19 ms·
Red seaweed supplementation reduces enteric methane by over 80% in beef steers
- kleton 6y agoThe active ingredient is bromoform, which might even be cheaper to dose than the raw algae.
- ars 6y agoBromoform is incredibly toxic, and possibly even a carcinogen. But if you feed them seaweed then it's suddenly all natural. /s That might be why. But in seriousness, I'm not so OK with feeding animals bromoform or seaweed for that matter if that's a common component.
- AlanYx 6y agoI agree with you. The EPA classifies it as a Group B2 probable human carcinogen, and it has been shown to cause liver and intestinal tumors in animals. I wonder if the reason the industry is pushing red seaweed supplementation rather than direct bromoform supplementation is that the latter might require greater evidence of safety (being essentially a medication rather than a foodstuff) before being allowed?
- selimthegrim 6y agoIs this what’s new about it? I thought this finding was already known?
- kleton 6y agoI'm not sure what's new here. All of this has been known at least 5 years.
- twic 6y agoThe nature of science is that experiments are repeated many times with slight variations before we consider that something is known. This paper does add details I hadn't seen before - it shows that adding algae to the diet increases the efficiency of converting feed to body mass, and reduces feed intake. There was reason to believe that would happen, but I'm not sure it had been demonstrated experimentally.
- readflaggedcomm 6y agoWhich is fascinating, because I thought seaweeds only helped cattle by adding protease enzymes, which also works with humans: try cooking legumes with kombu/konbu. But cooking up enzymes outside of seaweed seems a lot more costly than synthesizing solvents, assuming dosing cattle that way doesn't taint the end product.
- airhead969 6y agoThis is like improving ICEs to enable their continued existence. To what end? How about eliminating meat ag altogether since it's a waste of resources, a significant component of man-made climate change, a pandemic risk, a major source of pollution, driver of deforestation, and poses a threat to antibiotic resistance? But no, the typical rationalizations include: "Muh cheezburger is muh freedom. I can eat whatever I want. Where you gonna get protein, you pushy vegan weirdo, lettuce? Vegetables cost too much."
- ReadFList 6y agoHow about we keep eating locally produced meat because it's healthy, far more than those "fake" meats that are no more than vegetable oils, estrogen from soy and the likes, and chemicals to add flavour, and instead reduce waste? Do you really think that the increase in vegetable prodution would not have any environmental impact? We grow them out of the air? And ICE should continue to exist to make sure we stop at the border all those who break the law to try to entering a country. No country owes any right to foreigners to enter illegally. Let them fix their countries first :)
- paulcole 6y agohttps://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/soy/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/soy/ > Results of recent population studies suggest that soy has either a beneficial or neutral effect on various health conditions
- etu 6y agoSoy doesn't contain estrogen, it contains phytoestrogen which looks very much like estrogen but actually has the opposite effect and block "real" estrogen. Phytoestrogen can help to lower estrogen levels. Do you know where real estrogen comes from? Female animals. Do you know the gender of basically all meat/egg/milk products comes from? Females. So that's where your estrogen comes from. Not from Soy.
- samuelbalogh 6y agoEating local doesn't even make a dent in reducing your carbon footprint. https://ourworldindata.org/food-choice-vs-eating-local https://ourworldindata.org/food-choice-vs-eating-local
- j-pb 6y agoI guess everything helps, but we put so much effort into the problems with easy solutions, that could be invested into the difficult stuff. Livestock contributes to 15% of all greenhouse gasses. But the solution is easy, cheap, and only midly inconvenient. Going vegan. This has the added benefit of protecting threatened ecosystems in the rainforrest and seas. We could then spend that energy on the difficult stuff. Fast tracked rollout of renevables and interrim energy storage.
- Eric_WVGG 6y agoThe solution is easy, cheap, and only mildly inconvenient. Feed cattle some seaweed.
- j-pb 6y agoThe seaweeed is not a full on substitute for the refular feed. You still have the climate, land, and water impact of the majority of the feed. You're also stil stuck with the huge water requirements, antibiotic resistence, disease, and animal cruelty. You're advocating for a reduction of at most 50% of the harmfull effects. But going 100% is trivial, so why not do it?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Eric_WVGG 6y agoBecause I like solutions that are possible, and I can't think of many things more difficult than changing people's behavior. We can't even convince the public to wear face masks in public and that vaccines are safe, and you're telling me that it would be trivial to make everyone go vegan? Even discussing this is pointlessly filling the atmosphere with more CO2. I actually happen to think that our civilization will inevitably become vegetarian, but it won't happen within my lifetime, and in the meantime, some scientists have found a cheap way to reduce methane emissions. That's awesome! Stop pissing on their work.
- yboris 6y ago
- frankbreetz 6y ago"Transportation of the processed or unprocessed seaweed should be kept to a minimum, so cultivation in the region of use is recommended specially to avoid long-haul shipping." "Asparagopsis taxiformis, (red sea plume or limu kohu) formerly A. sanfordiana, is a species of red algae, with cosmopolitan distribution in tropical to warm temperate waters."[0] This seems to be a pretty big hurdle to overcome. Either all the cows are going to have to move toward the warm oceans or we will have to figure out how to grow the algae near the cows, both of these are huge undertakings. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asparagopsis_taxiformis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asparagopsis_taxiformis
- 52-6F-62 6y agoI think farming it at scale is something some groups are already pursuing—likely mainly because it could mean big, big business. I'm out of my depth, but is there any reason it couldn't be farmed in a hothouse?
- Robotbeat 6y agoShipping by electrified rail is one option. Efficient and potentially 100% clean.
- vuln 6y agoWhere are you getting the electricity to power the rail?
- YorickPeterse 6y agoOh I don't know, how about: solar, wind, nuclear, hydro; plenty of ways to power a railway network without the need for fossil fuels. The real challenge here is likely governments simply not wanting to invest in this.
- ars 6y agoOr, just ship the seaweed. There is no reason to "keep it to a minimum", shipping things takes far less energy than people like to imagine. You'll end up spending FAR more energy cultivating it in lots of small locales.
- tengbretson 6y agoDon't expect the conclusions of people that have decided they don't like meat to change. Only their rationales.
- andy_ppp 6y agoHas anyone checked if the animals also end up healthier?
- Justin_K 6y agoOr if the food product tasted the same or better!
- JeanSebTr 6y agoPossibly. My understanding is that seaweed improve the microbiota of the cattle which should be beneficial for the overall health. (I've no domain knownledge on this, but saw an interview with the founders of a company that produce seaweed for cattles. they do claim healthier animals)
- rossdavidh 6y agoOk, but does it also work on humans? :)
- brightball 6y agoThe first time I read about this a few years back I was wondering how long it would take to become the norm. Once produced at scale, its the easiest and fastest way to address the problem. If there are any companies out there getting into growing this stuff for industrial uses, I’d certainly be interested in investing.
- johnsutor 6y agoI read a piece about https://symbrosia.co/seaweeda https://symbrosia.co/seaweeda while back. I’m not sure if they have plans for large-scale production just yet, though.
- gambiting 6y agoThere is an incredibly important part of this that I feel everyone is missing. The grass eaten by the cows would produce exactly as much methane if it was just left to rot. It's not as if cows somehow produce methane out of grass that would otherwise just....turn into dust? None of those studies take this into account, they all just measure what comes into a cow and what comes out, but no one takes into account the amount of methane produced from the same feed even without cows involved. https://www.cbc.ca/radio/quirks/mar-2-2019-the-goodness-paradox-secrets-in-poop-converting-carbon-to-coal-and-more-1.5037008/do-cows-produce-more-methane-than-rotting-grass-1.5037019 https://www.cbc.ca/radio/quirks/mar-2-2019-the-goodness-para...
- jstimpfle 6y agoIf there is no difference there (I don't know anything about this), doesn't agriculture at least lead to higher rate / volume of grass growth?
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoOnly grass decomposed in an anaerobic environment would produce methane. Grass decomposed aerobically would produce CO2 instead.
- gambiting 6y agoBut methane decomposes into CO2 on a relatively short timescale(12 years?) so surely....it's a wash?
- ufo 6y agoThose couple of years where the carbon is in the form of methane instead of CO2 have a big impact because methane is a much stronger greenhouse gas.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoNot a wash. Methane has 85x the impact per unit as co2 which has a half life of 27 years.
- zests 6y agoI find this hard to believe. Here is my epistemic estimation: if this were legitimate, it would be huge news. I've been hearing about this for several years now but somehow it never amounts to anything. I would have expected large scale cattle studies by now but I have not seen any of those.
- dbetteridge 6y agohttps://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-12-18/csiro-super-seaweed-cattle-supplement-wins-$1m-prize/12992888 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-12-18/csiro-super-seaweed-c... Seems like at least one group trying to do something with it.
- titzer 6y agoYou find it hard to believe that a $66 billion beef industry doesn't want to completely overhaul its logistics and incur massive switching costs and larger overhead?
- nickelcitymario 6y ago1) It IS huge news. It's been reported pretty heavily. (Or at least, I've stumbled across this news many times from many different and mainstream sources. I suppose it's possible that my filter bubble is making it seem like a bigger deal.) 2) What's the incentive for the farmer? The benefits are entirely externalized. Less methane is good for the planet, but paying to add seaweed to the feed is nothing more than an added case for the farmer. So if we wanted to roll this out, we'd have to provide publicly-funded incentives for farmers to do so.
- zests 6y agoThere may be no incentive for the farmer but plenty of incentive for the scientist, the government and the philanthropist. My conclusions is that GHG from cattle is simply not as big of a deal as the environmentalists would make it seem. Another comment mentions that decaying grass also releases methane so I'm not even sure if there are any accurate numbers on the true effect of livestock on emissions.
- giardini 6y agoMy wife asks if this can be used for human males.
- aimor 6y agoYes, some people eat kombu (kelp) to alleviate gas caused by hard to digest sugars.
- valgor 6y agoNot eating cows or drinking cow milk reduces your carbon emissions from cows 100%. You actually don't need technology or a start up to solve this issue!
- MsMowz 6y agoThis isn't true unless your substitute is to eat nothing.
- arcticfox 6y agoThe "from cows" technically makes it pretty much true. Regardless, it's not a constructive comment for that reason.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoThere was an interesting TV show on British TV (apologies, my Google foo is not able to find the name at this moment in time) where they invited a number of people to eat dishes at a hypothetical restaurant, after each course the tallied the carbon emissions released in creating the dish. Now obviously being a TV show they had to show some extreme examples but it was definitely interesting when things like imported asparagus dishes released more than the British beef dish. However, things like the wine were even more challenging, wine imported from Australia in bulk tanks was relatively ok, but wines imported after bottling (from Europe for example) where horrible because of the extra transportation.
- ip26 6y agoToo bad there isn't some sort of free market based mechanism that would inherently account for all of these factors without you needing to think about it.
- MsMowz 6y agoI'm not sure if this is sarcastic, but there quite literally is not a "free market based mechanism" to do this. If there were, there would not be the market failure that we can observe today. There are plenty of market-based methods for accounting for these externalities though, such as Pigovian taxes.
- Doji 6y agoA common misconception which I frequently see when this topic arises is the failure to distinguish carbon cycles and one-way carbon emission. You exhale carbon dioxide. However, this carbon dioxide comes from the carbon in the food you eat, and the food you eat obtained it from the atmosphere. Thus, it's a cycle. As a system (ignoring food transportation, deforestation, etc.) it's effectively carbon neutral. By contrast, when we dig up oil and burn it, there is no cycle. It's a one way street. Methane production from cattle is slightly more complicated instance of a carbon cycle. The cows produce methane, which is a more potent greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide. However, it degrades in the atmosphere into C02. Since this C02 was obtained from the food the cattle ate, this is another cycle. Since the methane released from cattle is continually degrading, it does not accumulate. The total amount of bovine methane resident in the atmosphere is ultimately a function of herd size, or perhaps more accurately quantity of feed consumed. You may be surprised to learn that cattle herd size has remained relatively stable over time. Additionally our planet was once host to wild ruminants like Buffalo which no longer exist in large numbers. As a result I would be very surprised to learn that bovine methane production is completely out of historical context. As a result I see this as a topic which generally serves to distract from the root cause and real problem associated with climate change - fossil fuel usage.
- titzer 6y ago> Since the methane released from cattle is continually degrading, it does not accumulate. That's like saying lakes are impossible because of rivers. If you look at historical methane concentrations in our atmosphere, they are already almost 3x of pre-industrial levels, and over 3x of mean historical levels over the past ~1 million years [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_methane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_methane
- graeme 6y agoIs that from cow herd size increases or other causes? OP’s point was that with q fixed herd size the amount of methane accumulating in an atmosphere is stable. Lakes don’t grow and grow and consume the world.
- Tepix 6y agoThis is at least the 4th time that I read about this. The first time must be more than 10 years ago. Is anything being done? Are algae or seaweed being added to the cow's food? If not, why not?
- daniellarusso 6y agoSo, is the for grass-feed beef, or this is for corn-feed beef?
- stakkur 6y agoThereby raising harvesting and consumption of seaweed, shifting the burden from one ecosystem to another.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 6y agoDoes it work on humans too? Asking for a friend.
- mrfusion 6y agoSo if we ever did have a mini ice age, releasing methane might be a good way to manage it? Since it’s short lived.
- headbee 6y agoArticle from Wired on why algae isn't the silver bullet it's marketed as: https://www.wired.com/story/carbon-neutral-cows-algae/ https://www.wired.com/story/carbon-neutral-cows-algae/ Essentially, it's only useful for pasture raised cows (soy and corn fed feedlot cows already produce a fraction of the methane) and there's no practical way to add algae to pasture raised cows' diets. They also speculate that cows' microbiomes will adapt to the algae.
- pavedwalden 6y agoThanks for supplying the fact-check I was looking for. I think I've been seeing headlines about this "discovery" for over a decade, always presented as if it's a promising new technique but obviously there must be some reason it hasn't caught on by now.
- asciimo 6y ago"I can keep eating steak because Science is about to solve that problem..."
- wyre 6y agoSame. I would think at this point there would be companies focused on algae production for ruminants. AFAIK there is only one company in Australia that is doing this. I haven’t read the Wired article yet but my critique is that there isn’t enough seaweed being farmed to adequately enrich a significant cattle population and all this headline does is relax self-judgement of environmentally-conscious meat eaters.
- thescriptkiddie 6y agoIf we're going to continue to have cattle, pasture raised is the only way to do it. Feedlots are not just devastating to the environment, they are inhumane on a level that is difficult to even conceive.
- pvaldes 6y agoThis reminds me the kiri scam. Is a non solution from the start. Absolutely non-scalable
- mfi 6y agoVolta Greentech is a Swedish startup currently working on scaling production of this specific seaweed: https://www.voltagreentech.com/ https://www.voltagreentech.com/
- staplung 6y agoLegitimate question: how do they measure how much methane a cow produces?
- jayavanth 6y agoIt's not what you thinking. They use this https://www.c-lockinc.com/researchers/products/greenfeed-large-animals#product_description https://www.c-lockinc.com/researchers/products/greenfeed-lar...
- hannob 6y agoJust wanted to point out: This is a study with 21 subjects, split into three groups. Those are very small numbers. This "we can make cows climate friendly with seaweed" story pops up regularly. Call me skeptical as long as this is based on a few small studies and nobody ever tried this at scale.
- barbazoo 6y agoI wish we could collectively accept that meat consumption is a huge ecological and environmental problem our planet is facing and simply transition to a more sustainable, vegetarian diet. Reducing the effect that industrial meat production has on the environment is great and it's something we as humans do, improve the negative effects of our behavior when instead it would have far greater effect to change our behavior instead.
- aaron695 6y agoThe only direction we should be wasting time with is lab grown meat. If you are in high school or above you should also ask, how does reducing methane, which seems like a big chemical reaction change, effect growth. If growth is reduced by 1%, then you better start cutting down forests to grow more cattle. If it is better then you get to save forests and ecosystems. Stop cargo culting Global Warming. What you should care about is the environment and people, not reducing CO2 and methane. We need to make growing meat more efficient. (And Jevons paradox's isn't real is just another scripture from the environmental cult) CSIRO has a good FAQ on seaweed for cattle which they own IP for - https://www.future-feed.com/faqs https://www.future-feed.com/faqs
- PortlandMEnerd 6y agoAm I the only one who is wondering why the sample size was so small? It looks like only 21 cows were used and 7 of them were used as controls.
- minsc__and__boo 6y agoIf the delta is large enough then it should be statistically significant.