. Keep in mind he lives in a house in Palo Alto, CA where he bought all the houses around him to gain more privacy. He clearly values it.
- ManuelKiessling 5y agoThe best democracy that money can buy.
- amelius 5y agoWhere did the money go? We, taxpayers, have the right to know.
- brudgers 5y ago"Shareholders" doesn't mean much here. Facebook has Class A shares that each get one vote. Facebook has Class B shares that each get ten votes. The board has Class B shares. The Zuckerbergs control most of the Class B shares. Enough to have a majority of the votes. That's what owners of Class A shares bought into when they bought their Class A shares. If the article didn't ignore this, it would be a lot less interesting. So it does.
- wolverine876 5y agoHow does that impact the lawsuit? There's no vote involved, it's a courtroom. Whatever their voting power, they lose the same amount of money.
- throwaway2048 5y agothat doesn't mean class B shareholders can do anything they want that hurts class A shareholders.
- brudgers 5y agoThere’s no evidence (in the article) that any shareholders were harmed. Businesses pay money to settle legal issues all the time. The larger payment settled the issue (with the Federal Government). The smaller alternative would not have (according to the article). In the end some shareholders disagree with other shareholders. And anyone can sue anyone.
- dandotway 5y agoClass B shareholders can do anything they want that hurts class A shareholders, so long as class A shareholders can't successfully sue. 67.8% of Fortune 500 companies incorporate in the state of Delaware[1], largely because Delaware has a Court of Chancery that handles corporate cases and is renowned for making shareholder lawsuits unsuccessful. [1] https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/incorporating-in-delaware-advantages-and-disadvantages https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/incorporating-in-delaware...
- sireat 5y ago
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"Zuckerberg, Sandberg, and other Facebook directors agreed to authorize a multi-billion settlement with the FTC as an express quid pro quo to protect Zuckerberg from being named in the FTC's complaint, made subject to personal liability, or even required to sit for a deposition," one of the suits alleged. "... or even required to sit for a deposition." Has he even sat a deposition since the Winklevoss case. Years ago there was a shareholder suit against Facebook et al. that was going to trial (rare). Zuckerberg was scheduled to testify. IIRC, Facebook settled on the eve of his scheduled appearance. The plaintiffs counsel was quoted in the press as saying something along the lines of "Mark Zuckerberg may know computers, but I know ..." Clearly he was looking forward to it. :) Surely there are more litigators out there who would love to have a go at Mark Zuckerberg. Also, many years ago in the back and forth between Zuckerberg and Greenspan at Harvard, Zuckerberg made a remark that suggested he was frightened of federal court. Testifying before Congress is not the same as testifying in federal court. Congress is a big step up from appearing before some Harvard administrator for disciplinary violations, but its not under oath and the consequences of lying are, lets be honest, non-consequential. IMO, if a plaintiffs lawyer or prosecutor ever gets Zuckerberg into a federal courtroom to testify, he will halt and catch fire under questioning. Even with all the resources at his disposal, he is likely "uncoachable". He only knows how to lie, and as we have all seen he isnt very good at it. "They amended the complaints last month after receiving internal files about the board's discussions on privacy, which a federal judge had ordered Facebook to provide." There is value in discovery in litigation and regulatory proceedings against Facebook and Big Tech, regardless of the likely success of any of the indivdual cases, IMHO. These companies rely on non-transparency to carry out their surveillance "business" without public backlash. Every lawsuit against them is a chance to learn more of what they do and potentially publish about it. Much of what we know has come from regulatory proceedings or lawsuits. The more we learn about what goes on behind the scenes, the stronger the future allegations that lawyers can make. Bit by bit, they unpeel the onion. Wasnt it Zuckerberg and Google's CEO Schmidt who told the people they have nothing to fear about sharing what they know with Big Tech. When we ask Big Tech's staff to share what they know, they resist. Perhaps someone will remove the friction (as in "frictionless sharing"). Anyway, the question what price will Facebook be willing to pay this time to keep these shareholder suits from going to trial and Zuckerberg having to testify. That amount will not be public information. :)
- quietthrow 5y agoSerious question : I would like a person familiar with law to explain how is this not a bribe essentially? (Cos clearly it’s not treated like one. Where/what is the reasoning that invalidates my question )
- loeg 5y agoIt's a negotiated settlement between a regulatory agency and a business. This isn't a payment to an individual abusing their government authority to seek bribes.
- quietthrow 5y agoSo in essence if a crime or wrong doing is done by an entity and money is exchanged to reduce penalty it is considered a settlement. But the same thing done between people is a bribe. Here the entity is technically abusing their people given authority to enrich itself and people it’s responsible to and letting go of the other entity responsible for wrongdoing. Charging more money for that is ok. But if you swap that entity for people or person it’s a crime? I understand this is all interpretations but seems like a pretty dated way to bring “justice”
- hintymad 5y agoFB also pays $12M a year for Zuckerberg's security details? In comparison, Amazon pays $1.2M for Bezos. So, I was wondering what kind of security could possibly cost $12M. Sounds like a tax-free way of spending on house decoration?
- 93po 5y agoIf you want a few guys for security at any given time, and you want security 24/7, and you need security at multiple locations, then this all adds up really fast. 3 people in three shifts is 9 people needed per day. Given that people aren't going to work 7 days a week, you need extra people for coverage and weekend shifts. Let's be conservative and say 15 total. This is per location. Office, house, second house. That's 45 people. That's $266k per year in cost per person. Given the expenses of the motor pool, motor pool maintenance, travel accommodations and expenses for personal, the admin overhead of managing 45 people, etc etc this sounds fairly reasonable to me. If I was a billionaire I'd be spending at least that much too.
- missedthecue 5y agothe Secret Service has an annual budget of almost $2.5 billion (though they do have some responsibilities aside from protecting POTUS)
- runevault 5y agoI mean, the protect EVERY living president not just the current one.
- MerelyMortal 5y agoThey also protect visiting foreign dignitaries. And they get to use more exciting/expensive tools that would otherwise be illegal for private citizens/companies to use.
- kodah 5y ago
- entropicgravity 5y agoBillions is the currency that guys like Zuckerberg trade in. In this case Facebook allegedly paid off the FTC when it fact Zuckerberg should have paid it. So Zuckerberg just pays back FB the four billion and everyone is happy. It's like you and me trading nickels.
- kgwxd 5y agoThat's a regular suit with a Data mask.
- chrismsimpson 5y agoThe US again proving its two tier justice system. It’s frankly disgusting the Silicon Valley acolytes that deny this.
- dang 5y agoMaybe so, but please don't fulminate on Hacker News. A good comment adds new information, not just bilious repetition. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- rajacombinator 5y agoNice way to sneak in a little political cash off the books.
- wolverine876 5y agoI'm much more concerned with apparent corruption at the FTC: They took money to look the other way? What Zukerberg allegedly did, is it illegal? Is that a fair characterization?
- throwawaybchr 5y agoMore accurate title: Zuckerberg spent his own money to avoid litigation
- edwnj 5y agoI have no idea how those shareholders are going to argue saving Zuckerberg in a suit about Facebook is not in the companies direct interest. Like literally, other than being the CEO, he is also the founder, majority shareholder and the brand of the company. P.S. this is a PR ploy.. shareholders will never win a suit like this in a Deleware court.
- xpe 5y agoI think perhaps you mean you have no idea how these shareholders are going to win that argument. The argument is worth making. Shareholders want the board to consider many options and make a decision on behalf of their duties. Spending $5B to shield one particular leader is one option. There are others. There are many examples where boards and shareholders oust a particular CEO.
- LightG 5y agoIn English - Zuckerberg bought himself out of the legal system. Allegedly.
- wavefunction 5y agoI have to say seeing all these posts about Zuckerberg's privacy is very hilarious to me. He's as entitled to privacy as his users are.
- akagusu 5y agoThis is America.