24 ms·
Startup Stock Options – Why A Good Deal Has Gone Bad (2019)
- runawaybottle 6y agoAre there any startups that offer revenue sharing so you don’t have to rely on the mythical exit?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nowherebeen 6y agoThe only startups that will offer this will probably be bootstrap companies. Otherwise, VC backed companies will always push for stock options because it’s a better deal for them. I hope more startups starts offering revenue sharing.
- jraby3 6y agoRev share is a tricky incentive. It can incentivize people to waste money chasing revenue. Revenue isn’t always in line with the success of the business. As a business owner and VC I’d be extremely reluctant to offer that to employees.
- londons_explore 6y agoMost sales jobs offer some kind of revenue share. Sometimes revenue share is the only compensation. When cosco buys apples from a farmer for $1 and resells them for $2, they are effectively taking a 50% revenue share. A referral bonus for bringing in a new customer is also a kind of revenue share for the existing customer, and plenty of startups do those. I think the key is to compensate based on a revenue share of what you bring in, rather than of the total revenue.
- jraby3 6y agoThat’s true for sales jobs. I was under the impression he was asking about it for all key employees.
- foolmeonce 6y agoI've only heard of this with consulting. Multiple times I have heard traditional shops offer a 1-5?% of e-commerce revenue depending on the portion of work, but it is often since they are skeptical of their own success.
- geoffharcourt 6y agoPre-IPO the venture is likely not profitable, so you'd be getting a share of zero. Companies that are VC-backed are going to be held to an expectation of a big payoff, and will be in general discouraged from offering incentives that uncouple employee incentives from an exit. If I understand this right, it's part of why founders have started to be allowed to sell some of their vested shares at funding events, it gives them some more financial runway as the company's timeline stretches out (you don't want the optics of the CEO of your $50m series C to be eating peanut butter and ramen, etc.) I do think profit sharing would be a good lever for a bootstrapped company that is already profitable and wants to give key employees skin in the game.
- beagle3 6y agoNote GP asked about revenue sharing, whereas you discuss profit sharing. That's not the same thing. Salespeople and sales partners are often compensated with a sales based commission, which is a revenue sharing scheme. It's common and expected, and practiced everywhere there's deal flow. Technical people can rarely prove "ownership" of revenue, so they can't leverage that in negotiation and are left with "general" ownership through options or RSUs or whatever. There's nothing inherent or natural (or unnatural) about it. If money flows through you, you can usually demand to keep some of it. If it doesn't, you usually can't.
- eternalban 6y ago> Technical people can rarely prove "ownership" of revenue Maybe we geeks should let the sales teams run Powerpoint presentations instead of the actual product to address that misunderstanding.
- indymike 6y agoThis is such a silly thing to argue about. Sales are very dependent on product quality, availability and dare I say delivering features customers need when they need them.
- 6y ago
- saadalem 6y agoMore startup folks should read about Tomas Bata [0], he built about 2000 of houses for his workers. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom%C3%A1%C5%A1_Ba%C5%A5a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom%C3%A1%C5%A1_Ba%C5%A5a
- TruthHurts44 6y agoZapier.
- indymike 6y agoIt might say revenue share on the title of the contract, but the body of the contract will be about a share of net or gross profit.
- jhowell 6y ago> One possibility is to replace early employee (first ~10 employees) stock options with the same Restricted Stock Agreements (RSAs) as the founders. I am sure RSA are and will always be available to those with the skilleset that commands this level of compensation. I am unclear what would motivate the founding team or investors in a start-up to act otherwise.
- brabel 6y agoWhy would anyone want to work for your startup when they can get much higher salaries working for larger companies? Stock options used to be that differentiator for startups... now it's just an empty promise in most places.
- guywhocodes 6y agoPersonally for me it has always been faster personal growth from wider responsibilities. This makes a lot of sense in some stages of your career and your career goals but hardly for everyone.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoI’ve never heard of any startups where you can obtain faster skill or personal growth. “Wear many hats” means you must be whatever type of firefighting janitor the company needs this week, which often causes skill atrophy not skill growth. Larger companies not only offer better compensation, but usually offer much better career development, responsibility growth, training and “learn by doing” opportunities. The startup will promise you won’t be blocked by bureaucracy and as an early hire you can lead the design. Total lies. The bureaucracy and dysfunction will be even worse and probably involve a bunch of immature egos and “the design” will be endlessly compromised to get each successive round of diluting funding that yokes you to more and more traditional management bureaucracy through VCs. After experiencing the special hell of unrestrained founders who don’t know what they are doing and nepotism hires all through middle management, most people quickly realize it’s an insane trap and wish for the comfort of large firm bureaucracy, where at least there’s some minimal policy protection against sexual harassment or cultivating alcoholism as a company value or generally grinding unwitting young people into the ground with 80 hour weeks.
- polote 6y agoIn what world do we want employee to have stock options ? I mean, for me this is where the problem is, there is no reason to promise a lot of equity to an employee. Pay them well. Now any (private growing) company is well funded, you can afford market salaries.
- konschubert 6y agoStock options may motivate some people to think more about the interests of the company rather than their own.
- the-dude 6y agoStock options may motivate some people to inflate the stock price.
- andi999 6y agoI am nitpicking here, I know... They still think about their own interest, but the value of the company is now part of their own interest.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoThe question was more why employees should agree to it.
- Fordec 6y agoVery few startups are FAANG level funded. Why work for a startup and commit your soul to the effort for half what the big boys are paying? And far, far less risk of the company going bust in the next two years.
- polote 6y agoThis is the most common error people on HN make. This is not startup VS FAANG. A small percentage of people make FAANG salary. A startup is mostly paying as much as any other company
- ransom1538 6y agoWhat makes options a rough deal is the part of the contract: "We can change anything at anytime for any reason". What kills your options is dilution. You have no control over this AND as time progresses you get more and more diluted with new hires and rounds. You could be the second employee - however, if the founders & VC decide to make 20 million more shares [which they will] - you effectively have toilet paper -- AND you wont be in that meeting.
- umanwizard 6y agoIf the founders have the same class of shares as you, will this effect them equally?
- itake 6y agoNot if they just issue themselves more shares
- cj 6y ago> Not if they just issue themselves more shares This doesn't happen in the real world. When more shares are issued, it's because you've raised another capital round and the new shares go directly to the new shareholders (new VCs) and future employees who haven't yet been hired. New shares wouldn't go to the founders. Yes, it's hypothetically possible, but it doesn't happen in the real world.
- konschubert 6y agoIt happens regularly and it's called a re-up http://christophjanz.blogspot.com/2018/11/founders-please-dont-allow-anyone-to.html http://christophjanz.blogspot.com/2018/11/founders-please-do...
- cj 6y agoThe article is from 2018, and reads: > In the last year, we have seen, on more than one occasion, a behavior among later-stage VCs that we’ve rarely observed in the years before Which seems to imply it's not a common practice. As I mentioned, it's 100% theoretically possible to do it, but the percent of companies that actually do it is very low. It would be not only bad for early employees, but also bad for early investors - it would hurt the founders reputation among their early investors (and employees) which most founders wouldn't be willing to do.
- logicslave 6y agoStartups are a financial vehicle created to transfer the value created by the employee to the founders and capitalists. Often the founders have done very little of value before hiring a team to actually build the company. These people toil away, a decade later, the founder makes 20-100 million, the first employee, a few hundred thousand. There are exceptions, but this is largely what it is.
- pjbk 6y agoUnfortunately that is mainly the case these days. In theory it would make more financial sense that most companies at the startup stage would be fully employee-owned, considering the equity and tax scenarios. But what founders are open to that? It amazes me that still there are/were people, myself included, willing to partake in a rigged endeavor plagued with pitfalls and restrictions, compared to other business models out there.
- roflc0ptic 6y agoI just started working somewhere that does a different equity scheme called “profit interest.” The gist is, they issue you equity whose worth is based on growth in valuation from when you joined. So if you’re granted 1% shares and the company grows from 100m to 200m on liquidity, you’re entitled to 1m. It avoids you having to front money for stock options, and it also avoids the tax burden b/c when issued, the shares are worth zero dollars
- thomasahle 6y ago> So if you’re granted 1% shares and the company grows from 100m to 200m on liquidity, you’re entitled to 1m. It avoids you having to front money for stock options, and it also avoids the tax burden b/c when issued, the shares are worth zero dollars Isn't that just like normal stock options?
- konschubert 6y agoIt appears to simulate the normal stock options. Seems to be motivated by tax reasons. I think I've seen this called a "virtual option plan".
- londons_explore 6y agoIt might behave differently to dilution too...
- rutthenut 6y agoThe 1% options would be one percent of shareholdings at the time the option was offered. With more shares created/sold later, the dilution means when the options mature, they will be less than 1% of the total company shareholding, or value.
- ericbarrett 6y agoIt is pretty remarkable if it prevents dilution. Are you sure there's no weasel-wording in your contract that allows arbitrary changes in the future, has funky exercise restrictions, etc.? Their special tax structure makes me suspicious as well (if this is the US). Sadly I think VCs saw all the mini-millionaires being created at FAANGs in the last decade and have pressured many companies into watering down stock compensation, since it's "lost money."
- phendrenad2 6y agoHas anyone here made significant (2x exercise price) amounts from stock options at a non-unicorn in the last 5 years?
- xmodem 6y agoDepends on your definition of unicorn. I did quite well out of options at a previous gig. They IPO'ed shortly before I left and are now trading at >50x the exercise price.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoSignificant is $, not %. 10% of $1M beats 100% of $10k. Why would you expect options to pay big for a non-unicorn? Unicorn means the startup investment succeeded in its goal. No one gets rich when their investment fails.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThe percentage is actually more relevant to what we're discussing here, because it represents the gain from the employee's known starting point when they were hired. If they were only offered a measly number of options on being hired, well they can just decide to bail - it's the percentage gain that is the unknown and variable part of the equation. > Why would you expect options to pay big for a non-unicorn? I think the idea is that there should be a good swath of successful startups between "failed" and "unicorn". Indeed, the whole name unicorn came about because they used to be incredibly rare. So the parent is really asking "If you were in a moderately successful startup, did you get anything out of your equity?"
- xmaaayyy 6y agoUnicorns are startups with private valuations over $1bn, but I don’t know anyone that wouldn’t be happy with 1% of a $100M non-unicorn exit
- est31 6y agoUnicorn means the startup is as rare as a unicorn. Taking that as your benchmark for success is extremely unhealthy.
- rwmj 6y agoI think there are also tax implications of leaving a start-up with vested stock that you may not be able to sell on the market for another 8 years?
- srtjstjsj 6y agoOnly in the sense that you can't harvest losses by selling.
- rwmj 6y agoDon't you have to pay tax on the notional value of the shares, which leaves you in a difficult position because you cannot realise those gains.
- gizmodo59 6y agoYou don't have to unless you sell I think. Similar to real stocks you don't pay tax on stocks. You pay tax when you sell them.
- nfriedly 6y agoI think it depends on if you trigger the Alternative Minimum Tax. The default is that you don't pay taxes on ISOs at execution time, but if you trigger AMT then suddenly you do pay taxes, it can be a lot of taxes, and you may have no way to sell the stock to get the cash to pay the taxes. (Obvious you should talk to a tax professional rather than taking advice from a random stranger on the internet before taking any action.)
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoActual stock, no. Options, which are probably more common than actual stock with start-ups, you have to pay tax on the "profit" when exercising them. Often, you only have a short time to exercise options when you leave a company.
- mulcahey 6y ago
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoThe elephant in the room are transfer restrictions. VCs demand their preferred stock trade in the secondary market. At the same time, common stock is locked down. If the common stock is sellable before the company exits, the risk-reward calculus for company equity shifts in employees’ favor.
- cs-szazz 6y agoHow does something like this mesh with selling common stock but the company having right of first refusal? Say I want to sell common stock that I own, to someone who meets the SEC accredited investor definition. It seems that right of first refusal means that the company could buy the stock instead, but it would have to be at the price that I set with the external investor. In that case, don't I as an employee get liquidity either way, since it's being bought at the agreed upon price?
- alex_h 6y agoI learned the hard way that options agreements tend to have additional clauses allowing the company to unilaterally restrict sales. The contract might look like it has a straightforward process for employees to sell, with a company first right of refusal (with the company purchasing the stock instead). But there is usually additional fine print that basically gives the board veto power over any transfer of stock.
- cs-szazz 6y agoInteresting, are you able to share more? Or if you know where I might be able to read more about this?
- alex_h 6y agoI'm definitely not an expert on options contracts, but the examples of clauses I've seen are: (In the options exercise agreement): "All certificates evidencing shares purchased under this agreement shall bear the following legend: "The shares represented hereby may not be sold, assigned, ..., except in compliance with the terms of a written agreement between the company and the registered holder..."" (On the share certificate): "This certificate and the shares represented hereby are issued and shall be held subject to all ... bylaws of the corporation, to all of which each holder ... agrees to be bound" Either of which seems to give the company the ability to unilaterally reject any transfer/sale of shares.
- ghufran_syed 6y agoYC has historically had a big influence on improving financing terms for founders and reducing founder-hostile behavior by investors, by creating competition among investors for YC companies. Should YC maybe consider developing and enforcing a code of conduct addressing these issues, that might similarly improve the situation for start-up employees? They could maintain a public list of YC companies that abide by the code of conduct in order to encourage good behavior, and to help communicate to potential employees that they would get a “fair” option deal (as early investors, they would clearly have access to the terms of any financing deal). [EDIT: they could also maybe publish a list of investors who have committed to following the guidelines, and consider excluding VC firms from YC events if they won’t commit to those standards] Depending on how serious YC was about making a difference here, going against the code of conduct might even be grounds for exclusion from the YC community? My understanding is that YC has always focused on what’s best for the founders, even when they were the outsiders in silicon valley and at their own financial expense. Maybe now that YC is such an important player in the silicon valley ecosystem, they could use that power to maintain the health of that ecosystem in a way that few others could?
- chubot 6y agoBlog post from 2014: https://blog.samaltman.com/employee-equity https://blog.samaltman.com/employee-equity That's more of an admonishment, but at least they recognized the problem ...
- snowmaker 6y ago(I work at YC) Yes, we care a lot about making employee equity more generous and more fair. Part of our YC curriculum now is teaching founders about these issues and encouraging them to follow best practices around being generous and transparent with employees about equity compensation like Sam discussed in his blog post. I think there is still a lot more we can do, though.
- freewilly1040 6y agoTeaching founders is one thing, but equally as important is providing a platform that prospective employees can use to find out which startups are giving employees a fair deal. Speaking as a bigco eng who would love to join a startup, but is disillusioned by the economics of it.
- draw_down 6y agoI would like for my company to go public. Leadership has shared a timeline with us (as in “it will happen in the next x years”). Do I like having illiquid equity? No, but the company has opportunities to access some liquidity. More importantly, working for about five years will have provided me more than many people earn in a career. I want many of the things described here to change like anyone else does, but it would be nuts to call it a bad deal. I have a feeling people use this kind of junky thinking (“stock options are lottery tickets to be valued at $0”) to justify starting their own thing instead of being employed. But you should do whatever you’re going to do without needing to lie to yourself about how equity compensation actually works out for engineers.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoInvestors get convertible stock etc. If its a unicorn, maybe an employee has a chance. Anything less, the investor turns their $1M investment into a $10M debt or whatever, and soaks up the entire buyout.
- rongenre 6y agoThe other point here is that it's taking ~10 years to go from a company being started to going public. So most employees are going to have to make the decision to either cough up thousands to exercise their illiquid options and pay taxes on them or just have them expire worthless. At this point, joining as a seed-round or series A employee seems like a sucker's bet if you're expecting equity to be worth anything.
- kevinmchugh 6y agoOnly if you think the exit must be an IPO. Acquisitions and mergers can happen a lot earlier than that. Though those don't always pay out, of course
- tkay2617 6y agoI think the catch with acquisitions is that founders and investors have liquidation preferences.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIPOs are rare. Most exits come in the form of private acquisitions. You don’t hear about the latter group in the news because they’re usually much smaller companies. Many IPO-track companies are growing fast and attracting serious investment, so they pay engineers top dollar. They want to maximize chances of getting to IPO so they don’t benefit from cutting corners on a few engineers. If you have The opportunity to join an actual IPO-track company then go for it. The catch is that many startups will claim to be headed for IPO, so you have to look at actual growth and TAM and make your own judgments.
- rmk 6y agoThere are plenty of situations where there are down rounds or rounds where earlier investors are completely wiped out or diluted out of existence. In these cases, the early employees get screwed big-time. Even in the optimistic case of an exit, whether it be an acquisition or IPO, the risk incurred by the employees is way too high because of the lengthening of time towards the exit event. The lucky ones can get non-recourse loans and cash out with something to show for their efforts, but the overwhelming majority can't, and end up having to shell out real money for what are essentially rolls of the dice or losing that equity altogether. It's interesting that if a person has vested stock with nominal value of $100 and exercise price of $5, he can't use that stock in lieu of the $5! i.e., he can't walk away with $95 worth of his grant. I wonder if there are IRS regulations that bar this type of arrangement.
- formalsystem 6y agoIs there any reason why stock options can't be non dilutable? If new investors want to come in, they need to buy existing shares, the number of shares can be infinitely divisible to make it easy to always accommodate new investors.
- caust1c 6y agoThere is no legal reason why we can't have non-dilutable options. The only reason why it's such common practice is probably vanity (investors want to know they're getting X% when they invest) and the complexity of planning your fundraising schedule at the day of founding. Probably mostly the latter.
- jariel 6y agoIf you sell more shares, there is dilution - there is no way around it, it's math. Each stock is a slice, more stocks, then each slice is smaller. Now - if the company is growing you get 'diluted' but those stocks are worth more. But in the examples above where employees are getting 'less/not diluted' it must be at the expense of someone else: founders or older investors who won't like that. Given that founders, old investors and staff all generally get diluted at the same rate, dilution is actually one of the more fair things that happens in companies at least superficially.
- Groxx 6y agoLets say your company is valued at $100 and all stock is claimed for current employees. Now you want to raise money by selling 50% of your company to investors. So you create $100 more and now they own 50% (at $200 valuation). This means the investors either over-paid (2x what they were worth!), or you were strongly under-valuing the stocks that existed before. If you dilute, they get 50% at $50, and the existing stocks are now worth 50% their value. Because you literally sold half the company. --- The first is pretty obviously ridiculous. Nobody would pay 2x the worth, that's the point of deciding on a value. If they paid 2x, it just means you didn't agree on the value. But if they don't over-pay, it's the same as the second: prior to the sale, your company's value was actually $200 (you were just claiming otherwise), and after the sale your employees only have $100, i.e. half the company's value. Their stocks were still diluted.
- kuharich 6y agoPast comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19624164 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19624164
- andygcook 6y ago> “For later employees make sure the company offers “refresh” option grants to longer-tenured employees. Better yet, offer restricted stock units (RSUs). Restricted Stock Units are a company’s promise to give you shares of the company’s stock. Unlike a stock option, which always has a strike (purchase) price higher than $0, an RSU is an option with a $0 purchase price. The lower the strike price, the less you have to pay to own a share of company stock. Like stock options, RSU’s vest.” Aren’t RSUs taxed at the time of grant? Therefore in a refresh grant, the employee would get hit with a large tax bill on the fair market price of the equity, even with an 83(b) election. Most people probably don’t have that kind of money to lay down up front on something that could still go bust. At least with options, you can always (unless you get fired) stay long enough to see the come through to IPO where options are then a sure thing. Am I missing something here on the quote above?
- jeremyis 6y agoI think it’s time of liquidity for double triggered RSUs. That’s what big pre IPO companies give and at IPO all the accrued RSUs are taxed as income.
- draw_down 6y agoDon’t think so because they don’t have value at time of grant. They have a double trigger structure that doesn’t grant the employee a share until liquidity event. From a legal perspective there is a “significant risk” of them expiring worthless (typical window is 7 years I believe). This makes it not a simple windfall for the employee.
- commandlinefan 6y ago> Aren’t RSUs taxed at the time of grant? Not the times I've had them - they were always taxed at time of vesting. There's always an option (or at least I was always offered an option) to sell back some of the stock at the time to cover the tax, even if you weren't exercising the remainder right away. That way there was no out-of-pocket cost to you at the time of vesting (but you did have the option to keep all the RSU's and pay the tax due if you wanted to).
- danans 6y ago
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThe recent HN article on meritocracy comes to mind. I had never considered it this way in the past, but in the 70’s, productivity started decoupling massively from productivity gains. I.e. the best people at finance (meritocracy) figured out how to capture all the new earnings relative to the workers (who didn’t know this game was going on). This has snowballed into a situation where the financial meritocracy is competing with itself and could now never imagine a situation where non-finance people are being paid more in proportion with their value relative to baseline productivity gains. This article would fit that narrative as a symptom of one-upmanship gone amuck. How do we exit this brutal cycle? It requires a generation of new blood that is actually concerned about societal stability and recognizes the connection between instability and leaving 99% of folks behind as games are fought in ‘the ivory cloud’. Will this be dealt with sans revolution? Who knows...
- dehrmann 6y ago> productivity started decoupling massively from productivity gains. Productivity is a ceiling for wages. "Decoupling" implies that, for various reasons, there's been a surplus in the labor market since the 70's.
- medium_burrito 6y agoWhich there has been, basically. We effectively double the workforce with women entering the labor supply. H1B ramped up in the 90s, but that's not the same magnitude of change.
- dehrmann 6y agoAlso include automation and China industrializing, enabling outsourcing.
- runawaybottle 6y agoThe only chance of changing it was that our new emerging industries were supposed to be more equitable. Unfortunately not much of that happened, and the tech boss is the same as the finance boss, meet the new boss, same as the old one. I’m sorry gig workers, contractors, Amazon warehouse workers, startup workers, but there’s not much to see here. We’ll try to be better later if we get lucky enough to get a whole new industry again.
- webwielder2 6y agoSeems like the changes discussed here are largely unimportant since most companies fail before they go public.
- tonystubblebine 6y agoSort of a devil's advocate question, but does the value of the options deal depend a lot on a person's ability to choose and join good startups? One example I'm thinking of is Josh Elman who seemingly got into the VC game just on having worked at three companies that went on to IPO (LinkedIn, Twitter, FB) and so that was a track record that could stand in place of an investment record. It doesn't seem that impressive to me to have known that those three companies were going to do well, even pre-IPO. But is that repeatable? Basically, if you are getting into top tier startups then a lot of your lottery tickets hit at least a little bit. Sure, nothing beats a FAANG salary for average financial gain. But even little hits do a lot to even out the lower paying years. I've been getting equity since 2005 and my experience is that there are a lot of winners around me. Is that just luck (to some extent, I'm sure). But could a person gauge a bit whether they are in the in-crowd of companies that seem likely to do well? Options for the first 50-100 employees do make a meaningful difference in someone's life, so you can join a company pretty late and have a pretty good sense of their traction. I had or have equity in Odeo which would have led to Twitter stock if I'd stayed longer, Calm, Medium, Beyond Meat. I turned away Pinterest's corp dev when they were hunting to acquire a mobile team (not sure how serious, but I think we would have been a good team for them). So, that's a lot of winners that either actually hit, seem like they might hit, or that I was very close to. I had equity in Wesabe which I think would have been Intuit's acquisition target if Mint (an abnormally excellently executed startup) hadn't gotten their first. That would have been $500k to me. Also had equity in Branch, acquired by FB and Neighborland. Those are the "losers." I keep a loose accounting of how my friends did too, which is also a big part of why it feels like I've been working inside of an in-crowd. I started and then shut down a two person company. That other person went to Yammer (employee 70-ish) and made a big chunk of money. Wesable's CEO ended up VPE at Etsy and Stripe pre-IPO. That Stripe equity has got to be massive. A lot of the Wesabe team has done a stint at Stripe. The VP of Product at Odeo was the VP of something as Fitbit IPOd. The Branch founders got the FB acquisition and also had some Beyond stock. The people who've left my current company have all landed in good places including Squad which just got acquired by Twitter. A lot of my former team is at Medium (which I'm close enough to to feel pretty confident is a winner). Our employee #1 went on to be employee #57 at Pinterest. Again, I'm not comparing this to FAANG. But I never wanted to work for those companies. Instead, I wanted to work for startups because that's what interested me. But I also want to be able to retire and own my home and so for me, Options, are a big part of the mix that made that possible.
- fortran77 6y agoExactly. If you're not a founder or investor, expect your options in a non-public company to be worth zero. There are a dozen ways they can dilute them to worthlessness. You'll have a much better chance of making money on stock and stock options if you join an already-public company that has an ESPP and regularly grants stock options for their publicly-traded stock as incentives to the employees.
- throwaway4748 6y agoI became a millionaire with options from a startup IPO and hardly feel that I won the lottery. There’s thousands of employees at dozens of private companies that either went public this year or will next that will be in the same position. Certainly it helps that there’s a deluge of liquidity in the financial markets right now that has completely changed the calculus from even just a year ago. I would certainly be much more optimistic now than any other recent point in time if you work at a company with good growth prospects.
- barnacled 6y agowhat was the company valued at and what % did you own after dilution? Roughly speaking of course. I cashed out $500k pre-tax as employee #1 at ~1.3% post-dilution but pre-IPO with the startup valued at $35M so had the company been valued at a sub-unicorny $350M or so it would have made me a millionaire. Just wondering how the % numbers compare.
- throwaway4748 6y agoSmaller percentage of a much larger company. It’s a speculative market right now which helps. Most of these startups you’re seeing in the news are going public at $5B-$10B plus valuations. The big ones for $50B+
- barnacled 6y agoyeah there surely must be a fairly large floor before an IPO makes any sense. I'm pretty convinced the one I cashed out of is going to get diluted a bit more than acqui-hired by one of the big investors (who is in the same field as the startup) as the growth just doesn't look to have happened there. I think given the overall situation I came out of it well, but it does go to show that even when you do hit the startup share lottery as we both have the actual cash outcome can vary by a significant factor, though we are both lucky to have made cash given the 99.9% of startups whose shares end up worthless.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoAnother big difference in modern startups that wasn't mentioned in the article: It now takes more employees than ever before to get a startup company off the ground. It's basic math: You can give more equity to early employees when you have fewer of them. We have more services, frameworks, and technologies available to quickly build companies than ever before. Ironically, it somehow takes more engineers than ever to ship most products. The surface area and expectations for a modern product have grown substantially. Gone are the days when a couple of people would throw together a quick and ugly Rails application and then start trying to sell it to customers. I wish we'd see more startups bucking the trend of doing complicated React websites with complex backends that look like someone was trying to use as many AWS product offerings as possible. Unfortunately, it's increasingly difficult to convince engineers to focus on the easy, simple problems. Everyone wants things to be as complex as possible so they can pad their resumes for the next job, whether or not the product calls for it. Another factor is that interest rates are incredibly low right now. The cost of capital is so low that startup founders will often take excessive amounts of investment to grow faster and pad their runways. When it comes time for acquisition talks, the founders negotiate million-dollar "retention bonuses" with the acquiring company if their shares are worthless due excessive dilution and liquidation preferences. Works out well for founders, while employees get nothing.
- georgeecollins 6y ago>> It now takes more employees than ever before to get a startup company off the ground. But that is not true. If you look at the startups of the late 90's-- the time when people learned that stock options could be very valuable-- it took a lot of engineers and infrastructure to make a tech start up. As you point out more services and frameworks exist now. The reason why it takes more employees is the reason cited in the paper, companies stay private longer to make more money for growth investors. I agree completely with your point about the impact on employees. It's just that its not because the product requires it, it is because investors want the private growth.
- taude 6y agoAll my engineering teams are vastly smaller these days than earlier in my career. By a long shot. And we get way more done with fewer resources due to the fact that there's cloud computing, modern DevOps practices, etc. And then you take into account how many companies are using offshore resources (which typically are just expenses without options) at even lower prices. However, I'm curious if the other side of the business has grown with all the growth hacking marketing, sales floors that now seem like boiler rooms, etc...
- barnacled 6y agojust to a add a raw account of my experience for what it's worth: I joined a startup as employee #1 and though I opted to have slightly more salary than shares I ended up with 3.2% of the shares. I was with the startup long enough to fully vest and left with actual shares rather than share options (a product of me joining when the startup was just founded and had no share option scheme). After I left at I believe the 3rd or 4th VC funding round an offer was made to buy my shares by a VC who wanted more ordinary stock to convert into a new series B non-dilution higher priority share class. All of the VC shares were of course non-dilutable. I accepted the offer (I didn't have faith the company would IPO and felt the most likely exit - an acquihire - would come when I was far more diluted at far lower value) and after a very poorly communicated and drawn out process ("we'll pay you next week" for 4 months) I finally received payment valuing the company at around $35M at a diluted share holding of 1.3% netting roughly $500k gross. Throughout I was assured that I would only have to pay a capital gains tax (I'm in the UK) and additionally received faulty independent advice that confirmed that this was the case, however 1 day before payment I was told that I'd have to pay roughly half at income tax and the other half via capital gains (the latter tops out at 20% in the UK so this was a huge difference and cost me $55k+). This was done by the startup withholding the income tax and paying it directly on my behalf via the UK's Pay As You Earn (PAYE) scheme while leaving me to pay the capital gains later. In the end I had to pay roughly 1/3 of the payout in tax netting me ~$350k. I was paid out 7 years after I joined the company. Overall I feel the dilution _was_ offset by the increase in value of the company, and the % I received was fair as to my contributions, but the tax arrangements were handled very poorly indeed and gave no room for a more efficient arrangement. Given that I felt the shares were no more than lottery ticket toilet paper + suspected I'd get cheated in some way even if there was a payout the outcome was really really good and unexpected, and have in fact changed my life (I can now buy a house after years of misspending!) But I definitely don't think the economics work out too well. I was paid probably half of the proper wage throughout and put up with a lot before vesting, having stayed there for 5 yrs that works out to $100k extra a year on top of the smaller salary (started at $50k roughly) - a FAANG or such would probably have paid the same by the end. However at the time I joined I worked in a very unmarketable (and soul destroying) role and the position helped me change my career direction, gave me a lot of good experience and ended up paying out anyway. I'd not work at a startup again (not only for salary vs. equity concerns) but I don't regret having worked at one. Something of a stream of consciousness but perhaps it provides some kind of raw data to add to the pile!
- yalogin 6y agoIn a way this feels like the VCs realized that colluding with the founders and incentivizing them with RSAs will make them agree to staying private longer. That way the collective pile grows. However someone has to lose and its the employees.
- sanity31415 6y agoI'm facing a headache with some options I was granted for a startup back in 2013 for being an advisor. I didn't exercise the options at the time (hindsight is 20-20). The startup is doing well - it recently raised ~$300m at a ~$3b valuation, but my options expire in Dec 2023 and I'm growing increasingly concerned that they won't have a liquidity event before then. If I exercise my options before then it will be taxed as income which could leave me owing >$100k in taxes to the IRS - but if the company hasn't yet had a liquidity event then I can't sell the options to pay that. Seems like a ridiculous situation for early employees/advisors to be placed in.
- boatsie 6y agoThis is a common enough situation that there are companies that will loan you the money to help pay for options and deal with tax liability, using the shares as collateral. I haven’t used one myself and am not a lawyer or financial advisor. One for instance: https://www.esofund.com/blog/exercise-loan https://www.esofund.com/blog/exercise-loan
- solumos 6y agoYou should check out SecFi - they helped me out of a similar snag (non-recourse loan).
- sanity31415 6y agoThanks, I'll check them out.
- psanford 6y agoOne strategy is to exercise as many options as you can until you would hit AMT (or an amount above AMT you are ok paying). You can do this each year until your expiration date comes up.
- s17n 6y agoNot sure this would apply here - I don't think that advisors get ISOs (but I could be wrong).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rexreed 6y agoStock options are a poor proxy for company value. Instead, a company should allocate an interest in any in-the-money exit towards a pool that is distributed to employees on a rata share depending on duration of employment and period of employment. I've been working on an interesting formula for this that even rewards those who have left the company. Most employees don't need or want a share of the company. They want a share of the profits or proceeds from an exit. For example, a company can allocate 20% of all in-the-money proceeds from an exit to the Employee Exit Share pool. An employee's share of that Exit pool will be based on their employee-months worked divided by the total employee-months worked in the company, with every one year of employee months worked counting an additional time for the purposes of calculation. This thus rewards early employees and those who have worked for longer durations with a larger share.
- adrr 6y agoOwnership comes with legal protections from being screwed over during a liquidity event. End of the day, I want to be holding the same type of shares of the founders because I know that our interest are aligned.
- rexreed 6y agoAnd what specific legal protections would you be caring out most that would not be addressable with a shared exit pool? Common stock options are highly limited in their legal recourse and common share owners are often (legally) shafted through dilution, restrictions on share sales, and inability to access direct control. Anything that is worth caring about from a legal perspective can be addressed through means of a guaranteed profit and exit share versus the less tangible and more easily screwed around with common shares, in which employee and founder interests are in many ways not aligned.
- annoyingnoob 6y agoIts funny, I've been sitting on some shares for about 7 years since an acquisition, the company is buying them back this month. I had written the company and the shares off and somehow in 2020 they pulled the nose up. Really looking forward to the final payout! I feel really fortunate to have had what Steve calls a 20th century deal in the 21st century. I was able to maintain an undiluted share of the company, which interestingly I was never able to do in the 20th century.
- fullshark 6y agoAs a restless employee in a big tech conglomerate, interested in possibly going to a startup, this blog perfectly outlines why it would be totally insane for me to even consider it, and why frankly I have not. The big tech monsters have all the talent and unless the nature of the game changes it will be that way for the foreseeable future and tons of great ideas will die on the vine.
- silentsea90 6y agoSlightly related, Stripe now gives fixed $ amount of RSUs per year to new hires, which limits both upside and downside significantly. Not to act cynical, but to me it seems that this is another way of screwing employees by denying them stock appreciation on their initial grant. I understand that new hires would be signing off on this while joining so the rug isn't pulled beneath their feet, but this does seem like a start of a bad trend which if it catches on, will further the gap between employees and founders
- joshuamorton 6y ago> Slightly related, Stripe now gives fixed # RSUs to new hires, which limits both upside and downside significantly. Pretty much all companies start doing this once they get large-ish (snap, airbnb, lyft, uber, etc. all did essentially the same thing). At the valuation stripe has, I'm not seeing the downside, given that the upside of options is limited once you're the size of stripe today. > but to me it seems that this is another way of screwing employees by denying them stock appreciation on their initial grant How? If I'm granted 100 RSUs, and the company value doubles, my RSU value doubles. Fixed # of RSU is the better way (imo) in comparison to fixed dollar amount grants.
- silentsea90 6y agoI reworded my comment - but I meant that you're guaranteed (say) $100k worth of stock every year, so the #RSUs will be calculated at the start of each year. If the valuation of Stripe is 70 Billion today and one gets granted 100k worth of stock this year (say 100 units), if valuation is 140 Billion next year, employees get 50 units next year (ignoring dilution etc), instead of 100 units each year. I meant that it is fixed dollar amount not fixed RSU count per year at Stripe, if that helps clear it
- joshuamorton 6y agoAh, yes, that is the blehh approach.
- mateus1 6y agoI was part of a leadership team at a startup for 4.5 years (went from 10 to 200 employees, series A and B). During that time I accumulated a significant number of stock options which could potentially make me a millionaire. I left the company because my salary was incredibly low relative other companies in the same area. I have left and I have no possibility of exercising the options. I technically could but that would mean ~50% of my net worth in a single risky investiment. So yeah, I now price stock options at zero.
- dehrmann 6y agoIf they haven't expired, you should look into the companies that will loan you money to exercise. ESO Fund is one, Employee Capital Partners is another, and I'm sure there are others. There's also the option of trying to sell shares on a platform like EquityZen.
- mateus1 6y agoI'd love that. I don't think there are any players in that market in Brazil.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- LiamMcCalloway 6y agoHow about adding a 'most favored nation' clause in all options contracts?
- barnacled 6y agoI was lucky enough to cash out of a startup after 7 years and 3 or 4 rounds of funding (I had left by the time I got the payout) as a share buyback for one of the VC investors. I was diluted from 3.2% to about 1.3% but the value of the company had clearly risen so _at that point_ it was unimportant. However in my opinion the company's burn rate and lack of growth clearly meant a later exit (likely an acqui-hire IMO) would have seen dilution without an equivalent growth in value, not to mention the ever-increasing VC non-dilution shares accelerating that. I got majorly screwed on tax because the startup made no efforts to be efficient and were very chaotic in their arrangements for payout so that is definitely another important factor. Overall by winning the startup share lottery I made roughly $500k for 5 or so years working there and that was as employee #1 so the maths given the pay cut probably don't work out too well (perhaps break even if I'd played the career game well). However of course I am hugely grateful it happened and I got to see a startup grow from 3 people to more than 10x that and learnt a lot, as well as changing my coding career direction substantially. I wouldn't recommend joining a startup as a non-founder other than for changing career or starting out. The trade-offs don't really make sense in most cases and you get a lot less say than you think you might (founders understandably want to control what is their baby) - never do it for the money. note: I posted a more detailed overview of what happened at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25496667 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25496667
- GoodJokes 6y agoITT: rich people talking about rich people things
- njarboe 6y agoGoogle IPO'd at $85 a share with a market cap of $23 billion.[1] Quite a big oversight by Blank to say it IPO'd for under a billion. It is too bad good companies don't list sooner to let the public get some of the gains. I would have liked to have invested in Google pre-unicorn. [1]https://finance.yahoo.com/news/day-market-history-google-ipo-105500069.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/day-market-history-google-ipo...
- dang 6y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19624164 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19624164