21 ms·
A Little Money Laundering Can Have a Big Impact on Real Estate Prices (2019)
- zeveb 6y ago> The whole time, Boomers are stoking the coals on this fire, explaining this is “earned equity.” If you want your own, you need to work as hard as they did. Standing by as each irrational player enters the market is exhausting work. Boomers also had to save uphill for a down payment… both ways, in the snow or something. Why the needless dig at Baby Boomers? I am not one (and normally as ready to enjoy a dig at them as the next guy), it just felt … off. I can't blame someone who thinks his asset is worth something and who has made decisions based on that belief wanting to preserve that perception!
- naveen99 6y agoI don’t know real estate value is a lot bigger than global tax collection.
- raverbashing 6y ago(Might be anecdotal or even have changed, but it is worth telling this story) I once remember seeing a video where people described the steps needed to buy a property in Canada, obtain a mortgage, etc Some banks allowed college students to get a mortgage (wink), and depending on the country, there were different KYC/AML regulations that had to be followed. Notably, China was not in the list of countries with additional KYC requirements (double wink) Interpret this as you want.
- kareemm 6y agoThe classic example of this is a $31m house owned by a UBC student in Vancouver: https://torontosun.com/2016/05/12/311-million-vancouver-mansion-owned-by-student https://torontosun.com/2016/05/12/311-million-vancouver-mans...
- Cancan82 6y agoThis is insane - feels like something fishy going on... I wonder if business people in China use students and pay them a fee of some sorts to facilitate getting around KYC requirements etc?: “Land title documents list Tian Yu Zhou as having a 99-per-cent interest in the five-bedroom, eight-bathroom, 14,600 square-foot mansion on a 1.7-acre lot at 4833 Belmont Ave. Zhou’s occupation is listed as a “student.” The other owner of the property, which boasts sweeping views of the North Shore mountains and Vancouver, is listed as Cuie Feng, a “businesswoman.””
- gen220 6y agoI’ve been told similar stories by real estate brokers in NYC. Students in university cold calling brokers, looking to buy the “most expensive condo” in an agent’s book, sight unseen, and willing to pay in cash or wire transfer. As a broker, it must be very hard to ignore those incentives. The commission on just one of those sales must be incredible.
- valuearb 6y agoAnecdotal fairy tales are the best fairy tales.
- buzzerbetrayed 6y agoThis is now the 4th comment of yours I've come across in this thread, all offering no evidence of what you claim. Rather than just repeating "you're wrong" over and over again, you'll get a lot farther by clearly explaining why the article is wrong, once.
- valuearb 6y agoStraw buyers exist, not denying it. Straw buyers who are entirely price insensitive may exist, but are so rare as to be unicorns. If you are actually “laundering” money, ie from a crime other than fleeing oppression, the cost of laundering matters. Buying a $1M condo for $2M costs you a 50% of your ill gotten gains, and there is still risk of seizure. At those costs there are far cheaper routes for laundering your money. So what’s occasionally happening is that Chinese trying to escape the control of the PRC dictatorship send money to a trusted expatriate, sometimes a student, and tell them to pay up to $X for a property at market prices. Naturally this can lead to paying slightly over market because the proxy isn’t motivated to negotiate, or often equipped to. If I price my home at $1M when it’s worth $950k, they’ll pay the $1M. But they aren’t offering me $1.4M. And it’s questionable what the specific market price really is at any moment. My friend recently bought a home for $605k that was listed at $599k. He got an early preview the day before it’s initial open house. That night He made a full cash offer at $6k over ask that expired the moment the open house started. The buyer accepted 15 minutes before expiration. Did he overpay? The buyers received over a half dozen backup offers during the open house, some as high as $30k over ask.
- eisbaar 6y agoI'm sorry, but does that article offer ANY evidence at all for the impact of money laundering, except for the "just so" story in the middle? ("money launderers beat up prices, and the rest of the market just runs with it" - as if people were able or willing to pay arbitrary prices).
- Ensorceled 6y agoYeah, the article just assumes that a) money laundering via real estate is happening, b) it is increasing prices and then c) is trying to explain the logic behind it. But the title is misleading because the never actually establishes a) and b) ... it just meanders around in c)
- itsoktocry 6y ago>Yeah, the article just assumes that a) money laundering via real estate is happening Sort of like how people are walking into BC casinos with half a million dollars in $20 bills and authorities are being told not to ask questions? Yeah, we don't "know" there's money laundering, but reasonable people ask questions... https://www.msn.com/en-ca/news/canada/rcmp-detachment-head-warned-e2-80-98the-monster-is-growing-e2-80-99-when-bc-casino-opened-in-2004-inquiry-hears/ar-BB1asaS1 https://www.msn.com/en-ca/news/canada/rcmp-detachment-head-w... https://www.msn.com/en-ca/news/canada/virtually-no-controls-over-money-laundering-in-bc-casinos-commission-told/vi-BB1auxTA https://www.msn.com/en-ca/news/canada/virtually-no-controls-...
- Ensorceled 6y agoOh, I'm very, very sure money laundering is happening in BC. I'm certain money laundering via real estate is happening all over Canada; Chinese investors are buying abandoned farm land in Northern Ontario for some reason.
- itsoktocry 6y agoI agree, and frankly I understand why Chinese people want to get here. It's a great place! But we can't have vast sums of capital, of unknown origin, flooding our country and pricing out our own citizens.
- swiley 6y agoMaybe it's time we admit that without a thorough reform, the idea of a "housing market" is completely fictional. Furthermore, at least with the way our current laws are written, we prefer having a large homeless population because it maintains the wealth of some group of people.
- epistasis 6y agoWhat is fictional about the market? It seems to be behaving exactly like any and all other markets, with exactly the same tricks for exploiting them. It's really just textbook!
- simonh 6y agoIt's a real market, it's just heavily supply constrained. Conventional market theory assumes that supply will rise to meet demand, but between green belt laws, NIMBY movements and the difficulty of crating new land where people want to live, that's often a big problem in property markets. There's also the fact that we all need somewhere to live, and once we have a family we'll devote a very large fraction of our resources to get the best place to bring up our children in. So we have a limited resource we all (many of us) want. The result is people, us, compete with each other to bid up the price. We do it to each other. Yes there's definitely an impact from buy-to-let purchasers bidding up prices. Here in the UK the government recently revised property taxes to make it less advantageous to own and rent out property, which is a good start. How do homeless people maintain wealthy people?
- bsanr2 6y ago>It's a real market, it's just heavily supply constrained. >Conventional market theory assumes that supply will rise to meet demand, but between green belt laws, NIMBY movements and the difficulty of crating new land where people want to live, that's often a big problem in property markets. So... It's not a real market. Would we call a situation, wherein rice is $100/bag because local oligarchs have taken the bulk of imports/production and sequestered it in some private warehouse, a "real market"? Because that's essentially what's happening here. >How do homeless people maintain wealthy people? If your labor produces wealth that someone else claims, forcing you to become unhoused, your homelessness is intrinsically connected to their affluence.
- huhtenberg 6y agoVancouver is an extra special case because of all the Chinese/HK money parked there. A planeful of middle-aged Asian gentlemen in suits would land in the morning, take a private bus tour around open properties, pay the asking, board the plane and leave. Developers were literally building high-rises to give foreign "investors" something valuable to buy. This all but priced every normal family the fuck out of the market. It was completely insanely bananas. Not "a little money laundering" by any measure. Lovely city though, beautiful nature, excellent restaurants.
- CountSessine 6y agoDevelopers were literally building high-rises to give foreign "investors" something valuable to buy. ...and yet with all of this development, the rental vacancy rate still hovers around 0... ...and it’s not like we have a huge number of empty homes because we have 2 layers of empty home taxes at this point and we’ve precisely quantified how many there are (~6000 private residences out of a total of ~900000 in the metro area) and there aren’t that many... ...and the population keeps exploding at 2%/year... ...and most of the residential land in the metro area is still restrictively zoned for only single family homes. I don’t think that we need money-laundering to explain the crazy real estate market here. We just need plain-old NIMBYism, break-neck population growth, and historically-low interest rates.
- Kalium 6y agoPeople like having one factor to blame. It means they can avoid all the cognitive overhead of engaging with a complex reality. It means never having to evaluate if policies you support and goals you desire might be at odds. When everything is the fault of those foreigners, a truly remarkable amount of cognitive work just doesn't have to happen.
- mistermann 6y agoSimilarly, the same often goes for classification of people as racist without the burden of evidence or thinking.
- 6y ago
- kareemm 6y agoI lived in Vancouver from 2009-2018 and saw the insane price appreciation from money laundering. The main question people asked about the appreciation was: "is appreciation really being driven up by foreign buyers". Many came to the answer "no", because foreign home ownership was "only" in the 5-10% range depending on the neighbourhood. This article lays out the case why foreign ownership % isn't the right thing to be looking at: 1. The goal of a money launderer is to launder as much as possible 2. The goal of a home seller is to sell for as much as possible 3. If the asset being purchased is a home, incentives between buyer and seller are aligned and prices are higher than the non-laundering market would support (esp if there's another launderer who's interested). 4. Since the market for home prices is based on comps, a few launderers can raise market prices substantially 5. Lather, rinse, repeat The foreigner question was the wrong one to ask, though certainly a large part of the market was driven by foreign investment. The right question to ask -- and the problem to guard against -- was: "what's the impact of laundered money on the market". BC added the foreign buyer's tax of 15% in 2016[1]. But beneficial ownership laws come into effect on November 30 of this year[2]. The former created a slight disincentive for foreigners laundering $$ to buy. But turns out what was really needed to slow the tide of illegal money flowing into housing was more transparency and disclosure rules. [1] - https://financialpost.com/personal-finance/mortgages-real-estate/b-c-to-bring-in-additional-15-per-cent-real-estate-tax-on-foreign-buyers-in-vancouver-in-effort-to-rein-in-high-home-prices https://financialpost.com/personal-finance/mortgages-real-es... [2] - https://www.mondaq.com/canada/real-estate/988830/bc-real-estate-beneficial-ownership-disclosure-law-takes-effect-november-30-2020 https://www.mondaq.com/canada/real-estate/988830/bc-real-est...
- itsoktocry 6y ago>Many came to the answer "no", because foreign home ownership was in the 5-10% range depending on the neighbourhood. How many foreigners are able to obfuscate "true" ownership is also a huge question.
- Cancan82 6y agohttps://torontosun.com/2016/05/12/311-million-vancouver-mansion-owned-by-student https://torontosun.com/2016/05/12/311-million-vancouver-mans... This was linked further down... a student owns 99% of a $31mm property. A Chinese business person owns the other 1%. That sounds like trying to get around KYC / AML requirements and obfuscating things to me...
- aNoob7000 6y agoI'd be more interested in hearing about how people trying to move money out of governments and areas affects local real estate prices. I think Canada has more of a problem with wealthy Chinese trying to park their money outside of China than money laundering.
- cool_dude85 6y agoAs mentioned in the article, evading capital controls is money laundering.
- valuearb 6y agoLet’s not conflate fleeing an oppressive regime with actual crimes.
- mtnGoat 6y agoCrime is crime, let's not excuse it. You follow the laws of the country you are in regardless of circumstances in your past, coming from oppressive regime isn't a free ticket.
- valuearb 6y agoWhat Canadian laws are being violated?
- seemack 6y agoLaundering proceeds of crime - https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/section-462.31.html https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/section-462.31...
- valuearb 6y agoFrom your link: “(a) the commission in Canada of a designated offence; or (b) an act or omission anywhere that, if it had occurred in Canada, would have constituted a designated offence.” I wasn’t aware Canada had a $50,000 limit on moving funds from China.
- Cancan82 6y agoWow this is something I was thinking about... then the money launderer turns around and sells the house they just bought “for quick close” and that sets another precedent in the market... and so the process repeats. “All of a sudden, a money launderer shows up, and offers the owner 10% over ask for a “quick close.” You’re not too worried, your agent told you the place a few doors down is going to be on the market next week. Unfortunately, the new place now uses the home owned by the money launder as a comp. Now the ask is 10% more than you were expecting, because the marginal buyer set the price down the street. Someone else bites, and buys it before it “goes too high.” Now the money launderer’s buy was just validated in the system.”
- TYPE_FASTER 6y agoRelevant: https://newrepublic.com/article/143586/trumps-russian-laundromat-trump-tower-luxury-high-rises-dirty-money-international-crime-syndicate https://newrepublic.com/article/143586/trumps-russian-laundr...
- throw0101a 6y agoSeems that Canada is also more generally known for money laundering internationally, to the point that there is a specific verb for it: > Snow washing refers to hiding illegitimate financial transactions often for purposes of tax evasion in Canada.[1] The term is an amalgam of the words snow meaning purity as well as the cold Canadian climate and washing referring to money laundering. It is easy under Canadian law to set up a company, even for a fee as low as $200 (Canadian), while shielding the identities of the firm's real owners from the eyes of tax authorities.[2] The global elite, as well as criminals and foreigners avoiding economic sanctions, can set up shell companies to "make suspect transactions seem legitimate" under the cover of Canada's reputation for fiscal integrity.[1] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snow_washing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snow_washing
- sandworm101 6y ago>> Properly laundered money should be extremely difficult to tell from legitimate business. Fine point: The goal is not to make it indistinguishable from legitimate business. Rather it is to keep it distinguishable from illegitimate business long enough that police look elsewhere. The money launderer isn't trying to hid as a legitimate profit-seeking business. The goal is to add so many layers that the burden of investigation dissuades prosecution. So they aren't going to setup false cash-based storefronts so as to mix the bad money with the good (ie the laundromat joke in Archer). Such concrete actions are too dangerous. What they will do is bounce money across as many jurisdictions as possible. There may be no legitimate reason for doing this but they aren't really trying to seem legitimate. They just want to look like a very difficult target so that the cops will go after easier prey. That burden increase is more effective and less dangerous than the lies required to hide.
- zackkatz 6y agoAnecdotally, this happened in Denver when marijuana was legalized. Since the pot shops couldn’t store money with banks, many bought homes with cash. This led to a huge increase in cash buyers and a major spike in prices.
- germinalphrase 6y agoThey literally carried a briefcase of money into the closing without a banking intermediary?
- jrwoodruff 6y agoI've always wondered this too. Can you do a legitimate six figure transaction in actual cash? I'd be uncomfortable carrying around enough cash for a new car, let alone a house.
- asdff 6y agoMaybe that was the case as soon as it was legalized, but by 2017 dispensaries had deposited nearly $1bn into checking accounts at credit unions. In CA, my dispensary takes debit card. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/04/magazine/where-pot-entrepreneurs-go-when-the-banks-just-say-no.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/04/magazine/where-pot-entrep...
- x87678r 6y agoWhy would a launderer buy an overpriced apt in Vancouver when they could by something sensibly priced elsewhere? Maybe its easier if there are agents that speak foreign languages, but I'd hate to own a $2mil 2br apartment as a safe haven for my money stash.
- sumedh 6y agoThey are probably doing it for diversification. They will launder some of it in real estate.
- Spooky23 6y agoWhy would a company pay 10x more to operate in the Bay Area? That’s where the people you need and money is!
- asdff 6y agoLiquidity. You can list your apartment in Vancouver in the morning and accept an offer by the afternoon. You try that in middle of nowhere-ville and you might have a property on the market for a year. Plus these investors aren't living in them. They don't give a shit about how many toilets there are. They just care about it being an asset.
- yalogin 6y agoI am dumb enough to understand this. Can someone tell me how money laundering is done in real estate? Doesn’t the buyer have to deposit the money in a bank for the title company to transfer it? Or May be in cash transactions they don’t care as long as the buyer is ok with it. So the money is transferred outside the cpu Rey or through shell accounts and the asset changes hands?
- greesil 6y agoFrom the googles: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=4242839e-373c-4525-a853-3ad5cc84a17b#:~:text=Criminals%20lease%20out%20their%20properties,party%20rent%20using%20illicit%20funds https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=4242839e-373c.... https://pastebin.com/GTfxANd4 https://pastebin.com/GTfxANd4
- yalogin 6y agoThanks! Never thought about this at all till now. Certainly illuminating.
- valuearb 6y agoWhat a mass of conflicting and unsupported assertions.
- crazygringo 6y agoThis article isn't entirely true. Yes, prices are set by the margin, so small changes in supply and demand can have outsized effects on prices. But the article completely falls apart here: > If you are money laundering... The objective is to move as much cash, as fast as possible. This often involves large assets, and the bigger the price – the better... Both the seller and the money laundering buyer want the highest acceptable price... Competition between interests align, and there’s minimal friction preventing prices from going higher. This gets it completely opposite and wrong. It doesn't matter if you're laundering money or not -- you still want the best deal on an asset. You still want to sell eventually, and the lower your buying price, the more profit you'll make later. Everybody still wants to make a profit. A launderer will always prefer to buy 2 properties at a market value of $1 million each, over buying one of those at an inflated $2 million. Always. The laws of supply and demand don't disappear just because you're laundering money. The idea that "the objective is to move as much cash, as fast as possible" is totally made-up and totally ludicrous. The idea is to move the amount you have, in a reasonable timeframe, at the most profitable price. The only reason money launderers can have an outsized effect on the real estate market is because they generate more demand. Period. But that demand is no different from legitimate buyers. Demand is demand. That's the entire story. (Of course, if laws around LLC's and scrutiny around real estate deals were changed then that demand might dry up. But that doesn't have anything to do with the laws of economics.)
- CreRecombinase 6y ago2 properties at 1 million will probably require more time and effort though, right? Like they may be better off buying 10 200k houses, but the mob lawyer has more important things to do
- DonnyV 6y agoLOL "laws of economics"
- mtnGoat 6y agoNot sure I agree, launderers don't worry about price, they need to move funds and do so on a fairly reasonable timeline. Losing a bit of money is part of the cost of doing business, as long as it's lower then taxes, its still a good deal. Also hyping up a neighborhood you have flippable assets in, lends to wanting to overpay to drive pricing up. Your assumption that fraud follows normal logic is flawed. Read a few federal cases about laundering and you'll see, many of them ain't so bright. And sometimes money needs to be cleaned on a timeline, so overpaying is again, just another cost. Dangerous people like to be paid on time too, so you flip what you can in the time you have. Source: I know someone who, along with their family, was prosecuted for it on a very large scale.
- olalonde 6y agoThis article doesn't pass the smell test, it is pure speculation. Their theory is basically that 1) quick successive buying and selling always drives real estate prices up and 2) money launderers always engage in such activity because they want cash. If 1) was true, the profit seeking motive would ensure that everyone would be doing it, not only money launderers. As for 2), I don't see a reason why criminals wouldn't also be long term investors. If a criminal successfully acquires real estate without raising flags, why risk immediately cashing it out? If they need cash for their criminal activity, why bother "cleaning" it?
- dirtyid 6y agoAt least for Chinese buyers, they like BC for the weather, and east coast for convenience of flying back to China, and Canada in general for the now defunct investor VISA programs that made PR/Citizenship relatively simple. >money launderers I wonder if evading Chinese capital control is technically money laundering if such capital controls does not exist in Canada. That's like punishing Chinese dissidents for speech in Canada because said speech is illegal in China. Rich people get to escape repressive governments too amirite?
- dalbasal 6y agoA lot of modern "problem markets" ultimately show us (IMO) some of the limits of economics. Economic theorising and/or "storytelling," as my econ professor termed it, can create plausible explanations. They're not strongly predictive though. In-context (say, a stock market) these theories can be somewhat dependable. "Predictive" is a strong term, but it's less wrong within highly similar contexts... that's how trading algorithms (non NN ones) work. They theorize within highly limited contexts. In practice, these theories can be predictive enough to be successful trading strategies. In most cases, to be investably predictive a theory needs to be narrow. Certain asset classes, certain epochs, etc. Certain market conditions. Even though they use similar concepts (supply, demand, price, and their marginal determinations), a theory about energy bonds cannot be applied to urban real estate. More academic theories go for generality. Broader theory, but not tradable predictive. "Government and academics are still debating how much money is needed to distort a market. The truth is, not a whole lot is required to distort any asset market. This is a problem the stock market has been dealing with since the 1920s" Sure. Not much is required, but that just makes it plausible. I'd wager some real estate markets are much harder to nudge than others. The highly sensitive marginal dynamics this article is theorising aren't a feature of all real estate markets at all times. They're almost certainly very linked to bubble/bull markets. One rare example of broader theory being applied to actual trading is Soros. I think his concepts probably apply here. "Reflexivity," specifically.
- neilparikh 6y agoA nitpick about your comment (I agree somewhat with your general point): > a theory about energy bonds cannot be applied to urban real estate That's why capitalist thinkers like Smith and Ricardo came up with separate theories for land. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_rent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_rent and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rack-rent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rack-rent Now, it's another matter for people in the modern day to actually know about and use these theories, instead of the reductive "land = capital" model...
- golergka 6y agoIt makes much more sense when you imagine money launderer's money and your money having the same value in those dealers, but having different value for their holders. You, a law-abiding, legitimate buyer, have paid all your taxes and committed no crimes on that money. You can do with it whatever you want to, so for you, it's one to one, a dollar for a dollar. For a money launderer, however, the money is a hot potato. There's still a probability that it left a trail going back, so, he's not so free to use it as he pleases. It's basically very similar to counterfeit money in that regard: it's value to it's holder (who knows about the risks) is much less than a "real" dollar for dirty money dollar.
- option 6y agoI live in Bay Area 20 mins (by bike) from new Apple campus. A house next to ours has been empty for at least 5 years. Once a year a lady from China shows up for not longer than week. It is never rented out, just sits empty...
- hourislate 6y agoThis is how my sale went a few years ago in Toronto. One contractor, one couple with their realtor, and one realtor on the phone representing a remote client. Everyone put in a bid. The realtor representing the remote client gave an offer 200k over asking. Never saw the buyer. Drove by months later and still no one living there. Neighbor told me a young Chinese couple showed up a few weeks after purchase, got out and looked at the property for a minute and drove off, didn't even go in. Property was still empty 2 years later. Extended family remember sells house in Toronto (Bloor West Village). House is at least 100 years old and in rough shape. Gets an offer for 1.4 million (about 150k over asking) as is from a 20 something year old Chinese University of Toronto Student. The student tells family member not to be alarmed if the name on the contract is different from hers. House was rented out a few months after sale. I have dealt with many Chinese factories in a previous life. Many were State factories and everyone from the sales person to the accountant to the factory floor supervisor is on the take. They skim and over time accumulate some serious money. This money leaves the country in capital outflows into the real estate market in Canada. The thinking is I don't care if it makes any money as an investment, I just got to get it out of China so the CCP can't take it away. Banks are no good, so lets just put it in real estate. Who cares if we lose 200k on property, better than losing it all to the Chinese Gov. Another interesting story, real estate agent representing me tells me this story. He's on the phone with an agent representing a Chinese client who wants to buy a Condo in a new development in downtown Toronto. Realtor says client will take one. My Realtor asks him what kind of unit? Chinese buyers tells him not a unit but the whole 8th floor. The average price of a house in Toronto will be in the millions in the next decade. Anyone earning less than 200-300 k a year will not be able to afford one, unless they have a windfall inheritance. Now with a possible Hong Kong exodus, there is no limit to the insanity. Young Canadians in major cities are screwed. Renters for life.
- vmception 6y agoNot just Canada either
- gamblor956 6y agoThose is why China started limiting the outflow of capital several years ago. It has an immediate effect in LA, where a number of buildings under construction were financed by Chinese investors. In one case, the developer itself couldn't get it's own money out, and now they have a giant unfinished hulk right across from Staples Center.
- leakybit 6y agoI Don't get how you would launder money with real Estate. Are the Chinese flying to Canada with suitcases full of cash and customs officials just let them in without any questions.
- munificent 6y agoOne way to look at this is that money launderers are happy to pay a higher price because the house provides more value to them that it does to other buyers: it is both a real estate asset and a tool to launder their money. It's sort of like putting an offer down on a house with a pool when you can't swim. You rationally won't pay as much as the Olympic swimmer also bidding on the house because they get more value from it than you do. The first-order obvious rational solution is to "learn to swim". If you're going to buy a house, figure out a way to also launder some money with the purchase. That way you're competing on a level playing field with other money launderers. The second-order observation is that there is a business opportunity here. Shortly, I expect to see a Y-combinator funded startup developing an AI-driven mobile app that connects BC home buyers with criminals looking to launder their illicit gains. The market becomes more efficient and everyone wins.
- privateprofile 6y agoI find it strange that no one mentions London, property prices have soared in the past 20 years [1] with money laundering playing a key role [2][3][4][5]. Nowadays, football clubs appear to be a better option, as they allow easy laundering of billions instead of millions... [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/property-prices/london/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/property-prices/london/ [2] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/london-property-boom-built-dirty-money-10083527.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/london-prope... [3] https://money.cnn.com/2015/07/28/news/london-real-estate-money-laundering/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2015/07/28/news/london-real-estate-mon... [4] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/may/20/uk-foreign-property-register-needed-urgently-money-laundering https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/may/20/uk-foreign-... [5] https://www.newsweek.com/how-russians-launder-stolen-money-real-estate-407810 https://www.newsweek.com/how-russians-launder-stolen-money-r...
- flowersjeff 6y agoFinTech Idea: Create a website whereby foreign capital can be sent to a local for the purchase of real estate. Maybe even allow said local to live inside of the dwelling provided they pay a small service fee of sorts.... /s Perhaps though there is something here. If only there was a means of connecting these two groups, keeping in mind the additional parameters of those with the cash. After all, nobody likes a haircut. I'm sure the 'big' boys are doing this - I'm really targeting the rich (not the RICH) supervisor that has enough to buy one to two properties. Might be after the fact - as others have pointed out, there are a number of additional controls in place.) Still...
- whearyou 6y agoLast month I lost a bid on a house in a proximal suburb of major American tech hub to a cash offer 20% above asking. This is happening everywhere.