20 ms·
How Mormons built a startup ecosystem in Utah
- ihsw 6y ago> big diversity problem It's not a problem. > antiquated attitude toward the role of women and the gay community There's nothing antiquated about this, it is a widely accepted cultural value. > its absence of people of color There's nothing wrong with this. > and the overwhelming cultural dominance of the Mormon faith This is a strength. The cultural imperialism of so-called "progressive values" is insulting and provocative. The homogeneity of its population and its devout religious principles has driven the success of "Silicon Slopes," any imposition of values contrary to this will only serve to retard or reverse its success.
- jdhn 6y agoI find it interesting how so much of the article was concerned about diversity. It seems like SLC is punching above its weight class when it comes to startups even though it's not as diverse as the writer would like it to be, which raises the question as to whether diversity is necessary in order to succeed and grow even larger.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rbanffy 6y agoDiversity is not a requirement for economic success or profitability, specially when you exist in a non-diverse local ecosystem and shutting down minorities doesn't negatively impact your ability to tap local talent. It may impact growth prospects, as companies need to expand and open offices in other places. Being inclusive is, however, something I consider right and, for some, doing the right thing is more important than maximizing profits.
- throwaway894345 6y agoIt seems worth noting that having low diversity doesn’t mean you are shutting down minorities; “diversity” isn’t a natural state of affairs; it requires intentional investment to cultivate. You probably didn’t mean to imply the contrary; I just wanted to be explicit.
- waisbrot 6y ago> having low diversity doesn’t mean you are shutting down minorities Of course it does. How is it that Utah is almost all white? Is that where white people originated? Just random chance? In the natural state of affairs, since we now have the ability to move around the planet faster than we reproduce, entropy would have the world be an even distribution. You're right that diversity requires intentional investment, but that's needed to fight against the active force of bigotry.
- zozbot234 6y ago> Of course it does. How is it that Utah is almost all white? ... For the same reason why Utah is largely LDS, of course. Namely, it was largely white LDS who bothered to actually settle the place. It's a bit weird how some people find something nefarious in any perceived "lack" of diversity, as if founder effect, etc. was not a thing.
- jayd16 6y agoIts an extension of systemic racism in the country going back centuries, which is what the parent is referring to. That said, I don't personally expect every Utah resident to spend all their resources on diversity nor do I expect many are in the position to. That said, the argument that passive participation in an unjust system is tacit approval of that system isn't so far fetched.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> Its an extension of systemic racism in the country going back centuries, which is what the parent is referring to. I'm not sure this is true in Utah's case, and anyway it misses the point (Utah could be white for entirely nefarious reasons and we would still expect any given colorblind institution in Utah to be similarly white). > That said, the argument that passive participation in an unjust system is tacit approval of that system isn't so far fetched. It's entirely possible that one is: * unaware of the injustice * unsure of what can be done to help * already helping in a different capacity * spending one's resources otherwise making the world a better place (including potentially addressing worse injustices or just trying to provide for one's family, community, workforce, etc) * etc This "if you're not for my pet issue, you must be against it" isn't doing anyone a service.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI'm not sure they're not "doing the right thing". They can't hire who isn't here, and Utah is not a demographically diverse place. (Yes, they can recruit nationally, but for cost reasons, everyone starts by recruiting locally.) I haven't seen any sign of any of these tech companies "shutting down minorities". From what I've seen, if the right candidate is a minority, they'll hire them without blinking.
- rbanffy 6y ago> They can't hire who isn't here, That's a very good point. Lack of diversity is completely invisible if the surrounding context also lacks it.
- irrational 6y agoI live in Portland, OR. It was actually illegal for Black people to live in Oregon until well into the 1900s. That is partly why so few Black people live here. My company has been trying to hire more Black people, but it is really difficult when none apply since so few live around here and all the other companies are also trying to become more diverse. If you are a programmer who is also Black, please consider moving to Portland.
- tolbish 6y agoOr they can move somewhere where their token status won't be under constant scrutiny.
- yobi-ponti 6y agoGreat message to put someone in a box "if you're black and a programmer we need you to fill our diversity quota so uproot your life and come here so we can virtue signal and post pictures of you on LinkedIn" Hire good people, don't deny them on the basis of their immutable qualities. Don't pick someone because they look a certain way, but because they can do the work.
- foobiekr 6y agoOpen an office in Atlanta or DC. I'm not joking. I have tried multiple times to hire a friend, who is black, because he is good (and not because he's black), and have failed every time because his cultural support structure is simply not there. That's not his problem, and honestly, it's not the Valley's problem, it's just a factr. It took me a long time to understand this, but I realized, there's lots of places I wouldn't move, either, even for a good opportunity, because my expectations about the culture is some places and not others. There is a rate of migration now and then, but honestly, there is a serious geo problem. Some people go where the jobs are (born here, but grew up out east), some won't, and there's nothing wrong with that.
- mc32 6y agoAs the former head of HR at Apple said in the past but got fired for is that there are multiple forms of diversity and they have validity for particular reasons, however, to succeed as a business you mostly need diversity in thought (the opposite of groupthink), but there is also the social dimension of diversity which needs addressing if there are forces that are artificially affecting the dynamics. That said, Japan, China and others have been very successful without having to import much external talent. And there are places with more social diversity than the US such have not done well, though there are examples of very diverse places that do extremely well too (Singapore and to a lesser degree Malaysia). So success is probably more aligned with economic policies and other policies weigh less.
- bluedino 6y ago>> China has 'imported' a ton of IP and many people from other countries have gone to China and made fortunes setting up clones of non-Chinese businesses.
- AlchemistCamp 6y agoSingapore presents itself as "very diverse" but people will regularly be surprised if you have a western appearance and speak with the same accent as everybody else in the city. It's not really comparable to the US (or the UK or commonwealth countries or much of Europe) in that way.
- millbraebart 6y agoThe author lives in the great bastion of diversity... Burlington, VT. What a brave article.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoI suspect diversity is a requirement for growth. How are you expected to add thousands of jobs if Asians, Indians need not apply?
- bE9a3S5So8igd3 6y ago1. I think it's a myth that every company needs to metastasize and acquire all the wealth in the universe 2. Aside from that, "inclusiveness" is of course a complete bullshit term that's abused by hiring managers to mean "discriminatory hiring that favors minorities and females; especially the minorities CNN tells us to favor" 3. There is no evidence that companies composed of 100% whites are decidedly exclusive There's your daily dose of reality. Thank me later
- dang 6y agoPlease don't post in the flamewar style to HN. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules when posting here, we'd be grateful.
- rsj_hn 6y agoThe big economic growth success stories of the last 50 years were in China and East Asia: Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, Vietnam. Some of the least diverse places on earth. Many of these wont accept immigrants from other backgrounds at all, although they might accept low wage agricultural workers. Economic growth in the US over the same period was mediocre, with declining productivity, and in Europe, it was anemic. There is just no evidence that nations which focus on diversity in and of themselves have had better economic outcomes. Now it does make sense that if you are in a large multi-ethnic society then you will be at a disadvantage if you only hire from one group, since good people are hard to find, so why limit yourself to just a small subset of the population. This is less important for a small company than a large company that really needs to cast a wide net. So not intentionally excluding subgroups of your population makes economic sense. But I'm not aware of any evidence that being more diverse than your population will improve outcomes.
- Barrin92 6y agoif you want to grow outside of your domestic market it's a significant help to have as much possible information available to you when you build something, diversity is simply a way of information discovery. One of the most trivial examples being the soap dispenser that didn't detect black hands. If you have someone with dark skin on your team you discover it right in development.
- jariel 6y ago"diversity is simply a way of information discovery" This is one of the arguments given, and it makes a whole lot of sense, so much so, it's hard to negate. But in my years of business experience, I don't believe it's true. Having Engineers of 'XYZ Heritage' will not really in any way help you 'think differently' vis-a-vis the XYZ market. It just doesn't work that way. Now - having Engineers 'born and raised' in a certain part of the world - yes, that can possibly make a difference. It's no surprise that Vancouver has a lot of 'ties' to APAC. Paradoxically, when you start a business, generally you want to hit the very narrow segment of your best possible followers, in which case, diversity may be the opposite of important: you want to nail a demo, that may or may not be related to diversity. The primary advantage, I believe, of diversity, actually has nothing to do with diversity. I have mostly come to believe that most of it doesn't matter materially - what matters - is that companies and individuals have an opportunity to connect with one another. A young, white, CEO may simply be unwilling to look beyond his network and local horizons to find, for example, a lot of women. It's the issue of gender that will help the company, rather massive talent pools overlooked. So having internal biases agains 'certain types' results in just missing out on talent, not so much on some 'special thing' that those candidates bring. Mostly.
- throwaway894345 6y agoThe thing that strikes me as especially interesting about our drive for diversity is that it’s based on the premise that if you hire people who look different, then you will very likely get people with heterogeneous viewpoints, which will make an organization stronger. I think this absolutely makes sense provided you sample evenly from all races, genders, etc; however, what I suspect is happening is that organizations that sort of worship diversity end up selecting from each race, gender, etc only those people who are similarly obsessive about diversity, and this selection bias erodes much of the purported benefit of diversity. Notably, institutions like academia and media increasingly consider viewpoint homogeneity something akin to moral purity, and consequently they end up with lots of racial and gender diversity but minimal viewpoint diversity (of course the degree of homogeneity is not uniform across these institutions, but this doesn’t detract from my point).
- zozbot234 6y agoIntellectual diversity is dangerous these days. You might get canceled for being too diverse! It's interesting how woke culture seems to be pushing many organizations into being more discriminating when it comes to intellectual, political etc. viewpoints.
- carapace 6y agoFWIW, "It's interesting how..." seems to me to be a rhetorical signal that you have an ax to grind. Just grind it. Racism and sexism aren't "intellectual diversity".
- throwaway894345 6y agoI don't agree with the parent's tone, but I don't think the parent was claiming that "racism and sexism" were equivalent to "intellectual diversity"; I'm not sure how you got there. I also don't think it's very interesting or relevant to speculate about the parent's motives for their observation, especially to use pejorative language like "ax to grind".
- carapace 6y agoIt seems like most of these startups are not succeeding though innovation rather they are "just" executing well. '“the consumerization of enterprise.”' ?
- yroc92 6y agoHaving spent 10 years there, I can say this is true. There’s not much innovation, just solid business execution and sales, sales, sales. The proliferation of ambitious former missionaries is a driving factor for this cultural element.
- faitswulff 6y agoThe need for diversity is not a means to succeed and grow, it's a directive for redistributing wealth and power from those populations who already have it to those who do not. Diversity as being good for capitalism is red herring.
- 236dev 6y agoMore diverse areas have less unionization which is good for capitalism. https://observer.com/2020/04/amazon-whole-foods-anti-union-technology-heat-map/ https://observer.com/2020/04/amazon-whole-foods-anti-union-t...
- jariel 6y agoThe writers at very least need to take into context the population at large. Germany is not super diverse, neither is Utah. Hence, it will feel different than LA. Ironically, this is the 'Coastal Writers' being guilty of not respecting diversity (!) in that, not every place is like NYC or LA. That doesn't mean Utah is off the hook for not being fair, or for concerns about systematic issues, but Utah is literally less than 2% Black. So that's a starting point. I'm pretty empathetic to issues of unfairness or discrimination, but I lose interest when I see a ham-fisted or lack of contextual elements on the part of writers. Someone noted that Utah has a highly educated workforce - a lot of places do, that's not enough to make a 'Valley'. I think that such places will be great for Tier2 tech, by that I mean, tech that is an end product, not tech used by other techies. Shopfiy in Ottawa, is an example. Ottawa has 'great schools' super B+ competent work force, the most safe and stable place in North America. But not nearly the depth needed to make a Google or MS. Wix. Survey Monkey. I can see Stripe maybe happening out of the Valley. Though I often wonder what the difference would be - maybe Shopify needed to 'start' elsewhere but if it was now a fully SF company I wonder where they would be. But the 'centres' of social networks I think will remain in the big cosmo areas, and 'core tech' will mostly remain in the valley, other than little dots here and there, that usually get eaten up anyhow.
- bluedino 6y ago>> Utah is literally less than 2% Black Non-Mormon whites are treated quit differently in SLC. You don't even have to be brown.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arpowers 6y agoAs a non-mormon Utahn that lives in California; the reason things are so well in Utah has nothing to do w Mormonism and more to do with a focus on value creation as opposed to social issues, regulations, and taxes. California has been working very hard to kill it's golden goose for a long time. Reasonable people are going to other states.
- garraeth 6y agoYou could argue that it is due to Mormonism: "Deseret was proposed as a name for the U.S. state of Utah. Brigham Young—governor of Utah Territory from 1850 to 1858 and president of the LDS Church from 1847 to 1877—favored the name as a symbol of industry. Young taught his followers that they should be productive and self-sufficient, a trait he had perceived in honeybees."[1] 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deseret_(Book_of_Mormon) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deseret_(Book_of_Mormon)
- 0xcde4c3db 6y ago> California has been working very hard to kill it's golden goose for a long time. Reasonable people are going to other states. People have been saying that sort of thing since the '90s, if not earlier. If California has been working so hard for so long to ruin things, why are we still talking about places being the next Silicon Valley, and not the next Austin or the next Research Triangle?
- alexnewman 6y agoSilicon valley was built over 80 years. Obviously it's going to take more than 20 years for it's decline to be visible but it's clear to me that it's very far along
- austincheney 6y agoWell perhaps it helps to think of it in terms of raw numbers. California is bleeding about 60,000 people per year just to Texas. My city in Texas is averaging a growth rate of about 22% decade over decade having doubled since 1990 to surpass San Francisco in population and will likely surpass San Jose in about 15 years. On pace with the population growth is growth in diversity and average household income. That means that as the population increases the wealth distribution and access to purchasing and property increases for more people than naught. It’s not all peaches and cream in this fast growing city though. The tremendous growth results in colossal strain on traffic and infrastructure, but ownership of a large house with a yard is available to most people. That’s not such a big deal when you’re single, but it’s huge when you have kids. The demand for increased economic security likewise dramatically increases when you have kids. California is growing in population though, but very slowly and without equivalent growth in wealth per capita. That is largely a result in personal wealth primarily tied to home ownership and home ownership declining generationally in California. I take from your comment that you are less concerned with raw numbers and more concerned with vanity labels and trends. If you are a well funded founder perhaps California remains the place to be, but the numbers indicate it’s no longer the epicenter of economic growth that it certainly was in prior decades.
- jboggan 6y agoGood article for the most part. I was amazed when I moved here from Santa Monica a.k.a. Silicon Beach at how much startup and VC activity there is. Even down in Provo which I'd probably call the southern terminus of Silicon Slopes I overheard VC pitches at the next table in the restaurants every day at lunch. There is a lot of hustle and prosperity going on out here. Provo is also a very Mormon town in a Mormon state, containing BYU and also their missionary training center. Despite that I haven't found the cultural shift too jarring, though I will say the liquor selection in the state-run stores is a little lacking. Overall it seems like a very healthy and industrious community and I don't doubt it will continue to grow as the previous centers of tech innovation in America start to run into some very hard limits in terms of housing, cost of living, density of young well-educated workers, and overall lifestyle quality.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoHousing: The problem is that Provo and Salt Lake both sit in valleys with pretty steep mountains around them. There's not that much more room left to build more houses on. (Provo has some, south of it, and the Salt Lake Valley has some on the southwest quadrant, but they're getting somewhat close to maxed out.) So housing prices, while currently not that bad by the standards of the rest of the tech hubs, may not stay that way for long.
- elindbe2 6y agoCouldn't they build upwards though?
- irrational 6y agoThat would probably mean apartments, but Mormon families still tend to be very large (very very large by the standards of non-Mormon families) and they typically want large backyards for their kids. Maybe someday that will change, but not soon enough to make a material difference in our lifetimes.
- 6y ago
- dmode 6y agoCan we just stop calling every place with a few startups, the next Silicon Valley ? Just as the article said, Utah startups didn’t even raise combined $1bn in 2017, where SV companies routinely raise 30-40bn every year. It is just another bit player to write some articles about
- shakezula 6y agoI wouldn't call them the next silicon valley by any stretch, but the tech scene in Utah is undeniably booming.
- bE9a3S5So8igd3 6y agoLooking forward to Silicon Hell
- xeromal 6y agoDo you need to raise money to be a startup?
- adventured 6y agoIt's a fair point, nobody should be confusing the Salt Lake City area for Silicon Valley. Trajectory matters though, Utah is obviously doing well. Their annual venture capital raised has increased by roughly 300% in ten years and is likely to continue climbing. To put $1 billion into perspective, it's more VC than these countries have per year: Italy, the Netherlands, Ireland, Finland, Portugal, Denmark, Belgium, Russia, Norway, Austria. And it nearly matches Sweden. Utah raises more venture capital than Italy and Russia combined. Utah has three million people. They'll never have the population to challenge densely populated California. Can they get to $2-$3 billion in annual VC in the coming decade? Yep.
- aliante 6y agoEvery “next Silicon Valley” has a diversity problem. China and Japan are tech powers and have a diversity problem. The “diversity problem” seems to be a political one for writers rather than a problem for businesses.
- ArkVark 6y agoReligion and conservatism is highly correlated with higher fertility rates, and liberalism with much lower fertility rates, so we should expect the next generations of everything to have its roots in these sort of populations. If the high-fertility population is also intelligent and productive, we should be extremely happy with that outcome. https://jaymans.wordpress.com/2012/06/01/liberalism-hbd-population-and-solutions-for-the-future/ https://jaymans.wordpress.com/2012/06/01/liberalism-hbd-popu... The birthrate of the 'extremely conservative' is almost double that of the 'extremely liberal'.
- sudosysgen 6y agoAnd yet atheism in young people is at an all time high and increasing. Almost as if beliefs aren't actually genetic.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI don’t think the parent claimed that beliefs are genetic or even that they are 100% heritable; only that conservative, religious populations have higher fertility rates and consequently the next generation will disproportionately come from a conservative, religious background. Many liberal atheists also come from conservative religious backgrounds, for example. This much at least doesn’t seem very controversial to me.
- sudosysgen 6y agoWell, not really, because the next generation will disproportionately come from atheists, and likely the next one even moreso.
- ArkVark 6y agoAtheists and Agnostics have the lowest marriage rates and the lowest fertility rates: https://www.pewforum.org/2015/05/12/chapter-3-demographic-profiles-of-religious-groups/ https://www.pewforum.org/2015/05/12/chapter-3-demographic-pr...
- hpoe 6y agoSo I live in Utah been here for most of my life and been involved in the Utah start up scene, and quite frankly I've been wondering why Utah has been at the top of more tech hub lists. The fact of the matter is you have a very edicated population with two major universities a younger population and a government that looks favorably on business. I'm surprised it took anyone this long to notice. I think there are two factors that work against the traditional SV perception in Utah. Both of them stem from teachings of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints ( of which I am a member) the first is the emphasis on families. A commonly heard refrain is "no success can compensate for failure in the home", this emphasis on family doesn't always meld well with eh working 80-100 hours a week, FAANG obsession mentality that is caricatured as part of being an SV startup. The second is also another teaching of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints that counsels it's memebers to avoid excessive debt. Whereas the entire SV startup mentality is get as much VC as you can and blow through it as quick as you can to fuel growth hopong you can claw your way out later. As data point on this until a while back I was working at ones of Utah's biggest, hottest most profitable startups as one of the first employees. The CEO didn't take out a bunch of business loans or get VC, he had owned quite a bit of property and liquidated it all to start the company. Now the objection will be that everyone in Utah isn't a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, however the culture still is pretty pervasive. That being said there are exceptions to every rule and things are changing. But most importantly. There are too dang many of you coming to Utah and filling up my mountains and desert stay out find somewhere else live.
- dredmorbius 6y ago"...why Utah has been..." I think you're missing a "not" there.
- sbrother 6y agoTotally agree with this as a non-Mormon living in Utah. The culture is pervasive -- largely in a good way IMO. We moved here from California (ahem, sorry for filling up your mountains and desert) and love it. It's totally normal to have a family in your twenties, head out of the office at 5:00 sharp, and make friends hanging out with the kids in the mountains. Even as an ex-coastal democrat I am totally fine with the Mormon "compassionate Republicans" like Romney, Huntsman, and Cox. Wouldn't want to live anywhere else at this point. Now if we can just figure out traffic in the Cottonwoods.....
- potiuper 6y agoSo, when did Utah ban non-competes?
- mlinksva 6y agoUnfortunately they haven't, but it looks like they may have been limited to 1 year starting in 2016, see https://www.faircompetitionlaw.com/changing-landscape-of-trade-secrets-laws-and-noncompete-laws/#:~:text=Utah https://www.faircompetitionlaw.com/changing-landscape-of-tra...
- bilater 6y agoI'm hearing Boise Idaho is also coming up similarly to Provo.
- xeromal 6y agoI actually work remotely for a boise company and they pay me a LA salary. Boise is getting pretty hot though still small. They have loads of cool conferences and start up weeks, but of course it's all been shut down this year.
- W-Stool 6y agoI was there a few years ago to check Boise out as maybe a place to live. Nicest/cleanest downtown I think I've ever seen. Didn't end up making the move but I seriously thought about it.
- grahamburger 6y agoUtah and Mormonism are pretty interesting in both good and bad ways socially and culturally. I grew up as a Mormon in Utah and still live and work here. I don't really practice the faith anymore (finishing off my coffee as I write this!) but most of my family including my wife does. Culturally, Mormons are a bit like the conservative south, except remove alcohol, add a higher respect for formal education, and crank up that 'protestant work ethic' to 11. Not that southern conservatives are lazy, but I think there is more of a culture of enjoying some downtime with iced tea in the shade in the South than there is among Mormons. There's also a bit of a culture of natural distrust of authority figures in the south - especially highly educated 'Ivy Leaguers.' There's less of that in Mormonism. Mormons pride themselves on being highly successful outside the church, whether in politics, business or academia. This can create huge problems for people who don't feel like they measure up, especially for women who are expected to be perfect housewives and homemakers while also supporting their husbands careers and doing valuable, secular community work. Often while their husbands work full time and then spend their off days (and all of their disposable cash) doing an MLM side hustle. Although, as the article notes, Mormon women are highly involved (dare I say preyed on) by MLMs as well - There are MLMs for everything from cleaning products to beauty products to sex toys, all aimed directly at women.[2] The Mormon church does a pretty good job of teaching it's younger members (mostly just the boys, unfortunately) some basics of leadership and organizing group work efforts. These leadership rolls are mostly 'on the rails' - the church provides careful instruction of how to organize and lead to make these responsibilities approachable for the novice. Members are expected to speak in front of large and small groups from an early age, for example, and to preside over small groups of others near their own age in youth programs. For that reason lots of business efforts in Utah can just kind of coast on those same learned principles. There's already a shared cultural subconscious understanding of how groups of people 'should' work together, which overall makes things easier to get off the ground than trying to build these organizational structures from scratch. The obvious downside (at least for me, I think some people experience this as a positive) is that every day at work feels a bit like a day at church. The people look like same, are often dressed the same, the meetings run in basically the same format, it's all very homogeneous. I recently spent three years working for a company based in San Francisco. For me this was a breath of fresh air - the company was quite diverse among races, genders, sexual orientation and identity, etc. I didn't feel like I was sitting in Elder's Quorum meeting during daily standup[1]. I'm back at a Utah company now and while I don't have any problems with the company overall the feeling like I'm looking in the mirror at everyone I work with is stifling. Since stepping away from full activity in the church I've started to realize that these social structures are the main reason why a lot of people stay in the church. Somehow that had never really occurred to me, although it seems obvious now. For whatever reason in my personal life my social circle, educational and professional prospects, even romantic prospects were never really rooted in the church. But for many (most?) people who grow up in the church this is not the case - if they left the church they'd be losing not only a huge part of their own identity, but severing social ties and souring important life opportunities. For many people this is the glue that holds their lives together. I suspect this is true for most religious communities. (Or even non-religious ones, like the tech community in general, which has many of it's own problems - and yet we stay!) The other even more surprising thing I've learned since leaving is that a lot of people - both those currently in the church and some who have left - say that one of the main things they enjoy(ed) / value(d) about church attendance is the music. This is honestly weird to me because the music is about the most boring, generic, church organ+out of tune singing you can imagine. Even as a very young child the hymns were among my least favorite parts of church service. To each their own. [1] An in-joke for the other Mormons reading this. Elder's Quorum is the men's group in the Mormon church. This group meets every Sunday during church service (except during the pandemic, service is still mostly suspended world-wide). This group is specifically for men aged 18 through ~retirement age, which in the most populated parts of Utah overlaps with the group of men who are mostly employed at tech companies. This group is also specifically tasked with helping others in the community as needed, like helping people move or helping elderly folks with yardwork, etc. Overall these meetings end up feeling a lot like corporate meetings and vice-versa IME. The corresponding women's group is called the Relief Society. [2] See also the other currently trending article here about Mormons and MLMs. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23882026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23882026
- ww520 6y agoWasn’t Word Perfect or WordStar based in Utah decades ago? Utah has a long tradition of producing technology companies.
- nobleach 6y agoWordPerfect and Novell. There are several other names that have affiliation with Utah as well. The University of Utah is Alan Kay's Alma Mater. It's just a fantastic place for tech.
- dehrmann 6y agoAt least now, Overstock is the most famous company I can think of in SLC.
- andrewnc 6y agoQualtrics just had an $8 billion exit too, there are some
- grahamburger 6y agoWordperfect. Fun little epilogue - Wordperfect founder Alan Ashton used some of his fortune to establish Thanksgiving Point[1], a group of attractions in Utah including museums, a garden, a golf course, and some restaurants and shopping. The area is in biking distance from the offices of many Utah tech companies in Lehi City. I just moved to a home in the same neighborhood and it's really nice! We got a year pass to the attractions for the whole family for like $300 and bike over to something a few times a week with the kids. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thanksgiving_Point https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thanksgiving_Point
- whatsmyusername 6y agoI remember 2008. Pass.
- jimsparkman 6y agoI relocated to SLC recently after taking a new position in my company. It has been a very positive experience so far. Tech scene is bustling, a number of interesting meetups. From a geographical perspective, the mountains offer incredible opportunity for adventure. A mix of desert to high alpine. I’ve lived numerous places domestic and abroad, and haven’t seen anything quite like the accessibility to adventure as is found in SLC. Trail/mountain running, numerous ski resorts, Park City (of Winter Olympics fame), rock climbing, mountaineering and backcountry skiing, etc. All within 20 minutes drive. It’s surprisingly amazing how close to the city you can be and yet feel so far away. You can get ~6,000 feet above the valley within a few hours run/hike and see moose, mountain goats, porcupine, etc. Also interesting is the number of outdoor gear companies that have offices here. Petzl, Black Diamond, Backcountry, etc.
- m3kw9 6y agoAnyone can sell the crap out of anything not just mormons. This is just one big brag piece.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- milofeynman 6y agoI've interviewed in SLC before and the biggest problem with their startup scene is the complete lack of diversity. Otherwise it would be amazing to live near those mountains. I'm just not interested in working at a company with so literal cultural and racial diversity.
- arxv33 6y agoAs a person of color and someone who is interested in moving to SLC for more affordable cost of living I am interested. Can you elaborate more? What is it that you found negative? I worked at firms with lack of racial diversity where I was literally the only non white person but didn’t have much problem other than of course not being able to relate in some off the work conversations and socializing aspects of it. I thought SLC is now a lot more diverse than it was 10yrs ago partly cause the housing pressure in other big cities.
- sbrother 6y agoSLC is a great deal more diverse than it was 10 years ago. As an anecdote I moved here four years ago and I've overheard conversations in more and more different languages as I walk around the downtown area. My circle of friends is probably more diverse than it was when I lived in LA since it's largely people who moved here for the University of Utah or SLC-based tech jobs. Also, I believe SLC is at least 30% Hispanic, but it's pretty segregated both geographically and culturally. The rest of Utah is lily white though, and the tech scene (its centroid is somewhere between SLC and Provo) still feels heavily white and Mormon. I didn't used to mind as much because we would travel to CA once a month, but with the COVID travel moratorium I'm really missing diversity of all kinds.
- phaedryx 6y agoDefinitely more diverse than it used to be, but not like other large cities; Hispanic and Pacific Islanders are the two fastest-growing non-white groups, iirc.
- walrus01 6y ago
- npunt 6y agoI've been really impressed with SLC when I visit, and my brother recently moved there from LA. It's got a lot going for it and is quite appealing for tech, giving housing prices, a culture of reasonable working hours, and access to nature. SLC is also becoming more cosmopolitan, and the region seems like it is generally run quite well. Unfortunately, there's also bad pollution. The valley makes SLC prone to pollution and especially inversion layers in the winter and ozone in summer. You'd expect mountain air and you get that sometimes, but other times it's as bad as or worse than major cities elsewhere. One of the downsides of being a red state is less will to address environmental concerns like this. It's been slowly getting better due to car emissions standards (which Utah has no active involvement in), but there's still a lot of pollution sources that need addressing. There's an active refinery in town, at least one big mine across the valley, tons of trucks and trains passing through the region, and the airport is being expanded. Given the air is also extremely dry in the winter, I can't see myself moving there, despite it hitting a lot of my criteria for places to live. Were they to get their environmental house in order I'd say it's one of the best places to live. I hope someday SLC realizes its just not geographically destined to be an industrial hub, and makes responsible choices to shift away from that. http://www.stateoftheair.org/city-rankings/states/utah/salt-lake.html http://www.stateoftheair.org/city-rankings/states/utah/salt-... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_quality_in_Utah https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_quality_in_Utah https://www.sltrib.com/news/environment/2020/01/28/salt-lake-citys-air/ https://www.sltrib.com/news/environment/2020/01/28/salt-lake...
- remarkEon 6y ago>Unfortunately, there's also bad pollution. The valley makes SLC prone to pollution and especially inversion layers in the winter and ozone in summer. You'd expect mountain air and you get that sometimes, but other times it's as bad as or worse than major cities elsewhere. I had no idea about this, wow. What causes it? Just the fact that it's in a valley? I've been to SLC only once to visit some friends, but I guess I didn't really notice (was only driving through).
- hunter-gatherer 6y agoMy family lives north of Salt Lake and it does indeed get pretty bad, especially in the winter. I declined a job a Utah valley last year and the pollution was a major driver in that decision.
- hymnsfm 6y agoI doubt this comment will go over well, but I'll mention this small but important cultural fact anyway: Members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints no longer refer to themselves as Mormons or Latter-Day Saints. Only Saints. It may seem like minutia, but Saints (of whom I am one of them) worship Christ. Mormon, on the other hand, is one of many mortal prophets from ancient Americas and also the editor/compiler of the Book of Mormon. If you know just that alone, it'll probably score you points with the Saints that you meet. :)
- gjm11 6y agoThe trouble is that "saints" or "Saints" already has a meaning, which is not "members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints". (In fact, it has multiple long-standing meanings, of which that is not one.) I'm not saying you aren't entitled to call yourself that: of course you are. But you shouldn't expect other people to go along with it, any more than if you decided to call yourselves "Good People" or "Scientists" or "Turks". Of course this problem occurs over and over, because groups of people love to give themselves self-congratulatory names. Sometimes they succeed: consider "Democrat[ic]" (in US politics) and "Orthodox" (in Christianity and in Judaism), for instance. But it makes me sad every time.
- desert_boi 6y agoRecently LDS was still the endonym. The exonym is almost universal for non-Mormons. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exonym_and_endonym https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exonym_and_endonym
- hymnsfm 6y agoHere's the new style guide for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints: https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/style-guide https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/style-guide
- gjm11 6y agoThe style guide says: > When referring to Church members, the terms "members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints," "Latter-day Saints,” "members of the Church of Jesus Christ" and "members of the restored Church of Jesus Christ" are preferred. We ask that the term "Mormons" and "LDS" not be used. ... so in fact "Latter-Day Saints" is apparently perfectly OK, and "Saints" simpliciter isn't even one of the options they mention. (But of course this is a guide for those associated with the CoJCoLDS, not an attempt to legislate what language others should use. I don't think you're likely to have much luck getting anyone else to refer to the doctrine and practices of the CoJCoLDS as "the restored gospel of Jesus Christ", for instance.)
- Red_Tarsius 6y ago> big diversity problem That's just a codeword for anti-White rethoric. It's like saying "Delhi is too Indian" or "Beijing is too Chinese". Note that the author Adam Bluestein preaches diversity, yet chose to live in 82.7% white Burlington (VT).
- tropdrop 6y agoMy experience in Utah has actually been that the diversity problem is "Mormon" and "non-Mormon" (non-Mormon being the minority)
- so33 6y ago> It's like saying "Delhi is too Indian" No, it’s like saying “Delhi has too many Hindi speakers” or “Delhi has too many Brahmins” or “there are too few Muslims in Delhi” or “Delhi isn’t doing enough to combat colorism”. > or "Beijing is too Chinese" No, it’s like saying “Beijing relies too much on unregistered rural hukou holders who effectively form an invisible underclass unable to build wealth” or “Beijing is mistreating its growing African minority” (https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/04/15/chinas-racism-is-wrecking-its-success-in-africa/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/04/15/chinas-racism-is-wrecki...). Perhaps you should educate yourself on the real and pervasive socioeconomic, class, and racial divides present in any country, just like in the United States, before proceeding to make reductionist analogies.
- Red_Tarsius 6y agoPerhaps you shouldn't embarass yourself with false analogies (caste system, hukou issues). Utah being majority white _is_ the issue for the author. His implied solution is to dramatically change the demographics of the state and disrupt a successful, safe, high-trust society.
- selimthegrim 6y agoKashmir is too Muslim?
- yandrypozo 6y agoI'm so tired of those fake problems, when Silicon Valley started was majority white, one day the victimhood mindset will end and everybody will not find excuses to do things.
- onyva 6y ago>> “It turns out Catholicism is pretty strong there. You get a lot of rejection.” It’s like always astonishing to see how unapologetic/aware Americans are of their ignorance of the world and other cultures.
- steelframe 6y agoFull disclosure: I graduated from BYU, but I left Mormonism over 15 years ago. I still have a lot of active Mormon in-laws in the area, so I still visit SLC at least once a year. I know several people working in the tech industry there. There was no shortage of talent at BYU, but the lack of diversity on every front in the engineering programs was stark. Engineering programs were almost entirely composed of white men. In the hallways and labs of the Clyde Building, I heard a lot of sexist jokes. For example, "I'm dating someone who's going for her EE -- Elementary Education!" Looking back, I now realize it was really quite hostile toward female students. They often weren't taken seriously since the graduation rate for women at BYU was (and still is) horrible, and they were constantly asked out on dates by their classmates. Saying "no" too often would get them a "reputation," and I know of at least a couple who got a talking to by their bishops (male Mormon religious leaders) about the importance of dating so they could get married and start a family. Of course BYU itself is almost entirely Mormon. The only engineering students I knew who weren't Mormon were graduate students from oversees who probably didn't fully understand what kind of environment they were getting into when they accepted their scholarship for whatever program they were getting into. Since I visit Salt Lake fairly often I have a few contacts in the area who, shall we say, don't quite "fit the mold" for the kind of people you usually see there. It's really a chronic challenge for them to always be hit with microaggressions, both personally and professionally. You don't even have to look really that different for it to happen. A male wearing an earring, a visible tattoo, or something a bit flamboyant about your clothing can impact your ability to be included. And gods help you if you aren't religious and find yourself in a company primarily headed by active Mormon leadership. You can expect to be courted and invited to join at first, but once you make it clear that you aren't gonna convert, you're going to have an uphill battle in the inclusion front from that point on. That said, when I'm ready to start a tech business of my own, I'd really really like to be able to do it in the Salt Lake area. The problem is that I'd want a healthy amount of diversity among my co-workers, and the easiest way to go about doing that is to hire at a place where the diversity already exists.
- walrus01 6y agoTo be totally frank, the Mormons in SLC would probably view me as a corrupted, effete coastal leftist/liberal. And I would similarly have a real culture fit problem joining a company there. I'm not even remotely going to consider relocating to a place like Boise or Salt Lake City for a number of political and religious reasons. I know a number of people in the Pacific Northwest who feel similarly.
- bluedino 6y agoFrom Almost Perfect: Alan continued to teach at BYU, so he was in a perfect position to recruit BYU's best computer science students. He was a tough grader, and anyone getting an A in one of his classes was a candidate for a job offer. When Alan found students with exceptional talent, he and Bruce would offer them part- time jobs and put them to work on one of the programming projects. By the time they graduated, their work had helped the company grow to the point where we could afford to offer them good salaries. Eventually we used Alan's old grade sheets to search for good programmers who had already graduated. 40 years ago Mormons were making startups in Utah.
- telaelit 6y agoI work at a tech company in Utah and it really cannot be understated that the Mormon culture sweeps into literally every aspect of Utah. Not saying that’s negative, just that it exists. Me and my ex and non- Mormon coworkers had to beg management to let us have a happy hour for example, they had to change company policies to even allow us to do it. But I do love it here
- sneak 6y agoAny place that homogenous has deep racism and sexism waiting for you just underneath the surface. For me, this makes it a hard pass. It’s not even about the benefits of diversity, as I’m a white male and would fit right in as long as I kept my mouth shut. It’s about the huge downsides to a culture that values conformity and enforces unwritten, arbitrary rules to ensure future conformity. Conformity and homogeneity is gross.