13 ms·
The concerns are right but public assembly is critical in a democracy, and cannot be put on hold indefinitely. It's probably the most fundamental right in any c
by Barrin92 6y ago
The concerns are right but public assembly is critical in a democracy, and cannot be put on hold indefinitely. It's probably the most fundamental right in any civil society and with all these takes I have seen on twitter about COVID and the protests, a lot of people seem to seriously unerestimate the value that free assembly has.
Covid as bad as it is will be an issue of the near future, civil rights gains or losses will have an impact in decades to come.
- mberning 6y agoUnless you assemble because you want to work. Then the media will paint you in the worst light possible an act like you are actively murdering grandma.
- monadic2 6y agoIdk about the media but I, personally, definitely judge you. Care about something that matters and not just yourself.
- war1025 6y ago> Care about something that matters and not just yourself Maybe like feeding your family and keeping a roof over their heads?
- monadic2 6y agoI think the ship has sailed for that kind of support from the government, unfortunately, in no small part due to reopening.
- dionian 6y agoTo what extent is/should government be responsible for this?
- monadic2 6y agoObviously a “values” question, but if “tackling collectivized problems collectively” ain’t on the government’s list, I’m not sure why I’m paying taxes, and our government’s bi-partisan efforts to collectively address this pandemic are currently the most pathetic in the world. The only place you see half-way decent propositions is before they hit the chopping block on Pelosi’s desk—this ain’t partisan. Frankly the US government is rapidly losing any legitimacy to rule, though of course this is my humble opinion.
- dang 6y agoThe GP was a bad comment for HN but crossing into aggressive personal attack is even worse. We ban accounts that do this, so please don't. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Edit: flamewar comments like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23449798 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23449798 are also not ok on HN, so please don't post them either.
- cblades 6y agoAssemble carrying weapons and with half the crowd claiming that the entire disease is fake, though?
- DennisAleynikov 6y agoassemble with weapons because blm and it will be much better. and covid will make sure to stop existing because this is too important to listen to science.
- caseysoftware 6y agoDoes what someone is carrying - but not using - make their assembly invalid? Does what someone think make their assembly invalid?
- whymauri 6y ago>Does what someone think make their assembly invalid? Point out above where GP said those assemblies were invalid. Pro tip: they did not. Their right to assembly is not fundamentally invalidated, but the protesters are certainly open to a variety of critiques.
- caseysoftware 6y agoYou're right. That comment didn't actually say or contribute anything at all. Consider my comment withdrawn.
- monadic2 6y agoAdditionally, mask usage is seriously high at these protests. I’ll literally be marching down the street and see folks on rooftop bars, beers in hand, elbow to elbow, not a mask in sight. that scares me more than a protest where you can freely trail behind at distance.
- clairity 6y agoif they’re outside and elbow-to-elbow, then it means they’re likely not continuously spitting in each others’ faces. it’s marginally better if they stood a little farther apart but that risk shouldn’t scare you. worry about real risks, like police with riot gear.
- monadic2 6y agoSomehow I don’t have your confidence—I haven’t even gone inside the bars. Anyway I’m not worried for myself, I’m gonna be fine in all likelihood—it’s my at-risk friends and family.
- clairity 6y agotoo many people are beholden to irrational fear with this pandemic, rather than understanding. going into a bar is not a problem for your at-risk friends or family. it's what you do inside that matters. having a physically distant beer with a friend (assuming an uncrowded bar, as is required in most places) is quite low risk. geting hammered and carrying on with a bunch of in-your-face strangers is not. just avoid exchanging spit with strangers. being outside is the easiest and best method, and maintaining a little distance is a close second. wear a mask indoors if you can't maintain distance. it's easy. then you can set the fear aside and move on with your life.
- djaque 6y agoI went to a protest in my town and there wasn't an unmasked person in sight. I think that if you showed up without one, you would get called out and asked to leave.
- jbay808 6y agoAssembly is valuable, but there's a certain misery that comes with self-isolating for two weeks living on canned beans, having many businesses shut down, and working so hard at this to protect the lives of your elderly parents or your asthmatic sibling... ... And then watching 10,000 people pack together downtown exercising their right to free assembly, and likely undoing all those months of progress.
- eganist 6y ago> there's a certain misery that comes with [...] watching 10,000 people pack together downtown exercising their right to free assembly, and likely undoing all those months of progress. Yep, that's called privilege. And I'm not even trying to be snarky. From the perspective of the protesters, taking this opportunity to protest and possibly achieve change means hopefully lowering the general mortality risk for generations to come, not just in the immediate COVID future. If the first thing that comes to our mind is "ah shit, all that progress" or "I could get sick" and not "I have an opportunity to really make a difference," it's because that difference doesn't matter as much to us compared to the risk of getting sick, and the fact that that difference doesn't matter as much is a product of privilege.
- axguscbklp 6y agoBut are the protests really founded on something significant? If they focused simply on police brutality regardless of race, that would be one thing, but the general narrative seems to be that there is a big problem of white-on-black violence in the form of cops. Now, there is such a problem, but this ignores the wider context that in this country, black-on-white violence is a much bigger problem than white-on-black violence. Much of the media focuses on black-on-white violence but relatively ignores white-on-black violence. People who buy into the narrative end up having a very misleading notion of whether it is whites or it is blacks in this country who are menaced more by violence coming from the other group. In reality, it is whites.
- eganist 6y ago> But are the protests really founded on something significant? They're founded on 494 years of slavery, segregation, and oppression of a population based on a perception of superiority by the ethnic group in power. This has been endemic, has not come close to being resolved, and as you've exemplified, has been consistently the target of a litany of efforts to erase the argument (e.g. with whataboutism, such as your claim) to maintain a vice grip on a narrative. Melding two different data sources together: * https://www.statista.com/statistics/585152/people-shot-to-death-by-us-police-by-race/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/585152/people-shot-to-de... * https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/PST045219 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/PST045219 We have the following outcome: Ethnicity | EOY-19 killed | July-19 pop est | humans per 10m ------------------------------------------------------------ White, non-hispanic | 370 | 198,256,671 | ~18.7 Black | 235 | 43,984,096 | ~53.5 Hispanic/Latinx | 158 | 60,067,832 | ~26.3 These numbers aren't perfect, but that's an almost 3x and almost 1.5x multiple for LEO-on-Black and LEO-on-Latinx crime as compared to LEO-on-White. --- There's been a war between upvotes and downvotes on this post; I'll let the downvotes stand as a commentary on hackernews's readership. I'm not backing off.
- war1025 6y ago> Covid as bad as it is will be an issue of the near future, civil rights gains or losses will have an impact in decades to come. There is a lot of truth in this. In any war there is a level of acceptable losses. For most of the spring, the modern culture wars were on hold and there were no hills worth taking. Now there is something going on that has the potential for long term consequences, so the level of acceptable losses has gone up.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- charliemil4 6y agoThat’s also a case for reopening - or better never closing the economy - an abrupt stop and socializing losses will leave scars for decades.
- cma 6y agoEven places that stayed mostly open got huge hits to their economy due to caution from people. For the economy to not take a hit you would need to force people into Applebee's even if they live with grandma, etc.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoMaybe people are just sick of being told they have to put the economy above all else. Can't have single payer healthcare because economy, can't have more days off because economy, can't have a higher minimum wage because economy, etc. Ask me to take a risk because it is good for the economy and I'll tell you to fuck off. Ask me to take a risk to help reform violent police forces that oppress minorities and I'm more willing to do it.
- thu2111 6y agoLike quite a lot of lockdown supporters you appear to believe that there's this optional bit of frippery called the economy which can be switched off like a light switch, without consequence. Let me explain some of the consequences. In the UK people have been pulling out their own teeth with pliars because the dentists weren't allowed to be open, not even for emergency surgery. It was "too dangerous" for dentists to be close to their patients. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-devon-52321910 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-devon-52321910 https://metro.co.uk/2020/05/20/mum-tried-pull-tooth-when-couldnt-find-dentist-lockdown-12733941/ https://metro.co.uk/2020/05/20/mum-tried-pull-tooth-when-cou... In India, all the factories and shops were closed. But because it's India the government wasn't able to replace people's incomes overnight. Those people started to starve so they tried to go back to their home villages, in the hopes of getting some food from the land. But because of the lockdown they couldn't get transport either, so they started to walk, in some cases they tried to walk hundreds of miles. And some of them died because of it. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-52086274 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-52086274 In the UK there's now a backlog of 2.4 million cancer tests or treatments. There's no obvious way to catch up and some people will die because of it. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8374697/2-4-million-patients-caught-coronavirus-cancer-backlog.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8374697/2-4-million... The economy is defined, literally, as every service or product people sell each other. But sure, it's also just a minor thing that doesn't matter.
- rohitb91 6y agoI agree that public assembly is essential regardless of what is going on. But why were the people protesting the lock downs and business shutdowns and the limiting of freedoms the yahoos and crazy murderers? Why did nurses block them from protesting but not one would block someone now?
- nr2x 6y agoNot getting a haircut won't kill you, the police will. Also, for the most part, anti-racism protestors are wearing masks, anti-lockdown people, for the most part, are not.
- alchemyromcom 6y agoLosing your livelihood can kill you, however. If you are a small business owner, for example, and it's illegal to operate that business, your life is also in danger and your situation deserves empathy. Empathy is not finite resource. We can extend it to all people in bad situations, not just people we prefer.
- thethethethe 6y ago> If you are a small business owner, for example, and it's illegal to operate that business, your life is also in danger and your situation deserves empathy This is a false dichotomy. Sure, these people (and their workers) deserve empathy and support, but that doesn’t mean they should be allowed to reopen. You can support business owners via financial aid or other measures while their business is closed.
- glofish 6y agono, this is not about empathy but personal autonomy and sovereignity and autocracy. Why not allow someone to do something if they are willing to take the risk, why treat them as criminals? If you believe that you get infected at a store, don't go to the store ... case closed. On what basis is the state "protecting" someone that does not want to be protected? On what basis is someone considered a criminal when a crime could only potentially be committed? what if the person is immune to the disease, already had the disease, or does not mind getting infected?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- austincheney 6y agoI strongly disagree. Many people seem to believe this without any substance. Some people, as evidenced by comments here, only believe this when it aligns to their subjectively self valued concern. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_assembly https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_assembly According to Wikipedia assembly is an example of a civil liberty. The preeminent doctrine on civil liberties is On Liberty. According to John Stuart Mill the greatest destroyer, as addressed near the top of chapter 2, of civil liberties is populism whether from an aggressive majority or angry mob. https://www.bartleby.com/130/ https://www.bartleby.com/130/ Assembly only really means anything, to those observing, if the participants are assembling for a purpose of individually formulated passion opposed to an exertion of social pressure. That, as it would appear, is the difference between a protest versus an angry mob. That said I would say the most fundamental right is freedom of expression which can occur from a group or individual and be every bit as powerful and influential.
- jdsully 6y agoIt can certainly go too far, but if a system of government angers a majority of the population one has to consider who exactly it is serving.
- austincheney 6y agoIn that case consider a historic example. What is more important Common Sense by Thomas Payne or the protest it directly inspired? https://en.m.wikisource.org/wiki/Common_Sense https://en.m.wikisource.org/wiki/Common_Sense
- newbie789 6y agoI think a lot of people strongly believe things without substance, sometimes based on wikipedia and interpreting stuff written by people that died centuries before problems manifested in paradigms that would have been unimaginable to them. I'm a fan of John Stuart Mill's writing, but having a memorable book title does not make a permanently relevant tome that applies to all of history backward and forward. My understanding of assembly (no wikipedia reference here) is that it's a form of expression (which you also kind of said yourself). Are saying that assembly isn't good or necessary for society? Or is this entire post specifically about the OP's word choice? In either case, are you citing J. S. Mill as a form of "proof" for your assertion?
- whiddershins 6y agoCommerce, working, mourning the dead, having weddings, creating art, performing music. How is the ‘free assembly’ you are talking about more important, and even if it is to many, am I required to have come to the same conclusion, or to follow the conclusion someone else has made for me? I have a feeling a lot of freedom of assembly protections were really more about the ability to get together and discuss stuff than it was about marches and protests. In that case, our freedom to assemble has been massively curtailed for months. Who gets to decide what assembly is worth violating the lockdown for?
- tomp 6y agoDid you also support the protests against the lockdown, with the same justification?
- n9 6y agoOne can support the rights of any americans to freely assemble while being puzzled and horrified at the reason for the protest. To wit: I would support the right of assembly for anti-vaccination advocates and would support the ACLU in defending those rights. Hoewever, I feel that Anti-vaccination advocates are wrong, their actions are destructive and they horrify me.
- neonate 6y agoThe issue is the double standard with which some protestors were condemned while others were lauded based solely on which causes (and which classes of people) the commenters happened to politically support. It's transparently unprincipled, to the point of being a sad joke.
- theklub 6y agoSo the people in Michigan that nurses were standing in front of vs the BLM crowds.
- covidSurvivor19 6y agoJust actors probably
- stonogo 6y agoThat's not a double standard. That's just a standard. When one group of people is holding signs that say "stop murdering people" and the other group is holding signs that say "I need a haircut," and you're mad that "the commenters" are not treating them the same, the problem is not with the commenters.
- neonate 6y agoYou're making my point. You politically support one side more than the other, right down to belittling the side you unsupport as "I need a haircut". Maybe I agree with you politically, but when arguments from principle pivot from one week to the next based on which way the politics point, it's not really about principle.
- kortilla 6y agoStrongly disagree, I think the freedom of speech (the ability to disseminate information widely) is massively more important than gathering in large crowds. How would you even know there were protests or something to even protest without free speech and press?
- umanwizard 6y agoPublic assembly is critical, yes. So is the ability to work, run a business, get married, and engage in social gatherings. Either COVID-19 is serious enough that it merits cancelling a bunch of “critical” features of normal life, or it isn’t.
- thirtythree 6y agoAgreed. Protesting in my country is going on but funerals are restricted and weddings forbidden. Grandparents haven't seen there grandchildren in a long time...
- rayhendricks 6y agoI agree with this statement. At least here in Seattle the protesters and police are packed closely together and are yelling at oneanother. Very few if any police are wearing masks (I was ~20ft from anyone & wearing a mask but wanted to see things 1st hand). IMO this will create a level of pandemic similar to NYC unless we really start testing and contact-tracing. It does feel like much of the left is OK with this, whereas everyone was freaking out when the reopen protesters were protesting. This is inconsistent, and unfortunate as I do have somewhat left-leaning views.
- drusepth 6y agoDo you think most protestors would be okay with contract tracing, especially when the most critical times to trace are during protests?
- javagram 6y agoContact tracing a protest makes no sense anyway. Taking down a list of people who dined at a restaurant during a certain time period is one thing. How are you supposed to contact trace a 10,000 person protest? No one is going to know the random people they happened to be standing next to and chanting at a specific moment. If these protests are super spreading events it blows a huge hole in any attempt at contact tracing & targeted quarantine/isolation. Hopefully it turns out the virus somehow can’t spread well in these conditions otherwise this is a huge setback for a country that just sacrificed so much to reduce the virus prevalence.
- Dumblydorr 6y agoCovid will last for decades, the virus will become a new common way to get sick. Theres simply no lying about the numbers, the virus will kill old folks in massive numbers, disproportionately those of color as well. Sad to say many lives will be lost, I hope some positive change is wrought despite the spikes in infections we are bound to see.