38 ms·
I'm a huge fan of TikTok because after years of content stagnation and dullness, the internet is fun again. Especially places like Twitter and Instagram are out
by mrtksn 5y ago
I'm a huge fan of TikTok because after years of content stagnation and dullness, the internet is fun again. Especially places like Twitter and Instagram are outrage and depression inducers for me, consumed together it feels like the society is collapsing but everyone is living a perfect life at the same time.
The China thing is touchy but I want the west to beat them by being better, not by being dismissive and protectionist.
I guess by now everyone has heard of their legendary discovery algorithm so I'm not going there but recently I noticed that some of my favourite creators from the Youtube etc. are on TikTok and their material is much nicer to consume there. Why? I think this is because of the short and fast phased nature of the TikTok content. Instead of publishing 10 to 30 min videos(AFAIK Youtube encourages that, it is also good for the revenue), they put together a short video that shows the gist of the subject. They will also be much more responsive, quickly replying with short videos to the comments. It's a very dynamic place.
One exception for me is Nile Red, I love watching his 40 min chemistry videos. Actually, there are a few more YouTubers who's content works best on YouTube but I'm watching far less and I have more spare time now.
Maybe the medium is the message still holds? Maybe people are now ready to hear the message of the TikTok?
- cwkoss 5y agoIt would be really interesting if TikTok allowed users to make a sequential thread of videos, and added a scroll control to view "next video in sequence". Currently "part 2" videos are very tedious to find, if they could make a way to continue a sequence from the fyp with a simple gesture or button, I think they could seriously challenge longer form videos as well.
- mrtksn 5y agoI haven't created a TikTok video yet, so don't count on me for the details but on some videos I see a link to a playlist. BTW, I skip all multi-part videos unless there is a good reason for being multipart. Most are trying to game the system.
- Syonyk 5y ago> I think they could seriously challenge longer form videos as well. Is this like the Twitter feed readers that take what should be a blog post on an external site and stitch them back into something readable, instead of a blog post in 40 parts? There are plenty of sites that focus on long form videos and it might make sense to put long form videos there, if one wants long form video content.
- spiderice 5y ago> There are plenty of sites that focus on long form videos Youtube. It's pretty much just Youtube. They are the only player with meaningful market share. Even Facebook video is most effective at only 20-40 seconds. I would welcome any competition to Youtube, even if it means TikTok expanding.
- DLay 5y agoI’m shocked to see YouTube not even make AppAnnie’s top ten list at all. More people downloaded Twitter and Telegram over YouTube last year? Really?
- randomperson_24 5y agoI guess it comes pre installed on Android, which has a huge market share globally.
- wraptile 5y agoThere are lot of alternative youtube apps too though I can't imagine it being a big chunk of the market.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mywittyname 5y agoInitially, I'm thinking, "but that's just youtube with a slightly different presentation." But then I thought about the fact that a lot of significant developements were "just <something else> with a slightly different presentation."
- teddyfrozevelt 5y agoThey recently added playlists (they show up as yellow text with a gray highlight in the description) but the ability to make them may not have rolled out to everyone. They have notoriously slow roll outs (like with new TTS voices and the captions).
- dizzystar 5y agoThey can make a comment that says "part 2" and respond to it. Add a pin and it'll be at the top. Some creators do this, but not enough. Besides with 3 minute videos, this shouldn't be a problem anymore.
- jinguang 5y ago对应的中国内的抖音版,已经支持长视频10分钟以上,只是体验上还是不如短视频有趣。因为习惯了快餐,慢节奏的长视频让人失去耐心看完,除非它质量不错。
- madeofpalk 5y agoWhat you're describing is Quibi.
- tmaly 5y agoThere is a way to group a set of your videos by topic, they call the feature “playlists” and it was introduced in March 2021.
- tablespoon 5y ago> The China thing is touchy but I want the west to beat them by being better, not by being dismissive and protectionist. I don't think the only question is "who wins at having the most popular social network." The more concerning one is of exerting political influence through manipulative amplification/suppression (which is something the PRC has a lot of experience with). That could be both highly effective and extremely subtle and difficult to detect (e.g. activating one political tendency with relatively more call to action videos, while distracting its opposition with relatively more cat videos and relatively fewer calls to action).
- the-dude 5y agoAs opposed to US based networks?
- tablespoon 5y ago> As opposed to US based networks? There are important differences between being influenced by domestic actors, as part of a domestic political process, and being influenced by foreign actors. The latter is a far more serious threat to political independence. It's also pretty well documented that the PRC political authorities already use its domestic social networks in this way.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoYou are assuming that the person you respond to is american. He's dutch, and is regularly spied on by the US.
- tablespoon 5y ago> You are assuming that the person you respond to is american. No, I was responding with my thoughts as an American. And frankly, his comment was ambiguous enough to be open to multiple interpretations (e.g. 1. to a non-American, US-controlled networks are foreign; 2. and manipulation/propaganda happens on US-controlled networks already, so why should it be any more concerning on one from China; 3. etc.). > He's dutch, and is regularly spied on by the US. The issue I was talking about isn't spying.
- cronix 5y agoAnother thing Tik Tok does is get rid of people who are obese, queer, or otherwise the target of harassment. Their stance is it's easier to get rid of the person being made fun of or limit who can see their videos rather than the 10k people harassing them. > According to Netzpolitik, the social media company instructed moderators to find users who are “susceptible to harassment or cyberbullying based on their physical or mental condition.” These creators would then be marked with a “Risk 4” designation, meaning their videos would only be available to view in the country where it was uploaded. Company documents obtained by Netzpolitik explain TikTok’s reasoning for the ban, pointing to the fact that “bullying has been proven to cause severe emotional and physical distress, especially in minors.” > TikTok also kept a separate list of “special users” who were considered to be “particularly vulnerable.” Many of the creators on this list, Netzpolitik discovered, made videos with the hashtags #fatwoman or #disabled, or had rainbow flags and other LGBTQ+ markers in their profile. TikTok moderators marked these creators with an “Auto R,” which meant that their videos, after hitting a certain amount of views, would be banned from TikTok’s algorithm of suggested videos that appear in every user’s “For You” feed. As a result, these creators’s videos would reach a much smaller audience than the average user. For many, dreams of going “TikTok viral” and gaining notability on the platform would be squashed by the policies. https://www.them.us/story/tiktok-suppressed-fat-queer-disabled-creators https://www.them.us/story/tiktok-suppressed-fat-queer-disabl... > Social video network TikTok apparently limited the reach of people with disabilities, including facial disfigurement and Down syndrome. According to Netzpolitik.org, which spoke with a source inside the company, the policy was supposed to protect users with a high risk of bullying. In practice, however, it apparently amounted to discrimination — and the problem was compounded by moderators who needed to make snap decisions about users’ physical and mental traits. https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/2/20991843/tiktok-bytedance-platform-disabled-autism-lgbt-fat-user-algorithm-reach-limit https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/2/20991843/tiktok-bytedance...
- cma 5y ago> TikTok apparently limited the reach of people with disabilities, including facial disfigurement and Down syndrome. Hollywood and Youtube Originals presumably do this too, based on proportion of actors with these issues compared to what you see out and about.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> Especially places like Twitter and Instagram are outrage and depression inducers for me, consumed together it feels like the society is collapsing It's been interesting to watch the steady decline of Reddit and Twitter since they launched. They've always had a significant amount of doom-and-gloom clickbait headlines, but in the past it was far easier to filter out the bad and follow subreddits or Twitter people with high signal to noise ratios. Now, Reddit feels like a lost cause for anything other than consuming endless outrage headlines. r/popular is full of blatant misinformation that could be disproved with a simple Google search or outrage-bait headlines that make every event sound like the end of the world. Even the previously useful subreddits I subscribed to have been inundated with angry, angry people who manage to turn everything into an argument or relate it back to politics somehow. I have to wonder if TikTok is simply enjoying the early days where the fun, light-hearted content still outweighs the intentionally rage-baity content. There does appear to be vast amounts of misinformation and angry content on TikTok, but it hasn't yet flooded the platform to a degree that it's unavoidable. I feel like we watched a similar rise and fall of Clubhouse during the pandemic. The early days were full of people with genuine curiosity and good intentions about socializing, but it quickly devolved into lowest common denominator content. I haven't opened Clubhouse for months, but the last time I opened it I remember scrolling through endless "how to get rich" rooms that were keyword stuffing popular terms until I just gave up on the platform altogether. Maybe TikTok's algorithm and model can stave off the Eternal September problem, but I feel like it's only a matter of time until the signal to noise ratio drops below most people's thresholds for decent content.
- slownews45 5y agoAgreed - HN as well has been trending towards the outrage / doom model. The coverage of Apple just rips the worst articles (ie, apple committing child porn felonies), and the headlines are often wildly overboard (imply all Google workers going on strike etc). TikTok has avoided that somehow - def more fun and interesting there - I do keep on getting exposed at times to somewhat weird idea, but a bit less of the yell in your face while clapping kind of stuff you see elsewhere so they are doing something interesting with their algorithm.
- rjh29 5y ago
- em500 5y agoI agree that many Youtube videos are tedious and needlessly dragged out, probably caused by focussing on time spent as KPI. Too many Youtube videos nowadays give a strong vibe of creators being made only for the money. For TikTok I feel it's still at the stage where the makers, above all else, just want to be seen. But maybe it's only a matter of time before it devolves into aggressive monetization.
- danbolt 5y agoI feel like Vine had a lot of that quirky, comedic energy. It's a shame that Twitter decided to discontinue it. I sometimes still watch Vine compilation videos when I want to feel nostalgic.
- varrock 5y ago> For TikTok I feel it's still at the stage where the makers, above all else, just want to be seen. This sounds like what YouTube used to be like. I wasn't around much for it, but I can only imagine how fun it must have been in the early stages.
- IkmoIkmo 5y ago> I agree that many Youtube videos are tedious and needlessly dragged out, probably caused by focussing on time spent as KPI. Too many Youtube videos nowadays give a strong vibe of creators being made only for the money. Yep, and honestly I can't blame them. But at this point every video I watch I immediately press '1' to skip to 10% of the video as a start, then correct if I went too far or if I haven't gone far enough. The first 10% is usually spent on an intro which is entirely useless to 90% of the audience. e.g. there'll be a video called 'How to add a screen protector to your phone' of 10 minutes, at least the first minute will be a talking head asking if you remember how scared you get every time you drop your phone because it may have cracked the screen, explains how much that sucks, then explains that screen protectors reduce the chance of that blablabla. Stuff everyone knows, which is why they probably bought one, and after wondering how to put it on their phone looked up your video and clicked it... then after they explained the problem, they'll tell you that in this video they'll be providing an answer. It's okay once but it gets super tedious. Imagine for every search on Google you first get a minute of speech on what the typical reasons were that you likely searched for this, and that this google search is going to provide you with possible answers... That having been said, I see this on TikTok too. There'll be some music playing and a 'wait till the end' comment, and you're just staring at your screen and nothing happens until quite a bit later, and it's often disappointing too. At least on YT you can skip through easily.
- lovegoblin 5y ago> Maybe the medium is the message still holds? Was there ever any question? Your whole comment here is a perfect demonstration.
- gregkerzhner 5y agoCurious - does TikTok censor content that China would find sensitive, like the existence of Taiwan or pro Hong Kong protest content?
- saddlerustle 5y agoIt did in 2019: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/sep/25/revealed-how-tiktok-censors-videos-that-do-not-please-beijing https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/sep/25/revealed-...
- alexfromapex 5y agoRe: the China thing, is Instagram's Reels not a better alternative? Where you know your data is only being spied on by non-totalitarian regimes?
- phatfish 5y agoThe US has far more influence over most western countries than China ever will. I'm much more worried about about what the US can do with all the data it collects on its allies than what China does. Of course, I'd rather my government were to ensure the personal data of its citizens never leaves its boarders (similar to Germany). But that's far too much to ask of the UK.
- stanislavb 5y agoYou are addicted (most probably). Not exactly "a huge fan" (most probably). It shouldn't sound like blaming or something. It's just that TikTok has proven having a more addictive algo than FB.
- mrtksn 5y agoAccording to my iPhone’s screen time stats, it doesn’t look like an addiction. I averaged less than 30 min/day on TikTok. Twitter is over 2 hours. I would be on TikTok before sleep, sometimes for over an hour but not everyday. It doesn’t induce FOMO.
- tomcooks 5y agoWhat's fun about stolen videos with a selfie introduction, happy dances and lipsync? Does tiktok offer anything else? Sincerely, the no fun guy
- theshrike79 5y agoYes. Sincerely, one of the old farts who had the same opinion, but kinda likes TikTok now.
- emodendroket 5y agoI got sick of it in like a week, but clearly my preferences aren’t representative.
- tshaddox 5y agoIsn’t the discovery algorithm something that any media network could easily adjust to either favor the entire community of creators or to favor the network itself (perhaps by favoring creators with more lucrative advertising deals)? I would expect fairly new networks to adjust their algorithm towards the former to attract creators, then eventually tweak it towards the latter to please investors/shareholders/advertisers.
- durpleDrank 5y agoThat's crazy that you mentioned Nile Red. I coincidentally just finished watching his tiktok and thought "boy am I glad I didn't have to sit through 40 minutes of beaker swapping just to see the end result". I much prefer his tiktok channel over the youtube channel.
- mrtksn 5y agoInteresting, for me his long videos have ASMR effect. I also enjoy following his thought process, which is absent on TikTok.
- dragosmocrii 5y agoI've been using Coub since before TikTok was around for feel-good content.
- ren_engineer 5y agoTikTok's algorithm is just pre 2017 YT and FB cranked up by 100X. For some reason the media hasn't gone after TikTok yet for pushing people into "echo chambers" but they basically just feed the most engaging content with no breaks on the train. I read an article about the parent company and they have one of the most popular news app in India as well despite none of the engineers being able to read what content is being pushed to the top, they just let their machine learning push the most "engaging" content, which is basically stuff that is controversial, creates anger, etc.
- buryat 5y ago> they basically just feed the most engaging content with no breaks on the train. this is simply not true, i regularly get videos with less than 100 views, and a few videos i published got a few hundred views.
- sen 5y agoNew stuff is scored well too at first, so the algorithm can "test" and see what kind of traction the post gets. If it hits a certain score for traction then it's boosted more, and if it doesn't then it's buried. It's pretty much purely about the popularity curve of each post. The more it drives engagement the more it's boosted. All hail the algorithm.
- ren_engineer 5y agoevery video starts with 0 views, new videos all get pushed to small sample groups and the ones that get the most engagement in terms of watch time and other factors then get pushed to larger groups that's the point, the content that doesn't engage users doesn't get promoted. TikTok isn't going to push a boring video to millions of users
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoDespite this claim tiktok seems like it pushes some the least outrage machine type stuff. At least my feed is filled with interesting folks. HN is going down the road too now of the google is horrible, apple is horrible, facebook is horrible type headlines. I don't necessarily disagree - but... boring? Repetitive? There are never any positive suggestions any more (ie, here's how apple should screen for CASM). It's just pure outrage factory in some cases. Luckily for me at least HN still has some "boring" content with lots of what seem like smart interesting folks posting - keeps me coming back :)
- dTal 5y ago>the short and fast phased nature of the TikTok content Ahh, so it's Twitter for video... is this good? It's my impression that there's a growing consensus that Twitter's content length restriction optimizes for shallow hot takes and angry mobs.
- ehsankia 5y agoI don't think that's a rule, I think Twitter's length restriction has lead to quite a few good things too. Restrictions in general are a great way to motivate creativity. Of course there are limits to this. There are times where a 40m video or a proper 10 page blog post are more appropriate.
- cerved 5y agoremember Vine?
- WaitWaitWha 5y ago> outrage and depression inducers for me, consumed together it feels like the society is collapsing but everyone is living a perfect life at the same time. I am sorry to hear this. Are you comparing yourself to yourself of yesterday, or are you comparing yourself to the fictional characters of others on social media?
- meowtimemania 5y agoIf I use tiktok regularly it makes me feel depressed. For me it's best just to limit social media as much as possible.
- mrtksn 5y agoIt’s not really about me comparing. On Twitter (and reddit) the world is crumbling, what the society has become, WW3 must be imminent, anything is futile, very organization is evil, everyone is angry, and there are some people that are stupid beyond comprehension that that makes me think I shouldn’t even bother. The same old nonsense would keep be parroted repeatedly. Then I look at Instagram, everyone is having a perfect life. By perfect I don’t mean a life I would like to have, I too go to vacations and restaurants, what I mean is a curated perfection of what life is “supposed to be”. It’s just dull. When combined with TikTok It makes me feel like the society dried up. It’s like When people don’t do evil things and not yelling they do extremely mundane stuff out of the mill.
- BurningFrog 5y agoTikTok is the only genuinely happy and positive place on the internet!
- bamboozled 5y agoYesterday a friend posted a funny post about corona virus and getting her vaccine, she said something like, “I imagine I shoved much worse things in my body, it wasn’t so bad after all.” With a funny accompanying photo. She is in Australia where there is a pretty big campaign underway to improve the image of vaccines with younger people. Anyways, it was mostly unreadable because Instagram had put a massive warning from the WHO about how important vaccines are. I understand the intention was positive but it was also kind of ironic because it was a pro-vaccine post, it was also a bit of fun. The fun and good will was stolen.
- ehsankia 5y agoFunnily enough, the most fun content on Twitter, reddit and instagram these days are repost of TikToks. One very bold and interesting move by TikTok which I believe is a huge reason for their success is allowing videos to be downloaded as mp4 by default and shared on any platform. Youtube et al would never allow that, which is why Reels and Shorts will never succeed. Every time I browse through TikTok, I share dozens with my friends through all sorts of channels. Every time I try Shorts, I get a shitty youtube video link and I honestly don't want to spam people with Youtube links...
- manojlds 5y ago> The China thing is touchy but I want the west to beat them by being better, not by being dismissive and protectionist. That is what everyone thought when opening up trade with China - make it as a reason to make the country more open and move away from dictatorship.
- afterburner 5y ago> One exception for me is Nile Red, I love watching his 40 min chemistry videos I have dozens of "exceptions" like this on Youtube, slowly accumulated over years. A lot of the content on TikTok is being funded by TikTok themselves. If this is sustainable I suppose it could keep going forever, but I wonder if the way Youtube turned out in the long run has an inevitable monetization reason behind it.
- nirui 5y ago> the internet is fun again My opinion is, things happened on the Internet are mostly the reflections of what happened in the real world, +amplified. You got people from all the corners and they all got different backgrounds. The common is probably that they know how to buy reliable&comfortable keyboards. During the years, in China, Chinese companies has developed some sophisticated strategies to allow them to grow and sometimes thrive under the rules that should have killed them. One of such strategy is to provide only fun and nothing else. Imagine one day, George Carlin come back to life, expect this time, he only tells fun jokes, jokes makes nobody angry, jokes that only generate laugh. Of course it will be pleasant, even become a "place to escape to". I believe the word here is tittytainment (https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/tittytainment https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/tittytainment). --- Of course, platforms such as Twitter, YouTube and Facebook has problems of their own. Those big techs are trying to do something that they are completely incapable of while trying to make money out of it. Moderating is hard, they just can't do it, even with their discriminating stupid ideas such as keyword scanning and profile rating. I have this feeling, that is in the future, the Internet will become circlized -- Communities will be small, specific and private, just like those in the real world. Of course, few "Town Squares" will still exist, where talks there probably remain toxic.
- mrtksn 5y agoThe fun I mean isn’t only about entertaining me to death, there are plenty of thought provoking creators too. History, cosmology, math, philosophy - TikTok has it all.
- josephcsible 5y ago> The China thing is touchy but I want the west to beat them by being better, not by being dismissive and protectionist. The problem is that China doesn't play fair, so if the west plays perfectly fair against them, we won't beat them even though we're better.
- metrue 5y agoDefine fair.
- Wingman4l7 5y agoLet's start with low standards -- say, labor rights. Most Western countries cannot be competitive in manufacturing because of this differential.
- mrtksn 5y agoI’m not concerned about wellbeing of China but about the future of the West, simply because I am European. Quality of our products decline rapidly when they are not optimized for our needs but the needs of the country to compete with China. What terrifies me the most is becoming like China to compete with them(Where every individual msu provide for its country and not the other way around). I was shocked when TikTok was almost banned in the USA and people were rallying for it because China is banning US social media. Please don’t become China. If the US becomes like China, I am afraid Europe will follow and the world will be dominated by the Chinese way of life where individual rights and freedoms are limited in the name of national security.
- wraptile 5y agoI'm not sure if I'm surrounded by an algorithm bubble but content on TikTok is just so wholesome. It's really refreshing!
- b0rsuk 5y agoI think TikTok will figure a way to cram advertising into 60 seconds.
- yason 5y agoI think this is because of the short and fast phased nature of the TikTok content. Instead of publishing 10 to 30 min videos... Thanks, you just revalidated my opinion. I had vaguely understood TikTok to be more transient in communication, with less substance, but I never bothered to find out myself. However, I had slowly grown an inkling of curiosity whether there might be something in there in TikTok, actually. You just saved me an hour of eventually signing up and seeing it for myself. You see, it's exactly the 30-90 minute videos from good people, that I like on Youtube... My kind of fun, I suppose.
- peoplefromibiza 5y ago> I think this is because of the short and fast phased nature of the TikTok content. > they put together a short video that shows the gist of the subject not to sound dismissive, but what I read here is "Tik Tok algorithm is better at exploiting people's attention span issues"
- andreyk 5y agoTo be honest, I feel like Twitter, Reddit, Instagram, etc. are all a case of how you use it, it's not intrinsically that bad. And wrt short videos on TikTok, it's great that you enjoy the format, but I also think longer form videos such as on YouTube have a lot of value. TLDR I think TikTok is making 'the internet fun again' due to its novelty, Instagram, YouTube, Twitter all still have fun on there but as a byproduct of aging.
- kwanbix 5y agoFor me being controlled by China is a huge no. I am from a third world country, so neither USA, Europe, etc. But I don't like the totalitarian way of China. And before somebody thinks I have something against the Chinese people, my best man and best friend is Chinese. This is against the Chinese government's totalitarian way, not against the people.
- tmaly 5y agoIn my limited experience making videos teaching kids how to code, they prefer the shorter videos. But there is an age problem on TikTok like YouTube, your likely only to reach age 13-24 even if your educational content is targeted age kids under 13.
- didntknowya 5y agoi've actually seen far more diverse and niche creators on tik tok. their algorithm also promotes them if you show interest in those kinds of videos. youtube used to do a decent job but lately is more focusing on showing viral or promoted/paid videos. along with videos with 30second ads or useless intros, it's no wonder people are flocking to shorter form vids.