12 ms·
New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikable, contemptible
- Tycho 6y agoAccording to the article, this phenomenon is most obviously manifested in the humorous expression “own the libs”, and not, say, by shrieking scaremongering about fascism and comparing the other side to the Nazis.
- hartator 6y agoDo you mean this article about political polarization is polarized against one side? :)
- whodidntante 6y agoWell, I know you are being sarcastic, but my initial impression of the article was that while I agreed with everything the author stated, I felt the author was no where as subtle as she thought she was in herself promoting this polarization by what was left out. All of the examples were one sided (and imo true, with many worse ones left unmentioned), while there was no mention of the elephant - the world view that all members of a certain race are racist by definition, and that all interactions between races are, by definition, based on race, no matter what the context. How is this not demonizing the "other" ? My fear is that what used to be disagreements over what rights an individual has (who to marry, what to do in your personal space, what if any deities to bow before, what you are able to do with your own body) have turned into disagreements over what framework we should use to govern our society. Individual rights, imo, need to be respected, and can be done without infringing on anyone else. However, the current undercurrent of how we should govern ourselves as a society (marxism vs capitalism) is something that we all, as a society, need to abide by, and that differences in these views, historically, has been settled through war.
- toiletfuneral 6y ago“Forced hysterectomies to own the libs”
- Waterluvian 6y agoThe interesting thing is that the claims about fascism at least have the possibility of being true while "owning the libs" betrays its own disingenuous purpose of not even trying to make a point other than winning against the other team.
- Tycho 6y ago“own the libs” is satire, it’s not literally the political platform
- Waterluvian 6y agoNot exactly a useful claim given it can be made by anyone for any portion of their "team" they're embeeassed by. The core problem is that America uses a two party system and that can only result in heavy partisanship.
- Tycho 6y agoOne side has prominent interlocutors who routinely call the other side racists, Nazis, and harbingers of fascism in the United States, demanding their “de-platforming”. The other side sees this as hysterical nonsense spouted by sanctimonious hypocrites and people blind to reality, who deserve to be mocked, hence “own the libs.” These two sides are not equivalent. One is doing a lot more “othering”. The real equivalent would be some sort of Red Scare accusing the other side of being infiltrated by freedom-hating communist spies, demanding their removal from all institutions and positions of power.
- dsr_ 6y agoThere are concentration camps run by the United States government.
- dsr_ 6y agoIf you're downvoting this, you had better have proof that there are no concentration camps run by the United States government. Please show it to us. Otherwise, I accept your downvote as proof that facts are not relevant to you.
- dTal 6y agoWell yes, there's a wide gulf between voicing concerns about conduct and rhetoric, and being combative simply for the joy of watching your opponent suffer.
- empthought 6y agoOne side has literal Nazis marching for it, yelling “Jews will not replace us,” though...
- mnd999 6y agoI think most people on both “sides” find that unacceptable.
- empthought 6y agoThey do not. Only one American political party needs white supremacist votes in order to be elected. Only one.
- bsenftner 6y agoThan why have the GOP not not denounced them? Their silence is approval of the Nazis.
- knaq 6y agoIt's time for a fact check: https://finepeople.org/ https://finepeople.org/ The short video at the bottom of the page is particularly interesting.
- aetimmes 6y agoBut (at least in the US) the leader of one side doesn't - not enough to condemn it.
- yaakov34 6y agoAnd the other side attacked actual Jews with rocks and bottles recently. What, that's not "your side"? Neither are those guys "their side".
- ulucs 6y agoWhat happened? Antifa?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 6y agoTalk to people from the other party. But not about politics.
- matwood 6y agoIt's hard because so much has become politicized. The dominant item in many people's lives right now is the coronavirus either directly or indirectly, which unfortunately has also become political.
- zo1 6y agoI agree, we are all human after all. But that's becoming more and more difficult. The divide between the left and the right is no longer revolving around ideology, politics, regulation, laws, etc. It's now become a matter of "life and death", "racism" and "violence" for a large chunk of the Left (and to some extent more and more from the Right too if I'm being honest). The slogans that are emerging are being sponged by the individuals on the ground, and that is starting to make reasonable non-political discussion next to impossible. I.e. You can no longer mention in-passing that you support certain parties/politicians/political-beliefs.
- matwood 6y agoWhat I see anecdotally is that the left has become more inclusive, and the right as become more extreme. People have fled the right either to no party or to the center left. That leaves behind the extremes on the right which have become emboldened by Trump and their shrinking bubble. It's like evaporating water out of a glass of salt water. The water left behind becomes more and more salty. If you have ever had a salt water aquarium you'll know that you don't add salt water back to the tank, but fresh water in order to balance out the evaporation. You mention racism. The same people may have been racist before, but now they are ok yelling it out loud because the only people left in their bubble think the same way (Trump may or may not be racist, but he certainly stokes this fire). And this is why it's difficult, because if someone tells me they do not want black people living in their neighborhood, I'm going to tell them that's a racist statement.
- 6y ago
- oneplane 6y agoIronically, a lot of the world has seen the USA do this to everyone else for a while too. Too a lesser degree to their anglophone friends of course but the rest of the world is alien and unlikable all the same (with just as little arguments as you see in the political divide). I suppose one could argue that the isolationism/tribalism has simply expanded inwards as 'the rest of the world' has already been put in the 'other people/cultures' box and only internal boxing up of each other remains.
- the-dude 6y agoI doubt the phenomenon has anything to do with the US in the ROW. Here in NL, a NATO member, it has been primarily the 'left' which has been painting groups with different opinions as 'nazis' 'fascists' etc. Vegans describing other people as murderers. I blame this culture for our last political murder [0] which already happened in 2002. This phenomenon is not new, I think it has to do with the dissolution of the USSR and with it, the ultimate defeat of the original ideals of the 'left'. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pim_Fortuyn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pim_Fortuyn
- throwaway3699 6y agoThe left (at least, the internet left) do this here in the UK too. Twitter seems to think all Tory voters are rich white men who want the poor to suffer. Now I don't know if I'm in a bubble, because when I leave the internet and talk to actual lefties in person we always find a common ground. Hell, I have a friend group containing both anarcho communists and globalist one-world government types.
- the-dude 6y agoHave you seen the article posted here this week which claimed the main narrative on Twitter was only originating from about 6 people? For a long time now, the social media have been embraced by 'progressives'. I see them destroying themselves. Trump's 'surprise' election in 2016 fits in this : people don't voice their moderate opinion anymore, they vote however they want though.
- swiley 6y agoDelete your twitter/facebook/reddit account. Seriously! Go do it now! These sites are built with the goal of pushing people into groups that are always angry at each other. Angry polarized groups spend more time on the site and are easier to sell things to. The only thing ignoring this trash will do is make you a happier, more functional person.
- zo1 6y agoOn some level yes. But the unfortunate side is that it's seeping into the overall culture and previously-benign and relatively apolitical institutions. That makes it dangerous to "ignore" and hope it goes away due to us all deciding to be reasonable and ignore the hateful and prominent voices that use social-media as a megaphone. Some institutions being actively soaked in identity politics and other divisive elements: Higher education Lower Education United Nations Local government bodies Charity Organizations Sports
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway3699 6y agoI do agree with you and I want the constant crawl of IdPol stop, but I can't help but feel this is part of the polarization aspect. The internet is causing the growth of IdPol as well as the growth of the movement against it.
- swiley 6y agoIMO: it's not "the internet." At least, not to the same degree. It's the huge platforms with their own ad networks that are driving it.
- ForHackernews 6y agohttps://areomagazine.com/2020/10/27/why-fourteen-critics-of-social-justice-think-you-shouldnt-vote-for-trump/ https://areomagazine.com/2020/10/27/why-fourteen-critics-of-... IMHO, we need a return to "boring" centrist politics.
- zackkatz 6y agoMy wife wrote a paper about this phenomenon. This happens in specific policy contexts as well as generally. In political science, the phenomenon is called the “devil shift”, coined by Sabatier. Similarly, there is also the “angel shift”: you see people who agree with you as having more virtuous motivations. My wife, Dr. Juniper Katz, wrote about these shifts in the fracking context: https://www.academia.edu/37275520/The_Space_Between_Demonization_of_Opponents_and_Policy_Divergence https://www.academia.edu/37275520/The_Space_Between_Demoniza...
- ache7 6y agoIt is very sad that the authors of the article either believed in all these accusations against the Russians or are afraid to say that this is nonsense so that they are not accused of supporting the Russians. I want to note that the Russian government also accuses its political opponents of being foreign agents, using the same rhetoric.
- matwood 6y agoIt's well known that Russian trolls/bots use fake personas on social media in order to sow discord. Are you arguing that's not done at all, or that there is no evidence it's done in the article specific instance? Here's an article examining how it's done in relation to anti-vaxx. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6137759/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6137759/
- bsenftner 6y agoDon't all governments to this to any other democratic government? This practice is as old as democracy itself.
- ForHackernews 6y agoSince when is Russia a democracy? But yes, foreign propaganda has existed for a long time.
- bsenftner 6y agoNo, all democratic governments receive foreign propaganda from other governments, regardless of the others being democratic or not.
- matwood 6y agoThe OP was specifically arguing the Russians are innocent, which I think has been been shown they are not. If you want to expand the conversation into generally how world governments use disinformation to their advantage, go for it.
- mnd999 6y agoPeoples willingness to line up behind banners, flags and slogans without bothering to look at what those politicians are actually selling baffles me. I think if people from both sides were willing to ignore that and just sit down and talk about what kind of county they want to live in they would find they have a lot more in common than they think. I think this is what the article is proposing, and I think I agree with it.
- II2II 6y agoAre people willing to line up, or are they being pressured to line up? In many cases, a person's principles are clear from what they say and do. That being said, a refusal to align one's self with a movement is often construed as supporting the other side. There are many reasons for refusing to align: a preference for independent thought, a realization that ideological movements change, an understanding that one's own principles shift (while labels often stick), or simply not buying into some fundamental points. None of that seems to matter when issues are polarized.
- BurningFrog 6y agoWe are an inherently tribal species. It's in our DNA.
- konjin 6y agoI think I'm starting to realize why sport was pushed so hard until the 00s. It is complete nonsense that you can get your tribalism out on without impacting any part of your life. Imagine how much better the world would be if people checked game scores instead of tweets.
- throwaway13337 6y agoPolitics and sports are often linked. From chariot races to football clubs, real politic change happens through sports. Here's an account of the famous chariot race riot in ancient Constantinople: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nika_riots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nika_riots Humans will make an identity group worth dying for over anything.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- the__alchemist 6y agoThe article goes into specifics, but the general premise is as old as humanity. The subtitle: "The new political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikable and morally contemptible" This is tribalism at its core. It's baked into us for evolutionary reasons that helped us survive, but is now a detriment.
- throwaway13337 6y agoYes, the problem is obviously media and social media stoking up tribalism and rage. No, the problem will not solve itself by simply telling the public to think more critically. These media and social media companies are incentivized by engagement metrics - which becomes money through ads - to destroy society via enraging their user against one another. The algorithms that measure engagement and then feed it are the tools of our destruction. This is not intentional on their behalf but an emergent result of what they've optimize for. It's something that seems to be happening throughout the west - not just America. This monster is probably our biggest existential threat today. The question is how do we stop it?
- lazyjones 6y agoThis is just an escalation of the "groupthink" pervasive throughout the more progressive circles. Every 100 years or so it seems to explode into a full civil unrest/conflict or war. IMHO it indicates that we, as a species, are built/evolved to exist in small tribes and cannot cope with large societies or crowds.
- beervirus 6y ago“Deplorable.”
- plaidfuji 6y ago> A 2018 study had people who were partisan get exposed to some information on the other side. So if you’re Republican, you get to see what Hillary Clinton is saying, or if you’re a Democrat, you’re exposed to what Donald Trump is saying. And that actually made it worse. The messenger matters just as much as the message. People on both sides carry strong Bayesian priors associated with Trump and Clinton, as well as with most major news outlets now, so they’re predisposed to assume words coming from messengers of “the other side” are inherently untrustable or malicious. A more interesting study would be to expose partisans to identical content (an argument for something wonky, like trade policy or entitlement reform) through venues that otherwise look like their ideological stomping grounds, and watch how quickly people from both sides would agree. Another part of the problem is that many of the current polarizing topics (gun control and abortion come to mind) are rooted in fundamental moral differences that don’t allow for rational discussion of the middle ground. Either the government can take guns away or it can’t. Either people can terminate a pregnancy or they can’t. Slippery slope arguments dominate these conversations and make people afraid to give any ground. This is actually why I see promise for an AI tool like GPT-3 (or -6 or -7, more like) in politics. Prompt it with content from both sides and see how it answers debate questions. Maybe it would just learn how to give political non-answers. Maybe it would just lead to the politicization of AI, which currently enjoys healthy distrust from both sides. Or maybe people find that they’re more comfortable trusting a machine than a human from the other side.
- at_a_remove 6y agoI searched the article and was unable to find the phrase "basket of deplorables." That's puzzling, because it's a really stellar instance of the very action the article discusses. Certainly, you can get a very wound-up contingent of people anywhere who will work themselves into hysterics, call people murderers and Nazis (and then of course jump to how moral it is to punch them), but it's rather different seeing a statesperson succumb to that kind of thing was a little startling. The article missed an opportunity there.
- vehemenz 6y agoPolarization means the increased tendency to see the worst of the “other side.” But how can we honestly talk about the assymetry of today’s polarization without the analysis being accused of being political? After all, “Nazis are bad” is hardly a poltical statement.
- pibechorro 6y agoBy design. Illusion of choice. Divide and conquer.
- markvdb 6y agoFor some fresh breath and broader perspective, much of post war western Europe was extremely polarised between religious and non-religiuous (liberals, but especially socialists). You may want to watch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Camillo_and_Peppone#Films https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Camillo_and_Peppone#Films as an accessible example, but everyone from Western Europe speaking to people who were adults between 1940 and 1960 will dig up countless stories. Here's some of mine: - Near where I work, there's a tiny village. Until recently, there were two competing music bands: the "mice" and the "rats". One group was socialists, the others catholics. By 2010, both were largely composed of octogenarians and dying. But don't think they'd ever play one note together! - After WWII, my grandfather, being very poor and having been in the resistance, had a right to financial assistance. He never claimed it because his wife was catholic and the resistance group he participated in was socialist. Claiming his benefits would have been social suicide. - My mother's aunt was a catholic nun, and one of the nicest and most welcoming people, widely respectd by all in the village were she lived. Once, she went to the funeral of a local farmer, a socialist. Her going to that funeral was quite out of the ordinary already, to put it mildly. On her return, she said: "He was a socialist, but a very good and decent man."
- meekmind 6y agoDisengaging from social media or encouraging others to disengage on it's face appears to be the well-meaning advice of someone genuinely concerned with their own mental health and the mental health of others. For many this is precisely the correct course of action. But, the vocal minority and ideologues aren't going to disengage. If all those who recognize illusion refuse to retain territory in the cultural and political dialog then the social media landscape would only be populated by the uninitiated and those who seek to initiate them into echo chambers. Those who have discernment enough to be frustrated by the hypocrisies and bias on social media are precisely the people who can de-escalate and bring more balance, reason and rationality to it. The problem is then that the moderate voices are drowned out, censored, or out-right abused off the platforms (if not by actual people, but by droves of carefully coordinated bots). That leads to a larger discussion of the role of these platforms in societal discourse (or as the town square) and their woefully inadequate protections of free speech and privacy.
- civilized 6y agoHeadline: we're so polarized! How awful wrings hands Body: Republicans are bad Republicans are bad Republicans are bad Republicans are bad Republicans are bad Republicans are bad I don't even have a problem with a certain amount of contempt for Republicans, or at least their politicians. It's just, if you pretend to be concerned about polarization in the abstract, you might try harder to pretend to be concerned about the ways in which both sides contribute to it. If you only know about the specific ways in which conservatives or Republicans are bad, or "more bad", you're unable to overcome your partisanship in a search for the whole truth. If you want to learn about how the left contributes to polarization, you can start by having a look at Matt Taibbi's or Jesse Singal's Substack.
- scrollaway 6y agoThe word "republican" appears 6 times in the article. The word "democrat" 10.
- civilized 6y agoDid you read the article, or just count the word mentions?
- scrollaway 6y agoBoth, but maybe unlike you I didn't get stuck only on the parts that criticized republicans.
- civilized 6y agoIf you actually read the article, why would you choose an irrelevant metric that is basically uncorrelated with the actual content of the article to prove your point?
- scrollaway 6y agoVery easy way to disprove your frankly very low effort post. You have since edited it to be a bit more substantive but when I replied it was reddit grade.
- chaganated 6y agoThis is a sociology op-ed by a journalist for an ideologically-charged stats rag (538) being published in a science magazine. I would appreciate it if tree people would stick to their trees, and stop (erroneously) extrapolating every minuscule change in the sap into a chicken-little prognostication for the entire forest. I like liberals, I like conservatives, but one type I cannot abide are these preening, midwit, overcredentialed, underperforming, doomsayers. It will all be just fine.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- specialist 6y agoEditorial references this OC: Political Sectarianism: A Dangerous Cocktail of Othering, Aversion, and Moralization http://www.dartmouth.edu/~nyhan/political-sectarianism.pdf http://www.dartmouth.edu/~nyhan/political-sectarianism.pdf Same topic, list of authors match, recently published, near match on title. I'm pretty sure this is the paper referenced. For the love of the FSM, why can't people use links? Skim reading this paper, it appears complimentary to other reports. Will read in full shortly. -- Polarization isn't just one thing. It's the result of everything mushed together. Ezra Klein's Why We Are Polarized is a terrific summary, synthesis of the research. Connects so many dots. Physical sorting (urbanization) promotes polarization, faceted identities are now super identities, nationalization of media begat the nationalization of our politics, the massive political reorg fallout from LBJ's Great Society ending the Dixiecrat's strangle hold on southern states (aka Nixon's Southern Strategy), and many more. https://www.amazon.com/Why-Were-Polarized-Ezra-Klein/dp/147670032X https://www.amazon.com/Why-Were-Polarized-Ezra-Klein/dp/1476... -- Klein doesn't much touch on social media in this book. Some of his podcasts episodes are relevant. Two underreported factoids popped out for me, First, how the landscape changed from blogging to social media. Second is the elephant in the room about the algorithms and how most critics are guilty of conflating speech with signal boosting. (I have my own thoughts about social media, shared piecemeal thru my comment history. No thesis or narrative yet, sorry.) Whatever the evil of social media today, eliminating it outright (not gonna happen) would only mitigate some of the toxicity and definitely won't unwind polarization.
- TMWNN 6y agoPut on a "Make America Great Again" hat and walk through downtown Chicago, San Francisco, Ann Arbor, or Cambridge before or after election day 2016 (or 2020). Now, put on a "I'm With Her" or "Biden/Harris 2020" shirt and walk through Provo, Fort Worth, or Pensacola before or after election day. In which scenario are you more like to be yelled at and/or physically attacked?