11 ms·
> Or maybe the whole 'if we just lock down for two weeks, this will be over' tops the list of stupidity New Zealand had 26 deaths in over a year of the pandemi
by tialaramex 5y ago
> Or maybe the whole 'if we just lock down for two weeks, this will be over' tops the list of stupidity
New Zealand had 26 deaths in over a year of the pandemic. Not 26 per 100k population. Not 26 per day. Twenty six people full stop. Because in fact "We go hard and we go early" works.
Right now they are locked down (since last week) because they had one case in their community, but of course it isn't ever one case and they knew that, since that lockdown began there are now over 100 patients linked to that single infection. Under a lockdown the people who are surprised to discover that they're infected are (mostly) bored at home, not out infecting yet more people.
I think there's a fair chance they'll beat it again, and exit that lockdown as they did earlier ones. Because elimination strategy works.
- hcurtiss 5y agoYes. For small island countries like New Zealand it works "great." This was never an option for countries like the US, or even most of Europe. Much less so for countries like India. But we'll see how it goes. If New Zealand and Australia persist in this notion that they're going to stay locked down until the virus goes away, particularly with its endemicity now inevitable, I think you will soon find vast swaths of those countries in open, violent revolt.
- abraae 5y agoI live in NZ and can assure you from the front lines of the revolt that we don't think we're going to stay locked down until the virus goes away. The game has always been to play it by ear. That's been a great call so far, we've lived normal lives for the last year while incredible scientific advances have delivered vaccines. This is a long game, and we've done well in the first quarter. I hope the politicians continue making good calls as the game goes on. Don't assume that because we locked down hard that that will always be the path forward. That's your straw man talking.
- chinathrow 5y agoI wish you well. What I feel is a real problem in the makes is that you eventually have to open up again but with not enough folks vaccinated. And suddenly, you are in a situation many other countries have right now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- account42 5y agoDefinitely a concern for countries that have been able to lock down. Taiwan also had to rush to get people vaccinated when they had an outbreak recently.
- jamiepenney 5y agoOur vaccination program is ramping up nicely, even with the lockdown they're posting record numbers. Should be done by the end of the year, and if we can get this outbreak under control we'll easily get there before the next one.
- mikedilger 5y agoWhile not disagreeing with that, I think we can continue to eliminate. During level-4, the R value is clearly lower than 1.0 meaning the infection shrinks. And the infection is small since we locked down immediately when a community case was first found. Six weeks will probably do it... so long as we don't have (a) new cases coming in through the border, or (b) infected people flaunting the lockdown rules and spreading it faster than we can contain it. Indeed, if it blows out past a couple thousand or so, we will need to pivot.
- abraae 5y agoI agree, elimination still looks a good strategy, it's too early to give it up yet. If we can punch out the current outbreak (I'd put money on it, but not too much) and get back to zero then that will re-legitimise lockdown as a strategy for a bit longer. We've got a few "open 'er up and let it rip" friends and I just don't get it. There are so many potential game changers when you are an island. If a reliable saliva-based test appeared that produced results in say 2 hours we could reduce MIQ and use waiting booths at the airport. Even if it was only 99% accurate we could pool groups of 20 into rooms together while waiting for results. So many possibilities if we continue to think critically instead of politically.
- ImaCake 5y agoA quick word on test attributes and why we still don't have a more rapid test than PCR. Tests for disease rely on two numbers: 1. "sensitivity" - the proportion of people with COVID who get a positive test 2. "specificity" - the proportion of people without COVID who get a negative test. COVID, despite the media attention, is a rare disease compared to the number of people tested. Say we have 10,000 people tested for COVID at the airport. We have 99% sensitivity and 99% specificity. And we know 100 people have COVID (1% prevalence) in this group. Our test would find 99/100 of the positive cases. But it would also find an additional 99 false positives! It also misses one true positive case. Which would be disasterous for the quarantine measures in place in Australia and NZ. In short, even a gold standard rapid test is not enough, although at 99% specificity and sensitivity it would be somewhat useful. This is a lot less intuitive than it looks. The companies pushing rapid antigen tests at the start of the pandemic would have know better, but they chose to lie to the public about this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_and_specificity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensitivity_and_specificity
- nerdponx 5y agoYou can't really look at the US and say "it doesn't work", because even the slightest restrictions were leveraged into a major political issue.
- sokoloff 5y agoAgree. I don’t think anywhere in the US did anything that could reasonably be called a lockdown. “Try to gather in groups of no more than six (at a time).” “When you need food, go to the grocery store (as often as you see fit).” Is anyone surprised that a highly contagious virus was able to escape these “lockdown” measures?
- tdfx 5y ago> I don’t think anywhere in the US did anything that could reasonably be called a lockdown. Agreed, yet people still clamor for more of the same ineffective nonsense while dousing their hands in sanitizer and erecting plexiglass barriers in front of everything. We do everything except what would make a difference: fixing indoor ventilation.
- odessacubbage 5y agothe problem is that even those halfhearted measures have proven to be economically disastrous for small to medium scale businesses and virtually everyone without a line to nearly limitless private equity. pairing the rollout of ineffective 'lockdowns' with woefully insufficient safety nets [that were even further stripped down and delayed by politicking] has effectively poisoned the public will towards any further interventions across large segments of the country. you would have been hard-pressed to even deliberately design a containment more guaranteed for failure.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoYou can't say it looking at the US, but I think it's hard to find fault with the strength of the initial lockdowns in France or Spain or Italy.
- nintendo1889 5y agoIt was an option for China. They allowed international travel but disallowed inter province travel.
- peteretep 5y agoIt worked pretty well for Thailand, a country with 3k of land borders that people can and do walk across. Delta seems to have changed the calculus though
- strken 5y agoOne guy punching a horse and Queensland putting a hundred or so bored soldiers on the border to check permits of cars that drive past is not a state of open violent revolt.
- socialdemocrat 5y agoEdit: Don’t mean to sound nasty, but this type of reasoning gets repeated so often without much criticism. It worked for China too, so don’t come with this “small countries” crap. The US is “small” relative to China. Okay… now we get the “easy in a dictatorship” response to which I offer Japan. A democracy, with relatively large and dense population, yet have had relative few cases… although I am sure an excuse can be invented for them too…
- JackFr 5y agoHmmmm. Japan, I wonder what’s happening there right now.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoJapan is having lots of problems with COVID. They are like Sweden in this regard.
- moonchrome 5y agoThey are a bunch of islands in the middle of nowhere with a population of a larger city - how is their situation applicable to any major nation in the world ?
- tialaramex 5y agoUhuh. Hawaii, an entire US state that is "a bunch of islands in the middle of nowhere" and yet somehow didn't eliminate the virus has far fewer people than New Zealand.
- schnable 5y agoDid they lockdown travel into the state like NZ did?
- ghaff 5y agoNo. There have been plenty of people traveling in and out of Hawaii all along. There were some quarantine/testing requirements at various times. But certainly not closed borders. I even looked of going there at one point but, when I looked, hotels were quite expensive.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoHawaii has the lowest coronavirus death rate per capita of any US state and is lower than the US average by nearly a factor of five.
- AussieWog93 5y agoYet it's still almost 100x the death rate of NZ, per capita.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoHawaii is still allowing tourism from the USA, I assume NZ is not allowing similar tourism. They could have locked down harder (being an island and all) but didn't probably because their economy isn't as independent as NZ's is.
- itsoktocry 5y ago>Not 26 per 100k population I know people like to think that doing the per-capita calculation puts every country on an even footing for comparison. But it's kind of silly to straight compare countries with vastly different geographies and economies, regardless of population normalization. >I think there's a fair chance they'll beat it again If they are locked down, again, 16 months into this thing, they never beat anything.
- tialaramex 5y ago> If they are locked down, again, 16 months into this thing, they never beat anything. They eliminated this virus across Aotearoa. We didn't eliminate it everywhere else (actually almost anywhere else) and infected people continued to arrive at their border, eventually one of those infections (from Australia) leaked into their community about two weeks ago. Unless your point is some purely nihilist position like "In the end nothing matters" (then why are you posting?) they beat this and now they're going to have to do it again.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoThe point is that you can't just draw a line around obvious failure modes and say they're not part of the strategy. If you compare the median global response to "we beat the virus with a single lockdown!", that sounds like an obvious winner, but it's a much more equivocal story if you compare it to "we'll be doing snap lockdowns 1-2 times a year for the foreseeable future, and even then we may need to give up on elimination if one of the lockdowns doesn't work". (As someone mentioned upthread, this shouldn't be seen as a slight against the people or leadership of New Zealand, who generally seem to understand that lockdowns weren't meant to be a one-and-done measure.)
- hsbauauvhabzb 5y agoPlease don’t blame Australia for NSW’s mistake. The rest of us are facing a similar problem due to their state governments incompetence.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoBut.. they didn't beat it. It's not endemic, it's not "one of the common colds", it's a locked down island, where noone can enter or exit freely anymore. This is like hiding in a cave, and saying that you've beat the bear outside.
- monkeynotes 5y agoMy household has had zero cases per capita. Population count and relative isolation make a huge difference. You can't directly compare NZ with places like Germany or the US.
- dongping 5y agoWhen we talk about population count, maybe China is a country worth mentioning here? The success in New Zealand seems like the elephant in the room, that the Atlantic article failed to refer to. Not to mention China.
- DangsBaldHead 5y agoNZ has no cities. Auckland, the country's largest town, consists of 4 or 5 blocks of high density "city". Wellington another 2 or 3 blocks of high density "city". Outside of those few blocks the entire country is low-rise detached apartments, quickly giving way to semi-detached housing, which quickly gives way to endless suburbia. NZ has zero density.
- agrippanux 5y agoA lot of paranormal activity for Wellington given that density
- thelandofrandom 5y agoHahahahaha. Remember, the door is voice activated
- thorin 5y agoDoes anyone really believe the reported stats for China?
- dongping 5y agoI'm not saying that Wuhan's number is 100% accurate, feel free to inflate it by 10 times. But even with the censored social media in China, words do get across, and there's no evidence of any big outbreaks like in Wuhan or New York after April last year. Virus cannot teleport from person to person, so why wouldn't NPIs like real lockdowns with full food delivery and mass testing (unlike mockdowns in some other countries) work?
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoAs others have pointed out they're able to totally control their border and quarantine every single arrival. But more importantly, how will it end for them? Australia and New Zealand are among the worst corona zealot nations. New Zealand just shut down everything over a single case and the PM told people to not even talk to each other anymore. How will they get out of this? If they looked at the facts they'd understand they will have to open up eventually, might as well do it now. Instead they're now trapped in eternal 'zero covid'.
- InvertedRhodium 5y agoGot a source on the NZ PM saying they can't talk to one another anymore?
- areyousure 5y ago"Don't talk to your neighbours." https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/covid-19-coronavirus-children-are-at-home-even-if-parents-are-essential-workers-ardern/C6BCQOAV5EJGAU3ZPVZCYE4BUE/ https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/covid-19-coronavirus-children-...
- InvertedRhodium 5y agoTo expand upon your quote: > "We ask people to stay two metres away from anyone you pass," she said. "Stay local. Do not congregate. Don't talk to your neighbours. Please, keep to your bubble." To interpret that as anything other than physical distancing measures can only be deliberate obtuseness. You can talk to anyone you want, just pick up the phone.
- nojs 5y agoYour comment is slightly out of date. The stated position of both the Australian PM and NSW state premier is that elimination is impossible, and vaccination/reopening is the goal. https://www.9news.com.au/national/coronavirus-update-we-cant-stay-in-the-cave-pm-hits-back-at-state-opposition-to-covid-normal/b73cbada-773e-4559-97f9-2ab46ae74281 https://www.9news.com.au/national/coronavirus-update-we-cant...
- tdfx 5y ago> "We go hard and we go early" works. "We go hard and we go early" works *in a small, remote island nation that is willing to hermetically seal itself off from the rest of the world.
- wozniacki 5y agoAlso, a country with a GDP the size of the U.S. state of Oklahoma mind you (New Zealand's G.D.P 204,671, Oklahoma's G.D.P. 206,058 (in USD million, 2019, according to the IMF) [1] [1] Comparison between U.S. states and sovereign states by GDP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_between_U.S._states_and_sovereign_states_by_GDP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_between_U.S._states...
- talaketu 5y agoWhat does GDP measured in Oklahomas have to do with anything?
- wozniacki 5y agoIt gives you a general idea, how significant or insignificant an economy is and also roughly how many other moving parts of the global economy it has complex gears in. And thereby how many more fold damages can result from a catastrophic shutdown of the country, something a small geographically-on-the-periphery-of-the-world nation need not worry about, to the same degree.
- socialdemocrat 5y agoYou got it all in reverse. Large countries are much less affected by this as they are more self sufficient. Small countries have far more open economies and depend far more on import and export to work. They are too small to make everything themselves.
- LAC-Tech 5y agoNZ isn't North Korea. It's not a hermit jurisdiction relying on its own internal economy. It relies a lot on trade with the rest of the world - it gets a lot of money from exports and relies a lot on imports (everything here is depressingly expensive for that reason). Hell I'm even able to connect to communicate you using internet (the exact same kind you get in Oklahoma).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vondur 5y agoAnd it seem a as soon as they start to open up, they get new infections. How many hard lockdowns will they have to have?
- inreverse 5y agoOur last level four lockdown was in April of 2020 - where are you getting your information?
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoHow many tourists did you get this year? How many local tourists went to other countries and came back?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- roody15 5y agoNew Zealand is an island.. elimination strategy would not work in many other locations
- hfdskghkj 5y ago>New Zealand had 26 deaths in over a year of the pandemic. Not 26 per 100k population. Not 26 per day. Twenty six people full stop. Because in fact "We go hard and we go early" works. We could tackle smoking and obesity similarly to similar effect.
- spoonjim 5y agoNew Zealand is not really a replicable model. It has a lot of unique properties like the combination of wealth, remoteness, culture, population density, etc. Not a lot that other countries can learn from it. Other countries could learn more from countries like Vietnam. If you want to learn how to get a basketball in the hoop reliably, you’re better off asking a regular guy than a 7 footer who will say “well just put it in.”
- archsurface 5y agoPolice state shithole.
- ButtSpark69 5y agoI look at New Zealand and see close to the opposite. A near-complete failure. They've isolated themselves from the world for nearly 2 years, and have approximately zero things to show for it. They're not significantly vaccinated (25%, what happened??) and have no plan to be able to re-open up anytime soon. It sounds harsh, but I don't see that they've done a lot other than waste 2 years of their life sitting on their hands.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]