55 ms·
Tech firms face growing resentment of parent employees during Covid-19
- liability 6y agoI suspect people are less inclined to empathize with people they don't see face-to-face every day. Mass-WFH could cause a general drop in empathy, particularly when the circumstances are so stressful.
- save_ferris 6y agoI’ve noticed the opposite, actually. Working from home has meant that I often see parents interacting with their children or spouses during calls, I get to see another facet of my coworkers lives that I couldn’t before. Generally, I really appreciate this perspective, it’s very humanizing. The lack of empathy around parents long preceded COVID, it has everything to do with the anxiety-driven “ship or die” culture that’s prevalent in startup culture.
- rblatz 6y agoA lot of this feels like people looking into their neighbor's bowl to see if they are getting more than them. Love him or hate him Louis C.K. has a great quote here “The only time you look in your neighbor's bowl is to make sure that they have enough. You don't look in your neighbor's bowl to see if you have as much as them.” Times are tough, don't blame the parents for what they have to do, blame your management if they haven't adjusted team goals/metrics to take into account the new normal.
- ng12 6y agoAt the same time it's kind of hard for me to be sympathetic. Their bowls aren't empty: they kept their cushy, white-collar, benefit-rich jobs while tens of millions became suddenly unemployed.
- cheschire 6y agoAnd that comparison can keep on going once you start bringing in folks from other parts of the world. A poor person in America is still well beyond the quality of life of a well off person in some villages. It's kind of fucked up to say a struggling person doesn't deserve your sympathy just because their suck isn't the same shade as the other person's suck.
- pyronik19 6y agoThere is a team of 4 people. 2 have families, 2 don't. The ones that don't picked up the slack for the ones that did. Work quality was equal, but output was greater for the singles. The team has 2 slots for promotion. Do you ignore the fact that the single people put in more work or do you factor it in in the promotion decision?
- asciident 6y agoIn this scenario, is there a way to handle the promotions such that no one is upset? I can't think of one. Maybe put them on different tracks -- those who took "parental flexibility" can get promoted, but it occurs later, and the money saved from that deferred promotion gets given to the singles who put in extra time/effort? Not sure, just brainstorming.
- Kalium 6y agoNow you're in what is probably textbook discrimination territory.
- R0b0t1 6y agoCaregivers are not covered under federal law, but apparently they are under some state and city law. But how far do you take this? Is not getting a promotion penalization if your coworkers are more likely to be able to participate in work that garners praise?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- strictnein 6y agoNeither. The failure is with the team's manager. The team's leadership should have reduced the workload of the team. It starts at the top. I work at a (non-tech) Fortune 50 and the message from the CEO on down has been the same: take vacation, take care of your family, some priorities/projects for this year will not be met and that is fine.
- liability 6y agoI generally agree with that sentiment, but I'm not sure it's persuasive when expressed by somebody who will never have to worry about his bowl being empty (e.g. a successful celebrity like Louis C.K.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BluSyn 6y agohttps://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/genetic https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/genetic
- treis 6y ago>“The only time you look in your neighbor's bowl is to make sure that they have enough. You don't look in your neighbor's bowl to see if you have as much as them.” So then pay me 40% more and tell the parents not to look at my bowl. That's hypothetical because I have a small kid myself. But that quote is sucker talk. Demand that you are compensated for the value you provide because none of these mega corps give a shit about you. They will fire you the moment that it becomes profitable for them to do so.
- rblatz 6y agoThere is a lot of cognitive dissonance in this post. This whole conversation is about mega corps giving a shit, and accommodating people who are having increased difficulty during COVID. You can't get mad that they are caring, and then in the same breath say they don't care.
- treis 6y agoHaving childless people pick up the slack for no extra pay isn't caring. And even that level of "caring" is not going to last.
- all_blue_chucks 6y agoEmployees are not neighbors. Employees are responsible for negotiating their compensation (both monetary and non-monetary). It is absolutely appropriate to use information about others' compensation when negotiating for your own compensation.
- jansan 6y agoThere is a reason why the term "childless privilege" exists.
- olliej 6y agoWhat’s that reason? Because to my knowledge people aren’t forced to have children. This phrase exists to attack those without children by portraying people who made a different choice as having a privilege, when many literally can’t have children. Privilege is something you have irrespective of your choices, you don’t get to portray the consequences of your choices as if other people have privilege.
- emerged 6y agoSort of like buying a car and then referring to people who haven't bought the car as privileged for still having the money the car cost. Except in this case, the people who didn't buy the car are already actively paying taxes toward services for those cars even though they don't have one.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI am a middle-aged adult with no children who's worked at tech firms for the past couple decades. To be honest, the "resentment" of those without children have for "benefits" those with children get strikes me as extremely selfish, immature and displaying a total lack of empathy. This is time off specifically to take care of children, something now that has become exceedingly more difficult in Covid times. What's next, complaining that the cancer patient gets extra time off so why don't I? If anything, I'm thankful for all those people with kids who will (a) take care of the continuation of the human race, and more selfishly (b) support our society and economy when I am too old to do so.
- summitsummit 6y agonice opinion, but it's just that
- mmm_grayons 6y agoWell, there's a good argument to be made that having children is much more of a choice than having cancer. And yes, it's natural to be selfish, because employment benefits are at least something of a zero-sum game. More for one often means less for another. I could easily argue that those who demand extra benefits because of a personal decision they made (having children) are more selfish than those who resent that they receive them.
- wffurr 6y agoSociety doesn't exist without children. Child care is right up there with fire departments for things you, personally, as a childless person whose house has not burned down, need to exist in order to live in society, and not just a hermit in the woods.
- asciident 6y agoIt's not so clear to be honest. The global population is growing and leading to environmental disasters, and it's not clear why we need 10 billion people on this planet, rather than a more manageable 100 million.
- codemac 6y agoPersonally, I struggle with these feelings as well. It seems nuts that someone working 50%+ less than someone else is going to keep all the same equity, vacation, and salary. Then again it seems nuts that they don't. All employees who had children or family members to care for before or after COVID get none of the same support. I don't think backpay is coming for those who were forced to take leave or even quit their jobs when they had family they had to care for. It isn't "unfair" or something, parents with kids of certain ages have a much higher burden right now than most, and our society should support them. That support won't exist for anything exceptional, and for diseases like autism, alzheimer's or cancer, we've normalized the experience and force individuals to just handle it. It's hard to see how far some companies are willing to go for parents today, when I see how little we do for others.
- orky56 6y agoOutside of US, people expect the government to provide that safety net. In the US, we expect corporations to provide for health insurance, disposable income, and the tools/resources to focus on work. Meals, soda, and Slack work for early 20s fresh grads but not for parents/caregivers.
- staplers 6y agoTo reinforce this idea: Work expenses are only tax-exempt if you are an employer.
- jacquesm 6y agoThey are working as much or more. Just not on the same things. It's not as if being a parent somehow translates into more free time, in fact it translates into substantially less free time if any at all.
- codemac 6y agoCompletely agreed. But in the US we don't pay stay at home mother's for their time either. These companies should help their employees, I'm saying that there is a much deeper problem in our society in how we handle individuals who are not profitable.
- goldenchrome 6y agoI sympathize with the parents but this is just how life goes. If you have kids, you’re going to be more occupied than people without kids since we all have limited time on this Earth. And of course your career will be negatively impacted. There are good things about having kids and bad things. This is one of those potential bad things. If you don’t want to deal with this possibility then simply don’t have kids.
- alex_anglin 6y agoHow do you sympathize? Edit: For clarity, the comment is clearly unsympathetic.
- olliej 6y agoYou can recognize when things will be harder for some people than it is for others, but at the same time acknowledge that these are simply the consequences of different choices being made. I have no doubt it is harder for my coworkers with kids now than it is usually, but I also know that they chose to have kids, and knew that would mean that they’d have more “work” in some cases than if they didn’t have kids. But they chose to have kids, and I’m getting tired of these threads where everyone with kids seems to be saying that kids a purely a burden to be put up with, which is honestly what these complaints about it “being a full time job” sound like.
- goldenchrome 6y agoYes this is what I meant, thanks for clarifying.
- Ductapemaster 6y agoI don’t have kids, but this strikes me as lacking empathy in the current climate. Choosing to have kids or not pre-COVID came with a set of expectations, risks, and choices that were fairly well defined. Parental leave, childcare, proximity to family and friends, school, increased costs, medical treatemtn, etc. Parents could evaluate those based on what their employer offered and the experiences of their peers going through the same processes. Now, with COVID, the entire world has changed. School is no longer school. Childcare doesn’t exist. Friends and family are socially distanced or inaccessible due to quarantine. Parks and beaches are closed. Vacations are extremely limited. Any social interaction has become a risk. None of these were risks that a reasonable parent would consider, and even for the paranoid ones, it is highly unlikely that anyone considered it all at once. Given the extreme change we are going through, the “if you can’t handle it, don’t have kids argument” is just not realistic. A pandemic isn’t “just how life goes”.
- save_ferris 6y agoThis is one of the biggest reasons I’ve chosen to forego parenthood. I can’t imagine trying to carve out a solid career in tech while being a parent. I’m sure there are so many here on HN that will say it’s not so hard, but employer expectations have historically been incredibly high at companies I’ve worked for, to the point that sacrificing one’s personal life is pretty much expected (although never explicitly stated). The pattern of viewing non-parents as more accessible and therefore more committed has been incredibly noticeable, particularly among startups and smaller companies.
- itsoktocry 6y ago>employer expectations have historically been incredibly high at companies I’ve worked for, to the point that sacrificing one’s personal life is pretty much expected (although never explicitly stated). This sounds horrible. Honest question: why do you want to carve out a solid career in an industry that you can see works this way?
- save_ferris 6y agoBecause it's likely my best shot at financial independence. There's no other line of work I can pursue without taking on tens of thousands in student debt and starting over career-wise. I've worked in several industries in my life, and it's not like tech is unique this way. In a lot of ways, finance is much, much worse. It would be great to have enough money to pursue whatever goal or passion I wanted, but that's not my reality.
- mlady 6y agoI would refer you to the Parable of the Fisherman and the Businessman. https://www.momentum-coaching.eu/en/inspiration/the-parable-of-the-businessman-and-the-fisherman https://www.momentum-coaching.eu/en/inspiration/the-parable-... TL;DR: try to live now in the way you would want to live once you achieve "financial independence"
- grillvogel 6y agoso the solution is that everyone should focus on career and not have kids? that seems like a great long term strategy for society
- itronitron 6y agoParenting is a full-time+ job. Hopefully the past six months will help people better appreciate their colleague's partners/spouses that 'stay at home' to care for their children, but I admit that is optimistic.
- softwaredoug 6y agoIt's simply depressing how parent/kid-hostile society has become... I'm not saying we need explosive population growth. But I feel one of the main purposes of society is raising and protecting children. If you're a human-future-optimist, you want some kind of generation that's better than us to continue on.... I'm not saying you NEED to have kids, but I feel it's part of society's collective duty to consider the next generation, build a better world, enable them to build something better than came before...
- extrawork99 6y agoIt’s depressing how entitled a generation of parents have become. And I say that as a father.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago>It's simply depressing how parent/kid-hostile society has become... I think the Pet Parent thing is part of that, albeit w/ a positive vibe. I just found it odd that people suddenly started giving birth to animals and that no one found that noteworthy.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoSocieties that don't care about the future in the form of children won't have a future.
- ip26 6y agoSelf-selecting, if you will. Not to mention, if your society doesn't propagate, others will. Which means whatever your values are, good or bad, they will still be lost and replaced with the values of the society which propagates.
- chillacy 6y agoMost advanced countries do not have a self-sustaining birth rate (above 2.1, the replacement rate). Some are able to make up the difference in immigration, but immigrants assimilate and then the birth rates go back down. The US is at 1.77, Canada at 1.5, UK 1.79
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoThis reminds me of local retirees who are resentful that their taxes are paying for public schools. They seem to have forgotten that someone paid for them to attend school. Regarding parental time off, it's conceivable that their own parents never had that support. Maternal/parental leave is taking decades to roll out - perhaps as long as it took for public schooling to become universally available.
- calvinmorrison 6y agoIgnoring the fact the education costs have skyrocketed since they went to school
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago>education costs have skyrocketed since they went to school Going back 70 years, you could say that about most large scale services.
- MaximumYComb 6y agoSo has the cost of caring for old people but they don't complain about that.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoThat's a brilliant point.
- wayneftw 6y agoDo public taxes pay for my care when I’m old? I thought we just got Social Security which is a fixed rate.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoMedicare is one of our largest, non-discretionary outlays.
- ptmcc 6y ago
- Shivetya 6y agoIsn't it just bizarre how people can have children and not expect it to disrupt their lives. They are children, they require your engagement, this is part of the deal. Tech companies should offer the same time off to all employees whether they have children or not. Children should not be allowed to be bargaining chip to obtain more from others. Your choice. To be honest having children out weighs any negative impact it has on career progression and if you don't understand that you should have not have had children to begin with. Oddly this is little different than what some people do with pets, they are fine and wonderful until they realize they require time, attention, and money.
- burlesona 6y agoNobody expects having kids to be free or easy. But nobody expected to have a global pandemic that completely disrupted and in most cases eliminated the entire support structure that parents have in place either. Right now companies that are offering more support to parents are doing so because they recognize that parents are much more impacted by current events than non-parents, and also because this is expected to be temporary.
- extrawork99 6y ago> Nobody expects having kids to be free or easy. Lol. Yes. They do. They expect handouts from friends and family, both in time and materials. They expect tax breaks. They expect parental leave. They expect the world to fall inline with their desires, all because they chose to have children.
- edanm 6y agoNot many people have children without knowing it will disrupt their lives. On the other hand, not many people planned on a pandemic that would cause almost the entire support structure for having children to disappear.
- recursive 6y ago> Not many people have children without knowing it will disrupt their lives. On the other hand, the depth and extent of the disruption is not something I could have possibly imagined at the time though. Just saying, not complaining.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoFWIW, in the Bay Area at least, there have always been companies with fairly toxic cultures that impute "shame" on people who go home early or choose family events over company events. Because technical people have generally (although not universally) employable at multiple companies, it was has been possible to leave a company once you figured out they were 'dinging' you for spending too much time with your family. It is also why I found the rationale for leaving of "going to spend more time with my family" somewhat painful as it implies that company would not support that choice while still employing you. (and yes, I know its a euphemism more than an actual reason but still). One need look no further than the "controversy" over parental leave to understand that American companies have a fairly broken value system when it comes to their employee's well being.
- kache_ 6y agoIn remote environments, some people clearly put in more hours than necessary. It allows people who are capable of making sacrifices work overtime, and therefore raise the bar unnecessarily. No matter how much a company attempts to reinforce a 8 hour work day; people will sneak around it to keep up or to get ahead. This unbalances the playing field for parents. I myself am guilty of putting in more time than necessary. Sometimes I need to get a report in before eurozone starts, so I push something out at 11pm. It's in the best interests for a company to maintain the interests of people with children. People with children tend to stay longer and keep skill in your company, since they prefer stability. Compare this with new grads that job hop every year.
- dtx1 6y agoI'd be happy to do some overtime to help people with children in my company. Even as a childless single, I chose a family friendly company because it aligns with my personal values.
- daenz 6y agoThat's very noble, but do you believe that your choice should be forced onto others?
- ethanwillis 6y agoShould we be forced to pay taxes?
- daenz 6y agoExactly, I'm asking if they believe their personal choice to work additional overtime for a specific demographic of people should be compelled by the state via an additional tax. Do you?
- dtx1 6y agoSomehow you all think everyone is american because here in germany there are many taxes levied on me or rather not levied on families with children.
- daenz 6y agoIn Germany, there is a tax if you don't work overtime for people with children? Because that is what I'm asking about. In America there was an additional tax if you didn't buy health insurance, so it was compelled via a tax.
- ubercore 6y agoOthers can choose not to work at that company, right? In this scenario, nobody is being forced -- in either direction.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rriepe 6y agoThis thread seems weird to me when almost every other article here is talking about how limited and precious focus and attention are.
- extrawork99 6y agoI love all the comments saying that people should have empathy for parents. Being a parent is a choice. It cannot be compared to cancer. How stupid. Unless you think kids are cancer? The burden of YOUR children should not fall to your coworkers. They are your responsibility, and require YOUR sacrifice. Sincerely, A father making it work with his partner, and coworker sick of his coworkers making excuses for never getting anything done.
- burlesona 6y agoThis feels like more of an effort to create a story than accurate reporting of what life is like inside tech firms right now. 1. Parents lives have been temporarily turned upside down as almost all childcare disappears. Temporary is turning out to be a long time... but still. 2. Most companies are composed of people of all ages and stages of life which means there are lots of parents. Particularly when you consider management tends to be older and more likely to have had kids, it's not too surprising that management in most companies has looked at the outside world and said, "you know, we're all going to just have to do the best we can until this thing is over." 3. Parents naturally feel (1) stressed out and (2) guilty when they are having a hard time maintaining their old workload given the new and vastly different circumstances. 4. Some small minority of tech workers without kids have been unable to empathize with the situation and are publicly complaining about it. Given that saying mean things online is practically America's past-time, and trying to fan the sparks to see if you can make a flame is how news companies make money... it's not really surprising to see a story like this portraying some kind of "backlash."
- subsaharancoder 6y ago> This feels like more of an effort to create a story than accurate reporting of what life is like inside tech firms right now. This is very true. The genesis of the story is that at one of the FAANGs (I work for one of them) someone posted a question that kind of made it sound as "parents vs single employees" issue, the media (the NYTimes got the ball rolling) have jumped on this and are fanning the flames at a time when many people are tense and worked up over so many other things.
- pm90 6y agoHow is the media fanning the flames if they’re reporting on something that actually happened? Perhaps to you it may not be a big deal, but FAANGs are now a crucial part of the lives of Americans and the Public is naturally interested in what goes on in these companies. To a certain extent, this kind of media attention is an offshoot of the success of the Industry.
- deleted 6y ago
- WD-42 6y agoThis feels like a symptom of a society that has accepted the act of completely outsourcing child-rearing clashing with an event that makes that outsourcing impossible. Being able to work full time while comfortably having other people/institutions raise your child seems like a privilege. Now we are just seeing what happens when that privilege is taken away. I can't help but imagine there are a bunch of parents out there who decided to forgo full time jobs and careers to raise their own children shaking their heads and saying "this is how it is".
- ajford 6y agoBeing able to work full time while kids attend school isn't a privilege, it's often a necessity, at least in many parts of the US. Until relatively recently, supporting my family of four required both my partner and I to work full time. Raising kids is an expensive endeavor. Luckily, I've advanced in my career enough that I can now support my family on my own.
- WD-42 6y agoYou are right, but I think you are missing the context of the article. While I'd like to avoid generalizations, most employees of SV tech giants aren't exactly struggling to get by. These are employees that can now work from home (another privilege many parents don't have) a high paying jobs - the ones that usually afford them to be able to hire childcare so that they can work through the day.
- tbatchelli 6y agoHow much of this issue is related to having a part of the population think that people having children is solely a private question? "You had children, why should I bear your burden!" If none of us had children there would d be no economy to support anyone's life in, let's say, 40 years from now. People making and raising new sane and healthy people should be considered a social and common good, for the sake of all, and should be protected and encouraged. Maybe not too many children, true, but at least enough to keep some semblance of population balance, no?
- ngngngng 6y agoYep. If you want to see something scary, go browse reddit.com/r/childfree It's an entire community of people that feel like heroes for not having children, and despise the thought of even having to come into contact with a child. It carries a similar religious fervor to veganism but it doesn't actually help anyone or anything.
- extrawork99 6y agoLol. Found the person that can only identify as a breeder. Not having children is the most impactful thing you can do environmentally. Also: Veganism literally doesn’t actually help anything at all.
- asciident 6y agoI'm not advocating for the mindset there, but can't you see a justification of why that might be? I think reasonable people can debate whether or not overpopulation is the main contributor to the environmental disaster upon us that is an existential crises for humans on this planet. Under that perspective, wouldn't those who chose not to have children, while it was an unpopular option, be the heroes?
- rimliu 6y agoIt is underpopulation, not overpopulation that will be a problem soon (and already is in some parts of the world).
- 7leafer 6y agoThalia keeps smiling
- treyfitty 6y agoAnecdotally, my manager has been a terrible human being after I took paternity leave at the height of Covid in NYC. I 100% sense the resentment. Not only has he been a disgusting person towards me, but my duties have shifted to India and I’m being assigned projects where I have 0 experience in. I’ve been laid off from my current employer for taking parental leave before. So it’s not surprising that I’m being pushed out again. FYI: labor laws in my situation are very much stacked against me, as usual.
- holidayacct 6y agoIf you resent people who have children at your place of employment you have too much time on your hands.
- TheEnder8 6y agoI don't see how this is specific to tech firms? Why not any other company currently WFH-ing?
- rcpt 6y agoHonestly how prevalent is this hate? I haven't really seen it. To me this comes off as another clickbaity "let's bash on techbros" article.
- QuercusMax 6y agoI haven't heard any of it at Alphabet.
- derwiki 6y agoI would have said the same until I read this thread
- hprotagonist 6y agoI am charmed by kids popping into meeting backgrounds on zoom. They tend to speed up standups, and that's a good thing.
- analog31 6y agoCome to the Midwest. Here's how we do it. First of all, you can't retire at 30 on an entry level engineer salary (poetic license taken). Second, there are no child care benefits. Instead, parents with kids split things up. One parent (usually the one who was earning less anyway) dials down their career, perhaps by going part time. The other parent dials up, by competing for promotions. For instance, it's almost like clockwork that someone announces the birth of their first child, and shortly after that, they've become a project- or middle-manager, or they've gone to work somewhere else. A few years later, when their family life stabilizes, they might come back to engineering. That's what I did. This is a known economic effect. More than half of workers will change jobs for higher pay shortly after their first kid is born. There was a study of unskilled single women in a poor neighborhood in Chicago. After adjusting for everything else, the ones with kids tended to work for higher pay, changed jobs more often, and worked further from home. This is all pre-COVID of course, but is how things have worked for decades. Is this a good thing? Well, it stratifies the career ladder quite noticeably. How do you make it so that people with kids aren't running the entire show? Likewise for society as a whole? In my view, employer based child care benefits make about as much sense as employer based health care benefits.
- triceratops 6y agoAfter hearing that, I really don't think I want to come to the Midwest :-P (to work, that is).
- analog31 6y agoI look at it like being in a different country. I mean, suppose you live in country X, and you know that salaries and benefits are higher in country Y. Still, only so many people can move from X to Y, for whatever reason. So you live your life as well as you can in your home country. And at least you don't live in country Z. ;-) At my age and skill set, I don't know if I'd be competitive for a job in one of the high-wage cities anyway. There may be some things that I can do cheaper, that make it attractive for my employer to keep me rather than moving my work elsewhere.
- rdtwo 6y ago
- nsxwolf 6y agoThe anti-natalism in tech is just totally unsustainable. What will it become, a race to hire the last remaining infertile young people? Who will provide new humans to replace them - other families that aren't in tech? Parents have a strong influence on the careers of their children - we expect to completely remove that influence, since we will have no parents in tech - and expect their children to discover tech careers of their own accord?
- dydhsj 6y agoThey recruit from the “breeders”. Even before going to university a certain lifestyle that encourages consumption and materialism is framed as success, respectable, and as a pathway to happiness. Meanwhile sacrifice for others (for example) is never mentioned as something you can do. Sacrifice is something a “saint” like Ghandi or MLK does. So they (industrialists) siphon us off to work longer hours than we should for actually little pay. If you’re easily replaceable they’ll never pay you so much that you’ll work so many hours to have to give up having children. But your children are another story. They’ll go to college, saddle up with debt and, with 80k, get paid more than you and your spouse combined. But she’s working 50 hr/week for the promotion. 35, turns into 40 and your daughter hasn’t made you a grandchild. Overwork has dulled her cheerful smile. Fear of (the time commitment of) Down syndrome will have her abort any children that might not be perfect. And, as country debates it’s plummeting birth rates, the industrialist clamors to remove trade barriers so he can do it all over again elsewhere.
- solidsnack9000 6y agoIt's really of no consequence...there are just not that many people who work in tech. If none of them had children, it wouldn't matter.
- nsxwolf 6y agoThat makes me feel better if true.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Ericson2314 6y agoAs others are saying, any worker vs worker animosity here is a depressing and pathetic waste of energy. Focus on management. Remember money is relative, but total working hours is absolute.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aaomidi 6y agoWhat I find short sighted about these policies are they don't realize that people without children can also feel stressed and need more time off. e.g. if you're single during this time, you are completely isolated from the world, and your colleagues. This can be extremely difficult mentally and on an individual level can be much harder than just someone with a kid. These policies shouldn't be "oh if you have kids you can take this time off" and more "this is an unprecedented time, please take time off if you need it for any reason." Trying to make judgement calls on who needs the time off and who doesn't is the major cause of this issue.
- usrusr 6y agoI agree with your assessment about how social distancing is in some ways worse for singles, but I fail to see how time off would help.
- johnjj257 6y agoI'm sure to many being isolated and working non stop is worse than being isolated and having more free time.
- jartelt 6y agoTime off would allow people to relax, work on a hobby, exercise, etc. If you are feeling run down after working from a crappy, crammed apartment for 3 months, it can be refreshing to get an extra week or so off work with no questions asked.
- hvidgaard 6y agoBeing single, you have time for all that in a normal week anyway. And if you don't you wouldn't have had the time for social interaction in the first place.
- kenhwang 6y agoI've been encouraging my team (parents or not) to just take time off. The singles are suffering from essentially cabin fever given their typically smaller living accommodations and now missing social support. The parents are distracted, yes, but the singles/childless seem to be burning out way faster.
- KindOne 6y agoSame discussion, different site from 3 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24383264 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24383264
- stanfordkid 6y agoOur society is not organized collectively -- so you don't really give a shit about your co-workers kids. This is the origin of all the anxiety. You would not worry about sacrificing your time to help them, if you knew them. It is a simple fix, if companies were formed more like actual communities. Unfortunately, with specialized labor, this is pretty much impossible. There is a great book, called, "Capitalism and Schizophrenia", by a french psychoanalyst and philosopher duo, Deleuze and Guetarri. They get into why this organizational structure often lead to a profound disconnect by consolidating aspects of production into silos, as described above.
- cryptica 6y agoAll their employees are wasting time making the world a worse place anyway or going round in circles... And the corporations are getting free money from the Fed... So they should just give all their employees free money.
- x87678r 6y agoI'm pretty sure this is a made up story. I also rarely see parents work less - usually they're happy to work late to avoid having to go home and look after the kids. :)
- jedberg 6y agoBefore the pandemic, this resentment already existed. It's just exacerbated now. There have always been hidden benefits for people with kids. And although those benefits don't nearly make up for the extra responsibilities of having kids, those without kids feel that it's unfair. For example, someone with kids gets a bigger insurance benefit. Usually managers are pretty forgiving when someone says they need to leave the office at exactly 6pm every day to get to soccer practice, leaving the single people stuck without the same excuse. Oftentimes the single people are asked to do the extra off-hours work "because you have no kids so you don't mind right?" This is just an extension of that, which is perceived as unfair to the single folks.
- schreiaj 6y agoI don’t have kids. I have a partner with some very not fun medical conditions. I have never had any issues getting “dinged” for the fact that I have to stop work at a specific time because meds need to be taken with food. I communicate it clearly to my peers and managers. In the last couple months I’ve had to miss days to deal with doctors sometimes on zero notice (as in I actually responded to a question from my boss with “uh if this is urgent here’s my cell call in about 30 and I can discuss it but I have to take my other half to the doctor”) Some of this is being willing to admit it and just simply ask. I didn’t once and tried to work through it and my boss at the time reamed me out for it. But I’d also never think twice if a coworker said “I gotta take off early, got a date”. Life happens, as long as nobody is outright abusing it who cares? It sounds like in the situation you described people are abusing it and the managers are just not paying much attention.
- BrandonM 6y agoOne thing I've found in the change to being a parent is that I'm much more confident in saying, "No, I have this other important thing I have to do. If you want my contributions, it will have to be on these terms." Most employers that would accept that of parents would accept it of anyone. Most employers that wouldn't accept employees setting reasonable boundaries or making reasonable requests wouldn't accept them from parents, either. There are bound to be some that only accept boundary-setting from parents, but I assert that it's a very small percent of employers or managers. Maybe I'm wrong. What I'm proposing here is that most people are too afraid to ask for what they want. Parents have the benefit of having some of those expectations carved out beforehand, but I think that many of them also develop a newfound ability to say, "No, sorry, can't do that."
- rayiner 6y agoThis is a mark of a sick and decaying society. Without everyone having more or less two kids, who is going to pay for social security? (Or work at Amazon, etc., so your 401k isn’t worthless?) And no, immigration isn’t a solution, it’s a cop-out. Us immigrants still have to raise our kids amongst co-workers who are complaining why parents get more slack during Covid. (I mean, I don’t, because my coworkers aren’t psychotic.)
- tilolebo 6y ago"A manager responded that the employee was expected to work full time, or not at all." Wow, I have no words... What a shitty leader.
- hnFarmboy 6y agoThis is media framing that seems to be designed to divide parents and non-parents. Who really knows if many of the non-parents are actually mad at the parents rather than at their employers? This seems like a fabricated narrative pushed by wealthy tech companies, or maybe just by the media to get clicks and be controversial.
- markus_zhang 6y agoI think this is more of the firm's responsibility to communicate in a better way and sort out the conflicts in one way or another. This is stressful time for everyone and indeed the conflicts will intensify here and there. As a would-be parent I do believe that everyone is selfish and if the number of people who show such frustration do increase to hundreds then the company better addresses it directly instead of letting people attack each other. It's HR's (and manager's) duty to quiet such conflicts before it gets to that point.
- jknz 6y agoManaging remote school sessions plus my work was a mess. I made my 10 and 12yo kids drop their remote school stuff and work with me instead. The young one is responsible for slack, keeping everyone in the living room updated and replying with text and the occasional gif, he also summarizes with voice important incoming emails. Older one writes python code alongside me and I now mostly check her syntax. She learned git at the beginning of the pandemic and my manager is now impressed that commits from us get pushed while I am on the phone with him. The kids drafted an email yesterday to ask for a raise and align my compensation with that of 1senior+2juniors SWE. Fingers crossed
- seattletech 6y agoCouldn't you get kids in Vietnam who are cheaper? Are you also stack racking them?
- tolbish 6y agoExcept the kid dicking around Slack did more team bonding than you ever bothered doing and now he has your job.
- duutfhhh 6y agoThat email will make a senior HR person have a serious talk with 10 other HRs and lawyers, because the matter is non trivial, but their answer will be (delivered by your manager): "you'll get an extra bonus at the next perf cycle." Then they will wait if you settle for this.
- smabie 6y agoSounds like you are becoming obsolete!
- SenoraRaton 6y agoI'm pretty sure child labor is against the law....
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Waterluvian 6y agoOne thing I wish I could make my childless peers grok is that THERE IS NO VACATION when you have young kids. I’m taking this week off and people speak as if I’m on vacation. Please please hear my words literally: my job is my break. Weekends are more physically and intellectually exhausting than weekdays when I get to $&@# off to work for eight hours. My paid time off is a way to give us a fighting chance at laundry and housecleaning and other chores. Grocery shopping was my break today. Home Depot was my treat today. I’m not on vacation. Please help me keep my marbles. Give me a break.
- aftergibson 6y agoI feel you. Took my first "vacation" with our son last week, it was a far more stressful experience that a week working. My partner is seriously my hero.
- tolbish 6y agoDo you have family or close friends that could look after them for a few days?
- Waterluvian 6y agoThe one year old isn’t ready for overnights for a number of reasons. I’m not saying we’re in dire straits here. Being a parent is the most fulfilling thing I’ve ever done. But it’s also the hardest job I’ve ever had. And you can’t wake up and decide to take a me day.
- derwiki 6y agoThis is a tangent and I'm not trying to belittle your position: but the bit about can't waking up and decide to take a day off reminded me of a country song about how soldiers can't call in sick on Monday, work straight through the holidays.
- rsync 6y ago"And you can’t wake up and decide to take a me day." I encourage you to do exactly that! Go to your partner and tell them at X day in the near future, you will take all of the children and do everything and they can have the entire day to themselves. On the day, pretend as if they are on an airplane: don't call them, don't text them ... really do take care of everything yourself. No matter how stressful it is, do not unload any stress or guilt after the day is over. Next week it's your turn :) My wife and I each take a full day each week and a 1-2 week "sabbatical" each year. Recommended.
- tus88 6y ago> When the Boston Consulting Group surveyed 3,055 people across the US, UK, France, Germany and Italy, in March and April, it found more than a third of respondents were worried their performance would be unfairly compared with that of colleagues without family obligations. Why is it an unfair comparison and not an accurate comparison?
- projectileboy 6y agoThis all strikes me as the 10,000th variation of the old joke: the billionaire takes 11 donuts, leaves one in the middle, and tells the childless guy “hey, that guy with a kid is trying to take your donut.” If in the US we lived in a culture that actually treated people as humans and not as either expendable producers or expendable consumers, we wouldn’t even be having this conversation.
- subsubzero 6y agoLife with two working adults(both in higher level tech roles) and a toddler is absolute hell in covid. For the people complaining I wish they could spend a day in either me or my Wife's shoes and see how easy they have it. WLB has gotten so unbearable we are thinking of quitting one of our jobs and just going solo income. It was one of the main reasons we sold our house and left the bay area early this year so we are not trapped in a 2 income house payment.
- getpost 6y agoThere is a fairness problem, and I don't see a solution except to allow everyone to work less. Working less is not a bad thing. As a manager, I've always accommodated parental (or other family) leave requests. I even encouraged hesitant parents or other care-givers to take paid time away from work. I don't remember ever refusing leave or pressuring anyone to return to work. This was sometimes contrary to the employer's stated policy. Had I been asked about it (and I never was) I would have made the case that it is in the employer's interest and my interest as a manger to be flexible. I never had a request for more than a few days at a time. Obviously, requests to take an extended period (months or years) are another matter. I remember very few requests for non-vacation, self-care time off, just the rare "mental health" day. In my experience, it really is true that parents and other care-givers take more time off than non-care-givers. In partial mitigation, I have found caregivers to be somewhat more efficient in completing work at the office, compared to single people, especially single people under 30. Parents don't have time to waste! EDIT: I see two fairness issues, caregivers getting more time off than other employees. And, not all managers are the way I was, and it is unfair that "my" employees had a better situation than others.
- alexbanks 6y agoI"m not sure why this thread is so polarized. I am 30 and I don't have kids - I am burnt out from the pandemic and can assume that those trapped inside with their kids are orders of magnitude more burnt out than me. I feel bad for them. I am also very burnt out, which shows itself in an array of different symptoms (more irritable, more prone to being frustrated/resentful for those that have different situations than me, etc). It's fine to acknowledge that some have it harder than you, but to also wish that you had it easier. I wish we all had it easier. Sometimes, when I'm feeling most frustrated with everything, I wish I also had an excuse to work part time but keep my entire pay (which is, ignoring all else, what a lot of peers with children get). Humans are complicated and can have lots of feelings, some of which are irrational and some of which are unempathetic. We're all getting squeezed right now.
- watertom 6y agoCompanies don't have any social responsibility. Companies don't have any country allegiance responsibilities. Companies don't have any employee allegiance responsibilities. Companies only have responsibilities to the shareholders. If I was running a company in the U.S., and in my role I basically I am doing that I'd be completely furious with the the U.S. government and how they've handled the pandemic, and I am furious with the U.S. government and how they've handled this pandemic. Health care responsibilities for employees have been shoved down the throat of companies for years. Now companies are supposed to make accommodations for the failure of a government to act correctly during a pandemic. Pandemic, Blah, blah blah, "I need to spend my day as a parent, so I can't work, but please pay me like I am working." If an employee can't complete their job tasks they should be fired. It doesn't matter that it's the failure of a government to act that's causing the employee come up short, that's not the problem of the company.
- kixiQu 6y agoIf your company is incapable of structuring things to get done when you set reasonable boundaries about the amount you're going to work, that's its fault, not your coworkers'. If you choose to set those boundaries tightly and your company tries to put more than a fair burden on you, that is not your coworkers' fault. If you choose to do more and your company proves incapable of recognizing you stepping up to the plate in the absence of your parent-coworkers, that's your company's fault, not your coworkers'.
- fizixer 6y agoA job in big tech is not a job. It's half a job, half a privilege. Perfectly capable s/w developers fail big tech interviews for the tiniest slip-ups in a day long coding marathon. Big tech response: "We can afford to lose perfectly capable s/w developers as false positives during interviews, cz the supply for filling up our positions is abundant." A significant number of capable s/w developers even acknowledge that, and accept it as the nature of the beast. Big tech can definitely grow some balls and apply the same rules to those who get in and then decide to go on baby vacay sprees. (Oh, and btw, this also goes by the name of "an effin company doing its effin job!") Parents can switch to minimum wage jobs with full parental coverage, PTO, what have you. Don't think minimum wage is high enough to support children? I agree, let's raise the minimum wage. I even support government funded childcare. If a big tech company decides to run like a baby-producing country club charity, it's only a matter of time before it'll be taken over by an actual big tech company that gives a shit about its business.
- rdtwo 6y agoLol
- technotarek 6y agoThere is nothing unique about tech in this regard. Not saying it shouldn’t be on HN, but it’s a weird spin that adds nothing to the important and very real points of the article otherwise.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jb775 6y agoNot trying to make this political, but I wanted to point out my initial thoughts: It's probably safe to say a good majority of these tech employees skew left, and I'm sure a bulk of these "resenters" were the same people barking on facebook about keeping schools/businesses/daycares/etc closed down. However, the underlying causes of resentment discussed here are the 3rd and 4th order effects of keeping everything closed down. It honestly just sounds like once the "resenters" have skin in the game and are immediately impacted by the policies they're pushing, their reaction is to kick the nearest dad in the balls.
- chrisbrandow 6y agoHonestly, when public policy is garbage and everyone has to deal with unreasonable demands, it is quite natural for groups to turn on each other rather than to demand more for everyone. This entire experience has been difficult for everyone, and everyone is somewhere on a spectrum of minimal disruption to profound stress. I have kids, but it's been "ok" so far. On the other hand I know of a woman who is an attorney representing abused children. Her childcare bailed on her at the last minute. She had to do a zoom trial while her 2 year old began screaming in the background and she had no one to take over her case or her child. She literally broke down in court. There was no obvious "solution" to that situation. I don't have a conclusion other than it is up to employers and government to provide resources so that we aren't all fighting like animals over the scraps.
- FpUser 6y agoLetting parents with kids to arrange work schedule however they see fit is the least we can do. I understand there will be some professions/situations where it is not possible but it should be used as a general rule otherwise. We already have large segments of populace fucked up by the growing inequality and subjecting people to even more is really bad idea I think.
- kgwgk 6y agoAm I the only one who understands the title of the submission “Tech firms face growing resentment of parent employees” exactly in the opposite way than the actual headline “Tech firms face growing resentment toward parent employees”?
- crawshaw 6y agoSomeone took care of us when we were young. By the time we can be employed by major corporations for far more than the average family makes, we all owe a debt to those who care for the young. We cannot truly pay back those who took care of us, so we pay it forward. Maybe that payment will only ever be supporting the caregivers by our side. That is worthy work.
- syntaxing 6y agoI understand the stance of "taking responsibility of your actions", such as deciding to have a kid, but I'm pretty surprised how people view the current situation. At one point, society has to decide when to help those in need for benefit of society and your morality. How is this any different from any other natural disaster? You wouldn't expect one of your colleagues to work normally if they lost their house to a wild fire. You wouldn't tell them, "well you shouldn't of decided to live in a wild fire prone area. Suck it up and figure it out.".
- jively 6y agoIt helps if the founders have kids - both my co-founder and I have young children and we founded the company on the principles of work/life balance being paramount (Tyk.io). If you accept that people can be productive when scheduling their own time, you find that there's actually better participation and buy-in, since everyone has flexible time, the benefits for parents vs non parents are the same. Need to take time to take care of your sick cousin? Sure. Need to move to a different country to help your wife go to a specialist? Sure. Been on the waiting list for two years to go on a special hiking course? Go for it. People can be productive whenever if you let them. But everyone needs to be able to take the same approach to their own work/life balance. It's the humanist way to work, and if a company doesn't flex to let their employees flourish you're not doing your employees justice. Folks forget it's a value exchange between employee and employer not a one-way street. That's too easy to forget in the modern work environment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kingkawn 6y agofrom each according to their ability...
- davesque 6y agoThis just feels like a clickbait non-story to me. The media nowadays seems primarily concerned with sewing divisiveness to take advantage of people's fear and attract eyeballs and outrage.
- kirillzubovsky 6y agoIt is about time companies stop rewarding employees for time spent doing work, as opposed to results of the deliverables. In SV there is a myth that employees that are young and single are somehow more productive. That might be in a cruel sense true for the founders, as you most likely have no obligations outside of your company and generally feel like spending 24 hours devoted to it, but for an employee, this notion is utterly false. Plenty of married/parents spend unhealthy amount of time on their work, and plenty of single employees spend way too much time talking and playing games in the office, all to appear as if they are putting in the long hours. Meanwhile, although parents certainly have a lot less "free time," you also learn to be very efficient with it. Talk less, do more, be more strategic, ..etc. There is no one size fits all, and it's just lazy to say that one group is more productive than the other solely based on the factor of hours theoretically available to do work.
- skizm 6y agoI've gone through maybe 20 of the top comments so far and not one has pointed out that having kids is a choice. All of them are saying "childless workers don't understand parents have it tough!" Yes, they do. That's why they're childless. As a childless worker, if I volunteer at non-profits with all my free time, can I take 6 months of paid leave occasionally too? Which non-work related hobbies are deemed "worthy" for all this extra paid leave? Is there a list somewhere? Or is "being a parent" the only item on the list?
- mancerayder 6y agoIt's a give and a take, isn't it? For example, I don't have kids, but I know this whole experience is a nightmare for many people with kids. I can hear it in the background in conference calls - and sometimes I can literally see little kids running and jumping up and down. That's all you need to show me to gain my sympathy, because that's a nightmarish scenario as far as I'm concerned. I don't admire people with kids. Now, one day I might get sick, or a family member might, or something happens, or I need to take time for some reason. I expect the company to give a little there, too, if I've been there a while. It's not an exchange, just a humane approach one hopes and expects.
- notacoward 6y agoThe most important point here is that this is about the company's own self interest and the complainers are asking them to act against that. People who are unable to reconcile the demands of parenthood with those of their job will quit. That's bad for the bottom line, the company wants to avoid that, so they make accommodations. The reward - salary, equity, perks - each employee gets was always about supply and demand and cost of replacement, not mushy ideas of deservedness or fairness. The second point is that these same people were strangely silent when everything about working conditions benefited them. Long working hours and oncall requirements are far more burdensome to those with families than to those without. Ditto performance-review and promotion standards that require consistent delivery on pre-planned items over a long period of time. Easy enough to arrange your life around that when you have no other demands or commitments. I did that myself when I was single. It's a lot harder when an event within the family - even a joyous one such as a long-desired child - can throw your availability and concentration for an unexpected loop. Goodbye, last 11 months of effort. Have to reset now. After benefiting from years of policies that favor the childless, suddenly strict equality must be the rule? Please. Again, this is about the company acting in its own self interest. Attrition and lack of diversity are bad in the long run. The complainers are simply easier to replace than those they're complaining about. See first paragraph.
- solidsnack9000 6y ago"Long working hours and oncall requirements..." are not benefits and they are only increasing now for childless people, while the parents get multiple weeks of free vacation. You've engaged in a slight of hand here by describing the demands of a job that are somewhat easier for the childless to meet, and then turning around and treating these demands like they're "...policies that favor the childless...".
- notacoward 6y agoHow is a demand that is easier for the childless to meet, even if only slightly, not a policy that favors the childless? That's not sleight of hand. It's just English.
- a3n 6y agoI suppose if they're able, workers with children should quit and go somewhere more child friendly. Most ... no, all of the places I've worked, except the USN, have been matter of factly child friendly. It shouldn't be hard to find such a place.
- gorbachev 6y agoThis whole discussion to me just boils down to: I don't live to work. I work to live. Employers that forget that will not be my employers for too long. And, yes, I have quit more than one job for exactly this reason.
- snickell 6y agoA 50 year transition to 50% of the current population would be difficult to manage, but if you could skip ahead another 50 years, I believe everyone would have a higher quality of life: cheaper housing, less crowded nature and more of it, less competition for natural resources, more land available per person, more opportunities for recognition in winner-take-all markets, etc. At our current population density levels and birthrate, I believe society should (moderately) discourage having kids, and one of the best ways to do that is to say "those who want it the most should do it", which means those for whom its the most beneficial and meaningful. A good starting point for that is not to discourage having kids, but not particularly support it either. If its hard, that's ok, the people who are ok with the difficulty will do it, and those that aren't won't, and we'll have fewer new people to the benefit of ourselves and future generations. I didn't think this until several years ago, when I got the opportunity to work at an NGO focused on carbon neutral energy systems research. This gave me a lot of work time to explore what the US looks like today, and how that has changed over the past 50 years. One of my key random personal takeaways from several years exploring carbon chains, land use, etc, a takeaway shared with several of my colleagues who already had children, was that we had previously underestimated the degree to which quality of life in post-2000 (completely aside from quality of life for other species, which is a separate topic) is negatively impacted by the increased density of people. For example, and there's lots of stories you can tell like this, many people like having access to alone time in nature, and it's a lot harder in 2020 than it was in 1970, simply because more people in the country => less natural / fallow land. "The woods behind the neighborhood" is less and less a thing. As an aside, my wife and I were considering having kids until I got exposed to these viewpoints, and they changed my mind. I think its better that my brother has kids, because he REALLY REALLY wanted to have them. And that's great. But, for example, he now doesn't have the free time I have to do open source.... and neither will I if I work longer hours to cover for him ;-)
- curious_fella1 6y agoThis is stupid. I've seen 0 signs of this as the FAANG company I work at (my gauge being our internal forum). Absolutely 0 mention of this. No mentions from coworkers, friends, etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- daxfohl 6y agoI continue to wonder who is needing new widgets during this time. It all seems so disconnected from reality.
- chasd00 6y agomy wife is a middle school teacher and I have kids ages 8 and 10. I work at a major consulting firm but, fortunately, travel is zero right now. it's certainly been out of the ordinary having the kids at home and going to school over zoom. it's not easy but not much of parenthood is, I try to roll with it and pick my battles. I passed on some very cool projects because of LOE knowing full well I wouldn't have the time to dedicate. ironically, our friends having the hardest time are stay-at-home moms. back to school is a cherished time for them and they're having a hard time adjusting.
- solidsnack9000 6y agoI am surprised and perhaps impressed by the tremendous number of commenters dropping by to post that children are beneficial, we should all be working together to help parents, the purpose of society is to raise children...while omitting to mention that having children is also incredibly rewarding and represents evolutionary success of the highest order. No one would say, aerospace is beneficial, so we should give all the employees with private planes extra time off to pursue their avocation. Some of those planes are going to participate in search and rescue some day. People would recognize that this is robbing the poor to feed the rich and that is exactly what taking from single people -- overwhelmingly people who are less able, socially or financially, to have children -- represents. The many people who had children while expecting to rely on society for the whole ~20 years of it -- who had not backup plan involving extended family and didn't consider that a problem -- weren't thinking straight and made a mistake. It's amazing that so many people made imprudent choices and imprudency is not something we can ask our coworkers to cover for.
- S_A_P 6y agoThe entitlement of equality of outcome is real.
- nullsense 6y agoMy work gave those of us with kids 25% reduced working hours to accommodate. It was really good.
- breakyerself 6y agoUnionization of the tech industry is long overdue.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoI felt that the headline of this article wasn’t well-supported by its content. Almost everyone in the article supports parents and understands how difficult they have it. The only exception was three commenters on Blind, which is notoriously full of trolls. That’s hardly evidence of “growing resentment”. People here on HN seem to agree, if that upvoted comments are indication. To be honest, I feel this headline is clickbait trafficking on the anxiety felt by many parents.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TeeMassive 6y agoI'm going to be the devil's advocate here. Why should I have to cope with you absences while there is no downside for you but many for the rest of us? Ask for less hours, flexible schedule or delegate your responsibilities to someone else when you can't show up or when you risk getting called. Just because you have children doesn't mean you are entitled than me.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoParenting is a full time job. We have been brainwashed by feminists that all of us can do everything. Maybe reset assumptions. Covid brings home lessons.
- gxnxcxcx 6y agoWe have been brainwashed by capitalists that all of us must do everything.
- bluedays 6y agoITT a lot of people who don't have kids talking about the "benefits" of having children. It's pretty clear anyone who talks about "benefits of being of parent" don't have kids.
- dsaavy 6y agoAfter reading many, many comments here I think it's become very evident to me how important it is to live with/near extended family and very close friends. It takes a village to raise a child and living as isolated parents far from friends or family that can help in raising children is not sustainable. Americans (and maybe other western civilizations) seem to have removed ourselves so far from community that we forgot what true community is even for. Sharing resources and helping others simply to be a part of the "tribe" without having to pay for every single thing. This transactional consumerist economy has pushed us to where we're paying for everything, have incredibly fragile networks of dependency, and can't trust anyone unless money and a contract is involved.
- eximius 6y agoAll of the data presented seems to be parents who are anxious about their performance at work, then, what, a single anecdote about an asshole manager? I'm sure this problem exists, but I as a peer or manager do not hold this against those with kids. If you have kids, I want you to feel supported right now, not afraid.
- spaceisballer 6y agoI think the actual absurdity going on is that we are keeping pre-COVID expectations during a pandemic(crisis). I’ve used this time to really reevaluate the things my area is responsible for and trim the fat. We all know people have things that will come up, so we all need to be more Agile. Been pushing Kanban hard in my area now because we offer so much work flexibility. So I’ve been prioritizing work and making sure it’s there for the team to take on. If only one person usually does certain tasks, make sure they train others. And I’m there to protect them if upper management takes issue with their output. I feel like I’ve been cold hearted or just methodical but it’s only in regards to the work not the people. Work is just that, work. It isn’t life, come to work get your work done and if life gets in the way, fine let me know. I mean what the hell is the point of a team if one person (or many) have less availability and it all falls apart? Get the highest priority work done first and maybe that lower stuff isn’t actually that important.
- medium_burrito 6y agoIt is only fair for those who cannot have children to let them have parental leave when they get a pet (fur baby). I don't buy that we need to keep on producing children- there aren't enough decent jobs for the present generation, let alone a bunch of new kids, unless you count OnlyFans.
- ultramundane8 6y agoThis thread is absolutely bananas. I actually read most of it at 759 comments. The short version is that people with kids are insanely defensive about it. In many cases, they have literally rewritten their brains to see reproduction as exclusively good and necessary. If you suggest anything else, you will be swiftly brigaded and condemned. Those without children are all over the place. Their opinions vary from complete disinterest to strong resentment of parents.
- ulmas 6y ago"rewritten their brains"... conceiving, carrying, birthing, raising a child is not like picking a favorite beverage or ice cream flavour, and changing the choice as you evolve. It's not something you set your mind about, and change it a couple weeks later as a result of a mood swing, or because of an influential article or a comment on the web. "reproduction ... good and necessary"... people don't get kids because it's "good", and certainly not because it's "necessary"... They're a little more to it. and no, you either read all of the 759 comments, or you didn't. Also, skim through ≠ read.
- stormbeard 6y agoYou're not really making a point here. If you think they are wrong, then tell us why you think this. Shooting down the comment and providing no real input is unproductive.
- 762236 6y agoThe brain instantly rewrites itself when the kid pops out. Such a weird experience.
- thinkingemote 6y ago> reproduction as exclusively good and necessary If reproduction was bad and unnecessary you, me, none of us would exist. Reproduction is fundamentally essential and necessary for life itself. Bananas indeed. 7/10
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- darthrupert 6y agoOk, good luck with that sentiment, kids. If you want the ”crazy benefits” of parenthood, becoming one is not that difficult. Be prepared for a severe loss of quality of life and wealth in the short (0-21 years) run though.
- linuxhansl 6y agoNot _at all_ true where I work. I work with folks who have kids and folks that don't. There is absolutely no sign of this. I interact with a fairly large group of people; everybody is understanding and supportive. Now. Perhaps I'm in a lucky bubble here, and it's different in other places. Perhaps the article is click-bait. Hard to know. In the end it seems rather pointless to build up resentment this way anyway. There is so much evidence that a good work-live balance has a greater impact on productivity than skill - engineers who work less often get done more. Managers who do not understand that should, frankly, do something else.
- m0zg 6y agoFYI: if you hold these opinions, it would be wise of you to not voice them in public at work. Most of your bosses have kids, and as a parent myself I struggle to think of anything that would cause more resentment on my part than idiotic bullshit like this.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoThis is a real phenomenon. When my son was first born I blew through about five jobs in five years because I had to leave at 4:45pm - 5:15pm to pick him up from daycare or school. Before that I tended to remain in the same position for 5-6 years. Then I got into a position where most of my peers and superiors had kids, "got it" and I've been in that position for close to five years now. Especially annoying when your peers are coming in drunk or stoned, passed out at their desks half the time, and you are the one getting grief because you have a parent/teacher conference to attend. If my peers wanted to WFH because they were hung over, mo problem. If I needed to WFH because I was feeling ill, no problem. If I needed to WFH to watch my child I would have to do video calls with my boss every two hours to show what I had done. Eventually I wised up and just said I was sick instead of mentioning my son.
- honkycat 6y agoJust to get my take out in the open: I do not have kids yet. People are going to have kids and I like kids. Raging against that is like whipping the ocean. Of course we should support families as much as we can as a society, they are our future. ( And maybe we should cut workers some slack across the board...) However, I feel like people are creating this narrative where society is persecuting them for having children, and they feel judged and persecuted. Most people have children. Where is this boogeyman coming from? I agree that it is hard to have children in this political and economic climate. But to assert "People don't get how hard it is to have kids!" BULLSHIT! Most people fucking HAVE kids! And even people who do not have kids understand how hard it is! This persecution complex natalists have is completely unfounded. Society is VERY positive of having children. Now, support from the government/place of work is another story. But to suggest that society is "hostile" to people with children is absurd.
- rexpop 6y ago> Most people have children. I can't find any source for this claim.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- reyqn 6y agohttps://www.statista.com/statistics/241535/percentage-of-childless-women-in-the-us-by-age/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/241535/percentage-of-chi...
- rimliu 6y ago> Most people have children. Maybe because whilt that's true in general it is not true in the environments we talk about? Stats may be different in tech companies with very young workforce.
- destructured 6y agoThe various extra entitlements parents get in terms of paid leave, long-term leave with a guaranteed job on the other side, and so on, are a complete joke. I know my opinions won't be popular on this left-wing website, but there won't be any rational reply to what I say. The fact is that it is a benefit given to a specific group of employees and not others. What are the reasons? Well, there are none. In my country, it is required by law to have these benefits. The rationale they gave was "it is an essential role, we need to increase the birth rate, etc". After decades of this policy, there was no increase in the birth rate. The population had to grow via immigration, not births from residents. As for an "essential role", the people having babies don't think they are doing the world a favour, they are doing it for themselves. That is beside the point though. The reality is that I had to sit at my desk and watch as every parent in the company took months of paid leave off that I never got, based on a rationale that is proven to be incorrect. They often had more than one baby, so they took these benefits multiple times. The reality is that it was introduced to buy votes, and now they won't take it away. That is how it is in my country. It makes no sense to give money and time off to my boss, who makes more than me, and not me because I am not in any position to have kids. This is absurd.
- notadev 6y agoI hope the situation changes soon. I'm a parent and two of my kids are doing school online. I have been able to make it work, in that I'm not slacking at work or leaving stuff for someone else, but I'm working much longer than I ever did at the office. I've found the best way to meet the demands of work, while meeting the demands of my kids, is the put some work on the back burner. Once they go to bed, I catch an hour or two before getting up and knocking out the work I wanted to do earlier. I understand it's not tenable, but nothing else I can do at the moment.
- sriku 6y agoIf employees of tech companies have to argue about whether parents can be afforded concession due to the pandemic situation/home-schooling/etc, I wonder what improvement in quality of life that technology has actually yielded. Is this a US-specific phenomenon?
- jackvalentine 6y agoThere is a lot of talk about the extra hours non-parents are finding themselves working but I have found most of my resentment comes from the reduced ability to get things done. With half my team taking some kind of pandemic related leave or reduced hours we're just simply ineffective and treading water. That's just a fact the rest of us have to deal with but you can't deny that it's disappointing if you're motivated by achievement.
- drpebcak 6y agoThis is true, although I don’t resent anyone for it - it’s mostly just demoralizing.
- angry_octet 6y agoTo those who say "I didn't choose to have children, why should I suffer / pay extra tax / not receive time off?" I have a simple response: you exist because you were born and cared for by society. Caring for children (which is what those parents are doing) is a societal cost. Those raised by wolves should be allowed wilderness time.
- w_t_payne 6y agoAs a parent, I fear that even in the best of times, parenthood is simply incompatible with the level of time and effort that working in tech demands. I really wish I knew how to resolve this problem, but it feels more like a physical problem, to do with the limits of human attention and learning, than a social one. I suspect there is no easy fix.
- meowtimemania 6y agoI think part-time employment could be a viable solution. Parenting takes time and I’m not sure if there’s enough time in the day to be a parent and work a full time job
- kelnos 6y ago> More than half of 1,000 people surveyed by Care.com said they felt like they'd let down their colleagues due to juggling children and work during the pandemic. Frankly, it's true, they probably have. I've quickly learned that my co-workers who have kids will be less productive. But so what? This is just the reality we're all facing, and we have to account for that when planning and assigning work. Now, I don't think that should mean that I have to pick up the slack and work 80 hour weeks (that's just generally unfair, and I'm dealing with my own COVID-related difficulties), but that does mean that a project that would normally take 3 months might now take 4 or 5 or 6. Tech companies are lucky that they mostly still get to complete their projects, even late! Companies that require in-person and in-office work to get things done aren't completing projects at all right now. > And 45% believe their career advancement has suffered because they're juggling work and kids at home. This is the only thing that's actually a problem. Parents shouldn't have to be judged against their pre-COVID productivity levels. That's entirely unreasonable to expect of them, and there's nothing anyone can do about that.
- ____unionize___ 6y agoSo much debate about cost/benefits of children and to whom. Which employees subsidise others.... It's the _employer_ doing it. Allowing it. If there's good benefits (who doesn't want to work less/more flexibly). There's no reason not to give it to everybody. Act of god is kind of just an accelerator here. So long as there's shareholder value to be extracted, saying it's impossible is a lie. Stop squabbling and stand together to demand better working conditions for all.
- secondcoming 6y ago> Still, these types of experiences with rogue managers or toxic employees are unsettling many parents. What is 'toxic' about expecting to be treated the same as someone else who probably has the same contract T&Cs as me?
- jmspring 6y agoI’ll take the rep hit. But as a childless middle aged employee... I think we need to reign things in and less experienced expecting the world need to actually prove themselves beyond leet code and one prior couple year experience. Those with families, should expect the younger snots to be sympathetic because during this time those same younger snots are bitching about being stuck inside with third roommates, hang outs limited, etc. My point - regardless of your situation, Covid sucks. Those dealing with responsibility for others is a hardship; those expecting the world of opportunity and bitching about lack of progress, suck a fat one; we are all in this together.
- woadwarrior01 6y agoThis reminds me of an episode from my own life. After I'd left FB, I interviewed at a smaller SV social media company for a remote SWE role. The technical interviews were easy enough, during the final interview with the director of the department, he asked me point blank: "Do you have any children?". I found that question to be very jarring because my spouse was 2 months pregnant with our first child at the time. After pausing to weigh my options a bit, I replied with a curt "no". The first thought that came across my mind was, how was even legal to ask questions like that at a job interview? But then I remembered that he was sitting in California and I was in Ireland. In all likelihood there aren't any international laws preventing it. To conclude the story, I got an offer that I accepted. Told the director during our first 1:1 that I was expecting a child. At both subsequent interaction I had with that person started with an anti-natalist rant about how children slow down one's career. I left the company in 3 months. The anti-natalism was one of the many reasons to do so.
- gandutraveler 6y agoIt's so sad many commenters don't seem to objectively acknowledge non-parents argument here. Calling them as selfish and non empathetic. What If there is no pay cut and every employee gets the same 6 weeks time off whether you have kids or not. If employees are willing to work for those 6 weeks they will be paid extra. This should be a win-win solution. I as a non parent, I'm struggling with being locked down for longer duration. With almost none social and dating life. I used to eat company catered meals before covid and now I have to spend extra hours doing it all by myself and no one to share the work load with. I wish I could take time off from work, visit my family back home or work on finding my future partner. But our manager looks up to us non-parents to meet our OKR's. So yeah, being a non-parent in this pandemic is hard. So please don't disregard our struggles just because you were non-parents before and you think all we do is chill and play xbox.
- RankingMember 6y ago> What If there is no pay cut and every employee gets the same 6 weeks time off whether you have kids or not. If employees are willing to work for those 6 weeks they will be paid extra. This should be a win-win solution. This is the only way to do it, by my estimation, but how do you divvy this up? Does everyone just get 6 weeks off per year? I think that's a tough wrinkle, actually.
- renewiltord 6y agoWho gets upset by this? Say "I gotta go take care of my sister's/cousin's/niece's kids" and then go play videogames or Netflix or whatever. It's not like anyone can confirm.
- elindbe2 6y agoTo some extent all firms have to grade on a curve, so does it really hurt me if my parent coworkers are less able to deliver? If anything it would help me comparatively, though maybe at an overall cost to the firm's goals (which are different from my personal goals).
- cc23 6y agoThis whole thread makes me think that we all work too much. People are upset that those with children are given more schedule flexibility than those who do not have children. It seems like straight up jealousy. Instead of resenting parents, resent your manager and ask for ( or demand) what you want. The argument that other workers need to make up for the slack left by parents does not really make sense; you just add tasks to your backlog, and do them when you have time. You should be in control of your own schedule, and don't let your manager just extend your workday. If your manager does not respect your time and is overworking you, quit. As engineers, we are not punching a time clock. If you are, take issue with that, not the flexibility some other coworkers are getting (flexibility that they need). If you also want more schedule flexibility, push for it. Talk to your manager. Organize with your fellow employees. Organize with other engineers. Start a union (gasp!). Work-life balance is always a balance. Our jobs should take note of what we do outside of work and how that affects our ability to work. We are people, not mindless, identical worker bees. Our life outside of work is most likely more important to us than our life at work. Having children is very much unlike most other activities in that you cannot quit. You can quit a side hustle, you can quit a sport. But you can't quit being a parent. So when a parent turns to their boss and says "I need more flexibility", the manager has to give that flexibility or the worker is going to have to find a new job that does give that flexibility. Usually capitalism will extract as much time from a worker as possible, forcing the worker to give up many things in the name of work. It's impossible to give up your child though, so obviously capitalism has to yield there. But with better labor organization, capitalism will yield to other things too. If we all want schedule flexibility and more time so badly, let's unionize and get that. Not resent our working parents, who most likely have more on their plate and less free time than non-parents, even with the flexibility.
- cc23 6y agoI thought this community was left leaning until I read this thread. Individualism running really strong here.
- sjg007 6y agoThese articles appear every few years regardless of covid19. They also generate the same set of comments then as we see now.