10 ms·
So basically, it will be two companies which own both the CPU and GPU stack (AMD/ATI and Nvidia/ARM) and intel will just sort of end up at the wayside. Not rea
by dekhn 6y ago
So basically, it will be two companies which own both the CPU and GPU stack (AMD/ATI and Nvidia/ARM) and intel will just sort of end up at the wayside. Not really what I expected.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoThat could be in Intel’s favor if this becomes an example of “deworsification”. Something to be said about focusing purely on one use-case.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoIntel's been moving in the direction of launching a discrete GPU line for years: https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/9/21058422/intel-dg1-discrete-gpu-graphics-card-announcement-ces-2020 https://www.theverge.com/2020/1/9/21058422/intel-dg1-discret... And I'd hardly call Intel focused on one use-case. They seem to have their hands in all sorts of random-as-heck product lines like IoT devices and such, most of which rarely see much long-term support.
- fastball 6y agoI think they mean that Nvidia / ARM are currently each focusing on what use case and a merger could make them worse at both.
- Spooky23 6y agoThe random stuff at Intel are usually little experiments to see how complimentary tech drives Xeon sales. When they pitched IoT stuff, the real "sale" was to get Intel-based edge devices in place to herd the IoT. And to get "intel" about what customers are planning in the place around opportunities/threats like 5G. I think that effort in particular (about 5 years ago for me) was a warning sign about Intel -- they didn't internalize that your smart water meter would have a chip beefy enough very soon to connect to a cellular or other long range network and just hit a cloud endpoint.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoFWIW, Intel has been pushing towards launching a dedicated discrete GPU platform. If/when they recover, this would place us in having three distinct CPU/GPU companies.
- parsimo2010 6y agoFrom what we know so far (https://www.tomshardware.com/news/intel-xe-graphics-all-we-know https://www.tomshardware.com/news/intel-xe-graphics-all-we-k...), it will be a while before Intel competes in the GPU space. The first offering of Xe graphics (still not out yet) will probably not be competitive with cards that AMD and Nvidia released over a year ago. If Intel can survive their current CPU manufacturing issues, manage to innovate on their design again, and manage to improve the Xe design in a couple generations, they might be in a good position in several years. I (as a layman) give them a 50/50 shot at recovering or just abandoning the desktop CPU and GPU market.
- forgotpwd16 6y agoI wonder, why Intel abandoned the mobile market? I think only a single smartphone was released using an Intel CPU.
- thomasfortes 6y agoI had one model from Asus, battery life was terrible and if you were doing anything remotely intensive it doubled up as a nice hand warmer... I know that these probably are solvable problems, but they left a pretty bad taste...
- deelowe 6y agoI think radio tech is an issue in the mobile space. It is heavily patented and the big players who can integrate this technology into their chips can offer much more energy efficient solutions.
- paulmd 6y ago
- abledon 6y agoIsn't this a monopoly? doesn't seem very legal. If the future is so dependent on GPU compute, and there are only 2 companies (AMD/NVIDIA) making them.... isn't it insane to only have 2 companies the entire world depends upon? Edit: ok Duopoly, but still... kinda insane that only 2 companies in the world do it.
- jaywalk 6y agoIt's a duopoly, and unless you've got evidence that AMD and Nvidia are colluding to hurt potential competitors there's nothing illegal about it.
- ianai 6y agoIt’s really hard to call a duopoly much better than a monopoly. Sure you can probably identify points, but neither outcome is anywhere near efficient. I don’t know that it should necessarily be illegal. But it is market concentration.
- jaywalk 6y agoA duopoly is absolutely much better than a monopoly. You've got competition pushing you improve.
- Krns 6y agobut by definition isn't a duopoly not competing with each other? I might be wrong, but I remember it being about the two companies making deals with each other to keep both prices high and not innovate or improve, like ISPs in the US
- jaywalk 6y agoNo, that is not a characteristic of a duopoly and in many cases is illegal.
- 6y ago
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoWhile ARM can be great, I don’t think anyone is entirely writing off x86. Intel owns a lot of fab. And while I don’t get as hyped on it as other people, Intel going hard into RISCV could change the game for ARM (if it was handled in non-typical-Intel way)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dekhn 6y agoI'm not writing off x86, but I think AMD is going to define the future of x86 (like the did before), instead of Intel.
- physicsyogi 6y ago> I don’t think anyone is entirely writing off x86. Apple seems to be.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoThat’s fair. I was about to write how that’s a special case, but then I remembered that Microsoft is also making their own chips for Surface products.
- JiNCMG 6y agoBut Intel has already threaten MS with a lawsuit if it tries to emulate x86 for its ARM products. Meanwhile when Apple switched from PowerPC to x86 part of the agreement was a share of patents which gave Intel access to the multimedia extensions of the PowerPC (AltiVec?). If this "share" went both ways then Apple might be able to provide x86 translation on their SOC. NOTE: there is no evidence of this anywhere other than what MS was blocked when working on Windows 10 for ARM and the Apple-Intel agreements. If this does happen I think Intel will not sweat it because it will be only Apple. Apple has no interest in selling CPUs. They want to be able to make severe changes (cut the fat) between revisions and not have people crying about having to update their architecture to support it.
- dheera 6y agoNvidia hardware is great but my biggest concern is that this would eventually spell the end for Raspberry Pis and other good things that are ARM. That would not be cool.
- rgbrenner 6y agoCan you expand on that concern? Rpi uses a Broadcom soc.. so it isn’t like they deal with arm directly.
- dheera 6y agoDesigns of future ARM versions could end up being skewed toward NVIDIA's needs or worse, designed to or information withheld in ways that kill other embedded products and monopolize the embedded market. They could theoretically simply stop licensing ARM to Broadcom, although that might invoke some anti-trust suits.
- rjsw 6y agoBroadcom is Acorn, there is a suggestion in another comment that Apple has a perpetual licence to ARM, maybe Broadcom has as well.
- meragrin_ 6y agoDo you not know Intel is close to releasing their own GPUs or do you just think they will just fail at it? Even with the acquisition of ARM, I don't see Nvidia any better off than Intel at this moment as far as CPU/GPU stack goes. Frankly, I would think AMD would be the one to end up by the wayside since they still are weak on the software side.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoI think there's a good chance they'll fail. This is true of any new venture, so it's a bit lame to say, but there are reasons: Right now I have a fairly decent GPU in my Macbook which I've hardly used. Very little supports it, because it's not nVidia. I can't use it for AI training, for example. Sure, it might work ok for some games, but Macbooks aren't really for gaming, and nVidia has captured that market nicely anyway. Things can change; maybe Intel's software stack will be incredible. I don't know. But they have quite a hill to climb before they reach that summit.
- fomine3 6y agoIntel has good record to provide software, contribute to OSS, support for developers to support hardware than AMD, so possibly they can do better than RADEON on some world if they can provide great hardware.
- xvilka 6y agoThere's ROCm[1] though. It's just almost every ML platform blindly bent to the NVIDIA vendor lock-in. CUDA is a disaster, like DirectX was back in time. One day it will go, hopefully soon enough. [1] https://github.com/RadeonOpenCompute/ROCm https://github.com/RadeonOpenCompute/ROCm
- Spooky23 6y agoThere's a huge market for mobile devices that aren't Apple and are fast. Perhaps this would offer better SoC prospects than whatever slop Qualcomm is dishing out.
- 6y ago
- detaro 6y agoI wouldn't count Intel out yet. Sure, things don't look that great, but same was true of AMD/ATI until recently...
- DubiousPusher 6y agoIs this comparable to that situation? AMD & Intel were building chips basically to the same standard. ARM/Nvidia vs. Intel would be a lot more asymmetric.
- adventured 6y ago> I wouldn't count Intel out yet. Sure, things don't look that great I always get a kick out of the sentiment toward Intel on HN. Intel is booming financially. Things have never been better for them in that respect. They have every opportunity to fix their mess. Intel has eight times (!) the operating income of Nvidia, with a smaller market cap. Intel is one of the world's most profitable corporations. $26 billion in operating income the last four quarters. Their margins are extreme. Their sales are at an all-time high. Their latest quarterly report was stellar. In just 2 1/2 years Intel has added a business the size of Nvidia and AMD combined. If they can't utilize their current profit-printing position to recover, then they certainly deserve their tombstone. Nobody has ever had an easier opportunity to find their footing.
- detaro 6y agoRight, that's kinda my point, maybe not strongly enough stated. The "don't look that great" is "they'll probably have to buy fab resources from someone else" to keep up perf-wise (like their competitors, who are fabless), not "they're going bankrupt anytime soon".
- syshum 6y agoIntel has a habit of putting snatching defeat from the jaws of victory. Their decades of more or less monopoly status has made them complacent, their revenue is high still because of this inertia built into the market that simply will not vanish. The datacenter for example is still dominated by Xeon not because people like Xeon over Epyc but because there is not a easy migration path between the 2 platforms. If I was building a whole new server farm with all new VM's I would choose Epyc all day... but if I need to upgrade hosts in an existing farm with no down time well that will need to be Xeon then... When it comes to desktops/laptops though, Lenovo's AMD line is attractive and suffers no such problems
- trimbo 6y agoIntel has something like 60% of the PC GPU market because of their built-in graphics.
- Alupis 6y agoYes, but not the high-end GPU market, which is what Intel has been trying to break into for quite some time now.
- phkahler 6y agoARM is not in the high end GPU market either.
- parsimo2010 6y agoNo, but Nvidia is. So if Nvidia bought ARM, they could be a CPU and GPU maker.
- zymhan 6y agoNvidia has had modern ARM chips (the Tegra series among other) for at least a decade now. Any company can license ARM tech.
- parsimo2010 6y agoThe top level comment was about companies owning a CPU and GPU stack. NVIDIA licenses ARM IP now, if they bought ARM they would actually own the designs, putting them on the level of AMD and Intel where they would have greater control over the technology. Just licensing the designs puts a company on a lower chipmaking tier with Qualcomm, Samsung, Apple, Huawei, etc.
- tambre 6y ago> NVIDIA licenses ARM IP now, if they bought ARM they would actually own the designs NVIDIA Carmel is NVIDIA's own Arm v8.2-A design [0]. They only licence the architecture. The core is quite interesting, as it's doing dynamic recompilation for an underlying VLIW architecture. However, NVIDIA Orin[1] (followup for Tegra Xavier) will use a Cortex-A78 core[2] (formerly Hercules) licenced from ARM. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Denver https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Denver [1] https://nvidianews.nvidia.com/news/nvidia-introduces-drive-agx-orin-advanced-software-defined-platform-for-autonomous-machines#:~:text=NVIDIA%20today%20introduced%20NVIDIA%20DRIVE,four%20years%20of%20R%26D%20investment https://nvidianews.nvidia.com/news/nvidia-introduces-drive-a.... [2] https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/arm_holdings/microarchitectures/cortex-a78 https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/arm_holdings/microarchitectures...
- abrowne 6y agoOnly if Nvidia stop licencing ARM to other companies like Apple, Qualcomm and … AMD, right?
- Eric_WVGG 6y agoAs a founder of ARM, Apple is grandfathered into a "perpetual architecture license," clear sailing unless nVidia deprecated ARM in favor some something completely new (as I understand it), which seems unlikely to say the least.
- KMag 6y ago> As a founder of ARM, Apple ... Apple was a founding member of AIM (Apple, IBM, Motorola) for PowerPC. (As rumour has it, after DEC refused to go for a higher-volume lower-margin Alpha AXP derivative when Apple came knocking for an m68k replacement, Apple then asked IBM for a higher-volume lower-margin POWER derivative, leading to AIM and PowerPC.) As far as I know, only Acorn had a role in founding/spinning off ARM. On the other hand, I would be very surprised is Apple wasn't smart enough to get a very-long-term/perpetual license on the ARM instruction set before investing heavily in custom core design.
- rdsnsca 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_architecture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARM_architecture "In the late 1980s, Apple Computer and VLSI Technology started working with Acorn on newer versions of the Arm core. In 1990, Acorn spun off the design team into a new company named Advanced RISC Machines Ltd." https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1990-11-28-fi-4993-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1990-11-28-fi-4993-s... " Apple has invested about $3 million (roughly 1.5 million pounds) for a 30% interest in the company, dubbed Advanced Risc Machines Ltd. (ARM), but the exact ownership stake of VLSI and Acorn was not disclosed. "
- KMag 6y agoToday I learned! Thanks, and upvoted.
- akuma73 6y agoApple also fully controls the hardware and software stack for both CPU and GPU.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]