30 ms·
The largest study to date on the genetic basis of sexuality (2019)
- ohduran 6y agoNot an expert here but, IF a gay gene existed, wouldn't have it been evolved into extinction?
- TulliusCicero 6y agoNot necessarily, as long as it's recessive. Not an expert either here though.
- abcc8 6y agoIf recessive, you'd expect the wild type and 'gay' alleles to be in Hardy Weinberg Equilibrium. However, this obviously isn't the case.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoYes, it would; being recessive just makes the process take longer. I've pointed out on other HN threads that homosexuality has much lower concordance in identical twins (around 40%) than almost any other trait, making it an especially unlikely candidate for direct genetic causes.
- berelig 6y agoAlso not if for most of humanity the mates with this hypothetical gene were repressed into heterosexual relationships.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hello_friendos 6y agoImportant to note that there isn't just Gay and Straight, but more often people exist somewhere in between. That's why we have bisexual and pansexual people.
- npwr 6y agoNot if it is recessive. Example with a recessive "gay gene": Both parent have one normal allele and one "gay" allele. The repartition of the offspring will be: - 25% both normal alleles (normal phenotype) - 50% one normal allele (normal phenotype) - 25% both gay alleles (gay phenotype) But homosexuality is not a gene. I believe that the [fetal androgen exposure theory](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prenatal_hormones_and_sexual_orientation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prenatal_hormones_and_sexual_o...) is the one currently preferred.
- creata 6y agoA common analogy here is that in lots of insects, you see whole groups of non-reproductive members, and yet the idea of a "non-reproductive worker insect" hasn't "evolved into extinction." (I'm not commenting on whether being gay has a genetic basis or whether it's an example of kin selection, because honestly, I have no idea.)
- abfan1127 6y agonon-reproductive workers benefit the reproductive insects. For instance, worker bees benefit the queen. The queens that lay the eggs in the most beneficial ratios are most likely to survive and pass on. For this analogy to be equivalent, it should lead to having gay children benefit the adults enough to allow for more successful breeding. I do am not commenting on one's gayness has a genetic basis, because I also have not idea.
- lultimouomo 6y agoThe point is that non-reproductive insects don't have specific set of genes that make them non-reproductive - it is not an inheritable trait. If it was, then it would have evolved into extinction.
- Brian_K_White 6y agoOf course they do (have genes that make them non-reproductive) and of course it hasn't (evolved out of extinction). There is nothing about a possible genetic basis (whether complex and indirect or simple and direct) for an individuals non-reproductiveness that implies it has to result in extiguishing itself. Humans are social enough that genetics which benefit the group at the expense of the individual are perfectly selectable. Heck it even works for utterly antisocial species. All that's required for a trait to persist is for it to be good for any members by any means. It doesn't have to be good for the individual carrier, and it doesn't have to be good in a way that we happen to understand.
- slavik81 6y agoA more formal description: > If a gene copy confers a benefit B on another vehicle at cost C to its own vehicle, its costly action is strategically beneficial if p_B > C, where p is the probability that a copy of the gene is present in the vehicle that benefits. Actions with substantial costs therefore require significant values of p. Two kinds of factors ensure high values of p: relatedness (kinship) and recognition (green beards). The Selfish Gene is probably the most famous way of looking at that concept. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene-centered_view_of_evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene-centered_view_of_evolutio...
- KingMachiavelli 6y agoThere is also the 'beneficial sibling' theory where a homosexual sibling improves the reproductive success of their siblings/close family via being able to devote more energy to their siblings offspring instead of their own or are able to gather/utilize more resources that leads to a familial advantage.
- lr4444lr 6y agoCommon mutations are inescapable.
- hliyan 6y agoIt might persevere through kin selection. For siblings who share the gene, such an individual would have all the benefits of a male/female (security, hunting, care-giving), but none of the mating competition. One could argue if such a gene existed, it would be quite an altruistic one.
- NortySpock 6y agoA lot of the musings I've seen in this direction have been along the lines of (1) some people are bisexual and thus would occasionally reproduce and (2) if sexuality promotes "togetherness" and "group cohesion", then having "our gay uncle who 'has connections' and is always willing to help out the family group" is still beneficial for the family unit and thus a gay gene would not be selected against within that family lineage. Probably not a majority of the population, but there's no reason for such a "gay gene" (if it were to exist) to be driven to zero.
- fredley 6y agoNot neccessarily. Humans are social creatures, our genes' survival is not solely dependent on our individual ability to pass them on, since we share genes with our siblings and parents as well as offspring. For example, families with some non-reproducing offspring may fair better due to having a higher adults/children ratio. If such a gene existed (which perhaps it doesn't), it might benefit families who had members carrying it. This is the same reason some species have evolved alarm-calling when a predator is nearby. It benefits the collective (who share the gene), but at an obvious detriment to the individual's ability to pass on their genes in this case.
- ben_w 6y agoIn addition, one suggestion is that a possible “gay gene” would be something that causes extremely strong attraction to men in both men and women with that gene. Women with this gene would then be more likely to father children, which could counter the evolutionary pressure resulting from the male offspring with that gene not having any offspring. (I’m massively oversimplfing of course, my bio knowledge is fairly limited).
- ip26 6y agoUh, I know we’re all about redefining gender roles these days, but I’m not yet ready for women to father children...
- cwkoss 6y agoIn my EvoBio class a decade ago, my professor told us the theory that homosexuality could be adaptive based on birth order because it would reduce fraternal rivalry: the family would have an additional adult to care for the young without being a reproductive competitor.
- valarauko 6y agoThis doesn't make much sense, though. Every additional human is a very expensive investment of time, resources, and effort on the family, and offers no material return on investment for at least a decade in terms of productivity. True, while the gay son might not produce offspring to compete with his brother's kids, it also means he brings no additional mate and offspring to help out the family.
- mikepurvis 6y agoThe argument around this is that it's of social benefit rather than individual. Particularly when child/infant mortality is high and women have lots of children, it could be helpful to have a pool of adults supporting the child-rearing of others, especially their immediate siblings.
- nabla9 6y agoNot necessarily. * the same gene can have different phenotypes in different individuals. One phenotype may be net negative but the benefit from the other makes it net positive. * in social animal gene can be carried by relatives. Extreme example is ants and bees, most of them are not fertile but they help to spread their genes by helping those who are.
- Brian_K_White 6y agoMore than just that, as far as I can see, there is no reason this only applies to social species. If it benefits the pool that x% of members have a trait, even full sterility, then the genetics will result in x% having that trait, as long as the benefit continues to exist. I'm not sure what an example mechanism might be for some mountain cats or spiders or whatever that the species benefits from 4% of their members being sterile, but I see no reason that there couldn't be one, and it doesn't require the unfortunate exhibitors of the trait to preserve and occasionally produce the next exhibitor of the trait.
- valarauko 6y agoLet's assume the benefit is improved female fertility. If it's an autosomal trait, half of the carriers will be male, and lead to the vast majority of them refusing to have offspring. That would require the sisters to have a pretty spectacular bump in the number of offspring to offset their gay brothers. Indeed, since the trait is clearly polygenic, all the sisters do not inherit the trait equally, if at all. The sisters who do inherit it would have to be spectacularly fecund to compensate.
- pdpi 6y agoNot necessarily. If the gene is recessive, it will be passed on. The question then is: what happens when that gene expresses itself? The naive reaction is: individuals with the "gay gene" won't reproduce and it will eventually die out. A more nuanced perspective is that while that individual won't reproduce, their presence in the community helps the clan's survival, so a community with the gene is overall stronger, so the gene will stay around.
- agravier 6y agoDepending on other conditions (environmental and genetic), a particular gene may not be expressed in the same manner (or at all). You can find simple examples in recessive alleles. The phenotype of such genes will only be expressed when both alleles are of a compatible type. Another striking example: Sickle cell disease will only be deadly if both alleles carry the unfortunate mutation. But the unhealthy allele is unlikely to be eliminated by evolutionary pressure because carrying one allele provides significant protection against malaria. The interactions between genes and their environment is usually more complicated that these simple examples, but I hope it illustrates that evolutionary pressure may not suffice to erase some apparently unsustainable alleles from the population.
- btilly 6y agoThe striking example that you gave is more striking than that. Having one allele actually brings protection from malaria. So the recessive is selected for..as long as not too many people have it. That is why sickle-cell anemia mostly shows up in people whose ancestors came from places with a long history of malaria.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoI would think that being "gay" doesn't 100% prevent someone from fathering / mothering children.
- inglor_cz 6y agoThis. In the past, there was a lot of prominent personalities who were suspected of being gay, but left progeny. Social pressure to have children, especially if there is a title / wealth / prestige to inherit, would certainly play a role.
- kgwgk 6y agoNot only social pressure. It’s a fact that some homosexual people do want to procreate.
- xutopia 6y agoWell yes and no. It might actually give a benefit to other siblings. It could manifest itself only in certain circumstances in the womb or in the environment if something helps the phenotype manifest itself... For example there is a correlation with sibling order and homosexuality. The more boys your mother had before you the more chance you have of being homosexual. We're talking about a non-negligible increase of over 30%: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_birth_order_and_male_sexual_orientation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_birth_order_and_male...
- threeseed 6y agoWhat if the "gay gene" is tied to the "sexually attracted to our parents gene" ? And evolving out the former would cause the later to go which is detrimental to the overall health of the species.
- whatshisface 6y agoThe trouble with that argument is that it also works with, "If there was a genetic cause for shortsightedness, why is it still around?" "If there was such a thing as a genetic disease, why haven't they evolved out?" "If not having X-ray vision was genetic, wouldn't the absence of X-ray vision have been selected out?" You really can't expect evolution to accomplish its "goals," per se. It is sort of a gentle flow down a lazy river, towards adaptation.
- lultimouomo 6y ago"If there was a genetic cause for shortsightedness, why is it still around?" - because myopia doesn't significantly affect your chances to produce offsprings. It seems reasonable that being gay does significantly reduce your ability to have children; therefore it is reasonable to expect that if it was an inheritable trait it would have been selected against.
- Brian_K_White 6y agoEveryone keeps saying that, but it's simply not true. We have understood how this is not true for decades or even hundreds of years, and it's not even some impossible concept to grasp. All that's required for a trait to persist, is for it to benefit the pool, not the individual. The only way the seemingly obvious but incorrect idea you descibed applies is, a trait which is good for the group at the expense of the individual, if it's 100% effective like sterility unlike say alarm-calling which merely carries a risk for the individual, is that such a trait can never grow to where all members exhibit it. But it can absolutely be strongly selected for maintaining whatever the optimal percentage is. IE, if it benefits the pool for 10% of members to be sterile, then the percentage of sterile members will not decrease through the mechanism you and so many imagine, but will stay at 10% for as long as the benefit exists.
- dctaflin 6y agoAnd everybody keeps saying THAT. The problem is, that's a secondary effect. A secondary effect is going to have to be pretty strong to counter an obviously anti-competitive primary effect. You can construct scenarios, but I haven't seen any that seem particularly compelling. It seems to me that the default position of "it's not genetic" is much better supported by the data.
- zvrba 6y agoInterestingly, I've heard about many people who went from "straight", married with children to leaving their families because they've found out they're gay. I even knew one whose first sexual experiences were with women, and he decided he was gay later. In his "straight phase" he could have had fathered children if he weren't careful. Curiously, I've never heard about opposite cases (spontaneous [1] gay -> straight transition). Make of it what you want. [1] Spontaneous = ignoring attempts to "cure" gay orientation.
- praptak 6y agoThe other posts cover possible reasons why being gay may be actually good for the utility function of a gene. There is another hypothesis for why this hypothetical gene might not evolve into extinction. Being gay may just be a side effect of it, with some other benefits being the reason this gene stays in our gene pool.
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y agoIf you take a simplistic view of genetics where you draw Punnet squares and check if the offspring has GG alleles, maybe. Even if there are social benefits to there being some gay people around, that would still make those alleles pretty unlikely to be passed on. That doesn't imply there isn't a genetic component. Real genetics is a lot more complicated than that. The fact that something is genetic doesn't imply there is no social component. Genetic factors could lead to a predisposition for a certain behavior that would still be altered by environment. There could be many genes that each has some small effect but none of which is an on/off switch. Those would lead to more complicated selection pressures. We are pretty sure there is a genetic component. We are pretty sure that it isn't just "if you got the gay allele then you's gay". Also, some gay (or mostly gay) people have children. This is because a) most people are at least a little bit bisexual, b) people may want to have children even if the sex act isn't appealing, and c) there are social pressures to conform.
- tzs 6y agoThere are several possibilities. 1. If having gay relatives improved the chances that you will have children and they would survive to themselves reproduce, then evolution could favor maintaining a gay gene. Remember that for nearly all of our species' existence, and that of the pre-humans we evolved from, we've lived most of our lives in arrangements where our close relatives lived near us and most people in the region were also related to us. Your children have half your genes. Your siblings' children have a quarter of your genes. So in effect two of your siblings children are equivalent to one of your own as far as getting your genetic material into the next generation goes. If being gay meant that your sibling does not have their own kids to take care of and so they devote effort that would have gone to raising their own kids to helping their straight siblings' with their kids or to doing things that help the village that those with kids don't have the time for, that might greatly increase the survival rate of those kids enough to make up for not having kids of their own. 2. Being gay doesn't mean you can't have kids. Throughout most of our history, many many people have had kids with people they have not been attracted to. That goes for both gay people and straight people. 3. What if it were a bisexual gene rather than a gay gene? Having people in your tribe that can form with both men and women the kind of close bonds the people form for the sexual partners has some obvious advantages.
- notabee 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grandmother_hypothesis#The_grandmother_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grandmother_hypothesis#The_gra...
- throwaway2245 6y agoI view this question - and the deliberation over it - as coming from present-day society's latent homophobia. Doesn't the question apply to straight people, and anyone else, who don't reproduce?
- wyldfire 6y agoIf homosexuality provided a species or community benefit, it could be selected for in that way. Perhaps akin to aging phenomena that benefit the species through mortality.
- Kye 6y agoA lot of the search for a gay gene seems trapped in an outdated understanding of sexuality as a binary proposition: "you're either A or B." How do you even begin to contemplate a study on sexuality once you understand it as highly varied and fluid? Same with gender. They're bimodal distributions at best. You can't just crop off the confounding valleys and call what you do with them good science.
- another_kel 6y agoIntelligence or height is a spectrum too, yet we can probably explore existence of such genes. You just need to think in probabilities.
- abcc8 6y agoYes, this study indicates that human sexuality is a trait more complex than many other aspects of humans, i.e. height, eye color, hair color, skin color, etc.
- mnky9800n 6y agoThis would be evidence of your argument then.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- red01 6y agoTo be fair the LGBT movement purposefully pushed that misconception because it was more convenient for civil rights purposes.
- rootusrootus 6y agoWhen you're trying to convince the majority to quit discriminating against you, then you push whatever evidence you've got. Convincing them that it's genetic, and therefore not a choice, is a prime goal.
- t-writescode 6y agoIt was easier to fit in as a bisexual person in the past, than a homosexual person, so bisexual people didn't need as much representation in the past. Ironically, now we're at a point where that's flipped, and you need to be either gay or straight and can't be somewhere in the middle; but, earlier on, bisexual people could escape persecution and therefore weren't the primary focus. It's a lot more effective to have the discussion "Dad, I like guys!" and get the father to accept that in the 1950s than it was to say "Hey dad, I like guys and gals". The father could just as easily go "You know, I think there's some good looking men out there, too" and completely miss the point.
- remote_phone 6y agoI thought they determined already it was a hormone released in the womb during pregnancy, similar to left-handedness. That’s how you can get identical twins, but one is straight and the other is gay.
- the-dude 6y agoThat is a pretty self-contradicting statement in multiple ways.
- robertakarobin 6y agoNot necessarily. My twin boys who just turned 3 are identical according to a genetic test, but were in different sacs with different placenta. This is uncommon, but not THAT uncommon. I think it's not unreasonable that they would have received different amounts of chemicals. They are certainly very similar, but have many differences, and were a pound apart at birth.
- antattack 6y agoHonest question: what is being gay? Is it physical attraction? Emotional attraction? Both? Is it dislike, fear(?) of opposite sex?
- swarnie_ 6y agoAn innate desire to form an atypical pairing in a non-reproductive fashion. Honestly i have no idea but this might be one of the last places left on the internet you can ask a question like this without getting dogpiled. I've batted for both teams in my life and i still can't tell you.
- dleslie 6y agoIndeed, sexual attraction is a lot more complicated than "I am attracted to this bimodal extreme of gender."
- swarnie_ 6y agoAgreed, and it isn't a static thing defined at birth by nature, it can change backwards and forwards over a lifetime. Not sure why i'm getting a hard time from our co-commenters. I assumed this place being primarily US and Tech it would be quite liberal.
- dleslie 6y agoHeh, the political spectrum of this place is broad and well-distributed, but the quality of discussion _tends_ to be more respectful than most forums.
- rectang 6y agoI'm quite (socially) liberal and I thought your post was simply wrong, for starters. Among the places you can ask the question "what is being gay" without getting "dogpiled" are countless gay sites. Aren't gay sites part of the internet?
- 6y ago
- Bostonian 6y ago"Ganna and his colleagues also used the analysis to estimate that up to 25% of sexual behaviour can be explained by genetics, with the rest influenced by environmental and cultural factors — a figure similar to the findings of smaller studies." An argument for gay rights has been that people are "born that way". That appears to be false. Does this suggest that it may be possible to shape the environment to reduce the incidence of homosexuality? I wonder if societal normalization of homosexuality through the recognition of same-sex marriage, Pride Month, and LGBTQ clubs in schools and colleges have increased its incidence, and if the same is true for transgenderism.
- Taek 6y agoThe cultural factors related to being gay could easily be unrelated to how much being gay is accepted by society. Especially considering how many famous people are now known to have been gay during a time when it was not acceptable. Also, there are lots of social studies that seem to suggest having gay family members can be beneficial to the family as a whole, so reducing the amount of homosexuality in the world may actually be undesirable.
- SonicScrub 6y ago> An argument for gay rights has been that people are "born that way". That appears to be false Only if you take the strict literal definition of the phrase "born that way" to mean your genetic make-up. A person has little to no control over their environmental factors during their upbringing. Everything from average air temperature, food nutrient makeup, airborne particles, etc are environmental factors that we know influence other aspects of human development. Your comment is making the assumption that the environmental factor that causes homosexuality is witnessing other members of the species be homosexual, which is a large leap of logic to make. Especially knowing that homosexuality is quite common in the animal kingdom despite penguins not participating in Pride Months.
- hyperpape 6y agoEntirely right. Even more: "environment" in this context includes the pre-natal environment.
- imjustsaying 6y agoGay males reproduce by having sex with males when they're younger.
- swarnie_ 6y agoYou want to take a second crack at that? I'm not even sure what you're trying to say.
- tofery 6y agoIt's a meme I see every now and then. It is based on two beliefs. One is that boys molested in their youth are more likely to be gay later on in life. Another is that gay men (or some subset of gay men) are pedophiles. Combining these two beliefs, the meme asserts that gay pedophiles sexually assault young boys and "turn" them gay, and calls this a form of reproduction (in the sense of one gay man creating more gay men). The meme itself is intended mostly to get a rise out of people. It would be wise to pay it no mind. But if anyone wants to earnestly defend this position, I'm all ears.
- dominotw 6y agoDoes it mean people are socialized into being gay ?
- flowerlad 6y agoHopefully, no. Because if true then it legitimizes conversation therapies.
- zgin4679 6y agoOr even conversion therapies. I'd much rather not be talked to ad nauseam about it!
- jodrellblank 6y agoBut if they worked they wouldn’t be objectionable? Being forced into them would be objectionable, but being forced into your family farm doesn’t mean farming itself is bad. If conversion therapy was a thing that worked and you could choose it if you wanted, it would be like any other life choice - changing career, religion, nationality, etc.
- stemlord 6y agoThey have never worked. It's a well-known truth amongst gay people that the conversion therapy "success stories" are people who chose to go back into the closet for the rest of their lives.
- jodrellblank 6y agoI think my comment isn't clear enough. That they don’t work is why they shouldn’t be legitimised. They are offering a fraudulent or misleading service to anyone choosing to attend, and forcing someone to attend is a cruelty. I read the parent comment as saying “I hope homosexuality isn’t learned /because/ that would legitimise conversion therapy”, but I say that would be a fine hypothetical world - it’s objecting to the wrong thing, conversion therapy isn’t inherently a bad thing, it’s only bad in worlds where it doesn’t work, like the real world. Another way of saying it is, if homosexuality is socially determined (in the real world), why fear that would “legitimise” a conversion therapy which doesn’t work (in the real world)?
- airhead969 6y agoAbsence of proof from an infinite pool of choices isn't proof of absence, but complete understanding of the genome would eliminate it by exhaustion. In terms of XY exclusively-gay, I think epigenetic is still the leading hypothesis and not genetic by itself. It would be interesting to learn how the genetics set-us up for epigenetic influences. Other non-heterosexual and flexible sexualities for XX and XY seem more fluid and complicated to unpack. For example, I am unsure what proportion of lesbians are gold star and cannot be aroused at all by males, but I suspect it is low.
- coding123 6y agoI'm curious if they instead focused on a simple neural net that is fed genes + gay/straight flag if the NN would actually successfully predict it.... in other words, NN's don't care about "finding" that specific gene, they kinda include everything and it "finds" the gene without actually pointing it out. That's very different from the human approach which is to try to find something specific. I mean compare it to blood diseases based on genetics. There are many genes that lead to health problems that comes down the shape. But it's not just one thing, it's a spread of things. We're thinking Gay is a specific gene we're just as unlikely to find it. Not arguing any specific direction, but I just suspect the findings if they don't include variances in their methods.
- slaymaker1907 6y agoThe best you could probably do would be to match twins, so about 65%[1]. [1]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8494487/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8494487/
- klmadfejno 6y agoNeural nets for genetics are probably a good fit, and perhaps arguably, a better biological analogy than actual neurons. But they're likely already getting the gist here. They actually say that with genetic analysis (implying more than one gene at a time), they could explain 25% of sexual behavior. To be honest, that's a lot more than I would have expected. In biology, that's a pretty high predictive power, and I think is a way more interesting headline than "no single gene controls sexual orientation". At the end of the day though, many other factors will contribute, so genetics can only explain so much. With aggressive data collection during development, I would wager we could get sexual orientation prediction much higher. Probably not high on the proverbial bio-ethicist's wishlist of things to make broadly available.
- rickdeveloper 6y agoThis is an interesting idea. I wonder if we could then use something like [0] to trace back "gay-ness" as well as other "personality features" (I'm not sure what the correct term is here) to the exact genes. One potential issue I see is that the DNA of any person has an arbitrary length, which poses some challenges in the design of a neural network. Traditionally, this has been solved with LSTMs or RNNs, but as far I know these are designed for data with a temporal dimension (such as text or speech, which progress with time). I'm not sure if that's true for DNA. [0] https://arxiv.org/abs/1509.06321 https://arxiv.org/abs/1509.06321
- bonoetmalo 6y agoKind of hopeful we can stop using genetics as a way of justifying queer peoples' existence. Whether it's conditioning, a choice, or genetics, shouldn't really be a factor in how you treat queer people.
- rootusrootus 6y agoThat would be ideal, but some people need to be convinced that it is not a choice before they will consider treating gay people with respect. So long as they think it's just a behavioral decision, they can rationalize their bigotry.
- bzb6 6y agoIf anything this headline means the opposite, right? That you are not born a homosexual, at least from a genetic perspective.
- rootusrootus 6y agoI don't think it's making that strong a claim. They can't identify a specific gene. That's not quite "you are not born a homosexual." Plenty of studies over the years have shown statistically very significant genetic links. We just can't explain the exact mechanism yet.
- btilly 6y agoIt is much more nuanced than that. What they found was 5 areas of the genome that had predictive potential for people being gay or straight. Combined, they were able to predict about 25% of what makes someone gay. The other 75% is environmental. Note that some "environmental factors" may still be genetic in nature. For example there is strong evidence in animals that the prenatal environment has an impact on homosexual behavior. Which means that a mother's genetics can be correlated with her children's sexuality. Therefore a gene could impact homosexuality through changing the environment in the mother's womb. In that case the child having that gene would be correlated with the child being homosexual and the gene would show up in this study. But the differences between the child's genetics and the mother's would be an environmental factor.
- JamesAdir 6y agoIt's from 2019. The headline should be fixed.
- dang 6y agoYear added. Thanks for catching that. I changed the title earlier to the first sentence of the article because it seemed more factual and neutral.
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y agoDid anyone ever actually think there was a gay gene-- more accurately, allele? Homosexuality clearly has a genetic component, and we've known that for decades. But we've also known for decades that most traits are not controlled by a single gene and that human sexuality is not a binary matter. This seems like describing a launch to the ISS with the headline "No firmament".
- antattack 6y agoLooking inwards, attraction feels like pattern recognition combined with catecholamine release. So perhaps genes, but also hormones/environment would be responsible.
- readams 6y agoIt's unlikely there's a gene that codes for being gay. Homosexuality instead is better thought of as more like why men have nipples. Obviously the nipples are not useful to the reproductive success of men, but genetics and natural selection are messy and there's likely no easy path to not having them in men while maintaining their function in women. For homosexuality, the systems of sexual attraction in the brain need to tune to the gender somehow, and this is a system which, apparently, isn't 100% successful at aligning gender and sexual attraction. So the answer to "why are some men attracted to men" is the same as "why do men have nipples:" it's because women need to be attracted to men and because women need nipples. And of course it needs to be said that just because someone's sexual attraction isn't aligned to their gender it doesn't mean that they're inferior. We don't measure the worth of a person by their reproductive success.
- mrfusion 6y agoSexually antagonistic pleiotropy perhaps. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antagonistic_pleiotropy_hypothesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antagonistic_pleiotropy_hypo...
- dnissley 6y agoI think this is called a Spandrel: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spandrel_(biology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spandrel_(biology)
- masklinn 6y agoKin-selection hypothesis also allow for some fraction of asexual or homosexual population being a positive overall (from an evolutionary perspective).
- LatteLazy 6y agoThere is good evidence that gay males are much more involved with their neices and nephews [0] and that their sisters are more fertile[1]. [0] https://www.advocate.com/news/daily-news/2010/02/05/study-supports-gay-super-uncles-theory https://www.advocate.com/news/daily-news/2010/02/05/study-su... [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15539346/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15539346/
- ravi-delia 6y agoI'd definitely be surprised if a significant portion of homosexuality wasn't environmental, but to my knowledge there is a degree of heritability shown in twin studies. Actually reading the article shows that they found several genes that each contribute, but no single gene. That shouldn't be surprising to anyone, considering that almost every complex trait is somewhat affected by a huge number of genes each tweaking the result by a small amount. Remember that DNA controls the development of the body through an insanely complicated Rube Goldberg machine, no one should expect a 1:1 correspondence between any complicated trait and a gene.
- anaphor 6y agoRemember that heritability is a measure of a population, not an individual. So you're measuring the amount that genes vs environment contributes to a trait within that population. It's not an absolute number.
- ravi-delia 6y agoI mean, yeah? It's still fairly strong evidence against there being literally no genetic component to homosexuality, which I definitely saw a lot of in this thread. Unless I misunderstand your comment?
- anaphor 6y agoNot disagreeing with your original point, just adding that if you were controlling for environmental factors (everyone has equivalent environment), then you'd see more contribution to variance in phenotypes from genetics than environment. So for homosexuality, I'd bet the reason genetics don't contribute as much is because of the heterogeneous environmental conditions (just think about where you grow up and what religion you are for example). Edit: a good example of this in action is handedness, because different societies historically have different advantages to using different hands > Second, the samples used to estimate the handedness heritability were from different places, different years or different centuries and were not always representative of the general population. Heritability is not an intrinsic property of a trait: it varies with phenotypic and additive genetic variances and thus can vary across populations and across generations https://www.nature.com/articles/s41437-019-0274-3 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41437-019-0274-3
- Udik 6y ago> The study authors also point out that they followed convention for genetic analyses by dropping from their study people whose biological sex and self-identified gender did not match. As a result, the work doesn’t include sexual and gender minorities (the LGBTQ community) such as transgender people and intersex people. I don't get it, isn't this the whole point of the study? The G in LGBTQ stands for "gay", did they exclude people who self-identify as gay from a study meant to find the genetic basis of being gay?
- Aeronwen 6y agoNarrowing things down is easier when you control for one aspect instead of multiple ones. If, hypothetically, being trans inverted the expression of the gene for being gay, you'd have a harder time finding the gene until you accounted for it. By eliminating the possibility, you make it easier to find the gene you're looking for. If you can't find the gene in the smaller pool of subjects, you weren't going to find it in the larger one. But if you did find it, you can learn how it affects everyone in a different study.
- Udik 6y ago> If, hypothetically, being trans inverted the expression of the gene for being gay That, although always possible, seems pretty far-fetched. > If you can't find the gene in the smaller pool of subjects, you weren't going to find it in the larger one. Except that here the larger one includes precisely the community of people that has the highest incidence of same-sex attraction. Imagine trying to determine the influence of genetics on skin colour after having removed from your study everyone who self-identifies as black.
- tofery 6y ago>That, although always possible, seems pretty far-fetched. Sure, perhaps it is farfetched. But the point is trying to eliminate as many variations as possible to focus on a smaller set of people. Then once we have that, we can expand outward. Consider that instead of there being a "gay gene", there is a gene (or set of genes) that controls not homosexuality, but androphilia (sexual attraction to men/males/masculinity) and perhaps another that controls gynephilia (sexual attraction to women/females/femininity). [note 1] In that case, by looking at only one sex we could find such a gene. This is just an example of which there are many, but my intent is to show why looking at a smaller sample first could prove useful later. Note 1: There is some precedent for this particular theory: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Androphilia_and_gynephilia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Androphilia_and_gynephilia
- mrfusion 6y agoGenes aren’t a good way to explain most things. They’re more like LEGO blocks. It’s how the cells use and express the genes that matters. So you want to look at regulatory regions of the genome, promoters, and even how and when the dna folds up to inactive large regions. That’s where all the action is.
- iguy 6y agoThere are two meanings to "gene" here. What you describe as lego blocks are segments which code for a protein, which is one meaning. The other is just any code which affects the phenotype, including promotors etc. The SNPs mentioned in TFA are just known fairly common single-point differences, but aren't necessarily in coding DNA. Of course these are still heritable, just like coding changes.
- ahupp 6y agoIt would be nice if they included the upper bound of the genetic component from twin studies. Without that it's hard to say whether the 8-25% they found here is as much as we'll get, or if large studies are needed. It would be pretty surprising if they found a single gene though. The omnigenetic theory says that every complex trait is influenced by small contributions from many genes. https://www.quantamagazine.org/omnigenic-model-suggests-that-all-genes-affect-every-complex-trait-20180620/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/omnigenic-model-suggests-that...
- abfan1127 6y agoI recently read about the spectrum of homosexuality. Its not a black and white issue. I don't recall the Kinsey scale being the article I read, but it seems relevant. If this is the case, it seems less likely its a single gene. Perhaps its multiple gene expressions accompanied with environmental factors? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinsey_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinsey_scale
- haberman 6y agoIs there any trait that is strongly linked to a single gene? Whenever I hear a news article that there is no X gene, I am completely unsurprised. The idea that a single gene would uniquely determine a particular trait, as if it were a variable in a program like "bool has_blue_eyes", seems oversimplified and unrealistic.
- iguy 6y ago> Is there any trait that is strongly linked to a single gene? Sure. Sickle-cell anaemia is one classic case, one (recessive) gene. Huntington's disease is another, it's about a specific repeat number. But, as you say, most complex traits (such as height) aren't like that, and involve hundreds or thousands of different genes. IIRC eye color is actually fairly simple, not one gene but much of the control in just a handful? Maybe hair color too? (But not super-sure.)
- nradov 6y agoABO blood group gene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ABO_%28gene%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ABO_%28gene%29
- Simulacra 6y agoYes. MC1R which people with red hair carry. It's a very strongly associated gene. Also "People with freckles and no red hair have an 85% chance of carrying the MC1R gene that is connected to red hair. People with no freckles and no red hair have an 18% chance of carrying the MC1R gene linked to red hair." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melanocortin_1_receptor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melanocortin_1_receptor
- BugsJustFindMe 6y agoPeople latched onto the idea that sexuality is genetically determined because it seemed like the only viable way to defend themselves against rampant religious bigotry and oppression. It was a rope dangling into the well you were trapped in, and the well was filling with acid, but if you could just manage to climb that rope then you'd make it out. The reasoning went something like "if I can prove that sexuality is genetically predetermined then it means that I didn't choose to be this way". As if genetic predestination were the only possible reason to grant protection to a class. Some people fairly quickly saw the problem with this defense and expanded it to include other uncontrollable elements of childhood development, again leaning on the "if I didn't have a choice _then_ it has to be ok". As if choices were still somehow the problem. But that's always been a fucked up idea. It shouldn't matter whether it was predetermined or otherwise not in your control. If it's constructed then it's constructed. If it's not then it's not. People shouldn't be oppressed for their sexuality full stop, regardless of reason. I think the idea of genetic predestination might have been a short-term useful crutch in the past but I hope that we've begun to progress beyond needing people to explain themselves.
- memling 6y ago> But that's always been a fucked up idea. It shouldn't matter whether it was predetermined or otherwise not in your control. If it's constructed then it's constructed. If it's not then it's not. People shouldn't be oppressed for their sexuality full stop, regardless of reason. You are right, I think, to root the conflict in religion. The dominant religion in the West, Christianity, treats the human body as a given. That is to say that while you are more than just your body, you are certainly not less: there is a union of mind and body that separates only at death. If they disagree, a reconciliation must be attempted from the outside (i.e., by God). Of course today we have technology that puts a veneer of science on what is really a religious idea: we are essentially our mind and not our body. When the two disagree, we needn't change our minds because we can alter the body through hormones and surgery. On the face of it, I don't see how you could reconcile these two positions. I think the use of genetic predestination was used as an attempt to do this: if I'm made this way then how can it be wrong to be {gay, trans, etc.}? But in general I think the denominations that were predisposed to blessing homosexuality (for example) were unlikely to need scientific persuasions like that. When it became clear that rigid denominations weren't going to budge, it feels like genetic predestination became unfashionable.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoGenes + how they are read (epigenetics) both matter equally
- klmadfejno 6y ago> equally citation needed
- nomoreusernames 6y agoi dont get it. whats the problem with accepting that homosexuality might have traits other than where people want to put their genitalia. perhaps its about sending information down via genes and culture? seems homosexuals are amazingly beautiful at generating art and cracking nazi spy codes. maybe their families have other genes and we are just focusing on the whole where people put their genitalia thing vs the "wow maybe gays have a lot to contribute with, you know, just as women or men who are sterile." still find it hilarious that people have been obsessing about this since i was born and longer. accepting homosexuality took me like 1 minute. 45 seconds of laughing at two genitals of the same kind not fitting, and 15 thinking about i love my friend and i want her to be happy because she deserves to feel loved the way she needs too.
- Simulacra 6y agoI've always thought hormones had something to do with sexuality, because as Wikipedia says "sex hormones control the ability to engage in on the motivation to engage in sexual behaviors." What I'm thinking here is that motivation. Some people are motivated to engage with one gender or sexuality, and it becomes hard wired through that developmental process.
- LatteLazy 6y agoOne of the sad things about the state of sex ed is that this isn't taught in school. The interplay between genetics (homosexuality is at least somewhat heritable) and environmental factors (each older brother a boy has from the same mother increases the chance he will be gay by about 40%). Also, this study and many others uses the term "men who have sex with men" not gay. These are two overlapping but different groups. Plus you need yo look at evidence that sexuality is a modern construct. The Kinsey scale and attitudes to sex in other societies (where men who have sex with men are sometimes considered a third gender or where its more a matter of taste/fancy than a rigid part of identity) would help people understand actual sexuality more effectively. What you end up with is some genetics, some epigenetics and some environmental factors creating preferences of various strengths. Those are then buried under a layer of socially acceptable behaviour. Which in turn is filtered through identifies ("I'm not gay, I just do it with my mate"). The point being humans are messy.
- karmakaze 6y agoI would have thought occurrences of one identical twin being gay would already have covered this. I'm sure the study covers more but the title doesn't grab me.
- smnthermes 6y agoThere's a theory* that says things like autism, creative genius and homosexuality are caused by suppression of innate characteristics of our species. If so, then it makes sense why there isn't a "gay gene", since there aren't also specific genes for more than 90% of autistics. * https://archive.is/BsxMm https://archive.is/BsxMm
- angst_ridden 6y agoLike with most things attributed to genetics, it's more likely that we should be looking at epigenetics.
- adamredwoods 6y agoConsider studies done on penguins: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/229884855_Homosexual_Mating_Displays_in_Penguins https://www.researchgate.net/publication/229884855_Homosexua... > Some homosexually displaying males eventually paired with females, but such males were significantly slower in heterosexual pairing than males that did not display homosexually. In two extraordinary cases, same-sex pairs learned each other’s calls, an essential step in the pairing process. The frequency of such pairs was much lower than among displaying couples, significantly so for males. Finally, the frequency of homosexually displaying pairs was significantly lower than expected from random assortment of displaying birds, for both males and females. We examined possible explanations for same-sex display and its biological significance. A population sex-ratio bias in favor of males and high concentration of male sex hormones may help to explain non-reproductive homosexually displaying pairs.
- francisofascii 6y agoAn interesting finding is the fraternal birth order effect. The more older brothers you have, the more likely you are to be homosexual (for men). Seems to indicate in-utero mechanisms are involved. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_birth_order_and_male_sexual_orientation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_birth_order_and_male...
- drocer88 6y agoThe actual study: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/365/6456/eaat7693 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/365/6456/eaat7693 Result: "five autosomal loci were significantly associated with same-sex sexual behavior".
- Animats 6y agoIt's known that birth order matters. "The more older brothers a male has from the same mother, the greater the probability he will have a homosexual orientation."[1] Interestingly, this occurs only in right-handed males. See [2]: "Mothers of gay sons, particularly those with older brothers, had significantly higher anti-NLGN4Y levels than did the control samples of women, including mothers of heterosexual sons." There's something going on during pregnancy, and it's starting to be identifiable, but it's not understood yet. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_birth_order_and_male_sexual_orientation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraternal_birth_order_and_male... [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5777026/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5777026/
- fossuser 6y agoMy SO wrote a blog post that touched on the fraternal birth order effect which I thought was great (though I am biased): https://obscuredinosaurfacts.com/blog/post/2021/01/27/bayes.html https://obscuredinosaurfacts.com/blog/post/2021/01/27/bayes.... She expands on it and I think her writing breaks it down well (just make sure to check out the appendix correction too!)
- renewiltord 6y agoThat weird caveat about right handedness actually makes me think this is a spurious correlation.
- goodside 6y agoSexual orientation has a known association with handedness (same-sex-attracted people of either gender have higher odds of being left-handed/ambidextrous than do straight people) so it’s reasonable a priori for a correlation to exist in one sub-population and not the other. Splitting by handedness reduces variance for many sexuality questions — it’s not a sign of p-hacking.
- eightails 6y ago> Sexual orientation has a known association with handedness That sounds so strange I had to fact-check, and it appears you're right, there does seem to be a measurable association [0]. Perhaps even more interesting, that same article reports: '...the strongest handedness nding for both sexes was a marked tendency for participants who described themselves as ambidextrous also to describe themselves as bisexual'. How weird. [0] https://search.proquest.com/docview/205935496 https://search.proquest.com/docview/205935496
- meibo 6y agoMakes me wonder if there was a lot of thought given to ethics when planning this study. If we've learned anything, we should know that people will be terrible enough to want to "cure" homosexuality or detect it before birth, like trisomy 21, if it ever will become possible - and research like this will lead to that.
- throwanem 6y agoWhat they're describing is a very broad range of variations across multiple genetic loci with subtle effects that do not predict, only relatively vaguely correlate with, sexual behavior. They say as much, too, although at much greater length and complexity. I get the concern for potential risk around selective abortion, IVF, etc; I was around for the "gay gene" debate in the 90s. This isn't that. This disproves that. And what they're reporting could not be used in that way.
- meibo 6y agoThat's interesting, thanks - will read up on that. I'm gay but I sadly wasn't existing enough in the early 90s to have caught it live :)
- throwanem 6y agoMy experience has been that we are not generally very good at propagating our own history! On that note, if you haven't read Randy Shilts' And the Band Played On, I strongly recommend it. The events it describes are, I think, the single strongest influence on everything about US (at least) gay culture that's thus far followed.
- tofery 6y ago>terrible enough to want to "cure" homosexuality or detect it before birth Curious, why do you think that this is a terrible thing? I see that there are two parts to this. As for wanting to "cure" homosexuality, if a gay person consents, is this such a bad thing? I believe that forcing such a conversion on anyone (straight to gay or gay to straight) is not right, but if a person wants to change their sexuality, and we have the technical means to do it, should we not allow them to? And as for detecting homosexuality before birth (and presumably either "correcting" it or aborting the baby), I'm curious as to your views on "designer babies", as this seems similar to me. Would you compare changing the sexuality of one's child to changing that child's eye color, or do you think it's a different matter? And say a mother would only want her child to be heterosexual, and could do this before birth without any harm or changes otherwise to the offspring. What would you think about that scenario? Is the mother within her rights (morally, or otherwise), and what might you say to her? Interesting topic, curious as to your (or anyone else's, for that matter) thoughts.
- hypertele-Xii 6y agoFascinating! To me this sounds like the mother's body is trying to "nudge" the odds towards a daughter after several sons, but sometimes the process "fails" and produces an effeminate male instead - a gay son. Alternatively, some kind of meta-level mechanism to reduce competition over women in the community, ultimately improving its collective health and well-being.
- danbolt 6y agoGiven the number of comfortably-masculine gay men I've known, I have a feeling the womb isn't necessarily trying to ensure it eventually creates a Disney Princess. It feels a bit far-fetched, to be honest.
- golemiprague 6y agoI have never met a gay men who I could say is a masculine in the same way straight men are. There is always something a bit off even in the most straight passing gays. So my anecdote cancels yours and the theory stands.
- mc32 6y agoThat... seems unlikely. That implies a woman's reproductive system knows and remembers or at least keeps a tallies of the sex of the offspring it has produced...
- hansvm 6y agoOr that exposure to a fetus for prolonged periods of time has a measurable effect. You can reliably tell the sex of a fetus with a mother's blood test a couple months after conception. I still think it's a bit unlikely that there's a meaningful connection to be had there, but I wouldn't be totally shocked if I were proven wrong.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoWhy couldn't it? There's a lot of hormones (and other things) involved in pregnancy, right? Wouldn't some of these cause lasting effects?
- exabrial 6y agoI think this makes sense; it would seem natural selection should drop this as an _inherited_ trait. Regardless, everyone should be treated equally and with kindness. I don't think that's up for debate.
- 9967d2cad_askhn 6y agoJust wanted to chime in here and say that my younger brother is gay. Everyone in my family knew from when I was 8 years old and he was 6. We love him and we accept him.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoThere's no "gay gene"? Does that also mean there's no heterosexual gene either? If propagation is essential for the species, wouldn't it make sense that sexuality is hardwired?
- robin21 6y agoI wonder if anyway has attempted a more qualitative study on this. Asking exactly what attributes attract and what the person is thinking when they look at images of men and women. Do gay men think the same as women? Is it a spectrum? For straight men it seems mostly tied to women’s ability to carry children, coupled with a genderless beauty evaluation (e.g. symmetry) and then some measure of femininity (which is kind of like anti-masculine maybe). Femininity is really hard to quantify but it’s definitely a “know it when you see it” kind of thing.
- unhappyscien 6y agohmm sounds like it could be related to a parasitic influence then. Many behavior modifying parasites infect mammals,wouldn't be surprised on its affects on humans.
- tofery 6y agoWhy do you think it would be a parasite, as opposed to any other environmental factor? I don't know of any parasite that affects behavior in that way, but if you have some further information, I'd be interested in hearing it.
- xivzgrev 6y agoI found the conclusion to be misleading, based on this “ The researchers split their study participants into two groups — those who reported having had sex with someone of the same sex, and those who didn’t. ” So apparently you are gay if you have had sex one time with someone of same sex sometime, anytime in your life. Bisexual, bicurious, some one straight who experimented, etc would all then be “gay”, which are all more prevalent than being strictly gay. That’s like looking for genes that predict left handedness by selecting people who at some point in their lives have written with their left hand. No wonder they got confusing / weak signals. They should have limited to including only people who actually identified as being gay.
- musingsole 6y agoHarsh bucket boundaries are always the catch with studies like this. If you grew up in a smoky house or have had at least one cigarette in your life, you fall into a gray area of studies where you don't qualify as a smoker or a non-smoker.
- valarauko 6y agoMy understanding is that people who self identify as gay are a much smaller subset within the group of people who engage in homosexual activities. For example, in my Asian country a large segment of the guys you meet cruising are married men (to women) who identify as completely straight. Perhaps the wife is unwilling to engage in acts you enjoy, and sex with men is low effort high reward. I also knew many guys who preferred sex with men but couldn't fathom a romantic relationship with one, and identified as mostly straight. It's highly likely that most (though not all) of these men were truly gay/bi/pan, but unable to accept it due to social conditioning. I agree that a single encounter probably shouldn't count for the terms of the study.
- Sebb767 6y agoThis may be a stupid question, but I'll ask it anyway: How did gay people live in pre-historic times? Arguably, in our current culture, it is pretty obvious that gay people will produce less offspring than heterosexuals. However, looking on an evolutionary timescale, this culture is rather young. In tribal times, most males did not reproduce - lessening the impact of homosexuality. Maybe the higher female-to-male-gene reproduction rate is factor? This is just rough speculation, my knowledge is really limited. But it seems plausible at first glance.
- arp242 6y agoI think it's a mistake to see homosexuality as a binary on/off switch; in many cases it's a gradient. I'm generally heterosexual, but I've also had sex with a man. It's was okay, I guess, but I'd prefer women. On a scale of 0-100 my "gayness score" is probably about 10-20. A hard strong 0 or 100 is probably a lot less common than it's often portrayed: it's more of a bell curve. One explanation I've read is that gay men are more likely to be left alone with women as they're perceived to be less threatening; giving the gay man a chance to propagate his genes through infidelity (infidelity is fairly common throughout human history). The ever-eqloquent Richard Dawkins once called this "the sneaky fucker strategy". Something similar could also apply to women. It's hard to be sure of these kind of things, since it's, well, pre-history, but there are some models which can explain the propagation of homosexual genes and/or behaviour.
- neaanopri 6y agoYou can view homosexuality as an identity or as a behavior. Recently the identity option has been emphasized. Part of those is because it offers more legitimacy: if I can convince you that: 1. Gay people exist 2. I am gay Then, my homosexual behavior is more legitimate. Without the identity, Western legal codes were able to ban homosexual behavior.
- godmode2019 6y agoEveryone is looking for a environmental factors this could be one. Sexual Assault Risks among Gay and Bisexual Men - NCBI - NIH "One half of men (50.8%) reported childhood sexual assault" https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4117833 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4117833 Similar: https://i.stuff.co.nz/national/3949087/Abused-more-likely-to-be-gay https://i.stuff.co.nz/national/3949087/Abused-more-likely-to... Here is the speculation part: the more older brothers one has the older they will be from you and entering into sexual experimentation with younger brothers. A quick google shows that this is normal behaviour but the sings are normally similar ages. I tend to think its probably a mix between nature and nurture.
- mmmrtl 6y agoSeems more likely that the causality is in the opposite direction
- valarauko 6y agoI suppose it depends on causality - do otherwise "str8" men who experiment with other men "turn" gay, or do "queer" men self select themselves for such experimentation? Regarding your hypothesis, I'd suggest that perhaps queer kids are more likely to be targeted by older male relatives for sexual abuse.
- notmars 6y agoAnd here lies the problems of finding causation not correlation: - gay is not binary neither through time (people do evolve both way while getting old) neither through ‘space’ (some people are half/half, some people have some preference for love and others for sex, and so on) - genes are not expressed linearly, and one slight expression in the womb can mean something big, or nothing or maybe something? - social pressure about sexuality start early even though we may get better at avoiding some: blue for boys, pink for girls, boys do sports, blablabla and so on - internal development and expression of sexuality does not happen at the same pace and at the same amplitude for everybody (some people really are asexual their whole life) and of course the familly, sister/brotherhood, socio-economical environment influence it too So in these studies of sexuality and even worse, with the metastudies, I’m always left with the feeling that the hypothesis tested by it was broken from the start. What was the question they were trying to answer? « Is it biologically complicated? » Ok yes. « Do we have the tool to even make the distinction between a weak correlation due to the sample bias? » Can’t see how in this study. What am I missing?
- Zardoz84 6y ago> - internal development and expression of sexuality does not happen at the same pace and at the same amplitude for everybody (some people really are asexual their whole life) and of course the familly, sister/brotherhood, socio-economical environment influence it too Some people IS asexual. Asexuality it's a valid sexual orientation like being bi/pan/homo or heterosexual. It isn't lack of sexual development or sexual expression or result of family, socio-economical environment influences. Perhaps, you should inform about it better : https://www.asexuality.org/?q=overview.html https://www.asexuality.org/?q=overview.html
- corin_ 6y agoI might be misunderstanding a valid criticism, but your complaint is about the parent comment's using "are" rather than "is"? That's simply the plural version: if one person is asexual, multiple people are asexual.
- 6y ago
- hoseja 6y agoOh, I thought it would be about "sexual reproduction", not useless sexual attraction navel gazing.
- maxmcorp 6y agoThat is hardly correct. A genetic disposition to mate with the opposite sex would be a very strong force for reproduction. In other words: Genes that make you have sex with the opposite sex would be a huge advantage and so would be selected for. Even insect knows what to do instinctively. I would need VERY strong evidence to accept that it is not gentically encoded.