14 ms·
Your Move, iPad
- georgeecollins 6y ago>> Now, I’m only 33, but someday when I go full fuddy-duddy I will speak of this: the great Intel/Apple Silicon transition. I remember the 68000 Power PC transition. You have to be amazed at all the things Apple has survived. I agree with the author, the iPad needs more functionality. It isn't really robust enough to be a PC replacement and my mother in law still can't figure out how to use most apps. So just make the thing more versatile please.
- radimm 6y agoAs somebody who uses iPad Pro 12.9” as daily driver I don’t necessarily agree with the next steps. iPad still has a long way to go, but right now the most pressing issue at hand is the quality of 3rd party apps (yes, I’m looking at you Slack). But it’s going to be interesting to watch the differentiation of iPad Pro vs fanless Air M1 (or later).
- DennisAleynikov 6y agocurious to see how slack and others handle m1, are bad third party apps finally matched by better ram pooling?
- d_silin 6y agoIt is rather clear that iPad is primary a media consumption + light work (email + MS Office + ssh terminal = thin client) machine. With recent additions of Pen functionality it is also an amazing sketch book. But proper laptop is just in the different league for productivity. I tried using my iPad with external keyboard as the primary computer when my laptop was undergoing repairs and it was bearable, but not more than that.
- jonplackett 6y agoWhat was it you missed exactly? I'm assuming i would find the exact same, but i can't put my finger on exactly why.
- d_silin 6y agoTo answer that and above comments - it is a combination of form-factor and software limitations. Lack of adjustable hinge/base part and excessive OS sandboxing.
- _ph_ 6y agoBut why, is it anything hardware related, or isn't it, like the article described, a problem of the software infrastructure?
- qayxc 6y agoIt's the software. The hardware of the iPad Pro is actually even better than the Macbook Air, considering the built-in cellular modem, additional camera, touch screen /w pencil support, motion sensors, two more speakers, micro-location, GPS, etc. The processing power should be behind the Macbook (whether that's significant, I don't know), but the next iteration could close the gap. If it wasn't for iPadOS artificially limiting the use cases, I'd see an iPad Pro with detachable keyboard as superior to a Macbook for the aforementioned reasons.
- reader_mode 6y agoI use a proper keyboard and mouse with my laptop almost exclusively (the only exception is unplanned work while traveling or content on the go). In that sense iPad pro form factor would be a strict improvement - it's far better for casual use and I can set up a home server to SSH into for development outside of home, iOS is a deal breaker however - I need to run some tools client side.
- pedrogpimenta 6y ago> Is it headed toward functional parity with the Mac or will it always be hamstrung by Apple’s strict App Store policies and seemingly inconsistent investment in iPadOS? I see this converging in two possible ways (aside from killing the iPad): - Macs will have iOS - iPads will have macOS I don't see Apple giving that kind of freedom on the iPad, though. Another possibility is Apple making some kind of 2-in-1 Macs with touch screen. The paddings they added to all kind of UI elements on macOS seems to point in this direction.
- n1000 6y agoAlthough it makes me nervous, I think iOS and macOS will continue to move closer together. Big Sur feels already much like iOS.
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoMacs being able to run iOS apps now should give you a hint of the direction where it's going. I'm convinced a not insignificant number of people high up at Apple see the near future of the Mac as where you go to run multiple iOS apps, at least until iPads start to do that too. I think when the true next gen 14 inch MBP drops next year this will become a lot more obvious. This is uncomfortable to think about for people who are fans of computers but just look at the profit charts and when you follow modern Apple leadership actions, Macs where they don't get a cut of software and where users do have that freedom are the anomaly and there are some extremely juicy pieces of software that side of the fence which they are currently not profiting from.
- pjmlp 6y agoFrom my point of view and the whole Apple culture towards UNIX based platforms since its inception, expect "Macs will have iOS" to be the final outcome. UNIX support was only a side-effect of NeXT's acquisition (BeOS wasn't a UNIX based OS), and a question of survival to get the geeks to rescue the company. Besides A/UX, Apple was never serious about that market and now they are printing money, so if it doesn't need to be a proper UNIX clone, then any OS will do, including an evolution of iOS.
- bruceb 6y ago"Adopt a landscape-first mindset. Rotate the Apple logo on the back and move the iPad’s front-facing camera on the side beneath the Apple Pencil charger to better reflect how most people actually use their iPad Pros." No. No. Keep the camera in portrait mode. Or add another camera (I would love the option of selecting portrait or landscape camera).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoMultiple front facing cameras in different locations could also be used for some sort of stereoscopic imaging too. What about camera location as a configuration option at time of purchse?
- monsieurbanana 6y agoThat's really not something you can just decide to change on a whim, given how much work goes into the chassis, and how cramped things are inside.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoI dunno about that. The iPad, and iPhone for that matter, are already available in a variety of sizes, another hardware configuration doesn't seem implausible. And did you see that video from that person who put the headphone jack back in? Edit to add reference: https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/9/7/16267418/scotty-allen-strangeparts-iphone-7-headphone-jack-mod-shenzhen-diy https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2017/9/7/16267418/sc...
- deergomoo 6y agoIt seems like the best approach would be to put it in one of the corners. Then you could hold it in portrait or landscape without covering it with your hands.
- Tepix 6y agoThe article is spot on. Right now i notice that when I grab my iPad, i end up merely consuming, not getting any work done. Apple's decisions to - block certain types of apps (development) and - to charge outrageous prices for their keyboards (175€-331€ in Germany) appear to be the biggest issues.
- arethuza 6y agoI use my iPad for work as a collaboration device - it works great for audio and video meetings. In fact, as I type this on PC my iPad is sitting next to the monitor. All of that is most definitely "getting work done" to me. I also find it useful if there is something I want to research or a document to read to go and sit away from my desk - I much prefer an iPad to a laptop for that kind of thing. Indeed, I find the combination of a full sized PC and an iPad to be preferable to a laptop - which is neither as powerful and ergonomic as a full sized PC or as portable as a iPad. edit: In fact I do have a work laptop, but I left it in the office in March and have never been back... I don't miss it!
- deergomoo 6y ago> to charge outrageous prices for their keyboards (175€-331€ in Germany) Those damn iPad keyboards are the thing I understand the least about anything Apple sells, pricing-wise. I accept that Apple charges higher than average prices for stuff, sometimes to an almost offensive degree. But why is the regular keyboard case so expensive? It's a regular keyboard that's attached to a bit of plastic and fabric. Yet it's more expensive than the Apple Pencil, more expensive than the HomePod Mini, I mean christ if you're buying the entry-level iPad the keyboard adds 48% to the cost! Ridiculous.
- kayoone 6y agoI use my iPad complementary to my Macbook. Reading documents and taking notes with the pencil mostly. Scribbling down thoughts and concepts that sync over Onenote to my other devices. I have no desire to use it as a Laptop replacement and am not sure why people would want that. I can acknowledge that some people use an iPad as their sole device to work which I think is fine for many, but Software Engineers have such complex usecases it's hard to make a device like the iPad be perfect for them without compromising it's main user base.
- neetrain 6y agoI am an artist and loving using my iPad Pro, so I didn't have any doubt about its usefulness. I'm kind of astonished realizing that most people think "Apple has struggled to craft a cohesive, compelling narrative for the iPad".
- lyime 6y agoYeah that’s understandable. This article is from a software developers perspective. Even though it’s not specifically acknowledged.
- _ph_ 6y agoSoftware developers are essential for a healthy eco system. Without them, there are no applications which utilize the device. Yes, there is a lot of software development for the iPad, but it is always limited because you have to write applications on a completely different system than you are targetting for. And it is limited by what applications you are allowed to write. But even graver are the consequences for first time computer users. When I grew up, I learned computing with machines which would have at least a basic when delivered. I had the ability to do programming and understand what a "computer" is. Children, which today grow up with iPads are actively prevented of having that great learning experience. The Apple ad "What is a computer?" on the one side is brilliant marketing, on the other side is outright scary.
- user-the-name 6y agohttps://apps.apple.com/app/id908519492 https://apps.apple.com/app/id908519492
- _ph_ 6y agoYes, so what? There is a programming tutorial app for the iPad. That is nice. But that isn't to be mistaken for a programming environment, where you can develop to your hearts desire. Can I develop freely full screen applications with the Swift playground? Can I share the results with my friends?
- MrRiddle 6y agoAnd that’s exactly how you get completely locked in the OS. No thanks, let’s keep media consumption a primary thing on iPad and keep laptops as professional machines.
- jsharf 6y agoApple should really converge the ipad and macbook. Having something like a surface book where there's a laptop/desktop experience with a thin, light, detachable touchscreen and full desktop software would be really nice.
- bluescrn 6y agoThey’re two different worlds though. The world of precision input devices (keyboard/mouse) and relative openness (to running/developing software) and then the world of imprecise fat-finger touch input and the walled-garden landgrab. So far not even Apple has figured out how to make genuinely complex/feature-rich UIs (think Photoshop, XCode, Maya) work on a touchscreen device. Their best solution so far seems to be adding a keyboard and pointing device in the form of the Pencil.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoIt would be the worst from both worlds. It didn't work for Microsoft and wouldn't for Apple.
- rimliu 6y agoWe have a saying in Lithuanian about things like this: "nei velnias, nei gegutė" (neither a devil, nor a cuckoo).
- tomduncalf 6y ago"Move the iPad’s front-facing camera on the side beneath the Apple Pencil charger to better reflect how most people actually use their iPad Pros" - this! Face ID on iPad is really convenient, except the way I usually hold my iPad (landscape, with the pencil at the top) means that the front camera is more-often-than-not blocked when I want to unlock it. I rarely use it portrait so it seems a strange decision. Interesting post, I too have been wondering how the Macbook and iPad (Pro, especially) will co-exist in future. It seems inevitable that touch will come to the Macbook in some form in the next few years, and with the M1 it sounds like Apple are able to make thin, light laptops that don't run hot or burn through battery, removing a few of the key differentiators between the iPad and laptops. I do really like using the iPad for consumption and for some creation (music making, photo editing), but for any "serious" work I still find it frustrating at best (editing documents etc.), impossible at worst (development). The hardware is very capable, but the question is how they develop iPadOS to support these use cases without treading too much on the Macs toes - or will the two ultimately merge?
- 1123581321 6y agoI disagree with the premise. Now that laptops have the same performance and battery life, iPad is freed from having to be the laptop and can continue to develop its productive capability in the areas where focused touch and stylus work either outperform or result in different creative expression.
- tomduncalf 6y agoThat's a very interesting take on it actually. The iPad does excel, for me, in the areas where it offers a unique approach (as well as a consumption/browsing device). Music making is a great example, there's a whole unique ecosystem and way of working which has developed on iPad which doesn't really exist anywhere else. It's still somewhat tricky to see how e.g. a touch-screen Macbook which can run iPad apps, and an iPad Pro, differentiate themselves a few years down the line though I think.
- bonestamp2 6y agoThere are some great points in the comments here. Regardless of where mac and iPad end up, one thing is clear to me: Apple needs to add touchscreens to the macbook line if they want that line to live on with the next generation. I didn't always think this way, so hear me out. One of my kids has an expensive macbook. They don't use it because they have a cheap chromebook provided by their school that is underpowered and has poor battery life -- but it has a touchscreen! That seems like a terrible trade off to me, but kids these days expect every screen to be a touchscreen and when it comes time for them to buy their own laptop, they will buy the one that has a touchscreen.
- speedgoose 6y agoI have a ThinkPad with a touchscreen and an i7, I am really considering to switch to a MacBook with a M1 but the lack of touchscreen is a problem. I really like the touchscreen when I use it. The MacBook pro touchbar is a joke compared to a touchscreen.
- bonestamp2 6y agoI agree, and I have no need for it personally, but I think they'll leaving a lot of money on the table by excluding consumers who do want it.
- Jaruzel 6y agoSlightly off-topic, but I've not seen the kind of commenting system shown at the bottom of the article before. You are invited to write up a response elsewhere on the web including a link to the article, and then post your URL in. It's a bit like a manual-pingback. It seems a good idea in principle, but would anyone actually bother?
- saagarjha 6y agoGives her a pingback for SEO?
- alanfranz 6y agoThe iPad works fine as it is. And I think the base ipad and/or the ipad air are perfectly and totally fine for the kind of work that most people would do there (reading, annotating, some video watching). iPad Pros were useful once (when the basic ipad was a bit underpowered or had a worse screen, or no pencil support), but now their existence doesn't seem so necessary to me (of course, it's the usual Pro thing: maybe a lot of people don't feel the need for a Mac Pro, and yet some people scream they TOTALLY want such a thing). I think the iPad and the iPad Air are here to stay. I couldn't swear about the iPad Pro. I'd really like to hear from iPad Pro power-users - what's something that you can only get in a Pro?
- tomduncalf 6y ago>What's something that you can only get in a Pro? For me at this point, it's just the screen size. Personally I think once you get used to the 12.9", any other size feels too small, especially if you are doing anything creative like photo editing or music making.
- radimm 6y agoRight now diff between Air vs Pro is limited. For me the only noticeable thing is ProMotion (120Hz). Can't say 2 GB of additional RAM is seen somewhere as big differentiator. So it goes down to 12.9" screen size option.
- bjohnson225 6y agoMainly the large 13" screen. My partner has a job which involves reading lots of documents, taking notes and then reading/sending emails. The iPad Pro is more comfortable than the rest of the range for split screen mode. The notes can all be written with the pencil and then the iPad can be easily attached to a keyboard for when you need to send long emails.
- jimmydorry 6y agoScreen size is the largest differentiator between the Pro and standard iPads. I got a first gen iPad Pro (back in 2015!) and it's still running smoothly to this day. It runs the latest iPadOS. Meanwhile, my co-workers and family iPads have all failed, broken, or become obsolete several times since then. I use the iPad Pro daily for: - Evening reading - Reading on flights - Laptop replacement while travelling - Recreational writing with bluetooth keyboard - Recreational doodling with Apple Pencil - Light productivity tasks like email, etc. - General browsing
- areoform 6y ago> Introduce Gatekeeper and app notarization for iOS. The process of side-loading apps should not be as simple as downloading them from the App Store. Bury it in Settings, make it slightly convoluted, whatever: just have an officially-sanctioned way of doing it. > Ruthlessly purge the App Store Guidelines of anything that prevents the iPad from serving as a development machine. Every kind of development from web to games should be possible on an iPad. And speaking of games—emulators should be allowed, too. No. I am uncertain and unclear why a single company should have a monopoly on what we can and can't install on a general-purpose computational device. When the iPhone was first launched, it was launched into a world where carriers controlled what could be installed on phones due to a combination of contracts and the difficulty of developing for the environment. The "computers" in the early smartphones were, essentially, embedded systems with a rudimentary operating system on top. You couldn't do much of anything with them, so most people didn't try. Until Apple came along and brought OS X to the iPhone, that was the original promise. iOS was OS X on a phone, with all the great "APIs" and features that it indicated. However, Jobs wanted to keep it locked down with web apps being the only way out. AT&T were pleased with that arrangement and gave them a good deal. iPhone was a hit, and Apple had a crisis. They wanted to open up the phone to devs. Jobs said no. Jobs kept saying no until the App Store was created as a sort of compromise. In hindsight, this compromise ended up being a spigot of "free" cash, giving Apple the ability to control 30% of all revenue flowing through 1 Billion installed devices. If the average owner spends only $10/yr, Apple makes $3Bn per year, essentially for "free" on top of the generous profit margins of their devices and services. Smartphones have grown up since then. Moore's law has turned embedded machines into full-fledged computers, with the ability to rival desktops. And yet we're still stuck in this paradigm. Why? Why should we accept this as the way it should be? It hurts people like Becky and me. For smaller, indie businesses, 15% to 30% of your revenue going to a cut on a platform with little-to-no-oversight and extensive content restrictions means that several things are already off the table, and small businesses have to sell a third more to make the same amount. It hurts the users. An adult can't download and enjoy age-appropriate games on their phone because Apple says so. If they live in an oppressive regime, they can't use their phone for dissent because Apple lets their oppressors say so. Programmers and artists can't use their tools the way they want on computers they have bought and owned because Apple says so. Consumers with an artistic streak can't customize their phones because Apple says so. iOS users get a degraded experience for common apps because Apple says so. Apple jealously gatekeeps features, making several iOS apps either one or two updates behind their Android counterparts, or lacking in feature parity. Why should we - the users, creators, developers, and artists - pay a tax to a company that is acting against our interest and is locking up a computer we've bought with our hard-earned money? Why should we live in a world where Becky has to give 30% of her income to Apple as tithe? And I have to live with what little Apple allows into the store? Why should my creativity be limited by some corporate jockey sitting in Cupertino? So, No. We need to dream bigger. We need to set these computers free.
- Farbklex 6y agoI would prefer if smartphones and tablets would finally make the push to become desktop/laptop replacements. Microsoft tried it with the Windows Phone. Samsung and Huawei still have desktop modes in their phones. Google kinda explored the idea in some developer settings but the Pixel phones don't even support HDMI out via USB-C. Just like the Nintendo Switch allows us to play video games on the go and on the big screen with one device, I want to finally have a smartphone / tablet which makes a laptop obsolete. Just plug it into a dock and start using a monitor, mouse and keyboard. It appears, that apples performance boost makes it more feasible than ever now.
- purplecats 6y agothat's a really neat and plausible idea. i could imagine a case where the mbp essentially becomes a glorified shell for the iphone to dock into, and provides a large battery, keypad, speakers, and a screen without any of the core computer innards.
- jonplackett 6y agoIt makes sense in theory, but it's always going to be a lot less performance than having a device specifically designed for what you need. M1 is great because it fulfils that specific need.
- purplecats 6y agounless you could somehow leverage distributed computing. for instance, the shell "laptop" has a couple cores that can seamlessly modularly enhance the capabilities of the phone. I don't believe such a functionality exists as of yet.
- jonplackett 6y agoI think if anything is becoming clear from apple’s new direction it’s that putting everything on the same chip is a lot faster! I guess one thing you could do is have a chip that’s potentially faster in the phone and have better cooling in the laptop but even that seems kinda pointless with the air having no fan anyway. I can’t see apple doing this ever, it’s just too messy for them!
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago#4 (development stuff) is the biggie for me. I was hoping that Xcode 12 would finally be the version that runs on iPad, but that doesn’t seem to be the case.
- speedgoose 6y agoOven if they allow development tools, I think they will still only allow Safari/Webkit for some reasons which will make the iPad not the best platform to develop on for many developers.
- magtux 6y agoI've always felt Apple should let power users run MacOS on the iPad, it takes care of all the things the article speaks of. They can bury it by using iTunes or something to flash the image and 99.99% of people who don't need it will use it only as a MID device.
- _ph_ 6y agoI think Apple was right in that sense that just throwing MacOS onto the iPad would have been the right thing. Especially back then, MacOS would have been a very bad fit UI-wise, Big Sur makes a few steps towards the iPad now. But that doesn't mean that people shouldn't get more flexibility in using the iPad.
- _ph_ 6y agoI couldn't agree more with this article. I have been an iPad owner since I got the very first iPad on the day it was released and I am owning a 13" iPad Pro for 4 years now. I have always considered the iPad as an extremels faszinating hardware experience. But its actual use always seems to be constrained by the software. Indeed, it was always rumored how powerful the processor of the iPad must be, as little things are slow on that machine. But it wasn't widely acknowledged, as very few big software packages are running on the iPad. Count the percentage of software on the Mac which doesn't sell via the App Store and one might get an estimate, what the iPad is missing out. Partially, this has fiscal reasons, avoiding the revenue share with Apple, but a lot has to do with the App Store restrictions. There are far too many applications which are restricted or outrightly banned by the app store. When I started computing, a computer would come with an implementation of basic. You could immediately start programming on that computer. In my case it was the C64, for others MS Basic on DOS. Not even that exists on the iPad. There are a very few IDEs, which constantly have to avoid being too useful to prevent being banned. To big the danger for Apple seems, if you manage to write an useful App on the iPad without going through the App Store. Imagine a full featured Python or just Basic, which allows you to write programs with full screen graphics als full user interaction on the iPad. Imagine, if someone ported Squeak as an iPad app. It could perfectly run the whole environment inside the App, this would be a great experience. Imagine running a Lisp machine as an App. On the technical side, the iPad needs more memory. If it is meant as a "Pro" machine, it should have 8Gb of RAM, optionally 16. But most importantly, a limited form of swap should be introduced. Limiting the active memory of a single app to the available system memory makes sense, but the more complex an application becomes, the less it is acceptable to kill the process just because the user switches to another App. Even on the fastest machine, restoring the state might not be possible fast enough. This can eliminate a wide range of application. Instead, deactivated applications should be swapped out. So the swap would just allow them to run without interruptions.
- simonh 6y agoThere is already a thriving ecosystem of very powerful development apps on iOS. Pythonista is a full copy of Python 2.7 and 3.x, with an IDE, links to the GUI APIs and even a basic visual GUI designer for the iPad and iPhone. You can sync your scripts source code with Macs and other iOS devices through iCloud. http://omz-software.com/pythonista/ http://omz-software.com/pythonista/ Pyto is another Python app for the iPad, it's not as mature but is 100% open source on Github. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/pyto-python-3/id1436650069 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/pyto-python-3/id1436650069 Codea is an IDE for Lua with extensive integration with the iPad native APIs and fantastic graphics capabilities. https://codea.io/ https://codea.io/ There are several others for different languages, but I think these are the most mature. Some of these have even been used to publish apps on the App Store, by dropping the code into a Python or Lua app container project in XCode. You can also integrate them with Git from iOS using an App called Working Copy.
- supernova87a 6y ago> 4. Ruthlessly purge the App Store Guidelines of anything that prevents the iPad from serving as a development machine. Every kind of development from web to games should be possible on an iPad. And speaking of games—emulators should be allowed, too. #4 is fundamentally incompatible with the walled garden and becoming a dev device under your full control, and makes the author seem a little bit in fantasy land. The whole point of iPad and iPhone's controls are to prevent unsupervised, uncontrolled usage of the device. Apple is going to let you have unrestricted access to the cell phone chip and radio? iPads are for artists, designers, some creative professionals. Macs are for developers and hackers. It's pick one or the other. I for one hope that the Macs don't go further in the direction of iPads at least, and take away yet more control. I doubt they will let iPads go in the direction of Macs.
- _ph_ 6y agoNo, it isn't fundamentally incompatible. It is a prefect reasonal requirement for an App Store app to be checked for security and sticking to the sandbox. Which by the way the operation system should enforce. An App should only be able to see the filesystem which belongs to its sandbox and shared forlders. Equally, any direct access to the hardware should be prohibited by the OS, and usually Unix systems are pretty good about that. The App Store review should only check whether an App is a security risk, perform any malware functionality behind the back of the user. But the review shouldn't cover what kind of App Apple likes. A fully sandboxes IDE should be possible. A local shell should be possible, when limited to the applications sandbox.
- q3k 6y ago> You think Apple is going to let you have unrestricted access to the cell phone chip and radio? I mean, why not? At least why not to the level it's already possible on other kinds of machines? I can stick an LTE modem into my laptop and the world hasn't ended yet.
- chongli 6y ago#4 is fundamentally incompatible with the walled garden and becoming a dev device under your full control, and makes the author seem a little bit in fantasy land. The whole point of iPad and iPhone's controls are to prevent unsupervised, uncontrolled usage of the device. Apple is going to let you have unrestricted access to the cell phone chip and radio? I thought this for a long time. Then recently I heard another argument here on HN: the purpose of these draconian anti-development rules is to prevent bait-and-switch apps from existing. That is, apps that behave one way under App Store review and then completely change behaviour after normal users purchase them. Think: Volkswagen emissions cheating scandal type stuff.
- reader_mode 6y agoI'm just waiting for their competitors to catch up and take advantage of the ecosystem shift - Microsoft already had their ARM SoC tablet (I think with Qualcomm) so they will eventually move to 5nm - nobody really wanted to release ARM versions for that because Microsoft has way less pull with app devs - but if they can deliver M1 level performance in a generation and most of the software is ARM ready - I won't care that there's a M2 MacBook out there - because it's still not going to be the form factor I prefer for my mobile device and it still won't run MacOS on iPad Pro.
- Philip-J-Fry 6y agoThe iPad is fine. Don't be upset because you fell for Apple's "what's a computer" marketing. It's not meant to be a proper work device, you can't do much real work outside of email and word processing. Every tattoo artist I've seen uses an iPad to sketch out their designs. It's a very good tool for an artist. Most people are using iPads as media consumption, which is what they're very good for. Long battery life, high quality display, it's great. The iPad Pro is just a better iPad. It never became any better at doing anything just because it was really powerful. It's still just locked to iPad OS. The writer of this article wants a touch screen Mac. The iPad Pro will likely pivot to being this now that the M1 chips exist. Either that or Apple will keep it around and just make a touch screen Mac. But either way, the iPad will always be an iPad. If you want work done, get a real computer!
- vr46 6y agoI picked up a 12.9 Pro early last year to try and find new ways of working, not just trying to reproduce the laptop experience on an iPad, which seems to be one stream of effort from many people. And it worked, it was an incredibly collaborative device that could be passed around, drawn on, and used effectively in group settings. It enables things that are simply not possible on a laptop, and as the platform matures, that will hopefully become more obvious. One standout app for me is Concepts.app, allows me to draw and diagram and demo all in one go. It helped improve team and client relationships straight away. Admittedly, this method of working has vanished completely with remote, but I hope to get back to on-site and face-to-face working next year sometime.
- aikinai 6y agoI also recently discovered the Concepts app. It’s amazing and too bad it’s not more widely known.
- Cu3PO42 6y agoThere's something I really want from my iPad: support for custom keyboard layouts for attached keyboards. Mine is currently unsupported, so as soon as I need to type something I need to put it away and use another device, even if the iPad would be totally up to the job otherwise. Say, replying to emails or writing some sort of rough draft.
- dredmorbius 6y agoAccessory standardisation especially for keyboards is a massive failure of the tablet space generally.
- gpresot 6y agoI work as management consultant and the iPad+Apple Pencil+OneNote combination has been a game changer for my workflow. No need to have tons of paper notebooks to take notes during meetings (and then misplace 2 months into the project), no need to print powerpoint or pdf presentations or documents to make comments for the rest of the team. The OneNote app works really well and syncs perfectly with my windows 10 laptop (and my macbook pro for personal use). I haven't found another compelling use for it (I wouldn't use it to make powerpoint presentations, nor excel spreadsheets; i could use it for text documents in MS Word, but the full keyboard of a laptop and far superior trackpads make this a non-starter). For emails, the phone is good enough if i need to reply on the go. All this to say that how fitting an instrument is to your work depends on the kind of work you do. From what I have seen, graphic designers and artists have embraced the iPad. Do software developers really crave a touch-first instrument that is barely more portable than a MBP 13"?
- qayxc 6y ago> Do software developers really crave a touch-first instrument that is barely more portable than a MBP 13"? I don't know about the need for touch-first, but I can certainly see where the blog post is coming from. It's not so much about what the iPad can do, it's more about what it cannot do and that there's no technical reason for its limitations. It's kind of pointless to have two separate device classes when there's no technical difference between them anymore. Before the release of the M1 laptop and Mac Mini it could have been argued that the more traditional machines were more powerful and expandable. But there's literally no difference between the hardware of a Macbook, Mac Mini, and iPad Pro apart from peripherals (e.g. screen, keyboard, touchpad). Why would a developer even need two devices when the laptop runs the same hardware and is only missing things (modem, touch screen, sensors, cameras)?
- gpresot 6y ago> But there's literally no difference between the hardware of a Macbook, Mac Mini, and iPad Pro apart from peripherals (e.g. screen, keyboard, touchpad). screen, keyboard, trackpad, touch screen ports, are A LOT of what defines the hardware. It is clearly not only chipset and RAM. > Why would a developer even need two devices when the laptop runs the same hardware and is only missing things (modem, touch screen, sensors, cameras)? Maybe they don't need two devices in the first place. Isn't a MBP a very capable, portable, software development device? If the issue is that moving around with a MBP13 and an iPadPro with keyboard is cumbersome / heavy, then maybe the MBP plus the cheapest iPad with no keyboard would be more bearable and cover most of the use cases? Maybe the MPB and the iPhone can cover enough use cases. I think my point is that the reasoning around iPadpro and MBP should not be that they are in principle equally powerful, so they should allow me to do the same things equally well, rather than the two have distinctive hardware features (form, keyboard, ports...) that make one better suited than the other for specific tasks. Whether I value these specific tasks enough to buy both, depends on my personal needs (and cash reserves)
- rahoulb 6y agoI love iPads and have had one since they first came out. My primary "front-end" machine is a 12.9" Pro at the moment - I do dev work using Blink as a Mosh terminal to a Linux box, I do sketches, I communicate with clients on it. And I very rarely have any complications with using it. The only things I struggle with are * the browser - it's really annoying that notifications aren't allowed and I don't see why that's not the case * the browser - there's no web inspector - I rarely do front-end work but there's always some bit of CSS or JS to sort out (I use Luna Display into a 2012 Mac Mini or VNC into my Linux box for that) * a minor annoyance with audio - I'd like to use my USB microphone with it, but plugging it in means it gets recognised as an output device as well, so I can't hear anything - unlike a Mac I can't find a way to route the input from one device and the output to another. All my other annoyances with it are around poorly designed apps - for example ones that assume you wouldn't want multiple windows or think you only ever want to upload from the camera roll rather than the filesystem. UPDATE: one other thing - in the article she talks about landscape-first; I often use my iPad in landscape but it's in portrait mode where it shines. In landscape, with the magic keyboard, it just feels like a crippled laptop. In portrait with an external keyboard in a stand it feels like a writing machine. In portrait and with the pencil, it feels like a notebook. I don't really get the people who want the iPad to become a laptop when its strengths are elsewhere.
- pjmlp 6y agoNotifications are missing due to PWAs support. You can always plug the iPad and use the host web inspector, but I get your point. On device would be rather nice, even it needed to be an additional app for reasons.
- rahoulb 6y agoWell that's the thing that gets me. My Mac notification bar is full of notifications from web sites and pages I've long forgotten. Yet my iPad, also using Safari, isn't allowed to receive them.
- Joeri 6y agoFor web inspector you can load eruda console into any page via a bookmarklet. It’s not the same as a native inspector, but it has proven handy in a pinch. https://eruda.liriliri.io/ https://eruda.liriliri.io/
- Razengan 6y agoDidn’t read the article, but the iPad was my gateway drug into the Apple orchard. It was quite literally my first ever Apple product, and I had actually purchased it as a gift for the older people in my family. They had almost never touched computers, but they immediately took to the iPad, after an initial trepidation from fear of accidentally breaking an expensive thing. After assuring that there was nothing they could do to damage the iPad save for physically smashing it with a hammer, they were using it all the time. Watching them enjoy it impressed me with its accessibility and simplicity and I just had to try developing for it. So I torrented a VMWare image for macOS (Lion at the time) and started dabbling in it. My host machine was running Windows 8 and it was the first time I had ever used macOS. Gradually I began to notice that I was spending more time in the Mac VM than in Windows and loving every minute it. My next personal computer was a MacBook and I’ve never felt the need to go back to PCs yet. So yeah. The iPad was to computers what the Wii was to games. In fact, I think it’s gotten unnecessarily complicated since then, with its mystery meat menus and arcane gestures and removal of Dock labels etc. On one hand it should have stayed true to its original purpose, bringing basic computing to the computer-shy masses, but on the other a simplified OS would be a painful waste of the iPad’s beautiful hardware. Maybe it’s time to offer “Casual” and “Pro” UI modes in iPadOS?
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoI think the problem with iPads is that a large proportion of people need keyboards for part of their workflow - emails, reports, twitter etc. The attachable tablet keyboards can't really be used comfortably on the go - commuting, sofa surfing etc. A laptop has a sturdy, built in lap rest that can be used in just about any position. IMHO, the killer product is somewhere between an iPad and Macbook Air - with an attached reversible clamshell keyboard, or detachable/attachable keyboard that can be used to support the screen at any angle without being on a desk (ie not some flimsy magnetic lock), so the device can be used like a tablet or laptop and used in either mode wherever.
- llampx 6y agoYou're describing a Surface Book. Its a nice device, but I do believe Apple's hardware design can take it to the next level.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoI hope Apple don't end up going down the touch screen route with macOS. Windows has been much worse as a desktop OS since Windows 8, largely because of the shift to touch.
- Razengan 6y ago> The attachable tablet keyboards can't really be used comfortably on the go - commuting, sofa surfing etc. WHAT?? I disagree completely. The iPad’s fanless shell and the lightweight sealed keyboards make it PERFECT for random environments, especially restaurants and dining tables etc. where you don’t have to worry about dust or crumbs getting in anything and can just wet-wipe grease and crap off it.
- Slippery_John 6y ago> The attachable tablet keyboards can't really be used comfortably on the go - commuting, sofa surfing etc I disagree. I use mine for just these purposes, and I find the ipad to be significantly more comfortable to use than any of my laptops. > not some flimsy magnetic lock I've found it to be pretty sturdy. I've only owned the iPad Pro though, perhaps it has a more sturdy keyboard than other models.
- guptaneil 6y agoThese types of posts are popular on HN and generally suggest that people are bad at realizing when a product wasn't designed for them. It's a bit like complaining that a drill should have a flat back so you can also use it as a hammer. Sure, it might be technically possible, but not only will it never be as good as just using a hammer for the job, it would make the drilling functionality worse. If you're trying to use your iPad as a Mac, you will always be disappointed and rightfully so. These are distinctly different form factors with different primary inputs, and they should focus on what they excel at. Adding keyboard and trackpad support to iPadOS wasn't to help us developers move to an iPad, it was to help people whose only computer is an iPad fill in some missing gaps in their workflow. However, if you're planning to attach a keyboard to your iPad most of the time, just get a MacBook Air instead. On the flip side, if you're getting an iPad Pro, you should really be planning to buy the Pencil with it to take advantage of its strengths. Otherwise, you are probably looking for a consumption device (iPad Air or iPad no-adjective), but then you shouldn't be surprised that it doesn't help you create.
- melling 6y agoNo, this one of those “There are two kinds of people in the world” “Those that have imagination and those that don’t“ I am really disappointed that Google or Microsoft haven’t don’t a better job with tablets. Apple needs more competition. The laptop of the future is a better iPad. Remember when Apple told us we didn’t need bigger iPhones? If it didn’t fit in one hand, you were essentially doing it wrong.
- deergomoo 6y agoNormally I would agree with this, but I think in this case Apple would have to do so little to make this a suitable enough device to the software development crowd, and without affecting how the device works for everyone else, that I wish they'd just do it. All they'd need to do is allow sideloading. Even if they left all the other sometimes-problematic security aspects in place (like enforced sandboxing), it would be enough. People would find a way to do what they need to. I don't need it to be a full replacement for my Mac, but it sucks that I can't use this amazing, capable device to a bit of work on my sofa or on the train. Of course, they'll never do it, because money. Even if 99% of apps stayed on the App Store, the highest earning 1% would be sure to leave.
- jwr 6y ago> Adopt a landscape-first mindset. Rotate the Apple logo on the back and move the iPad’s front-facing camera on the side beneath the Apple Pencil charger to better reflect how most people actually use their iPad Pros. Hell no! I've been using iPads since the first one, and I love them — if I wanted a laptop, I would use a laptop. An iPad is fantastic for reading documents or taking notes in vertical, that's a large part of its appeal. Don't try to reduce it to the common denominator. I do agree the iPad should be less restrained: software has been holding this platform back for years now. It's an incredibly powerful computer that is only 6mm thick. Those of us who use it for things like audio production or 3d modeling realize how powerful it is, but it is being held back by Apple's obsessive control and neglect.
- Joeri 6y agoWhen you use the camera, do you use it in landscape or portrait? I find that anything I do in portrait I prefer doing on my phone, and everything I use the camera for on the ipad ends up in landscape, which makes the camera always at the wrong position.
- jwr 6y agoI never use the back camera on the iPad :-) I would like the face unlock to work both in portrait and landscape, but otherwise the camera in the back might as well not exist.
- ghaff 6y agoPretty much the only time I use the camera is if I'm using my iPad to take notes at a conference and I want to insert a picture of a slide. And even then it's awkward. Usually I just take pics of slides on my phone and insert them into a doc later if I'm energetic enough.
- dagmx 6y agoFwiw the iPad pro face unlock works in any orientation
- jeromenerf 6y ago
- emsy 6y agoIt’s not that the iPad isn’t suitable for work. It’s that if you decide to commit to it and use it for your work you’re now at the whim of Apple. They can wreck your workflow because they have a dispute with the developer. Combined with the push towards rented („subscription based“) software this makes for a very uncertain platform. Even if disputes are rare, as long as Apple holds this power I think it will only ever get worse over time.
- deergomoo 6y agoAt this point, the only thing standing in the way of me doing work on my iPad Pro is Apple. Would I like to work for 8 hours a day on it? Of course not. But I work mostly from home now. It would be great if I could ditch my laptop and have a desktop Mac for the bulk of my work, with the iPad filling the gaps. But as things stand, I can't run a web server, can't run PHP or Node, I can't even open dev tools in the browser without relying on a "real computer". Which is especially stupid considering that, even though my "real computer" is a 16" MacBook Pro that cost 3x what the iPad cost, the iPad is faster in many regards (and doesn't burn the skin off my lap either).
- theshrike79 6y agoYou can run the webservers on a raspberry pi easily. I think you can even connect them via USB-C directly and have a wired network between them. I do agree about the lack of dev tools on iPad Safari though
- deergomoo 6y agoIn this case then the Raspberry Pi fits the definition of "real computer" :)
- moonbug 6y agoA lot of this reads like the guy really wants it to be a faster horse.
- reissbaker 6y ago"The iPad has had amazing performance for awhile, so why is the M1 a game changer? Because it’s finally in a machine we can actually do things on.” This quote drives home well how the iPad feels, well... Perennially not-quite-there, for anything other than a certain kind of digital artist (but not most people who work in 3D, since the App Store doesn't have good general-purpose 3D modeling apps, and if it's not in the App Store, well...). When Apple eventually releases a competitor to the Surface Pro — that is, a tablet that runs macOS with a detachable keyboard (and Apple already has a great detachable keyboard!) — people will lose their minds and whatever that thing is called will fly off the shelves, just like people are so excited about the M1 when it's essentially just the chip from the iPad running a more-useful OS. Until then, the iPad will still trundle along, supported by those artists who can use it and the hardcore Apple enthusiasts. But it feels like the iPad's stuck in a weird corner where they're too much of an appliance and not enough of a computer for most people, and trying to iterate iPad OS to be less appliance-y seems a bit pointless when macOS can now natively run iPad apps, and merely lacks hardware that includes a touchscreen. Plenty of other manufacturers have shown they can put a touchscreen on a laptop, and sometimes even make you buy the keyboard separately as an accessory. I'd bet Apple eventually ends up there with macOS as well; and if Apple sells a touchscreen computing device that runs macOS, I think it's curtains for iPad OS. (They might still call it an iPad, of course. And hopefully give macOS a more touch-friendly UI! But it'll be the end of the iPad-as-appliance, which I think many of us here will be thankful for. And I think it'll sell better, too.)
- tempodox 6y agoI admire your optimism. I wouldn't expect that putting macOS on an iPad would mean “the end of the iPad-as-appliance” but rather the end of macOS being a general computing platform, given Apple's obsession with locking everything down. I doubt I can take much more iOS-ification of macOS already as it is.
- fareesh 6y agoDoes anyone think that there won't be another line of M1 macbooks next year?
- janfoeh 6y agoI believe the future of the iPad is in the exact opposite direction - as a computer for the majority of needs of people for whom Personal Computers and the desktop metaphor never worked. A Pareto machine that covers 80% of functionality with 20% of the complexity. Beefing it up towards something that is capable of serving as a development environment, as quite a few people wish for here, is fundamentally incompatible with that. Wanting a touch Mac is of course well and fine and understandable - but the iPad cannot become that without killing what makes it special in the first place. Maybe there is a way to expose more power through iOS' user interface without adding noticeable complexity - but if there is, Apple has not found it yet. A good chunk of enhancements have either made things more complex — the "just stuff another button into the share sheet" school of thought seems prevalent — or led to features that are wholly invisible and undiscoverable. Multitasking is a prime example: I end up using my girlfriends iPad Pro about once a week, and for the past year I have not managed to internalize how to reliably manage split screen modes and the like.
- christophilus 6y agoI mean, you can have both. What you experience today could just be the default desktop. If you go to settings -> superradmode you’d be placed in osx and can then do your dev thing.
- janfoeh 6y agoI do not believe you could - not without significant compromises, since both systems exhibit very different capabilities and security design considerations. You'd still end up with either a more complex iOS, a severely restricted macOS or a split-brained, dual-booting machine which has trouble even freely sharing files between its boot modes.
- flixic 6y agoNone of the suggestions in the post would increase the complexity. I like the way Apple redesigned the home screen experience this year: a LOT more features, but all are gradually discovered. App Library discovered when you "hide" an app. Togglable pages discovered when you tap on dots in wiggle mode. Widgets discovered via + in wiggle mode. Many people won't know about any of this, and that's fine. Same with Pro apps and plugins, or side-loading. Gradually discovered complexity, and only if you need[0]. The post does not argue for introducing a Finder and a file system, or overlapping windows. [0] - one possible downside would be if for App Store rules reasons some major apps would go for side-loading. Even if only Netflix decided to move away from the App Store and educate customers how to install via side-loading, it would suck for most people AND Apple. Probably the main reason why Apple will do anything in it's power to never allow this to happen.
- loso 6y agoThe iPad was the gateway for me into the Apple community. I was never a fan of Mac Os. But when I got an iPad I was hooked. Which then had me upgrade to an iPad Pro and Macbook Pro 16". Leave the iPad as it is. Improve on it, yes. But we don't need it as another laptop.
- usrusr 6y agoArticle reads as if the iPad would be required to change somehow, to compete with the M1 Mac. But why? It's in a perfect spot for Apple now: CPU performance proven by association with the Mighty New Mac, a happy place for those who prefer a garden with higher walls. Before the M1 Macs (or without them), extending the scope of the iPad would have made far more sense for Apple.
- rock_artist 6y agoI finally bought 7th gen iPad last year after Apple introduced Desktop 'like' browsing and iPadOS, Then I got Logitech Combo Touch (sadly they were faulty so I don't have them). and be-hold trackpad and keyboard (which work 'nice' but very limited in support). It's a GREAT consumer/entertainment device. even nice canvas for sketches. But any other productivity fails deeply. Here is a simple fail use-case (I think so): Apple's own Pages. * Try selecting text and copy/paste. (even with trackpad) sometimes the contextual options provide ANYTHING but copy/paste. * Apple's FileProvider... I like to do something quite common to my computer workflow, work within a Dropbox folder. This works nicely for few minutes, then you get a message complaining access failed and it closes the document (showing you tons of Conflicted copies). So for me at least, even declared usability of iPad for any productivity is subpar to macOS. (even with trackpad and keyboard)
- ThePhysicist 6y agoLast year, I wanted to buy an additional lightweight, portable computer that I could use for office work, as rebooting my Linux machine to work on Excel files (without breaking them in Open Office) became tiresome. I tried the iPad as well as the Surface Pro (6) and eventually decided for the Surface. My main reason was that the Surface is just a normal Windows computer that can run any software (I even run Linux on it via WSL for when I need to do some light development work), while the iPad is a strongly locked down device where I have to rely on the app store to get and install software, and where I don't even have a real file system to work with (though I hear they improved this with iPadOS). That said the UX and performance of the iPad is much better than of the Surface, which will often show stuttering and input delays if I open too many apps. In terms of productivity it rocks though as I can do all my office work and some development work on it (and it has a pretty decent keyboard as well). So I agree with the author that there's so much potential for the iPad, I don't think Apple will want to unearth that though as they'd probably cut into their own Macbook revenue by doing so. Hence the iPad remains more of a "toy" or leisure device that's (IMHO) intended more for media consumption than actual work.
- ghaff 6y agoMicrosoft has always had much more convergence between its laptops/desktop (well, laptop/desktop OS) and tablets (historically, to a fault) than Apple has simply because Windows was its beachhead. I haven't used Windows much for a decade (though I have a gaming laptop) but I know regular Windows users who really like some model of Surface as their travel machine.
- schwartzworld 6y ago> Is it headed toward functional parity with the Mac Since they are never going to give you a real terminal on iPad, if they do reach functional parity, it's going to be by crippling the computers, rather than giving iPads any special new powers.
- supermatt 6y agoIm hoping that the "new form factor" rumours for next years MacBook range, is in fact a macPad - the equivalent of a large format iPad with magic keyboard, etc - but running macOS. It would actually make the new ability to run iOS apps even more practical. Literally open an iOS/iPad app and it behaves exactly as an iPad would. iPads already have keyboards and trackpads, MacBooks have ability to run iOS apps - its not a great leap to see this as the next step. Id even be happy with a single TB port. Thats all Im using on my 8GB MBP M1 anyway - connecting to a dock for some extra storage, network, power delivery and connecting to 3 4k monitors while in clamshell (and SD card reader, and 4 USB3 ports left over, and daisy chaining...). I really don't get port-anxiety when one gives you all this... As for making macOS itself touch capable - god no. Keep those behaviours restricted to the views of the "iPad" apps. If you aren't plugged into a keyboard or a dock, or if you enter "iPad mode" (maybe via a hardware switch - like the old silent-mode one), then it could behave just like a regular iPad. Theres none of the windows nonsense if you don't make the "desktop" aspects touch capable.
- cercatrova 6y agoYes, the Apple equivalent of a Surface.
- supermatt 6y agoYeah - but without the "touch" stuff added to the desktop OS. Touch should be constrained to iPad views - both fullscreen and windowed - then there would be no temptation to create desktop apps which respond to touch - which is what makes the surface so horrible, IMHO.
- cercatrova 6y agoMaybe. Big Sur is already moving towards touch with its bigger icons, and larger spacing.
- BenGosub 6y agoThe iPad has received several updates that have made possible for professional music producers to use it in their workflow. Imo this is a great advancement, where, for example Android is still lagging behind.
- justinclift 6y agoMaybe they should go the opposite direction and make the screen on the (M1) Macbook Air into a touch screen with Pencil support? That way people could run their Pencil enabled iPad apps on their Macbook Air directly, without needing an iPad.
- blunte 6y agoI want a low latency handwriting tablet which can store and access all my data, including photos and videos. It does that now. I also would love to be able to develop on it for times when I'm on the road or in the air (and not sitting in business class, so there's not enough room to open a laptop. Basically all that is missing now is the ability to run dev tools and an ide of some sort. I'll even be unpicky about the ide...
- blunte 6y agoDoes anyone know with authority why apple is explicitly against allowing development ON the iPad?
- floydnoel 6y agoThere are plenty of apps for development in the App Store. I have a JS IDE called play.js, and a Python one as well.
- socialdemocrat 6y agoI am not sure it is true that iPad did not realize its potential. I have seen a lot of people who are uncomfortable with a regular computer who can finally get stuff done with an iPad. But it may be true that an iPad Pro could be a lot more. Personally I think iPads was too big of a success. For that reason I never use them any more. It made my kids and me addicted. They are too portable, versatile and engaging.
- kzrdude 6y agoWhat engages you with them? Asking out of curiosity, I've never owned one or used one extensively. (And I don't habitually buy electronics just because)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nottorp 6y ago> Ruthlessly purge the App Store Guidelines of anything that prevents the iPad from serving as a development machine. Every kind of development from web to games should be possible on an iPad. And speaking of games—emulators should be allowed, too. That's soo unlikely to happen.
- seek3r 6y agoOverthinking at its best
- tomp 6y agoI'm the target market for the MacPad Pro. I'm a software developer, and for the past year or so I've been using a Microsoft Surface Go as my primary development machine. I don't need a desktop (I'm not doing any ML that would require a GPU), and I want to go back to Mac (OSX is way better than Windows, easier to install software, more intuitive, JustWorks(TM), etc.) but there's simply no equivalent offering. I can't use an iPad for development (it's not actually a computer), so the only alternative is a MacBook (Air / Pro), which is however way less portable than a tablet. The addressable market is tiny though so I don't expect this to change anytime soon.
- cercatrova 6y agoPlease just put macOS on an iPad with a larger screen size. It would be the Apple equivalent of the Microsoft Surface, one which I was initially excited about, but which Microsoft hasn't updated in design since the Surface Pro 3 days. macOS is already moving towards touch, if you notice the pattern of bigger icons, more space between buttons, and larger padding. It's clear that macOS and iPadOS will converge. You can already run iPhone and iPad apps on M1 now. You could even have something like the Magic keyboard having its own battery like the Surface Book, and instead of the Book's docking mechanism, with the Magic Keyboard you could wirelessly charge from the keyboard to the iPad with the iPhone 12's new wireless charging mechanism. Then I could just buy one device rather than two. But I suspect Apple wouldn't like that very much, which is why we continue to see both macOS and iPadOS simultaneously. However, Jobs said to not fear cannibalizing your own product, because if you don't, someone else will.
- celeritascelery 6y ago> The process of side-loading apps should not be as simple as downloading them from the App Store. just have an officially-sanctioned way of doing it. This is the biggest thing holding the iPad back from being a developer machine. I can’t install what I want on it. I can only install what Apple approves of. Until this limitation is removed, the iPad will never be for pros.
- plg 6y agoI'm a prof (not in CS), and if I can use an iPad quite happily for 90% of my computing needs. Pre-pandemic, having the cellular version also means I can work anywhere, coffee shop, traveling, and not have to worry about wifi, or depleting my iPhone battery by tethering. The screen is gorgeous. The sound is impressive. The new keyboard thingy is very serviceable. _Overall_ I like using it more than using a laptop. It's my go-to machine when computing around the house, or when working away from my desk/office (e.g. coffee shop), or when traveling. The pain points currently (iPad Pro 12.9) are: - FaceTime camera on the "top" edge, which means, when used with Apple's own magic keyboard, the camera is actually on the side, giving a perfect view up my left nostril. There should be two cameras. This is so obvious. - File system stuff is still a pain point despite the recent advances in the Files app and in multitasking. The odd time when I want to have several apps open and move several files around it really is painful and I usually give up and move to my iMac. Honestly I don't know what the solution is. Perhaps it's a case of "iPad isn't supposed to be used for that sort of thing". Or perhaps it's a case of re-jigging my workflow. Which is up to me of course. I could just get a M1 MacBook Air and call it a day, that would be OK, but I still prefer the overall experience of using the iPad. - Coding, of course. If I am on a fast connection to a local machine I can use Remote Desktop, which is sort of cheating, it's just using a desktop Mac, sub-optimally. I can use an ssh client and access a remote machine using a text only interface, which works for some coding purposes, but not interactive graphics. My instinct is this is a problem not to be solved for the iPad as it's just not supposed to be used for that. I'm OK with that.
- wowamit 6y agoHere's a theory, iPads and Macbooks would some day (not too far away, too) run the same operating system, not just operating systems with the same core. They would just be two form factors. The unification has already started with macOS Big Sur.
- matt-attack 6y agoBut Apple is clearly headed in the actual opposite direction when you looking at iPhones and iPads. So incredibly similar in terms of hardware (basically a few inches of screen is all that distinguishes them). Yet Apple chose to bifurcate what was once a common OS. Recall they both used to run iOS. Now we have iOS and iPadOS. If Apple can’t unify the operating system for iPads and iPhones, how could they do it for macs and iPads?
- wowamit 6y agoI think Apple clearly understood they can't keep iPhone and iPad running the same OS because that holds what iPads can achieve. And that was one of the reasons they had to separate those two platforms. I feel Apple would like to see iPads as lot closer to Macs in capabilities than iPhones.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rubyist5eva 6y agoTech-savvy people always seem to miss the mark - but as someone that struggled to get my tech illiterate parents to be productive on a personal computer...giving up and just getting them an iPad was a revelation. It's not a difficult proposition: 1. iPad for consumption 2. Mac for production It's really that simple - though the ipad pro kinda blurs that line a little bit - but it's mostly for those creative types that want the "drawing experience" which the mac does not provide, mostly as a response to the Surface line of products. I can see where a graphic designer would have a Mac for "day to day" stuff and then jump to their ipad pro to do their "work drawing". Maybe having the files synced in iCloud so that they can do the final touch-ups on the Mac. Some might just buy the USB tablet or whatever and that's fine for some, but I would think the majority prefer the draw-on-the-screen feel and experience. iPad excels at that, so it makes sense to have the "pro" version with the extra horsepower for that niche market and a premium.
- kenshi 6y agoThe thing that's "holding back" the iPad isn't hardware. It's the economics of the App store. I'm sure Apple are very happy with the niche the iPad dominates in - it leaves plenty of room for Mac laptop sales.
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoI'd kill for an iPad that runs macOS. But using an iOS device as a main computer? It's a hard sell given you are only allowed to use App Store apps. So much software I want to use (e.g. most free software apps, the Steam back-catalogue, many older Windows apps) is not available on iOS and never will be. Also, of course, you aren't allowed to do software development on an iOS device. Maybe the new generation that's only known life inside the walled garden will be able to live within its constraints, even if they'll be impoverished in some ways. I think that's what Apple's counting on. I hope they don't succeed.
- crazygringo 6y ago> There’s no question that Apple has struggled to craft a cohesive, compelling narrative for the iPad... We know what it’s good for, and we can easily imagine what it could be good for, if only Apple would set it free. I'm so utterly baffled by this sentiment. What is not already cohesive and compelling about the iPad? What does Apple need to "set free"? This sounds like it's supposed to be huge and inspiring, but then the author's wishlist is mundane stuff like "another port", "landscape first", "position widgets anywhere". Huh? The iPad is already an amazing, cohesive, compelling machine. I use it daily for things like researching and annotating PDF's, playing games, recording professional-quality video, watching movies, doing shopping, videoconferencing, taking notes, etc. > It’s simple: people love their iPads. They love them so much they wish they could do even more with them... it’s time for the iPad to reassert itself—to remind us once again who it’s for, and what makes it special. Huh? The iPad doesn't need to "reaassert itself", it's doing fine. I guess the author mainly wants to run Final Cut on their iPad...? Which makes no sense to me because the screen honestly isn't large enough for an effective video editing interface. Weird article.
- lostlogin 6y agoThis had me scratching my head: > Introduce Gatekeeper and app notarization for iOS. The process of side-loading apps should not be as simple as downloading them from the App Store What does this mean? Side-loading by definition means not using the AppStore. Is it a poorly phrased version of ‘side-loading should be possible but should have hurdles to protect the unwary’?
- czzr 6y agoYes
- fsflover 6y ago> What does Apple need to "set free"? Perhaps this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25215060 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25215060.
- fassssst 6y agoI’m done with iPads and will move back to MacBooks. The software just isn’t there... I was just trying to use the Lightroom healing brush over a large area on a RAW photo and the app started rendering at like one frame every three seconds. Any my camera doesn’t show up reliably for imports when connected via USB-C. They’re great for reading and watching shows and drawing but I don’t see how the software for real work will ever catch up. I think we’ll just start seeing Macs in new form factors with touch screens and Pencil support instead.
- trianglem 6y agoThis article was naive and amateurish. Set the iPad free, really?
- dredmorbius 6y agoTablets --- and not just Apple's --- suffer from numerous arbitrarily-imposed limitations, as well as hardware standardisation issues, which cripple funtionality far beyond any fundamental hardware limitations. I've seen this for years on Android (this comment, as with most of mine, is being pecked out slowly on an Android device's highly error-prone soft keyboard, the folio-style bluetooth keyboard having long-since failed and no replacement being available). Tablets are a win for battery life, form factor, and the ability to seamlessly reorient (portrait, landscape, inverted of either). They're far superior to laptops for reading textual matter --- laptops largely don't transition from landscape to portrait, or do so cumbersomely or with fragile mechanisms. In portrait mode, displays (especially 16:9 high-gloss) ar too short, to low-resolution, and to reflective, to be attractive reading devices. But OS, available applications, arbitrary app crashing or closing, total available storage (Apple's recent offerings an exception), storage access limitations, finicky inputs, and application sandboxing (understandable from a security perspective, but an absolute pain in the ass from a usaability perspective) are everpresent pain points. The few tools which actually are generative are poor stepchildren, poorly supported, barely tolerated, anemic compared with their full-fleged bretheren, crippled by storage and permissions models, and under constant attack by the platfform owners. They still shine above all else on these devices. Termux is the only thing on Android which does not precisely suck. Ish on iPad seems a weaker cousin, but with vague promise. Both are needlessly crippled or outright blocked by Google and Apple. But even a modest set of shell tools, scripting languages, editors, remote-accesss tools (ssh, tmux), and package manageers (pip, cpan, npm, gem/rvm) convert a BDSM consumption-only device into stunningly useful generative kit. One place Apple have made progress is in standardising enough device physical specs to enable a viable hardware accessory market for keyboards, though most of those keyboards remain crippled by missing critical keys and nonstandard layouts. One begins to suspect deliberate sabotage. I have neither time not budget to evaluate and trial disappointment after disappointment. I am watching the introduction of full-grade Linux devices from Pine, Purism, and Remarkable with interest. (Remarkable, sadly, seems to be going down the same crippled-onboard-storage-capacity route.) I don't expect Google, Android, or their equally oppressive hardware partners (Samsung are utterly worthless) to serve this niche. It may be small, but it directly feeds the talent and mindshare pools on which they depend. Long-standing gripes: https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/lqgtwy_rhsfbdh5cdxb1rq https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/lqgtwy_rhsfbdh5cdxb1rq
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pritovido 6y ago> There’s no question that Apple has struggled to craft a cohesive, compelling narrative for the iPad... We know what it’s good for, and we can easily imagine what it could be good for, if only Apple would set it free. Of course there is question... The Ipad was a tremendous success for Apple. In fact, the M1 is possible because tablets in general and phones sell so much compared to normal computers that have made the price of those ARM semiconductors way lower than Intel's or AMD. It has not struggled in anything. When I wanted to know if making an Ipad app made sense economically for me I stayed an entire day on a big Apple store and they sold like 50 on a normal day. They sold like 3 or 4 macbooks. It looks geeks believe that companies are out there to satisfy them. But companies are there to sell products to as much people as possible.
- Majromax 6y ago> Of course there is question... The Ipad was a tremendous success for Apple. In fact, the M1 is possible because tablets in general and phones sell so much compared to normal computers that have made the price of those ARM semiconductors way lower than Intel's or AMD. From Apple's 2020Q3 financial results (https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/FY20-Q3_Consolidated_Financial_Statements.pdf https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/FY20-Q3_Consolidated_Fin...), the iPad is more or less their lowest-revenue product line (in competition with 'wearables and accessories'). It's the phones that put Apple in a position to make M1 silicon, and in fact that's probably the impetus for it -- the more restricted form factor has even tighter demands on power efficiency than the larger tablet/laptop/desktop formats.
- zepto 6y agoThe idea of programming on the iPad makes perfect sense. The idea of opening the iPad to make the programming experience more like a Mac, does not. (At least not from my read of Apple’s philosophy) What I expect is that Apple will eventually make something based on Playgrounds, but capable of producing apps that can be uploaded to the store. However it will be a closed loop system, Swift only. Obviously there will be the usual complaints about why this is bad from a control perspective, which are of course valid. I’m not here to argue that. What is good about this is that the constraints would force the development of a touch first programming environment. Don’t expect terminals or gatekeeper etc. This is the approach Apple has been taking with the iPad, and I see no reason they would change it now. The m1 Macs make it less likely that they will open the iPad, not more.
- myrandomcomment 6y agoI have an Air and an iPad Pro. What I want is it to be the same device, ie detachable screen that is the iPad, like a Surface from MS, but with Apple design language and macOS. Apple do that. Take my money and everyone else’s pretty quickly.
- asciimov 6y agoWhile all these things are nice, and certainly would get me to upgrade my current 6th gen iPad. But the thing that I would really like the most is a fixed memory manager. I have to reboot my iPad about once a week just so that safari will finish loading webpages and that the occasional apps I run stop crashing. In older iOS releases this was never a problem. And often the only time the device was rebooted was when an update required it.
- m3kw9 6y agoYou mean just add touch on the MacBook, MacOS and remove the keyboard. That would make more sense for your argument. iOS was designed for another type of user in mind. Don’t confuse iOS pros with MacOS pros
- yarcob 6y agoI really think Apple got it wrong with the iPad. They thought that iPads would replace computers for most people, but 10 years later it's clear that Apple's strict control over the iPad will never allow it to be as capable as a laptop. But the biggest mistake Apple made over the last ten years is that they have been holding the Mac back to differentiate it from the iPad. I would love to have always on 4G in my Macbook. I would love to have a touch screen and pen input on my Mac. I don't want to buy an iPad so I can draw on PDFs, I just want to do that on my Mac. Microsoft hit it out of the park with their Surface line. I think they made the right call, by understanding that people don't want app consoles. People want the power of a desktop, with all the great new tech from mobile devices, like touch screens and 4G. The Surface Studio is what the iMac should have been. It's weird to have graphic designers, once Apple's core audience, lusting after a Microsoft computer. Apple's reluctance to add touch screens to the Mac is really holding them back. Once you've used a surface device with a pen, you really start wondering why you can't draw on the screen of your Macbook. My guess is that Apple realized their mistake about a year ago, and they've started on getting iPhone/iPad tech back in to the Mac. They started with the processor, and the next step is adding touch displays and 4G / 5G to the Mac. Big Sur is obviously already optimized for touch, and I'm excited to see what the Mac will become if Apple allows it to compete with the iPad.
- sophiebits 6y agoThere is about zero chance that the processor architecture transition is not many years in the making.
- yarcob 6y agoSorry, I wasn't clear. I agree that the processor change was a long time coming. I'm speculating that they decided to also bring touch screens and 4G back to the Mac about a year ago, when they realised that adding multi-tasking to the iPad wasn't the panacea they hoped it would be.
- pdimitar 6y agoMy wife is lately extremely annoyed with her iPad Pro because she joined several Discord communities and wants to chat more with people -- on-screen keyboard is no good beyond a certain point. I bought her a nice backlit foldable Bluetooth keyboard and she loves it. When she heard about the M1 laptops from me, she wasn't very impressed, saying: 1. Well, MacBooks in general have been extremely powerful for a while, weren't they? 2. Will they come with the ability to put the keyboard facing down like the Lenovo Yoga tablets? While we here at HN may drool at every bit of performance without the fans sounding like a jet taking off, a lot of people just want some ergonomy. Sure, now there are 200 EUR detachable keyboards with a track pad but that's an insane price already. Still, it works for people like her who won't use their iPad Pros for work -- just to do a lot of other stuff on them. I for one would love to buy an ARM-based MacBook Pro with a keyboard that can be put in a face-down mode.
- zapzupnz 6y agoI'm surprised by the failure of imagination of HN readers. Nine times out of ten, HN readers are complaining about the limitations of the iPad; out of the woodwork come those who complain about those who complain. To my mind, Becky is not arguing that the iPad should become the next Mac. Nowhere in the article is that ever stated. Yet, that's the argument against which so many people are rallying. It is possible to wish for the iPad to do more whilst preserving what makes iPad … iPad. That's what the bulleted list contains: ideas for allowing a little more complexity whilst preserving simplicity. There are so many more things the iPad can do that expand on its current capabilities without compromising on the iPad experience — don't let your failure of imagination, your sense of "I like using my iPad this way, so everybody else must too" get in the way of dreaming up new experiences for the world's best-selling tablet and digital stylus. The iPad has already proven itself a wonderful balance of power and simplicity. Imagine what it could do when just a tiny bit more power is unlocked. Not just for pros, developers. For creative types. For school students. For people with disabilities and other special needs.
- aborsy 6y agoI was thinking of getting an iPad and pencil for remote teaching (writing on a board). Wacom tablet pads work fine for this use case as well, and are much cheaper. aBut that’s going to be useful only for the duration of the pandemic. Another use case is drawing diagrams and flowcharts for presentations. I have no time to watch TV or Netflix, neither I am into “creative work” so to speak. If it doesn’t have a proper Linux terminal and input interface, it doesn’t work well for me. Any idea if it’s worth it?