14 ms·
Nikola admits prototype was rolling downhill in promotional video
- rewtraw 6y agoHow does a huge corporation like GM end up partnering with such an obvious scam, especially post-Theranos? Where is the due-diligence? I saw NKLA stock skyrocketing, and spent 5 minutes researching the company to find out why, and all I found were massive red flags... how did GM miss them?
- carriganisms 6y agoIf you read to the end of the article it addresses the GM deal. GM will use its own battery tech. Nikola is basically just sales/marketing. The deal still makes absolutely no sense, but GM isn't dependent on Nikola having working tech or not.
- jfim 6y agoIt might actually make sense for GM. GM is building the vehicles using their own tech/plants (presumably not at a loss) and for doing so, is getting Nikola stock. If Nikola is an unexpected success, then they have a significant stake in it, and if they fail, then hopefully they don't have too many vehicles that Nikola hasn't paid for.
- HuShifang 6y agoIt wouldn't be the first time GM used a "sock puppet" (loosely defined) to escape its own reputation. [0] [0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Corporation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturn_Corporation
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- perardi 6y agoIt's baffling. Like you said, GM will use its own technology. So they bought 11% of Nikola for…edgy CEO shitposting on Twitter? GM can definitely build a good electric vehicle. They cannot seem to market a good electric vehicle—see Chevrolet Bolt sales, and then ask a random person if they know what a Bolt is. So the Nikola investment is the equivalent of buying a hip design studio?
- stu2b50 6y agoThey didn't buy any stock. GM gets 11% in return for supplying and R&D for the Nikola "car". But they didn't spend any cash, and in fact get cash because they can reimburse 700M. In the worst case, they were paid to do their own R&D. Nikola basically bribed GM with a insane deal so they can say they have a GM partnership.
- foobarian 6y agoEven better, remember the EV1? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_EV1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_EV1
- tyingq 6y agoNikola did have a pleasing exterior design for the pickup and a solid email list of potential buyers. Not worth a fortune, but something.
- gibolt 6y agoGM only stood to benefit, with the exception of tarnishing their brand and trust even more.
- mafuyu 6y agoIt was such a good deal for GM that it didn't matter. They got 11% of Nikola, which they can start selling off after a year. And that was just to allow Nikola access to their IP, which GM wanted to develop and test anyways. I imagine they got such great terms because Nikola has absolutely nothing working in-house.
- toomuchtodo 6y ago11% of 0 is 0. This simply solidifies the idea that GM is led by out of touch legacy management. "We were supposed to check they only rolled the truck down a hill?" Say what you will about Musk and Tesla (I know, I know), but their Class 8 Semi did a nationwide tour (under its own power) to potential customers [1] and also occasionally pitches in to perform vehicle deliveries [2], no downhill coasting required. [1] https://electrek.co/2018/08/25/tesla-semi-drove-across-country-supercharger-elon-musk/ https://electrek.co/2018/08/25/tesla-semi-drove-across-count... [2] https://electrek.co/2020/06/26/tesla-semi-spotted-used-deliver-vehicles-end-of-quarter-push/ https://electrek.co/2020/06/26/tesla-semi-spotted-used-deliv...
- xeromal 6y agoNot really. They can probably sell it at a loss and recover it all back in tax breaks.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 112012123 6y agoIn addition to the 11%, GM is also slated to earn up to 700 million dollars in cash.
- yholio 6y agoMore specifically was slated to earn 700 million, if the Nikola ponzi had been able to slip under the radar and continue. I'm absolutely sure NKLA does not have 0.7 billion lying around in cash, those are new investment that they need to raise. Fake it till you make it, they say. In the current situation, all investors will require substantial proof of working technology. No working tech, no new investment, the company will probably fold before paying back a cent to GM.
- bob33212 6y agoIt was a PR move. All major business websites had a story about the news. They would have preferred that this didn't come out and NKLA was able to create a real company, but it isn't like they shut down all their factories in anticipation of NKLA making all the GM cars.
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoDid GM pay Nikola cash for its investment? Or is it offsets against e.g. purchases of GM batteries?
- stu2b50 6y agoThe latter. Hence it's basically zero risk for GM. If Nikola is real, then the deal is good. If Nikola is a fraud, then it's not like GM wasn't going to do R&D on battery tech anyway.
- Tade0 6y agoWouldn't be their first time. Previously it was Envia Systems promising a 400Wh/kg battery years before this was on anyone's roadmap. Of course it turned out to be a scam.
- schwinn140 6y agoThe same way countless business, government, and philanthropic leaders were all duped by Theranos. Group think and greed are powerful drugs for those unable to perform their own critical thinking/research.
- an_opabinia 6y agoNikola, essentially, paid someone at GM in exchange for the deal.
- MiroF 6y agoThis sort of thing is (from my limited experience) incredibly common in the start up space.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- samfisher83 6y agoWalgreens, Safeway, and cleveland clinic partnered with Theranos. Cleveland Clinic is supposed to be one of the best hospitals in the world.
- yhoneycomb 6y agoThe Cleveland Clinic is only the "best" because of marketing. Think about it. Are the best and brightest REALLY clamoring live indefinitely Cleveland? Yeah right. The best hospitals are likely in California. Doctors want to work in California so bad that they actually take LESS money. It's called the sunshine tax.
- claydavisss 6y agoThey're going to get away with it. Now that the stock has short interest, the RobinHood kids will gather and create a short squeeze and Trevor Milton is practically guaranteed to become a billionaire.
- ravenstine 6y agoIt's interesting to me that they didn't use CGI. Maybe they were afraid people would notice? But tons of car ads are totally CGI. Back when I was at Dev Bootcamp, before that shut down, some car company came to shoot a car commercial in front of the building. People were expecting to see some cool cars and action on the scene, but I rightly predicted that there would be filming of backdrops, some green screens here or there, all done in a few hours, and no actual cars. Having looked at the video, I see no reason why they needed a real truck, even if they actually have a prototype. Are they just cheap as f*?
- tlb 6y agoSure, but it's not in question whether or not BMW or Ford can make a working vehicle. Nikola's ad is an announcement that they can, and in that context it's misleading.
- ma2rten 6y agoI'm assuming it would have been a bigger scandal / might have been revealed earlier if they had used GGI. "Truck rolled downhill" is harder to proof than "Truck doesn't exist and was done using CGI".
- lostgame 6y ago>> But tons of car ads are totally CGI. As silly as this sounds, it very well may be a cost factor - I am desperately seeking the article but I have read that car commercials actually use a highly advanced form of CGI that is incredibly, jaw-droppingly expensive. I mean, we could assume they just wanted to be honest and show the real thing; but we obviously know they had no interest in being honest whatsoever and it was obviously designed to mislead.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoCar ads use CGI because they need to a lot of localisation and customisation for trim-level specific shots. Making a CGI car ad from scratch might cost $10m+, but you can now do a new shot or make small changes in a day for a few thousand dollars. If you need a one-off video, it’s cheaper to not use CGI.
- sparrish 6y agoSo I guess they subscribe to the 'fake it till you make it' philosophy of start ups?
- onepointsixC 6y agoConsidering their founder bought a ranch which cost tens of millions of dollars, I think they're following the fake it till you can cash out WeWork model.
- xkjkls 6y agoThey aren't the only ones.
- anigbrowl 6y agoI really think that false statements made by commercial entities should be prosecuted as fraud. It's one thing to engage in vague sales talk like 'the new SuperTech Blinkenlights will turbocharge your actuarial skydiving research!!', but when you're making claims of having actually existing technology (which you may not be ready or willing to patent, but do want to raise money with), the public has an interest in protecting itself from fraud. Perhaps there should be some requirement to pay for independent professional witnesses, sort of like observers who validate Guinness world records as having met some (negotiable) standard of existing in the real world while being bound not to comment on the specifics of how it was achieved.
- BigCatStuff 6y agoI agree that it should be fraud, but I'm not sure how the SEC defines fraud. To me, the whole NKLA situation feels like a giant Kickstarter scam.
- ganoushoreilly 6y agoI agree. It seems like the Theranos of the EV world.
- roywiggins 6y agoEverything everywhere is securities fraud. > contributing to global warming is securities fraud, and sexual harassment by executives is securities fraud, and customer data breaches are securities fraud, and mistreating killer whales is securities fraud, and whatever else you’ve got. Securities fraud is a universal regulatory regime; anything bad that is done by or happens to a public company is also securities fraud, and it is often easier to punish the bad thing as securities fraud than it is to regulate it directly. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-26/everything-everywhere-is-securities-fraud https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-26/everyt... The problem is, who was defrauded? The investors, I guess, but if they sue then they can only collect money from the company that they own anyway. It's not obvious that's a money-gaining proposition.
- 6y ago
- BigCatStuff 6y agoI feel like Nikola is an example of why it might be bad for retail investors to have access to early stage companies (pre-IPO or not). A traditional venture capital investment has a better ability to do due diligence than the general public does. I'm not familiar with IPO listings through SPACs, but do these type of listings go through as much DD as a traditional IPO listing? It seems that every step along the way, NKLA had avoided close inspection of it's actual IP and assets.
- Miner49er 6y agoOn the otherhand, if Nikola was successful and retail investors couldn't get in early, it's an unfair advantage to the rich who are still allowed to invest. Nikola is actually a poor example of your point. Their stock price is still up since they IPOed. A retail investor could sell their shares now and be fine.
- an_opabinia 6y agoIt would seem we would gain a lot from greater transparency in who owns shares. For example, Robintrack's data was very illuminating, almost every stock that made it to the week popular list was full of retail bagholders: https://imgur.com/a/LbvUOdi https://imgur.com/a/LbvUOdi Bet you thought I meant insiders. I'd run from stuff idiots buy!
- quickthrowman 6y ago> It would seem we would gain a lot from greater transparency in who owns shares. Major KODK shareholders: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/KODK/holders?p=KODK https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/KODK/holders?p=KODK Retail holds a small percent of pretty much anything, institutions dwarf retail.
- an_opabinia 6y agoAlmost all of those institutions are holding shares on behalf of normal "retail" people, not professional investors. The statistic you are seeing is both in support of the claim of how much retail is a bagholder and in support of the claim that the word "institutional" is misunderstood.
- vikramkr 6y agoThere's a part of me that's happy that there's finally a nice example of technology fraud to point to that's a non-medical tech company. After Theranos, the takeaway has been "biotechs, especially diagnostic companies, especially anything involved with microfluidics, especially if founded by a white female engineer[0], are frauds." Theranos has been explained away as something that happens when Silicon Valley invests in biotech (which is just so stupid - Genentech was founded in the bay...), so instead of using it as an opportunity to rethink what is incentivized and how charisma is rewarded over capability, people instead decided that by adopting a bunch of flawed heuristics, they could avoid the issue forever. Well, here you go! Theranos 2: electric Boogaloo! Turns out Fraud is not industry specific! Who knew!? [0]I know a founder fitting that description that was put through hell because of all the pattern matching. And in my own startup, there was a point where I just straight up stopped mentioning microfluidics because of all the nonstop pattern matching and the dumb questions that resulted. Its so frustrating.
- xwdv 6y agoI opened a massive short position on NKLA today after seeing it up almost 10%. Uneducated speculators that have forgotten the lessons of Theranos are fueling its rise, and for them it will end in tears. For me? I will make a fortune.
- Miner49er 6y agoI wouldn't be so sure. Fundamentals don't matter much in this market.
- xwdv 6y agoThe time for fundamentals will return soon.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoIf "soon" is "less than a decade" I'd probably agree with you, but I still wouldn't be certain. The housing market took 6 years to go from front cover of the Economist to crash. A large reason for the market strangeness is the helicopter money from the Fed and the essentially zero interest rate environment. The helicopter money might end soon, but the crazy low interest rates might be here to stay. We might have to redefine what the fundamentals are.
- yholio 6y agoThere is only so much zero interest money you can burn through before people taking those loans realize that you have no product and they will be still liable for the principal. Nikola has no battery edge. Their hydrogen tech is vaporware - after more then 20 years of massive public and private investment in Japan and Germany, Hydrogen failed to achieve a competitive position in the marketplace. Hell, it has been 17 years since Bush Jr announced his plan for a "Hydrogen economy" - nothing materialized. Hidrogen is dead an buried, not coming back. Nikola has no propulsion in a market where even the company that has the best electric propulsion - Tesla - is struggling to put a compelling semi.
- 6y ago
- ckastner 6y agoThis is a horrible press release. Horrible. The allegations Hinderburg made are substantial, but a rebuttal as poor as this one is even worse than just staying silent. It would be somewhat understandable if they'd be trying to weasel out of one or two issues. But when all but a few of your rebuttals are "oh but in a strict technical sense, we didn't make the claims that Hingerburg is challenging", like "we never said the truck was under its own propulsion, the video was just called "in motion", or "the contract that we claimed was worth 250 million had an option that made it potentially worth 250 million", then that just underlines how much bullshit they have been spewing.
- Petrova 6y agoAgreed, when I read their response I thought that what they didn't say spoke volumes. Hindenburg's article covered every company in Trevor Milton's professional career from dropping out at Utah Valley State to Nikola. Hindenburg gave evidence that Milton perpetuated fraud at every single company he was involved in and they only challenged the 250 million option at DHybrid. I think the issue the legal team faces is that many of the things Trevor says are clearly false and misleading.For example, he claimed multiple times that Nikola is generating 3.5 megawatts of energy from solar panels on their roof. There is simply nothing there, it is a bold lie so naturally it's not referenced in their response at all. The entire company is built around mysterious battery tech that's twice as efficient as Tesla's batteries and hydrogen production at 18.75% of current cost. That is the central fraud in the company just as the unrealistic notion of droplets of blood for reliable testing was at Theranos. Eventually, if Nikola persists in trying use hydrogen they will face the technological and economic reality they've been hiding from investors and the company will fail.
- misiti3780 6y agoMilton is obviously an idiot, crazy and delusional, if he didnt realize someone could prove him wrong via google earth.
- jeffbee 6y agoOnce again we see that the short side is absolutely necessary to keep companies in check. A company that whines about short sellers is broadcasting its intention to act dishonestly. If you are long a company that puts out press releases about a short conspiracy, run for the exits.
- yholio 6y agoDamn straight. A short seller with compromising info has all the incentives to broadcast it, then sit back and look how he makes money. He injects valuable information into the market and puts his neck on the line - since the downside of a short position is unlimited. No such incentives exist for long holders. The problem are never short-sellers per se, bur rather the fabrications some diseminate to induce panics. Those guys that try to manipulate the market with false information should be vilified, not short sellers in general.
- throwaway5792 6y agoShorting doesn't have to involve unlimited risk, put contracts are defined limited risk and serve the same purpose.
- Kranar 6y agoI don't agree that they serve the same purpose; shorting is not the same as buying a put and the two only behave similarly in a very narrow and limited sense that isn't particularly practical. Yes in some circumstances money is gained if the price of a stock decreases with both a short and a put, but the risk profile, timing and cost are quite distinct. Furthermore it's absolutely possible and in many circumstances likely that the price of a put decreases even if the underlying stock's price decreases, for example if the volatility also decreases. I don't think many informed individuals treat shorting stock the same way they treat buying puts nor do they attempt to accomplish the same purpose.
- throwaway5792 6y ago
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoOn the bright side. The brakes must be working.
- DudeInBasement 6y agoProbably not. They just use friction.
- DobryMorozov 6y agoThis is the CEO that said their infotainment system is a HTML supercomputer. He's now a billionaire and has cashed out 70 million with nothing more than a fake prototype, lies and purchases from suppliers in which they give their equity and call it a strategic partnership.
- RosanaAnaDana 6y agoLiving the dream.
- nograpes 6y agoI thought you were exaggerating but I found the truckinginfo article (https://www.truckinginfo.com/330475/whats-behind-the-grille-of-the-new-nikola-hydrogen-electric-truck https://www.truckinginfo.com/330475/whats-behind-the-grille-...). I am not involved in this world at all... but is this common? Can you really expose your own ignorance in this way and also manage to keep investors?
- sisk 6y agoFrom the linked article, here is the full quote: > "The entire infotainment system is a HTML 5 super computer," Milton said. "That's the standard language for computer programmers around the world, so using it let's us build our own chips. And HTML 5 is very secure. Every component is linked on the data network, all speaking the same language. It's not a bunch of separate systems that somehow still manage to communicate."
- discreteevent 6y agoWhat a relief! No more worries about the ARM buyout. Just use HTML 5 and you can build your own chips.
- quantified 6y agoTasty word salad.
- vsareto 6y ago
- PaulHoule 6y agoLet me get this straight: Did "Hindenberg" really say that the hydrogen fuel cell wasn't working?
- sytse 6y agoNikola responded to https://hindenburgresearch.com/nikola/ https://hindenburgresearch.com/nikola/ which is a solid read.
- pkaye 6y agoThis is the company with $36k in total revenues from installing a solar system on the founders home. They list a bunch of products on their webpage. Do they sell any of them or is it vaporware?
- gibolt 6y agoThe renderings are real, not vaporware. You can 2D print them
- leto_ii 6y agoWhat Nikola seems to have done is outrageous, but am I reading it correctly that the short-seller was trading on insider information?
- stu2b50 6y agoWhere are you reading that?
- leto_ii 6y ago> But last week, the short-selling investment firm Hindenburg Research published a bombshell report claiming that the Nikola One wasn't close to being fully functional in December 2016. Indeed, Hindenburg published a 2017 text message exchange in which a Nikola employee stated that the company didn't resume work on the truck in the months after the show.
- stu2b50 6y agoThat's insider trading, but not Insider Trading™. >In the United States and most non-European jurisdictions not all trading on non-public information is illegal insider trading. For example, a person in a restaurant who hears the CEO of Company A at the next table tell the CFO that the company's profits will be higher than expected and then buys the stock is not guilty of insider trading—unless he or she had some closer connection to the company or company officers. However, even where the tippee is not himself an insider, where the tippee knows that the information is non-public and the information is paid for, or the tipper receives a benefit for giving it, then in the broader-scope jurisdictions the subsequent trading is illegal. Basically, so long as the text exchange wasn't given to Hidenburg in return for some kind of economic favor, there isn't a legal issue.
- maest 6y agoAs Matt Levine likes to say, "Insider trading isn't about fairness, it's about theft". Insider trading isn't about making the markets fair and giving the same information to all investors. It's about stopping people from trading on information they don't own - i.e. with information owned by the company itself. If I fly a helicopter and see oil levels in BP's oil tanks, I can trade on that information just fine, even if I mighjt be the only person with that info. If BP calls me up and tells me what their oil levels are in the same tanks, I can't trade on that information, because it was obtained from the company.
- belval 6y agoFrom the video: "Behold, the 1,000 HP, zero-emission Nikola One semi-truck in motion. Get ready for the pre-production units to hit fleets next year in 2019 for testing. The Nikola #hydrogenelectric trucks will take on any #semitruck and outperform them in every category; weight, acceleration, stopping, safety and features - all with a 500-1,000 mile range!" People were arguing about how Tesla's semi was dead on arrival because of these people.
- mandeepj 6y agoHave you seen this video from Nikola - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LbNopvpSbzU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LbNopvpSbzU ? It does not look fake.
- soared 6y agoThe video in question is from 2018, the CEO said the truck was functional in 2016. Your video is from 2020, so all statements can be true at the same time. Nikola likely lied about having functionality for years, but now they do have some functionality.
- giarc 6y agoWait, they also make a jet ski?!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rblatz 6y agoWhat terrifies me the most is that supposedly this company is planning to store a shit ton of hydrogen in the middle of the Phoenix metro area. Nothing that I've heard about this company makes me think it is at all equipped to properly handle that responsibility, and I'm adjusting my behavior to stay clear of that part of town.
- keketi 6y agoFrom the article: > Nikola's fortunes are now tied to the success of the Nikola Two, Badger, and other products. If those products are successful, it probably won't matter that the Nikola One was never drivable. I'm trying to figure out what is the difference between Nikola One and Two. By comparing https://nikolamotor.com/one https://nikolamotor.com/one and https://nikolamotor.com/two https://nikolamotor.com/two there doesn't seem to be any difference at all, apart from the pictures and videos. The specs are the same, technology is the same, performance is the same, all of the promotional text is the same, etc.
- chrisabrams 6y agoTwo didn't roll down a hill in a promotional video? I'm with you, I'm trying to figure that out as well.
- TheAlchemist 6y agoI thought you were joking, but it appears you're right ! I've also clicked on the 'tre' model, and while there is no specs, and 'performance' numbers are better , all highlights and inside pictures are the same. Amazing !
- reducesuffering 6y agoThose pages are practically copy and pasted. There isn't a difference because the trucks don't exist.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- trhway 6y ago>Our investigation of the site and text messages from a former employee reveal that the video was an elaborate ruse—Nikola had the truck towed to the top of a hill on a remote stretch of road and simply filmed it rolling down the hill. couldn't they just put in battery&motor from golf cart? Or, god forbid, from a Tesla :) >In October 2019, Nikola announced it would revolutionize the battery industry. This was to be done through a pending acquisition, but the deal fell through when Nikola realized (a) the technology was vaporware you don't say. Looking at all that gold rush and Alibaba prices i wonder may be i should start a EV company too. Don't need $20B, i think i can retire comfortably with 3 orders of magnitude less :)
- tus88 6y agoLooks very similar to the Tesla Semi.
- fma 6y agoYou mean Tesla Semi looked similar to Nikola One? As Tesla Semi was announced one year after Nikola One and there was/is even a lawsuit. https://electrek.co/2020/04/22/tesla-semi-design-lawsuit-move-forward-nikola-motors-weaker/ https://electrek.co/2020/04/22/tesla-semi-design-lawsuit-mov...
- projektfu 6y agoAfter Elon named his company Tesla, along comes a scam with their machine called Edison. Not to be outdone, a putative truck company circles back and calls itself Tesla’s first name, Nikola.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>After Elon named his company Tesla Tesla Motors was a thing before Elon was involved.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoTesla coils too!
- liability 6y agoThose have a right to the name though; Nikola Tesla invented them.
- projektfu 6y agoAh right
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- epanchin 6y agoWhy does the truck have a grill/air intake on the front?
- mdoms 6y agoThere are lots of reasons Nikola is fake BS but this isn't one. Hydrogen engines require air intake just like any other internal combustion engine.
- ericd 6y agoH2+O2 -> H2O+Energy Also, probably radiators for the above.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoTesla cars also have front air intakes (where the “T” is in post-2016 S/X facelift cars, also by the front foglights) for cooling and passenger cabin air.
- vcwanted 6y agoI am surprised that a BS company can raise so much money. If you are in VC and are able to raise series A, we are looking for capital. Continuous blood pressure monitoring with an arm sleeve. (No, not blood wave velocity in case you were wondering). Text me here if interested. Solid team, track record (prof of medicine, 100s of peer reviewed pubs)
- easton_s 6y agoWho here hasn't faked a demo? And this is a very different case then Theranos. They faked the demos and never had a working product. Nikola faked the demo and now has an actual working truck. Don't lie. You've faked a demo before.
- Voloskaya 6y agoThe mess they are in isn't just about faking one demo one time when they were 2 employees in a basement building a landing page. They consistently lied about basically everything, including key and core components. "In October 2019, Nikola announced it would revolutionize the battery industry. This was to be done through a pending acquisition, but the deal fell through when Nikola realized (a) the technology was vaporware and (b) the President of the battery company had been indicted months earlier over allegations that he conned NASA by using his expense account to procure numerous prostitutes. Nikola has never walked back claims relating to its battery technology. Instead, Trevor continued to publicly hype the technology even after becoming aware of the above issues. The revolutionary battery technology never existed – now, Nikola plans to use GM’s battery technology instead." "Inexpensive hydrogen is fundamental to the success of Nikola’s business model. Trevor has claimed in a presentation to hundreds of people and in multiple interviews to have succeeded at cutting the cost of hydrogen by ~81% compared to peers and to already be producing hydrogen. Nikola has not produced hydrogen at this price or at any price as he later admitted when pressed by media." [1] Tell me again how this is not like Theranos? [1] https://hindenburgresearch.com/nikola/ https://hindenburgresearch.com/nikola/
- fma 6y agoHow about a company that faked a working phone? A phone where there is only 1 set of workflow that actually was successfuly. A phone that could not play an entire song. And because the CEO knew the phone would crash, even during the only workflow that worked, he had multiple phones on stage that he would swap out when it crashed. Is that also a lie? Because that's exactly what Steve Jobs did when he debuted the iPhone. https://gizmodo.com/the-iphones-first-demo-was-buggy-as-hell-1441324523 https://gizmodo.com/the-iphones-first-demo-was-buggy-as-hell...
- mrtweetyhack 6y agoLiars will always be liars
- fma 6y agoNot to defend Nikola, but people are quick to forget that iPhone's first presentation was a lot of smoke and mirrors? "Hours of trial and error had helped the iPhone team develop what engineers called “the golden path,” a specific set of tasks, performed in a specific way and order, that made the phone look as if it worked." https://gizmodo.com/the-iphones-first-demo-was-buggy-as-hell-1441324523 https://gizmodo.com/the-iphones-first-demo-was-buggy-as-hell...
- jryle70 6y agoThat's common for tech demos, especially software demos. Hardcoded values, scripted paths, etc. Nikola's presentation was something else: > "We will have a chain on the seats to prevent people from coming in just for the safety. I don't want someone to end up doing something and driving this truck off the stage," Milton said. "This thing fully functions and works, which is really incredible." He specifically boasted that it was a fully working machine. That's a lie.
- gibolt 6y agoThey didn't take 4 years more to get something working afterwards. Nothing that was promised or shown didn't work, even if hacky
- jo032 6y agoNikola unlike Apple has no track record of shipping anything. But I do see your point about what they're doing (overhyping the future roadmap) being quite common. IMO the people comparing this to Theranos are wrong. Theranos sold a product to consumers that didn't have the capabilities it was advertised to have, whereas this is a transparently stupid company without a single product or customer except for the founder's self-dealing at his house. A lot of retail investors are gonna be hurt by this, but it's not clear to me that it's fraud
- ric2b 6y agoThe difference is that's a demo and companies don't say "this prototype I have right here is fully functional", that's just a bold faced lie.