16 ms·
How the Sacklers shifted $10.8B of an opioid fortune built on OxyContin
- pauljurczak 6y agoPut all Sacklers actively involved in opioid business on trial under criminal RICO statute and confiscate their property including offshore assets.
- wombatmobile 6y agoIf we had a justice system, that $10.8 billion would be recoverable, and used to try to rehabilitate the victims. But we don't have a justice system. We have a legal system, and a financial system.
- casraso 6y agoThis is why I am puzzled when people say 'you should fight your battles in the courts, not through protests'. It has always been about who can afford better lawyers, who can win the war of attrition, and a whole lot of luck along the way. Quite a few articles have showed up on HN the past week that reinforce this.
- zimpenfish 6y agoI think, generally, the people saying that are the ones who have the advantage when it comes to court battles...
- 082349872349872 6y agoSome thoughts attributed to ca. 600 BC: http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:2008.01.0063:chapter=5&highlight=laws http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:20...
- zimpenfish 6y agoHa, perfect, thanks.
- WJW 6y agoFighting battles through protests seems like it is mainly a case of who can afford better PR companies, win the war of attrition and has a whole lot of luck along the way. In addition, at least with a court case you can be sure public opinion doesn't just forget about it in a few months and moves on to the next hot item to protest.
- me_me_me 6y agoYeah, cuz that how every social change occurred in the world. Via two people talking in the room... Give me a break, legal system never changes itself. From Ghandi, Bolshevik revolution, Solidarity, French revolution to MLK. Change only occurs due to mass civil dissonance or armed revolutions. Never because you talk in a court and all people in power agreed you make sense.
- WJW 6y agoYou're arguing a different point than I made. Legal systems are as averse to change as the large masses of society (ie very averse). They do move eventually btw, but it's more on the scale of decades than months. What I was getting at is that protesting is not a very reliable way to effect change either. The "other side" of any protest is also trying to change the narrative and can often just wait out the protests. Look at how the various Occupy movements eventually dissolved after a few months because they weren't getting anywhere. Even the "main" camp (if one can talk about such a thing with Occupy) was eventually cleared by the police and didn't bother reforming somewhere else anymore. The gilets jaunes in France are currently experiencing the same problem. I'd be quite interested in a way to reliably bring about societal change in a reasonable amount of time and in a morally defensible way, but I have not found any yet. Since philosophers have been debating this since the days of the ancient Greeks I'm a bit doubtful that this is the time when we'll finally figure it out.
- shirakawasuna 6y agoProtesting is very effective when you do actual direct action and civil disobedience. Americans have gotten used to running ignorable police-sanctioned parades and calling them protests.
- autisticcurio 6y agoIf the system was honest, everyone would be taught at least the basics about law, medicine and finance, but you dont, you get taught enough to be a slave.
- dqpb 6y agoEveryone should teach themselves the basics of law, medicine, finance. Its easy to start. Just pick up some textbooks.
- autisticcurio 6y agoYou have no authority with your opinion though if you are not qualified. The exam process doesnt give your papers back to check your results against the text books and what the teachers have stated, so using science and previous observations going back at least 12,000years namely the various religions invented over time, people in authority can reinforce their positions by making sure trouble makers fail even as kids.
- calvano915 6y agoUnfortunately knowledge alone does not equal access to mechanisms of these disciplines. Without wealth, good luck using your law or medical knowledge to improve your situation aside from preventative measures. However, if knowledge is all you got, it's better than nothing at all and puts you ahead of many who won't be bothered.
- dqpb 6y agoI disagree. Knowledge is the great equalizer. You can't buy knowledge with money.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThey are taught - they just don't pay attention or remember the "boring stuff we will never use" and then after going with the flow for decades with no forward thinking look for somebody to blame for their own failures. Seriously, all of those who goofed off in home ec and math complaining years later that they don't know how to cook or balance a checkbook. The immediate resources were often subpar I will admit but don't say you weren't taught.
- unishark 6y ago> This is why I am puzzled when people say 'you should fight your battles in the courts, not through protests'. Sounds like it was worded wrong (depending what you mean by "protests"). "fight your battles in the courts" is generally a statement about non-violence, meant to suggest metaphorical fighting in courts instead of actual violence.
- lordnacho 6y agoDon't forget, there is also a reputation system. It should be made clear that whatever the justice system decides, much of their wealth has derived from an activity that was net negative for humanity. And yes, I have heard that PR companies exist to clean up reputations, but it should be possible to at least make it clear what happened. I think I read somewhere that a hedge fund had decided not to take an allocation from the Sacklers. That's exactly the kind of thing reputation is supposed to do. It's a blunt instrument, but people deciding to partially ostracize those who have done wrong is how things should work.
- save_ferris 6y agoI’m sorry but this is so naive. They were billionaires yesterday and they’re going to be billionaires tomorrow. Their reputation is going to be fine because we live in a society that absolutely worships money and those who have it. People with that kind of money can pay to scrub the internet.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> People with that kind of money can pay to scrub the internet. I'm sorry but this is so naive. Maybe true if you've got a bit of money and a little bit of notoriety, but I don't think that it would be possible to dissociate the Sacklers' name from the opioid crisis anytime soon.
- hans1729 6y ago> I don't think that it would be possible to dissociate the Sacklers' name from the opioid crisis anytime soon Attention is short. I wouldn't rule it out; pr goes a long way. Spend a couple million on a completely unrelated but well regarded cause of charity and folks who don't have skin in the opioid-game won't associate them for the bad they did (but for their most recent memories). What will keep the association alive for a while will be documentaries and those who watch them, but lets be real: that's not the public.
- 6y ago
- shrubble 6y agoWhen plunder becomes a way of life for a group of men in a society, over the course of time they create for themselves a legal system that authorizes it and a moral code that glorifies it. Frédéric Bastiat
- MRantiHATE 6y agoAre you referring to the fact that the Sackler family is all Jewish? Please cool it with the anti-semitism.
- metaloqui 6y agoHow did you manage to connect that to antisemitism?
- zentiggr 6y agoLooks trolly.
- justwalt 6y agoI think it’s an attempt to quote American Psycho, although it’s slightly wrong.
- MRantiHATE 6y agoWhat other "groups" are the Sacklers a member of?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> What other "groups" are the Sacklers a member of? I took it to be a criticism of American culture.
- rscho 6y agoRich people. They come in all shape and size.
- alpineidyll3 6y ago<Karl Llewellyn enters the thread>
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> If we had a justice system, that $10.8 billion would be recoverable We’re in the midst of a series of lawsuits and criminal probes seeking to do exactly that. When public pressure rushes prosecutors, we get nonsense like Arizona getting rejected for original jurisdiction by SCOTUS. We have due process. Not mob rule.
- cultus 6y agoMuch of the money is diffucult to recover by being tied up in byzantine arrangements of LLCs and overseas accounts. That's generally how the rich avoid paying taxes as well. We have due process for the privileged. Tell all of the poor defendants who have been held in Rikers for over a year without a trial that they have due process.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Much of the money is diffucult to recover by being tied up in byzantine arrangements of LLCs and overseas accounts Yet this reporter was able to assemble the trail from court documents. For every person creating Byzantine structures there are several adept at untangling them. > Tell all of the poor defendants who have been held in Rikers for over a year without a trial Not arguing that they aren’t getting an advantage. Just that there is zero evidence so far that they’re going to get away with it. Also, New York has abolished cash bail. If someone is in pre-trial detention, it’s because they were deemed to be a flight risk. Not because they couldn’t afford bail. (EDIT: Never mind, we rolled back most of the changes in April after a purported crime surge)
- stefan_ 6y ago"search warrant sacklers" 0 results It's hard to make a case for something being prosecuted in good faith if there is never any attempt at using the tools that are otherwise so vastly abused in prosecuting the most meaningless "crimes".
- stallmanite 6y ago
- umvi 6y agoSurely 100% of opiod usage isn't bad? So 100% of the $10.8B isn't blood money? I'm sure some % of the opioids really helped people. For example, my grandpa has extremely painful back pain, and opioids were a godsend. Yeah, he got addicted, but he's in his 90s anyway, so at least he can live the rest of his life without dealing with crippling back pain.
- bcrosby95 6y agoThe cost to market and develop the drug could easily outstrip the revenue from legitimate uses, especially if they spent a lot of money marketing the drug towards people that shouldn't be taking it. So yeah, all $10.8B could be blood money.
- jessaustin 6y agoHow much "development" did it take? Oxy was first manufactured in 1917. "Opioids relieve pain and are much sought by opioid users", film at eleven. Any physician who didn't know what would obviously happen when this drug was prescribed is one whose care I would avoid. But yeah, take all their money. The actions described in TFA obliterate the corporate veil. Frankly I don't know how they've avoided assassination attempts by the families of addicts.
- FlyMoreRockets 6y agoSure, there are good applications of opiates. However, from my understanding, the $10.8B number is the amount that the court has ordered, i.e. the "blood money" and punitive amount, not the total profit.
- sunstone 6y agoAccording to the article $4.8bn of the $10.8bn has already been paid in tax. So that portion has been 'recovered'. The remaining $6bn though is still in play. What I don't see being mentioned is jail time. So it's not criminal to push habit forming narcotics from behind a corporate curtain?
- mmm_grayons 6y agoIs all that money tainted? While oxycontin holds a huge potential for abuse I know plenty of people who have taken it for real pain, been helped by it, and moved on. "Just take it all" doesn't sound like justice either.
- smolder 6y agoTaking it all seems fair to me. When someone steals from a retailer, we don't just make them pay for it and send them on their way, because that doesn't disincentivize stealing in the first place. The Sacklers/Purdue would need to be punished for the predatory, antisocial scheme to prevent others like it.
- mmm_grayons 6y agoWhile an additional fine might be fair, again, just "taking it all" isn't. The Sacklers, while they might have played a small part, are being unfairly scapegoated for the whole of the opioid epidemic. This ignores the responsibility borne by states, physicians, and most importantly, those who choose to take the pills. This was also done with FDA approval. More importantly, this is a part of the larger narrative that everything has been caused by overprescribed opioids. However, there's no correlation between increased prescriptions and increased illicit usage [0]. Rather, it seems there's been a large growth over time of illicit opioid use [1]. The only place this sort of thing has been effectively combated is in Portugal due to its decriminalization and attempts to make things safer. Politicians caused this with their stupid "war on drugs". They are now pointing and saying, "Look, the big bad Sacklers did it!" so their own failures are ignored. Stop scapegoating one family for a political and societal issue. 0: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330922982_Today%27s_nonmedical_opioid_users_are_not_yesterday%27s_patients_implications_of_data_indicating_stable_rates_of_nonmedical_use_and_pain_reliever_use_disorder https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330922982_Today%27s... 1: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/09/180920161028.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/09/180920161028.h...
- smolder 6y agoI don't think they're being unfairly scapegoated. Oxycontin was an epidemic in itself. I've seen plenty of evidence from a variety of sources that their pills were aggressively and deceptively marketed as non-addictive, and that their wide availability led to an increase in opioid abuse. That includes knowing people who started on opioid addictions with brand name oxycontin and having heard countless anecdotes of the same. I'm having trouble understanding the motive for minimizing Purdue's role. The deception in marketing and all its consequences belong to them. It's difficult to imagine they merely made a mistake in trying to be effective marketers as opposed to knowingly misrepresenting what they sold in a way that was likely to harm the public. All that said, I generally favor your stance that ending prohibition would yield the greatest harm reduction.
- anm89 6y agoAnd what would a justice system look like, not in terms of vague sentiments or specific outcomes but in terms of process. Justice is inherently subjective. A "justice system" to you is a facist dictatorship as implemented because it inherently relies on all justice coming from the subjective opinions of a single person, you.
- iorrus 6y agoWhat this family did was pure evil, they should all be in jail not negotiating a settlement that will leave them financially secure and amongst the richest Americans. Imagine if this scenario played out in China.
- naringas 6y agoI imagine a couple ways this would play out in china 1. nobody ever hears nor finds out anything because it's all kept within the party. 2. they are publically shamed and they are sent to a re-education camp never to be seen or heard again. my 2 cents...
- obiye6657 6y agoI would accept #2. In fact I would like to see lots of people treated that way.
- iorrus 6y agoI assumed they’d be executed on the spot for knowingly enriching themselves while addicting millions, leaving them to slowly decline mentally and physically before eventual death. China would have zero tolerance due to their opium history that was imposed by the west. This is even more insidious however as the country’s institutions were mislead and this family made billions on the back of their countrymen’s misery.
- PakG1 6y agoMaybe. In the tainted milk scandal, the executives were jailed, and it was the lower level people who were executed. https://www.nbcwashington.com/local/natlchina-issues-death-sentence-for-tainted-milk-man/1855916/ https://www.nbcwashington.com/local/natlchina-issues-death-s...
- DSingularity 6y agoWhere would you likely get away with this crime? In a system where you must strike a deal with a party that must maintain loyalty to ideological principles most violated by your crime? Or in a system like ours, where you must strike a deal with some prosecutors? The chief concerns of these prosecutors is so often their conviction rates, public optics, and personal careers. The political structure in the west encourage these kinds of crimes. If you can exploit millions to make billions then you can settle in the event of criminal persecution, hire a pr firm to take care of public optics, and donate generously to parties in power to ensure that the pesky prosecutor/attorney-general is sufficiently motivated not to attempt to make an example out of you.
- mmrezaie 6y agoI am not american and I remember hearing about OxyCotin for more around 10 years. So I wonder why controling this problem which casued so many loses of lifes (not necessary deaths), took this long to be the target of the government. I also wonder was there one of these stupid political shows that US is used to them now that was stopping anyone to handle it. In the long legal battle I do not think this money is going to be recoverable (at least most of it).
- senorjazz 6y agoI remember it being discussed on drug (recreational) boards 20 years ago. It is not new > So I wonder why controling this problem which casued so many loses of lifes Did you not read $10billion in profit. People point to Mexico and the corruption the narcos bring to the Mexican state. It is the same in the US for this case. Just looked at who profited. Drs, lawyers, politicians, lobbists. Whilst the gravy train is running people are not asking questions at best and doing their best to stop them being asked. The corruption regarding oxycotin, ran from the top to the bottom of the system
- vmchale 6y ago> I wonder why controling this problem which casued so many loses of lifes (not necessary deaths), took this long to be the target of the government. Lots of shit falling apart here...
- shirakawasuna 6y agoThe United States is neoliberal with a couple social programs tacked on top. The interests of capital nearly always win. Individuals at the top are nearly always shielded from liability using various levels of companies in between them and the "consumer" and plausible deniability. The typical worst-case scenario is that the company has to pay a large fee that is still smaller than the profits they made through their monstrous actions. These are well-known forces that have acted this way for 150 years. Unfortunately, these systemic problems are not taught in school. Quite the opposite, they are treated more as minor aberrations that are fixed with a touch of social democratic intervention or regulation. And even that is considered an extremist position, extending to all kinds of subjects relevant to this community regarding how tech companies should be structured, labor organized, compensation structured (including healthcare), or even just having more coherent and explicit control over your personal data.
- songshu 6y agoI never understand why doctors are not blamed for prescribing these. Are doctors not supposed to be responsible for prescriptions? If they are not, should we stop allowing them to prescribe? Why don’t doctors unions throw out members who would claim to have been hoodwinked by pharmaceutical companies?
- thefounder 6y ago>> Why don’t doctors unions throw out members who would claim to have been hoodwinked by pharmaceutical companies? Because of the...money? There is/was plenty for everyone.
- pradn 6y agoDo doctors get paid more for prescribing one brand of medication vs another?
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoI think there are rules against payment but as we all know, there are ways around rules when it concerns money. Looks like there is a correlation between doctors being buttered up, and them prescribing opiods. https://lowninstitute.org/industry-payments-to-doctors-opioids-are-the-tip-of-the-iceberg/ https://lowninstitute.org/industry-payments-to-doctors-opioi...
- mannykannot 6y agothe pharmacutical companies have developed many ways of rewarding doctors for being compliant, such as by being paid 'consultants' presenting at conferences in exotic locations. For everyday practitioners, social primping (wining, dining, rounds of golf in prestigious locations and/or company) works as well as for just about everyone.
- Zaak 6y agohttps://www.healthline.com/health-news/is-your-doctor-getting-paid-to-prescribe-painkillers-for-you https://www.healthline.com/health-news/is-your-doctor-gettin...
- aronpye 6y agoPaywall, didn’t read
- mnw21cam 6y agoSmall amount of text, large number of big grey rectangles with "Loading" in the middle.
- dvduval 6y agoMe either. Imagine a world where the poor have no news access, and instead depend on Facebook for news.
- geodel 6y agoI am trying to imagine a world where everyone think they should get for free other persons' labor. I wonder what that thing is called.
- colmvp 6y agoFor some reason people online think writers and journalists are paid in Likes/Retweets
- triceratops 6y agoOpen source software?
- Murkin 6y agoSilliest paywall ever: 1. Open dev tools 2. Delete the overlay element (id = graphics-paywall-overlay) 3. Disable 'overflow: hidden' on body Or just run: document.getElementById("graphics-paywall-overlay").remove() document.body.style.overflow = 'inherit'
- umvi 6y agoYeah, the security on physical newspaper vending machines is laughably easy to defeat as well. Just smash the glass on the front with a rock and you can take as many papers as you want, for free. Or for a less destructive route you can use a special tubular lock pick.
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoTL; DR The Sacklers extracted about $6.1bn after taxes but before capital gains or losses and propose to pay $3bn in their settlement. To my knowledge, none of them have been arrested yet, though the wheels of criminal justice turn slower than those of civil law.
- downrightmike 6y agoThis would be a awesome time for Cops tv show to go get them.
- programbreeding 6y agoI know you're making a joke but FYI, Cops was just canceled after 31 years due to all the recent police protests. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/09/business/media/cops-canceled-paramount-tv-show.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/09/business/media/cops-cance...
- gameswithgo 6y agocriminal justice turns slow for the wealthy. for the poor you are often accelerated straight to being dead.
- Havoc 6y agoAlmost half to tax seems quite high actually compared to other major companies
- mschuster91 6y agoI totally get and support that said profits should be seized by the government and distributed to help affected communities. But doing only this is like beheading hydras: you cut one head off and nine new appear in its place. And with drugs, it's even worse than that - as users who previously were on medical quality clean stuff from legit pharmacies paid for by insurance, they are moving on to street stuff with all the side effects associated (criminal behavior to finance the addiction, contamination due to cutting agents, overdoses due to inconsistent dosing, gang fights, ...). The opioid crisis must be tackled at the root level, and that is a lack of physical and mental healthcare combined with the lack of a social security network and appropriate governmental aid to regions devastated by 30 years worth of globalization, modernization and rabid capitalism - to continue with the hydra analogy, the US needs to burn off the necks and then kill the body of the beast.
- IMTDb 6y agoThe US right now: "Some doctors told us the negative effects of opioids are not that dangerous compared to the short term benefits on physical pain. We sell that in pharmacies. This is a billion dollar industry. This was definitely a bad choice, we should have listened to the people talking about the danger of that addiction. Let's burn the skarks that were responsible for that". Also the US right now : "Some doctors are telling us the negative effect of THC are not that dangerous compared to the short term benefits on mental wellbeing. We sell that in dispensaries. This is a billion dollar industry. This is definitely a good choice, we don't need to listen to the people showing the danger of addiction. Let's praise the progressist that are responsible for that".
- civilized 6y agoIt's a good point to raise - at the same time, I think it's generally accepted that THC is on the safer side of the "problematic drug" spectrum, while opioids are on the riskier side?
- IMTDb 6y agoI agree that opiods are definitely on the riskier side of the spectrum, while THC definitely seem on the safer side - at least for adults. But we know that: that's why opioids are mainly sold after a prescription by a doctor and in a pharmacy. At least we are trying to limit access to opioids. On the other hand THC is currently almost advertised as being "good for you" (see all the papers/studies around it), and a socially acceptable/fun thing to do. While I don't really see anyone posting on social media a picture of themselves crushing some oxy pills. Overall we can expect the number of people negatively impacted by a THC addiction to be significantly higher in the next few years than for opioids. Even if at the individual level, the effects are lower. At the macro level this makes THC widespread use worrying - just like the opioids use is worrying. The really interesting thing is the difference in narrative. We know want to lock down one as much as possible, while we want to open the other as much as possible. PR wise, it's incredible. The arguments used in this article against opioids (it was a great business making lots of money !), are exactly the argument used in favour of THC (it is going a great business making lots of [tax] money !).
- adolph 6y agoSlateStarCodex's "Against Against Pseudoaddiction" is an enlightening read for some of the complexity involved. https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/09/16/against-against-pseudoaddiction/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/09/16/against-against-pseudo...
- brandonmenc 6y agoIn a similar vein, this video titled, "OxyContin patients, then and now" [0] is worth a watch. The music suggests the drug is horrible, but of the five patient cases: two are doing well on the drug and require it to function normally, one did well but died of a (not determined to be related) heart attack, one got off the drug with some difficulty, and one died after falling asleep while driving. Opioids are a miracle drug for people living with chronic pain. More people die every year from alcohol - which has absolutely zero therapeutic benefit. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkeQifzvSNE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkeQifzvSNE
- GordonS 6y agoI'm on regular opioids for chronic pain, and they have possibly saved my life. But I tried many, many alternatives. For the majority of chronic pain sufferers, there will be a better alternative to opioids. Part of the problem in the US is that doctors were reaching for opioids as first or second line drugs, when they should be further down the line.
- calimac 6y agohttps://ibogaineclinic.com https://ibogaineclinic.com Ibogaine Treatment is the safest fastest way to solve opiate addiction from Vicodin, Oxy's, Subutex, Suboxone, Fentynl, Heroin or any other type of addictive drug for that matter (SSRI, Riddenin, Adderol, Meth, etc...). It is the highest efficacy rate in the world and the more advanced treatment centers like Ibogaine Clinic Have developed advanced protocols to effectively treat individuals without withdrawal. It is literally wonder treatment that has not been allowed into the United States. Ibogaine Clinic has been treating thousands of people in the Maya Riviera In Playa Del Carmen Mexico over the last decade or more.
- rscho 6y agoAll-around-tech-bro-knowledge is strong in this thread. Doctors prescribe opiates all over the world, including oxycontin. Nowhere else is it a problem as big as in the US. Before wanting to withdraw prescription rights and sue MDs on a personal basis, perhaps people could think about the american exception? The US opiate problem is cultural and the responsibility is on both sides of the doctor-patient fence. The more people will be able and willing to sue MDs, the bigger the problem. Legal action on a personal basis is _so_ the wrong path. This is depressing.
- dillondoyle 6y agoOpiates are a huge problem everywhere. But the US and NZ are the only two countries that allow DTC drug marketing. And Purdue in particular was monstrous (in size and as an evil creature) in their direct to healthcare provider marketing. I would argue this a MUCH larger contributing factor than any cultural differences, and actually causing some 'cultural' differences. Where else is a drug pusher allowed to legally access a database of all scripts written by which doctors in order to target the top 1% of script writers who make up a large % of the profit. Then pay HUGE commissions to pushy non-educated salespeople - armed with criminally false 'research' funded by shell 'non-profits' - to bribe doctors to write even more. Not to mention Purdue actively incentivizing pill mill Doctors, actively reaching out to obvious criminal MDs to get them to sell more drugs!!!! It's disgusting and they need to be held accountable for manslaughter. all ill-gotten gains should be reposed and used for treatment. If this were any other drug dealer their cash/cars/etc would be seized immediately and the accused would have to prove the money was not ill-gotten to get it back. Put the Sackler's on the treasury sanctions list just like we do with Cartel leaders. Maybe them museums will start chiseling their names off of the buildings.
- nickff 6y agoThere are huge problems with opiods in many countries, but the USA has the most data. Canada has major issues, but only some provinces are tracking it.[1] [1] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-overdose-deaths-world-ranking-1.3961024 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/bc-overdose-...
- onetimemanytime 6y agoNot just the Sacklers: the government and the doctors are equally at fault. There should not be a trust system here, checks and balances.
- peter_d_sherman 6y agoLook at this article. 10.8 Billion Dollars (not million, billion with a 'b'), of which 4.6 Billion, close to half of it, went to the Government as tax payments... And yet the article seems to imply fault of some sort that various Sacklers moved millions (millions with an 'm') -- an order of magnitude less money of their post-tax-paid-for money, when 4.6 Billion, close to half of it, went to the Government as tax payments. I mean, with respect to the people that paid for the opioids, the Government doesn't give that tax money they collected, that $4.6 Billion back to the opioid purchasers, does it? Also, why is it that federal investigators seem to have no problems finding all sorts of ways that big corporate entities misspend millions of dollars -- but simultaneously overlook government misspending in the billions of dollars? I for one (and I realize my opinion is in the minority!), think the opioid addicts should get their $4.6 Billion dollars directly back from the Government -- and in cash -- not in political promises, treatment programs, hammers, or government cheese... You know, like give them all a "hey, you were an opioid addict and here's the money we took from you (as Sackler tax money!) back as an opiod stimulus package, an opioid stimulus check!" <g> And yes, I realize my opinions are politically incorrect. <g>
- summitsummit 6y agowhat is "<g>"
- nojvek 6y agoTIL: Oxytocin and OxyCotin are different drugs that are both pain killers. I remember being prescribed Oxytocin after my surgery and it was a fun woozy drug. Never tried OxyContin.
- nate_meurer 6y agoOxytocin is a hormone, completely unrelated. The words you're thinking of are oxycodone and oxycontin, and they are not different drugs. Oxycontin is a time-release formulation of oxycodone.
- athriren 6y agoExpanding on this, oxytocin has many known (and likely unknown) purposes but is most closely associated with context dependent social bonding and exclusion, sex, and childbirth. Somewhat coincidentally for the purposes of this conversation, it also inhibits chemical dependence (including opioids, which includes oxycontin and oxycodone). [1][2] [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0091305713002219 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009130571... [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5089904/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5089904/ This concludes the reply relevant section of my comment. Sidenote (mostly me screaming into the void): due to excruciating constant chronic pain from a botched surgery, I took three oxycodone for 4 years (March 2015-August 2019) every single day. It enabled me to work and live a (greatly diminished) life. For all of the harm the crisis inflicted—and the Sacklers did great evil for great reward—there is really not another class of medication that would have kept me functioning. Fortunately for me, I managed to get a very good job with great healthcare and I immediately used that to have a corrective surgery with the best surgery center in the country. This took me from about 65% functional (medicated) to about 85% functional, unmedicated. That last 15% is never coming back, and I have to live with the fact a doctor permanently damaged my body in an uncorrectable way. But, over the course of my treatment, the backlash against opioids began to make it difficult for my pain management clinic to provide the treatment I needed even though I was completely compliant (and had the regular drug tests to prove it—so many cups of pee). I would be dead without opioids. I would have killed myself. There are many more like me who still suffer from unmanageable pain who either cannot get the medication they need. There are many people who are not here because of opioids as well so I completely understand the backlash, I just hope we don’t overcorrect. The Sacklers harm cannot be undone, but their reward can be—expropriate it all (leave them an apartment with running water and a roof so that it’s technically legal).