12 ms·
OpenDiablo2
- imtringued 6y agoI actually don't understand the motivation behind these projects. Usually the games for which an open source engine is written for are quite old. Old enough that emulation should be more than sufficient to play these games on something like a Mac with an ARM based SoC. It is also not possible to exactly replicate the game without straight up reverse engineering the game's binary which will open you up for lawsuits. The end result is a very similar game that is merely sharing the same assets but it just isn't the same. If the project was created with the intention of allowing a new experience that is different from the original game then it will be harder than expected because you still need artists, musicians and so on to create more content. Ultimately I think people should focus on making a very good and very faithful clone instead of replicating an old game that still requires you to own the original and proprietary assets. Of course everything I'm talking about could miss the point of the project and the contributors are just doing this for fun because they like writing code for games but can't create game art on their own.
- gjs278 6y agothey can mod it and make their own version easier. the modding tools for these kind of games isn't the greatest. it worked for doom because it was a simpler game and there was a reference client provided, they are just trying to make the reference client.
- cobalt 6y agobeyond the obvious 'do it to show that i can' and similar reasons, one less obvious reason may be that often people want to mod these games and its easier than either making a reproduction or using hacks. Having the actual code the game runs (even if decompiled) allows you to both learn how things were done, as well as modify them and improve them. Many people starting out in games development often want to make games like RPGs to emulate a favorite game they play, but want to experiment with their own rules/mechanics
- marvin 6y agoThe point is obviously as an exercise to pick apart a piece of older technology, figure out how it was built and interacts with the original assets, and create a machine that works for doing that. If you've got a passion for software and the game in question, it's a rewarding activity in its own right, in addition to being an excellent avenue for learning new languages and tools. Not every instance of human effort needs to push the world forward in a way that's immediately economically rewarding.
- stefanchrobot 6y agoI started to write the engine for my favourite game in my favourite programming language and the experience was addictive and enjoyable beyond compare. Sadly I just couldn't justify to myself the amount of hours that I would need to spend to complete this project.
- pvg 6y agoThey can end up producing more convenient, better performing, better integrated, more moddable versions of the game. When it works out it's sort of an 'amateur/community remaster'. Of course that's piles of work so there's many more unfinished than reasonably finished ones.
- steerablesafe 6y agoHave you heard about openttd?
- waldfee 6y agoOpenRA states in the about section > This means that OpenRA is not restricted by the technical limitations of the original closed-source games: it includes native support for modern operating systems and screen resolutions... I think this is the most compelling reason - it opens up features that would be way harder to realize in the original engine. noteworthy - OpenXcom https://openxcom.org/about/ https://openxcom.org/about/ - OpenRA https://www.openra.net/about/ https://www.openra.net/about/ - OpenTTD https://www.openttd.org/about.html https://www.openttd.org/about.html
- crazysim 6y ago- OpenRCT2 https://openrct2.org/ https://openrct2.org/
- waldfee 6y agothank you, i'll need to give this a go
- Lariscus 6y ago- OpenMW https://openmw.org/en/ https://openmw.org/en/
- mikorym 6y ago> not restricted by technical limitations Yup, if you play Sacred Gold or Disciples II using open frameworks you get a game that looks much newer. But more importantly, perpetually playable. Disciples II has an edit that uses OpenGL that makes the game much faster and more playable, and gives widescreen. Sacred has numerous mods, such as giving 1080p HD (and more). The next question is going to be: "But why do you play those games?" To this I will ask, honestly, what is Fortnight anyway?
- heyens 6y agoDo you by any chance have a link to the "open framework Sacred Gold" you mentioned? It's been a while, but I sure would go look for my old disks to give it a try in FHD!
- rakoo 6y agoTo me it seems the point is to have an open engine to be able to create that kind of games; instead of starting completely from scratch, they wanted to emulate a base that is known to be working and actually fun to use, so the moment they reach feature-parity they'll have a solid foundation. After that anyone can create on top of the existing and make it even better. This feels like people who are passionate about the base game and would like to see it being open-sourced but they don't own the source code, so they do the equivalent
- rasz 6y agoThis might be more to your liking https://github.com/diasurgical/devilution#introduction https://github.com/diasurgical/devilution#introduction it is a faithful reconstruction of original Diablo source code from various debug builds leaked over the years.
- madmoose 6y agoScummVM contains almost 80 game engines (and a lot of sub-engines) supporting hundreds of games. Most of them are made by straight reverse engineering of the original executables. In the early days we did have a lengthy back-and-forth with a tenacious lawyer from LucasLegal but they backed off when we convinced them that we didn't support piracy. It is not uncommon for rereleases of older games to use the ScummVM engine instead of the original engine, see for instance the recent rerelease of Westwood's Blade Runner on GOG.com, which wouldn't have happened without ScummVM.
- anthk 6y agoScummvm compiled with --enable-all-engines supports a fuckload of games, even maybe, Microsoft Encarta. You can even run Ultima games.
- Kaze404 6y agoPeople ported Diablo I to the Nintendo Switch using a similar project.
- llarsson 6y agoCool! I would love to play this natively on Linux. I would also really like to easily read somewhere, website or github, what the status of the project is. Is Diablo II (with or without LoD) entirely playable? Do they actually also target other games as well? Their choice of words seem to indicate so: "OpenDiablo2 is an ARPG game engine in the same vein of the 2000's games, and supports playing Diablo 2." If so, which?
- ballresin 6y agoI only joined the project just this week, but I can tell you that the game isn't playable yet. It launches and runs, allowing you to create a character and walk around in town. Most functionality isn't wired up yet. There are a lot of opportunities to contribute. There are no plans to support any other games, but it sounds like they expect to be able to use it to create new games.
- anentropic 6y agois it cross-platform, since it's built in Go? runs on macOS?
- essial 6y agoI'm the lead and I use OSX Catalina :)
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoThis is written in Go and you should have no issue running it on Linux. It looks like there’s a small setup script you need to run first.
- perceptronas 6y agoVery exciting. Diablo 2 is one of the best games for me. Lore and universe is extremely interesting too
- ballresin 6y agoThis is exactly why I got involved and support it on Patreon. I played this a ton as a teenager. It is also written in my favorite language, Go, which means that on my Mac running Catalina this will likely be the only way to play the game in the future. I couldn't even get the game files without using a High Sierra VM. There's also the impending ARM transition, which this project should also easily support.
- simonklitj 6y agoExcellent point! I remember back when the original Rosetta was discontinued, and I couldn't play WarCraft 3 on my Mac. Haven't played D2 for a couple of years, but very excited by your points that even ARM can't kill this project. If the OS merges between iPad and Mac then maybe even D2 on iPad using OpenDiablo2. Very cool!
- vorpalhex 6y agoIf you want a modern incarnation, Path of Exile is basically a homage to Diablo 2 with it's own universe and story but same complex and enjoyable mechanics.
- fgonzag 6y agoI would hate being a newbie in PoE now a days. The game has gotten so bloated and ridiculously complex that it would take months to sort of grasp all the different league mechanics. I honestly can't wait for Diablo 4 as a PoE veteran since beta, I just don't agree with most of the recent design decisions. Lack of visual clarity, mechanical clunkiness with movement skills, rng on rng on rng mechanics (just progressing through maps can be incredibly frustrating if you're on a dry spell and can't even get maps to drop). It's almost as if the devs are intentionally creating frustrating mechanics, in a game...
- happy_path 6y agoSadly, this kind of engine rewrites need original data files. Alternative art content would be awesome (a la OpenTTD). Could donations help this?
- bootloop 6y agoI don't think this would be of interest for anyone surrounding this project. Requiring you to buy the original game keeps the publisher happy (to a certain level) and also gives you an argument for legality regarding the non-graphical content which might also be copyright protected.
- Maledictus 6y agoIf you are not using any of their content you are not violating their copyright.
- rubber_duck 6y agoBut then you need to replace dialogues and storyline as well ? Also items/spells/mechanics can't be a straight clone ? So you would end up with a completely different game ?
- taneq 6y agoYou say that like it's a bad thing.
- mikepurvis 6y agoBut it's also a massive increase in scope, and will likely make the end product less appealing/interesting from a nostalgia point of view.
- hajile 6y agoStat blocks aren't protected by copyright. Most game mechanics aren't patentable in the first place and Diablo patents would have expired. Names fall under trademark law and even names that they've bothered to apply for (let alone all those rejected for various reasons) aren't difficult to change. Story is a different question. The core story is incredible thin and derivative. Creating a new story wouldn't be very hard. That said, most players today would probably be much more interested in multiplayer anyway.
- jaynetics 6y agoIn an ideal world, Blizzard would get on board and help complete this, then sell an HD asset pack for a few bucks to make a quick million.
- pmilot 6y agoWhy help complete this? If they would be willing to have an open source D2 out there, they can just release the original source code. It would seem even more "ideal" to me.
- mraison 6y agoFun (or sad) fact: they apparently lost a lot of the source code and assets. Looks like they were able to recover most of the code, but not the assets [1] [1] https://www.gamespot.com/articles/how-diablo-2-was-almost-lost-and-why-a-remaster-is/1100-6471517/ https://www.gamespot.com/articles/how-diablo-2-was-almost-lo...
- im3w1l 6y agoThey said they lost the source code pre-release, but managed to reconstruct most of it. Given that it was released and that there have been many patches, I think the source code is fine. I think the only thing they really lost are the hi-def assets from which the lower-def ingame assets were created.
- taneq 6y agoAre you sure the in-game assets were created from hi-def versions rather than just being pixel art?
- unicornfinder 6y agoTo be fair it wouldn't surprise me - this sort of thing was pretty common back then. You'd create high def 3D models and then render 2D sprites etc from them.
- obidan 6y agoInterestingly this is written in Golang. I wonder what the main considerations for choosing it were.
- loopz 6y agoOn top of the hat: Safe, fast compile times, takes care of memory management for you, powerful stdlib, fast and lean execution, straightforward readable code, portability, static compilation, swiss army knife tooling. Potential downsides: Golang/libs maybe a bit immature for non-system/microservices projects.
- jonathanlydall 6y agoUnfortunately Blizzard has a history of shutting down open source projects of implementations of their IP, I would be surprised if they don't go after this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratagus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratagus
- simonklitj 6y agoDevilution is still alive, AFAIK: https://github.com/diasurgical/devilution https://github.com/diasurgical/devilution
- duskwuff 6y agoAnd Devilution is more of an infringement, as it represents a direct recreation of Blizzard's source code for Diablo 1. OpenDiablo2, on the other hand, is more of a reimplementation (albeit not a clean-room approach).
- logicNSci 6y agoI've thrown in the towel on some of my favorite games, anything from Blizzard, Nintendo (Zelda), and obviously EA. I think it "Clicked" when someone said 'none of the programmers that made Old_Game even work there anymore' These companies are selling IP, not a sequel. When you buy modern Zelda, you don't get Majora's Mask, you get a 2015 action game skinned with Link. Blizzard is a corporation that owns the characters and names. However you can play Diablo clones that are significantly better in 2020. You just need to be okay without Cain. Nolstagia is a hella drug.
- sydd 6y agoDoes anyone know why they switched from C# to Go?
- de_watcher 6y agoDoes anyone know why would you try to develop an opensource game in C# in the first place?
- Octoth0rpe 6y agoPresumably due to the wealth of C# code/libraries available to game devs. It's an incredibly popular language in that area, certainly more popular than Go. There are plenty of good reasons not to use C#, but we shouldn't pretend that there aren't plenty of good reasons _to_ use it for specific problem spaces.
- de_watcher 6y agoIt works in frameworks like Unity Engine, but otherwise it ends up like Space Engineers Windows-only which is a shame.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mywittyname 6y agoA lot of indy devs are using Unity. Hell, a lot of non-indy devs use it. So that's not a big deal. There are some other frameworks that use C# and are cross-platform. Monogame is the cross-platform replacement for MS's XNA, which targets most of the major game systems out there.
- de_watcher 6y agoAs the OpenDiablo2 developer has confirmed: cross-platform C# is a pain. Yes, I understand that Windows is big and there are a lot of C# developers/fans here who immediately scream "What? C# can do anything!!!", but in practice MS doesn't support opensource where it matters and when it matters.
- wheybags 6y agoHey, just gonna take this opportunity to plug my very similar project for Diablo 1: https://github.com/wheybags/freeablo https://github.com/wheybags/freeablo
- k__ 6y agoNice! Since it's written in C++, does it compile to WebAssembly?
- wheybags 6y agoI guess it could, but I haven't tried yet. It uses SDL and opengl, which I gather are well supported. You'd still need to load the original assets though, so it would maybe be more useful as a demo with some new assets.
- TravHatesMe 6y agoI'll take this opportunity to plug my project that I used to build plugins for Diablo 2: https://github.com/blurt/X86.Interop/ https://github.com/blurt/X86.Interop/ You can use this library to interop between C# and x86 assembly under a Windows process.
- pixelbath 6y agoGoing to use this opportunity to plug someone else's Diablo 2 clone written in C++ that's been around for a few years: https://github.com/eezstreet/OpenD2 https://github.com/eezstreet/OpenD2
- pjmlp 6y agoI wish to get just one pence in whatever currency for every time one writes Golang instead of Go.
- tankenmate 6y agoHow about a brass razoo? [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brass_razoo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brass_razoo
- hombre_fatal 6y agoI wish everyone wrote it "Golang".
- have_faith 6y agoFor anyone interested in this sort of thing, OpenMW (Morrowind) comes to mind and is still in active development: https://openmw.org/en/ https://openmw.org/en/
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThis is great. I wanted to try it on macOS Catalina but was too lazy to copy my GOG game files over from Windows. I noticed the top Morrowind torrent already comes with the "Data Files" folder unpacked from the installation. Download OpenMW, run the wizard, point it at the Morrowind.esm file (from the torrent or your own installation), and click play. We now have a Morrowind that works on all OS. Amazing stuff. Even detects mods dragged into the directory and lets you click and drag their load order.
- mentos 6y agoAnd here is what I consider the best client emulator for Ultima Online https://github.com/andreakarasho/ClassicUO https://github.com/andreakarasho/ClassicUO
- chungus 6y agoEarlier this year I read "Stay a while and listen" by David Craddock and it made me reinstall diablo 2 after not touching it for 15 years. After disabling d3d11 in wine, it has been running with no issues on ubuntu 20.4
- 87zuhjkas 6y agoFor anyone interested in this sort of thing, ReGoth (Gothic 1 & 2) comes to mind and is still in active development: https://github.com/REGoth-project/REGoth-bs https://github.com/REGoth-project/REGoth-bs
- the_af 6y agoWow. Gothic 1 was one of my favorite RPGs of that era. The setting was intriguing (it was devised to limit the world, but it was an interesting way of doing so), the world felt "alive", with night-day cycles and NPCs going their way, working, etc. I still have the box lying somewhere, because I keep the boxes of my favorites games. (Unfortunately, I don't think I have any way to read the original game discs anymore, so I have the game and at the same time I don't have access to its assets...)
- frabert 6y agoThe development has come to a (temporary?) halt right now, the bs::framework we were using encountered some issues right after we adopted it... Hopefully we'll be able to resume some time in the future! In the meantime, https://github.com/Try/OpenGothic https://github.com/Try/OpenGothic is more feature-rich. (Disclaimer: I worked on the project but I am not the maintainer nor am I any kind of leader figure in the dev team)
- Vysero 6y agoI played Diablo2 for almost 19 years. Then the Blitzchung controversy happened. Now Diablo2, and all Blizzard products are dead to me, and imo they should be dead to you all as well.
- ouid 6y agoI'm pretty happy to draw a distinction between playing a blizzard north game that I bought in 2002, and continuing to support activision blizzard today.
- Vysero 6y agoSure, I get that, if the copy of D2 that you're using was purchased from Blizzard North.
- artificial 6y agoBTW did you ever see the Diablo they came up with? There's gameplay, neat to think what might've been. https://blizzardwatch.com/2020/05/18/diablo-3-blizzard-north-screenshots/ https://blizzardwatch.com/2020/05/18/diablo-3-blizzard-north...
- Vysero 6y agoWow... I haven't read an article that made me more upset than that one in weeks. The "Diablo 3" we got had no business calling itself Diablo anything imo. We didn't dodge a bullet, we were robbed.
- artificial 6y agoI wholeheartedly agree! Oh no, I also wish I wasn't the bearer of bad news, lol. The creatives behind these projects are gone, I feel Blizzard is a shell of what it once was. I wasted countless hours with Diablo - another Blizzard project I'd like to have seen is Titan.
- 6y ago
- benologist 6y agoExcellent work. I think it is long overdue that many of our childhood cherished games, books, cartoons etc are paralleled in open source. Stuff from 20 - 30 years ago was supposed to be public domain once upon a time, Blizzard already made billions then got paid billions again when they sold to Activision and it's never going to reach public domain. Instead of public domain we have each generation paying $100b to continue enjoying pokemon, Harry Potter, Barbie, super heroes, cartoons etc.
- kazagistar 6y agoThis is going to go poof to lawyers the moment they release their remasters.
- BurningCycles 6y agoI don't think so, I believe the worst case scenario is they might have to rename the project to not have 'Diablo' in its title. Only project that I know Blizzard shut down was a Starcraft server re-implementation, presumably because it would allow you to play without having a legitimate cd-key.
- BosunoB 6y agoFor anybody interested in this, you should also check out Path of Diablo https://pathofdiablo.com/ https://pathofdiablo.com/. It's a popular mod with a lot of QoL improvements and which borrows Path of Exile's robust endgame mapping system for replayability.