12 ms·
The real problem here is poverty and a lack of social security in the US. That's a solvable problem. It just requires the will to solve it and for whatever reas
by jillesvangurp 5y ago
The real problem here is poverty and a lack of social security in the US. That's a solvable problem. It just requires the will to solve it and for whatever reason that is actually controversial in the US.
I live in Europe. Retirement is very much on my mind but more in the sense that I need to secure a little more than just the state pension. You can live on that but only barely. A lot of European countries are lot poorer than the US. Yet retirement is a thing in those countries and not really under any threat.
The need to work and the reality that a lot of work is just busy work that isn't really that critical because all the critical work is increasingly automated does not help with this. No offense but I work doing CTO work in startups and technically it's been a long time since I did anything close to producing critical goods or services. It's nice what I do and I live on it but I can't say with a straight face that it is all that critical or important. A lot of our jobs are like that. We keep ourselves busy doing things for each other or ourselves and try to monetize that. I can probably do that beyond retirement if I stay healthy. I might even enjoy that.
Post scarcity society is not that different from where we are today (at least us privileged people working tech jobs). Poverty is increasingly having to do actual work to feed yourself. In most countries that at least gets you to retirement. The US is kind of unique in that it is very wealthy and yet does not take care of its people in the same way that much poorer countries have been doing for the last century.
- courtf 5y agoIt's broken for sure, though it's not really anything new. The US is still structurally a slave society, even if we now have the freedom to bounce between plantations (unless your visa is only sponsored by a specific one).
- Seattle3503 5y ago> The US is still structurally a slave society, even if we now have the freedom to bounce between plantations What makes you say that?
- courtf 5y agoThe country has never functioned without hordes of cheap, disposable labor that must work into their geriatric years or starve. There is no long-term stability, nor any expectation of it, unless you can become part of the owner class.
- kwere 5y agoits called reality: where people exchange their assets (time,labour) for other assets (food, cars, houses) to benefit from comparative advantages in an almost free market.
- wiredearp 5y agoIf the combined cost of housing, education, retirement, childcare and healthcare amounts to more than any average person can earn during a lifetime, these advantages are in other words never comparative to your investment of time and labor, you could argue that the free market has instituted a form of slavery even if we call it reality. You are after all working under the threat of physical harm if your healthcare depends on employment and we call that violence. Except of course in America where we call it freedom.
- bluGill 5y agoNone of those expenses are fixed. When people earn more money they spend it on more expensive houses, better education, high quality childcare (read education), and better healthcare. The amount of money you make at minimum wage would fund a nice lifestyle in 1700 - inflation adjusted. The "bathroom" would be an outhouse and a bucked of water you heat on a fire. You wouldn't have even a beat up old car to drive. There is no visible end in sight to this trend.
- dredmorbius 5y agoLaw of Rent and Iron Law of Wages say otherwise. Read Smith. Book I, Chapter 8, beginning "There are certain circumstances, however, which sometimes give the labourers an advantage" and through to "The scanty maintenance of the labouring poor, on the other hand, is the natural symptom that things are at a stand, and their starving condition that they are going fast backwards." https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_I/Chapter_8 https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations/Book_I/...
- Supermancho 5y agoThe imbalance of power between employee and employer is clearer today than at any point in history. The free market concept of equilibrium is always going to favor the (financially) wealthy, which is not an equilibrium in the sense of equitable balance. Somehow, this is controversial to say here?
- Clubber 5y agoI know it may feel like a slave to have to work to live, but it certainly isn't anything like slavery in the antebellum period. It's more akin to the old soviet adage, "So long as the bosses pretend to pay us, we will pretend to work." The hyperbole bug doesn't do an argument any favors. It's overused today.
- courtf 5y agoThe only reason it comes across as hyperbole is because of the US history of antebellum slavery. Sure, we aren't all being held against our will, subject to extreme violence at any time, but the prison system does something pretty close. Many slaves throughout history lived relatively comfortably, and even Frederick Douglass described wage slavery in the US. It's a scary, controversial word, I guess, but the article depicts a pretty scary world for grandma to end up in too, if you ask me.
- Clubber 5y agoSomething also very common but less discussed is the practice of selling a slave's family members on a whim. Wives, husbands, children, parents sold, never to be seen again. A slave could also be raped, have their spouses and children raped on a whim as well. This was also common. There was also forced breeding. Having to work at a shitty, thankless job just isn't in the same ballpark.
- courtf 5y agoYes I've read Frederick Douglass. He lived that version of slavery, but still described wage slavery in writing about working shitty, thankless jobs. There is more than one way to use the word.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoI also live in europe. My retirement is based on paying ~25% of my gross income into a retirement fund, which is then spent on current retirees, and hoping that in many years, there will be enough people working to be able to pay my retirement. If you gave europeans those 25% as an extra net pay, there would be a lot more new cars on the road, a bit more savings/investments, and a lot more problems when people get old. "Smart" people would save and invest, and have better "pensions" than they'd have in the current system, and "stupid" people would work until 85yo, and die of hunger.
- kazen44 5y agopeople who are poor are usually not stupid. being poor is also a direct result of onces environment and the social and economic status of their parents. should we just accept that capitalism punishes the poor for something they have no control over?
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoI didn't say poor, I said stupid. Some people earning good wages now, would also buy new cars, and be fscked when they get old, and some people earning low wages now, would still invest the 'extra' 25% into something, that'll last until they need it to retire. ...but we do live in a system, that rewards such behaviour, so yeah...
- tapland 5y agoThe poor people's 25% isn't seldom a small small small small fraction of a more wealthy person's 25%. Low wage workers here (also Europe) can barely save any money (if at all), and have something like at least a 10x increase in disposable income after living expenses from moving in with someone, or getting a well paying senior dev job. It's not always an individual's actions having this effect, and if you decide to punish or reward based on it you are not rewarding based on morally reasonable metrics.
- pkdpic_y9k 5y agoI live across the street from a homeless camp in California in a house I dont deserve, my parents are amazing people and had no retirement plan and I have no idea whats going on or what Im going to do when Im too old to work and get fired from whatever bs tech company Im working for when Im 35 and Im just realizing it. Its 1:30 in the morning and my babys gonna wake me up in four hours. America is insane.
- omega3 5y ago> You can live on that but only barely. It depends, in Poland the lowest pension is less than 400 usd per month (which is less than 30sqm apartment in cheapest part of Warsaw). It's not enough to survive on unless you own your own accommodation or/and have support from the family.
- KptMarchewa 5y ago>It's not enough to survive on unless you own your own accommodation or/and have support from the family Which is given for somebody who lived through PRL and got apartment from state or mieszkanie spółdzielcze which they "bought" for 1% of value.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoMany people want something to change but don't trust the government. They have a point. The govt collects more taxes and then just spends more and is right back to needing more $. Often the money doesn't go to where it's needed because lots of palms need to be greased.
- register 5y agoI'll second this. This is mainly a cultural issue.
- refurb 5y agoLack of social security? Social Security is actually a pretty generous program (it was enhanced several times). Average monthly payment is $1,544 per person or >$3,000 for a couple. In Canada the average payment is $736 CAD or $610 USD. Even the maximum payment is Canada ($1200 CAD) is lower the average payment in the US. https://www.ssa.gov/news/press/factsheets/basicfact-alt.pdf https://www.ssa.gov/news/press/factsheets/basicfact-alt.pdf https://www.canada.ca/en/services/benefits/publicpensions/cpp/payment-amounts.html https://www.canada.ca/en/services/benefits/publicpensions/cp...
- thorwasdfasdf 5y agoGov spends 40% of all GDP. That should be plenty to take care of the elderly. Of the entire federal budget almost half goes to the elderly: medicaid/medicaid ~ 20%, social security almost 20%. the question we should be asking is. Why doesn't all this money go farther than it does? I'd say, we may not be nearly as wealthy as GDP/capita says we are.
- pasquinelli 5y ago> That's a solvable problem. It just requires the will to solve it and for whatever reason that is actually controversial in the US. i wouldn't assume that's more controversial in the united states than in europe. but if you're assuming public policy responds to what ordinary people want or need, while i don't know about europe, i can say you're confused about how the united states works. the way we've gotten positive change is by being a threat to the minority of the opulent. we're not making much progress now because we've been defanged. the "political divisions" in the united states are just different approaches to coping with that fact.
- bigdollopenergy 5y agoSo I'm also European, but we are absolutely not an example to follow here. Our retirements are absolutely in danger, we just haven't collectively realized it yet. I wouldn't be surprised if we fare worse than the US due to other factors. Every state pension system in Europe is a ponzi scheme nearing the the end of it's lifecycle. Almost all the money going in, is immediately distributed to current retirees and the fund levels are rapidly heading towards 0. Most estimates I've seen indicate that within a decade or 2 (without considerable rises in taxes) social security benefits will be around half what they are now in most of the developed world. The young are being royally screwed and paying into a system that offers them nothing. The US's social security system has the exact same problem, but the key difference being that a decent percentage of Americans actually have 401k's (~50% i believe) that they've been funding for a long time. Pension plans/401k'like schemes in Europe are far less common and if they do exist they haven't been around anywhere near as long. What will ultimately happen IMO is that everywhere in the developed world will just start means testing social security. Screwing everyone who saved up anything. We won't have a choice though, as it's the only way to not cripple the economy with exorbitant taxes and avoid large amounts of old frail people living on the street. The problem with Europe is they won't have enough people to screw over this way, and will end up with crippling taxes anyway that will cause more damage overall.
- kazen44 5y agomind you that there are far more radical options aswell, like major restructuring of the economic system thanks to climate change. it seems the current economical system is having more frequent and intense crises which the market cannot solve. Who knows how long the system will be sustainable once more and more of the earths resources are economically unobtainable? It only takes massive social upheaval to completely change the economic outlook for specific groups of people. A good example of this is the wealth many people amassed in the 20's which they lost thanks to war or revolution during the 30's and 40's.