30 ms·
Joe Rogan, confined to Spotify, is losing influence
- newbamboo 5y agoI thought this at first, but now think the opposite is true. His viewpoints were more diluted previously. A smaller base is of regular listeners paradoxically makes his messages stronger.
- nyx-aiur 5y agoDoes it?
- bitwize 5y agoInasmuch as his message doesn't offend Spotify, their key strategic partners, or their financial service providers -- sure, I'll buy that.
- newbamboo 5y agoCensorship is worse on YouTube. Think of how many affiliates YouTube/google/nbc has. I’d say more than Spotify. There’s a reason AM radio has more “extreme” content than FM radio. A wider audience means more people to appease; have to cater to the common denominator.
- InitialLastName 5y ago> There’s a reason AM radio has more “extreme” content than FM radio. A wider audience means more people to appease; have to cater to the common denominator. What? AM stations tend to have larger ranges (FM is limited by line-of-sight). There tends to be more talk on AM because the audio quality is lower (and more susceptible to interference); I would assume that talk radio (where opinions are actually being discussed) would naturally have more "extreme" content than music, where the opinions are diluted by the presence of other content.
- snowwrestler 5y agoDoes Joe Rogan have “messages”? I thought his whole thing was to be a neutral place for interesting conversations. If he’s trying to deliver specific messages now, that would certainly affect who wants to listen to him.
- zepto 5y agoThis seemed like the obvious trap he was going to fall into. I used to listen to him when he interviewed someone I was interested in. I even installed Spotify so I can access his podcast. In practice, because I don’t use Spotify for anything else, I have simply forgotten about him.
- Bellamy 5y agoWould you fell into a trap like this for 100.000.000$?
- zepto 5y agoApparently he made $30M in the year before the deal. If the deal lasts for more than 2 years, then he has made a serious error.
- Proven 5y agoThere's no question that can't be solved with elementary school math, right? Did he personally tell you that entering 2025 with a net worth of $175 rather than $195 million would present a serious problem for him? Does he not care more about other things in life?
- tomjakubowski 5y agoIs Spotify the only source of revenue from his podcast? I don't listen to JRE, but this thread suggests he's still running third-party ads on the show. Presumably then he's still getting some portion of that $30M/year on top of what Spotify pays him. > Spotify doesn’t play or include ads that interrupt the listening experience of Premium subscribers. However, some podcast creators may include third-party advertising, host-read endorsements, or sponsorship messages in their episodes. https://community.spotify.com/t5/Other-Podcasts-Partners-etc/Ads-on-joe-rogan-with-premium-account/td-p/5065185 https://community.spotify.com/t5/Other-Podcasts-Partners-etc...
- ganoushoreilly 5y ago
- anm89 5y agoIm sure the money was more than enough for him to feel compensated
- jazzyjackson 5y agoYeah it’s not like Joe’s goal in life was to influence people. Dude wants to make a living talking to people, which he’s achieved 100fold
- anm89 5y agoI agree. I don't think influence isn't important to him but I don't think he is in it for world domination.
- Bellamy 5y agoI'm paying Spotify Premium and still have to listen ads during the show. Spotify also sends video even though I just need the audio. It's a waste of valuable bandwidth and CPU. If there would an alternative I would take it. Anyway I have definitely listened JRE way less lately...
- jjulius 5y ago>I'm paying Spotify Premium and still have to listen ads during the show. I have Spotify and don't listen to podcasts much at all. When I have, it hasn't been on Spotify and I've always been able to skip through the recording to get past the ad (either with a "skip fwd 15 secs" button or by grabbing the slider and moving it manually). Does Spotify not offer that capability?
- jazzyjackson 5y agoThey’ve made it simple to skip ads because each ad pops up as a track that you can scrobble to the end of. I assume they’re satisfied with this because my dragging my finger across the name of the advertiser is probably a better signal of impression than hoping I was actually present during the ad roll. But Apple podcasts “skip 15sec” is still easier, I can do it without looking while driving.
- neartheplain 5y ago>each ad pops up as a track that you can scrobble to the end of The first time this happened to me (while loading up a Joe Rogan podcast), I legitimately thought Spotify was glitching out. There's no visual indication in the app that it's a temporary ad, or of how many ads you have to listen to before the episode starts. I made it to the beginning of the third ad track before giving up.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoI did experience an infinite ad loop once and force closed the app and opened it again. Spotify is buggy AF.
- AzzieElbab 5y agoIt is hard to make an argument against YT having the highest reach among vloging platforms. However, repeated guests not gaining as many Twitter followers as they did after first visit might be an indication of diminishing returns
- jazzyjackson 5y agoCould also be a commensurate drop in interest in Twitter
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI don't blaming him for taking the money from Spotify. He has ensured his descendants' wealth for probably a few generations. Good for him. I still see clips of him on YouTube. How does that work given his deal with Spotify, anyone know?
- wrink 5y agoThey are are allowed to upload snippets but are limited in length and number of clips they are permitted to upload per episode. I assume they provide the allowance for purely promotional reasons. Personally, I find the clips too short to be particularly interesting
- LinuxBender 5y agoAt first I thought he would be ok. His original gripe with Youtube was the censorship of controversial guests. Either he or Spotify prevented most of the controversial videos from being imported into Spotify so I guess the problem remains. Is there a platform that allows any/all controversial guests?
- jazzyjackson 5y agoAdvertisers don’t want to advertise next to controversial guests, so if there’s another platform they don’t have 100 megabucks to buy content with (I mean, podcasting is the most open platform of all before “exclusive podcasts” became a thing)
- opan 5y agoHe could use something like peertube or funkwhale.
- asdff 5y agoor joerogan.com
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe internet.
- wiether 5y agoI don't understand why people who seek freedom from enclosed and proprietary platforms are not bigger advocates of ActivityPub and software that relies on it. After Trump got banned from Twitter & Facebook, the right wing decided to "build" their own platforms and went to Parler or stuff like that, which wasn't a big success. But why not using awesome tools build by the FOSS community to support their need of freedom ? I don't share their ideas, sure, but if they used those tools, it will sure make them popular enough so other people would turn to it and start leaving Twitter, Facebook... It looks like crypto currencies : built by geeks wanting to build a better system, and mostly used by ill intended people. What don't we see the same thing for social networking ? Because at the end all they care about is money so they need to control everything and build their copy of Twitter or Facebook ?
- throwaway4good 5y agoJoe Rogan would be losing influence regardless if he was confined to Spotify, simply due to the competition. There is just so much more podcasting done today than there was two years ago, when he took the deal.
- billylindeman 5y agoPretty much haven't listened at all since his move to spotify. I don't blame him for selling out at all, but spotify is garbage for podcasts. If he went back to youtube I'd probably watch again
- daughart 5y agoJust like Howard Stern (note, SiriusXM also owns Spotify). They traded a broader audience and greater influence for stability and gigantic paychecks. E.g., in Howard's case, even though his personal influence shrunk, his importance to Sirius/Spotify grew as a fraction of the subscriber base is dedicated to one talent and would otherwise unsubscribe. Howard's deal has been renewed a number of times now. I can't blame anyone involved.
- jswrenn 5y agoCorrection: SiriusXM owns Pandora, not Spotify. https://investor.siriusxm.com/investor-overview/press-releases/press-release-details/2019/SiriusXM-Completes-Acquisition-of-Pandora/default.aspx https://investor.siriusxm.com/investor-overview/press-releas...
- rajbot 5y ago> SiriusXM also owns Spotify Sirius XM (nasdaq:SIRI) and Spotify (nyse:SPOT) are two different companies. Sirius XM bought pandora in 2019.
- adamrezich 5y agothis makes more sense for Stern because his audience is much narrower than Rogan's. Stern moving from terrestrial radio gave him more "freedom," whereas the same can't be said for Rogan. also, Stern took the deal when he had been established voice in radio for decades, whereas Rogan was (to my understanding) just reaching his height of popularity before the exclusivity deal began.
- pessimizer 5y ago> this makes more sense for Stern because his audience is much narrower than Rogan's. In what way was Stern's audience narrower at all than Rogan's? Stern narrowed his audience when he moved to Sirius, but so did Rogan, apparently. When Stern was in syndication and on E!, he had as general an audience as any radio personality (back when people listened to the radio.) Rogan has a very narrow demographic as far as I can see, and virtually that entire demo is a subset of who listened to or watched Stern during what was something like a 15 year long peak.
- shoulderfake 5y agoEchochamber effect here I presume. Joe Rogan is doing just fine on Spotify. He can choose not to extend at the end of his contract, go back to YouTube and continue just where he left off.
- jjulius 5y ago>Joe Rogan is doing just fine on Spotify. This article produced data to back up their assertion, I would be curious to see the data you're looking at that helps you make yours.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoThat implies constant growth is the only measurable metric. Probably it is for Spotify, maybe for Rogan, but it doesn't have to be.
- jjulius 5y agoNo, it asks for any specific example of how one might suggest he is doing "just fine". I would just like to see why someone thinks this article is incorrect, not simply that they think so. I would be fine with someone suggesting an alternative to constant growth as an example.
- scrumbledober 5y agoi think making $100 million could definitely be considered on the high side of doing "just fine"
- vannevar 5y agoIt's questionable whether online 'influencers' actually influence anyone beyond getting them to watch or listen to their show. What they definitely have is an audience, and that is valuable to the advertisers and marketers who do influence people, as well as prospective guests who want to promote themselves or a cause. I think influencers' main value for advertisers is acting as a magnet for certain demographics, providing another way to do targeted marketing.
- psyc 5y agoWell, there's this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28302725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28302725
- Spivak 5y agoWhich is an absolutely fascinating case-study! It's easy to just write it off as "kids mimicking content creator for attention" but it goes so much deeper than this because it's a learned subconscious reaction to stress. It's like tapping your feet or biting your nails but interesting because it's verbal. It's kinda like if you say "like" or "um" to fill space when talking you never really have to think about it but you can stop if you practice.
- vannevar 5y agoMaybe Joe's viewers will all start doing stand-up. :-) There was a marketing study of influencers from Rakuten Marketing that indicates that advertising through influencer channels produces positive sales results. But again, it's not clear that the influencer actually drove the purchases, versus just drawing an audience that was predisposed to make those purchases in the first place. https://www.iab.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Rakuten-2019-Influencer-Marketing-Report-Rakuten-Marketing.pdf https://www.iab.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Rakuten-2019-...
- elliekelly 5y agoIf influencers didn’t “influence” then advertisers wouldn’t pay them. That’s all “influence” is. Just a dressed up name for marketing.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoThis is less a problem for Joe than it is for his advertisers. I wonder about the effectiveness of pre-roll ads vs extremely annoying mid-sentence ad breaks scattered through the episode. Use to be joe was one of the more enjoyable blocks of 3 hour content to listen to because there were no commercial breaks.
- glonq 5y agoI stopped listening to him around the time that he signed to spotify. But I think that was coincidental. I just got sick of how he's such a nutter and a dummy -- even though I like many things about who he is and what he does.
- ram_rar 5y agoSpotify video leaves a lot to be desired as compared to youtube. They should stick to audio and improve on it. I dont understand, why do I need to go through ads for JR show even though I pay for spotify premium. The best part of youtube is that one could search through and get excerpts of the video. I could easily find JRs tidbits without the need of going through the entire interview. I still see some of the older excerpts in youtube, but less so in spotify.
- jollybean 5y agoAll regular media consumption is down, ratings for all news is down, I think we're all suffering from social media consumption fatigue, and there's is also an explosion of podcasts to listen to now. The Economist has daily 45 minutes, Conan O'Brien is on audio only etc.. And he might actually have a broader audience than before, does it matter that much that guests 'new follower' metrics are down? I think there's a broader context to consider here.
- falcrist 5y ago> All regular media consumption is down, ratings for all news is down, I think we're all suffering from social media consumption fatigue A quick google search seems to contradict this. Can you point me towards a source that backs these claims?
- beezischillin 5y agoI stopped watching purely due to the Spotify deal. I was willing to give it a try until I saw that they were memoryholing episodes. I might be in the minority here but it felt like a betrayal. If he wanted more money he could’ve invested in his own platform like many others and people would’ve followed. There’s plenty of other content in the sea.
- bostonsre 5y agomemoryholing episodes == ?
- ceejayoz 5y agoSpotify didn't bring over the old episodes with people like Alex Jones, Gavin McInnes, and Milo Yiannopoulos. > “There were a few episodes they didn’t want on their platform,” Rogan said, per DMN. “And I was like, ‘OK, I don’t care.'” https://www.thewrap.com/spotify-deletes-joe-rogan-podcast-episodes/ https://www.thewrap.com/spotify-deletes-joe-rogan-podcast-ep...
- duxup 5y agoKinda curious, do fans .. .care about that? I guess some do but I don't think I ever listen to past podcasts that I've already listened to...
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Kinda curious, do fans .. .care about that? Beyond bad faith concern trolling, I suspect not.
- nradov 5y agoI'm not particularly a "fan", but I do enjoy listening to some JRE episodes when he has interesting guests like Andrew Huberman. I don't care about losing access to old podcasts any more than I care about Netflix pulling certain movies. That's just the reality of all streaming services. Content gets removed all the time for all sorts of reasons. If you want to maintain access to something then you'll have to make a local copy on hardware you own.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- betwixthewires 5y agoYeah I know I stopped listening since the show went exclusive. I didn't listen to every single episode he did, but I did listen pretty regularly. I have not seen a single one since and don't really care to. I won't get an account with a company just to hear what you have to say. If you require that, as far as I'm concerned your influence just waned a little. I'm steadfast and unflinching in this, it is a firm rule I have.
- xutopia 5y agoTo be fair... his move to Spotify coincided with him spewing more and more anti-vax and anti-mask drivel that I don't have any interest in listening to.
- rapind 5y agoHe was always into the conspiracy stuff, and it was usually pretty light and interesting. The tone and guests definitely changed around the time he moved to Austin (no knock on Austin, I love that place). Politics and stuff I guess. I lost interest too.
- wickoff 5y agoMe too. I think his friend circle became almost entirely right leaning since the move and his viewpoints are no longer balanced. I listen to a few other podcasters who definitely can't called lefties, yet they manage to present things in nuanced and less biased ways. It doesn't seem like a very difficult thing to do, yet he fails at it miserably.
- Clubber 5y agoI don't think that's accurate. Do you have some links or anything to back that up? Like actual transcripts, not some media interpretation. "People say, do you think it's safe to get vaccinated? I've said, yeah, I think for the most part it's safe to get vaccinated. I do. I do," Rogan said on the podcast. "But if you're like 21 years old, and you say to me, should I get vaccinated? I'll go no. Are you healthy? Are you a healthy person?" "If you're a healthy person, and you're exercising all the time, and you're young, and you're eating well," Rogan continued, "like, I don't think you need to worry about this." If this is what you are referring to, is that really anti-vax?
- ta2987 5y agoYes.
- JxLS-cpgbe0 5y ago> should I get vaccinated? I'll go no. Yes that's anti-vax. We get vaccinated not just to protect ourselves from death, but also to protect those around us by reducing the transmission of disease.
- xupybd 5y agoI have a Spotify subscription. I used to watch Joe on YouTube. I haven't since he moved. I use Spotify at work to have something to drown out the noise around me. I watch YouTube to relax. My habits mean I don't even think of going to Spotify for a podcast.
- djrogers 5y agoLooks like I was mistaken - there is a JRE channel but it may be just clips
- neartheplain 5y agoNot exactly. He no longer posts full episodes to YouTube, just occasional clips: https://www.youtube.com/user/PowerfulJRE https://www.youtube.com/user/PowerfulJRE
- xupybd 5y agoI used to sit down and watch an hour or two of a full interview. I've not done so since I'd have to use Spotify to watch a full interview.
- salamanderman 5y agoGood
- truthwhisperer 5y agowritten by a journalist who does not understand statistics. He is still gaining twitter followers but not on the same rate. so his reach grows, but not as fast as it used to be. probably the same journalist who write about climate change
- goodfight 5y agoHe wanted less attention, you can't be king of the hill forever
- beebmam 5y agoThe more he embraces conspiracy theories, the less I find him persuasive. At this point, with his embrace of anti-vaccination ideas and being completely mostly to medical science and the scientific community out of contrarianism, I find him more annoying than interesting.
- markus_zhang 5y agoThe ones with Carmack and an ex-pilot (regarding UFO) were interesting. Other than that I really didn't have any knowledge of. It's more of the people he interviewed then his channel.
- falcrist 5y agoI had no idea John Carmack had gone on the podcast.
- mwidell 5y agoJohn Carmack and James Hetfield are a couple of very interesting guests he had.
- yellow_lead 5y agoIt's even hard to listen to these. I have heard enough of Rogan's "Wow!" and "Really?" to last a lifetime.
- bostonsre 5y agoLex did one [1] with the same pilot that saw the ufo (commander fravor). I went from "no friggin way do they exist" to "shit... it actually sounds plausible". [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aB8zcAttP1E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aB8zcAttP1E
- jgalt212 5y agoyes, to some extent Rogan is a modern day Larry King. i.e. he's a very easy interview in that he allows his guests to say pretty much what they want without too much push back.
- kamaal 5y agoIn general the easiest to way to make any one like you is to let them to all the talking, and sound like you ask interesting questions about their experiences, which make them and listening audience feel they are intelligent. There are these anecdotes about Benjamin Disraeli that anybody who ever talked to him felt like they were the most intelligent person in Britain, and at times if there were a bunch people around him, they felt like they took turns being the most intelligent people in Britain.
- surajs 5y agoJoe has had one hell of a run, I don't think he minds losing influence
- fedreserved 5y agoMake sure to circle back for the Tom ONeil episode. He spent 20 years writing a book about Charles Manskm, and unearthed several earth shattering revelations about the case.1. cia was most likely involved in allowing Charles Manson who was on probation throughout the entire period get away with multiple probation violations after spending half his life in prison. As a criminal defense attorney with the evidence he laid oitz it's obviois Manson had some sort of guardian angel Also lead prosecutor led key witnesses to commit perjury. The motive for the Tate murder the prosecutor put on was to send a message to the record producer who used to own the house. Key witnesses told him that the record producer was seem several times after the murders happened, and at trial the testimony was different.
- SXX 5y agoWhen he moved to Spotify I suppose I'll get his podcasts from torrents, but then I end up finding far more interesting podcasts to replace him. After all if any of his episodes are interesting I can just listen them two years later.
- captaindiego 5y agoAny recommendations you can offer for interesting podcasts?
- Zelphyr 5y agoI would like to mention Armchair Expert but they cashed in at the Bank of Spotify as well. Such a shame because it's a really enjoyable podcast. That said; Jocko Podcast is good, though the subject matter can be very heavy at times. Lex Fridman podcast is good. Some people don't like his somewhat monotoned voice but he has interesting guests. Literally! With Rob Lowe is fun.
- SXX 5y agoAs already mentioned there is Lex Fridman. Some people including me dislike the way he speaks, but listening on x2+ speed fixes that. I also enjoyed The Tim Ferris Show and he generally have more guests who are not related to tech. Though I mostly went deeper into podcasts related to software engineering and since most of them include a lot of off-topic some are quite fun: Soft Skills Engineering, The Bike Shed, Indie Hackers Podcast, Talk Python to Me, Unnamed RE Podcast. So there is always more interesting podcasts than time I have for listening. Might be you can't replace Rogan with one show, but you can always diversify.
- pleb_nz 5y ago8m not sure how his podcasts were distributed previously, but I would have thought a more multiplatform approach would work better long term. A lot of people don't have Spotify, I'm one of those, for the same price as Spotify I can get YouTube premium for me and the extended family, kill all ads, allow downloads and access to a decent music streaming catalog. Last time I checked the prices were not to dissimilar.
- laurent92 5y agoI think he was promised $100m for the Spotify exclusivity. No multiplatform works better than $100m ;)
- criddell 5y agoIt has also been argued Joe sold out at way too low of a price. https://www.supercast.com/blog/joe-rogan-got-ripped-off https://www.supercast.com/blog/joe-rogan-got-ripped-off
- therealdrag0 5y agoI would guess 5% conversion is pretty generous and unsupported.
- meowface 5y agoApparently it was a bigger number than that, though the exact number isn't known.
- ProAm 5y agoI think it was more than 100MM, he was making ~30MM per year on his own, and he signed a 3 year deal with Spotify. Im not sure why you'd sell for the exact amount you'd make if you just kept doing what you are doing with the exception of having to handle all advertising yourself and possible delisting/banning from YouTube.
- laurent92 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- duxup 5y agoI wonder if Rogan would 'not lose influence' had he changed nothing. Feels like these kind of personalities, while they can have long careers, growth / reach isn't infinite or sustainable.
- heyparkerj 5y agoI listened to Joe a lot when I was doing manual labor in 2013-2014ish. Like almost every single episode. I was always able to intake the things I thought were interesting and laugh off stuff I thought was dumb or unconvincing, but I do remember thinking that one day the greater internet will realize that his podcast is littered with content that people could easily misconstrue and start a real uproar about with sufficient motivation. Based on this, I think people shining a light on some of the dumber things that a self proclaimed dumb guy says while recording himself talking for 10 hours a week, and becoming a bit of an internet meme in the process was inevitable - and that's before he started saying whatever the hell he's been saying about vaccines and masks.
- duxup 5y agoI've thought about the balance between "I don't know and I'm going to think out loud here." and doing that as entertainment and ... where that leads to some responsibility for saying some stuff that you really don't know that is dead wrong and ... I duno. It's a weird world.
- motohagiography 5y agoI was looking for who these listeners were switching to, or what the change was relative to overall podcast listenership, and was totally surprised the authors didn't include a base rate in their analysis. Not including base rates in references to anything quantitative is like writing spam emails with spelling mistakes because being dumb enough not to notice is a good proxy for being dumb enough to buy what you are selling. Though I doubt whether the people at the Verge have the sophistication to be intentionally fraudulent. They just need enough noise or to craft a conflict around. However it's a good example of data-horoscope journalism, where you backfit your narrative to points on a line. Rogan is probably the most successful podcaster in the world by a variety of possible metrics, and I'm not sure what a reasonable expectation of how that plays out would be. Does he transform into a being of pure light and ascend into space, or, does he just do a job he likes until he doesn't anymore, and moves on to something else? The Verge should just say what they mean, which is that Rogan talks to off-brand people and you shouldn't be tempted by how good the conversations are because it will not align you with crumbling mainstream narratives, and instead you should spend your time engaged with their clickbait talking points factory deciphering their adolescent purple sophistry.
- MauroIksem 5y agoNot surprised..i stopped listening when he moved. It was entertaining but not enough for me to move podcast platforms.
- eplanit 5y agoRumble is gaining popularity; maybe he should move there.
- lanevorockz 5y agoJoe Rogan knew his days on Big Tech Pravda were counted ... he took his audience and went to Spotify where he took the profit upfront. Much smarter than most people that only follow the leader and don't have one shred of critical thought.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoThis sounds right to me. Big tech is very eager to deplatform anyone who holds contrarian views against the status quo, and this is especially true with regards to vaccine and politics. In some ways being on Spotify with a multimillion dollar contract actually offers some decent protection. Hopefully he's got a good contract.
- qwertyuiop_ 5y ago>To do this, we pulled data from the analytics tool Social Blade to track the Twitter following of every guest who went on Rogan’s podcast between December 2019 and July 2021. Guests generally see a surge of new followers after appearing on the show, with some gaining as many as 18,000 new followers in the week following their chat, and that effect has grown over time as The Joe Rogan Experience gained popularity. This is based on post show Twitter following of the guests. What if his loyal listeners are not into Twitter and are leaving.
- comodore_ 5y agoon top of that they highlight repeat guests which makes no sense. and the fact that they highlight them specifically is very fishy.
- fridif 5y agoJoe has publicly said that he did the deal for the money and nothing else. More power to him. Y'all have it twisted.
- blueprint 5y agohow do they have it twisted?
- chucksta 5y agoThey think he cares more about his reach then is dollars
- Alupis 5y agoIn the podcasting world, reach == dollars. With a declining audience, his show will generate declining revenue for Spotify, and eventually he will receive less money because of it. Keep in mind, Rogan said multiple times on his show he would never sell out because he wanted to do whatever he wanted to do... then he sold out to a platform that immediately cut off a large portion of his viewership.
- fridif 5y agoNo, not in Joe Rogan's case. The code is more something like: if (iLetSpotifyGiveMeMoney) {gain50millionDollars()}
- chucksta 5y agoYeah I'm sure he and howard stern both really regret limiting their audience. He didn't sell out in the traditional sense (product placements, no-go topics, etc)
- blueprint 5y agowho does?
- 5y ago
- atlgator 5y agoThe only Joe Rogan episodes worth watching are the Tim Dillon ones. If you know, you know. Otherwise, I stopped watching when he moved to Spotify. It's just a terrible platform all-around. He destroyed his brand for $150M.
- comodore_ 5y agothese seem like very flawed metrics to say the least. but then for twitter journos, twitter is everything.
- orange_puff 5y agoMaybe all good things simply need to come to an end. I feel like he basically has boomer politics now and the same predictable opinion over and over can get old. My brother said something that I think is true; Joe seems like the kind of guy who believes whatever the last person he spoke to said, so after moving to Austin he's become more conservative.
- rattlesnakedave 5y ago>all good things simply need to come to an end I think this is the crux of it. After >1600 episodes, how much is there left to say?
- tehalex 5y agoI have no interested in listening and I've thought about canceling spotify for how hard they push the podcast with no way to hide it.
- chrisco255 5y agoSpotify is just not set up for long-form video content. The discovery aspect of YouTube is one reason why it reels you in. You're scrolling through your feed, you see an interesting clip, and you click on it. Another big part of YouTube is the comment section. Spotify lacks on both fronts. I also think the JRE clips were a big part of what sucked people into watch full epsiodes. If a 5-7 minute JRE clip were interesting I might jump in and watch the whole episode. I don't think they've done that or done it as well on Spotify.
- dragonelite 5y agoThose short clips did indeed pulled in me in to just put a JRE episode on the background while working xD
- gordon_freeman 5y agoThis. The flexibility to search for a video coupled with YT's spontaneous recommendations is something unique to YouTube. So many times I have seen a clip about PBS Newshour episode on YT and then end up watching whole Newshour episode or most of it. Having all videos on varied lengths in same platform makes it easy to consume based on the time available.
- DantesKite 5y agoHe still posts Joe Rogan clips and I genuinely still enjoy listening to those.
- dharma1 5y agoJRE clips still get posted on YouTube but not the full recordings, which is annoying. I haven’t listened to many recently as a result. Just giving people the freedom to listen/watch wherever they like would be best. I usually prefer YouTube for podcasts - video, easy access and sharing, timeline sections, comments, recommendations, no ads and background audio with YouTube premium)
- LatteLazy 5y agoIts a vicious cycle: he got a bit crazy and anti-vax, hes in Austin so its 10 times harder to get good guests, and that makes it all the easier to lean into being antivax etc.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoHis move to Spotify isn't why he sucked, but Joe really has gone off the ego end. If you listen to his early ustream podcasts, he was just funny stoner. Now he's just lost touch.
- altacc 5y agoHearing "Exclusively on Spotify" on any podcast ad is a sure-fire way to make sure I never listen to an episode. One of the great features of podcasts is the flexibility in listening platform and I'd really rather not switch to Spotify's substandard user experience.
- xnx 5y agoSo true. I wonder if RSS could make a comeback if it were marketed as "podcast for articles".
- soheil 5y agoNo because no popular publisher would stay the moment a $100m exclusive offer is made.
- radicalbyte 5y agoI subscribe to Spotify but I dropped Rogan when he left. I have all my other podcasts in one app, listening history and all. Now I have to drop that because Spotify want to play monopoly? S** that.
- tantalor 5y agoScratching my head what "S**" means
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Zelphyr 5y agoMoney aside, I personally feel the Spotify deal was terrible for Rogan. He does more for Spotify than they do for him. Not least of which because Spotify, while pretty great for music, is terrible as a podcast player. And, yeah, he has gone off the deep end since the Spotify deal. Somebody dumping a giant basket of cash on your doorstep probably does the ego no favors.
- ssijak 5y agoSpotify is terrible for podcasts, but 100mil $ is enough (on top of $$$ he already has) to not care about nuances of does he gives them more than they gave him.
- busymom0 5y agoI think 100 million isn't much considering the amount of influence he has. I guess getting an upfront 100 million is better than over the years though. Does anyone know how long his contract is with Spotify? It's it's longer than 2-3 years then he's losing money imo.
- dlivingston 5y ago> he has gone off the deep end since the Spotify deal. Can you explain? I’m genuinely curious by what you mean.
- Zelphyr 5y agoI haven't listened in awhile because Spotify is such a terrible place for podcasts but, when I did, for about a month or two after he moved to Spotify, it seemed like all he was talking about were UFO's, other conspiracy theories, and how much he hated the COVID measures. Frankly, I don't care that he talks about those things--some I agree with him on, some I don't--but, in the past he did a good job of balancing those things out with guests who offered a different perspective. After he made the Spotify deal, it seemed like he went all in on his beliefs and didn't seem interested in exposing himself or his audience to opposing views anymore.
- LatteLazy 5y agoAnyone know any good alternatives? I listen to the Rachman Review on geo-politics and China Talk. But i dont think anyone else has as wide a range as Joe. Tim Ferris is ok but he's way more niche. https://www.ft.com/rachman-review https://www.ft.com/rachman-review https://chinatalkshow.libsyn.com/rss https://chinatalkshow.libsyn.com/rss
- knorker 5y agoNo wonder. Spotify is the most broken piece of shit on the app stores by far. Hey, let me download these so i can listen on the plane. Oh, the app just hangs on startup when you're in airplane mode. Well that's pointless. And on and on. It's a wonder anyone even can listen if they wanted to. Sorry, this comment is probably not HN material, but every time I use Spotify it makes me angry from how it just doesn't work.
- cpach 5y agoI actually like Spotify. For music, though. Listening to podcasts in a music app – makes no sense to me. I have Overcast for that purpose and I see no reason to switch. I can understand that it was a good deal for Rogan personally if he got 100 million USD for exclusivity but for the average podcast host I believe that an open platform is much better.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoAs an artist I do not like getting $50 per 1m plays.
- jdprgm 5y agoIt's been frustrating watching the Spotify (and general movement) with podcasts fragmenting and going exclusive. Spotify won with music because it improved upon the existing state of listening to music and offered a free or cheap solution that was even a compelling alternative to piracy. Podcasts for the most part were in the ideal state for consumers, almost always free and mostly client independent distributed w/ RSS. I don't think there is much of any argument that Spotify can improve that state for consumers by taking a podcast exclusive. These deals are just payouts for the hosts not investments that make the shows better. Most even very successful podcasts likely have low opex (some exceptions like NYT Daily) and don't benefit from a big pile of cash. On a different note regarding the Rogan Deal, Spotify took ages to add video streaming support on Apple TV (main way I would catch Rogan) which basically caused me to quit casual watching. They also only recently added offline playback for Apple Watch and even then it's premium exclusive and requires manual downloading of eps. I don't understand at all why an enormous company like Spotify is so neglectful of the entire apple ecosystem.
- Covzire 5y agoThe ads on Spotify for paying US users is what keeps me off of it for the most part. You can fast forward but it's a gigantic pain in the ass. Their UX is awful too compared to a simple web app, they should just clone a basic Youtube/Odysee/Rumble functionality for their video side.
- dadver 5y agoWait, -paying- users get ads in the US? Then why do they pay?
- Covzire 5y agoI'm assuming for the privilege of fast forwarding them, but I'm not sure, it's probably the biggest reason I can't feel any affinity for the platform at all. I'm happy to chip in for the service like i do with Youtube Premium, but come on. They're not short ads either, and I think most of them are put in place by Joe Rogan himself because they're often him going on for 2-3 minutes.
- danschumann 5y agoAs a paying customer, I wonder what I'm paying for when I get a 15 minute ad of Joe Rogan hard pitching me something.
- arodgers_la 5y agoComedian Bill Burr said it best: "I'm not gonna sit here with no medical degree, listening to you with no medical degree, with an American flag behind you smoking a cigar acting like we know what's up better than the CDC." [0] That quote is Joe Rogan's shtick in a nutshell. [0] https://youtube.com/watch?v=tSKVXl-WnrA&t=5m20s https://youtube.com/watch?v=tSKVXl-WnrA&t=5m20s
- beaner 5y agoFor it to be the schtick that'd have to be sort of the pont of the show, but it's only a topic of discussion so long as it's made relevant by those in our society, and even then that ignores the large diversity of guests and topics in his show. There's nothing wrong with listening to two regular people have a conversation regardless of their qualifications for the topics they're discussing. They don't pretend to be professionals. (Hence why that quote can be said and why they can laugh about it.)
- mmrezaie 5y agoI think we all know JRE is not about two people having shit conversation. I used to listen to it since 2016. In the past couple of years, JRE is all about let's bring out what triggers the other side; no matter what the other side is all about. I have friends I have lost because of this, whom I have no idea how to respond to their messages anymore; Intelligent and educated ones. Regular people argument doesn't apply in here.
- hirvi74 5y agoI agree. He used to have interesting guest, and I felt the conversations were more organic. I quit watching a few years back because I did not enjoy the direction the podcast was going in.
- pohl 5y agoJoe is "regular people"? He's a sitcom actor. He makes a couple hundred million a year on podcast ad revenue alone. He only presents himself as a "regular" person because that's the demographic he's targeting.
- the_third_wave 5y agoYes, of course he's losing influence seeing as how he's haemorrhaging listeners - like me - who do not want to get Spotify only to listen to Rogan. He often has interesting guests, he has no problems trampling all over the boundaries of correctness (which I deem to be a good thing) but he should have realised that there is a large overlap between the group of people who might be interested in listening to such conversations and the group of people who do not want to feed the Big Data Beast by installing and running apps like Spotify. I listen to a lot of netcasts using my own aggregator (based on Airsonic) which can handle anything which is available through an RSS feed. Spotify does not integrate with this system which means that Spotify-only content simply will be ignored - there is enough competition on the netcast market after all.
- TedShiller 5y agoI like Joe Rogan but yeah I didn’t follow him to Spotify. Can’t wait for him to come back.
- trimbo 5y agoMaybe it's because an election concluded and all news-type media has dropped off considerably. https://thehill.com/homenews/media/551210-tv-news-ratings-online-readership-plunge-during-bidens-first-100-days https://thehill.com/homenews/media/551210-tv-news-ratings-on...
- elliekelly 5y agoJoe Rogan is not “news-type” media by any stretch of the imagination.
- anfogoat 5y agoI enjoyed listening to Joe's podcast quite a bit, and had been since around the hundredth episode, but to me podcasts always equaled audio files indexed in an RSS feed. So as far as I'm concerned Spotify does not have podcasts, and that they tout otherwise is enough for me to avoid them out of spite, Joe or no Joe. Haven't heard Joe's voice in my ear since mid 2020.
- diragon 5y agoSpotify snatching exclusive podcasts made me quit Spotify for music as well. That's a grab that I do not tolerate. This further cements the fact that IPO is a near certain death sentence for a product.
- LegitShady 5y agoits too bad the app for youtube music is so horrible. How does it still not have a horizontal mode? How many goldfish are they paying to develop that app?
- paulpauper 5y agoThis is the weakest analysis I have ever seen for an article. It's just noise. The sample size is too small to make any inference. A combination of people quarantined due to covid , the election, and BLM hype is why 2020 was such a big year. Joe Rogan is still hugely influential. His comments in 2021 about vaccines made headlines everywhere.
- towb 5y agoOther than the show changing since the move Spotify just isn't a good media player, and it's a shitty podcast app.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ssijak 5y agoLately it is getting harder to get an episode I want to listen to. 70-80% are comedian friend episodes which I have 0% inclination to listen to (I wonder how many people listen to them compared to other episodes) and then there are 10-20% guests either from MMA or boring 20x already told story about gender/vaccines/masks/invermectin/etc. And then there are 10% of interesting guests. Previously on youtube it was much better. I even enjoy listening to some quacks, like Graham Hanckok because he has interesting stories, but he does not even has that lately.
- clipradiowallet 5y agoTo me, Joe Rogan is permanently and fondly associated with the episodes of Chappelle Show with Tyrone Biggums.
- devwastaken 5y agoThat's fine. An uneducated guy bringing on other uneducated guys that talk about something as if they're experts. Joe is an "average dude" who loves his disinformation and nodding his head to whatever BS someone says. People like words, personalities, hand waving. That's not where truth comes from. Truth is a hard fought battle that doesn't come to you in a podcast. It comes in written words, proofs, and is filled with uncertainty. Actual experts dont give black and white answers, they provide the information and context. People don't like that because it's complicated.
- sk2020 5y ago> That's fine. An uneducated guy bringing on other uneducated guys that talk about something as if they're experts. I’m not sure that’s distinct from the internet commentariat here or elsewhere.
- FullKirby 5y agoI heard experts give nuanced opinions on his podcast
- devwastaken 5y agoI hear "experts" on the news too, yet they're also the source of conspiracy nuts. Why is that? Because they have no honesty, and also run many fakers.
- hospes 5y ago>> An uneducated guy bringing on other uneducated guys that talk about something as if they're experts. He often has leading scientists and subject matter experts on his podcasts. >> Joe is an "average dude"… Average dude who: - Created one of the largest English language podcasts. - Is a successful comedian who writes his own material. - Is a leading martial arts commentator and holds black belt himself. - Made $30M last year plus made $100M from the Spotify deal. I am not sure what is your metric that makes him average.
- jbverschoor 5y agoJoe who?
- lolsal 5y agoWho is Joe Rogen and why would I care?
- slickrick216 5y agoJoe Rogan confined to his bath of money doesn’t care in the slightest.
- soheil 5y agoI think 2nd guest appearances are not going to see as big of a spike in followers than the 1st in general since it's likely that the same audience who were going to follow the guest have already done so, so not sure how much of this decrease can be attributed to a platform change.
- RobLach 5y agoSure you can blame spotify but generally personality based entertainment goes in and out of vogue quite quickly.
- kiawe_fire 5y agoI noticed a similar trend with Howard Stern and others once signing on with SiriusXM. My unsubstantiated take: audio has to be ubiquitous to work. It’s somehow more commoditized than video or other mediums. If it’s a radio show / podcast, you already have your “player” of choice (AM/FM radio, or a particular mobile app) and you expect the audio to work like tuning a radio station to your syndicated show, or putting in a CD, and the player just plays it. For some reason with video streaming, we equate services like Netflix with TV networks, so exclusivity is ok. But audio apps and services don’t feel like different stations or CDs, they feel like different mediums entirely. So while Netflix is to Hulu as NBC is to HGTV, Spotify is to Apple Music as CDs are to MiniDisc.
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoIt's obvious that ratings are down, but it's still enough to make money. Here are Some recent changes I can think of that cause lower ratings, all but one are related to Spotify. Spotify is awful to use. Not live anymore. Haven't done the fight companion since the Brian Callen allegations. Too afraid to be cancelled. So many more podcasts now. Especially Tim Dillon and Flagrant2.
- EGreg 5y agoWhy is he confined to spotify? Some centralized group i restricting his rights like the music industry used to bury albums and bands in the 80s? Meanwhile: https://www.rap-up.com/2021/08/10/tory-lanez-sells-1-million-nft-albums/amp/ https://www.rap-up.com/2021/08/10/tory-lanez-sells-1-million...
- INTPenis 5y agoThe discussions about Rogans social responsibility are just silly. He's an entertainer. People need to understand that. But his influence dropping, I'm not at all surprised. I used to follow him until he moved to Spotify. Now I only catch the occasional clip on Youtube. And I've actually forced myself to endure the awful spotify UI for some special episodes like Dave Chappelle. But otherwise I'd rather avoid that mess. It's truly awful. I don't see how Spotify won anything, as some in this thread are saying. Youtube still gives you maximum exposure, and for just a little more than what Spotify charges you get essentially the same music catalogue, AND youtube premium ad free. I can't deny that's a good deal to me. I haven't watched TV since 2010, Youtube has way too much content in truth.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sureglymop 5y agoWhy are those discussions silly? He has an incredible amount of influence but he at times has for example insane conspiracy theorists on with absolutely zero considerations about how him "appearing" like a good friend to them will influence his audience. He always ponders to his guests, which makes sure that they trust him and open up. That might appear to be a good thing but it becomes a problem when you have people with insanely irrational and unscientific ideas on and don't put up disclaimers about their redderick. I'm not saying "cancel him", but I can totally understand why Spotify would want to remove some episodes... Personally I think it's sad, because he does have the conversational and interview skills to really get a lot of information out of his guests but he let his platform become a stage for insanity.
- INTPenis 5y agoHey if you don't agree with him, just don't listen. But don't deny him his self expression when clearly he represents a lot of people who can relate. Enforcing some sort of social responsibility on him is indirectly denying him his self expression.
- 5y ago
- chimen 5y agoHe left a void which is now being filled by Lex Friedman and others. Rogan doesn't even bother placing something about the podcast in title - he just names the guest which doesn't say anything to me so I dropped his show long time ago. Even went that far and send him an email regarding how frustrating it is to just listen to show after show until you find a subject that you like. What he lost with YouTube is their algorithm which kept recommending bits and pieces aligned to what the user was already watching. With Spotify he's just there as an author/podcaster - nothing on the subject of what I am currently listening - he lost the context. I placing his growth on YouTube and its recommendation engine more than anything else.
- kojeovo 5y agoThere is a few sentence description of each guest. Not in the title but extremely visible for each episode in the app
- makeitdouble 5y agoDidn't follow Rogan but have experienced a similar thing with other podcasts. I like a majority of the episodes, but I wouldn't go listening week after week powering through meh bits in hope to find the interesting nuggets. Having an algorithm filtering the feed is a god send, hopefully both for me and for the author, who in theory gets more leeway to try different kind of stuff and see what sticks.
- dwd 5y agoSince he moved to Spotify the number of guests that interest me has dropped. Not sure if his move to Houston precipitated that. One of the few recent times I've tuned in was the other day with Lex who I tend to listen to more often as his guests are way more interesting. And Spotify's recommendation engine sucks for podcasting, most of the time it only suggests ones I've already listened to.
- ymolodtsov 5y agoI've always been wondering why niche 2-people shows put elegant titles and detailed notes with chapter markets and the largest shows ever with huge production teams don't even bother.
- cratermoon 5y agoGood.
- dnissley 5y agoI have to say this seems utterly un-noteworthy. "Person whose content was free now reaching a smaller audience now that their content is behind a paywall".
- pandeiro 5y agoNot surprised this degenerated immediately into a mass ranting session about pandemic science with pretty much the entire catalog of cognitive biases and logical fallacies on display. I guess that's interesting to some, from a sociological standpoint, but for me, there's more than enough of this on literally every other social media platform. I'm interested in a discussion about the actual dynamic of spotify vs youtube dissemination and whether the claims made in the article are valid. Because the entire premise is backed by the "secondary metric" of how many Twitter followers a guest's account grew by -- this seems pretty ripe for confounding variables, like the appeal of the guest, auxiliary appearances elsewhere, the news cycle at the time overlapping with the guest's subject matter, and other things. Curious what others think of this.
- Thorentis 5y agoMaybe it's the time of day, but HN is usually good at cutting through the usual politicised stuff, and just discussing the issue at hand. At the end of the day, Spotify isn't a Podcasts platform, and nobody I know associates Spotify with podcasts. Surely somebody on Rogan's team knew this, but I suspect the money was simply too good to pass up. Imagine starting a FinTech SaaS with the sole purpose of being acquired, and then being offered $100m by a Biotech company. I'd probably take it.
- jessaustin 5y agoThere is probably something to this analysis, particularly for new listeners. (Rogan might be big enough that new listeners are less important?) Spotify has chosen not to use these other platforms to the extent that it could use them. This is an example (perhaps the canonical one?) of Ben Thompson's "strategy tax". For an individual podcast, it would be better to have something on all platforms/protocols/modalities. They want to attract Youtube viewers as well as RSS subscribers as well as everyone else. A capitalist firm like Spotify that wants to make a little money every time anyone ever listens to anything is comfortable losing a bit on every show it produces, if it can convince investors that doing so could bring about their favored apocalypse of rent-seeking. Each show is taxed to benefit the firm's long-term strategy. Spofity seems to have modeled its Rogan acquisition as a platform crossover event. Lots of loyal Rogan listeners had never installed a Spotify app, and now a certain percentage of those people have. However, the way Spofity have structured this, as a one-time thing in which Rogan no longer reaches other platforms in comparable ways, seems to limit the potential benefit of this maneuver. The reason I no longer listen to Rogan's podcast is that it is no longer an actual podcast. My players are still pointed at his RSS feed, but that thing is dead. I have no interest in using special apps published by Spotify to listen to something that used to be available in the normal way. I realize that is a fairly odd preference, but it satisfies the categorical imperative. I'm not the only person who strongly prefers to listen in a particular way. Spofity's strategy is different from that of many patronage-supported podcasts, which publish e.g. half of their episodes publicly, with ads encouraging people who would like more episodes to send money. Those podcasts are marketed in a more open way than Rogan's.
- throwawaysea 5y agoSpotify and Rogan is a key example of how centralization into walled gardens is detrimental. I enjoyed easy, uncensored access to Joe Rogan's interviews and clips from them previously. But without that ease of access, I basically forgot about him. This is despite me being a paying customer of Spotify. Spotify has also demonstrated that they cannot be trusted, neutral stewards of information ecosystems like podcasts. They've censored/deleted lots of Joe Rogan's interviews, and their left-biased progressive employees have repeatedly protested against Rogan and asked for him to be booted off the platform. There is absolutely no way I will patronize podcasts on Spotify since I don't want to hand such a group the keys to the castle.
- tejohnso 5y agoI find myself listening to Lex much more, and Joe much less. Overall, I'm very glad that the format exists, and we're able to hear from experts / academics who otherwise wouldn't have a platform to really get into the details of their work.
- pas 5y agoGoogleTechTalks was this for a while.
- Darmody 5y agoI used to see his clips on recommended and after watching some of them I would look for the whole podcast if it was interesting. Now I don't even read the name Joe Rogan if I'm not watching UFC. It's sad because I really enjoyed some of his content.
- elzbardico 5y agoSpotify is no longer the only kid in town. First I had moved to tidal because of supposedly better audio. Then one day I figured out that I already pay for prime and get prime music with it, already pay Apple’s one iCloud bundle and get Apple Music with it, so tidal also went to the cancellation hole with Spotify. Not going to have an Spotify account just to listen to Joe Rogan.
- chadlavi 5y agoGood.
- optimalsolver 5y agoJust like Howard Stern moving to satellite radio or whatever it was. Out of sight, out of mind. This is also the dilemma writers face when putting their content behind a paywall. The conversation just moves on without you.
- andrewzah 5y agoI think anyone would take that deal for $100 million. Joe's the real winner while people argue in the comments about this or that about his podcast. Clearly, having controversial guests on is fantastic for his podcast's influence. I don't think Spotify is good for podcasts in general. I much prefer to consume podcasts with my own clients and workflows. Even youtube is better since it actually works well unlike the spotify app in my experience.
- ldiracdelta 5y agoExactly. I used to enjoy Joe Rogan, but I have my podcast system and I'm unwilling to change. I'm absolutely not going to change from a working federated system via RSS/atom xml to a centralized system where the employees throw a hissy fit about crime-think. I'm sure Spotify converted many customers and at $100 million, Joe Rogan won regardless.
- Goety 5y agoHe needs more mainstream influence. Spotify does not promote itself well.
- tailspin2019 5y agoJoe Rogan moving to Spotify is like Twitter moving to requiring login. The increased friction has resulted in stopping me from consuming two things that I should have been cutting down on anyway.
- sammalloy 5y agoI agree with everything that's already been said in this thread, but I've noticed one thing that hasn't been discussed at all. I live in a rural area where network connectivity is poor at worst and intermittent at best. I spent years watching Rogan on YouTube with nothing but network problems. Watching Rogan was a chore in the previous scenario, and YouTube did not make it easy. Once Rogan moved to Spotify, I never had a single problem with network connectivity. I could use the app to seamlessly switch between audio and video, and it was easy to both find and browse previous podcasts and quickly queue them up to play or watch. I could never do this before in a poor connectivity environment, but Spotify made all of this possible.
- rchaud 5y agoYoutube automatically switches to the lowest bitrate if it detects a slow network. Was it still too slow at 360p? I used NewPipe to download the YT vids ahead of time. It has the option to download only the audio streams, so a lot of bandwidth can be saved that way as well.
- sammalloy 5y agoI should note, I was not using the YouTube app, I was using the Safari browser on my iPhone all these years. To me, it seemed like a buffering problem, even at 360p. For whatever reason, Spotify loads immediately (or at worst, within five seconds) and gives me the best experience. Thanks for the tip about NewPipe.
- DantesKite 5y agoHe can always move back to YouTube after his Spotify deal is over, no problem. Joe Rogan never started the podcast for influence. It was just him shooting the breeze with friends. It just turned out that he was also one of the best interviewers on the planet. Good on Joe. Make that money. YouTube will always be waiting.
- glitchc 5y agoGood. Rogan spouts a great deal of rubbish on topics he knows very little about. His interviews are good though, some of them. Edit: Added “some of them”
- fossuser 5y agoIt's a mistake for someone with a massive audience and their own platform to give that up. There's a reason Spotify paid him one hundred million dollars (or whatever it was) - he thought he was getting the better side of that deal, but he was wrong. What Spotify is doing is worse for users, but also worse for content creators in the long run. Giving up control of your distribution is a mistake.
- secondcoming 5y agoI'm not sure the article's method of measuring influence is valid. - It assumes Twitter use is constant and its not losing users (I've deactivated my account, even though I hardly used it). - It assumes Twitter hasn't improved bot detection since before - It assumes that the issue is with Rogan rather than the guest (maybe it could be argued that Rogan is getting 'uninteresting' guests because of a waning influence)
- kevwil 5y agoGood. Sorry, Joe, but that was a bad move. Let me know when you start podcasting again. The turf war over the commercialization of podcasting reminds me of the Internet - designed to be free and open, destined to be walled off from free use and exploited to death.
- ffggvv 5y agoeh, i’d rather have the $100m and smaller audience if i was him..
- andrewon 5y agoThe drop after switch makes sense. There's gotta to be significant number of people won't switch to Spotify just because of Joe Rogan's show. Half of them is about right. His show is just one of many in my queue. I won't go through the troubleshoot of using two apps for podcast just because of him.
- theodric 5y agoI know we're supposed to only contribute commentary that productively advances the conversation, but the thought that keeps bubbling back to the top for me is "lol noob, you sold out; you got what you asked for" ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- diebeforei485 5y agoIt's unfortunate. Some of his guests are quite interesting. I appreciated him having Abby Martin on the show. I have no idea why covid is such a popular topic on podcasts. Do people actually like hearing more about it, don't they already hear about it every day?
- LAC-Tech 5y agoHe's still a lot more influential than The Verge
- mhh__ 5y agoI have definitely enjoyed parts of his show a lot, but I genuinely think him becoming less influential (which I don't quite buy) is a good thing societally.
- bob229 5y agoWho cares
- chromejs10 5y agoGood
- bamboozled 5y agoAfter his "emergency" podcast on Ivermectin, I'd day this is likely net positive thing for society. Not a personal attack on the guy, I just think maybe all the influence is going to his head a bit.
- CoryG89 5y agoAnecdotally, for me I didn't watch it religiously, but I would watch anytime there was a guest that I liked or found interesting. I haven't watched a single show since he moved to Spotify.
- wnevets 5y agoAt some point most of his listeners will realize just how terrible he is. MMA is supposed to be his bread and butter but his takes are absolutely trash. Every fighter is a killer, every champion is the GOAT, etc.
- rob_c 5y agoSo the verge finds something preferentially biased against some right wing creator therefore something obviously unbiased... It's reminding me of the gay frogs. Some truth, with an annoying presentation that distracts from the point.
- mastrsushi 5y ago“Mickey Mouse Data Analytics: The article”
- m0zg 5y agoMaybe it's for the best. He's a comedian who doesn't know anything about anything (and freely admits this to be the case), he shouldn't really have that much "influence". $100M in the bank sure is nice, I bet.
- AlbertCory 5y agoI can't tell Mr. Rogan what to do, but I'll just quote from the wise old man, Neil Young: Ain't singin' for Pepsi, Ain't singin' for Coke, Ain't singin' for no one, Makes me look like a joke.
- jsz0 5y agoJRE has never been quite the same since YouTube stopped them from live streaming or whatever exactly went down when they switched to pre-tapes. Many episodes are evergreen but any discussion of current events is a few days behind the news now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ubermonkey 5y agoI mean, Rogan is a tool and we're better off without him having an outsized voice, but "podcasts" to me mean "platform independent." I listen to very few (no commute), but none of the ones I do listen to or seek out for long drives are confined to a single service. That seems goofy and weird, and the very act of going that route would put me off.
- BEEdwards 5y agoSame thing happened to Howard Stern when he moved to XM (or Sirrus, which ever one won that war I have no idea what's going on in the satellite radio space), moving from an open broadcast to a pay to listen will always cut you off from all but your most devoted fans and prevent a lot of organic discovery.
- blueyes 5y agoI was gonna say the same thing. It's a gilded ghetto. He's a lot richer but a lot less people know or care what he says. Rogan's going the same way. And I have to wonder whether that's really what guys like that, who built their lives around gaining fame, actually want.
- SergeAx 5y agoMost online influencers are there to convert their influence into money. (That's why I personally don't interested in influencers, it is like being interested in ads.) I heard that Joe Rogan got a serious money for his exclusive from Spotify, so his mission is accomplished, deal is done and all he has to do is to follow the letter of contract. When he needs more money - he will figure something out. Until then this is what his audience got.
- breakyerself 5y agoWell that's good
- hartator 5y agoI used to listen to Joe Rogan podcasts almost exclusively when it was on Apple podcasts. Not anymore. Shopify experience is so inferior. The thing pauses for couple of seconds every time you open it as it switches from audio to video even if you don’t want to. The new studio looks claustrophobic - not Spotify fault though. To get back to Spotify, even if you pay for premium to get rid of ads, it doesn’t! I thought something wrong with my account and never looked into it for months until I reached out to Spotify support and been told that Joe Rogan is not included! Very disappointing. Spotify also started removing controversial old podcasts from the before time! Now I have switched my routine to listen to audio books which is more random in term of content quality but at least you don’t fight the platform.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aklemm 5y agoWhat a shame. Not really. The man did a thing that was entertaining, but it hasn't been worth the flirtation with evil and the dancing around with absurd, vapid "ideas".
- rhacker 5y agoCan someone explain where I can watch Joe now? His YT videos cut off in Nov 2020.
- diebir 5y agoWhatevs. Joe Rogan, as far as I could tell is some sort of loud macho redneck type that does not have anything interesting to say. On another note, Spotify is so buggy an application I am surprised how/why anybody is using it. The most common thing is that it crashes on my iPhone. I was considering buying it, but not after discovering how bad/buggy it was.
- TedShiller 5y agoThere is a simple way to explain why going to Spotify was not good for Joe Rogan: It doesn't solve a problem. If Joe wanted to make more money and build influence, he would be much better off doing that by staying on YouTube; he'd have infinitely more options. Now, all he can do is Spotify. "Exclusive", in this case, is not a good thing. The other dilemma is that the short clips still shared on YouTube (to entice you to come over to Spotify) are by definition already the best parts of the interviews. They wouldn't use the worst bits for that.
- fruityrudy 5y agoI like listening to Joe. And I always wonder what everyone complains about. But then I heard an anti-vax rant he did that was completely ill-informed. Made me a bit sad. https://youtu.be/tiwsv51Il4k https://youtu.be/tiwsv51Il4k I think he gets a bit too high sometimes. But I still like listening to him.
- jude- 5y ago...he complained, on a widely-read website, in front of an audience of millions.
- fzzzy 5y agoJoe Rogan doesn't care about influence.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Weryj 5y agoLets not forget Spotify podcasts has injected ads for premium users. Sorry, but that's a no-go.
- jollybean 5y agoThis is worth a closer look at the material mechanics of the Spotify UI and all of the issues, because it seems from the comments this is a big deal. I wonder how much just the discoverability of content on YouTube, and pictures of people, lends to actionable interaction. How about merely just the audience size, bringing in both new listeners, but also those of us who might have thought we were 'listeners' but really we just consistently came across the content, and listened to it, more like interested random action than conscientious 'following' of a podcast. Or the various other issues with Spotify UI, or even just it's more or less audio vs. video focus (maybe people really do like seeing Joe and guests). Or the visual snippets that made nice tweets. Or possibly just a natural change in popularity not driven by anything other than a decline of a big meme. It'd really be interesting to see more comprehensive breakdown it would tell us a lot about content in 2021.
- GaryTang 5y agoI still listen to JRE for free on Spotify and I have had complete strangers strike up a conversation with me about recent episodes. I love that you can listen to episodes while the app is minimized on iOS unlike Youtube.
- ffggvv 5y agoironically think his popularity exploded right before switching to spotify as articles got spread about his big payday. as well as the election. so it’s a bit unfair to compare that time period. wonder how it compares to 2018z also wonder if podcast listening could be down if people aren’t commuting
- baybal2 5y agoWho is this Rogan?
- chemmail 5y agoSo are you telling me, a lot of people listen when it is free, and now that people have to pay, a lot less listen? STOP THE PRESSES!
- atoav 5y agoThere was a big podcast I really liked and listend 200+ episodes of. I stopped listening the day it moved to spotify exclusively and never looked back. I understand if content creators want to earn money, but podcasts are made for RSS and musicians didn't really exactly gain from the move. If you are on spotify in addition to the RSS feed: great. If you are on spotify only: You are going to regret this. What I like about the German podcasting scene is that they recognized this for the most part, and yet they live quite well from donations. They don't need spotify and this is fine.
- ymolodtsov 5y agoPodcasts on Spotify still aren't available in every country. What's even weirder, there are countries where Spotify is officially present but still has podcasts disable for local users in the app. For me there's no legal way to listen to Joe Rogan. Not that I care too much. But I'm sure there's a lot of people out there who simply can't.
- rexreed 5y agoHold up. While I don't doubt the general conclusions of the article and most of the top comments here, the data they are using to back up their conclusions come from Social Blade which is notoriously inaccurate. Using Twitter followers growth as a proxy for influence is tenuous at best.
- kadomony 5y agoI don’t see how this is a bad thing. Rogan is a self-certified moron, and all the more power to anything that is degrading populism in today’s age of empowered morons.
- ireland352 5y agoThe transition over to the Spotify platform was a decrease in user experience. Downgrade with video integration. Downgrade with search ability on audio. Buggy resume feature for both AV. I get why he did it. YouTube was doing some weird speech shit at the height of Trump and COVID. It's wasn't like the minions at Spotify didn't try. Seems like the higher ups at Spotify is giving Joe more freedom. I definitely consume less of Rogan's podcasts since the switch. But I do seek him out whenever a clip on YouTube pops up and strikes my interest.
- wanderingmind 5y agoMaybe it's just me, but I have always felt most conversations at JRE are very shallow. I think it's because he doesn't push the guests enough or provide counter arguments to their statements. I have instead liked the podcasts of Sam Harris, Lex Friedman and more recently that of Jordan Peterson.
- garfieldnate 5y agoI discovered JRE shortly before the move to Spotify, and I'm still an avid listener, but honestly Spotify just freaking sucks compared to YouTube, and I would never actively search for more podcasts to watch on the platform. The load times and video display are worse, there's no ability to read or leave comments (Joe did say he asked them to work on that), I often have to refresh the page just to get it to respond again, it loses my spot and I have to scroll through 1,000 episodes to find what I was watching again, it's clunky and slow to skip forward and backward within an episode, and possibly the most egregious issue is the lack of search for episodes within a single channel. That said, Spotify gave Joe written guarantee of creative freedom and dollar amount up front. With YouTube, every episode was subjected to demonetization or down-rank roulette, which understandably made him really nervous to be on the platform. As long as Spotify respects this creative freedom (despite complaints of some Spotify employees), I can respect Joe's choice to move. I'm even a little happy that he left YouTube for this reason. A media platform should be accountable to consequences for its repression of speech.