40 ms·
Squatters in Spain who demand a "ransom" before they will leave a property
- gotoeleven 5y agoThe legal system is largely to protect criminals from "extra-legal" law enforcement by wronged parties. When the legal system can't function properly, for whatever reason, it is criminals who are ultimately in the most danger. In the US, if police are given stand-down orders during mostly peaceful lootings and riots then a lot of looters are going to get shot.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThat's definitely a large component of the legal system but I disagree with your implication that it is a primary purpose and assertion that the criminals are most endangered when enforcement is scant.
- sokoloff 5y agoOn a per-capita basis, I’d expect criminals would be at more risk in a devolution towards lawlessness. On a population-wide basis, non-criminals have much more to lose.
- literallyaduck 5y agoIf you don't shoot: https://www.rt.com/usa/490322-dallas-man-attacked-sword/ https://www.rt.com/usa/490322-dallas-man-attacked-sword/ If you do: https://www.rt.com/usa/507442-kyle-rittenhouse-aoc-white-supremacy/ https://www.rt.com/usa/507442-kyle-rittenhouse-aoc-white-sup... If you do nothing: https://www.rt.com/usa/490043-minnesota-riot-aftermath-videos/ https://www.rt.com/usa/490043-minnesota-riot-aftermath-video...
- vagrantJin 5y agoBe careful with that thinking. It has undertones of ignorance and a blind faith in violence. The law is there to uphold the social contract of peace. For every crime, 'just' punishment. Looters don't carry guns because they don't intend on murdering anyone. They are petty thieves. The moment we start to think everyone should have a gun, the unscrupulous - who would be a harmless petty thieves otherwise - can be transformed into the devils you imagined. Tread carefully.
- bprieto 5y agoI was in Bolivia a few years ago and I saw a big sign at a town that said "Thief found, thief hanged". The person guiding me said that the people there actually believed in that. Lynching is what happens when there is no police and justice system.
- bsanr2 5y ago>It was a reference to his holiday home in the Catalan seaside town of Sitges, and came from a neighbour. My sympathy plummeted. I'm expected to see this roundly rejected by the commentariat here, but I believe a serious conversation about the levels of inequality that allow wealthy foreigners to own desired property in countries where people are going homeless is perfectly reasonable and even necessary, as is taking the side that says, "This is egregious." >Javier claims he and his cronies target expensive apartments owned by finance companies and banks. >"I break in on a Friday. The following Monday, I call the bank and say, 'Hey you guys, I'm in your flat, and I'm going to destroy it. I can send you pictures if you like.' And the people from the bank say, 'Whoa - we're sending someone to see you.' And then that person comes and negotiates the price." Expect this in the US shortly. Americans will not stand being forced to rent the houses their parents built and owned.
- jimmyed 5y agoHeh. Spain being Spain.
- duxup 5y agoWhat is the law in Spain for squatting? In the US for most states squatting doesn't really 'pay' as legally you have to occupy the location for a relatively long period of time, maintain it, sometimes even pay taxes regularly before you have any real rights at all.
- john_yaya 5y agoI think the goal of the squatters isn’t to own the property, it’s to just get a roof over their heads and extort the owners in the process. They’ve carefully chosen a legal zone where they have a lot of room to maneuver.
- tecleandor 5y agoMost of the squatters aren't trying to extort, they're just trying to get somewhere to live for free or for cheap. Yeah, some are freeloaders, but lots of them have lost their jobs and/or are suffering the combination of the crisis and the spectacular surge of pricing on real estate this last years. Even with this problems, squatting incidence have been falling on the last 5/10 years.
- slothtrop 5y agoThey squat because houses are nicer and more spacious to live in, not for lack of any place to stay. On top of extortion.
- tecleandor 5y agoI didn't say it's for lack of space, I said it's for a lack of money. In fact, more than 10% of the homes in Spain are vacant. I think you may be talking about your experience in a different country or about a very concrete personal experience, and not in general.
- slothtrop 5y agoFair enough
- g3h4 5y agoHow about some hard men removing the Chief Pedophile from the White House. He has now murdered dozens of Us civilians with multiple explosions at the airport. FUCK BIDEN and FUCK YOU if you voted for him.
- diogenescynic 5y agoSquatters are absolute scum of the earth. If you ever have the misfortune of dealing with them, they will absolutely impact your financial and mental well-being. My grandpa died and we had to deal with meth head squatters who moved into his place (in California) and it was easily one of the worst abuses of the legal system I've ever dealt with. You can basically just break into a property and put a toothbrush down and tell the cops you had a verbal agreement with the previous owner and there's not much the police/sheriffs can do without a court order which takes months and a lawyer ($$$$$). Meanwhile, the meth heads are destroying the property. I definitely would have hired some "hard men" if I could have to deal with the squatters if I had the option.
- bsanr2 5y agoI find this hard to believe. If they are drug users, for better or worse, you can have them arrested for possessing/making drugs.
- slothtrop 5y agoNo. It's a joke. The police a) don't want to deal with the liability of an overdose on their watch, b) don't want to do the hour's worth of paperwork for arrests, because they just turn them right back on to the street. Junkies plainly do not get arrested most of the time.
- rvense 5y agoNor should they be. Drug abuse is a health problem. Unless someone is an immediate threat to their surroundings, the police should not be involved.
- Veen 5y agoDrug abuse is a health problem. Breaking into people's homes, damaging their property, and then extorting them is a criminal problem. You don't get a pass on lawbreaking because you have health problems.
- 5y ago
- mschuster91 5y agoPeople who have property that is staying so empty and unused that they don't even notice that squatters move in and then resort to (heavily implied) violence threats should have their properties confiscated. This sort of behavior is abhorrent and anti-social, this is still Europe and not some sort of third-world country. If the legal system is too slow for these people, they should lobby for better laws! Clearly, the free market has failed here - an obvious amount of massive empty properties should, according to theories of supply and demand, lead to low rents. I have zero sympathies for "landlords" who rather let their properties sit unused than accept market-acceptable rents.
- chrisseaton 5y agoIt sounds like this problem exists even if it's your only home and you live there full time. Go out for the day, come home, and the kind of person they interview could have broken in, changed the locks, and there's nothing the law will do about it for years.
- geofft 5y agoThat sounds theoretically possible, but it doesn't happen in practice, does it? (Which means that something is missing from this model of how squatters work.) Most of us leave our homes for the day to go to work and come back (or did, before 2020, at least). I don't know of a single case of someone returning home to find a squatter.
- willcipriano 5y agoBreaking and entering is one thing but this sort of thing happens with roommates and house guests all the time. First hit on Google reveals: https://nypost.com/2020/08/29/nyc-grifter-roomie-spend-first-week-after-squatters-return/ https://nypost.com/2020/08/29/nyc-grifter-roomie-spend-first... you can find plenty more. There have been cases were someone who was invited to spend the night has lived for weeks to months at a property without permission.
- selimthegrim 5y ago
- sparrish 5y agoWhen legal systems fail, folks will turn to 'hard men' to get justice. Thus it has always been, thus it shall be. To avoid this a society should aim for just laws, swift execution of those laws by law enforcement, and speedy trials by courts. If any of those three are failing, other avenues of justice will be sought by those who can afford it and that impacts the poor who can't 'afford' justice.
- sneak 5y agoI mean, it is just different "hard men" that show up to kick out the poor when you have fast and efficient eviction proceedings. It's the same violence, and the same outcome; one just uses neat uniforms. I also like the rule of law but let's not pretend that these two situations are really that much different.
- aaomidi 5y agoAnd since one of them isn't backed by the state, the people can neutralize them without risking their entire lives. There are a lot more people who don't own capital than there are people who do.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> There are a lot more people who don't own capital than there are people who do This attitude explains, at least in part, why they live in a place with the shoddy rule of law and a deficiency of capital. (The track record of revolutions which violently re-allocate property is terrible, mostly for the people who originally lacked capital, moreso in the last century.)
- manigandham 5y agoThere's a major difference in fairness and safety when going through the law. In fact, that's the entire point.
- aaomidi 5y ago
- option_greek 5y agoHow long before squatters are encouraged by eviction companies to squat. Its crazy how much the owners are paying without any permanent solution.
- Stevvo 5y agoAny permanent solution would require ending homelessness. That's actually a pretty easy goal, but not one our society is willing to pursue.
- option_greek 5y agoI would say its two pronged. One is definitely helping the homeless but another has to be upholding law and order. Otherwise people like that guy the article mentions as minting 10k euros per squat is going continue whether he has a roof or not. Its a classic broken window syndrome. If a small crime is tolerated for any reason, it encourages bigger crimes or organized crime (like the stories about stores not calling cops in Cali due to lack of response).
- Stevvo 5y agoHelping the homeless also takes out the squat baron; if we bring the homeless inside there won't be vacancies for the baron to squat in.
- curryst 5y agoIf you're willing to discard any objections to the contrary, it's also easy to fix on the other side too. Require rental contracts to be filed with the city like deeds are, and immediately remove anyone reported as trespassing in a place where they don't have a lease on file with the city. I think you're also ignoring that we're not out of housing. We're out of housing in the places many people want to live. If you go to Detroit, you can get a house for a song. Alaska will literally pay you for living there. There's a difference between having a place to live, and living somewhere you want to live. The former is easy to solve, the latter is hard to solve because demand is often driven by exclusivity.
- ausbah 5y agoseems like a of the all to familiar trend of a lack of affordable housing in major cities + crime at the margins in the form of squatting empty lots? either way, seems like there needs to be some sort of tax if there properties that are just sitting empty while the homelessness keeps rising
- bgorman 5y agoIt seems like there is an emerging western world trend of people being unable to afford their home, landlords being unable to enforce their property rights, and housing activists opposing new construction and rent increases. Generally all these issues seem to be made worse by restrictions on new housing development, land use restrictions and a large indigent population who cannot afford housing with their current wage earning ability. For now it seems like the government’s preferred solution is to not address the root causes and let landlords slowly incur losses and wealthier renters pay through the nose. I believe governments should be doing the exact opposite, they should have landlord and development friendly laws. The alternative seems to be mass homelessness and general societal decay. No one will invest in real estate if property rights cannot be enforced. However, indigent voters are a large vote bank. In California, 60% of adults paid no income tax in 2020.
- nivenkos 5y agoReal estate shouldn't be an investment. Just let people own the homes they live in. Everything else should be well-regulated perhaps even by government monopoly (e.g. first hand contracts in Sweden, or council houses in the UK). The entire reason we have such issues is because housing has become such a popular investment.
- AlexandrB 5y ago> No one will invest in real estate if property rights cannot be enforced. Good! "Real-estate as investment" is one factor responsible for the above-inflation rise of property values. It's part of why housing is unaffordable in so many areas. Non primary residences should be taxed out the nose.
- fighterpilot 5y agoNonsense. You reduce house prices by increasing supply via construction of apartments, and potentially having a land value tax. You don't do it by undermining property rights. This just makes everyone's reality a living hell and doesn't solve anything. What a truly sinister worldview you've adopted.
- popileviz 5y agoAlternative title: Hired thugs abusing the hell out of homeless people living in empty lots
- tecleandor 5y agoTruth is lots of them are violent and have connections with the, ahem, underground. Not-well-mannered boxers, bouncers, neo-nazis...
- beaconstudios 5y agoseems like a combination of /some/ people being rendered homeless by high rents, and /some/ criminals making a living off extorting landlords. I have every sympathy for the former, and none for the latter. Seems like they have a similar issue to SF - lack of building new homes leading to insane house and rent prices.
- babesh 5y agoStop spouting your biases. They are just plain wrong. Do some research first! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Spain https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Spain It isn't primarily due to high rents. It is due to the Spanish economy being shitty and badly run for decades. Then foreigners swooped in and bought prime real estate. But that doesn't mean that there is not enough housing. It is just that people were getting more and more poor with more and more unemployment. Here is a relevant quote: "Following the financial crisis of 2007–2008, the Spanish economy plunged into recession, entering a cycle of negative macroeconomic performance. Compared to the EU's and US's average, the Spanish economy entered recession later (the economy was still growing by 2008), but it stayed there longer. The economic boom of the 2000s was reversed, leaving over a quarter of Spain's workforce unemployed by 2012." It looks like it has recovered some but unemployment is still high especially for the young. Also there was a lot of youth emigration though recently there has been immigration from poorer countries. 25% below the poverty line 15% unemployment
- beaconstudios 5y ago
- logronoide 5y agoThe most shocking YouTube channel found last months is this one from one of these companies. They tried to produce a Reality Show showing their day in day out routines, but the broadcast networks rejected the project (they have obvious links with far right movements). Crazy stuff: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVAJkoGT9A4Fbm3Tmzb06DF3-1e8u9X6q https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLVAJkoGT9A4Fbm3Tmzb06DF3-...
- reccanti 5y agoA company full of strongmen committing semi-legal violence against poor people has ties to the far-right movement? I’m shocked!
- pope_meat 5y agoI'm shocked, shocked I say. Don't you know, being a landlord leech is very hard. Sometimes you have to spend a portion of your income to do maintenance even.* * If legally compelled
- bassman9000 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=88F3ceEKcqY&list=PLVAJkoGT9A4Fbm3Tmzb06DF3-1e8u9X6q&index=1 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=88F3ceEKcqY&list=PLVAJkoGT9A... Min 6:35 They may even doing him a favor: they're warning him he's breaking the law, and could face the consequences. And the things they're accusing him of are not just squatting.
- Hokusai 5y ago"this has led to the rise of private eviction companies, some of which use threats to achieve their goal." Some times landlords rent without contracts, to not pay taxes, and claim that the renters are squatting to evict them. A lot of shadow business going there.
- mofosyne 5y agoHow can that be fixed? Everyone now has a smartphone these days, surely there is a way to electronically log all these renting agreements.
- lazyjones 5y agoEurope has many broken laws that serve only to erode society. If you lose your rights to your own property because someone breaks into it, what's the point of owning real estate? Similarly, illegal migrants from some countries can just enter Austria and Germany, knowing they'll not be deported even if courts find they don't deserve asylum - and they will enjoy the benefits of those countries' social security systems, paid by the taxpayers. It's like well-known exploits that aren't being fixed on purpose and taken advantage of until the system breaks down.
- tehjoker 5y agoboo hoo, owning property is less important than people having places to live. You can have your treats after everyone is housed.
- smabie 5y agoWhere do houses come from then?
- tehjoker 5y agoFrom construction which can be paid for in many different ways, such as public housing, not merely rich individuals and corporations.
- eric__cartman 5y agoI wonder how you'd feel if after an extended trip you come back to your house/apartment just to find out some asshole decided to make it their home.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cynusx 5y agoThere always seem to be some sympathy in Barcelona for those poor people who can't afford apartments, but there is plenty of really affordable apartments on a train-ride's distance and they are extending the metro every year into new areas. Okupa's in Barcelona are now run by professional organizations, taking over a property and then subrenting to mostly latin americans who couldn't care less. They also happily engage in stealing electricity from their neighbors and shortcutting the water meters raising the bills for everybody else (Utilities are really expensive in Barcelona). Add to that that the mayor of Barcelona comes from the Okupa movement herself and she couldn't care less about people's retirement assets as they would never vote for her. There are real-estate investors buying apartments from old ladies who lost their extra pension income due to okupa's for cheap and then sending private services to expel the okupa's.
- spaniard89277 5y agoThere aren't plenty of affordable housing when you have large swaths of the population with unstable and low income. The spanish legal and economic setup is just bad. In fact I'd bet that most social spending done by Spain is basically useless, in that it helps basically nothing on social mobiity or capitalization of anyone depeding on them. My region, which I consider sloppy/clumsy at organizing anything, typically does a better job than the central state or other regions. My sister who lives in Ibiza requeted this new "basic income" for the pandemic, it only got a couple of months, and then got tangled into some administrative BS, and fined afterwards. So she has no income, and the rest of us (basically me, a low income worker and my dad, a pensionist) have to provide for her.
- spoonjim 5y agoWhy do you provide for your sister to live in Ibiza instead of somewhere cheaper? If she has no income then she doesn’t need to be there.
- spaniard89277 5y agoShe inherited a house there, it's the cheapest place to live for her. Not to mention she has kids etc.
- sumo89 5y agoIt's not just that the courts are bogged down meaning people can take advantage of the slow eviction process. A lot of places have a growing housing crisis, Barcelona especially, meaning there's a lot of people struggling to afford rentand being forced to look at less legal means of living in the city. https://www.bigissue.com/latest/barcelona-fights-housing-crisis-with-threat-to-seize-empty-flats/ https://www.bigissue.com/latest/barcelona-fights-housing-cri... https://www.catalannews.com/society-science/item/how-does-barcelona-s-housing-crisis-compare-with-other-cities https://www.catalannews.com/society-science/item/how-does-ba... https://www.uab.cat/web/news-detail/the-housing-crisis-territorial-implications-and-empowerment-strategies-1345680342044.html?noticiaid=1345781426171 https://www.uab.cat/web/news-detail/the-housing-crisis-terri...
- WastingMyTime89 5y agoI was quite surprised by this article. I have been out of the UK for quite some time and didn't realize the BBC had become a mouthpiece for the Tory. When did this happen exactly?
- abvdasker 5y agoHard to find much sympathy for the wealthy landowners who use violence to clear poor people out of their vacation homes. This is an obvious systemic breakdown where the solution will be either tougher laws against squatting or better public/affordable housing depending on your political ideology.
- babesh 5y agoIf a person would only read the article, they would find out that it wasn't poor people squatting in the homes. Rather it was people who did it to make a quick buck. And that one case of a poor person, it was rented out to them by someone who pretended to own the property. Don't let truth change your mind.
- burlesona 5y agoThere’s really only one way out of this mess, and that is for cities of the world to get serious about housing supply. First, in most cities, it is far too difficult to bring new housing units to market due to slow-moving non-deterministic regulation. Replacing that with efficient and deterministic regulation is the most important thing, so that over time the market can supply enough housing to bring prices down. Second, in strained housing markets (most major cities), property taxes need to go up significantly to reduce the utility of housing as an investment, and there especially needs to be a substantial tax penalty on vacant and semi-vacant (second, third homes etc.). There’s no reason a housing strained city shouldn’t use that mechanism to raise funds from the wealthy and discourage vacancy. Finally, cities that are sufficiently strained should impose significant hotel and vacation rental taxes. That’s harder to implement ordinarily because it’s not actually that easy for the government to tell the difference between a normal rental, short-term rental, and vacation rental. Also, short-term rentals are actually a healthy part of a local economy. But assuming that they started by making it much easier to build new supply and reduce the housing shortage, in the short term the city should be profiting wildly from tourists rather than letting tourists displace local residents. That tips the economic balance by lowering the demand for tourism to levels that don’t distort the local housing market. Over time that should be able to bring housing supply and demand to an equilibrium that is affordable to the locals, and at that point taxes could be adjusted over time (likely reduced) to maintain the equilibrium. Sadly, most people who work in City government have a really poor understanding of economics. They lean utopian socialist and are really offended by things like low income housing which tend to be ugly, and so they strangely and unintentionally ally with the hyper wealthy to try and exclude anything that offends their aesthetic (ie the poor), then fail at providing state housing that has the aesthetics they prefer because it’s economically infeasible to provide luxury housing for all. I wish this would change, but I fear that things will have to get much worse before this deeply entrenched dysfunction can be rooted out.
- spaniard89277 5y agoThere has been quite a lot of advocacy for a public housing model a la Vienna and better legal framework here in Spain. For some reason it just get dismissed in the left, as too expensive, and always gets overshadowed by arguments about price control. I even tried to get into a local party with this, and failed. All this while they advocate for increasing spending in all kinds of BS and and programs we already know are basically useless.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BrandoElFollito 5y agoFrance has probably the most fucked up law when it comes to squatting. Someone gets by effraction in an apartment/house, stay there for 48 hours and they are good to stay forever. If this is your primary apartment, the local government (préfet) is supposed to issue an order to get the people out. They do not (because plenty of important reasons - important for them of course). Police usually try to negotiate with the squatters. If there is a small child with the squatters getting them out is not possible at all. Except if you find them a replacement apartment. And they accept it. If this is not your primary housing, then you are completely screwed. Thee is almost no way to get the people out. We have from time to time in the news information about people who are trying to get their house back for years. If you try to move them by force, they will sue you and you pay 40,000 € plus prison. They can be sued for up to 12,000€ (and prison - this has never happened) I love my country, but the brain-dead idiots who passed these laws should be publicly pointed to, with their home address, so that they can kindly invite the squatters to come when hey are on vacation.
- orwin 5y ago> Someone gets by effraction in an apartment/house, stay there for 48 hours and they are good to stay forever. That's not true. No mention of 48h anywhere. Only place i found it is here: https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F35254 https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F35254 "Le préfet rend sa décision dans un délai de 48 heures, à partir de la réception de la demande." which roughly translate to "The prefect renders his decision within 48 hours of receiving the request." We have a family house that was squatted on the coast during last winter. We asked the squatters to leave (while redacting a letter to the prefect) and they too believed the "48 hour" stuff. The police did not however, and made them leave quite quickly (less than a week).
- BrandoElFollito 5y ago> That's not true. No mention of 48h anywhere. Please see https://immobilier.lefigaro.fr/article/ce-que-vous-devez-savoir-si-votre-logement-est-squatte_70f4422e-d36c-11e8-a48c-c6d2c6cff49b/ https://immobilier.lefigaro.fr/article/ce-que-vous-devez-sav... and https://immobilier.lefigaro.fr/article/logement-squatte-pourquoi-la-loi-bafoue-le-droit-a-la-propriete_3da696c0-eead-11ea-98b8-c14abd4b63fc/ https://immobilier.lefigaro.fr/article/logement-squatte-pour... The 48 hours are a generally applied rule for the squatters to be differentiated from, say, burglars. Because otherwise someone forcibly coming into your house while you are there could not be arrested at all. The ones you mention is for the preéfet to statute about the expulsion. > We have a family house that was squatted on the coast during last winter I honestly pity you. I know of two families whose house was squatted and it took months for them to get back their house (in a terrible state); They never got anything from the quatters (nor from the insurance in one case).
- ajay-b 5y agoIt amazes me that the law would allow someone to simply claim someone else's dwelling as their own. I understand on one side we must have tenant protections, but the definition of a tenant should be updated to one that is legally entitled to be within the dwelling by the say of the owner. Because in many American states, it is a perfect formula for extortion.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoClearly there is potential on both ends for abuse. To me this story highlights that there are a surprising number of unoccupied/rarely occupied apartments and homes. To me it's surprising that it wouldn't be in the interests of the owners to be renting them instead of leaving them empty (obviously that's a bit different when we're talking about a cottage on the beach or in the mountains, but why leave a flat in town empty?) My instinct is there must be a combination of perverse incentives that makes having paying tenants actually less appealing than letting dust gather. In a better world the flats wouldn't be empty to be squatted in by crooks or desperate people?
- hawk_ 5y agoit's the same tenants protection laws that keeps these apartments empty. someone can move in, pay rent for a month or two and then stop. good luck getting them to leave.
- franga2000 5y agoThat's breach of contract and you can sue them. Have it say something like "The obligation is terminated only after the tenant has moved out and returned the keys". If they stay, you can sue them for not paying rent since they're still a tenant. If they return the keys, immediately change the lock and enable the alarm. If they break in, you can sue them for damaging your property and they also get criminally charged with B&E.
- respondo2134 5y ago
- Hokusai 5y ago> Another of Javier's scams is to change the locks of empty apartments, then sell the keys for 1,000 or 1,200 euros to impoverished people who struggle to pay a market rent - a group that has grown in size since the start of the pandemic. These are not squatters but criminals scamming people trying to find housing. And bad policies that allow for too many empty apartments that nobody notices that have been occupied meanwhile rent and housing prices are high.
- tehjoker 5y agoIf it ain't your primary residence, I honestly could not care.
- masterof0 5y agoBecause people have the right to live for free in another person's property.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- umvi 5y agoBecause of the federal eviction moratorium in the US (and squatting laws in other countries), yes, people have the right to live for free in another person's property.
- oh_sigh 5y agoThe eviction moratorium doesn't mean you're living for free, it means that you're racking up a bill but your landlord can't kick you out.
- tehjoker 5y agoIf you think that money is getting paid back, I got a bet that BlackRock buys up all the foreclosed properties and becomes a feudal lord.
- oh_sigh 5y agoOk, but someone walking into a CVS in San Francisco and stealing things doesn't mean that it is correct to say CVS is giving away free stuff.
- AlexandrB 5y ago> The company started work three years ago and now gets 150 calls a day, says director Jorge Fe - 75% about tenants who aren't paying their rent, and 25% about squatters. So these are basically thugs performing extralegal evictions 75% of the time.
- koheripbal 5y agoMaybe they are enforcing legal evictions? As a landlord, having an eviction order is only the first step in physically removing someone that isnt paying. It's a bureaucratic nightmare.
- AlexandrB 5y agoThere's not enough information to know for sure, but passages like this make me think they're not checking for paperwork before they evict: > He could wait for the courts to make a decision - that could take up to two years. Or he could go private. > "People advised me to hire a company that specialises in negotiating with squatters to get them out."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- koheripbal 5y agoThis seems very plausible to me. When I went through the courts to have someone evicted - after a year long legal fight, the bailiff that finally came out to remove the tenant, gave me a business card to a friend of his that removes tenants. He said that as long as I have the eviction notice, the police/court would have no issue with physically removing someone, and that there was no reason to make the additional multi-month petition to have the court physically order the bailiff to remove the tenant. So ever since, I get the order, and then get two guys to go in and physically put all the person's stuff on the sidewalk, and lock them out. It sucks, but it's not like we're evicting single moms (who are usually able to pay due to gov't aid). In my experience, the tenants that get evicted are always the single male drug addicts (who are also on gov't aid).
- toiletaccount 5y agothis reminds me of a show i saw (iirc "nightmare tenants and slum landlords") where people found a house, rented it, and then found out the landlord had no connection at all to the property. the real owners were quite upset when they returned from vacation to find their newly remodeled home occupied by strangers and ended up living in one of their mother's attic for years with an infant trying to get the squatters to leave. unbelievable. in america you walk into your house with a 12 gauge (like you always do) and blast the cocksuckers you believe to be threatening your life. end of the goddamn story.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 5y ago> And there continue to be rumours about the relationship between eviction companies and criminal squatter gangs. [...] "They might even be linked," says Michael Regan. "I've heard very strange stories - it is quite murky." Brilliant. Squat then cousin calls the owner and says, we can get rid of them, just pay us and then we'll pay them too. Rinse, repeat.
- yawaworht1978 5y agoThis is the reason why it's ridiculously hard to just get a flat rented in Spain. Ever since covid it has gotten much worse. You will not believe the checks landlords and the agencies require, the bank needs to play along as well.
- fy20 5y agoI needed to rent an apartment for 6 months a few years ago while on an Erasmus course and it was hard enough then... I even offered to pay up front - in cash - if it would make the process simpler, but nope. A few agencies simply turned me away, then eventually I found one that would go through the process but it took a while and lots of paperwork.
- gammalost 5y agoA person shouldn't be allowed to own two different homes. It's absurd that some have summer homes abroad while people in the country are homeless
- respondo2134 5y agoyou're welcome to your opinion, and can support & promote this position, but you had better be prepared for me to make arbitrary limits around things you covet as well: no one needs more than one child / car / computer, $XXX retirement savings, n years of education, etc. For the most part free societies don't dictate directly but shape with the carrot and the stick.
- gammalost 5y agoIf a lack of cars, computers etc became a problem then I would be against people hoarding it aswell
- llampx 5y agoThe real issue is not homes but rather wealth, and some people (and some countries) have more of it than others. Unless you have a solution to reshape the Gini coefficient, setting arbitrary limits on the number of things one can own is not going to solve anything. Much the same way as rent controls don't solve anything.
- gammalost 5y agoDon't know where you live. But a big problem with rent controll here in Sweden is that it's just not enough appartments to go around. Sweden at least would need a new million programme or something similar
- c22 5y agoWhat if a surplus of those things is causing problems?
- umvi 5y ago
- saltedonion 5y agoThis entire thread just reads MADNESS in bold. The hell is this law supposed to accomplish?!?!
- hn-is-life 5y agoThis angered me to the point of shaking, including one of the top comments in the thread detailing the madness of the law in France. I hope I never have to experience this myself. But Spain and France are garbage countries if they allow people’s right to property to be violated in such a disgusting way. I am truly shocked and wish these squatters only ill
- olliej 5y agoit costs something like 10-20k cash to remove tenants from an apartment in SF, on top of whatever else the city requires you to provide, even if the tenants have not been paying rent. You can Alice act the house but that drastically reduces the market value of the house (e.g by more than the pile of cash you would otherwise be paying the tenants)
- spfzero 5y agoI wonder if this is an opportunity for paid house-sitters? You could have them sign a binding contract to prevent sitter from turning into a squatter. The house sitter gets free rent, the homeowner gets peace-of-mind.
- fy20 5y agoThere was something like that in the UK a decade ago, although that itself seemed like a racket, as the property owners and residents both paid. I understand now the law has changed, making it a lot harder to legally squat in the UK. https://www.vice.com/en/article/dpw5mv/guardian-schemes-kleinfeld-gentrification-homelessness-761 https://www.vice.com/en/article/dpw5mv/guardian-schemes-klei...
- slim 5y agoIt's strange that none on HN is seeing it as a startup opportunity :) why not offer house occupation service ?
- mehphp 5y agoWhat stops that sitter from claiming residency ;)
- theHIDninja 5y agoThis is why we need guns.
- HomeDeLaPot 5y agoThe problem isn't that people are squatting while you're at home.
- lazyninja987 5y agooh my god!!! this hits closer to home. This is rampant in India, Police wont even register a case against squatters and force the house owner to 'pay it out'. if the squatter is politically connected, there is nothing you can do, than just pray that squatter gets bored of your house. i would prefer to keep my house empty, than rent it to a potential squatter. In bangalore, the IT capital, home owners demand up to 10 months of rent in advance to ward of potential squatters.
- anovikov 5y agoWhy does this even exist? Why not simply make any and all trespassing a crime punishable by lengthy prison terms? Or problem is prison capacity? Why not solve it supply-side, just as healthcare?
- Arete314159 5y agoThis is very Spanish. I remember reading something years ago about how there weren't good laws or consequences in Spain to force people to pay debts. So in response, a company sprang up to follow debtors all day with people dressed in hideous costumes, until they basically shamed them into paying up.