27 ms·
Peter Thiel turned a Roth IRA into a $5B tax-free piggy bank
- foolzcrow 5y agoThe writer of this article sounds jealous and intellectually small.
- aurizon 5y agoYes, this is what it was made for. I got mine up to $150,000 based on the annual increment and a few smart buy/sell. I wish I had bought $50,000 Apple at $2, it would have turned into $25 million. A few like Thiel do better. Want to hurt Thiel? Hurt us all is your only way. Block options etc, so only trading shares can go in. No 'popcorn' shares that expand by 100 to one or more after they vest etc.
- vernie 5y agoThe usual response to any criticism of Thiel on HN: Actually this rocks!
- aurizon 5y agoI did not criticise Thiel at all, he did well. That said he did have the ability to capture the entire leap from option pennies into mature trading stock at many many dollars, and roll that over a few times.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- papito 5y agoAny suggestion on HN that Peter Thiel is a shit-tier human and a monster will get you downvotes. The funny thing is, there is never any verbal defense - just downvotes.
- peter422 5y agoI thought his book on startups was very well done and interesting. However this seems quite shady. The rich should still have to pay taxes.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThey do have to pay taxes. Maybe Congress should not pass laws that exempt them from paying taxes, or require them to pay more taxes.
- papito 5y agoCongress doesn't write laws - people like Peter Thiel do. You sound like these billionaires are innocent virgins. "Oppsies, I made all these billions because the incompetent congress let me do it". Uh huh.
- cinntaile 5y agoIt's a pretty smart loophole but it's not like he came up with this. He has tax specialists for that. Now, it's probably not a good idea for loopholes like these to exist. Articles like these can certainly make a difference to close them. Although it's definitely not black and white, excluding private shares would be too broad imo but maybe a different mechanism to determine the value should be used. More general I'd say Peter Thiel is both loved and hated and everything in between on HN, there is no real consensus.
- jrochkind1 5y agoWhy would excluding private shares be too broad? What portion of non-super-rich IRA's do you think have private shares in them? Probably approaching zero, right? Do people really need private shares to be able to set up retirement accounts? People can buy private shares when they have access to do so, they just can't use their IRA for it.
- cinntaile 5y agoI don't have any experience with the US tax system but where I live we have certain accounts that exclude private shares (and many other things). The main problem is valuing these shares correctly and if this can be done in an appropriate way I think it makes sense to not exclude them. For example... Private shares can be traded and are sometimes relatively liquid even though they're not public, in that case the trading price should be pretty representative of its real value.
- not2b 5y agoNo, it isn't what it was made for. You're limited to a $2000 contribution. Claiming that the value of a share of PayPal was 1/10 of a cent was nonsense. He found a loophole, sure, but it's morally fraudulent even if legally allowed. To close the loophole, putting private shares into a Roth IRA should be banned because they have no true market price that indicates their worth.
- bklyn11201 5y agoPrecisely. Was anyone else allowed to buy Paypal shares at 1/10 of a cent in 1999? If he alone marked this price, how would it not be fraudulent?
- jandrese 5y agoHe basically bought those shares from himself, which is why he was able to set the price arbitrarily low. The point of the Roth IRA is to encourage middle and lower class people to invest in their retirement by offering a tax incentive. But to avoid being abused by the rich the total yearly contribution limit is set very low. Thiel avoided this limit by simply selling himself a huge amount of stock for fractions of a penny on the dollar, knowing the actual price on the open market would be far higher. However, nobody can prove that the price of the private share would have been higher at the time because they weren't on a market. It would be like if you were trying to avoid taxes by selling your 1,000 acre mansion to a LLC that you own for $1 and paying the tax on that $1. This doesn't work for real estate, but the Roth IRA system is not as sophisticated so you can get away with it.
- icedchai 5y ago$2000 hasn't been the contribution limit for almost 20 years. It's $6K now, but we could argue that it's still not enough. Private companies that are raising money have a valuation on them done periodically ("409A valuation"), and this is what private stock options and common shares are based on. This is the IRS's own rules.
- silicon2401 5y ago> He found a loophole, sure, but it's morally fraudulent even if legally allowed. Morality is relative. You can't legally police other people based on your personal morality. To me, morality is maximizing your self-benefit, so there's nothing wrong with what Thiel did. If other people disagree, then there are plenty of avenues to campaign for outlawing what he did.
- throw0101a 5y agoMethod: > Yet, from the start, a small number of entrepreneurs, like Thiel, made an end run around the rules: Open a Roth with $2,000 or less. Get a sweetheart deal to buy a stake in a startup that has a good chance of one day exploding in value. Pay just fractions of a penny per share, a price low enough to buy huge numbers of shares. Watch as all the gains on that stock — no matter how giant — are shielded from taxes forever, as long as the IRA remains untouched until age 59 and a half. Then use the proceeds, still inside the Roth, to make other investments.
- patentatt 5y agoI also wonder if they can borrow against it. It would seem a pretty low risk loan for a banker to make, and it would allow people to access the money arbitrarily, negating the one downside or limitation. So yet another way that the rich can basically avoid paying any taxes. Does anyone know of any limitations or rules restricting what you can invest the contents of an IRA in? Can you set up a business, sell your IRA shares of the business, then borrow against that value? Basically a foolproof way to avoid paying any taxes ever. The best part is the interest rate just has to be lower than the tax rate, not even the rate of return, right? Incredible. I think Romney was roasted for doing the same thing with his IRA. Seems like any wealthy person could and should be doing this.
- HWR_14 5y agoRoths are bad collateral in general, because they are a special asset that survives bankruptcy (up to a certain level). Now, Thiel would actually care about his Roth getting chopped to only a few million, so in this case we'd have to look at what laws prevent that, which I don't know. Edit: Using a Roth as collateral is apparently prohibited under IRS rules 4975(c)(1)(B)
- mywittyname 5y agoI hope a law is passed that hits this kind of behavior with stiff penalties. Thiel isn't the first to do something like this. It is incredibly common. The letter of the law is that annual contributions are capped, and the spirit of that law is that this is done to keep these accounts from becoming tax-free, judgement-proof shelters for insane amounts of wealth. Perhaps caps on Roth the value of Roth IRAs and a limit of the type of assets held in them to certain bonds and publicly traded stocks. Somewhere between $1MM and $10MM with an annual CPI adjustment is probably a fair cap amount.
- m_ke 5y agoTwitter thread breaking this down https://mobile.twitter.com/propublica/status/1408002436124626946 https://mobile.twitter.com/propublica/status/140800243612462...
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhy did ProPublica omit exactly when the funding round for additional millions was in tweet 10 and 11? > 10/ So. >Right pointing backhand index IRS records show that in 1999 Thiel purchased 1.7 million shares of his startup, which would soon become PayPal, for just $1,700 — a tenth of a penny per share. > 11/ Even though Thiel's startup received millions in funding within months, Pensco still told the IRS these founders' shares were worth less than $1,700 at the end of 1999. >See where this is going? The only reason I can think of is ProPublica intended to suggest Thiel committed fraud by misstating the company’s valuation in 1999, but ProPublica wants to maintain plausible deniability because the funding round did not happen in 1999. It is great that ProPublica is pointing out how tax deductions/exemptions/credits allow for loopholes to exist, but I do not see a reason for them go after specific people for using them. Edit: copied tweets for easy reference
- anm89 5y agoWow they sure try to sledgehammer the fact that thiel has a lot of money here with the first 3 paragraphs and visuals making sure that you understand that 5 billion is in fact a lot of money.
- HWR_14 5y agoThat's five billion reasons for the IRS to comb through the transactions looking for prohibited self-dealing.
- anm89 5y agoSure, I absolutely think they should pursue it. I'm just saying, say the guy is rich once. You didn't even need to say it once, 95% of everyone reading knows very well that he is rich as hell. I don't need a visual to explain to me that 5 Billion is more than 30k
- HWR_14 5y agoI'm not sure if that's true. Even though I know (intellectually) how much 5 billion is, I find myself unable to truly grasp it.
- papito 5y agoI am sweating here the fact that I am making more than is allowed in order to contribute. Fidelity lets me, so I do, but someone like Thiel, of course, can find ways. How in the f*k do you invest into startups with something that is not publicly traded anyway? Was PayPal over the counter? Why was it so cheap?
- HWR_14 5y agoYou can invest in many asset classes in a Roth. You can buy a house. What I'm interested in is if Theil offered to invest $100 from his Roth at a $1,000 valuation with a handshake that he would then invest $1,000,000 at a $100,000,000 valuation. Or numbers that make more sense. Of course, if you're not an accredited investor, you cannot invest in startups. The idea is you could not recover from a loss. So I have no idea why a Roth should be allowed to invest as an accredited investor.
- missedthecue 5y agoThe accredited investor rules irk me. Not because investing in startups is a good way to accumulate wealth, but because of the double standard. The government happily separates literally tens of billions of dollars from poor people every year through the lottery, why can't we let those people crowdfund interesting new ideas if they want to?
- JacobDotVI 5y agoMitt Romney did this as well (although only to the tune of $100M). It was discussed in 2012 in various news outlets: https://www.investopedia.com/managing-wealth/grow-ira-100-million-plus/ https://www.investopedia.com/managing-wealth/grow-ira-100-mi...
- vmception 5y agoThats where I got the inspiration from for thinking about a lot of accounting differently. Financial engineering that people seem to neglect or be to scared of considering. With him sometimes Bain Capital made separate share classes, and I think they would give massive dividends periodically to the separate share class that only the 401k investors at Bain Capital would receive. I think its a really great strategy! Buffett should be doing that in Berkshire Hathaway for their employees instead of being sad about how much tax his secretary pays
- xkjkls 5y agoOr, the government should change the tax code to not make this possible and make the advantages of doing this moot. People need to be taxed, and we shouldn't have a system which requires a bunch of extra paperwork just for people to avoid it.
- vmception 5y agoThese simplistic ideas are exactly why it never will happen Roth versions of tax deferred accounts only exists because the government is an irresponsible spender and needed revenues. It made the contract with the people because its like a degenerate crack addict child scrounging for cash, in its case only to keep convincing international investors that it can slowly pay debt. Wow the contract worked and you just caught on 22 years later. What is your issue with people making good trades in a tax deferred and tax exempt accounts? That it needs more revenues again? The government will be fine, international investors are content with its revenue sources. These kinds of accounts are already subject to massive penalties and even UBTI regulations
- vmception 5y agoI do this with my 401ks and IRAs and Roth products too and unlike my non-profit entities in the 501 tax section the big trouble with the 400 tax section is that you cant do in-kind contributions So you cant contribute assets you have to contribute cash and then buy the assets, whereas with nonprofits you can also contribute assets directly This is just a small administrative hurdle, when you have contractual authority over an organization you can write options agreements and other grants that your 400 section tax deferred entity can afford. Self directed 400 section entities are typically formed as trusts, so it is easy to interact with them as distinct investors even if you are signing both sides of every contract. I think its funny in the article where the person quoted said they were “in favor of change” to the tax code. Add in kind contribution to tax deferred products like 401ks and IRAs!
- boringg 5y agoOne of the thing that sucks about all these billionaires running end run around the tax system (outside of the obvious pay your fair share) is that they then have a bigger and bigger war chess to splash around. Anyone else who is competing the investment arena has to either play by the same rules or can't compete. It inherently makes more people have to buy into these end-run tax scenarios or risk being left behind. In this case it looks Peter Thiel just went all in on the ROTH IRA beyond what anyone else did. Its not to dissimilar from the Countrywide CEO saying he was in a forced situation to get into subprime even though he had not interest and though it was a bad investment. If he didn't the board would vote him out. Recognize it is different but its kind of not unless the rules of the game change (which they may be in real time if this propublica billionaire take down works).
- rs999gti 5y ago> One of the thing that sucks about all these billionaires running end run around the tax system (outside of the obvious pay your fair share) How is what Thiel did an end around? He paid taxes on his contributions - https://www.hrblock.com/tax-center/income/retirement-income/how-roth-ira-contributions-are-taxed https://www.hrblock.com/tax-center/income/retirement-income/...
- boringg 5y agoI don't disagree - I would say that he definitely leaned in on the letter of the law and leaned away from the spirit of the law. $5B in untaxed gains is frankly both impressive in that he generated those returns and also feels a bit unfair to the rest of us who have to pay cap gains on all our smaller wins.
- dcolkitt 5y agoI think the central fallacy is that you're assuming more money makes it easier to achieve higher returns. For the vast majority of finance, you get diminishing returns to scale. There are many investment strategies that have limited capacity, and as you get bigger you either have to dilute or take increasingly risky positions. The phenomenon's pretty ubiquitous among hedge funds. Tons of funds produce stellar returns at $100 million AUM, then use that track record to grow to a $1 billion+ and all of a sudden put up mediocre results.
- prezjordan 5y agoI miss the days when the unfathomably rich would at least build a university or a park or something. The future is just so boring.
- FanaHOVA 5y agoThe Thiel Fellowship allowed Vitalik to drop out of school and work full time on ETH. And that's just one of the recipients.
- gaze 5y agowhy is that a good thing?
- fastball 5y agoSeems fairly equivalent to funding a new building at a university that is already mostly populated by rich kids, who by and large are doing things less useful to society than building a decentralized computing platform used around the world.
- arkitaip 5y agoBecause building for the privileged is the only thing the filthy rich can do. That or funding a shitty decentralized platform.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dnautics 5y agoAlthough I'm a pretty huge skeptic of the performance of the thiel fellowship (knowing some fellows personally and also knowing some of the showrunners), I don't think calling it a rich kid's club is fair, with the exception of Austin Russel.
- fastball 5y ago
- nrmitchi 5y agoWhat I don't understand about this whole maneuver is that Roth transactions must be made at arms length; ie, "Transactions must be made at arm’s length and not involve the IRA owner or a member of his or her family." An example of this is that if you use a Roth to invest in property, you are not allowed to use it personally, not allowed to manage it or do maintenance yourself, etc. Prohibited transactions risk tainting (and thus exposing) the entire account. How is Thiel investing in his own company not considered a prohibited investment?
- avelis 5y agoIt is IMO but who is going to actually enforce that?
- vmception 5y agoThats not the issue here
- joshfraser 5y agoMy guess is he used a self-directed IRA that he converted into a Roth.
- vasilipupkin 5y agodid he place the shares into IRA before any outside round though? because otherwise, he would have violated contribution limits?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI would assume he did, unless there is any proof otherwise. ProPublica specifically omitted this information, so assuming that it was all kosher seems reasonable.
- joshfraser 5y agoHe would have deposited them at company formation when they were essentially worthless.
- marris 5y agoDoes anyone know whether this kind of tax planning is available to today's startup investors? Are there any administrators which support this kind of illiquid investment?
- vmception 5y agoYes, Roth IRAs are quite simple as you can literally just have a stack of cash in your apartment labelled “Roth IRA” if you wanted to. All the reindeer games with IRAs are just so the accounting is hard to mess up, with separate usually electronic accounts.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- w0mbat 5y agoHeadline could be "Person uses retirement account to save money for retirement."
- _jal 5y agoWhy not? Similarly, another of today's headlines could also be 'Property damage inconveniences some in Florida'.
- sushid 5y agoThe intent of the article is to point out how the rich truly take advantage of existing tax laws/loopholes to stay even more rich. No one is claiming Thiel did anything illegal. But it does seem a bit preposterous that billionaires can amass $5B Roth IRA accounts.
- ne0flex 5y agoI'm curious how he was able to get a Roth IRA in the first place. Apparently Roth IRA began in 1997 and there's a contribution limit if you make above a certain amount.Given that Thiel started "Thiel Capital Management" in 1996, I'm willing to bet he was above the earning limit.
- xkjkls 5y agoProbably by a traditional IRA to Roth IRA conversion.
- hammeiam 5y agoAnybody can have a Roth IRA. Even if you're over the income limit for a Roth, you can still convert a traditional to a Roth IRA after you pay taxes on the amount. These conversions are pretty common and well known.
- anonAndOn 5y agoLike every other SV startup, he was paid a decent salary with lots of stock and thus qualified under the income limits.
- SamReidHughes 5y agoThis is based on stolen personal data.
- scop 5y agoIndeed. I'm surprised this is not a main part of the HN conversation. It concerns me that the IRS leaking personal financial information is not the main story.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- suyash 5y agoThat's a genius move, we should all learn from this and take advantage. Nice job Peter!
- Chris2048 5y agoThiel then used the wealth amassed in his Roth to invest in other startups How? I thought the whole point is you can't touch this money? Did he take on loans, promising to pay them back once he was 60? In 2004, he provided Facebook's first large outside cash infusion, investing $500K. His Facebook shares would grow tax-free in his Roth. I'm not sure I understand. Did he invest in FB and independently purchase shares (less than 2k pa) in his Roth? So the 500K was not the private purchase of shares?
- naturalauction 5y agoIt's possible he already had 500k in his Roth by 2004.
- fastball 5y agoYou buy 2000 shares with your Roth IRA for $1 per share. They appreciate in value to $1,000 per share. You sell the shares, now there is $2,000,000 cash value in your Roth IRA, which you can use to make other investments. Repeat ad infinitum without those transactions incurring any sort of tax burden, as long as you don't withdraw any of that money until you're 60.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoWhat do you mean by can't touch the money in a Roth? It stays in the roth account, but you can buy and sell assets as often as you want with the money you put in.
- misiti3780 5y agoHow did he buy non-public-ally trade FB shares in his Roth?
- missedthecue 5y agoWith a self-directed IRA, you can make all kinds of investments, including real-estate and private companies.
- ve55 5y agoWhat seems most unfair here is how difficult dealing with private equity is as a normal person; the entire purpose of the Roth IRA is that you do not pay any taxes afterwards, and that is how it functions for everyone, whether you are rich or not. On the other hand, the same cannot be said about the ability to purchase, find, and work with private equity. I understand many publications may dislike certain people (as one can note from who they choose to mention the most), but I don't see a reason why he would decline using tax-advantaged accounts just because he has attained significantly larger wealth and roi than most others using them.
- didibus 5y agoI agree about access to private equity, but did you read the whole thing? He purchased shares of his own startup at 0.001 cents, way below market rate. To me, that's clearly not the intent of Roth IRA. This means any startup founder can simply put their ownership shares into their Roth IRA and never be taxed on their company growth. It also doesn't seem they singled out Thiel, he has the biggest Roth IRA they know off, seems logical to discuss him the most.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fastball 5y agoHow is there a market rate if his startup was not publicly trading? The nominal value of the shares in my startup are £0.01. Sure, that's not what we've sold shares for, but the price we have sold them for was purely what the buyer was willing to pay for them.
- GordonS 5y agoSo, I was reading into this a bit recently after getting an equity offer (also in the UK). The "fair market value" is open to interpretation, but if the inland revenue come calling, you need to be able to explain it. For a startup with no assets that has not previously sold shares, £0.01. Is just fine. But if you've got assets, or you've previously sold shares as more than that, then quite clearly the market value is more than a penny. I mean, what better definition of "fair market value" is there than "what the buyer was willing to pay for them"?
- maerF0x0 5y agoIMO the only thing he did "wrong" was to make excellent returns within the bounds of a tax vehicle and with investment classes that most of us are typically excluded (accreditation, VC exclusivity) If we should be mad about anything it's that it's so difficult for the general public to get a good slice of diversification including the asset classes that turn 1000s into millions. Yes we can go work at a startup, but that is all the eggs in one basket. Better to spread that risk around 10+ investments like VCs do
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rajup 5y agoI agree. All the annoying animations and hyperbole in the article notwithstanding, it does not seem as malicious as the article tries to portray it. It is rather disappointing that there are barriers to some of these investments but I think without these barriers you would open the gates for all sorts of malicious actors taking advantage of unsophisticated investors.
- maerF0x0 5y agoI wonder if there are good VC firms that would let people participate in funds around the $1000 threshold? Like if I could give Garry Tan $1000 to just participate, no questions or interaction required just fill out the forms sign the check, see you in 10yrs... I know part of the issue is that many VCs have a high touch process for the people signing $100k checks, but maybe if they made it more streamlined they could generate more diverse investor base and just say to them "You wont hear from us, no you cant help, see you in 10yrs" kind of mentality.
- jppope 5y agoThey actually are opening up to unaccredited investors, you just need to have a CFP or CPA or something like that (not sure of the actual requirements, I just know that they recently changed them)
- 5y ago
- jb775 5y agoNot his fault the tax rules are broken for the ultra-rich. They always have been throughout history...so I don't expect any changes. If we tried, it would require regulation on how politicians can be compensated for the rest of their lives after taking office. Need to close the revolving door where politicians help out rich people/corporations while in office, then are compensated indirectly after leaving office.
- gameswithgo 5y agoSure it is, not his alone, but the ultra rich bribe the government to make sure the rules are broken. They are all at fault. Any attempt to fix these things is stopped by the ultra rich. They have even put their own people on the supreme court! (see comments by the Koch brothers stating this explicitly)
- drzaiusapelord 5y ago>Not his fault the tax rules are broken for the ultra-rich. This isn't some accidental software defect. The rich write these laws to their benefit. He's part of the class whose fault it absolutely is and considering his political position as a conservative, he advocates and helps keep up the corrupt system he benefits from directly, even if he didn't lobby for this specific tax regulation.
- joshe 5y agoAnyone actually done this with normal stock options (NSO if it matters) and have advice? My understanding is that it might be achievable with Pensco as the IRA custodian but I'd be interested in hearing how it worked in practice
- vmception 5y agoI’ve done it, you have to have executive authority over the issuing company to do it, as other directors and their legal counsel are too uninspired to do anything outside of the norm. Your IRA is a legal entity and you can grant an option to it. It needs the cash to exercise it. Options can have shares at any price in them, such as discounted to nothing but it comes down to which consequences you care about. Making a potentially screwy 409a valuation isn't a big deal, but also avoided if done before other investors come in. Either way it can be a tolerable level of consequence.
- ffggvv 5y agoi don’t get why twitter banned hunter biden discussion or BLM founder because they were private. but we’re all comfortable seeing the private tax records of these individuals that were stolen. the media has such massive biases
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- arbitragy 5y ago1.7m shares of Paypal at .001 is worth 5B at the current share price of 295. Obviously debatable whether you can mark shares of your own company / PE firm sponsor equity / etc at near zero in a tax sheltered vehicle. But if Thiel held shares in a personal account and borrowed against them he wouldn't have owed tax either, as unrealized capital gains are not taxed. Buffett, Musk, Bloomberg, etc. all have the vast majority of their wealth in businesses they founded, and have subsequently paid de minimuis taxes relative to their net worth. All have arguably made significant contributions to society and world at large, magnitudes higher than their net worth and taxes paid.
- vineyardmike 5y ago> All have arguably made significant contributions to society and world at large, magnitudes higher than their net worth and taxes paid. Very arguable. I would take up that argument. I don't believe this too be true.
- nickpinkston 5y agoI can't really blame Peter for taking advantage of the law. We should mostly blame our lawmakers for allowing our pro-oligarchy legal/financial system to exist.
- nickpp 5y agoAm I missing something? He didn’t seem to do anything illegal. This is the second article from ProPublica which: - accuses people of doing something that is perfectly legal - singles out one or two such people and exposes their private matters Is that ok just because they are rich? There is another comment thread going on right now where people are absolutely furious that they are tracked for targeted ads. How would they feel if their tax info was displayed online for all to see?
- medvezhenok 5y agoThere is an argument whether investing in securities that are non-public and have no official price (especially ones you have a controlling stake in) should be illegal (even if it isn't right now). I think that's what the article is about. If he contributed $5000, bought bitcoin at 1 cent and had the same amount of money now, it would be a non-issue.
- NonEUCitizen 5y agoand blames people for following the law instead of congress for writing the law as such.
- ffggvv 5y agoand hypocritically the media publishes this info and discusses it. yet refusing to discuss other disclosures as "private".
- kyleblarson 5y agoAnother sensationalist headline about people doing things that are not illegal. This article feels especially egregious since it is based on stolen IRS data.
- incogitomode 5y agoI wonder why the Roth didn't include any sort of cap or maximum exemption? It seems like that would have been an easy safety to build in, like a stop-loss for the government to avoid intentional and unintentional abuse leading to tax shortfalls. The federal gift tax has a limit of $11.7 million, seems like a gift to your older self might be considered similarly.
- xkjkls 5y agoI think they just never expected someone could use it to amass this much money. A $5500 a year contribution limit seems incredibly limiting.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- creddit 5y agoThe propublica tax leak is monstrously fucked up and I'm constantly shocked at how little anyone seems to question the validity of using personal IRS records for reporting.
- nrmitchi 5y ago"I'm constantly shocked at how little anyone seems to question the validity of using self-reported evidence that shows our one-sided the US tax system is for reporting"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway2048 5y agoim shedding a single tear for thiel's billions
- jdminhbg 5y agoThe good news is there's no way this total lack of privacy controls at the IRS will ever be used against non-billionaires.
- runako 5y agoIANAL but this topic is of interest. Without commenting on whether this was legal at the time Thiel made this transaction, it appears it would not be permissible under current tax law. (Update: the relevant text in the statute appears to have been in effect as early as 1995: https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?hl=false&edition=1994&req=granuleid%3AUSC-2000-title26-section4975&num=0 https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?hl=false&edition=1994&re...) Specifically, the law explicitly disqualifies anyone who is: >an officer, director (or an individual having powers or responsibilities similar to those of officers or directors), a 10 percent or more shareholder, or a highly compensated employee (earning 10 percent or more of the yearly wages of an employer) of a person described in subparagraph (C), (D), (E), or (G) (Source: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/4975 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/4975) So the relatively plain language would almost certainly include anyone who's a co-founder involved in actively managing a company today. This kind of blatant tax avoidance is going to end badly for our tax regime, which is likely to overcorrect.
- oxymoran 5y agoHe’s a quasi libertarian that doesn’t trust the government with his tax money. What was expected? Further, if you know that’s what he think and it’s within the law, what are we doing here with this expose? It would be one thing if he was critical of other people for working within the law to avoid taxes and you caught him being a hypocrite but this is not that. If we are going to be critical here, it should be of whatever loop holes allow this.
- mywittyname 5y agoHe has no problem taking the government's money though. If he didn't trust the government, I would expect that he'd refuse to work with them on the grounds of not being able to trust them.
- missedthecue 5y agoI believe that the parent is implying that Thiel doesn't trust the government to use his money prudently, not that the government is liable to cheat him out of a contract. That's not really a double standard any more than taking a paycheck from google while using duckduckgo on your PC at home is a double standard.
- breck 5y agoThe data here is super interesting. The tone and editorializing are idiotic. That being said, ultimately lawmakers are at fault. We need to start thinking of law as code. We want to minimize the complexity of law, just like you want to minimize the complexity of code. I have a new way to do that: https://github.com/treenotation/research/blob/master/papers/paper3/countingComplexity.pdf https://github.com/treenotation/research/blob/master/papers/... 2D Languages will be the future of the law and democracy.
- vmception 5y agoAll the “rich people tax” articles have an idiotic tone as if they’ve found a smoking gun of …. something They really prey on ignorance
- rglover 5y agoAs well as envy and greed, though, they'll never admit it.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoThe lawmakers are quite literally the same people who advise rich people on taxes. The funniest thing I ever saw was an African civil servant who had gone private now telling foreign companies how to fuck the government he used to work for.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- quickthrower2 5y agoWhat is a 2D language?
- breck 5y agoA language that can be near completely specified by a stack of 2D grammars of increasing abstraction. Binary notation is a general purpose syntax in 1 dimension. There exists a 2D general purpose syntax, where you not only have columns but all rows, and from there you can build abstractions from binary to numeral systems to letters to words to structs to systems.
- bosswipe 5y agoThe rich have defunded their police, the IRS has no resources to go after complex schemes like these. But they consider it out of bounds when poor people demand the street harrasment police be defunded.
- missedthecue 5y agoThe article actually says that Thiel was the target of a multi-year IRS audit, which didn't turn up any irregularities.
- vineyardmike 5y agoHe's known to be a litigious PITA so i'm sure they're worried about maintaining resources for eaasier-to-win audits.
- MandieD 5y agoI cannot put any money at all into a Roth IRA, despite making a decent but non-astounding IT salary (below the caps), because I'm an American living abroad who had the temerity to marry a foreigner and am stuck in "married, filing separately". I cannot use similar retirement plans in the country I live in, because no brokerage here wants to deal with non-rich people who are US citizens or have US income tax obligations (why I do not file jointly - at least one of us needs to be able to keep paying into a retirement account here!) Words cannot express my contempt for Thiel, who is apparently still a citizen of the country I live in. I'm pulling for the Finanzamt, however they can swing it.
- cannabis_sam 5y agoTax is a joke to rich people, and that’s the exact reasons economic inequality is a problem..
- missedthecue 5y agoIn the USA, the top 1% make 20% of the income but pay almost 40% of the taxes. That seems very progressive, not a 'joke'.
- tomjakubowski 5y agoCareful. The top 1% pay 40% of federal income tax, not of all taxes. Federal income tax is around half of total federal tax revenue. I also wonder, is that "20% of all income" figure 20% of all taxable income, or all declared income?
- richwater 5y ago> figure 20% of all taxable income, or all declared income? Since we're baselessly speculating, it might be 100!
- scep12 5y agoThe top 1% by what? Income? Here's another one: the top 0.001% make 0% of the income and pay 0% of the taxes.
- cannabis_sam 5y agoYou, apparently, missed the cue
- misiti3780 5y agoThis is off subject, but given that someone illegally leaked these tax returns on the richest, is anyone else not surprised we have heard zero about Trump's taxes? (I assume they are riddled with stuff like this)
- vineyardmike 5y agothey leaked a few years ago.
- misiti3780 5y agoya that is true, the NYT did that big expose, I forgot about that.
- underseacables 5y agoCan one learn this skill?
- lamontcg 5y agoMake a really good bet on a stock in your Roth that pops something like >10,000x. In his case it was Paypal shares. Then you have a massive tax-free investment shelter and you can be an angel investor for startups through it and seek out another >100x investment with it. It helps a lot to have better information and be more plugged into the investment culture than your average person on the street reading the NYT and trying to sort out where to invest their 401k. It also helps to be a sociopath so that all you care about is returns. There's a bit of an oversight here where the tax-free returns in a Roth shelter are completely unlimited, they probably should have been capped where massive windfalls became taxed some way, but rich people and those who carry water for them, would have flipped out.
- pjfin123 5y agoHow has all this information form the IRS leaked? ProPublica seems to have accessed many of the richest American's tax data. Is this something one person could do? How many people have that kind of access?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gwern 5y agoAn IRS insider leaked it, obviously. Super illegal and against the IRS culture, but now it's out there. What's puzzling is how apparently selective the leaked material all is. ProPublica has all these very specific memos and tax return info about Thiel's Roth IRA, and yet, they are only aware of Thiel's long IRS mega-audit (and that he won 100%), and don't know that it was in fact all about auditing his use of the Roth IRA trick? (Or that Fortune reported about the Paypal mafia's use of the Roth IRA back in like 2009?) Very odd.
- astrange 5y agoWhy do they have info about his Roth IRA anyway? That wouldn't be part of a tax record. Maybe it's from the audit? (Similar issues came up when people wanted to see Trump's tax returns to find out "if he was really wealthy". They wouldn't show that. Of course they might show a lot of other things.)
- NonEUCitizen 5y agoPart of the article mentioned the IRA was disclosed in his application for New Zealand residency. So does NZ publish residency applications? Or was that also leaked?
- sgpl 5y agoNot commenting on the morality of the leak but given the IRS has been gutted [0] over the years by those in power, perhaps this insider was sick of seeing the public narrative on taxes be completely different from what was happening privately. [0] https://www.propublica.org/article/how-the-irs-was-gutted https://www.propublica.org/article/how-the-irs-was-gutted
- exabrial 5y agoGood for him. I don't think this is a problem for a lot of reasons. First he didn't break any laws, second, US taxes are a waste anyway. They'll either be used to fight pointless wars, sent to special interests (See Pelosi's family), or used to fuel racial injustice with militarization of police. The only way out to is to stop feeding the beast.
- calkuta 5y agoGood. What's wrong, the government doesn't have enough money?
- giantg2 5y agoI'd love to even double my IRA. Sadly, I dont think this article will be helpful to me.
- tapmap 5y agoWhat people are missing here is the fact that Peter Theil is investing in new companies that go on to create thousands of jobs and billions of dollars in taxes every year. He risks his capital to create these new companies, and a lot of his investments go to zero. The next effect of this is that he's generating a lot more tax revenue for the IRS that he's saving from his Roth IRA.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cdolan 5y agoI am aware of the fact its popular to dislike the ultra-rich, but is this not worrying to the general public? ProPublica has obtained a trove of IRS tax return data on thousands of the country’s wealthiest people, covering more than 15 years. Someone leaked not only Gates, Bezos, Musk, etc data, but thousands of private citizen's intimate financial disclosures (edit: seemingly for the purpose of weaponizing the data against them). What crime were these thousands of people convicted of to deserve this?
- eloff 5y agoSome countries have public tax returns (Sweden? Norway? One of those Nordic countries.) I think probably they should be public data. That aside, for very rich people, having them be public is in the interest of the public as it reveals the shady stuff they do to dodge taxes (legally.)
- cdolan 5y agoDebating wether tax returns should or should not be public is a great debate to have, I agree. The country should be having that debate. And if we decide tax returns should be made public, it should happen in the future so everyone is on the same page. The fact is that US tax returns are private information, regardless of what other countries are doing or what you and I think should be done.
- machinebun 5y ago> Debating wether tax returns should or should not be public is a great debate to have, I agree. The country should be having that debate. And if we decide tax returns should be made public, it should happen in the future so everyone is on the same page. The same way the Snowden leaks were instrumental into regulation about surveillance, leaks like this are instrumental in crafting better tax policy, so I would say they are a public good. It's also not-quite possible to do it via completely legal means (as vested interest opposition is too big and has too much capital - the only way to battle against them seems to be to do it via not-so-legal means). So in this case the fight is punching up against people in positions of power, not down onto people that have no power, so I don't see a direct issue with it. If you have power, you should also have the proportionate responsibility.
- esotericimpl 5y agowatch out propublica, Hulk Hogan might be bankrolling another lawsuit soon.
- hash872 5y agoIs it legal for a startup employee to purchase shares with their Roth? I understand that an officer in the company probably cannot, but if you're just an employee- does anyone know if that's permitted? I skimmed about half the comments section here, not sure if anyone answered this already. If it is legal- pretty great deal for an employee either given RSUs or options to buy them this way, no?
- Tycho 5y agoThe negativity here is misled. Thiel made investments in companies which he thought might one day be of enormous value to society. Their current valuations, and the size of his IRA, prove him right. We can thank early investors like Thiel for bringing this potential to fruition. And not only that, but Thiel has not consumed any of this well-earned wealth, instead leaving it untouched, hasn’t converted it into scarce goods and services, presumably because he didn’t see virtue in the gross materialism that consuming it would entail. These investments are heroic acts by Thiel.
- steve_adams_86 5y ago> heroic acts I don't understand - can you elaborate on why exactly this is heroic?
- Tycho 5y agoIn the sense that he developed his business acumen and foresight to an exquisite degree and was then able to take well-informed risks with his own resources that in the end produced a great outcome for society (and himself). Many people fail to develop their talents, or squander them, or are too over-cautious to use them, and they and society are the worse for it.
- steve_adams_86 5y agoThanks, appreciate you taking the time to explain.
- verall 5y agoYup, no companies are quite as valuable to society as Paypal and Palantir. I can think of few companies that have done more good for more people, and Thiel deserves every dime of that $5B for ratfucking the populace.
- bawana 5y agoAnother example of fine financial engineering. Money from financial instruments (interest income, capital gains, etc) should be restricted in its use. That money should only be usable in purchasing real goods (not options) real products and real labor. By allowing investment gains to be used for further investment, we allow increasing demand for financial instruments to drive up their prices and attract even more money. Instead of building roads, schools and paying our teachers, we are using our money to 'buy more money', an abstraction that does not really benefit us.
- listless 5y ago> Yet, from the start, a small number of entrepreneurs, like Thiel, made an end run around the rules: Open a Roth with $2,000 or less. Get a sweetheart deal to buy a stake in a startup that has a good chance of one day exploding in value. Pay just fractions of a penny per share, a price low enough to buy huge numbers of shares. Watch as all the gains on that stock — no matter how giant — are shielded from taxes forever, as long as the IRA remains untouched until age 59 and a half. Then use the proceeds, still inside the Roth, to make other investments. What? Am I missing something or is that a horrible explanation of how this works? I still don’t understand how he used a Roth to shield 5 billion from taxes. I’m much more alarmed that he gets deals on startups that nobody else does. That hardly seems fair.
- maxk42 5y agoUtterly astounded and dismayed to see this much of HN's audience completely fail to comprehend what they've read here and paint this as some sort of sinister theft. This is the law functioning as intended. Thiel's case is a one-in-100-million+ event. He may have the only Roth IRA in existence that's valued at over $5 billion. But he didn't do it by exploiting some sort of "loophole" or paying high-priced accountants to shield his assets in foreign entities offshore. He put his investments in a Roth IRA just like any of you can do. The only difference is his investments were in the top 0.0001% in terms of performance. That's generally how people get to be billionaires. And that's not even to mention that the assets in a Roth IRA are essentially worthless to him - he's not old enough to make withdrawals or take distributions tax-free and you can't borrow against a Roth IRA. The funds are essentially unavailable to him for years to come unless he wants to pay taxes and penalties. Again - this isn't a tax dodge. This is someone who used the law exactly as intended without any illegal or shady dealings and happened to be incredibly fortunate. The whole article is a hit piece designed to get whip people into a furor. And lately I've been noticing propublica publishing a lot of those.
- sida 5y agoI don't think that's true right. Peter Thiel purchased shares in Paypal at $0.001 per share, which is far below fair market value. The "theft" here is the undervaluation of the shares with which he purchased at
- concreteblock 5y agoWho sold him those shares?
- sida 5y agoIt is in the article "Mr. Thiel purchased his founders’ shares in PayPal through his Roth IRA during PayPal’s formation" I am willing the venture a guess that the initial valuation was far greater than 0.001 per share. And this was all an accounting trick to exploit IRA
- ghufran_syed 5y ago“ buy a stake in a startup that has a good chance of one day exploding in value.” the propublica people must be rich, if they can reliably identify these kind of startups - everything is easy in hindsight. They also missed the bit where thiel paid tax on the $2000, that he invested. The whole idea of retirement accounts is that you either pay the tax at the beginning, or you pay at the end.
- gumby 5y agoI have tried to do this in the past and always been told it's not possible (as an exec in the startup it wouldn't be arm's length). I guess that's what I get for following the rules. Not that my IRA would have reached the billions mark if I had managed to.
- casefields 5y agoJust like Trump—or even Thiel himself—you've gotta not be scared to sometimes amass hefty legal bills, and you can get away with a lot.
- systemBuilder 5y agoAny IRA owner with more than 50 years of average family income ($3.5m) should be required to liquidate it. These are not tax shelters for the rich! But seriously this is no different than if he owned the stock shares outright and he just chose never to sell those shares for 50 years he would pay no tax! It's how the rich have break to the system to favor Capital over labor!
- adolph 5y agoI guess in 7-10 years Ryan Holiday will have another fun book to write about a news outlet going under via a “this is not kayfabe” lawsuit. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36681909-conspiracy https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36681909-conspiracy
- ajaimk 5y agoSince when is being smart and successful a crime? I definitely would expect this from ProPublica but not Hacker News? “Hacker” News!
- NonEUCitizen 5y agoThey did not write about people who used their IRAs to invest in startups that went belly-up and lost money.
- stevenalowe 5y agoThe key quote: “Get a sweetheart deal to buy a stake in a startup that has a good chance of one day exploding in value” In other words, use your Roth IRA to invest in startups (or stocks) that do exceptionally well. I’d be more concerned about the author’s access to “secret internal IRS data”…
- hamburga 5y agoIs this practice -- putting founder shares in a Roth IRA when they are worthless -- sort of standard practice? Is everybody doing it and Thiel just did it most successfully?
- dmoy 5y agoThey really should replace 401k (and 415(c)(1)(a)), 403b, 457, IRA, etc with just TSP-for-everyone. Don't make it contingent upon employer, and don't allow additional employer-sponsored tax-advantaged space. The fact that someone working at a large tech company can put away around $70,000/yr into tax advantaged accounts is kind of insane. Not even including the crazy edge cases that come with private equity like this Thiel instance.
- stretchwithme 5y agoWhat happened is the resources put into this account were invested in highly successful things. If all investment accounts were this successful, society would be 10X or 100X or 1000X more wealthy.
- ummonk 5y agoFounders shares are typically underpriced at a nominal value - which is why they’re tied by vesting agreements to continued employment at the startup. In effect, he was investing significantly more than 2k into his tax sheltered investment in PayPal - he was investing years of work at below market salary.
- Proven 5y agoExcellent job! The less the better - taxpayer money is mostly used against the people - to grow Federal bureaucracy, limit freedoms, wage wars, and so on. This is but one example of how overpaid US government employees are, by the way. Congrats to Thiel.
- smsm42 5y agoTLDR: Roth IRA is an account where when you put money into it, it can grow untaxed. It's not a loophole or anything, it's the sole reason this type of an account exists. It's like a regular bank account, but exempted from capital gains tax - in order to stimulate retirement savings. Thiel - among others, I presume - used some of the money in this account to make some very successful investment. He didn't use any "loopholes" or tricks, except for the trick of knowing what to invest in and taking the risk. Now he has a lot of money in this account, due to his investments being successful. That's it.
- IncRnd 5y agoIt's not a zero sum game. This is such a misleading article. Contributions to a Roth IRA are made after the taxes were already paid. Sure, the money grows tax free, which is what such an IRA does. So what? When the money is distributed, taxes are paid. The only issue is that the writer is engaging in class warfare.
- conanbatt 5y agoIt is most definitely an abuse of IRA's to shield from capital gains taxes this way. It was never meant to be used for this. On Wall street bets they talk about buying options with IRA accounts (famously wsbgod for example) so it happens frequently and with large amounts.
- IncRnd 5y ago> It is most definitely an abuse of IRA's to shield from capital gains taxes this way. It was never meant to be used for this. That is what an IRA is, a shield from capital gains. They are not meant just for people who lose money or whose investment growth is very low. It's meant for people who put money into them. It's wrong to blame the successful entrepreneurs, because they were successful. You know that when he wants to use any of that money or when he has to take distributions that taxes will be paid, and those taxes will be higher compared to them having been paid along the way.
- conanbatt 5y agoThey wont be paid if he doesn't sell before 60. This will be completely untaxed. Thats the IRA abuse: its meant to be used tax deferred as a retirement scheme for a certain amount (6k a year) not for billions. But because of its mechanics you would like to put your wildest shots into IRA's (say, option trading) because it has the highest expected value in case it goes up. In the spirit of the program, there would be a cap to how much money will be shielded from capital gains tax.
- IncRnd 5y ago
- cronix 5y ago> But Thiel doesn’t need a man-made island to avoid paying taxes. He has something just as effective: a Roth individual retirement account. But Thiel doesn’t need a man-made island to avoid paying taxes. He has something just as effective: a very well-paid tax expert who knows the intricacies and complexity of the tax code that the politicians have created, and you don't.
- imgabe 5y agoSomewhere right now Peter Thiel is assembling a team of lawyers to figure out if Propublica has ever done anything that anyone can sue them for.
- AtlasBarfed 5y agoLet me guess, if you're being compensated billions in stock-based compensation, you can structure special funds and reroute that compensation to the Roth IRA?
- pyuser583 5y agoI’ve been looking at ways to minimize my own tax exposure. College savings accounts are similar to 401ks, but they usually have a limit on the amount you can save. Makes sense here.
- pyuser583 5y agoOne of the reasons this is abusive: it allows Mr. Thiel greater liquidity than other investors. Most other investors have to pay taxes when they reallocate equity. Not Mr. Thiel.
- elevenoh 5y agoCan anyone put private startup shares into a Roth IRA?
- prepend 5y agoSeems like the fix here is to limit the types of investments that can be made in a RothIRA. Just allow publicly traded instruments. The unfairness here is that Thiel was able to buy his founder shares using Roth dollars and that’s subject to abuse, since founder share costs can be set arbitrarily.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoCapital gains tax is stupid. So is income tax. Why? They both tax changes to wealth. They are damping terms in the system. They actually slow down change. I thought Social Change is what you wanted? Instead, there should be a WEALTH tax, with a rate slightly exceeding historical returns to capital (say 15%), and with a standard deduction of at least $5M. The purpose of income reporting would then be to influence the tax agency's estimate of your cumulative wealth. Capital gains tax perverts incentives: It tells people to hold on to investments, even if they now think those investments are crap, even if they would rather now allocate their capital in some other way. This is one of the reasons why ETFs are a thing, and one reason why zombie companies continue to shamble on. Roths are the only accounts WITHOUT this feature. And income tax hurts people who actually work for their money. Really rich people -- do people think some boss gives them a SALARY? That's not how it works: They live off investment income. Capital gains and dividends. Both of which are taxed less than regular income. This wealth tax would directly stabilize the system towards a state in which everyone had $5M. There are other forces at play as well, so we wouldn't end up at that equilibrium, but we'd move closer to it. Basically, if you want to change the rules of Monopoly so the game ends with EVERYONE owning some hotels, this is how you do it. But you cannot, cannot set the deduction too low. People depend on investments for their retirement. You can't destroy that. ... Now I back off from my confident-sounding rhetoric. Is this actually true? What effects would this have on investment and corporate governance? Would it create a giant market for cryptocurrency? For perk-based compensation? I'm curious what second-order effects I have overlooked.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoI don't think anyone is surprised to see rich people skipping taxes that the middle class is meant to pay. When you have a corruptible, centralised government, a political apparatus, mass media that let you convert money in manipulating large numbers of voters - the ones wielding more power will have more influence and will be able to shape society in a way that is convenient for them. Thiel even admitted it: > In an interview on the website Big Think, Thiel said the U.S. tax system has > “fairness problems” in which “you have super rich people paying a lower rate than > people in the middle or upper middle class.” The only difference between the audience of this article and Thiel is in the way this problem should be addressed. The article is obviously meant to push for the "tax the rich till there are no rich no more" narrative, Thiel instead thinks we need less government: > The answer wasn’t taxing the rich more, he said, but “taxing the middle class and > the upper middle class a lot less” and cutting their dependence on expensive > programs such as Medicare and Social Security.
- stevep98 5y agoThere was another article about another PayPal mafioso doing the same thing, Max Levchin, in Forbes back in 2012… https://www.forbes.com/sites/deborahljacobs/2012/03/20/how-facebook-billionaires-dodge-mega-millions-in-taxes/?sh=7ccdbc7558f3 https://www.forbes.com/sites/deborahljacobs/2012/03/20/how-f... It says the following: “Tax rules bar you from investing your IRA or Roth IRA in a business you control—such a “prohibited transaction” can render the IRA immediately taxable and possibly subject to penalties.” Thiel and levchin, and probably many many others have certainly skirted the spirit of the Roth IRA.