26 ms·
Apple Disabling 'Sign in with Apple' for Epic Games on September 11
- sandstrom 6y agoAlright, so Apple are forcing all developers to add Sign-in with Apple (if they have other third-party login services), privacy benefits aside. But if you Apple decide that they don't like you anymore, they'll not only cut you off the App Store, they'll also bury all (or a subset of) your users. Apple is starting to act more and more like a bully. [1] https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#sign-in-with-apple https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#sig...
- RL_Quine 6y agoIntentionally breaking the rules and filing a lawsuit against them with a marketing campaign isn't as if apple just decided they "didn't like" Epic.
- basch 6y agoBut my identity is my identity. Unless my account is compromised, dont stop ME, the customer, from using MY identity. Right now the major identity providers are all black holes of support, if something goes wrong, you have no recourse to get yourself back. I'd be more ok with Apple not allowing new accounts, but existing accounts should not be removed from people without them agreeing to a transition process to a non sso, local epic account.
- aboringusername 6y agoNo company should be immune to valid criticism. Microsoft was forced to add a browser pop-up on their OS, because it was considered they were abusing their market position. Of course, retaliation is expected, but Apple has been so inconsistent in their application of the rules that every decision they've ever made is going to be called into question. And you can be sure if there is even a hint at favouritism or revelations they've given certain partners special deals (that perhaps Epic wasn't allowed but Amazon was), then they are well and truly fucked. The EU is not going to mess around. They are going to question every single decision Apple has made, and will make a substantial report into their conduct especially the effects on EU business and the economy. If the EU announces they are investigating you, you should be very, very afraid, they do NOT mess around and will absolutely be at the least issuing a rather substantial financial penalty and changes you will be forced to make within the business (and the OS). Just look at what they've done to Google in the past few years, this is going to be no different. I expect huge changes are coming for Apple in 2021 and I think we'll all be better off for it. So sure, take the actions/steps you want, but be prepared to really defend them, and hope you actually have a case that is applied equally and fairly to all.
- tehwebguy 6y agoWhat exactly, and please be specific, do you think Apple is doing that is wrong? It is not clear from your comments.
- supernovae 6y agoIn the case of Microsoft, they denied the Xbox gaming app on the store after it had already been going through wide beta use on ios. They denied it on the grounds that they need to review every xbox game. Which is nonsense. They don't review every netflix movie, they don't review every spotify song, they don't review other content. The app that was denied doesn't actually download the games either, its a remote/online streaming player so it is exactly like "netflix for games". Rumor is, Amazon was cut a deal and others have had a deal so the rules don't seem applied in a fair way. Amazon isn't forced to use Apple Pay for example. (which i think is the part specific with this specific case)
- Spivak 6y agoBut that doesn't make a lot of sense. Say this case was actually about Nintendo and the Switch. Nintendo doesn't allow any X rated games anywhere ever on their platform. And then this game comes along that, to the user, just plays other games. Why shouldn't they be reviewed like everything else on the platform? To the user the implementation doesn't matter.
- supernovae 6y agoXbox doesn't allow "X rated" games and the all games have an ESRB rating that could be enforced as native app controls just like music streaming, tv & video streaming. in fact, it's safer than Youtube if safety is a concern...
- Spivak 6y agoI'm not saying Xbox does allow that kind of content. Just that "we're an app that runs arbitrary other apps and the discretion for what is available and the rules they follow is ours instead of Apple's despite the fact that to the user they might as well be running locally on the phone."
- modeless 6y agoEpic alleges that Apple is breaking the law, and breaking the App Store rules was a pretty much required step to establish standing to sue. Is Apple above the legal system, such that they should be able to destroy businesses that dare to challenge them in court, regardless of the merits of their claims and before they are even heard?
- RL_Quine 6y agoWhere does the marketing campaign fit into your story?
- modeless 6y agoEpic has a customer base that won't understand the nuances of the case. If they didn't tell their story to their customers in a way they can understand, they would suffer a lot of damage to their reputation, regardless of whether they are right or wrong, because customers are being cut off from a product they enjoyed. They will suffer reputation damage anyway, but they at least stand a chance of convincing some of their customers that they have a good reason for taking these actions.
- ksk 6y agoThere was also a marketing campaign for Net Neutrality by pretty much every single tech company. It's perfectly fine that anyone at anytime can raise awareness for their cause. And in this case, the cause is in everyones interest who is losing 30% of their sales to Apple in an immoral tax.
- minhazm 6y agoYour comment makes it sound it sound like Apple is breaking the law. Epic could have brought on this lawsuit while still complying with the App Store rules, in fact the judge suggested they do that so their users aren't impacted. They wouldn't be getting kicked off right now and the Sign-in with Apple button wouldn't be getting disabled. They chose to break the app store rules, which they did agreed to, AND they also decided to sue Apple. They could revert their app right now and Apple would restore their account and they could still continue their lawsuit. Epic is just weaponizing their user base in their fight against Apple.
- staticman2 6y agoEpic's legal position as I understand it is that Apple is behaving illegally and they likely had to break the illegal rule for standing to sue.
- ogre_codes 6y agoThe judge in this case have suggested that the case can proceed if Epic reverts their contract breaking changes. Apple has made it clear in court that if Epic reverts their changes they can restore their standing in the App Store. > they likely had to break the illegal rule for standing to sue. I'm not sure if this was ever true, but it's quite clear at this point that they can make their app comply with App Store policies and and continue their lawsuit at this point.
- staticman2 6y agoLitigation had just begun and you believe the judge has already made a ruling on standing? Sorry I don't know where you got this idea but that's now how the legal system works. Do feel free to quote a written ruling from the judge if you think I am off base. A binding ruling on standing which Apple has had the chance to appeal to the Supreme Court. You do know the trial judge isn't even the final judge that would decide on an issue of standing, correct? Not only is your claim implausible, but a lower court judge doesn't have the final say on standing even if your claim was true.
- ogre_codes 6y ago“[t]he sensible way to proceed is for [Epic to comply with the agreements and guidelines] and continue to operate while it builds a record.” Id. “Any injury that [Epic Games] incurs by following a different course is of its own choosing.” Id. Page 5 https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.364265/gov.uscourts.cand.364265.48.0.pdf https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.364265...
- nodamage 6y agoEpic already had standing to sue from the $300 million in Fortnite IAP fees Apple has collected.
- aclelland 6y agoIt also shows that Apple really don't care about their customers and would rather stick it to Epic than continue to support the people who choose to use their login system. If Apple wanted to show some goodwill towards the end users who were caught up in this mess they'd continue to allow them to log in or provide a migration path. I wonder if this will be used against Apple in the future since it's clearly hurting people of they lose access to their game, progress and purchases.
- moksly 6y agoI think you’re vastly underrating the seriousness in which a company like Apple would treat this matter. They aren’t a petty child or a bully. They’re a company, and their market research likely show them that the key advantage they have over Android is their closed, easy to use and secure ecosystem. If Epic succeeds in breaking that, they’ll lose a lot more than 30% of the 20 ish millions a month that Epic is currently losing on this ordeal.
- mantap 6y agoApple prevents people who paid $10000s for their top-of-the-line computer, from using an equally top-of-the-line GPU from Nvidia, because ~10 years ago some Nvidia laptop GPUs had problems and Apple is obsessive about punishing them. Apple does act like a petty child, and a rather obnoxious one at that. They are the worst kind of company, one that considers it is doing you a favour by allowing you to be their customer. Sent from my iPhone.
- fomine3 6y agoI suspect that why Apple prevents using NVidia is because they won't support Metal and force support CUDA.
- cmbailey 6y ago> If Apple wanted to show some goodwill towards the end users who were caught up in this mess they'd continue to allow them to log in or provide a migration path. From the original article: Customers will be able to "update to a standard email address and password" and, even after the deadline to do that, "those who did not transition from Sign in with Apple may be able to contact Epic Games to have their accounts recovered manually."
- smnrchrds 6y agoIt appears that Apple deeply believes all iOS users are, fundamentally, Apple's customers, not the customers of any apps or services they use n their Apple device. It is consistent with their belief to take away Apple users from companies they no longer want to do business with.
- chasing 6y ago> But if Apple decide that they don't like you anymore... Epic intentionally broke the rules. Maybe Apple's actions are right, maybe wrong. But don't pretend Apple just out-of-the-blue decided to do this to Epic for no reason.
- FreeFull 6y agoEpic did intentionally break the rules here, but I definitely have seen stories on HN before where Apple would refuse to let an app pass review without providing a proper reason why, and some more shadier things. If they do decide they don't like a developer, that developer really has little recourse.
- animex 6y agoAnd don't forget if you offer sign-in with G or F, and you don't add Sign in with A, you'll be in violation as well.
- m3kw9 6y agoHow childish is saying Apple doesn’t like Epic. They violated the terms, they wanted all this to happen and expected it. No one should be surprised they planned this months ahead
- Jaxkr 6y agoI really hope this will damage Apple’s brand and platform... They enforce their TOS randomly and this will happen to smaller companies too. Hurts the consumer too. People will be locked out of their Epic accounts.
- nemothekid 6y ago>I really hope this will damage Apple’s brand and platform... They enforce their TOS randomly and this will happen to smaller companies too. Epic's own customers are blaming Epic for this snafu. It's hard to see Apple as the bad guy when Epic is the one who broke the rules first. Almost every gamer isn't going to be sympathetic to a player who broke the rules and got banned.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoIf rules are illegal then breaking them to challenge them in court seems justified
- Spivak 6y agoAbsolutely, but I'm surprised to see so many people think that civil disobedience is a consequence free act. The whole point is that you break the law and then visibly suffer the consequences to get attention.
- mythz 6y agoThis wasn't some random ToS violation, this was a willful egregious violation done with subversion & malice to undermine the App Store's revenue model. I don't fault Apple for wanting to sever all ties with bad actors. > They enforce their TOS randomly and this will happen to smaller companies too. If their ToS is randomly enforced, which other App/Company violated the same terms as Epic which Apple chose to not enforce? I can't imagine there'll ever be a single case where a remote activated violation to sneak pass App Review would ever be allowed to remain on the App Store once identified.
- 6y ago
- zxcb1 6y agoJust installed Linux on my Mac; it felt like freedom.
- bluecake 6y agoHow is power management? Which distro did you go with?
- dazhbog 6y agoHad alot of issues with power when i last tried Linux on a mac air.. Something with alot of interrupts firing and the linux kernel was using more power as a result. Thinking of wiping macos and putting windows pro only and using wsl or something. If anyone runs linux/win on mac hardware smoothly I want to know more details.
- alrs 6y agoSell your old mac and buy five comparable used Thinkpads?
- paulsmal 6y agoDid the same with my macbook pro 2015. But switched to dell xps for more cpu cores. Never had any issues.
- heavyset_go 6y agoCheck out my posts[1] about using Linux on a Mac the way you'd use macOS. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23607850 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23607850
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoI wonder by what year it would be impossible at a hardware level to do that. Apple has already been making MacOS more or more like its phone OSes, raising the walls of the garden. They might soon implement some privacy/security 'think-of-the-children' type 'feature' that makes it basically impossible to install any other OS on your Macbook.
- aboringusername 6y agoThis is something many people feared might happen, and now, it's become a reality: Apple can, at will, remove your entire foundation or business, your (their) customers and your existence on iOS is just gone. Apple is a company that needs to be brought down a peg or two, it's far too 'valuable' in terms of its market worth, and needs a huge kick up the ass as Microsoft once had to show them some respect. And the EU will levy the world's biggest fine at Apple, I predict north of $5 billion if not $10 billion for abusing their status with this being a notable case. Certainly, for public opinion, it means you now have to "tow the line", no protesting allowed. If you dare challenge us, we WILL REMOVE YOU. Horrible company.
- tehwebguy 6y agoIt doesn't mean any of that, it just means that if you want your app on Apple's app store you can only use their payment processing. Also, businesses generally don't have to do business with other businesses that are suing them.
- 52-6F-62 6y ago> Certainly, for public opinion, it means you now have to "tow the line", no protesting allowed. If you dare challenge us, we WILL REMOVE YOU. Isn't that how all private companies work? If you walk into a mom-and-pop corner shop with no "shoes or shirt" you'll be removed as well—whether or not you think it's some kind of righteous protest.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoThose kinds of rules are for pubic health reasons. If you serve the public then you can't discriminate against protected classes. Though it may be legal to refuse service for other arbitrary reasons. When I worked in retail and scouted prices at the completion they would ask me to leave the store.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoYour example is definitely better.
- floatingatoll 6y agoThis should, at worst, only affect users who hide their email address from Epic and use the Apple relay service. Users who share their email address with Epic would be able to simply continue using it, with a reset password if necessary. Apple also has the option to continue allowing Epic to deliver password reset emails to private relay email addresses, using their pre-11th DKIM/SPF settings, so that users can continue to reset their account passwords by email and login and change their email address. Cynically, I assume that if Apple does continue relaying password resets, Epic would change their systems in some way that intentionally breaks that somehow, in order to create further public pressure on Apple.
- bmarquez 6y agoThis just makes it risky for the consumer to rely on 'Sign in with Apple', especially for cross-platform applications. I found it extremely convenient especially from a privacy perspective (your name and email are hidden) but the risk I'll lose access to my accounts is too much.
- prophesi 6y agoI think this shows the risks of relying on _any_ social sign in. If that endpoint breaks, whether via a protocol upgrade, server downtime, or what have you, you can now no longer access any services relying on that social login.
- lolsal 6y ago> This just makes it risky for the consumer to rely on 'Sign in with Apple', especially for cross-platform applications. The risk/reward cuts both ways. If a developer starts putting malware/whatever in their apps and Apple nukes their access to "Sign On With Apple" then it protects me as a user, and I value that.
- badwolf 6y agoSame with 'Sign in with Facebook' If Facebook blocks your developer account (Had this happen to my company once) your users can no longer sign in - though are they really your users at that point, or are they (Facebook/Google/Apple/etc...)
- paulsmal 6y agoWould be nice if Epic could join Valve in making Linux a better platform for games.
- DivisionSol 6y agoEpic has no interest in doing things that are for the good of average gamer. Just trying to slice of various pieces of pies, and Linux gaming is too small to care.
- pjmlp 6y agoThey could start by creating their "Steam" Phone.
- thatguy0900 6y agoIs the Microsoft store still a threat to anyone? I was under the impression Microsoft had given up on that
- mywittyname 6y agoThis is exactly why I never use OAuth for any account unless it's a throw away account. I always assumed that it would be Google who first decides to push around their weight by removing login capabilities. Can you sign into your account using an id and password?
- joshstrange 6y agoIt's always interesting to read the comments on articles about the Epic Games situation. We can have discussions about Apple's cut or how Apple operates their store but this is such a clear cut case that I'm honestly surprised so many HN readers are siding with Epic (or maybe it's just the anti-Apple crowd looking for any reason to crap on Apple). Epic tried to get Apple to allow a whole new store on their platform AND allow Epic to do all its own CC processing. Apple said no and Epic flipped a switch to offer CC processing for Fortnite and so Apple removed the app and disabled the account. Part of that account access included the Sign in with Apple and so that is going away as well. Epic isn't fighting for the little guy, they wanted their own store where they would take their own percentage of sales. Lastly I'll just say that while 30% might be too high I think a lot of people are overlooking the value that the App Store and the iOS platform as whole provides. I swear all of the comments about "I could host it myself and use stripe and pay way less" just reeks of "...you can already build such a system yourself quite trivially by getting an FTP account, mounting it locally with curlftpfs, and then using SVN or CVS on the mounted filesystem..."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bmarquez 6y ago> Epic isn't fighting for the little guy Nobody is fighting for the little guy, but this is still advantageous for the consumer. Apple is even fighting with Facebook, since you are forbidden to disclose the 30% cut with consumers.
- oefrha 6y agoIf Epic’s PC store is any indication, consumers will eventually have to face bullshit exclusives that force them to use the Epic store and largely cost the exact same.
- Rebelgecko 6y agoI don't see that as a downside to Epic . Some games on their storefront are exclusives and ones that are available elsewhere often have the same price?* Isn't that an argument to get rid of the App store? EVERY game there is exclusive- there's no other way to buy it for iOS. And it's a bit tautological, but games on the App Store will never be able to undercut prices of competing stores on the platform because there aren't any. *btw I don't totally agree with the implication. Even though many games cost the same as Steam, many of them also don't. Even if only a subset of games is cheaper on Epic, that's a win for consumers.
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoThere we go! I’ve been saying forever that social logins are a bad idea for just this reason. What do you do when someone separates you from your users with no appeal and no recourse? In this place you can just shrug it off because nobody uses Apple sign-in anyway (look bellow for the one guy who does’s outrage). But imagine if Google or Facebook did this? The couple extra people you picked up by not making them create a new account wouldn’t be worth losing all your users or customers that sign in with either behemoth. Prediction: future iOS release disables Fortnite app from running.
- cletus 6y agoSo this showdown between Epic and Apple is really interesting. My thoughts: 1. Epic had to know Apple would go nuclear. If they didn't, they're completely incompetent. Let's assume that's not the case. So Epic was itching for a fight. Maybe they were delusional about Fortnite's power here? 2. Apple is going nuclear here. The message is that Apple wants to crush this. This is Apple making an example of Epic. It looks like Apple is prepared for this fight and doesn't want it to gain traction; 3. Personally I think for the vast majority of developers the Apple payment ecosystem makes sense. It's just for the likes of Epic, Amazon or Netflix it doesn't as they're large enough to have their own so 30% is a huge fee for those companies and ultimately untenable; 4. Apple's monopoly will end at some point. I have to believe that even Apple knows that. So it's just a question of time and Apple doesn't want it to be now; 5. I don't think the solution is for anyone to be able to have payment infrastructure. That kind of Wild West is no good for anyone. It's just a question of what the compromise looks like; I really do see this as the dying days of the Apple and Google app ecosystems.
- jbverschoor 6y agoYeah.. that's really uncool. So I'm all pro-Apple for the whole Epic thing, but by this one action, I will refuse to use sign in with Apple for good. They're basically hijacking users
- mvanbaak 6y agoNo, they are not. Epic broke the contract, they were warned, they laughed it off and got their apple developer account terminated. There is no 'login with apple' when the developer account implementing it is terminated. It's one of the services Epic knew was going to be impacted. If anyone is hijacking users, it's Epic.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoThis is like the mafia asking me to pay up or else they will kidnap my children, and when I refuse to pay up and my children get kidnapped, you tell me "Well this was one of the things you knew was going to happen". If the demands are unfair or extortionate I don't blame people for not capitulating to them. This the same idea that forms the basis of civil disobedience.
- user5994461 6y agoI don't think it's fair to compare the case to child abduction. Epic can continue to serve Fortnite just fine through the app store while the case goes though court. There is nobody being kidnapped and murdered here.
- jbverschoor 6y agoWhat if they actually can’t? For example if trump kicks out fortnite? I’m sure there have been some incidents, maybe murder, related to fortnite.
- GiorgioG 6y agoAs an iPhone X owner/user I'm less and less inclined to go with Apple for my next phone. Apple & Google have a duopoly on mobile phone OSes. It's been how many years that they've been taking a 30% cut? You mean they haven't optimized/streamlined the App Store processes in what 10 years? At least Google is not the only Android handset game in town and you can still sideload apps.
- gpm 6y agoApple is doing it's absolute best to allow Epic to demonstrate irreparable harm in their motion for a preliminary injunction... This is a curious decision considering that the primary distinction between the part of the temporary restraining order the court granted (against Apple interfering with unreal engine) and the part the court denied (against Apple interfering with fortnite) was that the court thought that Epic had demonstrated irreparable harm with respect to the former and not the latter. I don't get it. (Legalities note: A temporary restraining order is basically a "preliminary preliminary injunction", the same idea, but granted earlier and only lasts until the court rules on the actual preliminary injunction)
- fatnoah 6y agoI also don't get it. It feels like Apple is just shooting itself in the foot. IIRC, if you allow sign in with Google/Facebook/etc. you're required to support Sign In with Apple. Now Apple is disabling that just for Epic. Apple's playing right into Epics assertion that App Store rules are applied arbitrarily and capriciously.
- fooey 6y agoThe judge ruled there is no irreparable harm because it's trivial for Epic themselves to repair the harm at any time that they themselves caused.
- gpm 6y ago*because it was trivial for Epic to return the situation to the status quo. The court was very much not making statements about harm in general (that's just not what happens at this phase of litigation). Apple is moving the situation farther from the status quo... which strikes me as a very bad legal strategy when the ruling for them was based on the idea that maintaining the status quo did not cause irreparable harm. I expect the judge is going to have some serious questions about whether this action is in response to them violating the terms of service (status quo as I believe the judge is interpreting the phrase), or if it's about retaliating against the lawsuit [1]. Novel punitive actions using services that aren't directly related don't strike me as business as usual. [1] Unless the court rules in some way that makes the whole question moot. We shouldn't read too much into how the court ruled on the TRO.
- shepting 6y agoThis is bad.
- sneak 6y agoI think Apple’s brain drain over the last decade is finally starting to show. This undermines their entire user-facing SSO strategy with anyone paying attention. (The dev-facing “implement our SSO or you can’t be on the iPhone” isn’t really a “strategy” per se.) Of course apps will have to support it to be in the App Store, but this means that any user paying attention now knows that their accounts/logins for PAID SERVICES are potentially at the mercy of Apple’s control crusade battles. Dangerous precedent.
- threeseed 6y ago> I really hope this will damage Apple’s brand and platform This is a really ignorant and pretty crazy comment. Apple is this year moving to their own silicon and likely next year we will see the fruits of the large number of AR/VR acquisitions. Seems to me like you would need a lot of specialist talent to do both.
- sneak 6y agoWrong thread? That quote isn’t me.
- hienyimba 6y agoA petty move like this clearly shows that Apple as a company has nothing valuable to offer developers. Shutting down "sign in" options shows that internally, Apple is looking for a way to hurt Epic in a manner that hurts the most but they are coming up short. Although iOS accounts for over one-thirds of Fortnite's 360million users, Epic has already made the brave decision to let that portion of revenue go and nothing Apple does will hurt them into begging Apple to let them back into their walled garden.
- DonaldPShimoda 6y agoI don't think this is a specific targeted thing. It just comes with the general deactivation of the Epic account. It's the same as the whole "Apple is banning all apps made with Unreal Engine!" which was a poor take on the issue. (What actually happened was Apple un-approved Epic's license, which had a cascading effect because Unreal Engine was signed under the same license, and so software dependent on Unreal Engine became no longer signed and thus was not going to be allowed on the App Store.) I'm not saying Apple's in the right here, but people keep construing it as Apple "looking for way[s] to hurt Epic" and I don't think that's quite what's going on. Epic performed a significant breach of the App Store terms in a way never tried before, and the repercussions (which are detailed in those terms!) are being enforced on a scale never seen before. But it's not like Apple's execs are scouring, looking for minute and petty ways to hurt Epic. They're just going to let the lawsuit run its course, and in the meantime enforce the terms of the agreement (willingly broken by Epic) to the fullest capacity.
- mthoms 6y ago>What actually happened was Apple un-approved Epic's license, which had a cascading effect because Unreal Engine was signed under the same license, and so software dependent on Unreal Engine became no longer signed and thus was not going to be allowed on the App Store. Developers using Unreal Engine certainly do not sign their app with Epic's credentials.
- DonaldPShimoda 6y ago
- londons_explore 6y agoEpic can't currently send updates for any of their games. I'd guess that by disabling 'Sign in with apple', those games will now throw errors and stop working. And it'll look like Epics fault. It's all a big game of optics and PR....
- troughway 6y agoThen they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.
- ping_pong 6y agoTo me Apple is only proving Epic's point. Don't you dare make Apple mad, otherwise your entire business on Apple ecosystem will be destroyed.
- fooey 6y agoAll it's showing is that breaking contracts has repercussions. If you abuse a service, and they cut you off, you don't get to cry about them enforcing their rules.
- foepys 6y agoContracts are not necessarily lawful.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- johnbellone 6y agoYou do if you can afford the legal fees.
- g42gregory 6y agoI would like to know what happened to the anti-trust laws and their enforcement?
- dbxgiri 6y agoI'm the guy who created the ORIGINAL system what Apple selling as "Sign in with Apple". [My system uses the industry standards like OAuth2. Apple ditched OAuth2 just to steal my work] This EPIC GAMES ban isn't "personal" as you all think. If Apple don't ban "Sign in with Apple" for epic games, then Apple is very much screwed. That's because I wrote the patent claim in such a way. This is my patent claim: https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/claim11-12.png https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/claim11-12.pn... This is the result. https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/swjs2.png https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/swjs2.png I'm afraid to tell you that "Sign in with Apple" ban on EPIC GAMES is just only a BEGINNING. If you get banned from the "App Store", you cannot use the email address you collected via "Sign in with Apple". Period. This is a blog post I wrote to warn the developers few months back. https://www.domboxmail.com/news/apple-copied-our-product https://www.domboxmail.com/news/apple-copied-our-product Someone who had gone through my blog post shared the blog post in HackerNews 4 months back. Our wonderful Hacker news users flagged the post, because they all believes Apple is a wonderful company. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22875499 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22875499
- zie 6y agoGiving you the benefit of the doubt, since I didn't read everything, all you have proven is they came to the same implementation(s) as you have. That doesn't mean they literally copied your work. But since you seem to have a patent, good luck in the patent fight.
- syspec 6y ago> The following table describes the list of ideas copied from the paper I published. For the sake of clarity, I published my white paper in February 2019. Apple released "Sign in with Apple" in June 2019. So they copied it and released it, in 3 months?
- dbxgiri 6y agoYes, they have enough resources for that. "Sign in with Apple" is a very simple system. This is what I sent to Tim Cook on June 06, 2019 https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/1.png https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/1.png The very next day, techcrunch published this article. https://techcrunch.com/2019/06/07/answers-to-your-burning-questions-about-how-sign-in-with-apple-works/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/06/07/answers-to-your-burning-qu... Question 4 and 9 reveals how they are stealing my work. I actually lied about the patent filing date in the mail I sent to Tim Cook. Once you file the patent you cannot add new content. That's why they boldly published that techcrunch post. I lied about the patent date because I sensed Apple looking at my iCloud files without my permission and I was right. This is what I had in Apple's iCloud. https://www.dropbox.com/s/n1v5i9cymts1lgi/Screenshot_2020-07-14-21-16-21-80.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/n1v5i9cymts1lgi/Screenshot_2020-07... https://www.dropbox.com/s/e26gsw47skhd1cq/Screenshot_2020-07-14-20-10-07-55.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/e26gsw47skhd1cq/Screenshot_2020-07... That's why they bought it when I told them "I filed the patent in 2018". I filed only the provisional patent application. I fixed most of the technical loopholes after that. This is what I had in my white paper. https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/spapi3.png https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/spapi3.png My white paper says "javascript-only". Apple stole it using the word "Javascript-based". Please see Techcrunch question number 4. https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/149.jpg https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/149.jpg My white paper says "e.g. Signup Forms, Facebook Connect , Google Connect etc.". Apple stole that with this excuse. "Note that Apple is not saying “social” login though. It’s saying “third-party,” which is more encompassing.". I.e. They categorized "Facebook Connect , Google Connect" as "Social Login" buttons to steal it. Please see Techcrunch question number 9. On June 10, 2019, an Apple lawyer replied to me. https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/2a.png https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/2a.png https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/2b.jpg https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/2b.jpg https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/2c.jpg https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/2c.jpg You can clearly see he goes like "possibly because the patent office yet has to publish it". That's because he bought what I sold. If you pay attention to his response he goes like "Apple's products or marketing strategies might seem similar". If you take a closer look at the mail I sent to Tim Cook, you can see that I never mentioned anything about "Strategy". They are stealing both my product as well as strategy. That's why he explicitly mentioned the word "strategy" to convince me. For the record, they didn't release the product on June 3, 2019. They only announced it at that time. It took them few more months. This message is the one why Apple went through my 300 page paper. https://www.mail-archive.com/nanog@nanog.org/msg99136.html https://www.mail-archive.com/nanog@nanog.org/msg99136.html [see the date] Apple realised I fixed the technical loopholes. After that they started to cover their asses. For example by wording their terms like this. https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/prohibited.png https://www.domboxmail.com/assets/images/apple/prohibited.pn... They also changed the company type to a "limited liability" company and notified all developers. https://www.dropbox.com/s/ovamzqp5jw7zjgn/2020-09-07_02-36-21.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/ovamzqp5jw7zjgn/2020-09-07_02-36-2... They notified the developers on Feb 18, 2019 which is one week before my international patent application publication. My WIPO application got published on Feb 27, 2020. https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/4a/55/1b/2188ba0a16c5ae/WO2020039327A1.pdf https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/4a/55/1b/2188ba0...
- iJohnDoe 6y agoNot sure if this has been mentioned in other threads yet - The Fortnite iOS app is critical even if you don’t play Fortnite on iOS. The app has the team voice feature so you can talk to teammates while playing Fortnite. Everyone in your party can be playing on different devices (Xbox, PS4, etc.). If you open the iOS app then you can transfer the party voice to an iPhone. The sound is really clear and you can use your headphones or AirPods to talk and listen. I’m sure some will be pissed if they lost access to that. If you deleted the app or bought a new iOS device, can you still install Fortnite from previous purchases?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ajhurliman 6y agoFolks are always talking about whether tech companies are monopolies or not, and I just don't think we're using the right vocabulary. Why not just create a new legal definition of a platform and create regulations that rein in the companies that fit that description? Namely, self-preference on the platform (Google, Amazon), false information (Facebook, Twitter), transparency of the source of ads, or in Apple's case usurious rates. I imagine if platforms came with some regulations, all those folks clambering to "be the Uber of X" would sound about as cool as being a wastewater treatment plant, or a fire station.
- marcosscriven 6y agoThe thing I find fascinating is how people come together in groups to form companies. And then the behaviour of those people is no longer assigned to them, but the company. Apple does this, Epic does that. But both are made of individuals. All those individuals have choices. Some of those individuals are unspeakably greedy.
- extremeMath 6y agoThis is why you should avoid Apple entirely. They can do this to you, your company, your apps. I'm a big fan of FOSS as much as possible.
- dpc_pw 6y agoIf you don't own your platform, the platform owns you.
- tynpeddler 6y agoIt's astonishing the number of people in this thread that don't understand the basis of Epic's lawsuit. There's way to much of "Epic broke the ToS, therefore everything Apple decides to do in retaliation is justified". First off, Epic's whole lawsuit is that parts of Apple's ToS are illegal, and thus Apple has no grounds to enforce it as they did. Secondly, the kind of retaliation Apple has attempted to do here very much resembles anti-consumer monopolistic behavior. Apple is using their position in one market (common sign in, developer tools, hardware) to enforce their position in another (app store). Classic no-no. Obviously the final determination on these points will be made by the courts. In the meantime, if Apple isn't an anti-consumer monopoly, they sure are walking, talking and quacking like one.
- strbean 6y agoI got drive-by downvotes from Apple fanbois for saying this in a previous thread, but I think this could actually have a significant impact on the iOS user base in the long term. I'd wager that a significant portion of iOS's user acquisition funnel is children for whom Fortnite is a requirement. All those kids will be throwing tantrums until their parents get them an Android device.
- 411111111111111 6y agoI seriously doubt that. Apple hardware has always been more about being a status symbol then utility. To the average Apple user it's just not cool enough if it isn't availble on Apple hardware. Even looking back I'm still surprised how effectively Apple polarized people into fans vs haters after steve jobs rejoined back then...
- coldtea 6y ago>Apple hardware has always been more about being a status symbol then utility. Citation needed. Even Linus Torvalds had used several pieces of Apple hardware (iBook, G5, Macbook Air)... Perhaps he was in search of "status" too?
- DennisAleynikov 6y agothere are a few nerds here and there that actually prefer the weird Unix/BSD that Mac OS X is based on but theres no way Linus Torvalds is using the normie focused MacOS Big Sur and the current environment Apple used to support freedom in programming and use of the computer. That has not been the case anytime recently, they've taken the prison system of iOS and slowly implemented it on 'macOS'
- SergeAx 6y agoSo, for app developers, there's no feasible strategy out of it. Apps need social login, disabling it at all is out of the question. Implementing any social login means implement login with Apple ID (and following desing guidelines), or app will not pass review. By default, login with Apple gives a bogus email not connected to anything, so there's no way to send there a random password "just in case Apple want to kick us out". And app cannot ask for real email just in case, because it will not pass the review. Check and mate.
- mvanbaak 6y agoThe flaw in your comment is: "just in case Apple want to kick us out" If you simply decide to break the terms of your contract with them, yes, they will kick you out. But this is not 'in case Apple wants'. It's because the developer wants to break contract.
- m3kw9 6y agoThe “if Apple wants..” is a line of argument many are making here. To me Epic is disgusting in trying to pose as a saviour, but at the end for them is about more money.
- SergeAx 6y agoTell that to the author of HN reader app, which was twice rejected for not applying censorship inside his app [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24410652 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24410652
- user5994461 6y agoThat example is pure bullshit. Apple and Google have banned applications about COVID since the world was littered with apps and scams trying profit from the COVID pandemic. The author is making a news app that's promoting COVID articles and content, so it got instant banned on sight. That's super clear cut and straightforward even though he doesn't like that. You really shouldn't call that censorship. You're making a disservice to countries who experience real censorship, where people risk their life for saying innocent things.
- poorman 6y agoHow is this not Anti-Competitive behavior? "If you go up against us, we will take away your users and thus your source of income." Seems cut and dry to me.
- m3kw9 6y ago“Go against” meaning purposely breaking a TOS and then suing Apple. Epic wanted this so the crowd can call Apple the bad guy when they react to the terms.
- speedgoose 6y agoAs an user, it means that I must not use Sign in with Apple.
- drenvuk 6y agoI don't get why on Hackernews anyone would ever defend Apple here. Regardless of whether they're right to do this if Epic wins their court case against them we stand to gain the most benefit. Apple's incredibly high walled garden is honestly the scariest thing for me. If I develop for windows I can simply distribute my application on my site easily. With Android I can tell people to download from F-Droid if necessary. With MacOS We're nearly at the point that Apple will tell us and users what we can and cannot install or develop for the system. iOS and iPad OS are already there. Epic caused their own pain here, sure but What other way can we actually get a semi open platform that we're not being taxed on? Why can't we as users and developers have options on iOS? I think that if an operating system allows third party apps they should be _legally_ required to allow other app stores, sideloading of programs without penalty for doing so, or both. That goes for any platform, developed at any time by anyone. I have been completely at a loss for anyone defending Apple while hoping that Epic loses their fight. The first makes sense but the second is absolutely baffling.
- lolsal 6y ago> Epic caused their own pain here, sure but What other way can we actually get a semi open platform that we're not being taxed on? As an Apple user, the whole point here is that it's not an open system. I just can't get riled up over a developer not following the rules of a platform. I use Apple because the Apple ecosystem is valuable to me - the store, the SSO, the Apple ID, the UI/UX, the hardware - all of it. I don't care about Epic or any other developer that doesn't want to play nice with that ecosystem. Those kinds of developers don't have any value to me.
- losingthefight 6y agoI see this argument a lot, and I think it's fine if not a tad flawed. If that's what you want, you can keep it. I don't really see anyone saying "kill the review process" and "open everything by default". This would all go away if Apple simply made it a setting to allow other IPAs AND allowed outside payment / subscription management. Keep the garden if you want it. Don't enable outside installs. If you don't want to support a company not using Apple Pay and the like, then don't! You're the consumer! The difference here is Apple doesn't give you a choice. Even if the developer does all the legwork to build a payment system (for example, they have a web app as well) and market the app on their own, they have to give Apple their cut. You don't get a choice and neither does the developer.
- mlazos 6y agoI honestly don’t think Apple should be investigated for antitrust and I don’t think they can be considered a monopoly. There are plenty of choices in the gaming space, and there are a lot of android competitors to the App Store. I really don’t think epic should have any standing here. They’re just mad about Apple’s 30% cut. Apple charges a premium to people to be in their ecosystem and they do it anyway. This isn’t a monopoly by any definition. I do think removing Sign In with Apple is a bad look, but Epic is in over their head here, they really shouldn’t be suing Apple.
- cryptica 6y agoGames are often very low margin products, so it makes completely sense that Apple's one-size-fits all 30% fee wouldn't be suitable for a lot of companies. What doesn't make sense is how Apple got away with it for so long. The ad '1984' by Apple has become the biggest, most hypocritical piece of propaganda every created.
- mvanbaak 6y ago> Games are often very low margin products Yeah, so, did you check how much Epic earns with fortnite? I wont call this 'low margin' at all.
- cryptica 6y agoProfit margin is about the percentage they make after costs have been factored in. Their profit margin is indeed low; 12% of the revenue... compared to Apple who takes 30%. See https://gamerant.com/epic-games-store-revenue-split-explained/#:~:text=Sweeney%20also%20said%20that%20Epic,payment%20processing%2C%20and%20customer%20service https://gamerant.com/epic-games-store-revenue-split-explaine.... So my point is absolutely valid and it is shocking that Apple makes almost 3 times more money from Fortnight than Epic makes. Imagine spending years building an app and then someone else ends up making 3 times more money from it than you do...
- mvanbaak 6y agoThe 30% apple (and all other stores) “take” are not pure profits. They offer a lot of services that cost them money. So no, apple is not making 3 times as much.
- cryptica 6y agoApple's offering is a lot simpler and a lot more hands-off. I doubt their costs are very high and if they are, they're probably wasting the money because I can't see what's so complex about the Apple App store... And I'm a developer so I know that operating at that scale comes with challenges but it really doesn't compare to the challenges which the creators of Fortnight must face on a daily basis.
- ineedasername 6y agoDoes this prevent users from accessing their existing account/loot/vbucks etc through Epic directly?
- ineedasername 6y agoIt might only end up as little more than a rounding error, but I think Apple is losing this fight with consumers: Both my kids like Fortnite, and preferred to play on hand-me-down iPads. It was their main activity on any iOS device. Now they barely touch their iPads: We already had a single Nintendo Switch that they both shared, so we let them spend the money they saved to split the cost & buy a second Switch lite so that they can both still play together. After getting used to haptic joystick controls, they much prefer them to touch controls. They both now say "I hate Apple". They didn't get that from me: I think both companies are engaged in an arms race of their own self interest, and have explained the issue to my kids as being about both companies wanting to make money. Something like this: "Apple created a store and wants people who sell items in the store to share money from their sales, which is the way stores generally work. Epic thinks that Apple & Google take way too much of that money and Epic wants to keep more of that money, though they are willing to let users get some saving too." They both still hate Apple now, and when my daughter did pick up her iPad for the first time in days, she was afraid to spend her money on a different game she wanted because she thought Apple might take it away. (She's 7... she also kicks my --s in Fortnite. I'm smart, and decades of practice mean I pickup videogames fast enough to be above average in any new game. She is better & smarter than me in every way. I work in data science, and I'm half convinced that if I taught her the basics of SQL, python, R and a few presentation-layer reporting technologies, she could do my job in an hour of her free time each day. But, you know, child labor laws.)
- atarian 6y agoAll this trouble just to save 30% on a pair of digital trousers.
- lexusgx 6y agoMy gut reaction: it is a win to put the brakes on a virtual currency shop disguised as a video game. Perhaps this is something that needs legislative action. Addictive behaviors that turn people into paypigs for a minimally productive business are harmful.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 6y agoI don't care about Epic but I welcome this lawsuit. If they win, it will significantly improve the lives of millions of developers and users.
- type0 6y agoBoth users and developers should learn that they can not trust Apple with anything, not their data, not their income, nothing. It's the most abhorrent consumer tech company and should receive much more public shaming.
- bokohut 6y agoSo many entrepreneurs "drinking the kool aid" building their great idea that depends on others platforms of which on the surface appears warm and receptive however welcome to the real world which is cold and shunning. If you do not own your hardware and software systems your weakest links are the 3rd party providers which do not even know your name. Interesting again to see that "fees" started the core battle fight. Visa and MasterCard, along with other brands, are acutely aware of the coming payments swing and continue on buying sprees to protect their toll road. Whether it be crypto, RTP, FedNow or remains to be credit card is yet to be known however these events and more will continue to push businesses to bring payments in house cutting out more and more middlemen. This is long overdue.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- snyp 6y agoEpic here is not telling the truth. Apple has revoked their developer license which revoked the Sign In with Apple certificates. Apple probably sent them a courtesy notice about it but epic is just spinning it as if Apple is disabling their Sign In with Apple capabilities. This just looks bad on Epic.
- user5994461 6y agoThis here, should be the top comment. The court already validated that Apple disabling Epic account was okay.
- snyp 6y agoI don’t think what epic says here is entirely true. Apple said that they were going to remove / revoke Epic’S developer account which would probably revoke the certificates for Sign In with Apple as a result Apple would have emailed them about it. I think epic is just spinning it to suit their narrative. You wouldn’t want apps on the App Store with expired certificates to be able to use login and registration systems.
- pmarreck 6y agoOf the many things I never counted on happening this year that happened anyway, becoming a Fortnite fan was certainly near the top
- newbie578 6y agoAgain so many people defending Apple here just because they love their Macs... This just shows how Apple has a "deity" like status in the community, fanboys here are willing to die defending Apple and their arbitrary "rules". Just dare to imagine if tomorrow Microsoft came out and said Steam broke ToS and starting September 11 all accounts signed-up over outlook.com will be disabled. There would be riots on the streets and buildings burning, Nadella would give a resignation within a week. Yet for Apple, the rules don't apply (ironically). Tim Cook blatantly commits perjury in front of Congress and no one bats an eye, yet people are still willing to trash Gates how "arrogant" he was to Congress 20 years ago. The only true hope is for EU step in and completely revamp the App Store
- dpc_pw 6y agoApple is just returning to its roots. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xiAgrrwL_mk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xiAgrrwL_mk I know, I'm old.
- iainctduncan 6y agoMy impression so far is that Epic is playing a long game. And playing it perfectly. God I hope so.
- newobj 6y agoNow that's what I call a slapfight
- grwthckrmstr 6y agoThe comments and discussions are fascinating to observe. Here's the voices you can hear loudest and my thoughts on those. > Epic broke Apple's ToS Just because terms have been set, does not mean they are right or that they shouldn't be challenged. Remember, these terms were arbitrary when they were first set, why defend them as if it's written in the constitution? > But Epic is a big greedy corp that only cares about its own profits Yeah but Epic's win extends as a win to every small player in the ecosystem. In terms of size, Apple is a trillion-dollar company whereas Epic is multi billion-dollar company. The only people who can challenge Apple are companies like Epic, and not the small players and indie app & game developers. > Apple's reactionary behaviour is just proving Epic's case I know right! But that's the whole point that Epic started this saga with. Actually, it started before. Earlier this year HEY/Basecamp guys faced the same issue. Obviously they created a huge uproar, figured a path that works for them, and then shut up completely (instead of continuing the fight, as they promised they would). Epic here is fighting to make a change that will benefit everyone. > But I'm an Apple user because I like the closed ecosystem I get it, you want a platform to make decisions for you. In which case, you can continue using the App Store to get your dose of apps and games. But why does your indecision stand in the way of having alternative app stores where people who want to have a choice, get to make that choice. > But Apple isn't a monopoly There's 2 major phone OSes in the world. If you're making any kind of mobile game or mobile application, you HAVE to be on either or both mobile OSes. iOS has 60% of US market share, which means it IS a monopoly. Apple exclusively owns iOS. Apple is a monopoly. Closing thoughts In the end, I feel that people who don't understand the stand Epic is taking are people who have never done something of their own and failed or faced undue stress on their venture due to a large gatekeeper who stamps on whoever it pleases. I feel the people defending Apple here NEED to defend Apple to satisfy their internal narrative, which would reflect in their life's pursuit to be a 1 in 10,000 employee of a billion-dollar company. I'm airing the dirty laundry in the hopes that everyone gains empathy and perspective.
- mas3god 6y agoI dont like apple, but they should be allowed to do what they want with their platform. Nobody's forcing us to buy macs & iPhones.
- nojvek 6y agoAt this point if people really think Apple is a bully and want to do something out it, pull your apps out of App Store. Better yet do an over the air update letting the users know how much of a bully Apple is. If a significant % of apps protest, then Apple has to bend down. Apple isn’t with much if they don’t have the developer and customer mindshare. Microsoft lost the mobile market because they couldn’t make a viable AppStore. Those Nokia phones were fantastic but the apps were very subpar.
- lawlessone 6y agoThe bootlicking comments on that page..