18 ms·
Who Owns My Name?
- jeezzbo 5y agoA recursive signatory deriving root ID Rights + data use under control of people directly fixes this.. a process that repeats is a requirement to prevent second-class process from deriving system outcomes no longer produced "of, by, for" people, Individuals All, as root dependency of accurate governance in a civil Society. Recursive Signatory: https://www.moxytongue.com/2021/07/recursive-signatory.html https://www.moxytongue.com/2021/07/recursive-signatory.html
- ekster 5y agoThis reads like some kind of Sovereign Citizen / Time Cube babble.
- jeezzbo 5y agoThen you didn't read, and/or don't understand recursive idea.. a process that repeats. CS didn't come into existence until 1950's, so lack of process integrity for digital ID/Data Rights shouldn't be surprising, but structure yields results, not literature. Might want to get out of mass media rags too.. "Sovereign Citizen" is anarchistic, this is about structural integrity of a civil Society using accurate administrative precedence. Functional literacy required.. research "Self-Sovereign Identity" for more..
- ekster 5y agoYes I live in the EU where we have SSI, I was more referring to all the magical and fuzzy thinking surrounding it on that page.
- jeezzbo 5y agoAh, EU.. SSI is American concept.. recursive signatory is too, represents data structure "of, by, for" people. Foreign concepts in EU don't quite translate same in that admin context. Regardless EU efforts remain in tact, as Human Rights don't come from database.. thus EU chasing SSI accuracy.
- mcguire 5y agoThis is getting more Time Cube by the comment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- GoodJokes 5y agoShe has made her whole career about this event. I don’t blame her, but she is now fully in the game too.
- teddyh 5y agoThe answer to the literal question is simple. Other people use your name, not you, so the name belongs to other people. Render unto Caesar, etc. Your name refers to, not your identity (whatever that is), but the idea of you in the heads of other people.
- ectospheno 5y agoI feel like your answer not only ignores the entire premise of the article but also throws fuel on the power differential fire discussed within.
- tiahura 5y agoHe’s providing the unavoidable answer that the author feels is unfair - your reputation doesn’t belong to you, it belongs to everyone else. She believes it’s unfair because powerful people are able shape hers. I suppose the alternative is to have our reputation determined by unbiased Facebook factcheckers.
- adjkant 5y agoSo are you against all defamation lawsuits? This is more or less just an extension of that train of thought: people deserve to not have their reputation ruined unfairly by powerful structures. There's a big difference between gossip of people you know and a Hollywood movie.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Supermancho 5y agoThis is so poorly written, I'm not even sure what it's trying to communicate. This seems to be a bunch of ideas, events, and themes thrown together to try and elucidate some sort of response regarding a travesty of justice and a movie. I fail to see how this is worth reading, by anyone.
- podric 5y agoShould there be a way to trademark your own name in order to prevent its misuse in creative works? That way, film studios should have to pay a licensing fee to have your name anywhere in the film or its marketing material. It's strange to think that fictional characters often have more protection and control over the use of their name than real people.
- briffle 5y agoThat would quickly be abused to silence critics as well. Imagine if Brock Turner trademarked his name, and went after anyone discussing his story. Not to mention, your name is not unique. I know of at least 2 other people in the US with the same first and last name as me.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> Imagine if Brock Turner trademarked his name That's a separate and interesting discussion itself, IMO. On the one hand, how do you have sympathy for someone who does what he did? On the other hand, do we not believe in rehabilitation, redemption, or anything like that? It is getting easier to believe that the mania over Brock Turner has led to a disproportionate response. And to go against the mob is to risk becoming a pariah yourself. When the mob is the size of the Internet, this seems pretty scary.
- wonderwonder 5y agoI agree with this. I have no idea if the guy was a terrible person or made a terrible decision in the moment and did what he did. Either way he deserved a punishment greater than he received. With that said he is portrayed in the media and social media as if he is the second coming of Hitler. A ton of people do far worse things and are allowed to continue with their lives after serving their time. If people are not allowed a chance at rehabilitation (within reason, I think some crimes are unforgivable, but not his) then we are a lesser society.
- handelaar 5y ago"Rehabilitation" usually comes after an appropriate criminal punishment being issued and received, not before. That reasonable people think that getting just twelve weeks in jail for his crimes -- which he at no point admitted -- is an offensive undersentencing in no way justifies their description as a "mob".
- seriousquestion 5y agoThis is one of those cases where the news cycle and court of public opinion spiraled out of control, never to be corrected. Imagine how surreal and frustrating that must be? And she makes a good point about how these things get named: Who had the power in the relationship between Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky? The president or the intern? It matters what you call a thing. Calling that event the “Lewinsky Scandal” fails to acknowledge the vast power differential, and I’m glad that more people are now referring to it as “the Clinton Affair” which names it after the person with the most agency in that series of events.
- iratewizard 5y agoI think the big difference with the Lewinsky scandal is two things: everyone knows who Clinton is, so "the Clinton Affair" is not as precise; and Monica Lewinsky was not an innocent victim.
- ghaff 5y agoIs the direct connection actually explicit in the film somehow? (e.g. "based on the Amanda Knox saga") My impression, not having seen the film, is not. Usually, when there's a fictionalized novel/film based on a real world person (well, outside of someone really famous like JFK), it's usually obvious to everyone and all the reviews will mention it but the work will often explicitly disclaim any connection to actual people and events. Not much anyone can or should be able to do about that.
- OskarS 5y agoIt’s a really powerful article, and it’s hard to argue with any of it. What a nightmare it must be to have what happened to Amanda Knox happen to you. A totally innocent person, who was not only imprisoned for years for a crime she had nothing to do with, but also had her name dragged in the mud by the global press for years. To such an extent that most casual observers still think she had something to do with the crime. It’s clear that the filmmakers have no legal obligation to Knox (and she acknowledges as much in the article), but I think it is equally clear that they have a moral obligation to not slander her using a thinly veiled fictional character. It’s a shame too, because the real “Amanda Knox saga” would make for a much more interesting movie: what is it like to have your roomate murdered, your life destroyed, and your identity robbed from you by the global tabloid press? That’s the real Amanda Knox story.
- f38zf5vdt 5y ago"Capitalism" and "moral obligation" are probably mutually exclusive, e.g. Milton Friedman's "The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits". [1] Friedman would argue that the movie maker has a social responsibility to its employees and shareholders, and that bending truth to meet these obligations would be its moral imperative. https://www.nytimes.com/1970/09/13/archives/a-friedman-doctrine-the-social-responsibility-of-business-is-to.html https://www.nytimes.com/1970/09/13/archives/a-friedman-doctr... edit: To downvoters, I'm not agreeing with the perspective, just saying that there is one.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y ago> Capitalism" and "moral obligation" are probably mutually exclusive How else are we supposed to read this than something you are making the case for when you so directly say they are probably mutually exclusive?
- f38zf5vdt 5y agoI was referring to the "moral obligation" not to take someone's story and make it a different story for the sake of a profit, which the original poster was referring to as a "moral obligation". An alternative perspective is the "moral obligation" to ones employees and shareholders. What is a "moral obligation" is a matter of perspective. I try to avoid a lot of documentaries and "historical" films because of these conflicting sentiments. Going into seeing a film, you know that profit, in most cases, is the end goal.
- duxup 5y agoI had similar questions when it came to the film Sully. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sully_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sully_(film) In that film they portray the NTSB investigators as trying to paint the pilot in a bad light during the investigation. According to the folks involved in the investigation, including the pilot, this never happened. These are real people, they don't have the reach or voice of a movie, what happens when someone decides to portray them unfairly? Legally I don't think there's anything to be done, there would be too many bizarre second order effects if you simply couldn't portray someone without their permission. At the same time it seems morally questionable to not involve them, specifically if their voice is so much smaller than the medium.
- ghaff 5y agoPretty much every film based on real people and events takes liberties in service of narrative flow and drama. Sometimes one or more of the original parties are involved. Often they're not.
- assface 5y ago> Pretty much every film based on real people and events takes liberties in service of narrative flow and drama. Blood on the Blackboard: The Bart Simpson Story https://youtu.be/02-U9fHefPI https://youtu.be/02-U9fHefPI
- makeitdouble 5y agoExcept they almost never “punch up”. You don’t have blockbusters fictionalizing “the Trump saga” where he sells state secrets to Putin. Or Ruppert Murdock “Godfather” style fictional drama. Perhaps once they’re long dead, but surely not before. It’s the Amanda Knox of the world that get the “let’s milk this while it’s fresh” treatment.
- kevinmchugh 5y agoCitizen Kane
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sharikous 5y agoOh please, she was an accused murderer. There was no sure proof she did it, nor that she was innocent, so she was cleared. Notably she lied in court several times. She benefitted from the media attention to make money for herself and she is now publishing an essay she was not asked to do in which she tries to make many moral "who is the victim" points (of course claiming she is the victim). You could argue she should have been granted anonymity but I cannot see her as a helpless victim.
- duxup 5y ago>she is now publishing an essay she was not asked to do in which she tries to make many moral "who is the victim" points (of course claiming she is the victim) So? Is that a bad thing?
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI think some people believe you shouldn't fight back when you're tried and convicted in the court of public opinion even if you are proven innocent in actual court. That you should just roll over and die so their suppositions aren't challenged. It reflects and extremely weak stance and lack of confidence in your own take on the situation.
- danso 5y ago> Oh please, she was an accused murderer. There was no sure proof she did it, nor that she was innocent, so she was cleared From the Economist: https://www.economist.com/europe/2015/03/28/innocente https://www.economist.com/europe/2015/03/28/innocente > The Court of Cassation in Rome found Ms Knox and Mr Sollecito not guilty on the grounds that they had “not committed the act”. Italian law recognises different levels of acquittal; this is the most categorical.
- Twixes 5y agoShe was accused of murder, but in the end explicitly cleared by the Supreme Court as innocent.
- dkersten 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kortilla 5y ago> The New York Times did in profiling Matt Damon, “the sordid Amanda Knox saga.” Sordid: morally vile. Not a great adjective to have placed next to your name. Repeat something often enough, and people believe it. This is pretty stupid. When you read, “sordid Jewish genocide” do you think “sordid” is describing “Jewish”? There is quite a bit of bullshit in the article about power imbalances that isn’t coherent either. Both her and the murder victim had no power yet she is fine with putting the murder victim’s name up for an alternate headline. There may have been a point in there somewhere, but it got buried by a cheap attempt to ride the #metoo zeitgeist.
- PavleMiha 5y agoI don't think anyone has, or would ever, use the expression you created, but the article describes why this bothers her: "Not a great adjective to have placed next to your name. Repeat something often enough, and people believe it." I for one wouldn't like something to be described as "the sordid <my name> saga" if I was innocent.
- kortilla 5y agohttp://www.albionmonitor.com/0403a/copyright/rs-bush911scam.html http://www.albionmonitor.com/0403a/copyright/rs-bush911scam.... What do you think Sordid describes in that title? If you thought “9/11”, you thought wrong. Let’s try this a different way. If you read “the unjust Amanda Knox scandal”, would you think Amanda Knox is unjust?
- rideontime 5y ago> This is pretty stupid. When you read, “sordid Jewish genocide” do you think “sordid” is describing “Jewish”? Of course not, it should read "sordid Israeli genocide." Or are you saying it should be "sordid Palestinian genocide"?
- hnthrowaway8493 5y agoWow. Phrase above was almost certainly talking about the Holocaust.
- ineptech 5y agoFascinating article. I thought she was exaggerating when she complained about people accusing her of being a media whore, until I scrolled down to the [flagged] [dead] and saw someone doing just that. But I don't think she has a choice. In the past, it would've been possible for someone in her shoes to choose obscurity. In the past, the real Amanda Knox and the idea of Amanda Knox that exists in the collective unconscious of the media and media consumers would've drifted apart. Now, it's hard to imagine how that could happen. Even if she invented a new identity and moved to a small town in Alaska (which would be a new kind of prison sentence in some ways), it'd be newsworthy.
- ludocode 5y ago> But I don't think she has a choice. Some countries recognize a "right to be forgotten". This is a good example of where such laws can help. She doesn't currently have a choice because many Western countries don't recognize this right. This is something that could change.
- danso 5y agoHuh? The "right to be forgotten", as it exists in the EU, is specifically about search engine indexing. That would not meaningfully affect someone who would have been an infamous celebrity with or without the Internet. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten#Current_legal_frameworks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_be_forgotten#Current_...
- mikem170 5y agoI wonder if a country with different libel laws would help her? For example, I've heard it's easier to sue for libel in the UK than in the US.
- nr2x 5y agoI'm unaware of any jurisdiction outside of the EU (as "Western" as you can get) that has right to be forgotten. Are there any?
- 5y ago
- octopoc 5y agoCan't she sue the movie producers of Stillwater? Even if the movie producers didn't officially acknowledge inspiration, Vanity Fair mentions it: > This new film by director Tom McCarthy, starring Matt Damon, is “loosely based” or “directly inspired by” the “Amanda Knox saga,” as Vanity Fair put it in a for-profit article promoting a for-profit film, neither of which I am affiliated with There is clearly precedence for this type of lawsuit because of this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_persons_fictitious_disclaimer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_persons_fictitious_disclai...
- ghaff 5y agoYour link explains why that disclaimer is now routinely used.
- gumby 5y agoI think she became a public figure (through no fault of her own, as far as I can tell) and thus would unfortunately likely not be afforded the libel protections of a private citizen.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoIt’s horrible that you can’t choose not to become a public figure. You have rights which someone else can get rid of by giving you enough attention.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoIt's a balance with freedom of press/speech and like most things there are casualties.
- rootusrootus 5y agoIt seems like it shouldn't be so hard to solve, either. Someone should not become a public figure without demonstrating some kind of intent. If they are not pushing a narrative, trying to influence public opinion, etc, then they do not lose protection. We cannot let the defamers be the ones controlling the definition.
- villgax 5y agoGood luck Mikrowe
- theqult 5y agoThanks for your opinion fucking fuggitive bitch. Now please, take a plane and come for your sentence.
- gpas 5y agoI'm italian and I remember very well the shitshow that followed the tragedy. When a case has no clear ending, and the press has already issued its weekly verdicts, noone comes out fully innocent and in that moment justice has failed. I'm surprised to read her name for the second time in two weeks, now even here on hn. Just a week ago, out of the blue, even if people had rightfully forgotten her... https://twitter.com/amandaknox/status/1418628570453200897 https://twitter.com/amandaknox/status/1418628570453200897 She has all the rights to tweet everything she wants, but that's not the best way to go under the radar. I'm convinced that, when there's the will, the world is big enough for anyone to disappear and get a new life.
- silviot 5y agoI'm confused: are you taking into account the existence of this movie? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stillwater_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stillwater_(film) It's one of the points of the article. You really, really should take that into account before saying something like > I'm convinced that, when there's the will, the world is big enough for anyone to disappear and get a new life. and blame her tweets for the attention she gets.
- gpas 5y agoI don't know how much of the movie is relatable to her story, I guess I'll have to watch it... For what I know the tweet and most of all the article (which has spread at the speed of light from major online tabloids to every local news site) could even be a publicity stunt to generate hype around the movie itself. Who knows? Given the recent state of the media, everything is possible. And I'm very skeptic by nature. But let's get back to why for me is a lost battle. Look at the replies under her tweet, most people outside the US have made up in their minds a clear idea of what she is, she's guilty, they condemn her, no matter what the final sentence stated. I respect the sentence and consider her a victim too. But life is too short to try to change people's minds, or to fight against a movie "loosely based" on your tragic past. Maybe people wouldn't even noticed the correlation with her case (but again, I haven't seen the movie, I don't know how much evident is). I'm sure it's hard to live with those memories, but she has the means for a complete exit from the scene, people will forget, and a movie based on your life won't be profitable anymore.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoI wasn't familiar with this movie until now. How much does official marketing material mention Amanda Knox? From a quick look up, she doesn't appear to be in the official synopsis on e.g. Rotten Tomatoes. Because, hypothetical thought experiment here: --- Let's say Tom McCarthy had the idea for a screenplay while watching the Amanda Knox trial. He doesn't know, at that point, whether she is guilty or innocent, and it really doesn't matter—the case is just inspiration for a fictional story, which can play out however the author wishes. So he makes that movie, and it's in production, and one day in an interview a reporter asks "Where did you get the idea for this movie?" Maybe they even ask "This story seems kind of similar to the Amanda Knox case, was that an inspiration?" At this point, does Tom McCarthy need to lie, or decline to answer? Should he not be allowed to share his creative process with the world? Or, perhaps he just never should have made the movie in the first place... but that seems wrong, doesn't it? Creatives get inspiration from all sorts of odd places, and I don't want to limit them! --- Again, I have no idea if the real situation played out like this at all, and in fact, I'm just going to guess that it was far more egregious. But it's what I was thinking about when reading this piece.
- aaron695 5y agoMatt Damon kinda panics when asked (3:00 mark) - https://twitter.com/TODAYshow/status/1392101154650271749 https://twitter.com/TODAYshow/status/1392101154650271749 So there is a lot in what you are saying. They have not shut the idea down though, because they know it means a lot of money. Just like the people asking know it means money for their ratings. Amanda Knox has made them a lot of money with this article which has blown it up more. She has also gotten her blog out and now I'm listening to her podcast. It's her only way to profit on all this. The movie maker is not in wrong. The movie is about a violent Dad as far as I can see. It's the media who's been here the whole time.
- dml2135 5y ago> Or, perhaps he just never should have made the movie in the first place... but that seems wrong, doesn't it? Creatives get inspiration from all sorts of odd places, and I don't want to limit them! I thing the point of this article is no, that's not wrong. The story was clearly based on Amanda Knox, and making this movie perpetuates the harm that has been done to her. This isn't an exercise of creative freedom, it's an exploitive cash grab.
- pajko 5y agoFrom law's viewpoint, you don't own your face and your fingerprints. The police can force you to unlock your devices via face or fingerprint recognition, or can do it itself by force against your will, but can't force you to unlock via passcode (which is in your head).
- SavantIdiot 5y agoNot quite, it's a little murkier: https://www.eff.org/issues/know-your-rights https://www.eff.org/issues/know-your-rights (But since that Israeli company is selling iPhone hacking kits, locks probably don't matter anymore.)
- compiler-guy 5y agoNot that simple. From the law’s viewpoint you own your car or house, but there are legal ways of compelling you to do certain things with it, or even surrendering it.
- rootusrootus 5y agoIt's interesting to me how the truth got lost, and how uninterested people are in the aftermath. The real killer ended up with a sentence almost half the length of what Amanda Knox got. And he is already out of prison. Italy's justice system is very different from the US's, for better or worse.
- soheil 5y ago> Italy's justice system is very different from the US's, for better or worse. You clearly mean worse based on your previous sentence. Mind shedding some light on those "differences" for the uninitiated?
- rootusrootus 5y agoI do not mean worse. I mean different, with 'better' and 'worse' being subjective. Rudy Guede is 34 years old, out of prison with decades more life to look forward to. After cutting short the life of Meredith Kercher at 21, some people would argue that he should pay with more of his own life, maybe all of it. In the US, obviously, there's a good chance he'd never get out of prison.
- nr2x 5y agoGood chance he'd never make it to prison.
- bonzini 5y agoThe sentence that Knox got was zero, how is it half of 16 years? You can't compare a definitive sentence with one that was overturned. (Also the real killer got a 1/3rd automatic reduction by accepting summary judgment instead of a full trial).
- bitexploder 5y agoShe was wrongly imprisoned for 4 years. And had to spend 8 years of her life fighting to be free. So, yes, 8 is half of 16. They basically took her 20s from her.
- golemotron 5y agoThis falls into the same category as France asserting control over the use of the word 'Champagne'. People use words. People talk about events and other people. It's part of being alive.
- kube-system 5y agoNot at all the same. Food labelling laws are a consumer protection.
- golemotron 5y agoI'm doing a search now for hospital visits by people who accidentally drank wine that was mislabeled as champagne.
- kube-system 5y agoThere are plenty of consumer protections that have nothing to do with safety. Many countries have origin labelling requirements for a lot of goods, and they rarely were predicated on safety. Misrepresentation doesn't have to physically harm people to be bad.
- golemotron 5y agoProtections that have nothing to do with safety. Hmm...
- kube-system 5y agoYes, there are many of these protections in every country on the planet. Governments also often protect people from, for example, financial harms.
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoThe reason she’s mentioned in US media now and then rather than the victim and perpetrator is because she’s American and the public will be interested. In the U.K. newspapers talk about Meredith Kercher. That doesn’t make it right or excuse the dreadful treatment though. I can’t see how using her name to promote the film isn’t slanderous/libellous.
- lvs 5y agoNo, the reason was that she is very attractive. That sells advertising. It's as simple as that. Many of the vile things we complain about in media all come down to the business model.
- tutmeister 5y ago> In the U.K. newspapers talk about Meredith Kercher. Maybe sometimes, but Knox's name makes up the vast majority of headlines. Here are just three major UK publications, and see how little Kercher is mentioned in her own search results... The Independent: https://www.independent.co.uk/topic/meredith-kercher https://www.independent.co.uk/topic/meredith-kercher The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/world/meredithkercher https://www.theguardian.com/world/meredithkercher The Metro: https://metro.co.uk/tag/meredith-kercher/ https://metro.co.uk/tag/meredith-kercher/ That must be very hard for Amanda to deal with, her article was surprisingly calm despite the many reasons to be angry about this continued media hype.
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoTheir names will be forever linked so searching for one will bring up stories about the other. But those articles seem to prove my point - the stories with 'Amanda Knox' in the heading are about Amanda Knox not Meredith Kercher, her murder, or her murderer. The articles in the UK about the Meredith Kercher case don't refer to her has Amanda Knox roommate.
- renewiltord 5y agoMade me go look up the tale. I recall part of why the whole thing looked weird was that she said that the owner of the bar where she worked was there when the body was discovered. That dude, Patrick Lumumba, lost his bar and eventually moved to Poland. He was unhappy about the whole thing since he was only her employer. She got 3 years for slandering him but says she was pressured into it. Bloody hell. That’s a warning to not talk during an investigation. Looks like they were going to pin something on her.
- himinlomax 5y ago> That’s a warning to not talk during an investigation That's assuming the authorities respect your right to do so. It's not even that clear cut a right in England for example, in that there are cases where not talking to the police can be held against you. Also while the right to an attorney and against self-incrimination is enshrined in the European declaration of Human Rights and enforced by the ECHR, it took dozens of that court's decisions for France to start implementing it in earnest. I don't know about the situation in Italy in that respect but their justice system is usually a fucking mess, like their bridges.
- renewiltord 5y agoYeah, I believe it. I don’t trust any results from them. It’s not all Inspector Montalbano there.
- beeboop 5y agoi will never stop recommending this video. i've watched it a dozen times, at least: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE&t=1s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE&t=1s
- spoonjim 5y agoCrazy that she cannot she the bejeezus out of Matt Damon over this. This is awful.
- mindcrime 5y agoThis reminds me of the situation with Takedown / Track Down[1]. That movie was riddled with factual inaccuracies, especially ones slanted towards making Kevin Mitnick look bad and ones meant to glorify Tsutomu Shimomura. As I recall, there was a scene that featured a chase through the streets of Seattle between the two men, it may have even featured a physical tussle between them, but my memory is a bit fuzzy now. Anyway, in reality, at the point in time depicted there, the two had never even met, much less participated in a foot chase / scuffle on the streets of Seattle. I think Mitnick ultimately sued and got a settlement of some sort, FWIW. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Track_Down https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Track_Down
- throwamanda 5y agoThis instantly reminded me of OJ Simpson's trials and acquittal. What makes this so believable, at least here on HN? Because she's a young beautiful woman and not a scary black man? I hope people here , which is one of the more rational communities out there, would stop applying double standards. Maybe she is an eloquent writer, but why should rhetoric (or looks) be the determining factor when it comes to public empathy? #metoo and #blacklivesmatter both happened but I'm yet to see black people being judged less harshly and trusted by the public.
- kortilla 5y agoPerhaps because she didn’t lose a civil case on the same manner and they actually caught the real killer? OJ probably would have gotten more sympathy if there was some kind of viable alternative story.
- Atreiden 5y agoIs this comment in good faith, or are you needlessly playing Devil's Advocate? There are very few similarities in their cases other than the fact that they were both tried for Murder. - OJ was never convicted, he was acquitted outright. Amanda Knox was convicted. And only acquitted after appeals 4 years later. - OJ did not get charged in a foreign country, in which local police and courts failed to provide due process. In fact, he received arguably the best legal defense in the country. - OJ released a book afterwards - "if I DID IT: Confessions of the Killer" describing the murder in great detail. I mean, you've seen the book cover, right? https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/4/4f/If_I_did_It_2.png/220px-If_I_did_It_2.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/4/4f/If_I_di... I'm really stumped by this comment. OJ got off, and essentially bragged about it. How is there any similarity here? > why should rhetoric (or looks) be the determining factor when it comes to public empathy? #metoo and #blacklivesmatter both happened but I'm yet to see black people being judged less harshly and trusted by the public. I think you're massively conflating these two topics. There's a real discussion to be had on race dynamics and conflict in relation to public sentiment, but it's a real stretch to say that's at play here unless you have a better example than OJ.
- 5y ago
- kortilla 5y agoNote that she is mad she is not making money from the movie, not that her name is associated with the event: https://twitter.com/amandaknox/status/1418628570453200897 https://twitter.com/amandaknox/status/1418628570453200897
- mkl 5y agoI see no indication of what you're claiming in that tweet or her replies to it.
- mcguire 5y agohttps://twitter.com/amandaknox/status/1418719530038136833 https://twitter.com/amandaknox/status/1418719530038136833
- dr_kiszonka 5y agoEven if it were true, should the producers throw some money her way? It sounds like the right thing to do, doesn't it?
- kortilla 5y agoNo? She didn’t help make it.
- gist 5y agoTerrible what happened to her but truth is she is a public figure and has not avoided the limelight either. (Not that that matters with my argument but will mention). She is fair game for any creative pursuit (song, movie, book, news article, blog post) and nobody owes her any courtesy to reach out they can if they want. Imagine if you wrote randomly to Amanda Knox vs. some other non well known person. Generally you would not expect to get a reply from Amanda (who probably has all sorts or randos and non randos (ie random person) reaching out) but a well written letter to a non famous (or notorious) person you'd probably get a reply. Nobody owes her anything just like she is not obligated to anyone as similar to the rest of us. She doesn't get any special courtesy because of what happened to her just another regular person at this point. This reminds me of how a good looking man or women often is. They reject people all the time but when they get rejected they get all indignant that they were not treated with respect.
- delusional 5y agoReading this, I can't help but ponder the role of mass media in society. How much of our collective worldview is based on marketability of stories in Hollywood? I don't think the writers on Stillwater had any intrinsic interest in retelling her story unfaithfully, but ultimately they are in the business of modifying the story for maximum market appeal. In this case that sucks for Amanda. An incorrect version of her story has entered the public consciousness as myth and I, like Amanda, imagine that this myth will stop much needed debates about the system that led her to innocently going to prison. How many of the myths that I believe in, and interpret the world by, have been distorted by market forces? It's a really scary question if I'm honest.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mcguire 5y agoNote, from Deadline (): "UPDATE 7/30/21: To Clarify Legal Status Of Amanda Knox. The 2007 case of Amanda Knox, the American convicted in an Italian court of murdering her roommate (after being convicted and spending four years in jail Knox was acquitted and freed in 2011. She was later definitively exonerated by the Italian Supreme Court Of Cassation in March 2015), was the impetus for writer-director Tom McCarthy’s Stillwater, but in the 10 years since beginning, abandoning and starting over, it has evolved into something much more – and much better." I find it interesting that they mentioned she was convicted twice in a paragraph about her legal status, with the acquitted and exonerated part relegated to a parenthetical. And to have a plug for the movie.
- sudcha 5y agoEveryone just trying to make money off of her story is very sad. Both her courage to fight, and put things into perspective in such an eloquent way is inspiring. I wonder if the news outlets doing paid promotions using her name will ever respond with an apology, or a follow up post.