19 ms·
Raspberry Pi 4 PCIe bridge “chip”
- wronglebowski 6y agoI find this fascinating, and I have a few follow-up ideas. How many PCIe lanes are on this connector? Is this a full 16x slot? I assume since it has a very limited amount of PINs I'd assume it's just a 1x. The next obvious step is hooking up this to a PLX chip. Duplicating the number of lanes available even if there's no additional bandwidth could really open up doors.
- philcrump 6y agoFrom the article it's 'just' a 1x PCI-E 2.0 lane (theoretical 5Gbps throughput). This is all the VL805 expects so all that's broken out to it's pads and 'easily' accessible.
- LeonM 6y agoIt is 1x, obviously. But I highly doubt that the PCIe bus is going to be the bottleneck here ;-) I guess it would be possible to design an ATX size motherboard with a RPi4 compute module slot (once CM4 becomes available). The PCIe bus would allow all sorts of peripherals. Don't expect any performance though.
- anon73044 6y agoHave you seen https://turingpi.com https://turingpi.com ? I can't imagine an ATX/ITX/STX compatible breakout board for everything on the Pi 4 would be an impossible task.
- LeonM 6y agoWell, yes, something like that, but not in a cluster form, but just a single CM4 on a mini-itx form factor board, with PCIe slots, USB ports, ethernet, etc. You could build a fully blown Linux desktop peripheral wise, just don't expect desktop performance.
- tcas 6y agoIt's 1 lane, but a 16x connector to allow plugging in any device. PCIe devices can be downgraded into a lower number of lanes. Many motherboard 16x connectors aren't even a full 16x.
- q3k 6y ago> The next obvious step is hooking up this to a PLX chip. Duplicating the number of lanes available even if there's no additional bandwidth could really open up doors. I did this with an external PCIe 'splitter'/switch board: https://twitter.com/q3k/status/1225560443927891971 https://twitter.com/q3k/status/1225560443927891971 It worked, kinda. After a kernel rebuild with the drivers I wanted and dtb bumps to allow for more PCIe MEMBAR space i was able to get multiple devices (IIRC 10GbE and SATA controller) to work simulataneously, just very slowly.
- floatboth 6y ago> bumps to allow for more PCIe MEMBAR space huh! huh! can you have enough BAR space for an AMD GPU to run? Rockchip RK3399 is infamous for having too little for GPUs..
- joezydeco 6y agoI'm starting to think RPi owners just don't want to acknowledge that there are other embedded linux-capable dev boards out there that can do all the things they want (eMMC, PCIe, multiple USB3, eSATA) without going through all of these insane hacks. If it's for the adventure, cool. If it's because you are pissed at the RPi folks for not including it then holy crap widen your horizons....
- ericcholis 6y agoI think the "spirit" of the RPi is what encourages this hacker/maker mentality....which is perfectly fine by me.
- joezydeco 6y agoFunny. I thought the original spirit of RPi was to be a BBC Micro to a new generation of schoolkids and let them explore a modern desktop programming system for cheap. The "let's hack this into a Beowulf cluster!" stuff was secondary. Now it seems to be primary and the education stuff is, um, not even mentioned anymore?
- pjmlp 6y agoIt is still mentioned, in the context of UK education.
- mikepurvis 6y agoThe education market may have been seen as larger and more "addressable" when this was all in the planning stages.
- iNate2000 6y agoThis is what happens when you let people explore something for cheap: they do all kinds of things you didn’t expect. The outcome couldn’t have been better.
- HeyLaughingBoy 6y ago
- trollied 6y agoDiscussion from the original PCIe hack: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20399555 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20399555
- billars 6y agoso one can connect a pcie sata adapter and connect sata disks even if on the same x1 lane?
- tssva 6y agoGiven it is x1 PCIE 2.0 you are likely to see little performance benefit vs using a USB solution for connecting sata drives while introducing potential stability issues.
- tyingq 6y agoThe Tindie store seems to be out of stock. But, if you need one of these, the GitHub repo for the project includes an Eagle brd file. Note that most PCB houses want Gerber files. PCBWay has an online converter for brd files. It does require creating a userid on their site, but it will give you the Gerber file without buying anything...so you're free the buy the PCB from anywhere you want.
- fortran77 6y agoIf you can plug a keyboard into the power socket, I'd love a Raspberry Pi mod that put an NVMe drive on the PCI bus. _That_ would be a useful little computer.
- fulafel 6y agoDoesn't the chip-ectomy also lose Ethernet? Edit: apparently not, but how is the Ethernet connected on the pi4? Is it on the BCM SoC?
- makomk 6y agoYeah, the Pi 4 finally has an onboard Ethernet controller on the SoC itself.
- fulafel 6y agoThis says the Ethernet controller is "natively attached" but the SoC datasheet doesn't mention Ethernet: https://www.raspberrypi.org/documentation/hardware https://www.raspberrypi.org/documentation/hardware /raspberrypi/bcm2711/README.md So maybe it's a separate chip?
- floatboth 6y agoMaybe. The chip closest to the Ethernet port has BCM on it..
- mschuster91 6y agoYou have to search for RGMII in the bcm2711 datasheet, which is a media-independent link. In theory you could rip the PHY chip out and replace it with a fibre PHY, so you'd get a fibre Pi.
- sbierwagen 6y agoThere's a couple Raspi clones with NVMe, with the most expensive being the Nvidia Jetson Xavier NX carrier board.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoGreat work, this opens new flood gates for Raspberry Pi community and I'm glad that the maker made it available on Tindie. Off topic: When I heard about Apple silicon on iMac, I was wondering whether it will retain PCIe or will Apple will 'courageously' kill PCIe on iMac (/s).
- fb03 6y agoI long for the day we can buy proper ATX-sized arm boards. This is nice and all but arm can do way more, and without all that historic 16/32 bit mode clutter x86 has for compatibility.
- redbeard0x0a 6y agoit has to be coming soon, apple is going to be making arm macs and aws has m6a instance types running 64bit arm right now.
- floatboth 6y agoYou can buy mini-ITX sized ones from SolidRun. They even run open source firmware (EDK2) that exposes most things as generic ACPI hardware.. well there's still quirks and hardware bugs of course :D
- non-entity 6y agoIs edk2 something that should be run in production? I thought it was more of development platform for UEFI.
- floatboth 6y agoWell, commercial vendors usually use AMI's modified version that has a proprietary fancy setup UI and whatever other crap. But for hobbyist custom firmware (these ARM systems, Chromebooks, etc) completely raw upstream EDK2 is totally fine. Fun fact, System76 now runs slightly modified EDK2 (as a Coreboot payload) with a custom setup UI written in Rust: https://github.com/system76/firmware-setup https://github.com/system76/firmware-setup
- b1gtuna 6y agoNo doubt that RPi has been a game changer, but I can never convince myself to build a light file/media server with a Pi. Do I really want to spend $100+ buying a Pi and accessories, or should I just spend $300 on a Synology... which actually has an NVMe slot.
- floatboth 6y agoOr, like, repurpose your previous desktop into a server when upgrading the desktop.
- rvense 6y agoEven old laptops can make good servers. Built-in UPS and screen for recovery. Depending on just how old, you might even be able to add more storage using USB3 ports, or with a controller in an ExpressCard slot or in place of the wireless card, or by replacing an optical drive.
- zeppelin101 6y agoThis! I have a highly underpowered laptop (which I bought brand new but at a very low cost for travel purposes) that I just didn't know what to do, because it was so damn annoying and awkward for any personal use. The keyboard was quite awkward. The trackpad was even worse. The display was so basic that even I didn't want to use it for YouTube/Netflix. The CPU... well you get the point. Finally, just a few weeks ago, I thought that I would really like to build a Linux server and thought of my Raspberry Pi 3. I remembered that I would need to connect an external HDD to make it even halfway useful for data storage. I would also need to find a USB wifi adapter (because my home setup currently isn't wired). Then I looked at this laptop which had been collecting dust for like 2 years. I realized it was perfect for my needs: has a 1 TBB HDD (not SSD) and a built-in wifi adapter. I installed Lubuntu (one of the least resource intensive distros) and then started installing numerous services on it: Nextcloud, IRC bouncer, SMB server. I only have Nextcloud running at the moment as it's the only thing I've been able to make serious use out of, but it just works.. perfectly.
- 6y ago
- blattimwind 6y agoVery clever to use the same pinout as the PCIe "flexible risers" that already use USB cables, so only the chip replacement is necessary.
- boznz 6y agoNot just the adventure for some. We use the RPI3/4 as a plug-in module to my clients range of industrial controllers because we want reliable availability, forward/backward compatibility and the most important recently is we want to diversify our supply chain from China it fits the bill nicely on all three.
- peter_d_sherman 6y agoI'd love a computer like the Raspberry Pi -- but one where every chip on the system board is "plug-and-play", that is, all of the chips have pins, and all are pushed into sockets such that any one of them could easily be pulled and replaced by another chip that matches the pinout for the given chip, with no desoldering or re-soldering...
- alblue 6y agoOne of the biggest limitations of the RaspberryPi is that it’s only got one network port, so that rules out running it as an OpenWRT router for practical reasons. Does anyone know of a similar miniature board with multiple network ports that could be used as an OpenWRT router? I’d like to replace my crumbling router with a low power one that is more configurable than my old one.