16 ms·
Google: “Any harm Epic has suffered is not irreparable and is of its own making”
- phire 6y agoGoogle (like Apple) is trying to claim that the only harm Epic has suffered is fortnite being kicked off the play store. That's not how Epic see it. Epic think the harm is that they are unable to do payments the way they want and smoothly run their own games store on phones. They even claim that Google is blocking them from making deals with phone manufactures about bundling their games store on certain phones out of the box.
- wccrawford 6y agoYeah, apparently "paying too much for services they don't fully use" isn't "harm" to Google. I doubt they'd see it that way if they were on the other end.
- mehrdada 6y agoKey word is “irreparable” not “harm”. If you pay too much you can capture that if you get a final judgement later. It’s not “irreparable” unless you go out of business, for example, in the meanwhile due that harm, so there’s no emergency requirement to compel the other party to do something right away.
- GeekyBear 6y agoWhen Epic tried to make the "30% is too much" argument in court last Monday before Judge Gonzalez Rogers, it didn't go well for them, according to an FT reporter who live tweeted at the hearing. >“The 30% of what you complain seems to be the industry rate, right? Steam charges 30%. Microsoft: 30% ... If you go to consoles: PlayStation, Xbox Nintendo all charged 30%. Physical stores: game shop, Amazon, Best Buy, Walmart all charge 30%. Apple and Google charged 30%.” “it's all 30%, and you just want to gloss over it. You don’t want to address it,” judge YGR says. Oof, Epic doing poorly on Apple’s 30% fee being excessive. “There doesn't seem to be evidence to support what you're saying,” Judge YGR says. https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1310618271675105282.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1310618271675105282.html
- smnrchrds 6y ago> Steam charges 30%. Microsoft: 30% ... If you go to consoles: PlayStation, Xbox Nintendo all charged 30%. > Physical stores: game shop, Amazon, Best Buy, Walmart all charge 30%. Apple and Google charged 30%. How on earth is this not price fixing and/or oligopoly behaviour?
- vikramkr 6y agobecause its an industry standard. Its not illegal to go "looks like everyone else is charging 30%, let's charge the same). And in general, you don't have an incentive to undercut on price in a situation like this since nobody wins a price war - you try to bring some other value to justify listing on your platform (like a captive audience). Its easiest to just go with whatever ends up being the industry standard- and these prices are all public, no secret information has to be shared to see what everyone else is doing.
- jkachmar 6y agoBecause that might actually represent the fair market value that these sorts of storefronts represent?
- rbg246 6y ago30% in physical shops is entirely different to 30% on digital shop fronts. In physical shops you have a lot more capital invested, because that 30% feeds the retailer, the landlord, the construction company whereas the mobile marketplace has gobbled up two layers of the economy and charges the same rate with pretty insanely significant barriers of entry to compete. It comes down to a question of monopoly and how much is too far which maybe everyone here has differing opinions on when that limit is reached.
- rtx 6y agoGoogle has invested 100s of billions in Android.
- brian_cloutier 6y agoThis is not entirely fair. Here is Epic's claim of harm: > In retaliation against Epic for introducing competition to Google Play Billing, and in furtherance of Google’s anti-competitive scheme, Google removed Fortnite from the GooglePlay Store. As a result, Epic suffered—and continues to suffer—irreparable harm to its reputation, goodwill, and competitive standing. Each day that Epic remains off the Google Play Store causes Epic unquantifiable harm because Google’s other restraints ensure that downloading apps outside an app store is threatening and technically challenging to most users,which prevents Epic from effectively distributing Fortnite to many Android users. Epic only calls out their absence from the play store. They don't articulate any other harms. So, it's natural that Google would only react to this one harm, Epic didn't claim any others!
- nitrogen 6y ago> In retaliation against Epic for introducing competition to Google Play Billing I think this supports the OP's phrasing.
- viktorcode 6y agoAs a preemptive strike Google changes third party stores rules on Android 12 towards easier operations.
- ksec 6y agoI feel bad for Epic. I know their intention, but the way they are going into this battle is just wrong. And they are kind of losing public support and court orders, all while burning bridges with Apple and Google. One could argue Epic is trying to demonstrate Apple and Google are basically Visa and MasterCard. ( That is purely my guess, personally I dont see Epic has planned a decent, long term strategy other than simply charging into battle ) And in EU Visa and Master had to lower their CC processing fees from their 3-5% in US to somewhat sane %. Similar case in AUS as well. I wonder if Tim Sweeney saw the opportunity from DHH / Hey.com, decided to take a bet and jump onto it. Simply judging the flow from Twitter and people within his own circle. ( or Bubble ) I actually have no problem with Apple or Google charging 30% for gaming. I do have problem with Apple charging business like Fitness class, Online Email Services, Education or all other Services simply for access through their Apps. Had it been something like 5% to 10% I think everyone would have been happy to pay. It was estimated 80% of App Store revenue were from Gaming. Apple could have lower their non-gaming cut without substantial loss of services revenue stream. But it seems there are large enough group of Americans thinking Apple can charge whatever they want. It is their platform.
- Qahlel 6y agoThe 30% is overkill and who says it will stay at 30%? What if Apple tomorrow decides to increase it to 40%? What can any dev do? Stop being this naive.
- RL_Quine 6y agoWhat if they don't? What if they demand your first born child? That sort of hyperbole is not a good argument.
- jasonzemos 6y agoThe statement is a slippery-slope, but it's not a fallacy. The concept of a monopoly is one we can agree on, and the exposure to the risk being described is a real one. What is to stop a monopoly deciding 30% becomes 40%? Not much.
- 6y ago
- b20000 6y agoGoogle, keeping it delusional in 2020.
- MattGaiser 6y agoAnyone have a sense of who is winning or losing here (besides the legal proceedings)? Outside of Hacker News, this story seems dead.
- urda 6y agoIt will be real hard to argue to any judge that Epic has anything going for them when 1) they actively broke the TOS and were forward about it 2) they actively sneaked code past reviewers to push a feature that broke said TOS 3) They had an ad campaign and in-game-event ready-to-go from the moment they got pulled, which continues to demonstrate how premeditated this maneuver was. It will be real hard for a judge to have to agree with them. They could have corrected it, got back into compliance and continued their legal case, but this was not the route they picked. They gambled, and have (most likely) lost.
- oh_sigh 6y agoEpic could still prevail if the TOS terms they broke are found to be illegal, unenforceable, etc. The important point is Epic doesn't want to be compliant with the current TOS.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoSure, but that's something to be worked out in the pending trial. In the meantime what Epic wants isn't really important to anyone.
- trevyn 6y agoI get the sense that in order to have legal standing for a lawsuit, you have to be actually harmed. I'm under the impression that they had to do more-or-less what they did (minus the press blitz) in order to have legal standing to bring a case. In this case, I think they are arguing that the harm occurs because "who decides if you can be on the App Store" should not be a monopoly, and users should be able to decide if they trust Epic to handle payments instead of Apple. The argument is that the TOS itself is (or should be ruled), in its current form, illegal. This case is particularly interesting, because it is clear that Apple + Google have a duopoly on a very important market, and both companies exhibit near-identical anti-consumer behavior in this particular respect. So while consumers may have a nominal choice, they do not have a real choice about a decision facet that matters. I'm curious about any anti-trust precedent here, and how this was handled in the courts. (i.e. two separate lawsuits against the companies in question, some sort of unified legal plea...?) How is (implicit) collusion handled?
- vikramkr 6y agoYou can sideload apps on android - im far less sympathetic to Epic here compared to their case against Apple. I remember looking into seeing what fortnight looked like on mobile a while back and for Android I dont recall there even being an option to get it through the play store - it had to be sideloaded - and that worked fine. They're standing on thin ice going against android (especially considering the entire country if China uses phones that essentially don't use Google services at all but still run android - Google does not have the same sort of control over android that Apple does over ios).
- Fej 6y agoEpic did for a time only distribute their game through their launcher, available only as an APK from their website, but they eventually capitulated to Google's policies and listed Fortnite on the Play Store. They did this because it is evidently not realistically possible for a commercial app to be distributed outside of the Play Store and reach a critical mass of the Android userbase, whatever the cause(s) may be. Google has made the process of installing alternative app stores obtuse enough that general consumers might not do it. It's not that obtuse, especially to readers of this site, but it looks as though it's enough. There's also the restriction that app installs and updates cannot be done in the background. Another possibility, or perhaps in addition to the above, is that the general public never goes outside of default app stores to search for games, or is never persuaded to do so. It's the path of least resistance to only use the one(s) included with the phone. Fortnite is the one attempt at a massive enough scale that could have broken this pattern, but it didn't, even though they had Fortnite on all the other platforms to use as an ad, which targets exactly the people most likely to jump through the hoops.
- shirakawasuna 6y agoSideloading is definitely a pain in that the Google Play Store is given privileges so long as you don't have root (the vast majority of people don't). For example, while the Google Play Store can automatically update 10 apps at a time, other stores (such as F-Droid) require you to manually approve and update every single one, waiting for the installation to complete.
- commoner 6y agoThe allegation that Google prevented OnePlus and LG from preloading the Epic Games launcher onto their devices is a factor in this case that does not apply to Epic Games v. Apple. https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/13/21368395/fortnite-epic-games-oneplus-deal-google-play-store-lawsuit-lg https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/13/21368395/fortnite-epic-ga... If this allegation is true, it's hard to blame Epic for the losses resulting from a decision that Google made.
- jjeaff 6y agoI'm not a lawyer. But that sounds like a textbook example of tortuous interference.
- boulos 6y agoMe neither. But tortious. :).
- nitrogen 6y agoDoes anyone remember if Be ever got any remedy over MS locking BeOS out of OEMs? Obviously the tactic worked as we're not using BeOS, and Apple based macOS on NeXT.
- gorbypark 6y agoBe's IP (or the entire company? I can't remember) was sold to Palm for $11m at the end of Be, Inc's life. Palm actually ended up suing Microsoft for anti-competitive behaviour (on the now defunct Be's behalf), and that law suit was settled a few years later for $23m. I don't think Microsoft had to admit any wrong doing, they just paid the money to settle the situation.
- jjeaff 6y agoI think in some cases, we could say it was "tortuous tortious interference".
- Aunche 6y ago
- anfilt 6y agoEpic has a more shaky case here because you can side load on android. The biggest thing I could think epic can shake at google is how google pushed handset manufactures to limit agreements with epic. Although I am not a fan of bloatware it's interesting google singled out epic here.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoLeading Indian startups are supposedly forming an alliance to launch their own App Store for fighting the duopoly[1]. IMO, There was already an open, accessible, free app store called - 'Internet Browser' upon which Internet was built. These companies undermined it in collusion with the duopolies to hoard more data from their customers and are now crying wolf. So, the answer they are proposing now is creating a monopoly to fight the duopoly? [1] https://techcrunch.com/2020/09/30/indian-startups-explore-forming-an-alliance-and-alternative-app-store-to-fight-googles-monopoly/ https://techcrunch.com/2020/09/30/indian-startups-explore-fo...
- stouset 6y agoYou can certainly accuse Google of hoarding its customers’ data, but I think you’ll have a hard time levying that same accusation at Apple. Not that Apple has zero data on their customers, but the difference in quantity (and intrusiveness) is likely off by a factor of thousands.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoBoth platforms provided necessary instruments to hoard personal data such as - location (GPS/cellular triangulation), Microphone, Cameras etc. There was absolutely no difference in what instruments they provided to gain data until recently.
- newen 6y agoApple’s argument for privacy is that they don’t give away their user’s data to outside parties. Friend who used to work at Apple told me they store lots of user data and do the typical intrusive data analysis on the data. They just don’t give it to third parties.
- millstone 6y agoNo, Apple's argument for privacy is that they don't collect the data, period. For example Apple Maps has no sign in, does not retain your searches, and uses E2E encryption for syncing. Very different than GMaps.
- Animats 6y agoIn a related area, it may be time for independent "add-on stores" for browsers, separate from the ones Google, Mozilla, and Apple operate. Chrome and Firefox now use the same add-on format ("WebExtensions"), so there's no need for separate stores, and Safari is going that way. But each browser vendor has a separate approval process with its own rules and fees.
- ramshanker 6y agoI sense regulation incoming. ;)
- supernova87a 6y agoCall me a corporatist, but I don't even think Google and Apple should have to justify their 30% pricing at all as "reasonable". They could charge anything they like -- 100%. It's a voluntary contract, and Epic doesn't have to engage in it. We don't have to engage in it. There's no fundamental right to offer an app on an app store, and if the scope of the market is defined as the market for video games/content, then none of these places are monopolies and companies/people are free to set their desired prices. Who is the court, or any of us, to say what should be the charge for selling a game on a marketplace? That's like someone telling you what your profit margin should be for a product that everyone wants. Why should it be tied to your costs? I mean, in many cases it is, due to customer demand reasons, but there are tons of things that you pay for that have prices nothing close to what it costs to provide. That's why I think it will fail in court at least (maybe not the SEC, or Congress). The argument that 30% is unfair goes nowhere in court -- so what should it be? Courts are not the forum for that question. Anyway, I finish with snark: if Epic invoked its same logic on itself, clearly it should reduce its profit / subscription charges to a "reasonable" level. Epic is the only one I'm able to buy Epic games from -- clearly they're a monopoly and need to have their market-abusive behavior and extortionate pricing regulated? Right? I find irony in many people who get probably so knee-jerk opposed to Google/Apple and "on Epic's side" will find themselves justifying why they should be free to set their own prices when they launch their next product.
- Barrin92 6y agoCall me a democrat but I think the United States of America shouldn't have to justify its laws at all and should regulate Google's and Apple's store however they want, tax them 100% instead of 20%, after all they voluntarily made a business, they can move their HQ to Swaziland, who is to tell the American people how to regulate their businesses It's not like Apple and Google can't move, there's like 200 countries, that's like a hundred times more countries than app stores
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wbsun 6y agoOff topic, I am wondering what are missing in mobile browser before we can completely move these games to web and get rid of native apps? Faster JS? Accelerometer and other censor APIs?
- 6510 6y agoIf they do a phone and a gaming OS I would buy it. also, I similarly wonder what we are missing for google and apple to force websites to use their payment system and tax the 30% hell out of the entire economy. And remember, no "sideloading" though brick and mortar stores!
- ohyeshedid 6y agoBandwidth is likely the largest hurdle.
- ladberg 6y agoI believe most sensors are already available to web apps, but a big burden for games would be storing assets on the user's phone as something like Fortnite takes a few gigabytes even on iOS with lower resolution textures.
- ry454 6y agoWe're missing the desire of Apple & Google to make this happen. Apple won't let Safari compete with its app store and Google won't let Chrome compete with its app store.
- ThatPlayer 6y agoAs examples of this, Safari doesn't even support HTML push notifications: https://caniuse.com/notifications https://caniuse.com/notifications , which would make it near impossible to make an entirely web based messenger app.
- pjmlp 6y agoUsable 3D APIs for starter. WebGL 2.0 is at the level of OpenGL ES 3.0 (we are at GL ES 3.2 since years now) and has constraints in place due to security reasons. WebGL 2.0 compute got a standard update last September, but there are no plans in sight to ever make it out of nightly previews, specially given WebGPU. WebGPU still remains to be seen when it will be available, and in what form, if ever. WebAssembly in 2020 is still trying to catch up with what Flash Alchemy allowed for in 2011. To top this, even if you managed to make a cool 3D Web game in proper framerate, it can run like a dog in the customers browser in spite of their good native gaming experience, because the browser for whatever reason blacklists their GPU model and reverts back to either software rendering or not running at all.
- bitwize 6y agoJust stating the obvious: punks jump up to get beat down.
- trevyn 6y agoI guess you're right, Martin Luther King Jr. did get beat down. But his cause sure as hell didn't.
- xbmcuser 6y agoMy problem with apple and google charging 30% is when they are the competitors. So in essence you are asking your competitors to finance you. If apple wants Apple music or a video subscription service they can't charge as Spotify or netflix 30% same for google etc. And I think this should apply to almost all market services/stores not just mobile app stores. If you want to be market infrastructure provider you should not be allowed to compete in it or allowed to charge 30% rather it should be a nominal fee.
- stanrivers 6y agoThis is an interesting point that people miss sometimes - so thank you for bringing it up. I guess a comparison would be a utility that both owns the transmission lines and power plants? However, the transmission line rates are set by regulation. We have accepted as a society that the infrastructure needs to have regulated pricing. So why is it all that different here? The transmission of the products, just given the way the cellphone market works, is basically limited to either App Store or Android Store. I basically have no alternative. Isn't that approaching a monopoly / duopoly where regulation starts to make sense? I say this all as a fairly conservative person, but it just seems too similar to utilities to me... Why am I wrong? (Serious Question)
- luckylion 6y ago> Isn't that approaching a monopoly / duopoly where regulation starts to make sense? Or it might be a cartel (few players are coordinating for maximum revenue, are not competing, prices are fixed), but we usually won't let that stand either. It's good to remember that Google and Apple (and others) have been found to collude before when they made secret no-poaching deals. They settled for $415m. I don't know how that would work though, without breaking up the companies.
- mook 6y agoI believe a better comparison would be Comcast also having a Netflix competitor… let's call it Xfinity Stream. And then they make Netflix have extra costs (say, having plans that have low monthly bandwidth caps that limit how much you would be able to use Netflix) but exclude their own service from having those costs. Essentially, making an artificial floor on competitor prices where their own service can ignore that floor. … Let's just say there's a reason my example is oddly concrete. In your example, as far as I know consumers do not actually interact with the power plants, and have no choice on what utility company to use; to do so would require duplicate infrastructure. In the (either) app store case there is — I can still install the Microsoft mail client instead of the Apple or Google ones.
- hindsightbias 6y agoApple should just release their own Fortnite clone and be done with it.
- ohyeshedid 6y agoLots of companies have tried, and none have attained the level of popularity that Fortnite has.
- gdsdfe 6y agoI think this is ultimately about what the consumers want. Google and Apple can easily drown epic games in lawyer fees and expenses etc. ... But do they have a case in front of the public, do consumers care enough to give a shit, maybe ... I don't see it.
- ivanstame 6y agoBig tech should die!
- ry454 6y agoIMHO, Google & Apple are safe for at least 4 more years: the current and next US administration has no interest in changing the status quo in the corporate world. Maaaybe something will happen in 2030.
- parasubvert 6y agoIt must be fun being Apple to be both perpetually doomed by detractors as having minuscule marketshare and collapsing sales (any day now for the last 40 years)... and also a rampant monopolist that must be turned into a public utility because we’d much rather have the government review apps than Apple or Google (wait what?). Pick one! But if you pick monopolist, don’t expect regulation to necessarily go the way you want it to. It probably will preserve everything you hate about the current system, just replacing Apple with a bureaucracy. Forcing the return of the Wild West of the PC ecosystem Into mobile will only happen when consumers demand it. They won’t, because that wasn’t a very user friendly approach. It Was originally for tinkerers and hackers and that pedigree continues to this day. Mobile carriers and government aren’t likely too fond of the idea of phones where anything can be installed on them.
- fragsworth 6y agoAt some point monopolies stop being the more user friendly approach by abusing their position to the point that they provide bad service for high costs, and you're forced to deal with it. These companies were user friendly at first, but as all companies do, they are slowly squeezing the profits out of everything they can. They are steering us towards a local maximum that ends in them taking a massive chunk of the money from everyone forever, for no benefit to anyone else, simply because they're sitting on market inertia. People could eventually demand something like that "Wild West" you speak of, because it is the solution that fosters competition and prevents the monopolies from abusing their power. But I think there is something preventing that from happening - the companies in charge are spending vast amounts of money on PR to convince the public that their monopoly situations are not really so bad. And, I think as a result, they've got folks like you defending them.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoAnd yet, the platforms and the services they provide just keep getting better and better, and Apple is still charging the same 30% cut that they started with back in 2008. "Slowly squeezing the profits out of everything they can" just reads like anger fantasy.
- 6y ago
- onetimemanytime 6y agoHijacker: yes I shot him but it is of his own making. He didn't cave in to my demands. (Yes, I know Android marketplace is Google's but what we'd think if MS did the same with Windows, charge a cut of every transaction. Don't like it? Too bad, no one is forcing anyone to use Windows)
- Razengan 6y agoReplace Google with Apple in the headline and this would be 10x as many points and comments in less than half as much time.
- simonkafan 6y agoIt's like if you would have to ask Google or Apple for permission when you want to open a coffee shop or any other business and have to give them 30% of your profit. App marketplaces must be a public good and under the surveillance of the public and not controlled by a few old chief executives of Google or Apple.
- ericmay 6y agoIt’s like if Apple and Google went out and bought land and built a very desirable mall and you want to open up your business in their mall.
- crumbshot 6y agoMore like if, between them, they held almost all commercially-zoned land and then proceeded to run a landlording duopoly.
- twhb 6y agoI think the parent analogy is better. The land outside Apple and Google isn’t illegal to build on, just less desirable.
- dingaling 6y agoAnd the mall owner charged not only rent, but 30% of your store sales which could only be made through their proprietary payment system. Sounds lucrative.
- cannabis_sam 6y agoI fucking love Epic’s attempt at precedent here! Fuck whatever contract you signed, actively breach that contract, claim some faux-high-ground, while you’re completely fucking over the people who actually use your rickety-ass malware-as-a-service “app store”...
- reason-mr 6y agoAll of the app stores charge 30%, with some stores going so far as to impose an evaluation fee when listing a new app. It is completely outrageous relative to the amount of work they have done (which is amortized over all of the apps in the store), versus that of creating the app/game. Plus I find it fishy (in a collusionary way) that all of the stores charge basically the same percentage. And, as pointed out, they will not allow another competitive app store on their platforms. Each store in basically a monopoly per platform, with the possible exception of steam/windows.