11 ms·
Was cancer less likely in a pre-industrial world?
- newsclues 6y agoDid the age of oil or age of nuclear power have more unintended consequences?
- sharklazer 6y agoThe age of glyphosate, an antibiotic that has been sprayed so much that it’s testable in the rain and in sources of groundwater at this point. The effects of long-term antibiotic exposure are up still being learned. But it clear means a gut biome disruption. Thanks Monsanto. Err... Bayer (same people who sold Heroin over the counter 100 years ago)
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoLast time I reviewed the glyphosate literature it wasn’t that impressive of a link between Roundup and cancer. Has anything changed? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5705608/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5705608/ I agree Monsanto is a horrible company, but for other reasons.
- pfdietz 6y agoGlyphosate must be bad, because Monsanto is bad. It's inference by moral contagion, which as everyone knows is an excellent way to do science.
- titzer 6y agoDid you actually read the article you linked? It is actually arguing that logic doesn't work. > Overall, a scrutiny of the method used in these commentaries by Samsel and Seneff reveals a major flaw. These authors employ a deductive reasoning approach based on syllogism, which is formed by two or more propositions used to generate a conclusion. The first proposition is generally related to glyphosate’s properties (e.g., glyphosate is a chelator of Mn) and the second proposition is related to human physiology (e.g., sperm motility depends on Mn). From each of these pairs of propositions, Samsel and Seneff conclude a causative link of glyphosate with the etiology of different diseases. For instance, since glyphosate is a metal chelator (proposition 1), and since sperm motility depends on Mn (proposition 2), they conclude that glyphosate may partially explain increased rates of infertility and birth defects (13). They extend this reasoning to multiple body functions to propose that the dysregulation of Mn utilization in the body due to glyphosate’s metal chelating properties explains autism, Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, anxiety disorder, osteoporosis, inflammatory bowel disease, renal lithiasis, osteomalacia, cholestasis, thyroid dysfunction, and infertility. More recently, Beecham and Seneff have used the same reasoning to conclude on a causative link between glyphosate chelation of Mn and the large rise in the incidence of autism spectrum disorders in children within the US (35). However, there are no scientific studies establishing a causative link between glyphosate and the described chronic diseases. They are literally saying that syllogism cannot possibly work because there aren't "scientific studies". What is syllogism? It's literally logic. If you then read the actual article they are criticizing, there is literally graph after graph establishing a strong correlation between disease and glysophate use. Not only do they find correlations, they reason through several causative mechanisms, in extremely detail, based on chemistry, and then somehow that doesn't count? That paper is absolutely choc full of evidence. What more are they holding out for? It's like their brain doesn't work.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoI'm sorry, I don't see what you see in that article and I don't think you understand it either. Graphs showing increased cancer risk since glyphosate was introduced is almost zero evidence that it does anything. Lot of other things have happened in that same time period such as increases in obesity, etc. The real way to study it is to give an animal glyphosate and see if it does anything to cancer rates. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4819582/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4819582/ Evaluation of carcinogenic potential of the herbicide glyphosate, drawing on tumor incidence data from fourteen chronic/carcinogenicity rodent studies "There was no evidence of a carcinogenic effect related to glyphosate treatment."
- titzer 6y agoYou seem motivated to push a particular narrative and are cherry picking papers to support it, so I really don't want to go back and forth anymore about this, but here's a even larger meta-study that has a completely different conclusion. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7014589/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7014589/ > The strongest evidence shows that glyphosate causes hemangiosarcomas, kidney tumors and malignant lymphomas in male CD-1 mice, hemangiomas and malignant lymphomas in female CD-1 mice, hemangiomas in female Swiss albino mice, kidney adenomas, liver adenomas, skin keratoacanthomas and skin basal cell tumors in male Sprague-Dawley rats, adrenal cortical carcinomas in female Sprague-Dawley rats and hepatocellular adenomas and skin keratocanthomas in male Wistar rats. In fact, this paper links to some of the same studies that the paper you linked to also does, with different conclusions. In particular, it seems your paper was extremely selective about which cancers could be caused by glysophate, e.g. ignoring several types. > Graphs showing increased cancer risk since glyphosate was introduced is almost zero evidence that it does anything. That's just an absurd statement, so I'll disengage now.
- slumdev 6y agoAre you from the Agvocate "Tough Conversations" team?
- speedgoose 6y agoI thought it was no evidence of glyphosate causing cancer. A bit like we don't have evidence than 3/4/5G causes cancer.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ch4s3 6y agoGlyphosate is a broad-spectrum systemic herbicide and crop desiccant not an antibiotic.
- slumdev 6y agoThe evidence of Roundup/glyphosate's carcinogenicity is playing out in courtrooms around the world. And it ain't looking good for Bayer.
- axguscbklp 6y ago>Bayer (same people who sold Heroin over the counter 100 years ago) You say that like selling heroin over the counter is a bad thing.
- pronlover723 6y agoPossibly no, according to the article. up to 14% of deaths 400 years ago in the UK were cancer according to the new research. It's currently 29% in the UK, and 17% in the world. 29% is much higher than 14% but according to the article people used to believe it used to be just 1%. How much of that increase to 29% is because of new problems or just because we live longer so cancers get the chance to kill us more vs all the things that used to kill us earlier
- sonograph 6y agoTangent topic; I have often wondered if back pain was less likely in the past? How did they manage without chiropractors?
- cortic 6y ago>How did they manage without chiropractors? We've always had charlatans pretending to have solutions to our problems before chiropracty and homeopathy, we had traveling salesmen peddling fish oil as a cure-all and of course the power of prayer. Not sure if it speaks to the gullibility of humanity or craftiness of private enterprise.
- klodolph 6y agoI imagine the answer is different depending on whether you have agriculture. Agriculture can be back-breaking work.
- jeltz 6y agoExcerise and especially walking and running does a lot for back health but at the same time they probably did a lot heavy lifting and handicraft (weaving, shoe making, etc) in bad ergonomic positions.
- 1123581321 6y agoPoor ergonomics are almost non-existent in traditional cultures. This makes some intuitive sense as only in a wealthy industrialized society is poor posture and back/leg weakness de-correlated from surival. This is one starting point to research it: https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2015/06/08/412314701/lost-posture-why-indigenous-cultures-dont-have-back-pain https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2015/06/08/4123147...
- XorNot 6y agoChiropractors are charlatans so it was the same as any other healing elixir scam that was being run (which are notable and commonplace throughout history).
- Sebb767 6y agoOne thing which I always thought of, but which the article doesn't mention, is age. Especially older people seem more prone to cancer, so in my mind a lower life expectancy will naturally lead to a lower cancer rate, as people die before cancer "is able to get them". Or am I missing something?
- eliben 6y agoYes, age and life expectancy is a huge part of it. In the book "Rebel Cell: Cancer, Evolution, and the New Science of Life's Oldest Betrayal", Kat Arney touches upon this exact question and reaches the conclusion that cancer was as prevalent in ancient times as it is now (perhaps accounting for surges like smoking-related cancers), and also mentions age as a big factor in the archaeological discrepancy.
- GuB-42 6y agoYes, I tend to think of an increase of death by heart disease, cancer and neurodegenerescence to be good news overall. These diseases are essentially dying of old age. Better treatment for heart disease will mechanically increase cancer deaths and/or Alzheimer.
- kmonsen 6y agoYeah, you have to die of something and as you get old one of those will hit quite likely.
- Nasrudith 6y agoReminds me of the actuarial sims which excluded all deaths from disease, old age, and traffic accidents. Stairs were one of the top killers but population tapered off even as "cannot die of disease or old age" immortals although some outliers could make it a bit past a millennia.
- hanniabu 6y agoThis is a common misconception. Life expectancy hasn't changed much. It's children dying that bright down the average in earlier years. If you lived to your 20s your life expectancy was pretty much the same as it is now.
- arnejenssen 6y agoThe modern age has possibly removed some carcinogens like inhaling smoke from (bon)fires, mycotoxins from spoilt food, nutritional illiteracy and unsanitary conditions. But the modern age has introduced a lot of new ones like tobacco, food additives, sugar, gluten, radiation, asbestos, industrial processing of food, pesticides, sedentary lifestyle.
- sokoloff 6y agoIs tobacco use higher today vs pre-industrial eras? I don’t think of it as a particularly modern introduction to humanity.
- magneticnorth 6y agoTobacco was unknown in Europe until Europeans were introduced to it by native Americans. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_tobacco https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_tobacco
- sokoloff 6y agoWow. That’s mind-blowing. I knew it was a huge economic driver in the early American colonies, but I always imagined it pre-dated [in Europe] the colonization. Thank you for my TIL!
- throw0101a 6y agoOther things that changed post-1492: potatoes, maize (corn), tomatoes, cocoa (chocolate), vanilla are probably most predominant across the Atlantic. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbian_exchange https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Columbian_exchange Bunch of stuff happening in the Pacific as well, e.g., chilli peppers (capsicum): * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chili_pepper#Distribution_to_Asia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chili_pepper#Distribution_to_A... Good book: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1493:_Uncovering_the_New_World_Columbus_Created https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1493:_Uncovering_the_New_World...
- 6y ago
- rubicks 6y agoBefore normalizing the data for life expectancy? Almost certainly.
- throw0101a 6y agoPerhaps of some interest is the book The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer: > The book weaves together Mukherjee's experiences as a hematology/oncology fellow at Massachusetts General Hospital as well as the history of cancer treatment and research.[3][5] Mukherjee gives the history of cancer from its first identification 4,600 years ago by the Egyptian physician Imhotep. The Greeks had no understanding of cells, but they were familiar with hydraulics. Hippocrates thus considered illness to be an imbalance of four cardinal fluids: blood, black bile, yellow bile, phlegm. Galen applied this idea to cancer, believing it to be an imbalance of black bile. In 440 BCE, the Greek historian Herodotus recorded the first breast tumor excision of Atossa, the queen of Persia and the daughter of Cyrus, by a Greek slave named Democedes. The procedure was believed to have been successful temporarily. Galen's theory was later challenged by the work of Andreas Vaselius and Matthew Baille, whose dissections of human bodies failed to reveal black bile. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor_of_All_Maladies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor_of_All_Maladies PBS made it into a documentary: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancer_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cancer_(film) * https://www.pbs.org/show/story-cancer-emperor-all-maladies/ https://www.pbs.org/show/story-cancer-emperor-all-maladies/
- TimonKnigge 6y agoHighly recommend the book, also his other book "The Gene" about the history of genetics.
- zackees 6y agosv40 is a cancer causing virus that contaminated 1/3rd of all polio vaccines. From wikipedia: The discovery of SV40 revealed that between 1955 and 1963 around 90% of children and 60% of adults in the U.S. were inoculated with SV40-contaminated polio vaccines. Link to studies: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=sv40+cancer&btnG= https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=sv40...
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y ago"Studies of groups of people who received polio vaccine during 1955–1963 provide evidence of no increased cancer risk." [1] [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25057632/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25057632/
- zackees 6y agoNIH is corrupt and often covers for big pharma which funds it. SV40 has consistently been found in tumors across the body: https://cancerres.aacrjournals.org/content/67/17/8065.short https://cancerres.aacrjournals.org/content/67/17/8065.short
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoCorrelation does not equal causation. A virus being found in a tumor doesn't mean it caused it.
- sm0ss117 6y agoQuick rule of thumb, the reason we associate it with cancer is because the only ppl we systemically tested for it had cancer. If you tested everybody you'd probably find it in everybody since it was in a mandatory vaccine
- Supermancho 6y agoI think a quick google search has steered you wrong. I don't think this is a huge story (I've never heard of SV40 before reading this thread), but just a little deeper...reading the executive summary, the story seems less clear cut. "The committee concludes that the biological evidence is moderate that SV40 exposure could lead to cancer in humans under natural conditions." And there's more. SV40's probably also transformative (observed in both mammals and humans) and the vaccine has moderate evidence of causality. Then there's the strange disappearance of the CDC page awhile back - http://www.laleva.org/eng/2013/07/cdc_disappears_page_linking_polio_vaccines_to_cancer-causing_viruses.html http://www.laleva.org/eng/2013/07/cdc_disappears_page_linkin... And the papers correlating the virus to cancer: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10472327/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10472327/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16966607/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16966607/ etc
- bryanmgreen 6y agoProbably a dumb question, but I’ve wondered if plastic has anything to do with cancer in the modern era? Mostly everything we consume these days has been touched by a form of plastic.
- ksd482 6y agoI think it’s a valid question. I am wondering if microplastic is a factor in addition to air and water pollution, processed/pre-packaged food. Another factor maybe humankind beating/cancelling natural selection due to modern medicine. So people who would normally perish in olden days are living longer only to be later killed by cancer. There’s another factor of total population. More people means more diversity and more DNA copying errors? Can someone expert in this field comment on this?
- throwaway12319 6y agoThere's very extensive documentation on the carcinogenic effect of microplastic and atmospheric particulate. It's not a debated issue: it's well known.
- pharrington 6y agoThis presentation[1] from two years ago says two monomers used in different microplastics are known to be carcinogenic (ethylene oxide and vinyl chloride) - other monomers might be, and the polymers themselves weren't known to be carcinogenic. Do you have some more up-to-date sources ? [1]https://cues.rutgers.edu/2019-microplastics-conference/pdfs/3_Pachkowski_Potential-for-Human-Health-Effects.pdf https://cues.rutgers.edu/2019-microplastics-conference/pdfs/...
- refurb 6y agoWhat? This is absolutely not true. You realize we implant plastic medical devices into people, right? And those have gone through clinical testing? The best I’ve seen is increase inflammation due to small plastic particles.
- noT1 6y agoI thought it was accepted by the medical community every major ailment occurred at much higher rates “back in the day”. That it’s a case of having lacked sophisticated detection methods the numbers are so low.
- mikewarot 6y agoWhen I saw a great^n grandmother's 1870 census entry, which said she had 7 children, 1 of which was still alive (at 55), the reality of life back then hit me hard. This a meaningless question for most people, if it helps save lives in the future, great. I think you should also pay attention to Bret Weinstein's work on telomeres and cancer. If the environmental pressures are for a low age, you end up with long telomeres to allow more dividing of cells to replace those damaged, however those same long telomeres make you more susceptible to cancer should you live longer.
- CoryAlexMartin 6y agoAre our telomeres long enough to allow for the development of cancer, or is it necessary for the system to be overridden, thus allowing cells to replicate indefinitely? My layman's understanding was that benign moles were benign, and not cancerous, because the telomere system was functioning normally and limiting growth. Am I wrong?
- R0b0t1 6y agoMoles don't stop growing primarily because of telomere length but because the human genome has effective methods of controlling cancer. You get cancer something like 4 times a day but the cells are terminated. (It is possible telomeres play some part in this, but I have never seen it proposed.) What you are likely trying to broach is the question "do organisms evolve to die?" the answer to which is "yes." This was originally studied in pea plants. The maturation of the seed pods sends a chemical signal back to the main plant which induces death. It dies so that its progeny have more space; this is incentivized over generations because a changing genome is more advantageous to a static one. Same logic can be applied to animals. It is not just that there may be no pressure to evolve telomere repair, it may be that telomere repair is markedly disadvantageous.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arkh 6y ago
- 101001001001 6y agohttps://youtu.be/06e-PwhmSq8 https://youtu.be/06e-PwhmSq8
- szundi 6y agoPeople didn’t live long enough to have cancer back then.
- deep-root 6y agoIt's a bit of a myth that humans have only had long life in modern times. This is partially due to the calculated "life expectancy" of many eras including infant mortality where perhaps 30% of the population died at age 0. If a quarter or half of your population is dying at age 0, then another quarter or half must likely be living into their 70s for the mean age to end up 35.
- masklinn 6y ago> This is partially due to the calculated "life expectancy" of many eras including infant mortality where perhaps 30% of the population died at age 0. Well not really age 0, rather between 0 and 5. The rest of your point stands.
- mcguire 6y agoThe total life expectancy of a white male infant in 1850 in the US was 38; at age 10, 58; at age 20, 60. White female, 40, 57, and 60. In 2011, the male expectancies were 76, 77, and 77; female, 81, 82, and 82. (https://www.infoplease.com/us/health-statistics/life-expectancy-age-1850-2011 https://www.infoplease.com/us/health-statistics/life-expecta...) Life expectancy of children and young adults has increased significantly in addition to the reduction in infant mortality.
- NaturalPhallacy 6y agoVery young children get cancer even today.
- supernova87a 6y agoYou know there's a public health saying about the efficacy of interventions: "After you save people from dying of cheap things, they start dying of expensive things."
- throwtheacctawy 6y agoHave there been any studies that disprove the correlation between petro-chemical production/usage and the rise in cancer? I've seen countless stats that plots petro-chemical use over years, and cancer rates. The charts are identical.
- blutfink 6y agoBetteridge's Law of headlines: "Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no."
- GekkePrutser 6y agoI think it was mainly less likely because people were so much more likely to die of other causes, so they'd die before the cancer got a chance. Healthcare was at its most basic and out of reach for common people. I'm sure some of our environmental issues make cancer more likely. But we shouldn't imagine that the pre-industrial world was super healthy. People were living in filth. This was in fact one of the reasons they died so soon. It's also one of the few things we haven't really found a cure for. I think because each cancer is a different random genetic mutation that would benefit the most from a custom generated antibody or something. Whereas other major causes of death have been pretty much eradicated by things like antibiotics and vaccines. So I think this makes the numbers relatively higher. And of course because healthcare was so poor, I'm sure there would also be many causes of death misattributed. Even in this day and age we can't seem to standardise it. Some countries attribute every death to coronavirus if the person was infected, others only if it was 100% certain to be the cause of death.
- mlac 6y agoI’d hazard a guess that a lot more people also died of “natural causes“. Unless you cut someone open, the way cancer actually kills you (organs shutting down, trouble breathing, etc) would be described as “natural causes” or getting old and dying…
- doggodaddo78 6y agoI would suspect bodily stressors like fasting reduce the chances of cancers taking hold because those cells are usually less resilient than normal cells (like the principles of chemotherapy). Having abundant food I would suspect is what gives most cancers a comfortable body to develop in. Also, modern proliferation of toxic chemicals. Furthermore, people living longer are inevitably going to go by either cardiovascular issues/stroke, pneumonia, or cancer.
- courtf 6y agoI'm more interested in the pre-agricultural world, and the differences between that time and our own would be significantly greater than comparing to a mere couple hundred years.
- phendrenad2 6y agoThe dismissive comments here are confusing to me. Of course this is a valuable thing to study, because without it we won't know if there are factors about our modern industrial society that could be altered to increase our lifespans even more. Or is 80 years just "good enough" and people don't want to live to 160? Also if we find that cancer was less prevalent before, that's a useful data point for how much cancer can be avoided in a hypothetical ideal situation that we should perhaps shoot for.
- xg15 6y agoThe methodology in this study seems really sketchy to me. So we start with one indicator of bone cancer that is well-established: bone lesions. This indicator shows a significant rise from medieval to current times. Now we use another, less established indicator (ct scan results) and find... a number consistent with the first result. Finally, we make some "extrapolations" about the rate of undetectable cancer based on our observations and lots of assumptions. In the end, we show that our extrapolated(!) cancer rate is higher than expected and does not show as much of a difference between medieval and modern times. None of this explained the significant rise in the first indicator. Also, even if you liberally pad your data with extrapolations, wouldn't you have to apply the same formula to the indicators of cancer in modern-day individuals? By the way, the modern-day cancer rate is still ~3x higher than even the extrapolated rate (15% vs 50%) - yet, the article goes one step further than the study and frames this as a finding that the cancer rate didn't grow at all.