29 ms·
Court dismisses Genius lawsuit over lyrics-scraping by Google
- techntoke 6y agoGoogle hate train incoming
- polyomino 6y agoThey pop champagne in Mountain View every night.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cjsawyer 6y agoWhat will google steal when all the other websites are dead?
- loraa 6y agoClearly if you come up with a b.s. site like genius you'll have to deal with that type of stuff at some point. Can't get mad if Google is profit off stealing from you while you steal from other sites.
- toohotatopic 6y agoNothing, because then you are on google sites all the time and google gets all the ad dollars. For some reasons, google wants to become AOoL, introducing the A with their AMP service (or with Applied Semantics). This rises the question: Will content owners create their own content network? If Google steals your content on the internet, why put your content on the internet? Why not have an app that delivers content to paying customers? Now each content provider tries this on his own with his own app. why not combine the efforts and just offer a browser for their closed network or embrace the Brave browser? If all content producers pull this off together, the audience will be there. Facebook could offer a Facebook content network on their own because they already have the audience, and Genius and all those Recipe sites could publish their content in a secure way. Maybe Instagram with its text pictures is already the predecessor. It seems like Google was taken over by Applied Semantics in the same way that Boeing was taken over by McDonnell Douglas because in the long run, nobody offers up his content for search if it is ripped off.
- dwheeler 6y agoI am not a lawyer, but my understanding is that only the copyright holder can sue for copyright infringement. I am pretty certain Genius does not hold the copyright to those lyrics. It's odd Genius brought this case at all. This is briefly noted at the end of the original article, but it seems like the whole point. Did I miss something?
- luma 6y agoThey are going to have a problem with standing for the exact reason you suggest. This case was one company who was scraping other people’s copyrighted works suing another company for doing the same.
- SilkRoadie 6y agoIsn’t their main argument unfair competition? Google, the starting point of the internet, decided to undermine their business by taking their collated content and publishing it at the top of results? Google appears to do this for other things, asking questions often shows answers without needing to visit the website. Perhaps these are all licensed and there is a kick back for these sites... Google appear to be serving ads on content other people have collated while eliminating the source of traffic to the original site.. If that isn’t unfair business practice and taking advantage of their monopoly on search I don’t know what is.
- qtplatypus 6y agoThe problem is because the form of unfair competition is copying the copyright act takes charge and the claim must be made under copyright law.
- dwheeler 6y agoBut companies are absolutely allowed to do things that cause other companies to go out of business. It happens all the time. Think of the buggy whip manufacturers. "Unfair competetion" has a specific legal meaning. As I understand primarily in the US it's under state law. Here's a summary: https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/unfair_competition https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/unfair_competition I agree that this Google practice looks dodgy to me. But the question is, what law specifically is being broken? This looks like a copyright case, and if that's the issue, then the copyright holder is the generally the one who has to bring the case in. (I believe there are exceptions such as when exclusive rights are granted, but I haven't seen a justification that they apply here.) That's what the law requires; otherwise the courts would be even more swamped. Again, I'm not a lawyer.
- kyle_morris_ 6y agoIf Google can scrape my site, am I allowed to scrape Google results? Could I create a Google clone by scraping? If I scraped the most common search results from Google, front page only, and removed all the ads what would Google's argument against that be? On one hand, so many sites make finding information difficult, on the other it feels pretty scuzzy that Google prevents searchers from clicking through to the site that put the work into generating content.
- wombatmobile 6y agoIt is scuzzy that Google steps on other sites' air hoses. Your idea to scrape Google's search results is pithy, ironic counter-innovation at its dastardly best. All you need to pull this off is funding for a top legal team, and deep reserves of emotional energy. Go for it!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anonymousab 6y agoI would assume Google respects robots.txt, so you should be fine non-abusively scraping their site insofar as you respect their robots.txt
- tempestn 6y agoYeah, the tricky thing for those scraped by google is that given google's search monopoly, the sites can't block their scraping entirely, since they need to be shown in search results.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoGoogle's robots.txt does not tell the full story. For example, if you include a User-Agent header and put certain strings in it, e.g., "curl/7.47", you will be blocked. echo -e 'GET /search?q=robots.txt HTTP/1.1\r\nHost: www.google.com\r\nUser-Agent: curl/7.47\r\nConnection: close\r\n\r\n' |socat -,ignoreeof ssl:www.google.com,verify=0 The problem with the robots.txt "standard", e.g., ones like Google's with no "crawl-delay" directives, is that it does not define what is a "robot". The query above is obviously not a "robot", but Google, with all it resources, still treats as such. Google probably does more (abusive) scraping than any other entity. Web scraping is in their DNA. It is in their web pages, too. curl https://www.google.com/search/static/gs/animal/m05py0.html|grep scrape
- loraa 6y agoSo genius scraped all the other lyric sites that came before it, and now they are mad that Google is stealing the lyrics genius stole from other sites... ok.
- drivebycomment 6y agoTechcrunch article left too many questions for me so I looked up and found https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/genius-lawsuit-google-922666/ https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/genius-law... which seems to be a much more detailed and nuanced explanation of what is going on here, with backgrounds on who, what, etc.
- jimmy2020 6y agoGenius does not hold lyrics copyright but the site business model depends on traffic generated by lyrics which is in this case hijacked by Google.
- AgloeDreams 6y agoThey license lyrics however and, critically, often times lyrics and their copyright are not a package deal. many songs don't have lyrics provided from the publisher. Genius allows users and artists to upload the lyrics. Google has the copyright but blatantly steals the content. This obviously is not protected in US law but it is elsewhere (see news sites and such in some countries requiring google to pay). Google then uses their search results to leverage their position.
- emptyparadise 6y agoI wonder if it's even possible to fix Google search in the framework of a for-profit company. It seems like the trajectory of any ad-supported service eventually lands it in a "don't let the user out no matter the cost" phase. Perhaps such a service really does need to operate as a non-profit foundation of some sorts. There was a post about regulating Google like a public utility recently, but perhaps we should also consider looking at other less conventional internet "public utilities" - things like the Internet Archive, Wikipedia or essential open source projects like Debian. I think a search engine that's transparent both in terms of its logic and how it's maintained and managed might be the only way.
- dannyw 6y agoThe other option would be strong antitrust enforcement; allowing competitors to emerge and compete with incumbents.
- icebraining 6y agoHow would that work? What should an antitrust order demand Google to do in order to allow competitors to emerge?
- therealdrag0 6y agoWell in this case, not steal their content. It's wrong for Google to siphon other businesses work for their own profit. Google shouldn't steal Genius or Yelp content. Facebook shouldn't steal YouTuber's content, etc. etc. It's not hard to see how if you were in the little guys shoes you'd feel screwed over. We need to innovate our laws to reflect that.
- icebraining 6y agoIt's not Genius' content. It's the musicians', who actually wrote the lyrics. If it was their content, they could sue for copyright infringement. Google has been sued on those grounds, and forced to change how they do their business (e.g. provide ContentID to handle copyright infringement on YouTube). But I suppose we could say "don't scrape and present content outside of a regular search result". But then again, Google claims they haven't done so - that they got those lyrics from LyricFind, a lyric licensing platform - and Genius didn't present any evidence that this wasn't the case. So I'm not clear on how could any laws help here. Finally, the question was not about Genius, it was about allowing competitors to Google to emerge. I don't see how would this help.
- remote_phone 6y agoIt’s not just copyright. Because of Google’s monopoly what they are doing is stealing a revenue stream from Genius. This is another case of Google leveraging their search monopoly. They need to be declared a monopoly and put on a very short leash here. I hope something comes of the hearings in Washington late last month.
- jonas21 6y agoRegardless of what you think about the lawsuit, you have to give them credit for their watermarking method: https://imgur.com/IGs0sg7 https://imgur.com/IGs0sg7
- sien 6y agoDoes anyone know if ebooks are watermarked in a similar way?
- worker767424 6y agoNot sure about ebooks, but I assume every workplace email sent to all does this to catch leaks.
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoThey almost certainly are for some sources. And probably with your unique user id to work out who leaked the copy on to torrent sites. The way to check this is pretty easy though, get 2 users to bit for bit compare their books to work out if they are identical.
- young_unixer 6y agoOpen the book in Evince, Print to PDF. Bam, your book is now anonymous.
- probably_wrong 6y agoI am not following your line of reasoning correctly. The watermarking is done using characters that look different from each other. Printing the book will not change those characters, and therefore it is still possible to extract the original information. Harder, but not impossible. For this information to be lost, Evince would have to print the book in a crappy font that uses a single symbol for both. Which is possible, but I think it's not what you were going for.
- 6y ago
- exogeny 6y agoRemember when Horowitz gave this company $10 million just because he liked rap music? Good times.
- AgloeDreams 6y agoIn fairness, their product is fantastic.
- praveen9920 6y agoJust a thought experiment: If Google releases paid version of search where it won't show ads, personalize based on your click-through history and do not copy content from source for presentation, won't share your data with anyone, would you opt for it? Root cause of most of the issues seem to be monetization model of Google where they are optimising people to stay within their ecosystem.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoI'd like to be able to remove the ads, but I don't care about the rest of it. Besides removing ads, the other things you mention would make the service less valuable for me.
- danShumway 6y agoIt's an interesting question. I don't trust Google, and a fast pivot to another product/offering wouldn't change that overnight, so I would lean towards no. I paid for Youtube Red, even though I never signed into the service on Youtube and even though I already got all of the Youtube-specific benefit in the form of adblocking and NewPipe. I did that purely to try and signal to Google, "I will pay for content, I want you to have revenue sources outside advertising." But ultimately Youtube Red seems to have been a failure, my signal hasn't changed the course of the company, and the parts of Youtube Red I did get value from (say, Music) have gotten noticeably worse over the years. I'm planning to drop my subscription in September. I think it would be tough for me to buy into another product like that from Google, my experience trying to buy products from Google to get around advertising/tracking has been both a practical and moral failure. Certainly I won't sign up for a paid GSuite account now. But I do already pay for Email (Fastmail), bookmarking (Wallabag), and a few other "free" internet services and apps today. So I might pay for search if a company like DuckDuckGo offered it instead of Google. But I would need to see what their offer actually was. I mean, heck, I'd be giving recurring donations to DuckDuckGo today if they accepted them, they're on my list of companies I want to exist. So paying 5$ a month for a "premium" search experience wouldn't really be that different, even if I never signed into it.
- erklik 6y ago
- DigitalSea 6y agoGoogle has a history of scraping content that they want, their business is built on the back of scraping other peoples content. The story I read just recently of what happened to Celebrity Net Worth was an interesting read where Google asked for an API, they refused and Google just scraped the content anyway. There was no lawsuit, but CNW put up fake content and sure enough, it made its way to Google. It is all ironic given how aggressive Google are in blocking any attempts to scrape its content.
- smabie 6y agoThat's like saying it's ironic that a soldier fights for his life when he tries to kill other people. It's just the war that is being fought, not some sort of hypocrisy or irony.
- harry8 6y agoGarbage. We live in a society of laws. Even soldiers. Google have shown they have no respect for the law not equality before it and will cheat while using the law as a cudgel. Recall law exists that the strongest might not always get their way. "Ironic" is the pole way of pointing this out. Without law, Google cease to exist immediately. They are incapable of enforcing property rights without it. Pardons aside, soldiers go to jail for taking an attitude like Google's.
- TAForObvReasons 6y agoJust like Genius, Google licensed the lyrics. If they didn't, the publishers definitely would have sued. Ironically, it is Genius that seems to have no respect for copyright law. Genius ended up having to settle a case years ago because they were using lyrics without the appropriate licensing [1]. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/07/business/media/rap-genius-website-agrees-to-license-with-music-publishers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/07/business/media/rap-genius...
- bawolff 6y agoWhich law did google break? Scraping in and of itself isn't illegal last time i checked, and usa doesn't have database copyrights unlike some juridsictions.
- greggman3 6y agoThank goodness. I'm happy that google gives me lyrics and I don't have to go an add covered lyrics site. It perfectly fits their mission "to organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful".
- pottertheotter 6y agoI enjoy using Genius. People, including the artists, leave commentary on lyrics that give me a deeper understanding of the lyrics.
- brokenmachine 6y agoI enjoy Genius too. Genius with it's annotations is much more interesting than just the lyrics in plain text. Also Google makes you click the big down arrow before showing the complete lyrics, which makes me irrationally annoyed.
- echelon 6y ago> to organize s/organize/steal Google is blatantly ripping off companies and putting them out of business.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoThe crux of the legal decision here is that Genius doesn't own the copyright on the lyrics either. Hard to steal from Genius what they don't own in the first place.
- AgloeDreams 6y agoGenius does give the tools to crowdsource lyrics, meanings, and comments. Google brought the rights to display lyrics but not lyrics themselves..they just steal that from other companies and rehost it with their own ads. Copyright law was not designed to handle this, which is something that is obviously morally wrong and will eventually harm consumers. Google has stated: 'if you don't want to be crawled, use Robots.txt' which because they have 90% market share, is clearly impossible for Genius. It's downright evil.
- Lammy 6y agoRemember when Google punished Genius (then known as Rap Genius) by removing them from search results entirely? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6963365 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6963365 https://searchengineland.com/google-has-officially-penalized-rap-genius-for-link-schemes-180777 https://searchengineland.com/google-has-officially-penalized... Pretty funny that Google depends on them for content now.
- alextheparrot 6y ago> Defendants made unauthorized reproductions of Plaintiff’s lyric transcriptions and profited off of those unauthorized reproductions, which is behavior that falls under federal copyright law. Does this mean Genius still has grounds to sue, as the copyright protections are on their “work” which is the transcription? It also seems to mean a ToS is not useful for protecting content, only determining legal users interaction with it (Excluding loading the page). A webpage is a work rendered through a browser, kinda makes sense I guess.
- bawolff 6y agoIs the transcription actually copyrightable? Just because genius wants it to be doesn't make it true. Compare to the whole word perfect clip art lawsuit
- alextheparrot 6y agoI think that’s their case to make, but from what I could find the answer seems to be probably not. Derivative works are copyrightable (Translations, adapting a book to a movie), but it might be hard to argue an exact copy of the song lyrics are “derivative” as they aren’t an original creation, but simply a subset of the old work.
- bawolff 6y agoSee also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bridgeman_Art_Library_v._Corel_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bridgeman_Art_Library_v._Corel....
- weisbaum 6y agoGoogle has been doing this for a long time. Rich snippets are all stolen pageviews. To make matters worse, they now don't let the site which is featured in the snippet have a secondary ranking further down the page. They keep adding schema, which SEOs eat up because it provides a secondary level of content optimization but it's not as effective as it used to be for increasing CTR on your serp results. The one positive of this is I no longer have to goto recipe sites which overload my screen with ads and put the ingredients 50% down the page. Google just scrapes the content and displays it in the snippet box.
- weisbaum 6y agoDownvote away - doesn't make you guys any more accurate as to what is really happening here ;)
- wnevets 6y agoDidn't genius get caught using black-hat seo manipulation?
- HJain13 6y ago> LyricFind. LyricFind is a Google licensing partner, and may be the source of the Genius content appearing in Google’s search results. LyricFind published an explanation on its web site Monday, saying, “Some time ago, Ben Gross from Genius notified LyricFind that they believed they were seeing Genius lyrics in LyricFind’s database. As a courtesy to Genius, our content team was instructed not to consult Genius as a source. Recently, Genius raised the issue again and provided a few examples. All of those examples were also available on many other lyric sites and services, raising the possibility that our team unknowingly sourced Genius lyrics from another location. As a result, LyricFind offered to remove any lyrics Genius felt had originated from them, even though we did not source them from Genius’ site. Genius declined to respond to that offer. Despite that, our team is currently investigating the content in our database and removing any lyrics that seem to have originated from Genius.” https://searchengineland.com/google-to-add-attribution-to-licensed-lyrics-providers-318402 https://searchengineland.com/google-to-add-attribution-to-li... The dismissal seems logical to me
- luckylion 6y agoIf that flies, it's a great tactic. You can't just use the data from site A, so you build anonymous sites B, C and D who use the data from site A, and use the data from those sites instead. "We didn't source from A".
- jdm2212 6y agoIt's not a great tactic if the owner of site A decides to sue you and subpoenas the hosting providers for B, C and D. You can only get away with it as long as you aren't successful enough to draw the attention of anyone with money to burn on legal fees.
- jtxx 6y agopretty much data laundering
- qppo 6y agoLast I checked, ignorance wasn't usually a defense but I'm not a lawyer. I just know not to pretend the Keurig I bought off the back of a truck was a good deal for everyone involved. But physical analogies to IP fall apart quickly so I'm not going to encourage people to read into that too deeply
- dang 6y agoThe rest of the stack: 8 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21781668 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21781668 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21700866 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21700866 June 2019: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20194952 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20194952 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20201139 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20201139 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20204625 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20204625
- ikeboy 6y ago>A state court >Eastern District of New York Ugh. Basic legal literacy can no longer be expected in the media? EDNY is a federal court, not a state one.
- gnicholas 6y agoThis was confusing to me as well. I saw EDNY and was confused about why it was booted due to federal preemption. Considering the importance of this procedural aspect, it seems like a pretty big deal to get this wrong. The real story here is left completely untold: why didn't they bring a copyright claim? Could they bring a copyright claim in the future? Could one of the owners of the copyright bring a claim? These are the questions that matter.
- qtplatypus 6y agoThey couldn’t bring a copyright claim because they don’t own an exclusive license.
- dingaling 6y agoThat's not literacy but domain knowledge
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sgentle 6y agoThis is a bizarre take. The most substantial point is buried near the end of the article: Genius does not own the copyright to the lyrics. Yes, they may have taken billions of painstaking person-years to hand-transcribe them onto artisanal silks, but no matter how much effort you put into copying someone else's work, it doesn't make it your work, and you can't sue people over it. At best, you could claim your copy is a derivative work, but that only grants you protection for your additional creative contributions on top of the original work, which for a straight transcription is... well, nothing. Genius knows this, which is why they didn't file a copyright suit. Instead, they claimed other things like unfair competition and breach of contract. However, Title 17 Section 301 of the US Code says that "all legal or equitable rights that are equivalent to any of the exclusive rights within the general scope of copyright [...] are governed exclusively by this title". To avoid this, Genius needed to prove that their claims weren't "equivalent" – ie weren't just copyright claims dressed up as something else. They failed to do this, and so their case was thrown out.
- Polylactic_acid 6y agoAren't collections of facts copyrightable? So google has copyright over google maps and I can not copy that but I can go out and record exactly the same data since I collected it myself.
- Semaphor 6y agoI would guess maps is a different case because those are their own works. There are decisions on design being made, how to show overlays. But that’s just my assumption.
- rndmze 6y agoInteresting to see the roles reversed. Didn't Google complain that Bing was copying their results a couple of years ago ? Is it possible to have a middle ground ? I can see both points of the argument : - Genius does not own the lyrics, in most cases these are entered by users afaik. A similar example would be somebody adding an address/info on Google Maps. - On the opposite end, associating a query like "that song written by blue haired 80s singer" to an actual result sounds more like a transformative work (although google owns user entered information as well here with the database of all the queries entered by users). Would it be possible to have a framework where you can purchase such data at a fair price ?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- earthnail 6y agoI think it's important to point out that when you license lyrics, you don't actually get the lyrics. I know, sounds ridiculous. You'll get the license to display them, and when you ask the rightsholders of these lyrics (the publishers) for the actual lyrics they'll tell you "oh, we don't have the actual text, just the rights. You need to find the text somewhere else." As a result, creating an accurate lyrics database like Genius has done is an enormous amount of work, and my non-lawyer gut-feeling says that in this case, Google is screwing over Genius big time. Too bad the legal system doesn't support that.
- abdulhaq 6y agoIt's for this sort of thing that Google had to get rid of their "do no evil" spiel.
- wodenokoto 6y agoDoes this mean that scraping is allowed, regardless of TOC as long as you don’t distribute copyrighted materials? Basically it sounds like the court said “scraping data against TOC and publishing scraped data at best amounts to a copyright violation”
- ohmaigad 6y ago> The Ninth Circuit affirmed that any data that required no authorization to access and was freely available by default was fair game for scraping. As the court pointed out, ‘authorization’ to access data is implicit unless steps are taken to restrict general access. Part of Linkedin vs HiQ ruling.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoI think that was the decision of the LinkedIn scraping case about a year ago. It held that you can't have a page that is accessible to the public but not to your competitor's scrapers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiQ_Labs_v._LinkedIn
- dubb20 6y agowhat about OHHLA.com, which genius scraped ?
- flexie 6y agoDoes the US not have anything like database rights for collections of data? What about unfair business practices? At the end of the day, Genius has probably spent thousands of man years collecting the lyrics and Google free rides on that getting it all in seconds.
- draw_down 6y agoGenius copied their lyrics from older places like OHHLA. OHHLA got ripped off by pretty much everyone, pretty sad actually. And if Genius were to be confronted on this, they would have the exact same response as Google and LyricFind. You play in dirt, you get dirty.
- kobayashimaru 6y agoTurning information into knowledge is impossible without humans and thus would invalidate Google's business model if it had in any way to pay for it. Looking with fresh eyes you could say Google is the biggest leech ever created.
- cromwellian 6y agoWhat does a GPT-3 future look like? If I ask it to fill in lyrics for a song or facts about companies and this comes from the knowledge it gained by “reading” a vast corpus, how is this different than a person reading the Genius site, memorizing the song, and the transcribing the lyrics? Too me this is the endgame for all of these complains about search not being ten blue links anymore. Future knowledge engines will be vast AIs that have assimilated information into internal self organized structures, and will synthesize requests for that knowledge “in its own voice” Unless AIs are lifting content by overfitting and making exact replicas instead of expressing the same facts in an entirely new way, I don’t think people will be a able to sue especially when the process by which the answer arrived is a massive Rube Goldberg contraption with 100 billion parameters. GPT-3 for example can already extract information from SEC EDGAR reports, a service other companies often charge money for.
- paul_f 6y agoThis all seems odd to me. Publishing song lyrics on the Internet seems like a small feature of a search engine and not an entire company with millions of dollars invested.
- bobcostas55 6y agoWhy not write some original lyrics that Genius would own the copyright to, wait for google to scrape them, and then sue over that?
- michaelcampbell 6y agoWell, as they say in TV shows, there's the truth, the law, and what you can prove. (And I guess taking that tack, what's fair.) The content of the article is about one of those things, but the court case was about another.
- hahla 6y agoCurious if anyone can shed some light on what this would mean for the “featured snippet” feature of search results. Google has been scraping web pages, and showing answers to users queries using unique content directly on the search results page.
- 1f60c 6y agoSerious question: why is Google allowed to scrape websites with impunity, but other, smaller businesses and individuals aren’t?
- AgloeDreams 6y agoIf you don't want to be scraped, just say so in your Robots.txt!' It's leverage to force companies into picking being stolen from or being never seen.
- look_lookatme 6y agoLet's not forget that at one point Genius launched a product that would scrape your site, re-host it, then overlay comments on it -- 100% without your control. They have played the game and lost and now they are desperate. They should have got some adults in the room before it was too late.
- criddell 6y agoWhat would be different today if on day one they had all the necessary licenses in place?
- dannyw 6y agoDid Genius hire someone overtly ambitious or simply incompetent lawyers?
- greggman3 6y agoTo me this is as simple as some people made an easily copied site that provides very little value (there's 50+ lyrics sites). Google, rightly, adds lyrics results to search. It's part of their mission. Sucks to be Genius but if they want people to visit they need to provide something more than "facts". As for the idea that Google scraped the site, as pointed out elsewhere, they didn't, their contractors may have, the contractor pointed out to Genius that the same results Genius was complaining about were on many other sites (maybe those sites copied from Genius as well). The contractor offer to remove many copies anyway, Genius didn't respond. Further, this is exactly the kind of thing that is probably not too far from automating via speech recognition and/or ad partnering. If it was me, I'd consider trying to partner with the music companies, send us the lyrics and we'll link to your site/band/videos...
- AlexandrB 6y ago> To me this is as simple as some people made an easily copied site that provides very little value (there's 50+ lyrics sites). Spoken like someone who's never looked up lyrics online before. Genius is to lyrics what Stack Overflow is to programming questions. In both cases there were/are other sites doing the same thing, but they are ad-riddled, inaccurate, incomplete, and sometimes paywalled.
- tantalor 6y agoThe 285th Rule of the Ferengi Rules of Acquisition states that "No good deed ever goes unpunished."
- joshuaissac 6y ago> If it was me, I'd consider trying to partner with the music companies Genius already has deals with the music companies for the licences required to display the lyrics.[1] Someone stated under a different comment thread on this story that music companies will only provide the licence, so Genius has to source the lyrics separately. But I do not understand how any of this is relevant to Genius getting their content taken by Google's contractors. If Google displays that content on their own website, no-one will click through to Genius. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/07/business/media/rap-genius-website-agrees-to-license-with-music-publishers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/07/business/media/rap-genius...
- 60secz 6y agoWhen your "moat" is a non-exclusive license, and your competition is in FAANG...
- larrik 6y agoIs this court arguing that it's legal to scrape a website regardless of theirs ToS? That copyright is the only law that matters on the web for this sort of thing?
- Aachen 6y agoFrom my 5-minutes-reading-the-comments understanding, this is fairly specific to lyrics because they're not your invention, even if there was work involved in transcribing them. I don't think this applies to scraping different kinds of content. For example, a map is similar but different: no creativity involved (just map what's there) but lots of work. Yet that falls under sui generis database rights (which Wikipedia says the USA doesn't have, but Wikipedia also says they signed a treaty and so they have it... It's complicated) and Google can totally sue me if I copy their map data into OpenStreetMap. (Yet we can't sue them if they use our open data as a distinct but invisible/unlabeled layer.)
- Digit-Al 6y agoI can't really understand why Genius cares. If Google didn't scrape from them they could scrape from one of dozens of other lyrics sites with pretty much the same results. The value add of Genius is not the lyrics anyway. I never go to Genius to just look up lyrics because the site is fairly heavy. I use another site that is lighter and has a nicer lyrics format. The only reason I go to Genius is for the real value add - the song annotations; and these are added by volunteers. I rarely use the Google version of the lyrics either to be honest.
- nutanc 6y agoSo if I scrape Google search page and remove the ads and show it on my page, that's ok now?
- tareqak 6y agoIs it not possible for a copyright holder to give the power to sue on their behalf to a licensee?