18 ms·
Delta Variant
- Traubenfuchs 5y agoAccording to Wikipedia, this variant was first detected in India, in late 2020. If it's that much more infectious than other variants, where was it til now?
- ceejayoz 5y ago"If exponential growth is so fast, why did my two pennies only turn into four?"
- EliRivers 5y agoIts Wiki page shows where it has been since then; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SARS-CoV-2_Delta_variant#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SARS-CoV-2_Delta_variant#Histo...
- p410n3 5y agoIn india. Since most countries limit travel, it'll take longer to get around
- oscardssmith 5y agoCovid (original version) took several months to spread around the world without something public health measures to slow it down. The Delta variant took about the same time despite the fact that significant portions have a degree of immunity from the vaccines or previous exposure, and much less international travel.
- pier25 5y agoIt's been in the UK news for some time now. In Mexico (where I live) we had the first Delta cases a couple of months ago. It is now the main variant and comprises 90% of sequenced samples (although Mexico doesn't sequence enough samples). https://outbreak.info/location-reports?loc=MEX https://outbreak.info/location-reports?loc=MEX
- brutos 5y agoAssuming this is actually a genuine question: Here are the per country ratios of different VOC/VOI: https://covariants.org/per-country https://covariants.org/per-country It took a while until it became dominant in India, and then a similar pattern repeats in each new country.
- herbst 5y agoIt's all over, and was all over the news early 2021 already. Not sure what you are talking about (Or which kind of media you consume to come to that conclusion)
- raphlinus 5y agoYou're being downvoted, but that's actually a good question. An explanation that fits the fact is antigenic drift. A variant that's different but not necessarily that much worse will outcompete another variant in which the population has built up significant immunity. The difference in fitness doesn't need to be that large. If the virus truly had a massively larger R0 value, as is asserted in TFA, then you'd expect it to catch fire extremely quickly as soon as it starts showing up, and everywhere it is found. Ron Fouchier (see TWiV 777 as cited elsethread) certainly believes that these huge R0 values are not plausible, and that antigenic drift fits the observable facts better.
- CPLX 5y agoI have to admit, I'm a little perplexed about all the discussion around the Delta variant. It almost feels like people are discussing this like it's a plot point in a novel, a new looming threat that comes after Act II, rather than a cold scientific fact. As someone who lives in New York and has been vaccinated for months, should I worry about this? It seems like the answer to that question is no, I shouldn't. Also notable is that walk-in instant and free vaccinations are available everywhere in the city, I see signs all the time when walking around, so anyone (who's older than 12) who isn't vaccinated is making a clear choice. I really do get that other parts of the world don't fit this description, and that there's subtlety to this and it's complicated. Like I really get that. But what are articles like this trying to convey? They seem to be telling me that I should feel differently than I do now, and that I should take different actions than I am taking. But what are those arguments? What's the intent of writing an article like this? I see the takeaways section at the end but it doesn't feel like it matches the tone of the rest of the article, which seems to clearly imply that letting your guard down on COVID is a mistake. The first sentence sends that message clearly, saying "I don’t think people are paying enough attention to Delta". I disagree with that thesis statement, I think vaccinated people with no policy authority who are overwhelmed and often in mental crisis after a year of this shouldn't pay attention to Delta at all.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iamben 5y agoI thought it was a very well put together article that summed up a lot of everything - especially if you were on the fence about getting jabbed. As a vaccinated person - exactly as he said, you probably don't need to worry: "If you’re vaccinated, you’re mostly safe, especially with mRNA vaccines. Keep your guard up for now, avoid events that might become super-spreaders, but you don’t need to worry much more than that." But maybe this is a good summary to send to those who aren't in your position yet?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 5y ago
- littlestymaar 5y ago> I don’t think people are paying enough attention to Delta In the US probably. In Europe Delta has been followed closely even in mainstream media for at least a month.
- jsbdk 5y agoCan't everybody get vaccinated in the US unlike the EU where you have to wait for your turn and can't buy vaccines? That would explain the difference
- Thaxll 5y agoIn the EU for major countries you can get vaccinated any time, it's the same reasons as in the US some people just don't want to.
- jsbdk 5y agoWhat major countries? I live in Spain and in most regions people under 30 still can't get vaccinated.
- CannisterFlux 5y agoAccording to a few news sources, those in their twenties can now get vaccinated in Catalonia, Canary Islands, Castilla-La Mancha, Baleares/Navarra, and Madrid. I don't know how accurate that is. It may depend on where/how you book the vaccine. I'm in my 40s and live in Madrid, and only got my first dose last week in the local health center rather than a large vaccine hub, because it hasn't been very well advertised. I assumed I still wasn't eligible. You should just try booking a vaccine, worst that can happen is the system won't let you.
- xxmarkuski 5y agoRight now in Germany vaccines are available in abundance, just today Berlin opened a Drive-In Vaccination Center at a furniture store and at Vaccination Centers in Saxony appointments are not needed anymore [1]. [1] https://www.tagesschau.de/newsticker/liveblog-coronavirus-dienstag-219.html https://www.tagesschau.de/newsticker/liveblog-coronavirus-di...
- cute_boi 5y agoI see the article is well written. The problem is developed countries are doing nothing significant. They think if they vaccinate their population they are good. And they are supplying only some excess vaccines to developing countries which is like drop in bucket. And they are stuck on patents, greediness and all of these thing. I don't think the country where I live will have vaccines till 2023 and people here are already tired of multiple lockdowns and masks...
- jsbdk 5y ago>They think if they vaccinate their population they are good. What else do they have to do?
- ceejayoz 5y agoHelp get the rest of the world vaccinated, too.
- jsbdk 5y agoDoesn't seem like that's a good idea, since the supply of vaccines is not infinite.
- ModernMech 5y agoLuckily we don't have to vaccinate infinite people.
- shkkmo 5y agoIncreased funding and coordination can absolutely increase the available supply of vaccines.
- mchanson 5y agoI think the richer countries helping pay to vaccinate the world is a good and smart thing to do.
- ssharp 5y ago
- joelbluminator 5y agoHaven't read the piece but I have read a few things by this guy that made me panic. I don't know if he was right or wrong but he has a tendency to be overly bleak. Yes Covid kills, a lot. Also car accidents and air pollution kill a lot. I haven't gained anything from reading this guy despite all the good info, it hasn't given me any action items and I suspect a politician reading him won't gain anything either.
- TaupeRanger 5y agoWhy would anyone ever compare an exponentially spreading infectious disease with car accidents? They aren't even in the same realm of concern for public health.
- joelbluminator 5y agoI am saying I am not sure the amount of panic was proportional to the amount of actual deaths. > At least 30.7% of deaths in India can be attributed to air pollution from fossil fuels--that means about 2.5 million people die every year after breathing toxic air.9 I mean who cares, all I know is how many Covid deaths they are having, probably Indian people themselves are much more aware of Covid than Air pollution. Why? Mostly because Covid is still new and pollution is old and boring.
- cloverich 5y agoBecause your parents aren't dying from air pollution tomorrow, but they might from COVID. And the vaccine can stop it, and there's a race between DELTA and the vaccine for your parents lives. The story is a bit different in the US, where its more about people not wanting to take it, and an often cited reason is that the virus is going way whether or not that get vaccinated (because other people are). If that story changes, then their reasoning is no longer valid.
- kube-system 5y agoImmediacy and individual actionability are also important factors in the difference between people's reaction to those two situations. COVID can kill you within days and you can wear a mask today to do something about it. Pollution might take 20 years and if you don't emit any pollution there's a billion other people around you that will. "There's nothing I can do about it" is what many might say.
- accurrent 5y agoI've a feeling at the end of the day the only solution will be to scale up the number of medical facilities/personnel/equipment so we can cope with changing and mutating virus. With sufficient care, access to oxygen etc, we may still be able to handle the onslaught of new variants. Vaccines, while very important, will not be a magic bullet unless we can get them to enough people fast enough. This still remains a problem.
- usrusr 5y agoMedical facilities already take up a considerable fraction of total productivity. Vaccine production on the other hand is a tiny footnote in the grand scheme of things. Vaccine output could be increased tenfold or more for less effort then it would take to increase medical facilities by only a few percentage points. It's a comparison like getting a second TV for seeing more frames per second vs trying to do the same by commissioning more oil paintings (from a really bad painter)
- accurrent 5y agoThis is true for rich nations. In many poorer nations simple improvements to the healthcare system are far more realistic than creation of a new vaccine plant. mRNA vaccines are currently only produced by very few manufacturers, getting these vaccines to poorer nations is just not happening. In the mean time the vaccine will continue to mutate in these nations. The fact is many poorer nations lack basic equipment like oxygen generation units. This basically spells death for people who would otherwise recover. To put an example. Singapore has had 62K infections but only 32 deaths. Why? Its a small very rich nation. While there were large numbers warded in icu and requiring oxygen supplies, we had the equipment. By contrast anywhere else on earth we see far poorer survival rates.
- havkom 5y ago”Now, with Delta, it looks like the figures are 64%, 93% and 93% according to Israel, and 79% for symptomatic infection and 96% hospitalization according to the UK.” I doubt these will turn out to be correct numbers. Looking at recent week’s data in Israel possibly paints another picture (keep in mind while parsing the numbers that there are plentiful many more vaccinated in the population than not in the age groups that gets hospitalized): https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/0/d/1kiOrQxOtBg0__IoLkEZgqhMDpIQCXbBxEE78BwqcOs4/htmlview#gid=472501586 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/u/0/d/1kiOrQxOtBg0__IoL... Nevertheless, it is clear that vaccination helps and is important, but I have doubts about 90+% protection from hospitalization.
- colincooke 5y agoThere are some statistical concerns with how Israel came up with their numbers, so I would put more faith in other countries results, at least for now. My best guess is that the 64% is for any detectable disease, not symptoms (i.e. you test positive but don't feel meaningfully different), which means the vaccines do their job at quickly eliminating the virus.
- XorNot 5y agoThe more important result is although Delta is resistant to being neutralized by existing antibodies, it does not prevent it in serum-trials against vaccinated individuals, the like most biological systems the human immune system is exponential: starting from an effective antibody response, it can overwhelm any nascent infection (i.e. hospitalizations would not be expected to rise). The number I've seen is a 3-5 fold reduction in the kinetics of neutralization [1] - this is concerning for whether you can spread it, but seems to my eye pretty consistent with hospitalization effectiveness remaining about the same. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03777-9 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03777-9
- havkom 5y agoMaybe. But I was commenting on the real hospitalization numbers and implied vaccine protection from comparing the ratios 1) hospitilized vaccinated vs hospitilized non-vaccinated [the linked spear sheet] and 2) vaccinated in relevant age brackets vs non-vaccinated in relevant age brackets.
- usrusr 5y agoIs seems kind of logical in hindsight: the first mutation of the predecessor bat/pangolin/whatever virus genome to cross over to humans is an MVP full of "compatibility bugs" that barely achieves R0>1. A few billion dicerolls later many of those "compatibility bugs" have found fixes. Remember the hand washing phase of the pandemic? Aerosol transmission was basically ruled out because it was assumed that spread would have been much faster if it happened by aerosol. Turns out like it was aerosol all the time, just slowed down massively by all those "compatibility bugs" that are now slowly ironed out. Fortunately, our immune systems adapt as well (both individually and industrially, by ramping up mRNA capabilities and production)
- davnn 5y ago> full of "compatibility bugs" that barely achieves R0>1 Did I miss something? COVID-19 was highly contagious from the beginning, thus the drastic measures, or not?
- babyblueblanket 5y agoIt is highly contagious. But not as much as say, the measles.
- dragontamer 5y agoCOVID19's main issue is that it takes anywhere from 5 to 14 days before you feel symptoms. During this window, it looks like you're still spreading COVID19 around. Therefore: traditional means of preventing spread (ie: staying home from work and/or school) are ineffective. Measles or Ebola (or plenty of other diseases) have a much smaller window of spreading (because you feel sick sooner).
- floxy 5y agoWhat's the latest on asymptomatic spread for covid-19? Last update I had seen was that this wasn't likely. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-020-19802-w https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-020-19802-w
- colincooke 5y agoI will say that on the vaccine front the data provided by Israel seems to be the worst results of the bunch, and while we can't completely rule out their results there is a good chance it's an underestimate of efficacy. Here are some efficacy estimates against Delta from other sources: https://twitter.com/EricTopol/status/1414254993536786433 https://twitter.com/EricTopol/status/1414254993536786433 Highlights are (symtoms/hospitilization): - Phizer: 79-88%/96% - Moderna (one dose, not much data): 72%/96% - Astra: 60-67%/92%
- Unklejoe 5y agoAre you aware of any results for the J&J shot? That's the one I got but it always seems to be left out.
- selectodude 5y agoHere you go, straight from the horses mouth. Take that as you will. "A preprint submitted by the Company today to bioRxiv contains a new analysis from blood samples obtained from a subset of participants (n=8) in the Phase 3 ENSEMBLE study. These data showed that the Johnson & Johnson single-shot COVID-19 vaccine elicited neutralizing antibody activity against the Delta variant at an even higher level than what was recently observed for the Beta (B.1.351) variant in South Africa where high efficacy against severe/critical disease was demonstrated." https://www.jnj.com/positive-new-data-for-johnson-johnson-single-shot-covid-19-vaccine-on-activity-against-delta-variant-and-long-lasting-durability-of-response https://www.jnj.com/positive-new-data-for-johnson-johnson-si...
- AnimalMuppet 5y agon=8?!? That's... um... nice for those eight people, I guess. It's sure not much to draw conclusions from, though. (I also got J&J, so I hope they're right. But the sample size makes this little better than anecdote.)
- 015a 5y agoAin't that the truth. I opted for the J&J almost solely because the media & government strongly suggested it would be the "primary" vaccine going forward; given it only required one dose, scale-up would be easier, easier to transport, more people would end up with it, and thus I figure it would receive the largest scientific scrutiny for positive and negative side-effects going forward. Far from it. Those of us who got it now feel like the weird step-children of the COVID pandemic, constantly left out of headlines and media. Though, I guess at least, it can very rarely cause an extremely dangerous nerve condition, so we got that going for us which is nice.
- hattmall 5y agoMy question is why don't we have treatment? Yes we know vaccines are good as preventative but we also know that vaccines are vulnerable to mutations and waning efficacy over time. It's also somewhat burdensome to need to vaccinate all people all the time. Where is the research into effective treatments and why do we seem to prefer mass vaccination over acute treatments for the sick. Is it just much more difficult to formulate effective treatments or is the influence of capitalism pushing toward the solution that has the most customers and is the most profitable?
- oscardssmith 5y agoIn general, anti-viral treatments don't work very well. Antibiotics have worked great, but it's much harder to effectively target viruses with medicine (probably because they reproduce inside the cells of their hosts)
- ceejayoz 5y agoWe have gotten a lot better at treating COVID patients since the first couple of months, as we figure out which interventions work and which don't. Stuff like putting patients prone made a surprisingly large difference in the mortality rate. Drugs like antivirals are "vulnerable to mutations and waning efficacy over time" just like vaccines are, and they're a lot harder to make.
- pier25 5y agoThese new variants were to be expected as the vaccines seem to be accelerating these mutations. My understanding is that the COVID vaccines train the body to recognize the outer protein layer of the virus. In consequence when that changes (because of mutations and natural selection) the body becomes less effective at recognizing the virus. Geert Vanden Bossche[1] has been warning about this for months now. He says it's possible at some point a new variant will come out that makes current vaccines completely ineffective. [1] https://twitter.com/GVDBossche https://twitter.com/GVDBossche
- neogodless 5y agohttps://www.dw.com/en/fact-check-what-do-we-know-about-the-coronavirus-delta-variant/a-57949754 https://www.dw.com/en/fact-check-what-do-we-know-about-the-c... > The earliest documented COVID-19 case caused by the delta variant (B.1.617.2) was found in the Indian state of Maharashtra back in October 2020 It doesn't seem that blaming this variant on vaccines makes much sense.
- bvaldivielso 5y agoAs far as I understand (I don't have any background in biology), mutations will happen regardless of whether people are vaccinated or not. There might be mutations that make the virus circumvent some vaccine protections, but those mutations would take place even if we weren't vaccinating people. Nothing about the vaccines "guides" the virus towards specific mutations. Mutations are random. If this is correct, why would not vaccinating people be better than vaccinating them? (In fact, the fewer people that get infected, the less room for the virus to mutate). Is my understanding correct? Can anybody point out where I'm wrong?
- teataster 5y agoAs far as I understand, and I don't understand much. Also I am not endorsing vanden Bossche because I don't understand much. Furthermore, just as everyone else, he is just trying to sell his vaccine over others'. The issue is selective pressure. Yes, the virus will mutate. But under an mRNA vaccine, only the spike protein needs to mutate for the vaccine to be render useless. In other words: mutating the spike protein will give the virus access to very broad unimmunized population. Up to that it makes perfect sense to me and my limited evolutionary knowledge. I can't tell wether is right or wrong. But it makes sense. He goes further saying that antibodies from vaccines are more affine to the virus, even with mutated spike protein, this compromises the natural immune system, given it will try to fight off infection with useless vaccine-learnt antibodies rather than with natural antibodies. This will make the virus more deadly. This seems off to me. I can't see the logic, but I will be happy to be corrected. How can something be ignored by the virus and be more affine to it? Again, he says that all these issues are solved with his vaccine, once he finishes it.
- specialp 5y agoI'm not sure what the end game is here. The original plan was "flatten the curve", which meant keep hospitals from getting inundated. Then it became wait for the vaccine. COVID is not going to go away. The vaccine has dramatically decreased the amount of people dying from it. Cases going up without dramatic increases in death or hospitalization might not be a bad thing. The alternative is lockdowns that will never completely end the virus, and have a significant impact on our lives. It will just slow the spread over a very long time. There are ever present dangers that we just live with like the chances of getting in a car accident and dying, but we decide that these risks are low enough that we carry on normal life.
- joosters 5y ago'There are ever present dangers that we just live with like the chances of getting in a car accident and dying' Have you not noticed how we have put a lot of time, effort and money into increasing the safety of road travel? Do you just 'live with' the chance of dying in a car crash, or do you have technology like seat belts and air bags?
- specialp 5y agoYes and we put a lot of time into making a vaccine. What if I said too many people are dying of car accidents, and they can almost all be completely prevented by lowering speed limits to walking speed. We live with the risk because it is low enough and making everyone travel at extremely low speeds would have a very adverse effect on the economy and quality of life. Safety improvements have been implemented that have not had a very onerous impact on life like having an airbag and seatbelt. And they allow us to drive at reasonable speeds with a reasonable level of safety. But still 40k people a year die in the USA. So if technology produces ways to make living with COVID less onerous and safer then why not? It is easy for us as mostly tech people to be like yeah lock that down forever. I am still getting paid full pay working from home, and my packages still come to the door. But for a lot of people it is a very large cost to pay. And eventually we will not be able to keep printing money out of it. People need to work and live.
- 5y ago
- idownvoted 5y agoAh, nothing says "credibility" like reiterating the good old burning covid-corpses of india lie, or removing India from your scary looking chart of new infections, because it would show India's steady drop in new infections. Hopefuly Thomas gets a bit more convincing scaredata for the Lambda Variant.
- matz1 5y ago>It looks like the risk of death is 2x higher for Delta than for the original variant: 2x of what ? 2x of low risk is still a low risk.
- alkonaut 5y agoYou literally quoted the answer to your question
- matz1 5y agoThe author mentioned the risk is 2x higher but what is the risk of the original variant itself ? The author didn't mention that.
- alkonaut 5y agoThe author spends a section on that, including a chart. Search for this passsage to see the chart: The IFR (Infected Fatality Rate4) for the original variant was about 0.01% for those in their 20s and 0.2% for those in their 40s. Direct link to the chart https://cdn.substack.com/image/fetch/f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fbucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F7e833c1e-ddbf-44b1-829c-319be504a88c_644x462.png https://cdn.substack.com/image/fetch/f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_p...
- matz1 5y ago>The IFR (Infected Fatality Rate4) for the original variant was about 0.01% for those in their 20s and 0.2% for those in their 40 Thanks, so 2x of that is 0.02% and 0.4%, that was my point: 2x of a low rate is still low
- alkonaut 5y agoI don’t think anyone is arguing 20-somethings should be getting the vaccine for (their own) risk of ending up dead. The risk is low but not even healthy 20 year olds should disregard a 2/10000 risk of preventable death.
- haunter 5y agoIsn't there a Delta Plus variant now?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chess_buster 5y agoYes. Few cases. So far.
- notacoward 5y agoThere is. It's also known as B.1.617.2.1 or AY.1 here: https://www.who.int/en/activities/tracking-SARS-CoV-2-variants/ https://www.who.int/en/activities/tracking-SARS-CoV-2-varian... The good news is that the differences relative to "original Delta" seem to be pretty slight.
- raphlinus 5y agoSome counterpoint. A lot of the assertions, particularly the fact that delta is dramatically more transmissible than ancestral type, are reported as fact in the mainstream, but the evidence for this particular claim is thin. It certainly is true that delta is outcompeting the other strains. But inferring higher transmissibility from observational or ecological studies is not really sound. Most of the increases can be explained by human behavior - a third to a half of Americans are not fully vaccinated, and people are going out, not wearing masks, etc. Determining higher transmissibility in the virological sense is a difficult experiment and I don't think is really being done. This is discussed in some detail in TWiV[777], a discussion with Ron Fouchier. If you use influenza as a model, the picture looks completely different - new strains are coming up all the time and outcompeting the older ones, but that's just because people have developed immunity to the older ones (antigenic drifts). The new ones are not fundamentally different or more transmissible. For people who don't want to listen to the whole thing, the main point is also made in a NYT opinion piece[2]. Pueyo claims that alpha is 60% more transmissible than ancestral type, but again the evidence doesn't strongly support this. Indeed, a preprint just came out[3] in which alpha looks pretty much identical to ancestral type when it comes to viral loads and clearance. I've really enjoyed and appreciated Pueyo's writings. In particular, I think "The Hammer and the Dance" was groundbreaking and we could still learn the lessons from it. But I think this one is a miss: it could present real insight, but instead mostly propagates conventional thinking. There's a really interesting science communication aspect to delta: it's basically a proxy for the (very true) statement, "the virus is still dangerous." In fact, one prominent evolutionary biologist accused the NYT op-ed of verging on "delta denialism". Accurately communicating reality in a way that is useful to people is fantastically hard, and we just don't have an ecosystem for it. I think this is the reason I've become addicted to TWiV and other similar highbrow sources - I hate being fed partial information and feel compelled to learn more. [777]: https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-777/ https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-777/ [2]: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/27/opinion/covid-vaccine-variants.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/27/opinion/covid-vaccine-var... [3]: https://twitter.com/BallouxFrancois/status/1414909262657114116 https://twitter.com/BallouxFrancois/status/14149092626571141...
- shkkmo 5y agoThe evidence cited in the article is not just looking at prevalence graphs, it is a study that looks at within household transmission rates and thus public social distancing and mask wearing would have no effect. And your [3] source explicitly warns against using their findings to compare infectiousness. > I don't believe 'infectiousness" is necessarily the ideal term here. B.1.1.7 (Alpha) could be intrinsically more 'infectious' than previous 'non-variant' lineages in circulation (e.g. higher risk of initiating an infection with the same infectious dose of virions). 4/
- neogodless 5y agoHmm @dang this doesn't seem controversial, or shouldn't be. We should be curious about the details of a dangerous strain of a virus, and learn more about it. I'm not sure if this deserves to be "[flagged]" but perhaps I'm missing the bigger picture.
- dqv 5y agoI think it gets that tag after some threshold of flags and then has to be revived. >controversial I would say there is some contention going on in this thread.
- neogodless 5y agoThis is a complex problem. The original post seems to be a collection of facts and information about a thing. The thread should have some discussion about what to do with this information, but of course there has been politicization of issues like this (bizarrely, since I'm not sure who benefits from the disinformation!) But in this case, the flags have the effect of just hiding an informational article, which may be the desired effect if you believe it is politically disadvantageous for facts to be shared and discussed. There's no way for me to say all that without being on a "side" even if I really do not wish to be, and for the moderators, the issue might be similar, though I suspect some can break down the issue with a clearer lens.
- dqv 5y agoThis is just how it works on HN. It's not the first time an informative article has been flagged and it won't be the last. All kinds of articles get flagged. You have to check in on /newcomments to find interesting discussions.
- egeozcan 5y agoThe question is, if some people stop believing in computer science and flag basic programming articles, would that have the same effect on CS and Math articles like it did with biology and statistics? To be more general: Do politicians really have the superpower to stop the spread of any information through polarization?
- garyfirestorm 5y agoWhy did this get flagged? This is an important article that probably will change an unvaccinated individuals mind.
- throwawayboise 5y agoThe author has no credentials in this area.
- franciscop 5y agoThe article purposefully conflates numbers to tell a narrative. I am talking only about EU, and at that southern EU which is where I've been following the numbers closely. Delta variant has been acting for up to 1 month in some regions, and as described in the article yes cases are up very quickly. However, the article says: > COVID deaths [...] And if you think Europe or the US will be spared This is not reflected at all with the current numbers and the author is mixing deaths in one country with infections in another. There hasn't been even a single uptick of deaths in EU so far that I've seen, and we are past the potential 2+ week delay from cases to deaths so if it was of importance for EU, we'd see a massive climb in death graphs. That is just not happening, so regarding deaths this seems, so far, not to be a concern at all for highly vaccinated countries. Yes there are many other concerns for which we want to avoid more infections (saturation of hospitals, potential for more mutations, etc.) which are worth discussing, but this article is instead just conflating numbers. See a comparison taken 2 days ago of "infections" vs "deaths" in Spain, which includes this delta wave: https://imgur.com/a/A9VFS4G https://imgur.com/a/A9VFS4G
- tremon 5y agoand we are past the potential 2-week delay from cases to deaths Not everywhere. See here, for example: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/netherlands/#graph-cases-daily https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/netherland... The Netherlands went from 550 cases/day at the end of June to 10,000 cases/day now. The Delta variant took less than two weeks to spread as much as the EU variant did in two months (Sep 1st - Nov 1st). Of course, it was helped a lot by the government deciding to open up bars, dancings and nights clubs on June 26th so it's not a fair comparison :/ Point is, we'll have to wait two weeks to see what effect this will have on the death rate. I expect the death rate to be a lot lower than in November, partly because of vaccinations but also because the age group that flocked to the bars and night clubs is a lot younger than the earlier wave victims. Still, I don't expect our death rate to remain in the single digits as it has been since the beginning of June.
- ginko 5y agoStill, the UK is quite a bit into the delta wave and the number of deaths have barely budged: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/uk/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/uk/
- hardlianotion 5y agoWhy is this flagged?
- pattrn 5y agoThe author links the following paper as a source for his comments: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3868853 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3868853. Unless I'm reading it incorrectly, the mortality rate of the infected, unvaccinated population is 0.5% (131 / 26,632), and the mortality rate in the infected, vaccinated population is 2.5% (33 / 1,410). Does this mean that the vaccine decreases your chance of contracting the virus, but increases your chance of dying if you do contract it? (Note: I understand that the overall death rate from the paper is 0.002% for vaccinated population and 0.012% for unvaccinated population.)
- sauwan 5y agoI'm guessing that vaccinated people get tested at a much lower rate when they're feeling cold like symptoms, so the denominator there is probably significantly reduced.
- programmarchy 5y agoI think you’d need to separate out the populations by age demographics to make that hypothesis because the vaccinated population could be skewed towards older people.
- pattrn 5y agoGood point. I just checked the paper, and it's true that the vaccinated population had proportionally more 60+ year olds (by about 3x). As I read through this more, It's a bit surprising that out of 805,124 people (includes uninfected) under the age of 45, there were only 5 deaths. Haven't looked into the data for a long time.
- mrmanner 5y agoI read an explanation in another context, that sounded plausible: Mostly people with symptoms get tested, and the vaccines are quite good at preventing symptomatic illness. Thus the share of infected individuals not caught by tests is larger in the vaccinated population, which makes mortality among the vaccinated look worse than it is. source https://www.ijpr.org/health-and-medicine/2021-05-13/no-the-death-rate-for-vaccinated-people-is-not-higher-than-that-of-unvaccinated-people https://www.ijpr.org/health-and-medicine/2021-05-13/no-the-d...
- nhod 5y agoFWIW, I’ve been fully vaccinated (Moderna) since March. I was just in Provincetown, MA for the usual yearly 4th of July celebration with 10K other gay men, and Delta ripped through everyone. I got breakthrough COVID, which I assume is Delta because the symptoms were much more like the common cold than classic COVID. I probably know ~150 people in that group, and at least 14 people I know got breakthrough COVID. Meanwhile back here in LA I found another 5 people (trainers and members) in my very small, outdoor gym got breakthrough COVID. Everyone I know is fine health wise, no hospitalizations, and it was more annoying than anything, but it does indicate anecdotally that Delta is not going to go well.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- abystander 5y agoDidn't the CDC stop collecting data about this too? I seem to recall reading something like they only test hospitalizations now.
- drno123 5y agoDoes anyone, really, consider Pueyo relevant regarding Covid? My understanding is that he, a marketing expert, came up with hammer and dance which was used to push lockdown agenda. Lockdown did not greatly help reduxe cocid deaths and it introduced a lot of other problems such as delayed cancer diagnostics, mental health issues, compromised immunity in small children etc. This guy is a danger to public health.
- tpoacher 5y agoI honestly don't know how to feel about Tomas Pueyo. He's very opinionated about what he writes, and has gained good readership and influencer status on this topic. It's clear in his writings that he fancies himself as an "amateur of expert insight". He may be 100% correct. He may also be 100% wrong. It's hard to tell (let alone without invoking the conditional fallacy). However, the most lasting impression I have of him is when he was invited in one of those "both sides" TV programmes in the UK on the basis that his "Hammer and the Dance" blogpost at the time became very popular. He was invited to debate with a renowned epidemiologist, who was part of the COVID-19 team advising the UK government at the time, and who was there to discuss the rationale for the policy after copious simulations by his research team. The epidemiologist was considered an expert and leading figure in his field. Meanwhile, Pueyo's self-described title on his blogpage at the time was "data visualisation expert" or something along those lines. Now, like I said, he may be 100% correct (or not). This is not about making an "ad verecundium/hominem" argument. But all I remember from that TV debate is that his main argument tactic on TV was effectively interrupting all the time by saying "wtf", "people will die because of you" and visibly eyerolling and audibly sighing an awful lot, without offering much counterargument except by referring to his blogpost and the "obviousness of his claims". All this to the dismay and visible frustration of the epidemiologist who was trying to remain civil, objective, and doing his best to remain calm, relay the science as clearly as he could, while trying to avoid unnecessary panic and drama. Honestly watching it made me feel like you had just pitched the dalai lama in a debate against trump. Pueyo has now changed his blogpage's tagline from "data visulisation expert" (or whatever it used to be) to "Understand the biggest problems and how to solve them". Forgive me if that doesn't sound as vague and grandiose to you as it does to me, but at best it doesn't come across to me as very humble from someone who, at the very least, is not particularly qualified for that description (then again, who is). So, good on him for writing these blogposts and taking a stand, but while he may (or may not) be 100% correct (if there is such a thing), after that TV performance I witnessed, I'm taking his (otherwise professionally edited) blogposts with a large pinch of salt.
- zzzeek 5y agoive never heard of this author and i thought it was a good blog post. your post is for better or worse the definition of ad-hominem and also black-and-white thinking (100% right or 100% wrong). In the US, we are in a dangerous place where social distancing and masking have basically stopped, and with a much more contagious variant like Delta we're defintiely going to have a much bigger problem again in the coming months. I didn't see anything in this article that struck me as counterproductive towards preparing for the continuation of the virus.
- _user112 5y agoUK gov's statistics shows "delta" variant results in next to no deaths. Meditation is great for Anxiety.
- tigershark 5y agoWith more than 87% of the adult population with 1 dose and more than 66% fully vaccinated.
- throw_nbvc1234 5y agoSure and there are people in this thread implying that that's not a relevant factor and places like the UK and US are going to be seeing massive deaths soon. And nobody talks about the natural immunity aspect either. Even if it just blunts the severity of the symptoms, places like florida probably have had ~30% of their population infected. I'm going to guess the "bad" people who didn't wear masks, got infected, are mostly part of the non-vaccinated percentage of the population. They could be added to any vaccine percentages from a pandemic response perspective (with downsides of being less accurate count, presumably less consistent immune response ect...).
- deregulateMed 5y agoNot sure why science/math minded people are buying into any COVID Fears. The death rates are 1 percent, and it particularly targets old and obese people. I have no problem getting vaccinated and paying for n95 masks for old and obese people. But COVID reminds me of post 9-11 terrorist fears. Statistically insignificant and gets people glued to TVs. Instead of the military industrial complex winning tax dollars, big pharma wins tax dollars. I just want a science based approach to these pandemics, instead we got hysteria.
- effie 5y ago> Not sure why science/math minded people are buying into any COVID Fears. It's a way to feel important and make money. Exposure, likes, quotes, clicks. People love audience. Kudos to scientists/science presenters who keep their cool and present a balanced view of COVID-related information despite the widespread censorship and hit pieces. I can recommend dr. Mobeen Syed's YT channel, he's bringing in interesting guests (often doctors) where they discuss all new knowledge on COVID treatments, vaccines etc.
- skybrian 5y agoA 1% death rate (10,000 micromorts) may not be Russian roulette but it’s scary high by modern standards. Compare with skydiving (8 per jump) or giving birth (120 or 170 micromorts, depending). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micromort https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micromort
- deregulateMed 5y agoCan you re-run those numbers to eliminate obesity and old age? These groups can wear n95 masks and lockdown. If they can't comply with those orders, it wouldn't help if the rest of the population complied either.
- dna_polymerase 5y ago> Not sure why science/math minded people are buying into any COVID Fears. Oh simple. They actually understand math.
- gfodor 5y agoContent like this that fails to incorporate demographics as natural immunity goes in the “alarmist” bucket for me at this stage. We know the vaccines work against delta. If you are in a developed country and wanted a vaccine you have gotten one. The delta so far does not harm the young in any meaningful enough way to change our calculus around children. The thing we ought to be worried about is what happens if a new variant pops up that hurts kids. I’d like to see analysis from a virologist on the odds of this happening given selective pressures.
- bamboozled 5y agoAs a reader of HN for several years now, it blows my mind how polarized we all are on this issue. Something smells here, you're not allowed to question anything without being down voted to oblivion, one way or another. Why?
- timr 5y agoCovid discussion has become equivalent to politics. Most people have strong opinions on the matter, these opinions usually correlate strongly to their favorite political party's stance, and few people have the experience or knowledge to evaluate scientific information rationally. It's a recipe for uninformed debate. On top of that, in the US, the previous president was so politically polarizing that literally any statement he made was aggressively opposed by many people. A lot of SARS-CoV2 response got caught up in this dynamic. Wide segments of the population are simply misinformed of basic scientific facts, and slick charlatans (like the author of this article) twist information in subtle ways to scare people. Terrified people are naturally going to be more volatile, and this has been exploited throughout the last year and half.
- bamboozled 5y agoIt certainly feels like hangover from the Trump times, and yes, it's insanely political and quite hysterical. Now, people overcompensate, if there is any questioning or hesitancy to take the vaccine, ask questions about origins etc you might be a...Trump guy, or a nut and so you need to be told by the Non-Trump guys what' up, by being downed. It's Kind of like Post-Trum-Stress-Disorder, PTSD. It's really quite fascinating.
- timr 5y agoIt's unfortunately pretty common for people adopt an "opposite of what That Guy said" stance on any particular issue. Obviously, taking a position that is the opposite of an illogical person makes you just as illogical, but it's much easier than thinking.
- 5y ago
- 74d-fe6-2c6 5y agothe delta is even less virulent then past variants. it's only marginally more lethal than the flu. long covid is a fuzzy excuse to prolong the panic culture.
- gentleman11 5y agoThe article ststes that there were 2M Covid deaths in India. Stats I saw yesterday said 400k. By comparison, the USA had 600k
- iamben 5y agoI believe he's referring to excess deaths.
- driverdan 5y agoMultiple sites seem to back you up. Example: https://covid19.who.int/region/searo/country/in https://covid19.who.int/region/searo/country/in
- statguy 5y agoThe official Indian death numbers are a vast undercount by most accounts.
- alok-g 5y agoThe actual numbers in India are alleged to be an order of magnitude higher than the official numbers. There have been articles like [1] trying to estimate the actual numbers. The OP is likewise citing an article that's saying actual numbers are six times higher. I do not have access to the cited article to say more. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/05/25/world/asia/india-covid-death-estimates.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/05/25/world/asia/in...
- skadamou 5y agoWithout debating the whole article, I found this one excerpt to be somewhat indicative of his writing more broadly: "Unfortunately, I turned out to be right. The short explanation is that the viruses that tend to win do so because they reproduce faster. Such a virus will grow faster inside a person, and will make that person more infectious, faster. It will also kill that person faster." This is a fairly vague statement with broad implications (and a pinch of hubris) supported with insufficient evidence. I appreciate that he is trying to simplify a complex issue into lay-mens terms but I worry that writing like this only adds fodder to the anti-science movement because it is full of quasi-truths.
- effie 5y agoIndeed. The very distinct feature of initial SARS-COV-2 was that people had extremely large viral load, yet little symptoms (when compared to other regular viruses). Even if the virus evolves towards larger viral load, this does not mean that it will be more lethal.
- tomp 5y agoThis is also in contrast to what I learned about illnesses - basically that the more “evolutionary successful” ones are the ones that are less dangerous, and kill the victim slower - think HIV or herpes. Which, even logically, makes sense - it turns out that a mildly infectious alive person walking around is a better reproduction vector for the virus than a highly infectious dead person.
- timr 5y ago> The short explanation is that the viruses that tend to win do so because they reproduce faster. Such a virus will grow faster inside a person, and will make that person more infectious, faster. It will also kill that person faster. There is not a single part of this sentence that is actually true: 1) the Delta variant does not "reproduce faster", except perhaps in the broad sense that it (may) be more successful in a population than other strains. 2) the variant does not "grow faster inside a person". This is nonsense. 3) "will make that person more infectious, faster." Also nonsense. There's no evidence of this, nor any bioplausibility for the statement. There's limited evidence that viral loads are higher, but that isn't the same thing. 4) "it will also kill a person faster". There's no evidence of this, either. This paragraph is exactly what's wrong with Pueyo, in a nutshell: he takes a tenable fact ("Delta is more fit in the population") and twists it in ways that sound plausible and scary to laymen, but that are absolutely not supported by science or evidence.
- throwitaway1235 5y agoCan we provide the data necessary for young men to take one of the mRNA vaccines for Covid-19? The question. What percentage of men under 40 have had a cardiovascular event, specifically myocarditis, after taking the Phizer or Moderns shot? Primary reason I haven't been vaccinated yet.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> What percentage of men under 40 have had a cardiovascular event, specifically myocarditis, after taking the Phizer or Moderns shot? https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/new-information-for-parents-on-myocarditis-and-covid-19-vaccines-202107012523 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/new-information-for-pare... > Doing the math, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) notes that for every million doses given, there have been 67 cases of heart inflammation in boys 12 to 17 (nine in girls of that age group), 56 in those aged 18 to 24 (six in girls), and 20 in males 25 to 29 (three in girls). It's not exactly "under 40", but if you're in that 25-29 age group, it's 0.002%. If you're in that higher-risk 12-17s group, 0.0067%. I'm fairly comfortable rounding that down to 0% for my personal risk evaluations, especially given "majority of cases have been mild".
- throwitaway1235 5y agoThank you for providing numbers.
- mandmandam 5y agoHere, try numbers from an actual study: "Clot risk to 18-39s from AstraZeneca vaccine is twice as high as Covid death risk, Euro study finds" - https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-40328123.html https://www.irishexaminer.com/news/arid-40328123.html
- rcxdude 5y agoThose are not the numbers requested, given mRNA vaccines was specifically asked for.
- shireboy 5y agoOne question I hope some HNer can help me with, that I'm not seeing answered: How is _testing_ affected by these variants? This is relevant to me as I've had symptoms but tested negative with BinaxNow, and now have to decide on some activities.
- mchusma 5y agoWhy the heck have we still banned children from getting the vaccine? This article doesn't address this 1 time, and this is IMO the most important issue related to covid today. Quite frankly, I don't care if anti-vaxers get COVID (there is some nuance to this, but basically true). There is only 1 large group in the US that is banned entirely getting a vaccine, and that is children. We need to find a way to un-ban this thing now. Vaccines are safe & effective. Just let doctors and parents make their own decisions about giving children vaccines. I have 3 children, 6, 5, and 2. Covid is about half as dangerous as drowning for them. Sure, that isn't a ton, and not as much as the elderly, but I worry about them drowning! I would give all of them a smaller dose right now without hesitation. But I can't have that option, because the government has banned it. We keep making the same mistake. "Lets ban vaccines for a long time, run tests, and let people die so that people have confidence in the vaccines." Then, here we are, with like half the country turned anti-vaxer. Banning vaccines is a complete and utter disaster from a policy perspective.
- fitzie 5y agothe one thing I wanted to know "is aquired immunity from other strains effective against delta" isn't mentioned or discussed. perhaps the door knockers will have the answers I need.
- joelbondurant 5y agoDiaper face alert!