41 ms·
I am a middle-aged adult with no children who's worked at tech firms for the past couple decades. To be honest, the "resentment" of those without children have
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I am a middle-aged adult with no children who's worked at tech firms for the past couple decades. To be honest, the "resentment" of those without children have for "benefits" those with children get strikes me as extremely selfish, immature and displaying a total lack of empathy. This is time off specifically to take care of children, something now that has become exceedingly more difficult in Covid times.
What's next, complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I?
If anything, I'm thankful for all those people with kids who will (a) take care of the continuation of the human race, and more selfishly (b) support our society and economy when I am too old to do so.
- summitsummit 6y agonice opinion, but it's just that
- mmm_grayons 6y agoWell, there's a good argument to be made that having children is much more of a choice than having cancer. And yes, it's natural to be selfish, because employment benefits are at least something of a zero-sum game. More for one often means less for another. I could easily argue that those who demand extra benefits because of a personal decision they made (having children) are more selfish than those who resent that they receive them.
- wffurr 6y agoSociety doesn't exist without children. Child care is right up there with fire departments for things you, personally, as a childless person whose house has not burned down, need to exist in order to live in society, and not just a hermit in the woods.
- asciident 6y agoIt's not so clear to be honest. The global population is growing and leading to environmental disasters, and it's not clear why we need 10 billion people on this planet, rather than a more manageable 100 million.
- wffurr 6y agoParents in tech firms in developed countries are reproducing below the replacement rate already. Regardless, you need a next generation for society to continue to function.
- asciident 6y agoI think it makes more sense to think of the human population globally, rather than on a per-country basis. We have one planet, and environmental problems are not self-contained inside a country's borders. You're right we need a next generation for society to continue. But right now we're trending in the opposite direction. Just like your first concern about a fast-growing invasive species is whether it becomes extinct if it doesn't reproduce enough.
- gtaylor 6y agoWhy did you use the word "demand", there?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ll931110 6y agoThe problem is, people without children are told (or required) to pick up the workload left behind when the coworkers having children taking (multiple) weeks off. For once or twice that might be okay, but if became a chronic problem, no wonder they are not happy.
- PeterisP 6y agoWell then, direct the anger at those who do the telling or the requiring.
- pojzon 6y agoThat not always help but for sure will backfire at you. Im writing next part as a parent of two. We have in team people who take multiple days off due to taking care of children, often not even counting it as taking a day off. Management doesnt care and expects people who do not “exploit” their privilages to do work for 2-3-4 people. Its also not the way to go, but any comment about that is a hard “stop being so selfish”. What to do in such a situation? Start doing the same to make company bleed money while frozen?
- Apocryphon 6y agoHonestly, this is why labor unions could help even highly-paid occupations such as software engineering. There needs to be something to serve as a counterweight to management, especially during economic downturns when finding a new job is more difficult.
- slg 6y agoDear boss, My team is really struggling with the challenges that have come along with this global pandemic. Everyone is doing their best given the situation, but we aren't able to deliver the same level of productivity on a consistent basis. Can we setup a call to discuss adjusting expectations and shifting workloads in order to keep everything running as smoothly as possible? Sincerely, pojzon There is an email template for you.
- Reedx 6y agoOnly after having a kid did I fully realize just how much time and freedom I had.
- MacsHeadroom 6y agoFreedom to go to bars (closed), clubs (closed), trips (not happening), concerts (canceled), conventions (postponed indefinitely), festivals (closed), etc... Most things childfree people get meaning out of are canceled until further notice. You still have your parenthood. What do we get? Extra work for equal pay? Great, that'll make the pandemic suck less.
- RHSeeger 6y agoThe freedom to just sit down and breath. I don't think you really grasp just how much having children robs you of your "self" and your down time. Heck, even the ability to go to the store to shop for food can be seriously impacted by having a child. Having a child doesn't just take away your ability to go out for a drink; it takes away EVERYTHING and replaces it with different things.
- rdtwo 6y agoHe won’t get it until/unless it happens to him. I was the same way once
- pb7 6y agoChildless people don't feel bad for parents for the same reason they don't feel bad for startup founders that work 100 hour weeks. You're putting in the effort for 95% your own benefit (a child that grows up and keeps you company on Christmas in old age, or a big pay day from selling your company), and 5% societal benefit (children growing up and joining the workforce, or a company providing a valuable service and employment). At the end of the day, there will be enough people that pursue these things without any extra incentives so you don't get the pity as well. You can disagree and still see the argument as valid. I certainly won't give a shit if no one pities me for being a parent because the time and effort is mostly for me -- just like it is for everyone else.
- codemac 6y ago> cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? In my experience they actually don't, and they aren't paid during the same period either. They are forced to take medical leave, and receive significantly reduced pay.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- klipt 6y agoDepends on the state and employer, in California at a big tech firm you generally receive full pay for FMLA leave (since the employer will top up the reduced amount provided by the state). But then it's the same with parental leave, which also depends on the state and employer.
- pojzon 6y ago> and receive significantly reduced pay. That depends on the country you work in. In Poland you get 80% of normal pay which tbh is a really good deal.
- majormajor 6y agoThat's not a "really good deal." Do 20% of your normal expenses magically go away? And if you have to spend any extra money of your own for care or related things (maybe none of your old clothes fit anymore!) it gets worse. Plus, you know, there's the HORRIBLY ILL part of it.
- pojzon 6y agoMy expenses dont go away, but I dont have to work in the same time either. Time is money, so for 8h/day I get 80% of pay and still have those 8h..
- ithinkso 6y agoAnd only 30days/yr of this is from the employer's pocket, the rest is from the state which is also a good deal the other way around.
- mdoms 6y agoYou're comparing your parenthood with cancer, but it's the others who lack empathy?
- dang 6y ago"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mc32 6y agoI agree. Parents are making sacrifices which benefit society as a whole. Those children the parents are taking care of now will be the ones who will provide for the one complaining now via taxes as well as services rendered to them. If anything, companies should be providing more childcare so that more women (as well as some men) will have less of a burden balancing career and caregiving. I see these people as being petty complainers who wouldn’t raise their own children (own or adopted) but complain someone else is willing to be a productive member of society engaging in the workforce and raising the productive adults of tomorrow when these complainers will be asking for benefits and services that would be unavailable without future adults. It's similar to "I don't take the bus, why should my taxes pay for public transit." I would concede if there are people exploiting this privilege then that’s a problem and management should address it.
- ng12 6y agoWhat I've seen is the complaints are largely coming from couples that want to raise kids while both parents work full time jobs. Asking for fewer hours so you can continue that lifestyle is asking your employer and fellow employees to subsidize your second income, not your ability to have and raise children. My coworkers with SAH spouses aren't feeling the burn anywhere near as badly -- it's just an extended summer for them. I feel a lot of empathy for single parents but those seem to be relatively rare in the field.
- puszczyk 6y agoI think school and day care are a reasonable assumption. It’s a bit unfair to say — _keep your spouse at home because there maybe once-in-a-lifetime pandemic and the schools will be closed_.
- alisonkisk 6y agoIt's more fair to say "save some money for a rainy day" or "you will have to sacrifice some of your quality of life and savings due to the pandemic".
- qppo 6y agoIt's a normal and rational human emotion to feel anger or annoyance at differential treatment for no fault of your own, whether that boils over as "resentment" is a function of your own emotional maturity in my opinion. But there is a growing resentment from "child-free" folks who take issue with your points a) and b). I don't know how I feel about the first point but the second one is a critical failure point in our society and economy that should be removed, and we shouldn't necessarily design an economy with incentives that promote growing population.
- doopy-loopy2 6y ago"I'm thankful for all those people with kids who will (a) take care of the continuation of the human race" lol gtfo
- dang 6y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? You've been doing it repeatedly and we're trying for something different here. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=stave%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...
- purple-again 6y agoI will guess the sentiment is common to people who get upset when their coworkers get to take cigarette breaks and they don’t. The perceived unfairness of them getting a benefit you want (10 minute break every hour hanging out behind the store) compounded by the feeling that they are the better one because smoking is a bad thing anyway so why am I being “punished” for making the right choice? Those of us with parents understand the other commenters point about what’s next “getting upset about cancer patients going to the doctor” because yeah...we love our children very much. Childless people can be forgiven for thinking that the time is more akin to sitting around the table playing a board game with everyone laughing and having a great time so they are resentful that you are getting a benefit in the form of extra time off and for a lot of them probably compounded by the feeling that they made the better noble decision by having no kids. In both cases the business is letting it happen (smoke breaks and child care) for really only one reason. It makes more business sense to accommodate the issue then it does to try and fight it when the cause is societal and pervasive.
- fizixer 6y agoI have two babies: - My pure math research (nothing to do with my day job). Possibly resulting in a part-time PhD program. - My financial portfolio (again not related to my day job). These two babies of mine are as precious and valuable to me (maybe more) than your human babies are to you. Oh, and they take way more time. Do I get extra benefits as a parent of two babies?
- pavlov 6y ago“My financial portfolio is as valuable and takes more time than your human babies” — You must have a Master’s degree in Empathy from Trump University.
- Swenrekcah 6y agoAnalytical as you surely are, you might notice that your babies are, in fact, not babies in the sense of the word under discussion. Therefore you do not get PTO for growing them.
- MacsHeadroom 6y agoUnequal PTO is a subsidy from your coworkers. If active workers don't pick up the slack, their stocks loose value. You want more PTO? Trade me your stock options.
- rdtwo 6y agoYep they get the same benefits eveone else does. You get to be screwed by government mishandling of covid. Your employer simply decided you were getting screwed less than your peers so they shifted a bit more in your direction. At will employment you are free to quit of course.
- newtoday 6y agoComparing your math research and stock portfolio to raising children, especially when using amount of time as part of the argument, is indescribably laughable.
- R0b0t1 6y agoWith this I think there is a unique take: typically those who feel comfortable having children are better off. Those who are better off get rewarded for having children. So it can be a "rich get richer" problem. If you are currently childless you might end up subsidizing your coworker's choice to have children to your detriment.
- RHSeeger 6y agoAnd in non-pandemic times, they're subsidizing the continuation of society for the childless, to their own detriment (less free time, less self time, less money, less social life, less sleep; the list goes on and on and on).
- Mirioron 6y agoExcept children benefit their parents. Before social security, children were your social security. This mechanism hasn't disappeared. Childless people already pay more taxes that are used to subsidize other peoples' children, but they don't get nearly the benefit from that that parents do.
- wrkronmiller 6y agoI strongly suspect that, among wealthy tech workers, children are a net drain when you factor in: - These workers have enough income to finance their own retirement easily - The additional real estate to raise children near a tech hub is often prohibitively expensive - These kids will almost certainly go to college and maybe private school, which adds up _rapidly_ It's important to consider _who_ we are talking about here.
- Mirioron 6y ago>It's important to consider _who_ we are talking about here. But then their noble sacrifice isn't as important for society anymore, is it? If we simply need more children, then it's not relevant whether they're born to the family of the tech worker or someone worse off.
- loosescrews 6y agoAt least in the US, the pandemic has changed everyone's life created stress for everyone. These policies seem to indicate that non-parents don't have an additional burden worth recognizing. It is easy to see it this way too as most of the managers and executives at big tech companies are parents. For young non-parent tech workers, this may be the first time that they have to figure out how to feed themselves during the work week. I know many people who moved from home, to school, to big tech work were all of their meals are provided. This was one of the big perks they were sold when joining the company, and now it has been pulled out from under them. Some of them know how to cook, others don't. Either way, they have to learn how to manage working food preparation into their schedule.
- jansan 6y agoIs this a joke? My 12 year old son would be able to cook for himself if it was required. Of course the kitchen would be a total mess. With instructions like the video below everybody can learn how to cook within a few days. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sw_Ze9zIafM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sw_Ze9zIafM
- nicbou 6y agoAs someone who loves to cook, I don't fully agree. 60% of cooking is logistics: knowing what to eat, setting time aside for grocery shopping and meal preparation, and keeping food waste to a minimum. In my opinion, this is a lot harder than the actual cooking. If you've never done it before, it's surprisingly hard. Cooking in a well-organised, well-stocked kitchen is very different from starting with an empty pantry, blunt knives and no idea of what to do.
- RHSeeger 6y agoI have a hard time agreeing with this. Cooking things like hot dogs, dogs and beans, pasta and meat sauce, etc... that's relatively simple for anyone. And it can be done for the time being until they figure out how to cook better things; things that will make them happy. The ability to ease your way into cooking for one's self should make it relatively trivial. Honestly, compared to figuring out how to work from home without losing 50% of your productivity (for someone that wasn't already setup for it), the food part seems easy.
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoI'm a parent and a cancer patient. I have no problem if someone complains about the time off I take. Though I don't think anyone would complain. I keep it to a minimum, and I make up for it when I can. Some people are going to sacrifice their personal life, and their health for their careers. I decided a long time ago that I was not going to do that. I accept that others may climb the corporate ladder faster than me, and I agree that they should.
- tyldum 6y agoI feel those who complain fixate on other people's benefits, but neglect their own. By not being at work, those people lose out on opportunities within the company. And don't underestimate the stress generated by not working 100%, but there is nothing you can do about it. Not to mention trying to pick up the slack after the kids are in bed, after you've done homework/homeschooling. We all do our best with the current situation, it's not like we go home to slouch on the couch and laugh about the suckers at work without kids.
- gones00n 6y agoI wonder why tech companies aren't allowing the option to change from full-time (100%) to part-time (60%), while retaining all the benefits especially healthcare in the U.S. This can help ensure that everyone is being measured fairly - for example parents can opt to change to 60% and their role/responsibilities will be adjusted accordingly. Management will be able to hire to fill the gaps. Conversely if you're a parent that opts not to change to part-time and fails to deliver per the full-time expectations, then you get a "NI" rating or PIP. Seems like this might normalize the compensation/recognition dimension at the heart of this debate. For parents that feel they can't stomach the pay cut from the switch, then there's no option but to work nights/weekends.
- ajford 6y agoSo it might depend on the individual and company in question, but not everyone is "loosing" time parenting, and in many cases the allowance they're seeking is the ability to flex their schedule so they can do something like a 4hr schedule in the AM and a 4hr schedule in the late afternoon/evening. They're not seeking fewer hours for the same pay, but the ability to work their 8 hours when they can instead of a standard 9-5 schedule. Yes, this may not work for everyone, but in plenty of situations there's no reason that should be a difficult ask. As long as I complete my sprint work, why should it matter whether I wrote that code or report or graph between 12-4PM or 6-10PM?
- kevstev 6y agoAs a mid 30s childless man I completely agree. We essentially sent people home on a Friday, told them to figure out a work from home situation, and then they were told welp your kids aren't going to school either, and whatever childcare you had lined up has now vanished too- and this is all happening in the course of a few days at most. So now you have kids to worry about all day, home schooling to oversee, focusing on your actual job, and then on top of that oh yeah there is still a mildly terrifying pandemic going on with an uncertain outcome. I work in the NYC area, and everyone is tight on space here as it is. I barely held it together during all this, how parents did with young children is beyond me. Maybe I am making assumptions here on the general political leanings of those here, but if you are talking about supporting anything like Medicare for all, UBI, BLM, PPP or even just support the Democratic party in general, pulling a little extra weight for those in a time of need is IMHO a relatively small ask that you as an individual can implement compared to those agendas.
- rootusrootus 6y agoIgnoring the obvious downsides for a moment, I'd happily trade places with one of my childless coworkers right about now. This morning I went up and down the stairs at least ten times while trying to get my 7- and 9-year old kids successfully established in their first remote learning session, simultaneously participating in two consecutive Zoom meetings with coworkers, and figuring out how to solve a nagging issue in our application that has stumped the rest of the team. I won't be cut any slack by management, in fact it works out the opposite -- as the team lead, I need to be around all day to answer questions, solve high-level problems, and fit in a bit of architecture work around new projects around the edges. I put in more work time for the office now than I did if you added up all my previous office time, lunch time, and commutes. I wouldn't give up my kids for anything but I will be so very happy when this pandemic is safely behind us and we can get back to something approximating what we had before.
- Mirioron 6y ago>I'd happily trade places with one of my childless coworkers right about now. Yes, some things come with downsides. I'm sure a lot of people would also want to trade places with you during the happy times you have with your kids. But you can't usually get the benefits without the downsides.
- nicbou 6y agoI don't fully agree with you. Back when I worked in retail or fast food, smokers could step out for a 5 minute smoke break every once in a while. As a non-smoker, I wasn't allowed to just sit there for 5 minutes. At the end of the day, we got paid the same, but smokers got 30 minutes off, courtesy of the non-smokers who picked up the slack. Likewise, parents are excused from work because they have children. I fully appreciate the difficulty of being a parent and the necessity for those measures. I don't think we really have a choice. It's either that or we watch them slowly crack under the pressure. That being said, they chose to have children, and I chose not to. Whatever I have going on instead can't have priority over my work schedule. Whether it's a side hustle or a little league baseball team, it has to wait. To be clear, I want those parents to get the time they desperately need. However, if this arrangement is to last, then childless employees should also get time for their personal obligations, whatever they might be.
- wonnage 6y agoYou can't wave away taking care of kids as "personal obligations", as though it was akin to doing laundry or something. Also, "I chose not to" is a silly statement - do you think all the parents looked into a crystal ball and thought yes, despite the oncoming pandemic, I will have these kids"?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ethanwillis 6y agoThey get the perk of more flexibility because they're providing a service to society, raising children for the next generation. You don't get this perk because you didn't have children. Your contribution is more work because you have more time to do it.
- nicbou 6y agoThis argument is made again and again in this thread, and it never got addressed. 1. There are already functional mechanisms for contribution. A single, childless person is already contributing more through their taxes. The government already heavily subsidises child-rearing. 2. Child-rearing is given an arbitrary pass that other equally charitable actions wouldn't get. A single, childless person couldn't let his commitment to Doctors Without Borders affect his work performance. 3. I'm not sure if "children are our future" is our future. This model might not be viable forever as the world population keeps growing. This is a whole other can of worms.
- falcolas 6y ago> the "resentment" of those without children have for "benefits" those with children get strikes me as extremely selfish, immature and displaying a total lack of empathy. Unpopular opinion: We should not be rewarding or elevating people for having unprotected sex without the support network to take care of their children in the event they are unable to attend school. There's a thousand reasons a child might not be able to attend school. If your plans for raising a child rely upon schools being able to take them off your hands for 8+ hours a day (not to mention feeding them), that's your problem, not ours. It's "selfish" and "immature" to bring a child into the world that you don't have the time or means to raise.
- dimitrios1 6y agoJust do yourself a favor and relearn basic human empathy again.
- falcolas 6y agoI have. I have a lot of empathy for children who are going hungry because their parents brought them into this world without a means to support them. I have a lot of empathy for children who are unwanted, ignored, and otherwise harmed by "inconvenienced" parents. I have no empathy - I have nothing but contempt - for the parents who bring those children into this world.
- throwaway5792 6y agoTry again.
- ShroudedNight 6y agoIs it 'inconvenience' when an uninsured motorist injures a parent badly enough such that they can no longer provide for their child? Fundamentally, how big a hedge do you believe parents have a duty to incur before society should reasonably be expected to intervene and help carry the burden? It sounds like you believe that only those with enough wealth that they can fully self-insure against all conceivable events of any frequency greater or equal to once a century that causes loss of ability to care, should procreate. Given our history as a species, that would be an extreme and significantly non-obvious point of view to hold at all, let alone with the vitriol that you seem to harbour on this matter.
- onetimemanytime 6y ago>>If anything, I'm thankful for all those people with kids who will Bravo!! Your choice or luck in life is yours. But kids will pay for your social security, will pay taxes to maintain the city/state/country and will be the soldiers and military guarding you. That's just the selfish part.
- FooBarBizBazz 6y agoWhy should I pay for your locally-grown children when I have alternatives? Say each woman has maybe one child late in life, so the population has a half-life of about 35 years. In exchange, I get to double the educated workforce of my society, which makes it produce more economic output. I also get the performance advantages of diversity. The only thing I have to do to keep things working is attract a number of immigrants equal to 50% of the population each generation. Which, because the scheme generates lots of wealth, is not hard to do. So what's the value-add for your alternative?
- ericmcer 6y agowith super low fertility rates (b) is especially important... and something a bit frightening for anyone who is looking at retirement in 20-30 years
- hinkley 6y agoLack of empathy has been a common trait among problem employees that were too good at their job to simply suggest removal. My buttons are more around things like constantly making work harder for everybody else and then dismissing complaints or slowness because it works for them, but I have no illusions that this sort of selfishness comes in only one flavor. My favorite games are teams. My favorite workplaces are teams. And while I've worked at lots of places, in big groups, I've only worked on a few Teams that weren't in name only.
- Spooky23 6y agoThat happens too. People are assholes. I worked at one place years ago where the union fought management to eliminate center centers of excellence to avoid other cuts that would have amounted to a 0.25% reduction in future retiree benefits.
- xwdv 6y agoI do not agree. I specifically chose not to have children because I knew of the burdens they would place on my career. Those who decided to have children should not get treated any differently. They knew what they were signing up for, they do not get to have things both ways.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hvs 6y agoThey also knew there would be a global pandemic that would require them to both educate their children full-time and work full-time.
- xwdv 6y agoI fail to see why people think that matters. Any number of tragedies or inconveniences can happen when you have children. If a perfect life where everything goes according to plan is your requirement for having kids then don’t have them.
- tus88 6y ago> What's next, complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? Do they? Isn't that just called sick leave or time off without pay? > If anything, I'm thankful for all those people with kids who will (a) take care of the continuation of the human race I thought people have kids because they want kids and enjoy family life?
- jartelt 6y ago1) I think you are ignoring that it is possible for non-parent employees to be negatively affected by the pandemic as well. You seem to be dealing with it very well (which is great!), but others may be stuck working from noisy, cramped apartments and may be getting little to no social interaction. This is can definitely cause health issues and degrade happiness. Those employees look at the large amount of family leave parents are getting and ask "why can't we get a little extra help as well?". If parents get 10 weeks of leave, how about you give non-parents 1 week of extra PTO or leave. It doesn't need to be exactly equal, but the pandemic is hard on everyone. 2) I think the non-parent employees are saying the company is showing little to no empathy towards their struggles. I really think it's less of "how dare that parent take extra leave" and more of "how dare facebook give parents all this extra leave and give non-parents nothing to help them cope with stress." 3) You choose to have children, but you do not choose to have cancer. I think your comparison there is misguided.
- _coveredInBees 6y ago*You choose to have children under the assumption that a once-in-several-lifetime pandemic doesn't shut down the world, take all child-care options off the plate and leave you stuck at home caring for one or more children with no support system while also trying to juggle work. No parent "chose" the current situation, just like no one chooses to have cancer.
- tabtab 6y agoI'm not sure if this is sarcasm. I'm confused. Without children, humans cease to exist. Although, arguably there are too many humans already.
- maire 6y agoI don't think resentment is a real thing. It is lack of flexibility when a company grows large enough to defer decisions to hr. When my children were young my employers were very supportive of granting flexibility for my family responsibilities. I was also very productive and giving me flexibility was an obvious win win. When my daughter had a young family she faced resistance because over the years hr has gained greater power and "if they give flexibility to one employee they have to give flexibility to all employees." The irony was the hr rules at her company allowed work sharing if she was in marketing but not for engineering. They waited until she quit to give her the flexibility she needed. I think smaller companies are better able to work with employees than larger companies.
- Aunche 6y ago> strikes me as extremely selfish, immature and displaying a total lack of empathy Empathy needs to go both ways. Childless employees tend to be younger and less experienced, so they often are paid less than those with kids. If you're a junior who needs to work 80 hour weeks to pick up the slack from seniors with kids, but you're also paid less, it's understandable that you would be angry.
- ironman1478 6y agoNo single employee at a company is productive enough that them leaving literally doubles a person's workload, especially when most people aren't actually productive for an entire day and there is a lot of evidence that 4 day work weeks are just as productive. If this environment did exist, the employee should quit unless they are making A LOT of money.
- sellyme 6y ago> the employee should quit Because the job market is looking so fantastic right now? Yes, you're describing a hostile workplace, but right now is the worst time in over a decade to be giving up a reliable income.
- ironman1478 6y agoI think in general you are right, but this article was about tech workers, who are largely unaffected in terms of the job market from what I can tell (I could be wrong about this though). Also, it seems like the job market is ironically getting better for tech? I am seeing more remote opportunities on who's hiring so the job pool is opening up due to this.
- Traubenfuchs 6y agoBut countless employees have such a low productivity, they can double it and still not reach their peak capacity. I know many developers that spend the majority of their work days just staring out of the window.
- zem 6y agohonestly, i would not be at all surprised if there were people who resented a cancer patient for "not pulling their weight". american culture has a depressingly strong element of "your misfortunes and hardships are entirely your responsibility to bear; don't ask us to help with them". edit: right here in this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24413813 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24413813
- wh1t3n01s3 6y agoOur society (and economy) is killing our planet. We are too many. Not to have kids is a choice of life, not the opposite. We are not endangered.
- thegayngler 6y agoI know this is going to be a really unpopular take. I tend to be more libertarian on this. I think the government and tech should get out of the business of prioritizing and promoting a specific family structure using tax code and other benefits. Let people decide if they want to have kids and deal with the fallout accordingly. We already have people we can't adequately support now but you have the government and tech companies incentivizing people financially to have families even when they can't afford it. IMO it is selfish to force other people to finance your family even when there is already plenty of resources to pay for your own family. These "benefits" the families are getting leave very little resources for the most vulnerable people in society. I just think it's generally selfish and irresponsible to have kids if you need the government structures to finance your lifestyle through the tax code and other government institutions. I see people making far and away more money than me but they pay a lower tax rate than me because they have kids and I don't. That's not only selfish on their part but also unfair. If the US had an adequate social safety net that includes UBI, Housing and Healthcare this might all be moot.
- throwawaybabies 6y agoI'm probably going to get downvoted for being "selfish" but I absolutely do not care about the continuation of the human race and I want as much time off as my coworkers who made the bad life decision choice of making children.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwta22 6y agoI guess I'm out of the loop but I didn't realize that parents actually felt like they're doing society and the human race a favor by having several kids. I always viewed it as the opposite. We're at no risk of extinction and companies should not subsidize people for having kids, at least not more than 1. Many people love taking advantage of that sweet sweet 16+ week parental leave.
- sokoloff 6y agoI love my kids. Even with that, I assure you I was looking forward to the break and reduction in workload when my parental leave expired and I went back to the office...
- hodgesrm 6y ago> What's next, complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? I think the problem starts with framing the problem as parents vs. non-parents instead of considering a wide range of reasons why employees need more flexibility in work schedules for personal or family reasons. Those include sickness, taking care of children, taking care of elderly parents, a sick spouse, taking care of sick/dying pets, etc. It's difficult to think of anybody who would not be affected by one or more of these.
- Loughla 6y agoRight? It's almost like employers need to kill the 9-5 factory mindset for those of us who don't make widgets. I maintain my department with the understanding that you have to meet people where they are in life. Flexibility is key, with high, clear standards. My staff are happier and more committed than any other department on our campus because of this. People aren't that hard to figure out - value them and be empathetic to their experiences.
- tracerbulletx 6y agoHave you actually noticed this happening in your workplace? I've read these stories in the news but no one is acting like that at all where I work which is a mid sized tech start up. Everyone is VERY understanding and accommodating there is a general atmosphere of dealing with a very difficult situation together.
- outworlder 6y ago> (a) take care of the continuation of the human race I understand the sentiment. But the human race is not in any danger of going extinct any time soon. We are at almost 8 billion people now. Certainly we don't need to add that much more? > What's next, complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? This slippery slope is not needed. A cancer patient has no say on whether or not he's going to get sick. Parenting is a choice. One that's been ingrained in most people from an early age, but still a choice. That's in no way the same as a disease. If parents get benefits, non-parents should get benefits too. Possibly different ones. But we shouldn't pretend that only parents have issues. This is even ignoring the fact that people may have other people they need to take care of that are not their direct descendants. Extend benefits to everyone. End of story.
- ashtonkem 6y agoI’ve seen some incredibly petty behavior about fairly minor differences in benefits, never underestimate the ability for well paid employees to bicker over comparatively small things.
- TedShiller 6y agoI fully support those with children as well, including all the extra benefits, flexibility, and compensation needed to raise healthy children. I think this is great for all involved, including those parents, children, and society at large. The part that's missing is that childless workers should get the same benefits, flexibility, and compensation as workers with children, so that they can handle challenging and complex elements of their own lives that are no less complicated, challenging, expensive, or time consuming than having children.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- secondsettwist 6y agoI think the issue here is that, at least at Facebook, everyone is getting the same bonus this year regardless of performance. So those with children are getting extra time off, and those w/o are picking up their work in some cases but aren't getting compensated for it. So either give everyone time off or give parents time off but make bonuses dependent on performance.
- shard972 6y ago> If anything, I'm thankful for all those people with kids who will (a) take care of the continuation of the human race, and more selfishly (b) support our society and economy when I am too old to do so. You forget that plenty of young people don't want to support either of these things when it comes to certain demographics.
- shock 6y ago> What's next, complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? Having kids is a personal choice. Getting cancer isn't. What are you on about?!
- jwilber 6y agoI agree with your larger point, but your cancer comparison is absolutely ridiculous. Especially in a paragraph claiming others lack empathy. The vast majority of white-collar parents not only chose to have children, they actively planned to. Nobody plans to have cancer. Of course there is a purported difference in feelings toward the two, and the responsibilities they entail.
- zeroonetwothree 6y agoI don’t think the cancer analogy is good either but to be fair no one planned to have children in a world that removed all their expected child care options.
- 908087 6y ago> What's next, complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? Cancer isn't something people choose to inflict upon themselves.
- disown 6y ago> To be honest, the "resentment" of those without children have for "benefits" those with children get strikes me as extremely selfish, immature and displaying a total lack of empathy. Where is your empathy for the "middle-aged adult with no children"? Are you sure you are a "middle-aged adult with no children" because you sound like a person with children. > If anything, I'm thankful for all those people with kids who will (a) take care of the continuation of the human race, and more selfishly (b) support our society and economy when I am too old to do so. Then aren't you being selfish by not having kids? We had another thread a few days ago and almost the same comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24384369 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24384369
- haram_masala 6y agoLet’s keep HN a place where we assume the best of each other, accept each other at their word, and treat each other with dignity and respect.
- RandoHolmes 6y agoroughly in the same boat you are, and I actually find it difficult to believe that this is anything more than an imagined problem. I can't imagine there's that many people that don't understand children are important and children need to be taken care of. I certainly have never gotten angry at not getting the tax breaks those with more dependents get, and I can't imagine there's that many other people who do. My opinion is that this is just another journalist trying to drum up drama for clicks.
- Loughla 6y ago>I certainly have never gotten angry at not getting the tax breaks those with more dependents get, and I can't imagine there's that many other people who do. Cruising through this comment section tells me that a lot of people think about this a lot, apparently. Many are also apparently bitter that their tax dollars pay for services for children, even though they don't have children. What a confusing attitude.
- RandoHolmes 6y agoYeah... I quickly revised my opinion after continuing through the comments of this thread. Apparently there ARE people who are that angry? It doesn't really make sense to me. I saw one poster compare it to smokers who get to take quick smoke breaks. I don't have a habit that forces me to take breaks every 30 minutes to an hour or I go into withdrawal, doesn't make me smell like a smoker, and doesn't inherently put me at risk of cancer. Isn't that in itself a reward for not smoking? Instead you have to get pissed at someone who smokes? Do you REALLY want to be out there inhaling that smoke with the other smokers? It just makes no sense to me, but I've also never viewed working hours as a zero-sum game.
- rtlfe 6y ago> strikes me as extremely selfish, immature and displaying a total lack of empathy We're talking about 22 year olds who have always been told they're smarter than everybody, spend more of their free time with computers than with people, and started making $200k+ immediately after college. Those adjectives correctly describe a large portion of those people.
- acrimonia 6y ago> spend more of their free time with computers than with people Not of my own free will, I assure you.
- jimmaswell 6y agoI feel like companies could easily afford to just give everyone the same time off even if that's the amount of time off these parents allegedly get. Shouldn't be an issue if not for our toxic culture of overworking. They get by fine with far more vacation on average in Europe etc.
- bsder 6y agoPeople would be a lot more sympathetic to parents if parents were being a lot more sympathetic about things like elder care, for example. People taking care of parents with Alzheimer's in this mess are way worse off than parents. You can see your children. You can take care of your children. Your children can see you. Your children can see other family members within reason. Your children probably won't die of Covid. Seeing your elderly family member with Alzheimer's might kill them. Getting them medical care is a long dance with various doctors in order to try to not give them Covid. Maybe you have to make a choice to pull them out of a memory care facility and bring them home so they don't die. And, if they wind up hospitalized, they may wind up dying completely alone and isolated. The problem is that parents often act like they uniquely deserve special treatment. Yeah, that pisses people off. Everybody should have enough leave to deal with things. Period. Not just one "special" group.
- manfredo 6y agoIs the resentment coming from childless people and directed at parents? Or is it coming from parents and directed at childless? Anecdotally I see a lot more of the latter in this thread. It reminds me of a time when a co-worker complained in a semi-anonymous work channel how it was a problem that some of his other team members worked 9am to 8pm and contributed way more than the other team members. The rationale was that this made other team members feel uncomfortable. This baffled me. If I work 9-5 and someone else puts in 60 hours a week I can empathize with the insecurity of this juxtaposition to a degree, but it seems nonsensical to complain about it. It's like if you're in a band, and a couple of the team members practice really hard and play way better than the other band members. This behavior is actively helping the group, if some members feel insecure about their relative levels of commitment then their insecurity the the problem - not the dedication of other members. Things change when you factor in competition for rewards and recognition. Definitely this makes it harder for people with more obligations outside of work to contribute. But I'm not sure if this makes for effective justification to adjust our expected contribution to get the same reward. If someone came up to me and said that they volunteer at a homeless shelter for 30 hours a week and this cuts into how much they can put into work, I'd compliment them on their selflessness but point of that these actions are selfless precisely because these commitments involve sacrificing other opportunities. Choosing to become a parent is analogous. Not to mention, society already does give parents greater rewards in the form of tax deductions and government services paid for by all taxpayers regardless of whether or not they have children.
- mindcrime 6y agoI'm 47, no children, and have worked in tech most of my adult life. And I have NO resentment towards any parents who ask for, and receive, a certain amount of accommodation to deal with having their children at home during such an unusual time. And I can't even begin to grok the mindset of the people who do harbor that kind of resentment. WTF? Have you people not heard of compassion, understanding, or just basic human dignity? FFS, already. So somebody else might get a couple of percentage points more on their bonus than you think they "deserve". And if bonuses come from a fixed pool, that means less for you. Well, wwaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhh, cry me a river. There's more to life than fixating on every dollar you could possibly be paid. And consider what kind of accommodation you might be looking for, asking for, or even expecting, sometime in the future when something extraordinary happens. There are reasons we have all those old cliches about "the shoe being on the other foot" and "the table turning" and so on...
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoWell..if I could cry a river, it wouldn’t be for you. Look, it’s not personal. It’s about the money. Please feel free to donate your money. How about turning that non judgemental POV to those who don’t care to be on your side.
- mindcrime 6y agoI'm not claiming to be "non judgmental" here. I'm saying there's a place for basic human compassion. If you don't get that, I think you're a shallow, pathetic, and sad person. Feel free to disagree. YMMV. And the really weird thing here, is that I'm the person that the stereotypes would suggest would be on the other side of this discussion. I'm totally on-board with Ayn Rand's notion of "the virtue of selfishness" and totally a supporter of capitalism, etc. But none of those things preclude - by definition - having a little capacity for empathy and understanding.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoYes. I agree. No one died. It’s a matter of 1. Time management 2.Resource management 3. Not having a sense of entitlement. They have to deal with it like the rest of do. The milk of human kindness will dry up very quickly when parents and their supporters go around claiming that the act of personal procreation subsidized by the whole entire rest of us is a selfless sacrifice for the entire human species. Yes, my mileage varies re your opinion about me being ‘shallow, pathetic and sad’. Please feel free to fuck off.
- jquery 6y agoThis is absolutely the right attitude. I’m glad to see it at the top of the HN comments on this article.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoI think you missed the point of the article entirely. The complaints aren’t so much about what parents do get, but instead about what childless employees don’t get. When your parent coworkers are tossing extra work over the fence to you, ditching critical meetings at the last second without delegating, which in turn forces you to stay late and put the pedal to the metal for weeks on end to maintain their productivity for them and your own, all while not only not getting a thank-you but instead getting effectively a middle finger where your colleague is saying “fuck you, you don’t have real problems or commitments because you don’t have a kid, pick up the slack and deal with it cuz I’m on kid duty” it’s extremely miserable and open season on extreme burnout. Let alone the wildly ridiculous idea that you might get an extra bonus, higher raise, faster promotion, etc., for picking up that slack... you’ll be lucky to get coworker parents just even being slightly kind to you and showing a modicum of appreciation for the childless people picking up extreme slack despite their own lockdown induced mental health and time crunch issues.
- Loughla 6y agoThat sounds like a really shitty co-worker, regardless of having children or not. If your co-worker can't prioritize with accommodations for childcare and the like, then s/he needs to be fired. I am now, after months of fighting with my administration, allowed partial remote work to cover for the days we do not have childcare after school for my kid. The expectation being that my job is done, regardless of where I am. The understanding being that if my job isn't getting done, I will get fired, regardless of whether I'm in the office or not. I would argue that the situation you present is either a) over the top, or b) a shitty co-worker using an excuse to get out of work.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoIn my company the parents have a huge sense of entitlement, so this bad attitude and taking childless coworkers’ time for granted is pretty universal, not just a few bad apples.
- Waterluvian 6y ago“And here I am using my own lungs like a sucker”
- Aloha 6y agoI always volunteered to work more, I travel more than my married peers, I'm willing to give up some holidays and be more flexible, with the caveat that I get whatever time off I need without reservation - its a social contract, and I believe strongly that it takes a village to raise a child.
- Loughla 6y agoThis is how our office functions. My younger, single staff are more willing to work holidays and travel, but the implicit understanding is that they get the cushier assignments, and are allowed more flexibility during the regular week. Everyone is happier that way. People with kids get their holidays, single people get to be young, single people whenever they want. It's sort of like being flexible and meeting people where they are in life is the best thing for everyone.
- StanislavPetrov 6y ago>What's next, complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? Having a child is a choice, getting cancer isn't.
- irrational 6y agoAfter my wife and I were done having kids my work rolled out 90 of paternity and/or maternity leave for each child. That’s a lot of “vacation” time I missed out on (seriously, we had 5 kids - so 450 days of vacation). But, I’m not bitter. I’m happy for others who can take advantage of this.
- jb775 6y agoThe ppl complaining about parent employees are the same ppl complaining about how schools MUST be closed due to covid.
- rconti 6y agoI just skimmed the article, and I don't doubt the issue is real, but they cited, I think, one actual human who had a specific complaint. It feels like an article written with its narrative before its 'research'. My anecdata is my company is (publicly and at the middle leadership level) very supportive of the compromises parents and others are making, I harbor no resentment towards parents, and have seen not one shred of it in informal communications. YMMV.
- ornornor 6y ago> If anything, I'm thankful for all those people with kids who will (a) take care of the continuation of the human race, and more selfishly (b) support our society and economy when I am too old to do so. This is debatable. I’m of the opinion that there are too many humans on the planet, and that having children is a very resource intensive and polluting choice. I don’t think people who are having children as altruistic heroes but rather the opposite: selfish individuals. If we take your argument to the absurd about cancer patients, I can say that encouraging coworkers to get children by giving more benefits is akin to give extra benefits to people who drive single occupancy SUVs to work while giving nothing to people who take mass transit, walk or bike.
- collyw 6y agoI assume that the vast majority of people with children make the choice to have them, something that can't always be said about being childless. And having children is hardly comparable to having cancer.
- reyqn 6y agoI don't really care that people with kids have advantages over me, in fact, I pushed for them to have these advantages, because they need it more than I do. However, I don't think we should consider that people that have kids contribute more actively to the continuation of the human race, or our society. The human race / our society will be just fine with less kids.
- dclowd9901 6y agoI think most of my peers think like you. This article smacks of rage bait.
- EvilEy3 6y ago> What's next, complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? If they brought cancer tumor on themselves, then yes. [You just compared kids and cancer, mate, FYI]
- PestoDiRucola 6y agoHaving kids is a conscious choice you make and hopefully one weighs all the pros and cons when one makes such choice. Getting cancer is not.
- bumby 6y ago>This is time off specifically to take care of children I think this is the crux of the problem that some people have. I am happy to work for a company that allows flexible schedules to help parents. I have no qualms about shouldering additional burdens to help. However, there is a certain percentage of opportunists who take advantage of the situation and confuse this generosity with entitlement. I have some suspicions that some of this time is being used for side projects rather taking care of kids. I have multiple coworkers who have installed new pools/patios during this flex period and will occasionally even cut online meetings short to oversee some of the work being done at their house. It does cause me to raise my eyebrows when they can't get their workload done because of they feel entitled to a certain amount of extra benefits. I think people need to feel like everyone is pulling for the same mission and part of the same team. I'm grateful to be in a position to help ease other people's stress but leaders need to make sure everyone is still accountable and not taking advantage of the situation.
- fatnoah 6y ago>If anything, I'm thankful for all those people with kids who will (a) take care of the continuation of the human race, and more selfishly (b) support our society and economy when I am too old to do so. I agree that having kids provides benefits to society. If one wants to be selfish, the taxes those kids pay are going to fund my social security, infrastructure, etc. when I'm no longer working. On the other hand, as a manager person in tech, I'm always very proactive about ensuring that EVERYONE is able to take advantage of whatever schedule flexibility is offered, even when there's no formal policy in place. A huge part of that is making sure that expectations are consistent across all groups. I absolutely can see how COVID has helped to fuel this resentment, though. As a caregiver (of my kids in this case, but it would apply to being anyone's caregiver), I'm able to take up to 10 weeks of paid leave in single day increments. There's no such thing those who aren't caregivers. As a manager, I'm more than willing to exercise a little civil disobedience by ensuring that those folks are able to take the time they need without draining their PTO balances. I'm sure I'm not supposed to do that, but I don't flaunt it.
- Chris2048 6y ago> selfish, immature and displaying a total lack of empathy Are these your kids you're taking care of, or orphans you adopted for the sole reason of benefiting society? Let's be realistic - few people having children care about market demand. There are plenty of things I could do that might benefit society, I still have to do them on my own time/dime. If you think it's a raw deal - don't have children; If you want to have them anyway, don't pass it off as a selfless act, and accuse society of being "extremely selfish, immature and displaying a total lack of empathy" for not supporting your decision. > complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? Did the cancer patient make a decision to have cancer?