17 ms·
Yeah, I bought a $1000 device, but somehow Apple gets to decide what I run on it? I just cannot see how that is a desireable situation.
by Aeolun 6y ago
Yeah, I bought a $1000 device, but somehow Apple gets to decide what I run on it? I just cannot see how that is a desireable situation.
- mcphage 6y agoIt's true for every video game console, which have run to up to $600. I'm not sure if $400 makes that much of a difference.
- Causality1 6y agoA game console is not a general-purpose computer.
- yladiz 6y agoWhat is the definition of "general purpose computer"?
- Causality1 6y agoOne that is advertised as not constrained to a single genre of use. Game consoles are for entertainment. Consumption. That's why I can say "game console" and you know exactly what I'm talking about. Smartphones are for anything and everything. "There's an app for that."
- JiNCMG 6y agoNot a legal classification.
- Causality1 6y agoI'm making a moral argument, not a legal one. Legally Apple can do whatever they want and I give Epic's lawsuit a very low chance of doing anything at all.
- uberduper 6y agoI can make calls from my xbox. I can create and upload content. Check the weather...
- sagichmal 6y agoNeither are phones.
- thedracle 6y agoMaybe it shouldn't be true for every video game console. But even then --- a mobile phone has analogues with other computing devices that are more open.
- ifmpx 6y agoVideo game consoles shouldn't be locked down either.
- edude03 6y agoIn the case of game consoles though, they're essentially general purpose PCs that are sold to under cost with the expectation that they'll make their money back on game sales. I think that's a fair assumption, and of course if game consoles weren't locked down it would open the doors for people to get x compute power for less than it would be worth otherwise. Whether you agree with that model or not, it's definitely different than the iPhone model where you are paying full price for the hardware, but are limited in what software you can run on it.
- chongli 6y agoNintendo tends not to sell their consoles at a loss. People criticize them for using older hardware but they make a profit on every unit sold plus their first party titles drive the console sales to a large degree. If Microsoft and Sony could no longer take a cut of all software sales like Apple does, they’d simply be forced to adapt their business model, perhaps to something similar to Nintendo’s. Gamers would either have to pay full price for modern hardware (less volume discounts) or otherwise settle for older parts. Microsoft and Sony would have to focus a lot more on bringing top developers in-house with exclusive publishing contracts. Life would go on.
- limomium 6y agoUnder cost? My understanding is that consoles cost MORE than an equivalent self-built PC, and that the expectation that sells them is the guarantee that the games will WORK. On an actual PC, there's no guarantee that any software works with your particular configuration. That is, consoles standardize system specs, and include a markup reflecting that.
- edude03 6y ago> consoles standardize system specs, and include a markup reflecting that That's an interesting take that I didn't consider - that console manufacturer can charge money for the guarantee that the games will work. However, from a quick google, two sites [0][1] have tried to build a PC with the same specs as the PS4 Pro ($400) and came up to ~700. [0]: https://www.gamespot.com/articles/we-built-a-pc-using-ps4-pro-specs-how-does-it-perf/1100-6443491/ https://www.gamespot.com/articles/we-built-a-pc-using-ps4-pr... [1]: https://modcrash.com/the-ps4-equivalent-pc-build/ https://modcrash.com/the-ps4-equivalent-pc-build/
- rpdillon 6y agoGame consoles are for entertainment. Phones run our lives. There is a difference in practice, though perhaps not in theory.
- bergstromm466 6y agoYour game console isn't a pocket-sized multi-purpose computing device with a camera, GPS and more...
- mcphage 6y agoSome of them are that and more.
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoI don't check my console 75 times a day. There are no studies that demonstrate the absolute ubiquity and irreplaceable nature of a gaming console; there are for phones. I don't order a pizza with it. Or check my email. Or call Uber. Or read HN. Or take pictures of my kids. Or make phone calls. Or check social media (well... I don't... but over 3 billion do). Or... There's a way that a "smart phone" (more accurately, a palm-sized computer that happens to make phone calls) is a general computing device - and a critical component of modern life in Western civilization -- that a gaming console is not.
- pjmlp 6y agoYou might not do it, yet all of that has been possible with handhelds for the last 15 years.
- bergstromm466 6y agoYeah but you would have been on your own. It was never as ubiquitous as it is today. The real world is now very much living on server farms+mobiles, more than ever before. All this seems like such an immature pointless argument. in fact i'm going to stop wri
- mr_toad 6y agoManufacturers love it. Inkjet printers, coffee makers, cars, vacuum cleaners, laptops. If a manufacturer thinks it can get away with monopolising parts, accessories, and services it will try it. If Epic does win it could set a very wide-reaching precedent.
- nodamage 6y agoOn the flip side, the fact that no one has successfully sued manufacturers of inkjet printers, coffee makers, cars, vacuum cleaners, and laptops over this issue should give you some clues as to how likely it is for Epic to win their case.
- chongli 6y agoThe lawsuit doesn’t have to succeed in court for Epic to succeed. If the case generates enough publicity but ultimately fails, they may be able to lobby Congress for a new law akin to the Magnuson–Moss Warranty Act [1]. Then, instead of precedent they might have statutory protection for what they want to do. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty...
- danieldk 6y agoPhilips tried to block other companies from making Senseo-compatible coffee pads. The European Patent Office revoked Philips' patent after opposition of competitors: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Senseo#Revocation_by_the_European_Patent_Office https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Senseo#Revocation_by_the_Europ... And actually in the case of Inkjet printers, the court of appeals and the supreme court ruled in favor of companies making third-party cartridges and refills: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ink_cartridge#Legality_of_refills_and_third_party_replacements https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ink_cartridge#Legality_of_refi... The EU started an antitrust investigation into Apple's App Store practices: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_20_1073 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_20_... Retaliation, such as this one by Apple, or the recent kerfuffle around the WordPress app are only going to increase the probability of antitrust action against Apple.
- woliveirajr 6y agothere were a time when game consoles were just a hardware that would run any cartridge that you inserted. restricting what could run in it is recent.
- jkelleyrtp 6y agoThese types of restrictions are all over the place, and I'm not sure if they're good or bad. TVs and audio-listening-devices come built-in with dmca protection, meaning you can't watch pirated footage or listen to pirated music even though you own the device. Is that good? Is that bad?
- admax88q 6y agoThat's bad, 100% bad. My TV does not need to be playing detective and monitoring every use of it. My car doesn't prevent me from exceeding the speed limit, not does it report me to authorities if I do.
- Aeolun 6y agoGive it a few more years.
- carl_dr 6y agoI suspect this was a bit of a throwaway comment, but ... “EU ruling means speed limiters will be mandatory in the UK [and EU] by 2022“ https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/news/motoring-news/mandatory-speed-limiters/ https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/news/motoring-news/mandatory-spe...
- Aeolun 6y agoI did think we had a few more years :/ thanks for letting me know though.
- jimmaswell 6y agoHow would a TV know it's being sent something pirated? I can't find a source on this.
- Aeolun 6y agoI’m not really aware of any console manufacturer other than Nintendo that spends as much effort trying to prevent me from doing that. Generally I don’t want to do it with my console either, as I explicitly buy it to play games. The same thing is not true for my phone, which is very much a general purpose device.
- kyriakos 6y agoThe difference with game consoles is that the main reason for locking them down is to avoid piracy rather than controlling what the user runs.
- snowwrestler 6y agoFederal law says you can jailbreak your phone or tablet and put whatever you want on it, and Apple cannot stop you from doing that. The question is whether the law requires Apple to code their OS to make that easy for you. It’s up to the courts of course, but I’m skeptical there is a viable, consistent legal theory available to Epic under current law.
- dylan-m 6y ago> Federal law says you can jailbreak your phone or tablet and put whatever you want on it, and Apple cannot stop you from doing that. That's a strange one. In patching security holes, Apple are actively preventing people from jailbreaking their phones. And they should be. So that argument seems ... problematic. This kind of thing was never about making it easy to jailbreak your devices. Actually, it's kind of about the opposite: you should be able to own a device that runs code of your choosing and also have that device not be riddled with security vulnerabilities. (And, despite Apple's bizarre insistence to the contrary, this is very possible).
- perryizgr8 6y agoCorrect, apple can either release a phone with perfect software with no bugs, or continue to provide bug fixes (security vulnerabilities are bugs). This is totally orthogonal to letting the owner of the phone run whatever software he wants. As windows has shown, it is quite possible.
- 6y ago
- veilrap 6y agoI bought a $1000 device because Apple gets to decide what can run on it. I like iOS, and I like that Apple provides a great user experience on the device. I was not in any way coerced into buying said device, and there are a plethora of other options for substitute devices had I wanted more control of what runs on the device, which I do not.
- greggman3 6y agoWhat other things in your life would you accept similar limitation? Would you accept a house that only allowed furniture, food, books, electronics, devices from the company that built the house? Do you think it should be legal for a company to make a house with those conditions? Would accept a car that could only take gas, tires, oil, electricity from the company that built the car? Should it be legal to offer such a vehicle? You used to be able to buy a VCR and choose only to rent videos from Blockbuster video if you wanted "safe and clean". That didn't require any company making the VCR to force people to only to go their "safe and clean store". Apple doesn't need to force everyone on iOS to go to their store for you personally to continue to only get apps from their store.
- bigyikes 6y agoIf that house or car provides sufficiently compelling features or other benefits then, yeah, I would totally buy one. Should it be legal? I mean, why not? If you don’t want one, just don’t buy one. There are plenty of other houses and cars out there!
- dx87 6y agoSounds like a similar situation to buying a house that belongs to a HOA. You pay extra to give up freedoms, but have the peace of mind that you won't have obnoxious neighbors that make your house difficult to sell.
- darksaints 6y agoAre you serious? HOAs not only do not prevent obnoxious neighbors, they virtually guarantee it.
- Trias11 6y agoApple could sell a brick for $1000. If one doesn't like it's abilities - don't buy!
- mlcrypto 6y agoYou what you were getting into when buying an Apple product lol
- mdonahoe 6y agoYeah but I don’t like it
- eecc 6y agoYou knew perfectly well how applications are installed on that device before you bought it. If you disagree to that just go buy anyone of the other posh 1000$ devices on the market. It’s not like the ‘00s when you couldn’t buy a PC without Microsoft being involved
- bluescrn 6y agoAs a person in tech you’re going to understand locked-down devices, code signing, and monopolistic app stores. But does an average consumer (who bought an iPad for the kids to play Fortnite on...)
- naikrovek 6y agoKnowing a situation before entering it does not justify or legitimize that situation in any way.
- neuronic 6y agoI am glad Apple is actually managing and moderating their store as opposed to the ocean of fraudulent crapware on Google Play and to an even more extreme extend the Windows Store... I have never had a single person complain about what they can't run on an iOS device. The apps that aren't availabe are either crapware or if they are useful they only matter to 0.00025% of users who can gladly go get an Android instead.
- posixplz 6y agoHaving a manufacturer-curated channel of apps is great. That channel should not come at the cost of consumer choice or competition.
- ur-whale 6y agoFreedom is indeed strong stuff and clearly not for everyone.
- CogitoCogito 6y ago> I have never had a single person complain about what they can't run on an iOS device. I personally hate that I cannot reasonably run software _I_ write for _my_ phone without having/using an Apple developer account. There now you've heard a complaint. I'm sure if you were to pay attention, you'd see this same complaint voiced quite often.
- Grustaf 6y agoWhy is it a problem for you to have a developer account? Can't you deploy to your own phone with a free account these days?
- CogitoCogito 6y agoIs it still the case that any app you deploy to your phone needs to be re-deployed every 7 days?
- gridlockd 6y agoAs a developer and iOS user, I strongly disagree with this. Due to these restriction, iOS devices are toys to me, not tools to use for work. Yes, there's a lot of crap on the Play Store, but there's also a lot stuff that I don't like about Android that makes me not want to use it, much less gladly. There is a lot of prohibitions in the iOS guidelines that serve no purpose but Apple's business interest, such as running a "platform" app that has other apps embedded. Of course, if you're WeChat, you get to ignore that rule. To pass off all this as "security" or "curation" is just dishonest. There's a lot of crap on the App Store too, but that crap can't be as malicious because iOS has a better sandbox, not because Apple does the literally impossible task of scanning for hidden malicious behavior in its review process. Of course users are not complaining about having no access to apps that were never developed in the first place, because 80% of the revenue is on iOS and going Android-only makes little sense.
- tinus_hn 6y agoWas that a surprise to you? And did you only notice after the period where you can return the phone for your money back, no questions asked?
- LexGray 6y agoIt may suck that Apple makes decisions about what runs, but if rules are there then I would expect them to be enforced. The thing that ticks me off most about this game of chicken is the timing. Pretty much have 10s of kids stuck at home due to COVID-19 who use this to socialize and who have sunk in 10s of dollars getting their access yanked to what they paid for because Epic didn’t want to follow the rules any more. Epic basically is messing with kids when they could have just stuck to lawsuits.
- zxienin 6y agoConsider that the reason you buy this $1000 device, is that Apple decides a lot what happens on this device.
- athrowaway3z 6y agoI think this is the wrong analogy to make. I bought John-Deere farm equipment. Are they allowed to break it remotely if the GPS detects I've resold it or did my own maintenance? In other words: I bought something in the general understanding it is 'tractor'/'general purpose computer with 4G' but its capabilities are an artificially restricted. I think it would be in everyones best interest to have such consumer protection/rights from such practices. Perhaps they should be required to market themselves with a prominent disclaimer saying they are restricting it's normal functions.
- Grustaf 6y agoIf you don't like that situation then look around for another device without this limitation. Besides, you can always get a developer account and run whatever you want on it.