14 ms·
Atlantic Ocean currents weaken, signalling big weather changes: study
- scoofy 5y ago>Other climate models have said the AMOC will weaken over the coming century but that a collapse before 2100 is unlikely. And, lets bury the lede of why no one will care about this unless they are already on board for fighting climate change.
- zamalek 5y agoExactly. Just like nobody cares about 1C. It's amazing that one specific party is ramming in amendments against green energy right now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _Microft 5y agoI'm not sure I understand correctly. Do you want to say that the author unnecessarily relativized what he wrote about so far or that the last sentence is the actually interesting part and everything else was sort of a preface (which seems to be what "burying the lede" means [0], from what I can tell (as non-native speaker)) [0] https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/bury_the_lede https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/bury_the_lede
- scoofy 5y ago"Bury the lede" here was used semi-ironically. The article reads like something dramatic that we should be concerned about. However, the effects are not felt for 80+ years, so, presumably, that concern will evaporate for most people alive today, as they will certainly not experience these externalities. Thus at the end, the click-bait nature of this article is revealed, as the author notes at the end, that all this dire concern will simply not influence the vast majority of decisions, as concerns about climate change have for the last 30 years. I use "bury the lede" ironically as someone who read this article as something that may, finally, change the idiotic production and development patterns we've been following in the face the climate change threat, when instead, the real part of the story is that, no, no one will care.
- 11235813213455 5y agoI'm totally aware climate won't have time to deteriorate enough for my lifetime, but for me it's like a duty to minimize my environment footprint, I'm really close to nature, I eat foraged fruits (figs! currently) and not polluting (bike, local food, minimal consumption/buying) is like a nature bro-code that I can't break. Picking up plastics wastes is one of my ways to thank nature for its food, I know it sounds maybe "spiritual" for you, but it's really my mentality, and I live right inside a place of over-consumption (French code d'azur), so I'm a bit like a marginal there, so you're right in sating "almost no one will care", but I hope more people will see the point for such a lifestyle (healthy, simple, happy, and environment-scalable)
- scottLobster 5y agoThere is nothing scalable about eating foraged fruits/food. Modern populations would starve without modern agriculture
- 11235813213455 5y agoThere are many ways to eat more or less local food, via producers. If you take France for example, it could easily be self-sufficient in fruits/vegetables (currenly it's not because of how they destroyed the beautiful old agriculture (orchards, permacultures) to grow intensive monocultures of corn and things for industrial derived products instead (they are less efficient by yield/surface, and much more demanding in resources, more polluting, creates more erosion, kill life in the soil,..). Eating mostly plant-based food is definitely scalable https://ourworldindata.org/land-use-diets https://ourworldindata.org/land-use-diets
- qsdfgd 5y agoNews flash! Population setup to be reliant on current system will need to change to use different systems.
- gdubya 5y agoGood work! Keep at it. You're not alone.
- MauranKilom 5y agohttps://xkcd.com/2278/ https://xkcd.com/2278/
- steve76 5y agoJust wait 100 years. While you do that, give me all your money. I'm busy doubling the murders. Sure, you will starve and freeze to death, but hey, I got a private island child rape dungeon to run.
- macintux 5y agoOther threads today: - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28085342 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28085342 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28078575 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28078575 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28082887 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28082887
- swader999 5y agoObligatory shout out to The day after tomorrow.
- ben_w 5y agoPlease don’t. Fiction isn’t evidence, and there are too many people who don’t want anyone to believe in reality who will mock those who are trying to create solutions to the real problems as if the fiction is the only thing which exists.
- swader999 5y agoBecause science fiction never becomes science fact?
- hh3k0 5y agoBeen a while since I've seen someone quote Fox Mulder.
- ben_w 5y agoMainly because of the reasons I just gave. Also because even though stopped clocks are right twice a day, you shouldn’t use them for timekeeping — Fiction can be satire, or have a social message, or be hard science to give a narrative explanation to confusing-but-real physics, but it can also be Harry Potter, The Hobbit… or the wildly implausible specific events and timescales in The Day After Tomorrow: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Day_After_Tomorrow#Political_and_scientific_criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Day_After_Tomorrow#Politic...
- chasd00 5y agoAll the climate change i hear about is a change for the worse. Are there any places on earth where the change will be for the better? We've had pretty mild summers in TX for the past 5 or so years. If that's due to climate change then great, i'll just live here.
- crackercrews 5y agoYes, many more people die of cold than of heat. Global warming will likely save a couple hundred thousand lives per year in this regard. [1] 1: https://www.wsj.com/articles/climate-change-natural-disasters-ahr-river-flood-germany-wildfire-risks-11628177742 https://www.wsj.com/articles/climate-change-natural-disaster... edit: added "in this regard". Did not mean to suggest that we know how all of the implications of global warming pan out.
- IntrepidWorm 5y agoAt the cost of horrific hurricanes in the tropical and subtropical regions. Locally there may be effects seen as beneficial, but globally it's looking to be a downhill slide.
- takeda 5y agoA lot of people who also think about it politically forgetting that it will also increase migrant crisises. As things get unhabitable people will be migrating. This will apply to the southern border of US.
- crackercrews 5y agoGP acknowledged that there are many bad things but asked if there were also good thing. I was only answering that question. I was not claiming that it is good on balance.
- soperj 5y agohasn't there actually been less horrific hurricanes instead of more? There's been one cat 5 that's hit the US since 2005.
- throwaway888abc 5y agoThere is movie about this. Watched few days back, surreal to see the headline on Reuters. The Day After Tomorrow (2004) https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0319262/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0319262/ 2 minutes summary - trailer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ku_IseK3xTc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ku_IseK3xTc
- eganist 5y agoWorth noting that TDAT took the concept of the AMOC collapsing and turned it into one of the most absurdly unscientific science-based films short of Armageddon. But it was pretty entertaining if you could find a way to stay plugged into the movie and not feel disenchanted by the concept of polar cyclones icing things with tropospheric air. Still, there was that initial kernel of truth to it, which is what we're reading about now. (not a climate guy; I'm probably getting some parts of this wrong)
- hindsightbias 5y agoJames Burke was doing it 1989: After the Warming: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RfE8wBReIxw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RfE8wBReIxw
- awb 5y agoFrom Amazon's info about the movie: > Twentieth Century Fox invited a group of scientists to preview this movie, to test their reactions to the "science" used in it. None of the scientists were impressed with what they say, although most conceded that the movie was enjoyable nonsense. > The consultation by N.A.S.A. scientists was requested before the filming of this movie, but N.A.S.A. stated that the events in this movie were too ridiculous to actually occur, and denied the request.
- sn41 5y agoThat's really funny. It almost reads like The Onion.
- spideymans 5y ago>If the AMOC collapsed, it would increase cooling of the Northern Hemisphere, sea level rise in the Atlantic, an overall fall in precipitation over Europe and North America and a shift in monsoons in South America and Afria, Britain's Met Office said. Have the other major climate models accounted for this? Most I've seen have predicted rapid warming in North America. Not sure how to reconcile the difference. Perhaps the cooling effect is more concentrated over the oceans and coasts?
- tuatoru 5y agoNorth America is a minor fraction of the northern hemisphere. Yes, models have consistently predicted warming and drying of the western US at least since I was running climateprediction.net HadCM3 models (through BOINC) in the 00s: the return of the Great American Desert, basically everywhere west of the Mississippi and south of British Columbia. Secondly, the cooling is an average, and relative to the situation without collapse of the AMOC. In most places, it still gets hot; but in Northern Europe, not so much. It even cools relative to the situation in 1900, IIRC. And yes, you are right about the location. The visible part of the AMOC is called the Gulf Stream, and it's the reason London does not have the same climate as Labrador.
- Teknoman117 5y agoMaybe it's a bad idea to be currently thinking about buying a house in southern California. It's just so depressing. No one cares, no one is willing to do anything about it. All the politicians say that it'll get fixed at some point in the future (i.e. after their careers) so that their current donors don't get mad. You also have the people who see the evidence for a warming climate, and just say "well that still doesn't mean we humans have anything to do with it". Even if it was a completely natural process, the result is going to be bad for us. We should do something.
- tuatoru 5y ago> We should do something. Oh, we (the global "we") will, eventually. It's just that the incentives for politicians are to let crises get bad before acting, so that people notice them and remember them. No-one (well hardly anyone) remembers people who stopped a catastrophe from happening in the first place. For example, Stanislav Petrov ought to have a statue in every town in the world.[1] But "who's he?" is what you get when you mention him. In the case of climate change, when the effects are bad enough for politicians to act, their actions will be draconian but ineffective. I can't offer any Disney ending to the story, but we must carry on anyway. It won't be the end of the world, just a much worse future than we might have had. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov
- bilekas 5y ago> If the AMOC collapsed, it would increase cooling of the Northern Hemisphere, sea level rise in the Atlantic This seems somewhat counter productive, if the northern hemesphere is cooling, how would that result with sea levels rising? Or they're not related ? This really seems strange, would a new `current` not naturally establish based on the temperature relocations ?
- laurent92 5y agoAnother funny item is, icecaps attract water by gravity, so if they melt, sea would lower by ~7m around the caps, and rise around the tropics. Anyway, with so many parameters and effects, I don’t venture into predictions anymore ;)
- tuatoru 5y ago> This seems somewhat counter productive I'm guessing you mean counterintuitive. That's one of the great things about the scientific method, that it tells you things you never would have guessed. > how would that result with sea levels rising? The Gulf Stream (part of the AMOC) brings warm water north, Evaporation happens (and the evaporated water rains out over land, where some is absorbed or flows south). The remaing sea water on the surface is now saltier and denser so sinks. Without the AMOC, the surface water is less dense. The local mean sea level rises due to gravitational effects. Precipitation also happens more over the sea, freshening the surface sea water. Fresh water is most dense (compact) at 4 degrees Celsius. Salt affects this, but the less salt there is, the smaller the effect. I guess when you crunch the numbers you get the result they state. > would a new `current` not naturally establish Last I checked, some years ago, I think it was believed that no new large-scale overturning current would establish for some thousands of years, which means the sea stratifies (settles into non-mixing layers), with a top relatively fresh and light layer over dense anoxic deeps.
- bilekas 5y agoThat's both crazy interesting and terrifying.. Thanks for clearing it up!
- jb1991 5y agoWasn't this a big part of An Inconvenient Truth, how global warming could actually usher in a new ice age or something like that?
- typon 5y agoIt's depressing to think that when that documentary came out, the general reaction of the public was ambivalence to outright laughter. Al Gore really was a visionary, even if he was 30 years late compared to the climate scientists.
- throwawayboise 5y agoAl Gore is a hack. Look at the way he lives. He doesn't walk the walk. He's just a publicity hound.
- airstrike 5y agoYou've just described virtually every single politician.
- jessaustin 5y agoGore hasn't run for anything in decades, so he can't really use that excuse.
- freen 5y agoLook at that serf, decrying feudalism! Such a hypocrite, participating in it! If you are anti-slavery, yet eat chocolate, I have bad news for you.
- moosey 5y agoAppeal to hypocrisy and name calling. Every statement you made was either logically fallacious or just verbal abuse.
- AuryGlenz 5y agoThats’s funny, Florida isn’t underwater and Mt. Kilimanjaro still has snow. That movie was nothing more than modern day, “the end is nigh” doomsaying. Is man made global warming real? Almost certainly, but it’s hard to call a documentary visionary when basically none of its predictions have panned out.
- yosito 5y agoTL;DR this article is about a model, which differs from many other models. It is not about new evidence or a dramatic event that has been recorded.
- Deadsunrise 5y agoSo the only thing to do is keep emissions as low as possible. The likelihood of this extremely high-impact event happening increases with every gram of CO2 that we put into the atmosphere.
- blueblisters 5y agoIt's unlikely we will be able to achieve our emissions targets. We need a combination of CO2 scrubbing, non-intermittent renewables, and even geoengineering to restore Earth's energy budget.
- brendanmc6 5y agoBefore any of that we need a heavy carbon tax. "We" being every developed country. A tall order... but absolutely vital.
- disgruntledphd2 5y agoI think carbon border adjustment taxes by the EU and US would probably be enough to get started.