17 ms·
Researchers looking for mRNA were ridiculed by colleagues
- dekhn 6y agothroughout my 20+ year career in biology I was repeatedly reminded of what I call "the protein bias" where DNA and RNA are treated as boring molecules that just exist to support proteins. I was an RNA researcher for a while and it's an absolutely fascinating molecule and over the years people have built up more and more evidence that RNA influences biology in deep ways that aren't fully appreciated. It's funny about the magnesium in the article- getting the Mg concentration right when working with delicate nucleic acids is absolutely key to good results.
- lrossi 6y agoPersonally, I think it’s best if scientists lean towards the conservative/skepticism side, to filter out scams or bad science. But there should be a balance between that and allowing new ideas to surface. Do you think it’s taken too far?
- dekhn 6y agoYes, it's taken too far. Multiple times in RNA biology people have made legitimate discoveries and were required to implement heroic methods to make their case. The first two I think of are Tom Cech whose grad student demonstrated that RNA can be an enzyme with extremely reliable evidence but they had to put in a few years of work to actually get the community to agree. Similarly, Harry Noller had very strong evidence the heart of the ribosome was an RNA machine and it took 40 years and a crystal structure before the community finally accepted it. A similar case happened with DNA with the Avery experiment which was as good a proof as you'll ever get in biology, but it wasn't until Hershey Chase that the general community overcame the skepticism that DNA could be the molecule of heredity.
- readflaggedcomm 6y agoFrom the article: >Other researchers “rolled their eyes in horror” when he presented his theory, Jacob recalled in his memoir, The Statue Within. “With a little encouragement, my audience would have jeered and left,” he wrote. Skepticism and contempt are distinct and disparate feelings.
- heriol 6y agoI think there's a wide gulf between healthy skepticism and mockery or dismissal. It should be totally acceptable (if not laudable) to investigate unpopular or long-tail ideas. Sure, a lot of them will not amount to anything, but you also have a chance of discovering something totally unexpected.
- ramraj07 6y agoI think the opposite - hold the highest standards for the quality of the data and it's interpretation, but we need to allow the wildest of hypotheses to be tested without judgement. Conservatism at the hypothesis step is the biggest reason science today sucks if you ask me. I'll say the job of being conservative belongs to engineers, and is one of the main differentiators between science and engineering. The most amazing discoveries even in the recent times often come from scientists testing some of the wildest hypothesis - a rotation student in Andrew Fire's lab thinking he's injecting RNA into the gonad of a worm when he was stupidly injecting them into its mouth, or when a young Yamanaka had no clue basically and did a random experiment in his new lab adding a bunch of genes to cells to see if they do something. I've sat through sessions seeing scientists laughed at for their wild hypotheses, by what I can only call as old, over-congratulated high school valedictorians who are only actually good at playing politics and writing grants, with a self professed love of science and discovering things that's as genuine as a Republican saying he is all for facts. Let the crazies risk their lives on the wildest hypotheses. Fund them as long as they are systematic and methodical in their efforts to prove them. That's how you make science take the leaps it needs to be truly transformative for civilization. That's how I intend to do science and I learned clearly that I don't belong in academia. I have no intention of even swinging the science bat if I'm not at least trying to shoot for the moon!
- throwawayboise 6y agoAt the same time, labs and researchers and equipment cost real money. There are opportunity costs. There some good reasons to not spend money on wild conjectures.
- ramraj07 6y agoSure let's spend it on what, MOD-ENCODE version two? That's super useful and curing cancer and tuberculosis left and right eh!
- StavrosK 6y agoEh, you can allocate a percentage of resources on wild conjectures, since many of our biggest discoveries have been made that way. No need to shut them down and ridicule them.
- pid_0 6y agoconservative and skeptical are not the same thing Science should be absolutely progressive in that ALL questions are asked and ALL hypotheses are tested, with a significant amount of skepticism and critical analysis.
- lrossi 6y agoRight, maybe “conservative” was not the best choice of word as it has many meanings. I was thinking about “cautious”, not “traditionalist”. Sorry for the confusion, I’m not a native speaker.
- gnramires 6y agoThe dichotomy of 'skepticism' vs 'open-mindedness' doesn't capture all that is important about scientific inquiry (specifically, both of those are important of course). One approach to Science I think is really illustrative is Wheeler's[1] 'radical conservatism': you should accept, and seek, radical ideas, under a skeptical, formal, foundation. So for example, if someone proposes a "free-energy" device with some outlandish explanation, that a priori isn't radical conservatism, because while the proposal is radical, it clashes with the conservative basis of local energy conservation of all modern physics (or maybe with the 2nd law of thermodynamics). However, for example in General Relativity, the question of energy conservation at extremely large scales is not well settled. So that's something you could explore, without letting the fear of ridicule stop you (for breaking energy conservation), as long as you retain solid foundations[2]. Not only that, but this kind of outlandish idea is often how science moves forward, not by making the most obvious hypotheses about established theories (which we already largely know the answer for!) -- but it's difficult to naively distinguish from crackpottery. By solid foundations, I mean you can even revise your physical principles, as long as they explain available evidence and you're able to formalize them to a good degree. Also by 'radical' it is meant that we shouldn't judge ideas by whether they are outlandish or not (Feynman writes extensively about this in his talks) -- Nature doesn't seem to be particularly concerned with seeming outlandish[3]. So to get rid of this bias, you can flip the coin and go after outlandish ideas (ideally simply unbiased, but it's a strategy). See Kip Thorne's memoir, which I haven't read to completion but I'm sure is good: https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1901/1901.06623.pdf https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1901/1901.06623.pdf [1] (the great friend from Feynman and with enormous contributions) [2] In GR there is some very non-intutive large scale behavior: you can move without reaction mass in vacuum, which naively would seem radical, and violating conservation of momentum. However, it's allowed, and proven!: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/886/swimming-in-spacetime-apparent-conserved-quantity-violation https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/886/swimming-in-... [3] In reality, what defines what's "bizarre", "outlandish", "unintuitive" for us, are (1) Our previous experiences in the world, (2) Our coded instincts and neural architecture. There's no guarantee those will be valid when extrapolated to a different domain: objects at very small scales, very large scales, very high energies, etc.
- stocknoob 6y agoScientists should be skeptics of their own conservatism. Much "conservatism" is in the name of defending egos. “A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it.” - Max Plank It'd be nice to not wait a generation.
- lrossi 6y agoRight, there are plenty of such examples from physics. I was wondering if biology is the same. But it actually sounds worse. I think computer science is doing much better nowadays. The “NoSQL” movement for example was particularly impressive, it’s something that wouldn’t fly in most other sciences.
- sjg007 6y agoExcept that NoSQL has been around for decades. It just went by a different name in the 1960s.
- selimthegrim 6y agoPick IIRC
- dboreham 6y agoISAM
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoWe're onto NewSQL now.
- Sharlin 6y agoNoSQL is much more about software engineering than computer science, and software engineering is ridiculously susceptible to fads in a way no mature engineering discipline should be. And almost never are those fads actually new ideas, because trends work cyclically rather than linearly. Most SWEs are just too ignorant of the history of their own trade to realize that.
- ukj 6y agoWhat's the "right balance" between Type I and Type II errors when assessing the quality/potential of new research?
- marvin 6y agoI disagree almost 100% with this. The most novel scientific ideas are so wild they're almost in crackpot territory. Novel ideas in general are ideas no one has ever explored before. And while most science is incremental, most science is also...not very useful or interesting. I'm sure that scientific funding could be cut 50% without any noticeable negative impact, assuming the right 50% were cut. (That is of course the difficult question, so I'm not literally advocating this). Conservativism is a very bad trait to have in scientific roles. It's not as bad as being dumb, not being curious or not intensely seeking the truth, but on a system level it will steer the ship in the wrong direction. Paul Graham recently wrote some essays that explored these ideas in a much clearer and more precise way. To me they were just nagging in the back of my mind for a long time. Recommended reading if you've got a few minutes. http://paulgraham.com/think.html http://paulgraham.com/think.html
- Nasrudith 6y agoI have to ask what the hell is wrong with them - even if considering proteins as an end all you would at least consider DNA and RNA peripherally useful to look into to figure out the process of their creation and constraints. To go with a clumsy metaphor living wheels and axle style of locomotion cannot be plausibly grown and moved by known organic structures - it would have to use it. Knowing more what can be produced would help figure out what cannot and commonalities. The reaction doesn't make any sense even for protein folding obsessived.
- LetThereBeLight 6y agoThat is interesting, I have had the exact opposite experience. People saying that genes and their regulatory circuits are all that matter and that proteins are boring byproducts of that. I guess it is a matter of what sub-community you find yourself in.
- domnomnom 6y agoProteins are practical.
- tim333 6y agoI just did some science at college and thought DNA and protein cool and RNA the dull go between but now find it interesting that RNA may have been the original life on earth and predated all the other stuff. Wikipedia: >...the evidence for an RNA world is strong enough that the hypothesis has gained wide acceptance. The concurrent formation of all four RNA building blocks further strengthened the hypothesis. >Like DNA, RNA can store and replicate genetic information; like protein enzymes, RNA enzymes (ribozymes) can catalyze (start or accelerate) chemical reactions that are critical for life. One of the most critical components of cells, the ribosome, is composed primarily of RNA...
- aspaceman 6y agoI took a course on DNA computing and it blew my mind. Representing Turing machines as mixtures of chemical in a test tube, and having an RNA strands behavior encode a program is precisely where I see biological computing headed. It was really wild how forward thinking the research seemed, but how primitive the results they could get was due to the limitations of biology.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vedtopkar 6y agoI'm doing my PhD on topics related to mRNA and took a seminar class with Meselson in college. Really crazy how quickly our field has gone from obscure to mainstream this last year.
- rpiguyshy 6y agothis is the aspect of science that is not talked about in the media and among "science, fuck yeah" "big bang theory" bros. science is full of dogma, politics and downright dirtiness. people who do research are often showmen more than scientists, because the system selects for people who can sleazily promote their own research to win grants, or people who just hop onto whatever bandwagon is popular. and the worst part is that people who are blowing on the kindling of the next big breakthrough are not only discarded by the scientific establishment, they are ridiculed viciously. anyone who says we should "listen to science" needs to open a history book. dogma, dogma, dogma. its the most insidious parasite in the modern western world and has happily escaped completely the confines of its old religious home.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> anyone who says we should "listen to science" needs to open a history book. dogma, dogma, dogma You're describing humans. What makes science novel is its mechanism for challenging and disproving blowhards without tipping into anarchy. That makes dogmatic incumbents' positions less stable while, remarkably, maintaining the integrity of the system as a whole. Science doesn't (or shouldn't) claim to negate our worst instincts. Simply to uniquely check them through its method.
- healinpor 6y agoThis is subtly one of my favorite comments in the history of Hacker News, and I've read a lot of good ones. We're at this weird historical moment where we are enjoying the many rewards of Enlightenment philosophy, but we've forgotten almost all of the stuff they wrote about the weaknesses of human nature. Everyone and their brother is throwing mud at the notions of reason and logic thanks to postmodernism, pointing out their hypocrisies and failures, ignoring the fact that that's the default. Of course human beings are contradictory and full of self-interested behavior and reasoning. They knew that in ancient Greece better than we do! The point is that we have demonstrated we can improve on the baseline condition, not that men have suddenly become angels. It's a false standard and enormously damaging.
- oceanplexian 6y ago
- thgaway17 6y agoI just want to thank the person who posted the Biontech / Friedman / RNA herpes vaccine story here on HN in October ‘19. Got in on BNTX @ 15.
- kaycebasques 6y ago> Researchers looking for mRNA were ridiculed by colleagues Sounds like textbook Structure of Scientific Revolutions?
- deepnotderp 6y agoYup. I honestly believe The Structure of Scientific Revolutions should be required reading
- PostOnce 6y agoIt was in ~2008 at the school I was at
- rostifar 6y agoInterestingly, the early days of deep learning also followed this pattern. Some context [1]. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/hoo6m8/d_ml_oldtimers_when_did_deep_learning_really_take/ https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/hoo6m8/d_m...
- wetpaws 6y ago"progress in science is happening one funeral at a time"
- jonplackett 6y agoIt's so hard for people to let go of an idea. I remember reading about how a lot of Einstein's later ideas came from him trying to disprove Quantum theory, and that it takes ~50 years for a big idea to be accepted. ie, as you say, it's never accepted.
- refurb 6y agoThis makes for a good story but shouldn’t be surprising. You don’t have to go far to find people willing to ridicule a new idea in science. Most of the time it’s “why are you focusing on that area of research? It’s a dead end”. It makes for a good story for the non-scientist, but as a scientist this is how it works. Until you can prove your theory it’s just a theory and it’s the job of other scientists to poke holes in it.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoLove the 90 years old have the interest to lead cello. It is this interest in spite of obstacle that get us to here. However still one has to know technology itself is neutral. Now we can produce a drug that can disappear after its effect, that can patch the system without the main source code involved ... Is it dangerous? Who stop some outside western governance to make and try getting their piggy stronger ... then accidentally
- peter_retief 6y agoI sometimes wonder who are these administrators who seem to consistently block scientific discovery? Having worked as a research assistant some years back I was dismayed at how political scientific research was. Nothing happened without the nod of a few well connected academics.
- aritmo 6y agoIs there a list of those colleagues that did the ridiculing?
- Leparamour 6y ago>Is there a list of those colleagues that did the ridiculing? It doesn't matter anymore. Those names will now have switched over to the winning side, probably claiming they were agreeing in secret all along.
- aritmo 6y agoThe benefit in investigating who exhibited the bad behavior, is to understand how to avoid such toxic circumstances. There are feuds here and there in scientific fields, and those do not advance science.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoWhen I was a physicist, people adept of "alternative" things (telepathy, telekinesis, ...) were all saying that we are closed minded and that we do not let anything outside of what we know to be brought to light. As I mentioned in a comment in the past, I had the chance to be a regular on the radio (90's) and said several times that I officially announced that I will switch the topic of my PhD thesis the moment when someone shows me a physical event that I cannot explain. Oh boy, I saw my fair share of lunatics and fanatics, I spend nights in haunted houses, with children whose parents claim they have telekinesis capabilities etc. Unfortunately, I did not switch, ended up with a standard PhD instead of the Nobel-yielding one about telekinesis or homeopathy. To the people who were saying that we do not want to look at anything outside our comfort zone, I told an old joke: "John was constantly praying to his god to let him win at the lottery. Day after day, he was praying and praying. Then one day he saw a bright light and a loud voice said JOHN, GIVE ME AN OPPRTUNITY, BUY A TICKET!!" This is more or less this: show something unusual, please!
- tramav 6y agoAre you sure that you are not the person in your joke: "The physicist John was constantly announcing on radio to let people show him a physical event that he cannot explain. He was a regular on radio and asked several times. Then one day he read this sentence on the internet: JOHN, PUT SOME WORK INTO YOUR RESEARCH, HE WHO SEEKS FINDS."?
- at_a_remove 6y agoThe line "Oh boy, I saw my fair share of lunatics and fanatics, I spend nights in haunted houses, with children whose parents claim they have telekinesis capabilities etc." suggests that much seeking was done.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoYes, thank you for quoting. Way too much seeking, actually. It was fun, though. You get to meet some very unusual people.
- jonplackett 6y agoThis reminds me of a quote: "Don't worry about people stealing an idea. If it's original, you will have to ram it down their throats." -Howard H. Aiken
- flyinglizard 6y agoA very effective person I know would gaslight people in meetings to think his ideas were actually theirs.
- corty 6y agoThat is a common technique taught in rhetoric and management courses. People are quite fond of their own ideas and implicitly devalue the ideas of others. Therefore, if you don't care about owning an idea but care about getting it done, just talk the leader or the whole group into thinking it was theirs. It is actually quite easy, because most people are sufficiently vain to accept this without resistance.
- davidgerard 6y agoIt's amazing how much you can get done if you don't worry about taking the credit.
- bsenftner 6y agoAnd then the selfless employee is not promoted.
- alpaca128 6y agoThat is not what gaslighting means.
- flyinglizard 6y agoYou must have missed the update
- delecti 6y ago
- orlovs 6y agoI find this article kinda funny from nowdays perspective. There so many things, more controversial or less controversial. where other side being ridiculed big time, when they dont agree on “scientic” dogmas. Starting from begining of universe, tackling global warming/green stuff, lets not even talk about covid19 related issues, from origins or how to surpress it. Lets face it, since we are living in one united info space, there are less and less thougth diverity how to do things in same field
- GuB-42 6y agoThere is a lot of thought diversity, it is easier than ever to find crackpot theories. The difference is that as science advances, it is becoming harder and harder to simply understand what's going on. Research on the beginning of the universe involve taking into account huge amount of observation data. Come up with a theory and you are going to get questions like "how do you take into account this spectrum density of that oddball galaxy no one but specialists heard about?". And if you don't come up with a satisfactory answer, then your theory is simply wrong, especially if the official theory explains this. Global warming? People on TV make is sound easy, far from it. We suspected it long ago but definite evidence is relatively recent. It involves complex statistical models and again, because it is real science, tons of observation. How to tackle it is even harder because you add a political/economic dimension to it. Scientists can say "if we do that, this will happen", and they are not even sure, but if the "solution" involves, say, killing half of the human population, this is clearly unacceptable (and you are going to piss off the Avengers). Covid19 research is actually a bit looser than usual because of the emergency, but again, hard stuff. But it is interesting to see that scientists tried whacky stuff, and these mostly failed.
- eevilspock 6y agoTime to break out the Thomas Kuhn again.
- williesleg 6y agoGlobal warming gals?
- z5h 6y ago“The mRNA slips into our cells, carrying instructions to make antibodies that target SARS-CoV-2”. No. The mRNA has instructions to reproduce part of the structure of the virus. Our immune system creates antibodies to the foreign and inert bits of virus.
- TaupeRanger 6y agoI don't have much confidence in the scientific accuracy of a "long read" article that begins with the mind numbing trope of a storybook personal anecdote. 80% of this article is free of useful or relevant information. The parts that anyone would ever remember could be summed up in 3 paragraphs. I really hate this trend in journalism but I suppose it exists for a reason, as people won't read things that aren't "entertaining".
- zamalek 6y ago> part of the structure of the virus. Specifically the spike protein that's been talked about everywhere. There is no actual COVID-19 virus involved. It would be like cloning only your fingers, and using those finger clones to train fingerprint scanners. Later on, when the real human comes along, those scanners would recognize you. Those finger clones wouldn't be able to do anything else meaningful and would eventually decay away.
- garyrob 6y agoThe fact that an idea is rejected is not, on its own, evidence that it's any good. However, great ideas are often not "obviously" good, because if they were, someone would have done them already. And if they're not obviously good, they'll tend to be rejected when they're first discussed. This is even true when the idea is explained to experts in the relevant field field, because the experts think they know how things are done, and a really great idea is usually sufficiently different from their and habitual modes of thinking that it will seem inconsistent with what they have long "known" to be true. If you have an idea and it's rejected, it probably should be. But if you have, in fact, thought it through in more depth than anyone else, and actually know more about its part of a field than the most experts in that field do, then it might be right. You have to take full responsibility for deciding that; during the critical time of an idea's gestation, no one can take that responsibility for you. Eventually, if and when the idea is made real, it will be verified in the real world.
- mvh 6y agoMy dad (U Arizona professor of public health) interviewed Matthew Meselson at length, mostly about topics other than the mRNA discovery. Anyone interested can find the interview here: https://mobile.twitter.com/sci_history/status/1147879614670417926 https://mobile.twitter.com/sci_history/status/11478796146704...
- Sosh101 6y ago> The mRNA slips into our cells, carrying instructions to make antibodies that target SARS-CoV-2. This isn't correct at all.
- EricE 6y agoAny time some idiot spouts "the science is settled" just point them to this.
- initramfs 6y agoI was a student of Carl Woese, who studied mRNA in the 60s and 70s. He made the yuuge discovery of archaea being, not only the third domain, but closer related to humans than procaryotes. He wrote letters to Francis Crick too, which have been published. Another interesting person who was thought to be kooky was Douglas Engelbart https://hackaday.io/page/9869-the-mother-of-all-tech-demos-and-human-computer-interaction https://hackaday.io/page/9869-the-mother-of-all-tech-demos-a...