10 ms·
Maybe it’s just me, but I find it odd that Gates is the go to source for public health issues. His biggest contribution is money, which pays for really smart p
by refurb 6y ago
Maybe it’s just me, but I find it odd that Gates is the go to source for public health issues.
His biggest contribution is money, which pays for really smart people to tackle these issues.
So why not talk to the really smart people he hired?
- rglover 6y agoAn excellent question that shouldn't be downvoted. Why is Bill Gates "the guy?" Don't read that in a conspiratorial sense, just in a rational "can someone explain this to me" sense.
- dimator 6y agoHis foundation has been in the health space since it's inception. He's very hands on, and consumes and synthesizes health knowledge, which he's been doing for a long time. He has a broad view of many of the factors that go into vaccines, treatments, societal impact, etc. I've never seen him stumped or give a political non-answer on any of the interviews he's been given. I consider him an authority on the topic.
- zornthewise 6y agoHe has spent a large amount of time coordinating and strategizing health care interventions in multiple countries over the last couple of decades. Seems like he would be in a very good position to explain this stuff to the public.
- olivermarks 6y agoGates was born wealthy and connected and is now one of the richest humans on the planet, and owns or controls multiple corporate media companies (his foundation funds UK media company the guardian 'global development', the UK BBC 'world service trust as european based examples, Conde Nast in the US (Wired etc) are effectively Gates PR mouthpieces). As an oligarch he can pronounce as a 'philanthropist' on global public policy direction with little or no media pushback or investigation into his affairs. He follows in the footsteps of Carnegie, Mellon and other powerful monopoly business titans in the era of Davos globalists and is the consummate big league globalist.
- Upvoter33 6y agoThis is misleading at best. Sure, his dad was a lawyer and he was raised in a well-off househould. But he made something -- Microsoft -- through his own ingenuity, effort, and business acumen. I didn't agree with his business ethics, but to pretend he just fell into MS because of his connected family is fairly ridiculous. Amazingly, he has since turned his fortune into one of the most successful philanthropy projects probably in human history. Now, do I think governments should do what he does? Yes. Would I prefer higher tax rates for people like him so the people could decide what to do, not him? Yes. But he has actually been working for good, you have to give him that. And now my life is complete: here I am, trying to defend Bill Gates, on the internet.
- olivermarks 6y agoIt's not misleading at all, you've just grown up in a warm bath of Bill Gates PR. Gates is a very shrewd business man from a very shrewd and well connected family. There is nothing 'amazing' about his monopolistic practices, which he is now focusing on global bigPharma. Gates hides behind a 'giving it all away' trust based (aka tax avoidance) philanthropy but his wealth has doubled in the last few years. I wouldn't normally waste time on this but Gates is a dark character once you look beyond the pr veneer and fawning media coverage. We are in a very serious global pandemic where transparency and solutions by, of and for the people are needed, not for profit 'philanthropic' capitalism and social controls.
- BeatLeJuce 6y agoDid I despise MS od the 90s and their business tactics? Sure. But wether he pays taxes on his philanthropic endeavors doesn't really matter, what matters is that they exist and do some good in the world -- and certainly, spending money on health care is good in my book. So what makes him a "dark character" in your eyes?
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoI’d love to see a video of you being decapitated with a chainsaw.
- BurningFrog 6y agoHis foundation is one of, if not the leading actors in the world in this field, and Gates himself is very involved in the work.
- TheOperator 6y agoHe has broad experiencing in tackling infectious diseases through methods like vaccination & propaganda and he also has doubtless expertise in computers. He has long before COVID frequently been the target of conspiracy theories of him vaccinating people for nefarious purposes. Thus questions regarding a contemporary infectious disease potentially treated by a disease causing odd politicized conspiratorial behavior on social media is right up his wheelhouse and he's a well known public speaker. There are many epidemiologists you could hear from, and most people have heard from them repeatedly, but Gates offers a fresh perspective due to his fairly unique experience and perspective.
- 3131s 6y agoBecause he chose to be the guy.
- GaryNumanVevo 6y agoFor a couple of reasons; Gates is well known and will draw more visibility. He’s a well trained public speaker. He knows enough about the subject matter to communicate it effectively. Also, a short interview probably isn’t long enough for someone with deep subject knowledge to scratch the surface.
- refurb 6y agoOk, I’ll buy the visibility thing. When Gates talks about anything people will listen. Maybe it’s just the cynic in me, but it comes across as a bit of “billionaire worship”. “He’s made lots of money, so he must be brilliant and I want to hear what brilliant people think about Covid.”
- sukilot 6y agoZuckerberg and Musk and Trump are billionaires and no one wants to hear their ramblings. Gates has run a huge public health organization for over a decade.
- jryle70 6y agoEh, Musk is well respected when it comes to space matters. Check out his conversations with Everyday Astronauts, Scott Manley, Tory Bruno, Peter Beck as well as space journalists.
- harry8 6y agoZuckerberg grants an interview to opine, he can get that in any newspaper or magazine and it's on the front page here. Musk's ramblings are always covered and he's used them to build a brand in Tesla the equal of Mercedess without spending a single dollar on advertising. President Trump is the actual president of the USA. God bless us all. I see the point you're trying to make and I wish were true, but it just isn't as supported by the precise examples you've given.
- im3w1l 6y agoYeah, Gates-branded information has a good reputation.
- tolbish 6y agoBecause we are all more likely to click on the link that says "Interview with Bill Gates" instead of the link that says "Interview with smart person you are not familiar with".
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI'm not a fan of Gates, but he's clearly a smart person. Think of him as a sort of CEO of the organization that coordinates lots of the work done by the "really smart people", a CEO smart enough to be able to give Levy a better summary than Levy would come up with himself if he spoke to 10 actual experts.
- benatkin 6y agoIt isn't just MSM folks that go to him. He's proven to be reliable over decades. That's the main reason, I think. There was a small reason to talk to him about public health at first, but over time it's grown into a huge reason. The question remains, is what is he reliable at? Why do I and so many others want to listen to him more over the years? I think it's because of the depth and breadth of issues he discusses. It's a sweet spot for me, between talking in too much depth and not enough depth.
- numpad0 6y agoI think he’s like a bored nerd tremendous in managing Windows and using web browsers. So I’d think his accounts would be as easy and correct as some wiki articles or better, and at the same time would sound “irrelevant” to the public for the lack of emotional components to it.
- nugget 6y agoThe "smartest" (most accomplished?) experts within a field will often disagree with each other - sometimes on very important topics. I've encountered this first-hand. It's more common in certain fields than others, but I've seen at least a little bit of it almost everywhere. I can see value in an independent third-party from outside the field who brings experts together, listens to their best advice, and then decides what course to recommend.
- m0zg 6y agoNot strange at all once you consider how the press operates: - Bill Gates: 10 million clicks, $$$ - Joe Schmoe, MD, PhD: 0 clicks, no $$$
- fabian2k 6y agoThere are many other people interviewed about Covid and other public health issues. But until recently almost all of the experts were essentially unknown to the general population. Gates is simply a very widely known name, and due to the Gates Foundation actually somewhat relevant to the topic. I could very well be that his interviews attract far more attention than interviews with experts, but you can't really compensate for that kind of name recognition.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoIndeed very wealthy unelected elites shaping public policy should leave a sour taste in all of our mouths.
- Closi 6y agoI mean we have other unelected experts leading the pandemic response (eg Fauci) so does he need to go? Or is it just about the wealth? Bill Gates is there because his foundation is responsible for helping to eradicate diseases and coordinate pandemic responses, so without his wealth he certainly has experience in this field.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoFauci was appointed by an elected representitive. Who appointed Bill Gates? He purchased his position of influence/ Nothing against the man. I'm distrustful generally in the richest people in the world wielding control that can make their friends even richer. I really doubt I'm alone.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoFauci was not appointed by an elected official. His position as head of NIAID is selected by the agency. This position makes him sought by Presidents. He was not put there by Presidents.
- mehrdadn 6y agoDon't forget he gave a TED talk warning the world about the next pandemic. And obviously he knows a thing or two about high-level issues dealing with epidemics (which extend beyond just the medicine). Why would they just ignore him?
- spaetzleesser 6y agoBut why listen to him either? You could have talked to any disease expert over the last few decades and they would have told you that a pandemic will be coming and that we aren't prepared.
- bitcurious 6y agoOne reason is incentives. He is an expert who is spending money. Most experts are asking for money. Thus, he is incentivized to find the most effective solutions.
- Keyframe 6y agoUnlike a field expert, dude has influence, reach and an organization (with experts) in the trenches, and now decades of experience in all of the above. He’s not a couch-commenter. It’s like asking why we ought to listen anyone from Y itself here since they have zero experience with temp/vacation housing, storage, payments... all true, but they have experience with people and what and where and when to listen to. Gates is like that, multiplied by decades of experience.
- MrDresden 6y agoBill Gates was not in anyway, no matter how much he might have liked to be, a prophet about the increasing likelyhood of a global pandemic. This possibility has been discussed and researched for decades by experts and policy makers around the world.
- mehrdadn 6y agoI never said he was the only one who warned the world about the next pandemic. Nor do I believe he sees himself as some kind of prophet on this either.
- spaetzleesser 6y ago"So why not talk to the really smart people he hired?" There is definitely a billionaire cult going on these days. I don't know when it started but I see more and more headlines "billionaire does X", "billionaire says Y". Somehow being a billionaire gives you credibility on everything you do or say.
- WalterBright 6y agoIt's probably better than the celebrity actor endorsements, or whatever "influencers" say.
- cubano 6y agomore like on par with them.
- matwood 6y agoLike it or not money is influence. It’s even more amplified when you have an incompetent government. It would be great if Trump hadn’t bungled the entire response, then maybe BG would just be another person behind the scenes helping with funding.
- mdoms 6y agoBill Gates is a public health expert. He has been working on these problems with some of the smartest minds in the field for decades now. How long does someone need to be working on a problem before they're worthy of being a "go to source", in your opinion?
- codebolt 6y agoLike it or not, he's become a highly controversial figure for a large fraction of the population, particularly within the societies that his foundation works. In my opinion, they'd do good to pick a figure whose name is less tarnished if they want the message to be more broadly accepted.
- creato 6y agoNo matter who you put forth saying what Gates has been saying, they will quickly be tarnished by the same baseless bullshit. Effectively 0% of people knew who Facui or Birx were before the pandemic. Now they're the target of the same kind of controversy.
- prox 6y agoIt’s the same mechanism over and over. If I say something on a blog or newspaper like : “user Creato makes apps that make people dumber” It is you who have to go on the defensive, especially if it gets spread far and wide, regardless if it is true or not. But the lie is out there and your truth has to catch up.
- social_quotient 6y agoMaybe zero young people but I’d say well informed middle age and up would know who Facui is. It’s hard to debate this with a source but these people have even in the news for decades when things go wrong. I disagree with the “effective 0%”
- dgfitz 6y agoI’m a allegedly well-educated well-over-30s person, didn’t know who either of them were.
- blablabla123 6y agoYes, it's really weird, also that he is actually supporting the WHO financially. But here's the reality: U.S. doesn't spend enough to WHO (in fact now they even want to leave), so he gives them money - which is actually possible for everyone. Also Bill Gates wasn't the only "Cassandra", practically every popular science magazine (and probably also HN) has written about the possibility of a future pandemic since years. And yet, Government did nothing. Actually in Germany there were even pandemic simulations about 10 years ago, showing how bad Germany is prepared. Still, nothing was done to improve that. I think the summary is: this is really odd but it is even more odd how governments are unable to work on long-term topics unless shit hits the fan.
- amelius 6y ago> I think the summary is: this is really odd but it is even more odd how governments are unable to work on long-term topics unless shit hits the fan. This is just because there is no incentive for any politician. It's just like how security is at the bottom of the budget list for most IT companies. Unless we have a framework where people are accountable, nothing will change.
- drivebycomment 6y ago> this is really odd but it is even more odd how governments are unable to work on long-term topics unless shit hits the fan. Not so odd. This is a common human behavior. We humans are very slow in responding to low probability but high impact events, especially if they require coordination. E.g. upcoming climate disaster ("climate change" is a euphemism at this point), or nuclear weapons stockpile and the military systems which are effectively a dooms-day device for humanity. At a smaller scale, various preventable accidents like Beirut explosions or most industrial accidents. Ironically, a well functioning bureaucracy is one of the best answers, as you can see from Taiwan or South Korea's preparedness and response to COVID pandemic.
- matwood 6y ago> And yet, Government did nothing. That’s not true. GWB took it very seriously and put a plan in place. Obama modernized the plan. Trump is the one who ignored his predecessors and set the stage for the mess we are in. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/06/how-white-house-coronavirus-response-went-wrong/613591/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/06/how-whi...
- ponker 6y agoHe’s smarter than and has more public health experience than anyone in the senior ranks of the US government, so he’s the best you’re going to get.
- MrDresden 6y agoI guess for the general U.S audience having a well known figure, who has been active in the public health space for some years now through his foundations, speaking as an authority on the ongoing crisis makes sense, giving the lack of ongoing leadership in that country. However for someone living in a western European country it would not be received very well if a business person, even one with such a big philanthropic side to them, would become the go to authority on public health and wellbeing during this time. For that only be an actually trained and experienced professional can be turned to. edit; spelling.
- sukilot 6y agoEU has their unelected bureaucrats in Brussels. US has their unelected oligarchs in Seattle Palo Alto, and New York.
- claudeganon 6y agoI’m not fond of either, but in comparing responses to the pandemic, the European bureaucrats seem to be outcompeting the American oligarchs.
- MrDresden 6y agoMy country of residency is not part of the European Union. But you are correct, that there are sadly always problems in most human made systems due to its inclusion of the problematic element it self. Us.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoIf you can listen to his talk and tell us what part of what he said is wrong then I think you will have a point. Anyone can talk about anything and certainly he can talk about what he and his organizations are working on and what they plan to do about various public health issues.
- MrDresden 6y agoPlease don't misunderstand me, I don't believe he said anything wrong. Nor do I think he doesn't have the right to have a say or to have an opinion on the matter. My point is more along the fact that he is predominantly a business man who has done a lot of good around the world with his philanthropic foundations. He is a well informed individual with deep pockets and political connections, who is well placed to enact change in what ever forum he would decide to use those resources in. He is neither an elected representitive nor someone who has to answer for his opinions or actions to any authority within a regulated professional occupation (doctor, professor, publishing researcher etc). The way that U.S society works, and the level of trust and respect that the general population places on the 'famous' and 'rich' just doesn't resonate with the reality of life where I am. That is why he, or his like, would never be turned to as authority figures on this matter in my country of residence as they aren't looked at as experts on these matters nor trusted to not have an alterior motive (however small).
- paxys 6y agoWhy interview the CEO of a company and not engineers building the product?
- refurb 6y agoDepends on the questions I guess? I’ve heard my own CEO try explain something technical and it’s clear they don’t really understand it (and why should they? That’s why they hired experts). In this article Bill says “most of the Covid tests are garbage”. That seems like a technical statement that should come from someone who is an expert in testing. If the question was “what do you think the most promising Covid treatments are?” that’s a good question for Bill, assuming he’s involved in the funding decisions (maybe he’s not?).
- frosted-flakes 6y agoHe's saying most of the American tests are garbage because the results are so delayed. It doesn't take a genius to explain that.
- yalogin 6y agoI don’t understand what your motivation is for saying this. Why do you think Bill is not to be asked these questions? Do you think he would twist or misrepresent facts? Do you think somehow funding so much research makes him untrustworthy?
- refurb 6y agoOh, they can certainly ask Bill these questions, but I would say there are a ton of people who have far more expertise in infectious diseases than him. If they were asking him about funding these efforts, then yeah, he’d be the go to guy. But asking him about the science?
- yalogin 6y agoHe is not about the details of the research, in the whole article he was simply talking about it as a manager who understands what he is leading. I am sorry but the way you phrased those statements feels as if you are convinced he is lying and has nefarious intent.
- refurb 6y agoHe makes the statement "most of the tests are crap". That seems like a technical question to me.
- pteraspidomorph 6y agoHe was talking about the performance of the procedure as a whole. He's saying most tests are unacceptably slow in the US because the labs doing the testing aren't paid less for being slow, so they take in more customers than they can handle reliably.
- refurb 6y agoActually, he blames reimbursement and has this to say "Because the federal government sets that reimbursement system." That is not an accurate statement. Yes, the government sets reimbursement for Medicare and Medicaid, but not for private insurance which is ~60% of Americans.
- throwaway080920 6y agoIndeed, if you look at what he was saying at the end of February, there was no concern about the way the U.S. was handling the pandemic. Look at what he wrote on February 28th[1] - his recommendations for the current pandemic are for richer countries to assist poorer countries, and for a vaccine to be made. If someone like Gates sounded the alarm on the poor way the U.S. was responding, it might have made a difference, but he did no such thing. Like most of the leadership in the U.S., he seemed to have a big blind spot with regards to how bad things could get in America. Some people were sounding the alarm early on (take a look at the last minute of this video[2] for an example), but were mostly ignored. [1] https://www.gatesnotes.com/Health/How-to-respond-to-COVID-19 https://www.gatesnotes.com/Health/How-to-respond-to-COVID-19 [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E8VImMUvz-A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E8VImMUvz-A
- richardw 6y agoQuestion 2, he says the CDC should be the face of the pandemic response because they’re the experts “by a lot”. He gets listened to so he does interviews. This wouldn’t be on HN if it were Fauci. And he gets to say the unedited. He can call BS because he doesn’t have a boss who can yank his budget or job.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoBecause he's not just randomly throwing money around and has a well earned reputation for getting a decent return on his investments: he tends to spend money on things that work. So given that he's actively spending money and getting results, his perspective on what things need to be invested in and why is very interesting. There are plenty of rich philanthropists but very few with Gates's level of understanding and ability to make good policy choices.
- tasogare 6y ago> he tends to spend money on things that work Like on WHO? The organization that lied for months about the potentiality of the covid to become a pandemic and that is excluding on political ground the country that handle best the virus (Taiwan). By still sponsoring this China’s lying organization, Bill Gates lost credibility in my eyes.
- versteegen 6y agoYou seem to be misremembering WHO's reluctance to declare that the pandemic had reached the criteria to be called a "pandemic" (due to having been accused of being too hasty last time) as something... entirely else.
- blub 6y agoManaging the foundation as a business with the goal of maximizing return on investment is precisely one of the criticism leveled at Gates. Note that return on investment refers to financial return, not some abstract notion about improving the world.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoI think there's nothing with focusing on ROI in a foundation that presumably does not enrich shareholders (which a foundation does not have) and instead puts any savings to good use doing more of whatever they want to do.
- 6y ago
- blub 6y agoRich elites have a long history of oversized influence on public policy in the US. I'm not sure why exactly this is happening, but I think it's at least partly because of the relatively low involvement of the government in various social topics. If you think about it, having public policy being at least partially dictated by unelected and unaccountable individuals is not a good place to be. Hasan Minhaj had an episode on the Patriot Act about this topic and how: a) the huge sums of money and foundations these billionaires manage have less of an impact than one would think because of the staggered way that the money is handed out, organizational bureaucracy and the fact that most problems that they're trying to tackle don't really lend themselves to being quashed just by throwing money at them. Many pursue such philanthropy also in part to clean up their public image and as a tax reduction strategy. b) those huge sums distort the domains that they are injected in and could in some cases cause harm. The Gates Foundation is known for favoring high-impact project and sucking the air out of the room for other initiatives for example.