17 ms·
Colorado county's voting machines banned after security breach
- sidlls 5y agoWhole countries with public counting of paper ballots have election results faster than we do. The phrase "voting system" is an absurdity. It highlights the overly complex, bug-riddled lunacy we have now. A lockbox, under guard with multiple observers, collecting ballots over the voting period, followed by a public counting of the paper ballots is simple and fast. What we have now isn't.
- syshum 5y agoThe uniparty does not want secure, fast, accurate election. Election manipulation is the game... Neither side of the uniparty want to admit that though and believe "their side" is the pure and virtuous side, where as the "others" are evil vote stealers or suppressors
- hatware 5y agoI like how this is fading because folks can't process reality. How anyone thinks lifelong politicians are serving us in _any_ way is beyond me.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI’m struggling to identify what is a uniparty here. I fee that the two parties in the United States have multiple separate issues and behaviors that are mutually incompatible enough to call two different political organizations. For example, when the republicans were in power, very few social programs were passed/rolled out in the 4 years they were in power for. The Democrats in comparison have passed a significant amount of legislation in just 8 months, including new social programs like the child tax credit. Similarly, the removal and reinstatement of protection for Dreamers also seems to be one of those issues the parties broadly are incompatible about. If you would like to educate me, I would welcome it! Maybe my understanding of a party is wrong, or my understanding of policies are wrong. I’m not really into politics so I don’t know much.
- macksd 5y agoThey may be referring to the fact that the two parties will often join forces to protect the status quo. Where you see support for things like ranked choice voting, or easier ballot access for third parties, you see less support from the established party leaders because the status quo is their best case scenario. It's all about democracy as long as you have the majority. While in actual votes the parties may differ, in principle I often fail to see any clear difference in philosophy. Someone running against the incumbent will slam them for abuse of executive orders and support for the Patriot Act. Then they'll get in office and sign a renewal of the Patriot Act and issue more executive orders than their predecessor. In that way I see them as a uniparty on many issues. In other ways Republicans are just anti-Democrats and Democrats are just anti-Republicans. They seem to use the same arguments on different issues depending on what happens to suit them or what politician they're defending. I've seen Republicans slam Biden for his failure in Afghanistan and failing to get Afghan nationals that helped the US military evacuated. But watch them do a 180 as soon as any of those Afghans arrive here. Which party believes you have absolute autonomy over your own medical decisions and that doctors need to treat you according to your own wishes? Well it depends on the treatment we're discussing. It doesn't depend on any consistent principle. Call it a uniparty or not - I just don't trust either to be sincere about any democratic principles anymore.
- mindslight 5y ago
- dannyw 5y agoAustralia has a simple and trustable election system. Paper ballots, reinforced by the fact that more or less every citizen can get a job working on election day. Your duties include looking up people based on what they say their name an address is (no ID required; although many electors hand me their ID anyway) on a big electoral roll book, cross out their name, and hand them a ballot with your initials. They go to one of the booths and mark their selection, and drop it off into a zip-tied big ballot box (that is visible to the general public, and of course election staff at all times). After the polls close, the polling official cuts the zip-ties on the ballot boxes, everyone working sorts ballots into piles and count them, along with scrutineers from political parties who can watch. An officer-in-charge records and publishes the results continuously, and everything is saved and shipped for OCR-based recounting to verify the numbers. The process is federally operated and the same processes are followed everywhere. Results are almost always revealed on election night. The electoral roll books are processed centrally after every election, so someone who votes twice would be quickly caught. Someone who votes under fake names and addresses would most likely cross-over with someone else, hence an investigation would still happen. (We also have compulsory voting, which is another subject for debate, but it does mean "vote under multiple names" is mitigated without the need for ID laws). The job pays reasonably well (A$457 for the day), more or less everyone who applies gets hired (I believe there is a bias towards maximizing first-time applicants), and it's hard to think about election fraud when every citizen can be part of the election process itself, and it's hard to conceive of how fraud can happen.
- smt88 5y agoThe US systems are often similar to this, including the several steps of checks. None of that matters in the face of conspiracy theorists who live in non-reality.
- sidlls 5y agoNot really. Most of the US is run on a very opaque system of electronic machines and poorly thought out processes ostensibly to make it more secure.
- jcranmer 5y ago> Whole countries with public counting of paper ballots have election results faster than we do. How many of those countries have as many races on a typical presidential-year ballot as the US does? The US is also generally pretty fast to count its ballots; note that the election result is usually known within hours of polls closing, despite the insane number of races on the ballots. What happened in 2020 is there was an unusually high number of mail-in ballots, and this was combined with several states intentionally slowing down the counting process.
- seoaeu 5y agoHand counting of ballots works well when you're only voting for a single elected office. In the US, most elections involve voting for many different offices all on the same ballot. Really, we should just be switching to using scantron style ballots everywhere. They're paper ballots which can be efficiently counted by a machine, and are super easy to manually recount later
- sidlls 5y agoAre you suggesting most other places, including those with counted paper ballots, don’t have multiple offices to elect at election time?
- tzs 5y ago> Really, we should just be switching to using scantron style ballots everywhere. They're paper ballots which can be efficiently counted by a machine, and are super easy to manually recount later. Better yet, switch to Scantron style ballots with some clever mathematics in how the ballots are made, and some clever chemistry in how they are marked, and you can then make it so that all the ballots can be published afterwards, any voter can verify that their vote was counted toward the correct candidate, anyone can verify that the totals for each candidate match the vote, a voter cannot prove to a coercer that they voted the way the coercer wanted, and any voter can do a check before voting to try to catch shenanigans with being given tampered with ballots, all without requiring any changes to the Scantron counting machines so that there is very little addition cost for all of these protections--and for voters that don't care about verifying that their vote was correctly counted it works just like plain Scantron voting--fill in the bubbles next to the candidates you want to vote for. https://www.usenix.org/legacy/events/evt08/tech/full_papers/chaum/chaum_html/index.html https://www.usenix.org/legacy/events/evt08/tech/full_papers/... https://eprint.iacr.org/2010/502.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2010/502.pdf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scantegrity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scantegrity
- dane-pgp 5y agoUnfortunately such systems assume that all of the parties in the election are working in good faith towards finding out the true result. They don't deal with the threat model of one (or both) major parties deciding to deliberately cast doubt on the outcome of an election by lying about or losing one of the secret keys needed to check the results. Even if all the parties behave correctly, it's still not clear that such a system is really solving the underlying problem. If someone claims there were thousands of fake votes sent in by dead people, are you really going to reassure the public by saying "Don't worry, we've re-calculated the modulo-n equations using the cryptographic key's bitstream acting as a stream cipher"? That's just asking for the backfire effect to kick in.
- ajay-b 5y agoI agree, the overly complex use of machines, followed by closed door counting, lends it self too much to impropriety. I think America has mostly honest elections, but after last year‘s election I am… Uneasy about the whole system. Simple is better.
- bediger4000 5y agoWhat exactly makes you uneasy? In the case of Mesa County, CO, the breech of security was by a conspiracy theorist. There is no voter-level election fraud, so the USA doesn't need strict ID requirements. Colorado is particularly transparent about how they do risk-limiting audits of all elections, so fearing about electronic counting machines mis-counting is misplaced. What exactly, are you uneasy about?
- tohnjitor 5y ago- Arguably unconstitutional changes to state voting laws less than six months before election day. - Authorized election observers banned from their designated polling places on election day. - Cessation of ballot counting on election day. - Waiting until observers leave to count large numbers of ballots that were hidden under a table all day. - Hundreds of thousands of ballots with no chain of custody records. - Double standards about who is allowed to challenge vote certifications. Democrats challenged Trump's election and both of Bush 43's elections as is permitted in the Constitution. When Republicans did the same in 2021 they were threatened with impeachment and removed from committees. I'm sure I'm forgetting other reasons to be uneasy.
- bediger4000 5y agoNone of these issues are true in Colorado, or Mesa County. For other states, all these issues were addressed in more than one lawsuit each, and all such lawsuits were rejected. The suits didn't get filed in one state, and appear before one judge. Multiple states, multiple judges. A lot of the suits were appealed, and failed on appeal, too. To be uneasy about this is to believe in a far reaching, many hundreds of participant conspiracy. Further, the states in which these concerns were raised are all swing states. This seems suspicious in and of itself. Why not raise concerns about procedures in Colorado? It's a vote by mail state, and even in Colorado Springs districts, there was a big swing to Biden from 2020 results. Seems like you'd take on the easy places to prove a conspiracy, and you'd raise legit concerns. But no, swing states are the only places, it looks like trying to game the refs, to borrow a sports metaphor.
- Spivak 5y agoThis system is simple but it’s neither fast nor available. The thing you have to worry about with this kind of system is ballot stuffing which leads to needing an additional requirement to verify each voter and observe them filling out and depositing the ballot. This creates a bottleneck at the polls which is why every election there are news stories about people having heat strokes or being turned away after the polls close. It’s also not available because making people show up to a few set of fixed locations at specific polling hours will exclude people who don’t have access to transportation which is why during the Obama election the big thing was the Obama campaign providing busses to voters. If you’re willing to give up some anonymity (only that you voted not what/you voted for) then mail in ballots, public drop-boxes, and walk-in deposits are much faster and more available. If you can mail in then great! Done. If you want to go to the polls then you fill out your ballot ahead of time, verify yourself with the poll worker and then drop it in the box. Done. 30 seconds a person rather than 10 minutes a person. I think the culture in the US surrounding voting is the real issue. The discussion is always around security and integrity and making sure only the right people vote which are the kind of problems people who read too many Tom Clancy books care about. Meanwhile we only get at most ~50% turnout every year and people have to fight to actually cast their ballots. And we pretend that our election results actually mean something when half the country doesn’t vote and the sample that does is so skewed because the factors that keep people from voting aren’t random.
- sfteus 5y agoMy only issue with a paper-only drop box is there's no redundancy. I would think with having poll watchers from multiple affiliations and multiple shifts per day to ensure you have many eyes on the box it wouldn't be a concern. But, if someone or some group managed to figure out a way to "stuff the box," you'd have no proof it happened. I really like the system we have in DFW now. We have a global voter roll so you can vote in any location in your county. You submit your vote on a machine, which keeps a local machine-level tally and prints out a paper ballot. You verify the contents of the paper ballot, then drop it into a vote counting box, which scans, tallies, and displays your vote for you to confirm. If at any time anything looks wrong, you notify a poll worker to resolve it. At the end of each day, they verify the counts on the machines and ballot box match, then the ballot counter/box is locked along with the memory cards of each individual machine, so you have day-by-day results. When the election ends, the ballot boxes are delivered to a central county counting system where they are put into another large-scale counting machine to verify that the counts there match the local counter/box. If at any point there's too many discrepancies, they'll do hand counts of the paper ballots. They can also unlock the voting machine memory cards if necessary. All of this process is done under the supervision of poll watchers. In theory, you get near instantaneous results as each voting location can simply total the ballot box results and report them. You also have 4 separate systems (voting machine, local counter/ballot box, central counter, paper backups) that would need to be compromised to successfully tamper with the results. I'm sure it wouldn't make a conspiracy theorist satisfied, but to me, it's a system that balances speed and convenience with the simplicity and security(?) of a paper ballot, without unnecessarily obfuscating the process behind electronic-only voting.
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 5y agoJust add some risk-limiting audits (like what Colorado has, incidentally) and this is the kind of election system I would like. https://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~stark/Preprints/gentle12.pdf https://www.stat.berkeley.edu/~stark/Preprints/gentle12.pdf
- xadhominemx 5y agoIt’s hard to stuff the box because fraud would be instantly detected when many voters submitted multiple ballots.
- throwjd764glug 5y agoIf a lone clerk can compromise the machines, should we really be using them? Do we know and trust everyone who had (legitimate or otherwise) access to these machines, including the manufacturer? And what benefit do they offer over a hand count, to justify so much risk? Just because the Republican's allegations about fraud were without merit, does not mean electronic voting is a good idea.
- DisjointedHunt 5y agoThis past election cycle politicized what should have otherwise been treated as a national security threat in unauthorized access to voting systems. Notice i use the word "systems" to include the human element as well as all the other components that go into making what we have today far from an acceptable system of voting in the most powerful individual on the planet.
- yarky 5y agoIt looks like the safer way to vote is avoiding technology, which I find a bit counterintuitive even though many countries rely on paper and people counting, I've even done it once (forced by law). I don't know how wrong I might be in this, but it looks to me like it systems are vulnerable by nature and hence the only secure voting system seems to be a system that avoids relying entirely on IT systems. The technical problem is solvable, but the security and transparency (to the public) are harder to get, specially the security aspect since blockchain technology could potentially help dealing with transparency.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y ago> It looks like the safer way to vote is avoiding technology correct. obligatory XKCD: https://xkcd.com/2030/ https://xkcd.com/2030/
- merpnderp 5y agoGiven the audits and investigations of past elections, and that up until the summer of 2020 most democratic leadership were saying the election would be fraudulent, why aren’t we allowing republicans to audit to their heart’s content? What could it possibly hurt to make it completely open and accountable, for whatever they feel was sketchy? Surely national harmony is worth a Stacy Abrams style audit?
- pacerwpg 5y agoThis is an open ended request. Specifically which elections were not open and accountable and now require an official audit?
- Audiophilip 5y agoI think Tom Scott's video about e-voting couldn't be more relevant today: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI
- greypowerOz 5y agoi still refer people to this also. He neatly summarises the core issues. People watching other people count marks on dead trees works great.
- smt88 5y ago> People watching other people count marks on dead trees works great. They did this twice in Georgia and it didn't get the conspiracists to shut up or change their minds.
- ricardobeat 5y agoThe Brazilian design for voting machines addresses most of those concerns in a nice way. I couldn’t find a full description in English but Wikipedia has a few bits: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_voting_in_Brazil https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_voting_in_Brazil
- greypowerOz 5y agorespectfully, that article simply repeats variations of scenarios tom brings up in his video;) pick any part of the process in that article and ask "how do you know that the black box is trustworthy?" , in the context of assuming that some nation states have a vested interest in messing with the process...
- treesprite82 5y agoIt sounds like the random selection of machines for the parallel "mock election" is intended to help with that issue.
- 5y ago
- redis_mlc 5y ago> A spokesperson for Denver-based Dominion Voting Systems, which provides election equipment to Colorado and 27 other states, said the company continues to work in full cooperation with the state and Mesa County authorities. Oh, you mean Dominion Voting Systems, apparently bought by the CCP for $400 million just months before the 2020 election? Funny how the MSM never reports on who owns Dominion.
- ricardobeat 5y agoIf a single breach to a ceremony involving the equipment is enough to invalidate it’s use completely, doesn’t sound like the machines are designed with enough layers of security? Couldn’t they repeat that step and reset that leaked password?
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoIt’s a safety precaution. Consider it like a supply chain breach: If you discover that your supply chain has been possibly tampered with by QAnon-associated conspiracy bloggers who deliberately lied to circumvent background check requirements and who also disabled the security cameras that week, you replace the equipment to be safe while you investigate. > Griswold also said that one week before the breach, Peters ordered her staff to turn off the video surveillance system that monitors the voting machines and that it was only recently turned back on. Precautions for supply chain breaches aren’t unique to voting machines. If you discover supply chain tampering for anything security-sensitive, you replace the gear. This goes for everything from people’s laptops to network equipment. The full article has more details. This wasn’t just a simple leak. There’s some strange corruption involved at that office.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- h2odragon 5y agoNote the story isn't "insecurities suspected in voting systems", its "systems exposed for inspection" ... Why would a voting system not be totally open and inspect-able by any citizen of the jurisdiction using it, and/or anyone else? What've they got to hide?
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThe inspection seems to have included the administrator passwords. That seems like something worth hiding from the general public.
- aristophenes 5y agoYour implication is that whoever has the administrator passwords can tamper with the machine to affect the results. And that someone, who is not the general public, should have access to the passwords. How is that better? So certain chosen individuals an have the power to tamper with the machines, but no one else? Isn't that the exact problem that is concerning people? Machines that cannot be completely publicly inspected shouldn't be used.
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>And that someone, who is not the general public, should have access to the passwords. How is that better? I'm not in favor of electronic voting either. There was a clear thing covered in this inspection that needs to be hidden. Whether that makes for a good election system is a separate matter.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThis story is wild. The headline is about the machines, but the article is really about some strange corruption within the department that led up to the breach: > Griswold also said that one week before the breach, Peters ordered her staff to turn off the video surveillance system that monitors the voting machines and that it was only recently turned back on. Somehow they ended up with an unauthorized person attending a procedure to update the machines, which then resulted in video and other information being posted to a QAnon-affiliated blog. Replacing the potentially compromised machines is a good move, but it seems like the real story is that something has gone very wrong inside this government office.
- maxwell 5y agoWhy replace the machines instead of using paper ballots?
- saryant 5y agoAll of Colorado uses paper ballots. These machines are only used to tabulate paper ballots. Each election is then followed by a risk-limiting audit to ensure the machines’ accuracy.
- pm90 5y agoIt frankly seems like a deliberate sabotage. It doesn’t help that the county clerk is apparently attending a QAnon conspiracy conference at the moment. Any election official that shows allegiance to such theories should be summarily banned from ever holding public office.
- rsynnott 5y ago> Peters ordered her staff to turn off the video surveillance system that monitors the voting machines and that it was only recently turned back on. This is probably about the point where you should ask your boss's boss "is this okay?" rather than just following orders, tbh. The whole thing is bizarre.
- caseysoftware 5y agoCan't they just wipe them clean and restart? How is one person being present during an upgrade enough to render the physical machines suspect and beyond repair/review? If they are compromised, I'd love to see a post mortem and understand how they were compromised and how that can be mitigated going forward.
- torgoguys 5y agoNo reason for your question to be downvoted. I've done my small part to reverse that. I doubt the officials suspect the machines have been compromised, but they have no way of knowing. There are chain of custody rules to help ensure integrity of the systems. Those have been violated so the machines can't be used until they've been carefully examined and recertified. Putting this in a money context might help some--lets say you owned slot machines that could have big payouts. Would you let rando unauthorized person to be alone with one of your machines in a private office, doing upgrades, and still trust the machine? Probably not. You'd want to take a look at it top to bottom before trusting it to do any payouts. The person might not have done anything wrong but you've got to be sure first, and since there are other ways these things could be compromised than just adding unauthorized software to the hard drive, a clean install isn't enough.
- caseysoftware 5y agoSo far the claim is "an unauthorized person's name was entered into the log of people who were present for a secure software update conducted by Dominion employees" and not "rando unauthorized person to be alone with one of your machines." If someone seeing an update executed compromises the machines, that's a HUGE problem. But I think you're spot on with the slot machine comparison. In a casino, asking security to turn off the cameras monitoring an area would be a breach in itself. They wouldn't do it and would report someone who requested it. In this situation, "how could an official could order it?" and "why did the security team do it?" are both things to look into. Was this standard operating procedure? If so, for how long and when else did it occur? And broader, are there other jurisdictions where they had similar security lapses? If so, when, where, and for how long? Further, were those machines also removed from service and analyzed?
- mschuster91 5y ago> Peters survived an effort to recall her from office over the ballots and other issues, including allegations that she failed to maintain adequate staffing in the election division. I might be tempted to say that the voters of Mesa County deserve having their freedoms stolen away. A vital part of democracy is holding transgressors accountable, and the voters of Mesa County have failed their responsibility.
- logicchains 5y ago>I might be tempted to say that the voters of Mesa County deserve having their freedoms stolen away. A vital part of democracy is holding transgressors accountable, and the voters of Mesa County have failed their responsibility. I mean, if she really was deliberately messing with the counting somehow, the result of the vote doesn't necessarily reflect what the voters actually voted for?
- blondie9x 5y agoUnreal. Because voting is secure the conspiracy theorist decided to create a conspiracy and potential security threat by releasing passwords online for the system and allowing people in to the back door. How pathetic. You were that hard up for a conspiracy? They should vet these people more and allow less individual access. I’ve seen some systems where 2 or more people of opposite political parties have to open the facilities at the same time. Maybe try that?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bediger4000 5y agoYes, Colorado voting is secure, and yes, a conspiracy theorist, who happens to be Mesa County's Clerk and Recorder, is completely to blame for the security breech. What you're leaving out is that because the election didn't turn out the way the Clerk wanted, she's muddying the waters and making further fair elections far more difficult.
- acituan 5y agoThat’s not how opsec works. It shouldn’t matter who the agent is, if it happened it is also a vulnerability of the system. It should withstand tampering by any sufficiently motivated party. It is like saying “yes, my website was hacked, but it was by an evil person” or “it was through social engineering.” Don’t care, it was hacked, can’t happen on such a critical system.
- bediger4000 5y ago> It shouldn’t matter who the agent is, if it happened it is also a vulnerability of the system. It should withstand tampering by any sufficiently motivated party. That's exactly opposite of what infosec experts say, and opposes experience as well. I mean, someone, probably Israel and NSA, got Stuxnet into an airgapped Iranian nuclear facility. Don't try to argue that perfection is necessary - it isn't Security is an economic good, with a price, and a value. When value exceeds price, implement the security. Otherwise, live with it.
- leejoramo 5y agoI live in Mesa County. This is a costly mess.
- bdavis__ 5y agoI grew up in Mesa county. Last time i visited the MJ dispensaries were just over the county line; that stuff is not allowed in Mesa County. Boebert is the Congressional Rep. For Colorado, low wages, very Republican, general lower education. And the last thing they need it to waste public money on this kind of BS.
- aristophenes 5y agoThe Colorado Secretary of State is unintentionally showing the conspiracy theorists are correct. A single person having physical access to the voting machines, months before the election, who has different political views from the Secretary, is enough to make those machines unusable. When the entire election in a district is run by officials from a single political party, with unlimited access to the voting machines, what is the other political party supposed to think? I had no opinion before now, but clearly these machines are unusable anywhere.
- xphilter 5y agoAh yes. The conspiracy theorists really showed us! Next, proud boys and Q will team up to buy a pizza place, kidnap a bunch of kids, and create a kid prostitution ring.
- bediger4000 5y agoThis is the opposite of reality. Colorado resident here. The CO Secretary of State has been proactive about everything election related. There's complete, transparent procedures for voting, there's educational materials about the risk limiting audits that get done for every election. All registered voters get a ballot in the mail. You can return them by mail, use a secured drop box which reside in locations under security camera. You can check your ballot's status on-line, and get email updates. You can also vote in person, should you want, on election day. Some yahoo state rep introduced a patently-unfair bill that would have made CO do things like stop counting on midnight of election day, which would almost certainly leave large fractions of ballots uncounted no matter how you vote, mail or in-person. No way around that. Thankfully, the CO legislature is not particularly crazy this year, so it failed. The conspiracy theorists caused the breech - the Mesa County Clerk is the one that c illegally copied the voting machine hard drives and gave the images to other conspiracy theorists. You are putting the blame exactly in the wrong place.
- aristophenes 5y agoYou missed my point entirely. The fact that a "breach" could happen and is something that is dangerous means the conspiracy theorists are correct. They feel about the Secretary of State like you feel about the Mesa County Clerk. If the situation was reversed and the Mesa County Clerk was the Secretary of State, would you feel confident about the elections? Who is getting access to the voting machines and what are they doing? If having access to the machines means that you can affect the results of the elections, and the public cannot safely audit that, then these machines are unusable at all times. You trust the Secretary of State. You think everyone in the state and country should trust the CO Secretary of State. Fine. But eventually an untrustworthy person gets to that seat of power, it's naive to think corrupt people wouldn't try and succeed. And from that point on they decide election results, and only other corrupt, complicit people run the government. The only real skill they need is to appear trustworthy, as grifters are already good at doing. The conspiracy theorists just think this has already happened. We should have a voting system that you would feel comfortable to be overseen by your ideological adversaries.
- GolfPopper 5y agoI really hope I'm reading this wrong, but it looks like the key takeaway here should be that an official responsible for security completely subverted their responsibilities, allowed unauthorized access, and disabled monitoring... and the only reason anyone found out is one of their co-conspirators broadcast the resulting access all over the internet. If the only way a bank (or its depositors) knew the bank had been robbed was if the robbers told everyone they'd robbed that bank, would we consider the bank secure, no matter what consequences employees faced? There seems to be a fundamental failure of process with no plans to actually improve security in the future.
- sylens 5y agoIt was my understanding that going into the symposium, the issue of Mesa County’s machines was already on the radar and there was an active probe into Peters
- rsfern 5y agoThat’s correct, because a certain conspiracy theorist published “smoking gun” screen caps of information on the voting systems in question, and there was unredacted information that led back to Mesa county. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2021/08/8chans-ron-watkins-scores-a-major-own-goal-with-leaked-bios-passwords/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2021/08/8chan... Edit: I’ve read the OP from NPR more closely and it says the investigation predates this episode and was triggered by an unauthorized person showing up in some logs
- nikkinana 5y agoOf course.
- motohagiography 5y agoHave predicted for years that electronic voting would cause civil unrest because in a highly contested election, it does not provide adequte physical evidence of vote integrity. The whole idea of electronic voting is designed to forfeit the integrity of a process whose entire legitimacy depends on the integrity of that process. As they say, this isn't the first time they stole from us, it's just the first time they've been caught. Anyone who has scratched the surface of this issue is unlikely to be persuaded by new assurances about new electronic voting controls, other than committed partisans who are fine if it's rigged in their favour. The more interesting question is, what are the knock on effects of a popular loss of confidence in western elections held with these machines?
- odessacubbage 5y agoi would assume that the presumption of fraud would itself lead to greater degrees of fraud with the inherent justification among partisans being 'well the other guy is doing it so this is the only way we can keep up'. that in of itself might not be that bad but if the fraud or perception of fraud has potential to act as a force multiplier for existing instabilities and intra-party paranoias then it becomes very easy to imagine the process dismantling itself. it really seems like the experiment for this decade is figuring out just how much distrust institutions can take on while still remaining functional.
- platz 5y agohttps://www.vice.com/amp/en/article/dyvjwa/mike-lindell-is-hiding-an-alleged-election-data-leaker-as-fbi-open-investigation https://www.vice.com/amp/en/article/dyvjwa/mike-lindell-is-h...
- platz 5y ago> Peters was among those who have been spreading baseless conspiracies about the election, but despite being accused of helping leak official election data to a QAnon promoter, she still appears to have a large support base in Mesa County. The Daily Sentinel reported Wednesday that “a large group of Mesa County residents asked the county commissioners to condemn Griswold for her investigation and to stand behind Peters, saying the clerk is a hero for trying to uncover cracks in the state’s election system.” And this Saturday, supporters will hold a “patriot rally” for Peters.
- thepasswordis 5y ago“Nobody except us can be alone with these machines otherwise you can’t trust them” Is not something that anybody trying to ensure trust in elections should ever say.
- joelbondurant 5y agoDemocrats gonna democrat.
- GaryTang 5y agolol more and more conspiracies are becoming more and more likely
- tamaharbor 5y agoMaybe Trump was right. (Democrats start your downvoting.)
- newbamboo 5y ago“On conspiracy website” Heh. What’s that saying, “even paranoid people have enemies.”
- Threeve303 5y agoDemocracy is broken because half of the people don’t want it anymore. So they will never be satisfied in that process.
- midnitewarrior 5y agoBreaches are acceptable and their detection proves the security system works. Undetected breaches would indicate a complete failure of the security. Problems are to be expected, as long as the system can detect and deal with the breach, democracy is protected, albeit at greater cost in this instance.
- hamburgerwah 5y agoOne of those contradictions I am at a loss to explain is that the same people who seem to be freaking out about vaccine card fraud completely deny that voting fraud is widespread.
- angelzen 5y agoGOOD. Now we need to ban mail-in voting and move voting day to a Sunday.